Blockchain SAFE: Simple Agreement for Future Equity: Navigating SAFE Contracts in the Crypto Era

1. What is a SAFE and why is it popular in the crypto space?

One of the most innovative and exciting developments in the crypto space is the emergence of SAFE contracts. SAFE stands for simple Agreement for Future equity, and it is a type of investment contract that allows investors to fund startups in exchange for a claim on future equity. Unlike traditional equity or debt financing, SAFE contracts do not specify a valuation or interest rate at the time of investment, but rather defer these terms until a later event, such as a funding round or an exit. This way, SAFE contracts offer a simple and flexible way for startups and investors to align their interests and share the risks and rewards of innovation.

SAFE contracts were originally designed by Y Combinator, a prominent startup accelerator, in 2013 as an alternative to convertible notes. Since then, they have become widely adopted by the startup community, especially in the US. However, SAFE contracts are not limited to the traditional startup sector. They can also be applied to the crypto space, where they offer some unique advantages and challenges. In this article, we will explore how SAFE contracts work in the crypto context, and what are the main benefits and drawbacks of using them. We will also provide some practical tips and examples for navigating SAFE contracts in the crypto era. Here are some of the topics that we will cover:

- How SAFE contracts work in the crypto space: We will explain the basic mechanics and logic of SAFE contracts, and how they differ from other types of investment contracts, such as equity, debt, or tokens. We will also compare and contrast different versions of SAFE contracts, such as pre-money and post-money SAFEs, and how they affect the valuation and dilution of the startup and the investor.

- Why SAFE contracts are popular in the crypto space: We will explore the main reasons why SAFE contracts are attractive for both startups and investors in the crypto space, such as simplicity, flexibility, speed, and alignment. We will also discuss some of the use cases and scenarios where SAFE contracts are most suitable, such as seed funding, bridge financing, or token sales.

- What are the challenges and risks of SAFE contracts in the crypto space: We will highlight some of the potential pitfalls and drawbacks of SAFE contracts, and how they can be mitigated or avoided. We will also address some of the legal and regulatory issues and uncertainties that surround SAFE contracts, and how they vary across different jurisdictions and markets.

- How to negotiate and execute SAFE contracts in the crypto space: We will provide some practical advice and best practices for both startups and investors on how to approach and handle SAFE contracts, such as how to choose the right version and terms, how to conduct due diligence and valuation, how to monitor and enforce the contract, and how to deal with disputes and conflicts. We will also illustrate some real-world examples and case studies of successful and unsuccessful SAFE contracts in the crypto space, and what lessons can be learned from them.

By the end of this article, you will have a comprehensive and in-depth understanding of SAFE contracts in the crypto space, and how they can help you achieve your goals and objectives. Whether you are a startup founder looking for funding, an investor looking for opportunities, or a curious observer looking for insights, this article will provide you with valuable and actionable information that you can use to your advantage. Let's get started!

2. Benefits of SAFE contracts for crypto startups and investors

One of the main challenges that crypto startups and investors face is how to value the tokens that are issued in exchange for funding. Traditional equity models may not be suitable for the dynamic and uncertain nature of the crypto space, where tokens can fluctuate significantly in price and utility over time. This is where SAFE contracts come in handy. SAFE stands for Simple agreement for Future equity, and it is a type of contract that allows investors to provide capital to crypto startups in return for the right to receive tokens in the future at a discounted rate. SAFE contracts offer several benefits for both parties, such as:

- Flexibility: SAFE contracts do not specify a valuation cap or a discount rate at the time of signing. Instead, these terms are determined by the future token sale event, which may depend on various factors such as market conditions, regulatory developments, and product milestones. This gives both the startup and the investor the flexibility to adapt to the changing circumstances and negotiate the best deal possible.

- Simplicity: SAFE contracts are designed to be simple and easy to understand, without requiring complex legal or financial terms. They are also standardized and open-source, which means that anyone can use them without paying fees or hiring lawyers. This reduces the transaction costs and the time required to close the deal, allowing both parties to focus on the core aspects of their business.

- Alignment: SAFE contracts align the incentives of the startup and the investor, as both benefit from the success of the token sale event. The startup gets the funding it needs to develop its product and grow its user base, while the investor gets the opportunity to acquire tokens at a lower price than the public market. This creates a win-win situation for both sides, and fosters a long-term relationship based on trust and mutual support.

3. Risks and challenges of SAFE contracts in the crypto industry

While SAFE contracts offer a simple and flexible way for crypto startups to raise funds and for investors to participate in the future growth of the industry, they also entail some risks and challenges that need to be carefully considered. In this section, we will explore some of the potential pitfalls and drawbacks of using SAFE contracts in the crypto space, as well as some possible solutions and best practices to mitigate them.

Some of the risks and challenges of SAFE contracts in the crypto industry are:

1. Regulatory uncertainty: The legal status and enforceability of SAFE contracts in the crypto industry are still unclear and vary across different jurisdictions. Depending on the nature and structure of the SAFE contract, it may be subject to different regulations and requirements, such as securities laws, anti-money laundering rules, tax implications, and consumer protection laws. For example, in the US, the SEC has issued guidance on how to determine whether a digital asset is a security or not, based on the Howey test and other factors. However, this guidance is not binding and may change over time, creating uncertainty and complexity for both issuers and investors of SAFE contracts. Moreover, some countries may have more restrictive or prohibitive regulations on crypto-related activities, making it difficult or illegal to use SAFE contracts in those jurisdictions. Therefore, it is important for both parties to conduct proper due diligence and consult with legal experts before entering into a SAFE contract, and to comply with the relevant laws and regulations in their respective jurisdictions.

2. Valuation ambiguity: One of the key features of SAFE contracts is that they do not specify a valuation cap or a discount rate for the conversion of the SAFE into equity or tokens. This means that the valuation of the SAFE contract is determined by the valuation of the subsequent financing round or the network launch event, which may be subject to market fluctuations and speculation. This creates ambiguity and uncertainty for both the issuer and the investor, as they may not know the exact value of their SAFE contract until the conversion event occurs. For example, if the issuer raises funds at a higher valuation than expected, the investor may receive less equity or tokens than anticipated, diluting their ownership and returns. Conversely, if the issuer raises funds at a lower valuation than expected, the investor may receive more equity or tokens than anticipated, increasing their exposure and risk. Therefore, it is advisable for both parties to agree on a reasonable valuation range or a formula for the conversion of the SAFE contract, and to align their expectations and interests accordingly.

3. Liquidity risk: Another challenge of SAFE contracts in the crypto industry is the lack of liquidity and exit options for the investors. Unlike traditional equity or debt instruments, SAFE contracts do not grant the investors any rights or claims to the issuer's assets or cash flows, nor do they entitle them to any dividends or interest payments. The only way for the investors to realize their returns is to convert their SAFE contracts into equity or tokens, and then sell them on the secondary market. However, this may not be possible or feasible for several reasons. First, the conversion event may take a long time to occur, depending on the progress and success of the issuer's project. Second, the equity or tokens that the investors receive may not be liquid or tradable, due to regulatory restrictions, technical issues, or market conditions. Third, the equity or tokens that the investors receive may not have a stable or favorable price, due to volatility, competition, or other factors. Therefore, it is important for the investors to assess the liquidity and exit potential of their SAFE contracts, and to diversify their portfolio and risk accordingly.

4. How to create and execute a SAFE contract on the blockchain?

One of the most innovative applications of blockchain technology is the creation and execution of smart contracts, which are self-enforcing agreements that can be programmed to perform various functions without the need for intermediaries. Smart contracts can be used to facilitate a variety of transactions, such as crowdfunding, voting, identity verification, and asset management. However, one of the most promising use cases of smart contracts is the implementation of SAFE contracts, which are a novel form of fundraising for startups in the crypto space.

SAFE stands for Simple Agreement for Future Equity, and it is a contract between an investor and a startup that grants the investor the right to receive equity in the future, in exchange for providing capital to the startup at the present time. Unlike traditional equity or debt financing, SAFE contracts do not specify a valuation or interest rate for the startup, nor do they impose any obligations or restrictions on the startup's operations. Instead, SAFE contracts are triggered by certain events, such as a valuation round, an IPO, or an acquisition, that determine the amount and terms of equity that the investor will receive.

SAFE contracts were originally introduced by Y Combinator, a leading startup accelerator, in 2013, as a way to simplify and streamline the fundraising process for early-stage startups. However, SAFE contracts have also gained popularity in the crypto space, where startups often face challenges in raising capital from traditional sources, such as venture capitalists or banks. By using blockchain technology and smart contracts, startups can create and execute SAFE contracts on the blockchain, which offer several advantages over conventional methods, such as:

- Transparency: Blockchain technology enables the creation of a public and immutable ledger that records all the transactions and events related to the SAFE contract, such as the amount of capital raised, the trigger events, and the equity distribution. This ensures that both the investor and the startup have full visibility and accountability of the terms and outcomes of the SAFE contract, and can avoid any disputes or frauds.

- Efficiency: Blockchain technology eliminates the need for intermediaries, such as lawyers, accountants, or brokers, who usually charge fees and commissions for facilitating the fundraising process. By using smart contracts, the investor and the startup can directly interact with each other, and automate the execution and enforcement of the SAFE contract, without any human intervention or delay.

- Flexibility: blockchain technology allows the investor and the startup to customize and tailor the SAFE contract according to their preferences and needs, such as the trigger events, the valuation cap, the discount rate, the pro rata rights, and the conversion mechanism. By using smart contracts, the investor and the startup can easily modify and update the SAFE contract, as long as they both agree on the changes.

To create and execute a SAFE contract on the blockchain, the investor and the startup need to follow these steps:

1. Choose a platform: The first step is to choose a platform that supports the creation and execution of smart contracts on the blockchain, such as Ethereum, Cardano, or Tezos. The platform should provide a secure and reliable network, a user-friendly interface, and a compatible programming language, such as Solidity, Plutus, or Michelson.

2. Draft a template: The next step is to draft a template for the SAFE contract, which defines the basic structure and logic of the agreement, such as the parties involved, the amount of capital, the trigger events, and the equity terms. The template can be based on existing models, such as the ones provided by Y Combinator, or customized according to the specific needs of the investor and the startup.

3. Deploy the contract: The third step is to deploy the SAFE contract on the blockchain, which involves compiling the template into a smart contract code, and sending it to the platform's network, where it is verified and executed by the nodes. The deployment of the SAFE contract requires the payment of a fee, known as gas, which depends on the complexity and size of the code.

4. Fund the contract: The fourth step is to fund the SAFE contract, which involves transferring the capital from the investor to the startup, in exchange for the right to receive equity in the future. The funding of the SAFE contract can be done in various ways, such as using cryptocurrencies, stablecoins, or tokens, depending on the preferences and capabilities of the investor and the startup.

5. Monitor the contract: The fifth step is to monitor the SAFE contract, which involves tracking and verifying the transactions and events related to the agreement, such as the capital raised, the trigger events, and the equity distribution. The monitoring of the SAFE contract can be done using various tools, such as blockchain explorers, smart contract analyzers, or dashboards, that provide real-time and accurate information about the status and performance of the contract.

6. Execute the contract: The final step is to execute the SAFE contract, which involves converting the right to receive equity into actual equity, based on the terms and conditions of the agreement. The execution of the SAFE contract can be triggered by various events, such as a valuation round, an IPO, or an acquisition, that determine the amount and type of equity that the investor will receive. The execution of the SAFE contract can be done automatically by the smart contract code, or manually by the investor and the startup, depending on the preferences and capabilities of the parties.

An example of a SAFE contract on the blockchain is the one created by Compound, a decentralized lending platform, in 2018. Compound raised $8.2 million from 26 investors, using a SAFE contract that granted them the right to receive equity in the future, in exchange for providing capital to the platform. The SAFE contract was deployed on the Ethereum blockchain, using a smart contract code that specified the trigger events, the valuation cap, the discount rate, and the conversion mechanism. The funding of the SAFE contract was done using Ether, the native cryptocurrency of Ethereum. The monitoring of the SAFE contract was done using Etherscan, a blockchain explorer that provides information about the transactions and events related to the contract. The execution of the SAFE contract was triggered by a valuation round in 2019, that valued Compound at $90 million, and resulted in the conversion of the right to receive equity into actual equity, based on the terms and conditions of the agreement.

SAFE contracts on the blockchain are a novel and innovative way to raise capital for startups in the crypto space, that offer several benefits over traditional methods, such as transparency, efficiency, and flexibility. However, SAFE contracts on the blockchain also pose some challenges and risks, such as regulatory uncertainty, technical complexity, and market volatility, that need to be carefully considered and addressed by the investor and the startup. Therefore, SAFE contracts on the blockchain require a high level of due diligence, trust, and collaboration between the parties, to ensure a successful and mutually beneficial outcome.

5. Best practices and tips for negotiating a SAFE contract

A SAFE contract is a simple agreement for future equity that allows investors to participate in the potential upside of a blockchain project without acquiring any tokens or equity at the time of investment. However, negotiating a SAFE contract can be challenging, as there are many factors to consider and pitfalls to avoid. In this section, we will explore some of the best practices and tips for negotiating a SAFE contract in the crypto era, based on the experiences and insights of various experts and practitioners in the field.

Some of the best practices and tips are:

1. Understand the valuation cap and the discount rate. These are two of the most important terms in a SAFE contract, as they determine the price and the amount of equity or tokens that the investor will receive in the future. The valuation cap is the maximum valuation of the project at which the SAFE will convert, and the discount rate is the percentage reduction in the price per share or token that the SAFE holder will get compared to other investors. A lower valuation cap and a higher discount rate are more favorable for the investor, as they imply a lower entry price and a higher ownership stake. However, these terms should also reflect the realistic expectations and potential of the project, as well as the market conditions and the level of risk involved.

2. Negotiate the trigger events and the conversion mechanisms. A trigger event is an event that causes the SAFE to convert into equity or tokens, such as a token sale, an equity financing, a change of control, or an IPO. The conversion mechanism is the formula that determines how many shares or tokens the SAFE holder will receive upon conversion, based on the valuation cap, the discount rate, and the price per share or token in the trigger event. The trigger events and the conversion mechanisms should be clearly defined and agreed upon by both parties, as they affect the timing and the outcome of the conversion. For example, some SAFE contracts may have a provision that allows the investor to convert the SAFE into tokens at any time, regardless of the trigger events, while others may have a provision that requires the investor to wait until a certain trigger event occurs, such as a token sale.

3. Consider the rights and obligations of the SAFE holder. A SAFE contract may also include some additional terms that specify the rights and obligations of the SAFE holder, such as information rights, voting rights, anti-dilution rights, drag-along rights, or redemption rights. These terms can have a significant impact on the investor's ability to protect and exercise their interests in the project, as well as their exposure to liabilities and risks. For example, information rights may grant the investor access to the project's financial and operational data, voting rights may allow the investor to influence the project's decisions, anti-dilution rights may protect the investor from the dilution of their ownership stake, drag-along rights may oblige the investor to sell their shares or tokens along with the founders in a change of control event, and redemption rights may enable the investor to demand the repayment of their investment under certain circumstances.

4. Evaluate the legal and regulatory implications of the SAFE contract. A SAFE contract is a novel and complex instrument that may have different legal and regulatory implications depending on the jurisdiction, the nature of the project, and the type of the conversion. For instance, a SAFE contract that converts into equity may be subject to the securities laws and the corporate laws of the relevant jurisdiction, while a SAFE contract that converts into tokens may be subject to the crypto regulations and the tax laws of the relevant jurisdiction. Moreover, a SAFE contract may also raise some ethical and social issues, such as the alignment of incentives, the governance of the project, and the impact of the project on the society and the environment. Therefore, it is advisable to consult with a qualified lawyer and a tax advisor before entering into a SAFE contract, and to conduct a thorough due diligence on the project and its team.

By following these best practices and tips, investors and founders can negotiate a SAFE contract that is fair, transparent, and mutually beneficial, and that enables them to participate in the innovation and the growth of the blockchain project. However, it is important to note that a SAFE contract is not a one-size-fits-all solution, and that each SAFE contract should be tailored to the specific needs and circumstances of the parties involved. Furthermore, a SAFE contract is not a substitute for a trustful and collaborative relationship between the investor and the founder, and that both parties should maintain a constant communication and a shared vision throughout the life cycle of the project.

6. Examples and case studies of successful and unsuccessful SAFE contracts in the crypto world

One of the most challenging aspects of investing in the crypto space is the uncertainty and volatility of the market. Unlike traditional equity financing, where investors receive a fixed percentage of ownership in a company, crypto investors often have to deal with complex and ambiguous terms that may affect their returns and rights. This is where SAFE contracts come in handy. SAFE stands for Simple Agreement for Future Equity, and it is a type of contract that allows investors to fund a crypto project in exchange for a future claim on its tokens or equity. SAFE contracts are designed to be simple, flexible, and fair for both parties, avoiding the need for valuation caps, discounts, or conversion mechanisms.

However, not all SAFE contracts are created equal. Depending on the specific terms and conditions of each contract, some SAFE contracts may be more beneficial or risky than others. In this section, we will explore some examples and case studies of successful and unsuccessful SAFE contracts in the crypto world, and analyze the factors that contributed to their outcomes. We will also provide some best practices and recommendations for both investors and founders who are considering using SAFE contracts for their crypto ventures.

Some of the examples and case studies that we will discuss are:

- Coinbase. Coinbase is one of the most successful and well-known crypto platforms in the world, with a valuation of over $100 billion. Coinbase used SAFE contracts to raise $75 million in 2015, when the crypto market was still nascent and uncertain. The SAFE contracts gave the investors the right to receive either common stock or preferred stock in Coinbase, depending on the terms of the next equity financing round. The SAFE contracts also had a provision that allowed the investors to convert their SAFE contracts into tokens if Coinbase decided to launch its own token in the future. This gave the investors the option to choose between equity or tokens, depending on their preference and the market conditions. The SAFE contracts also had a clause that protected the investors from dilution in case of a down round. As a result, the SAFE contracts enabled Coinbase to raise capital quickly and efficiently, while giving the investors a fair and flexible deal.

- The DAO. The dao was a decentralized autonomous organization that aimed to create a platform for crowdfunding and governance of crypto projects. The DAO used a type of SAFE contract called DAO tokens to raise over $150 million in 2016, making it one of the largest crowdfunding campaigns in history. The DAO tokens gave the investors the right to vote on the projects that the DAO would fund, and to receive a share of the profits from those projects. However, the DAO tokens also had a major flaw: they allowed the investors to withdraw their funds at any time, without any penalty or lock-up period. This created a vulnerability that was exploited by a hacker, who drained over $50 million worth of ether from the DAO. The DAO tokens also had no legal protection or recourse for the investors, who were left with worthless tokens and no way to recover their losses. The DAO was a disaster that showed the dangers and pitfalls of poorly designed and executed SAFE contracts.

7. Future trends and developments of SAFE contracts and crypto equity

As the crypto industry evolves, so do the ways of raising funds and distributing equity among investors and founders. SAFE contracts, which stand for Simple Agreement for Future Equity, are one of the most popular and innovative methods of financing startups in the crypto space. They offer a simple and flexible alternative to traditional equity or debt financing, allowing investors to receive tokens or shares in the future at a discounted price, based on the valuation of the next funding round. However, SAFE contracts also pose some challenges and risks, both for the issuers and the holders, as they are subject to legal, regulatory, and technical uncertainties. In this section, we will explore some of the future trends and developments of SAFE contracts and crypto equity, and how they might affect the dynamics of the crypto ecosystem. Some of the topics we will cover are:

- The emergence of new types of SAFE contracts: While the original SAFE contract was designed by Y Combinator for seed-stage startups, there have been several variations and adaptations of the concept to suit different needs and scenarios. For example, some projects have used DAICO (Decentralized Autonomous Initial Coin Offering), which combines SAFE contracts with smart contracts and governance mechanisms, to ensure accountability and transparency of the funds raised. Another example is SALSA (Simple agreement for Long-term Stake Alignment), which is a modified version of SAFE that aligns the incentives of investors and founders over a longer period of time, by introducing vesting schedules and clawback clauses. As the crypto market matures, we can expect to see more innovation and experimentation with different types of SAFE contracts, tailored to the specific characteristics and goals of each project.

- The integration of SAFE contracts with DeFi protocols: DeFi, or decentralized finance, is one of the fastest-growing and most disruptive sectors of the crypto industry, offering a wide range of financial services and products, such as lending, borrowing, trading, investing, and insurance, without intermediaries or centralized control. DeFi protocols are powered by smart contracts, which are self-executing and immutable pieces of code that run on a blockchain. SAFE contracts, which are also based on smart contracts, can benefit from the integration with DeFi protocols, as they can leverage the existing infrastructure, liquidity, and security of the DeFi ecosystem. For instance, SAFE contracts can be used as collateral for borrowing or lending on DeFi platforms, or as a way of accessing yield farming or staking opportunities. Moreover, DeFi protocols can also use SAFE contracts as a way of raising funds or distributing equity among their users or contributors, creating a more decentralized and inclusive model of governance and ownership.

- The regulation and standardization of SAFE contracts: One of the main challenges and uncertainties of SAFE contracts is the lack of a clear and consistent legal and regulatory framework, especially across different jurisdictions. SAFE contracts are often considered as securities, which means they are subject to complex and stringent rules and regulations, such as registration, disclosure, compliance, and taxation. However, the definition and classification of securities vary from country to country, and some jurisdictions have more favorable or hostile attitudes towards crypto assets and activities. This creates a lot of confusion and ambiguity for both issuers and holders of SAFE contracts, as they may face legal risks, liabilities, or penalties, depending on the interpretation and enforcement of the law. Therefore, there is a need for more clarity and consistency in the regulation and standardization of SAFE contracts, as well as more education and awareness among the stakeholders, to ensure a fair and safe environment for the development and adoption of SAFE contracts and crypto equity.

8. Key takeaways and recommendations for using SAFE contracts in the crypto era

In this article, we have explored the concept of blockchain SAFE, a novel form of Simple Agreement for Future Equity that leverages the advantages of blockchain technology and smart contracts. We have discussed the benefits, challenges, and risks of using SAFE contracts in the crypto era, as well as the legal and regulatory implications. Based on our analysis, we would like to offer some key takeaways and recommendations for entrepreneurs, investors, and regulators who are interested in or involved with SAFE contracts in the crypto space.

- SAFE contracts are an innovative and flexible way of raising capital for crypto startups. Unlike traditional equity or debt financing, SAFE contracts do not require valuation, dilution, or repayment. They allow startups to raise funds quickly and easily, without giving up control or ownership of their projects. They also enable investors to participate in the future success of the startups, without bearing the downside risk of losing their principal.

- SAFE contracts are not without challenges and risks. SAFE contracts are still a relatively new and untested form of financing, and there are many uncertainties and complexities involved. For instance, SAFE contracts may face legal disputes over their enforceability, validity, and interpretation. They may also pose tax and accounting issues for both parties. Moreover, SAFE contracts may expose startups and investors to various risks, such as market volatility, regulatory changes, technical failures, and fraud.

- SAFE contracts require careful design and execution. To avoid potential pitfalls and maximize the benefits of SAFE contracts, both parties should pay attention to the design and execution of the contracts. They should clearly define the terms and conditions of the contracts, such as the trigger events, the valuation cap, the discount rate, and the conversion mechanism. They should also use reliable and secure platforms and protocols to create and execute the contracts, such as Ethereum, Tezos, or Cardano. Additionally, they should consult with legal, tax, and accounting experts before entering into SAFE contracts.

- SAFE contracts need more research and regulation. As SAFE contracts are still in their infancy, there is a need for more research and regulation to support their development and adoption. Researchers should conduct empirical studies and experiments to test the feasibility and effectiveness of SAFE contracts in different scenarios and contexts. Regulators should provide clear and consistent guidance and rules for SAFE contracts, to ensure their legality, transparency, and fairness. They should also balance the need for innovation and protection, and foster a conducive and collaborative environment for SAFE contracts.

Read Other Blogs