Blockchain differentiation: Private vs: Public Blockchains: Key Differences and Use Cases

1. What are blockchains and why are they important?

Blockchains are a revolutionary technology that enables distributed and decentralized systems of trust, where transactions and data are recorded and verified by a network of nodes, rather than by a central authority. Blockchains have many potential applications in various domains, such as finance, supply chain, healthcare, voting, and more. However, not all blockchains are created equal. Depending on the design and implementation, blockchains can have different characteristics and trade-offs that affect their suitability for different use cases. In this article, we will explore the key differences and use cases of two major types of blockchains: private and public.

- Private blockchains are blockchains that are restricted to a specific group of participants, such as a consortium of organizations or a network of trusted peers. Private blockchains have the following features and advantages:

1. Access control: Private blockchains can enforce strict rules on who can join the network, read the data, and write the transactions. This allows for greater privacy, security, and compliance with regulations.

2. Performance: Private blockchains can achieve higher transaction throughput, lower latency, and lower costs than public blockchains, as they do not need to rely on complex consensus mechanisms or incentivize miners to validate transactions.

3. Customization: Private blockchains can be tailored to the specific needs and preferences of the participants, such as the choice of consensus algorithm, governance model, and smart contract functionality.

- Public blockchains are blockchains that are open to anyone, without any permission or restriction. Public blockchains have the following features and advantages:

1. Censorship resistance: Public blockchains are immune to censorship, manipulation, or interference by any single entity or authority, as they are maintained by a large and diverse network of nodes that operate independently and competitively.

2. Innovation: Public blockchains foster innovation and experimentation, as they allow anyone to create and participate in new applications and services, without any gatekeepers or intermediaries.

3. Inclusion: Public blockchains enable inclusion and empowerment, as they provide access and opportunity to anyone, regardless of their identity, location, or status.

To illustrate the differences and use cases of private and public blockchains, let us consider some examples:

- Hyperledger Fabric is an example of a private blockchain platform that is designed for enterprise applications. Hyperledger Fabric allows organizations to create permissioned networks, where they can define the roles and permissions of the participants, the endorsement policies of the transactions, and the smart contracts that implement the business logic. Hyperledger Fabric is used by many industries, such as finance, healthcare, and trade, to enable collaboration, efficiency, and transparency among multiple parties.

- Bitcoin is an example of a public blockchain platform that is designed for peer-to-peer digital cash. Bitcoin allows anyone to send and receive value, without any intermediaries or trusted third parties. Bitcoin uses a proof-of-work consensus mechanism, where miners compete to solve cryptographic puzzles and earn rewards for validating transactions and securing the network. Bitcoin is used by many people, such as investors, traders, and activists, to enable financial freedom, sovereignty, and resilience.

2. Definition and Characteristics

One of the main aspects that differentiate blockchains is the level of access and control that they offer to their participants. Blockchains can be classified into two broad categories: private and public. These categories are not mutually exclusive, as there are also hybrid models that combine elements of both. However, for the sake of simplicity, we will focus on the main features and characteristics of each type of blockchain.

- Private blockchains are blockchains that are only accessible by a selected group of entities, such as a consortium of companies, a government agency, or a private organization. These entities have the authority to decide who can join the network, validate transactions, and maintain the ledger. Private blockchains are often used for scenarios that require high levels of privacy, security, and efficiency, such as supply chain management, identity verification, or voting systems. Some examples of private blockchains are Hyperledger Fabric, Corda, and Quorum.

- Public blockchains are blockchains that are open to anyone who wants to participate, without requiring permission or identity verification. Anyone can join the network, send and receive transactions, and contribute to the consensus process. Public blockchains are often used for scenarios that require decentralization, transparency, and censorship-resistance, such as peer-to-peer payments, digital assets, or social networks. Some examples of public blockchains are Bitcoin, Ethereum, and Cardano.

The table below summarizes some of the key differences and use cases of private and public blockchains:

| Feature | Private Blockchains | Public Blockchains |

| Access | Restricted | Open |

| Control | Centralized | Decentralized |

| Consensus | Faster and cheaper | Slower and more expensive |

| Privacy | Higher | Lower |

| Security | Depends on the trustworthiness of the entities | Depends on the robustness of the cryptography |

| Scalability | Higher | Lower |

| Interoperability | Easier to integrate with existing systems | Harder to integrate with existing systems |

| Use Cases | Supply chain management, identity verification, voting systems, etc. | Peer-to-peer payments, digital assets, social networks, etc.

3. Advantages and Disadvantages

While public blockchains are open and decentralized, private blockchains are closed and centralized. This means that only authorized participants can join and access the data and transactions on a private blockchain network. Private blockchains are often used by enterprises or organizations that want to leverage the benefits of blockchain technology, such as security, immutability, and transparency, without exposing their sensitive information to the public. However, private blockchains also have some drawbacks that need to be considered. Here are some of the advantages and disadvantages of private blockchains:

- Advantages:

1. Privacy and confidentiality: Private blockchains allow the network members to control who can see and access their data and transactions. This is especially important for businesses or institutions that deal with confidential or proprietary information, such as financial records, medical records, or intellectual property. For example, a private blockchain network can be used by a consortium of banks to share and verify transactions among themselves, without revealing their identities or balances to the public or competitors.

2. Scalability and performance: Private blockchains can handle more transactions per second and process them faster than public blockchains, because they have fewer nodes and less computational power required to reach consensus. This can improve the efficiency and productivity of the network participants, as well as reduce the costs and delays associated with transactions. For example, a private blockchain network can be used by a supply chain management system to track and trace the movement of goods and materials across multiple parties, without relying on intermediaries or third-party verification.

3. Customizability and flexibility: Private blockchains can be tailored to the specific needs and preferences of the network participants, such as the governance model, the consensus mechanism, the smart contract functionality, and the data structure. This can enable the network participants to optimize their business processes and workflows, as well as to innovate and experiment with new features and applications. For example, a private blockchain network can be used by a research and development team to collaborate and share their findings and innovations, without compromising their intellectual property rights or quality standards.

- Disadvantages:

1. Centralization and trust: Private blockchains are controlled by a single or a few entities that have the authority to grant or revoke access, modify the rules, and validate the transactions. This can create a risk of corruption, collusion, or manipulation by the network administrators or the dominant participants, as well as a dependence on their honesty and reliability. For example, a private blockchain network can be used by a government agency to store and manage citizen data, but this can also raise concerns about the privacy, security, and sovereignty of the data, as well as the accountability and transparency of the agency.

2. Security and immutability: Private blockchains are more vulnerable to cyberattacks and data breaches than public blockchains, because they have fewer nodes and less distributed consensus. This can compromise the integrity and authenticity of the data and transactions, as well as the availability and resilience of the network. For example, a private blockchain network can be used by a voting system to record and tally the votes, but this can also expose the system to hacking, tampering, or denial-of-service attacks, which can affect the outcome and legitimacy of the election.

3. Interoperability and compatibility: Private blockchains are isolated and incompatible with other blockchains, both public and private. This can limit the network participants' ability to interact and exchange value with other parties outside their network, as well as to leverage the network effects and innovations of the broader blockchain ecosystem. For example, a private blockchain network can be used by a loyalty program to reward and redeem points among its members, but this can also restrict the members' options and opportunities to use their points with other programs or platforms.

4. Advantages and Disadvantages

One of the main aspects that differentiates blockchains is the level of access and control that they offer to their participants. Public blockchains are open and decentralized networks that allow anyone to join and participate without requiring permission or intermediaries. They are often considered as the true embodiment of the original vision of blockchain as a distributed ledger that enables peer-to-peer transactions and fosters trustless collaboration. However, public blockchains also have some drawbacks that limit their suitability for certain use cases and scenarios. In this section, we will explore some of the advantages and disadvantages of public blockchains and how they compare to private blockchains.

Some of the advantages of public blockchains are:

1. Transparency and immutability: Public blockchains are transparent and immutable, meaning that anyone can view and verify the transactions and data stored on them. This enhances the security and integrity of the network, as well as the accountability and trust of the participants. For example, Bitcoin, the first and most popular public blockchain, allows anyone to track the history and balance of any address, and prevents any tampering or censorship of the transactions by its consensus mechanism.

2. Inclusiveness and innovation: Public blockchains are inclusive and innovative, meaning that anyone can join and contribute to the network without facing any barriers or restrictions. This enables a diverse and global community of users, developers, and entrepreneurs to access and leverage the benefits of blockchain technology, such as financial inclusion, social impact, and new business models. For example, Ethereum, the second-largest public blockchain, supports a vibrant ecosystem of decentralized applications (DApps) and smart contracts that offer various services and solutions across different domains and industries.

3. Network effects and interoperability: Public blockchains benefit from network effects and interoperability, meaning that they grow and improve as more participants and resources join and interact with them. This creates a positive feedback loop that enhances the value and utility of the network, as well as the potential for cross-chain collaboration and integration. For example, Polkadot, a public blockchain platform that aims to connect and secure different blockchains, enables seamless and scalable communication and exchange of data and assets among diverse networks.

Some of the disadvantages of public blockchains are:

1. Scalability and performance: Public blockchains face scalability and performance issues, meaning that they have limited capacity and speed to process and confirm transactions and data. This results in high costs, low throughput, and long delays that affect the user experience and efficiency of the network. For example, Bitcoin can only process about 7 transactions per second (TPS), while Ethereum can handle about 15 TPS, which are far below the demand and expectations of the users and the market.

2. Privacy and compliance: Public blockchains lack privacy and compliance, meaning that they expose the transactions and data of the participants to the public and do not adhere to the regulatory and legal requirements of different jurisdictions and sectors. This poses risks and challenges for the users and the network, such as identity theft, data breaches, fraud, sanctions, and lawsuits. For example, Bitcoin transactions are pseudonymous but not anonymous, as they can be traced and linked to the real identities of the users by using various techniques and tools.

3. Governance and sustainability: Public blockchains have governance and sustainability problems, meaning that they have difficulty and controversy in making and implementing decisions and changes that affect the network and its participants. This leads to conflicts, disputes, and forks that undermine the stability and harmony of the network, as well as the environmental and social impact of the network, such as energy consumption, carbon footprint, and social responsibility. For example, Bitcoin has experienced several hard forks, such as Bitcoin Cash and Bitcoin SV, that have created competing and incompatible versions of the network.

5. Examples and Applications

Private blockchains are a type of distributed ledger technology (DLT) that operate within a closed network of trusted participants. Unlike public blockchains, which are open and permissionless, private blockchains require an invitation and validation to join the network. This allows for greater control over the governance, security, and performance of the blockchain. Private blockchains are often used by organizations that want to leverage the benefits of DLT, such as transparency, immutability, and efficiency, without compromising on privacy, scalability, and compliance.

Some of the use cases of private blockchains are:

- Supply chain management: Private blockchains can enable a more efficient and transparent tracking of goods and services across the supply chain, from the source to the end consumer. By recording every transaction and movement on the blockchain, private blockchains can reduce fraud, waste, and errors, as well as improve quality, safety, and customer satisfaction. For example, IBM and Walmart have partnered to use a private blockchain to trace food products from farm to fork, enhancing food safety and recall efficiency.

- Healthcare: Private blockchains can facilitate the secure and seamless sharing of medical records and data among authorized parties, such as doctors, patients, insurers, and researchers. By using cryptographic encryption and smart contracts, private blockchains can ensure the privacy, integrity, and consent of the data, as well as automate processes and transactions. For example, MedRec is a private blockchain project that aims to create a decentralized medical record system that empowers patients and providers.

- Financial services: Private blockchains can offer a faster, cheaper, and more secure way of conducting financial transactions and services, such as payments, remittances, trade finance, and asset management. By eliminating intermediaries and central authorities, private blockchains can reduce costs, risks, and delays, as well as increase transparency, trust, and compliance. For example, JPMorgan Chase has developed a private blockchain platform called Quorum, which is used for interbank payments, debt issuance, and tokenization.

6. Examples and Applications

Public blockchains are open and decentralized networks that allow anyone to join and participate without permission or intermediaries. They are often considered as the most transparent and secure form of blockchain, as they rely on consensus mechanisms and cryptographic proofs to ensure the validity and immutability of the data. Public blockchains also enable the creation and exchange of native tokens or cryptocurrencies, which can be used as incentives, rewards, or fees for the network participants.

Some of the use cases of public blockchains are:

- Digital currencies: The most prominent and popular example of public blockchains is Bitcoin, the first and largest cryptocurrency that aims to provide a peer-to-peer electronic cash system. Bitcoin uses a proof-of-work (PoW) algorithm to secure the network and prevent double-spending attacks. Other cryptocurrencies that use public blockchains include Ethereum, Litecoin, Monero, and many more.

- smart contracts: Smart contracts are self-executing agreements that are encoded on the blockchain and can facilitate various transactions and interactions without intermediaries or trusted third parties. Ethereum is the leading platform for smart contracts, as it supports a Turing-complete programming language and a virtual machine that can run any arbitrary code. Smart contracts can enable various applications such as decentralized finance (DeFi), decentralized autonomous organizations (DAOs), non-fungible tokens (NFTs), and more.

- Identity management: Public blockchains can also provide a way to create and manage digital identities that are verifiable, secure, and portable across different platforms and services. For example, Civic is a project that leverages public blockchains to create a decentralized identity ecosystem that allows users to control and share their personal data with verified entities. Another example is uPort, which uses Ethereum to create a self-sovereign identity system that enables users to own and manage their identity and reputation.

- Supply chain management: Public blockchains can also improve the efficiency and transparency of supply chain management, as they can track and trace the provenance and movement of goods and materials across different parties and locations. For example, VeChain is a project that uses public blockchains to create a platform for various industries such as luxury goods, agriculture, logistics, and more. VeChain uses smart chips and sensors to collect and record data on the blockchain, which can be accessed and verified by anyone.

- Voting systems: Public blockchains can also enhance the security and integrity of voting systems, as they can provide a tamper-proof and auditable record of the votes and results. For example, Voatz is a project that uses public blockchains to create a mobile voting platform that allows voters to cast their ballots securely and conveniently. Voatz uses biometric authentication and blockchain encryption to ensure the identity and privacy of the voters, and also allows for real-time verification and auditing of the votes.

7. A Combination of Private and Public Blockchains

One of the main challenges of blockchain technology is finding the right balance between security, scalability, and decentralization. Depending on the use case and the requirements of the participants, different types of blockchains may be more suitable than others. However, there is also a third option that combines the best of both worlds: hybrid blockchains.

A hybrid blockchain is a blockchain that operates on both private and public networks, allowing for selective data sharing and access control. A hybrid blockchain can leverage the advantages of private blockchains, such as faster transactions, lower costs, and higher privacy, while also benefiting from the features of public blockchains, such as transparency, immutability, and interoperability. A hybrid blockchain can also provide more flexibility and customization for the users, as they can choose which data to keep private and which to share with the public.

Some of the potential use cases and benefits of hybrid blockchains are:

- Supply chain management: A hybrid blockchain can enable a more efficient and transparent supply chain, where the participants can track the origin, quality, and status of the products, while also protecting sensitive information such as prices, contracts, and inventory levels. For example, IBM and Maersk have developed a hybrid blockchain platform called TradeLens, which aims to improve the global trade ecosystem by connecting shippers, carriers, customs, and ports.

- Healthcare: A hybrid blockchain can improve the security and accessibility of medical records, while also ensuring the privacy and consent of the patients. The patients can store their personal health data on a private blockchain, and grant access to authorized parties, such as doctors, insurers, or researchers, on a public blockchain. For example, Medicalchain is a hybrid blockchain platform that allows patients to own and control their health records, and share them securely with healthcare providers.

- Identity management: A hybrid blockchain can provide a more reliable and user-centric identity system, where the users can create and manage their own digital identities, and verify them with trusted entities, such as governments, banks, or social media platforms. The users can store their identity data on a private blockchain, and share their credentials or attestations on a public blockchain. For example, Civic is a hybrid blockchain platform that offers a decentralized identity verification service, where the users can prove their identity without revealing their personal information.

- Voting: A hybrid blockchain can enable a more transparent and secure voting system, where the voters can cast their votes anonymously and verifiably, while also preventing fraud, manipulation, or coercion. The votes can be recorded on a private blockchain, and the results can be published on a public blockchain. For example, Agora is a hybrid blockchain platform that provides a digital voting solution, where the voters can use their smartphones to vote remotely and securely.

8. Future Trends and Challenges of Blockchain Technology

As blockchain technology evolves and matures, it faces new opportunities and challenges that will shape its future development and adoption. Blockchain differentiation, or the choice between private and public blockchains, is one of the key factors that will influence the design, performance, and security of blockchain applications. Depending on the use case, different types of blockchains may offer advantages or disadvantages in terms of scalability, privacy, governance, interoperability, and regulation. In this section, we will explore some of the future trends and challenges of blockchain technology, focusing on the implications of blockchain differentiation for various domains and sectors. Some of the topics that we will cover are:

- Scalability and throughput: One of the main challenges of blockchain technology is to achieve high scalability and throughput without compromising decentralization and security. Public blockchains, such as Bitcoin and Ethereum, have limited transaction capacity and speed due to their consensus mechanisms and network size. Private blockchains, on the other hand, can achieve higher scalability and throughput by restricting the number and identity of participants and validators. However, this also reduces the level of trust and transparency among the parties involved. Therefore, a trade-off between scalability and decentralization must be considered when choosing between private and public blockchains. Some of the possible solutions to improve scalability and throughput include layer-2 protocols, sharding, sidechains, and interoperable blockchains.

- Privacy and confidentiality: Another challenge of blockchain technology is to ensure privacy and confidentiality of the data and transactions stored on the ledger. Public blockchains, by nature, are open and transparent, which means that anyone can access and verify the information on the ledger. This can pose a risk for sensitive or personal data, such as financial records, medical records, or identity information. Private blockchains, on the other hand, can provide more privacy and confidentiality by encrypting the data and restricting the access and visibility of the ledger. However, this also reduces the auditability and verifiability of the ledger, which may affect the trust and accountability among the parties involved. Therefore, a trade-off between privacy and transparency must be considered when choosing between private and public blockchains. Some of the possible solutions to enhance privacy and confidentiality include zero-knowledge proofs, homomorphic encryption, and differential privacy.

- Governance and regulation: A third challenge of blockchain technology is to establish effective governance and regulation mechanisms that can balance the interests and needs of the stakeholders and users of the ledger. Public blockchains, by design, are decentralized and autonomous, which means that they operate without a central authority or intermediary. This can enable more innovation, participation, and inclusion, but also create challenges for coordination, decision-making, and dispute resolution. Private blockchains, on the other hand, can have more centralized and hierarchical governance and regulation structures, which can facilitate more efficiency, stability, and compliance, but also create challenges for innovation, participation, and inclusion. Therefore, a trade-off between centralization and decentralization must be considered when choosing between private and public blockchains. Some of the possible solutions to improve governance and regulation include tokenomics, smart contracts, and self-sovereign identity.

9. Summary and Recommendations

In this article, we have explored the main differences and use cases of private and public blockchains, two types of distributed ledger technologies that have gained popularity in recent years. We have seen that private blockchains are more suitable for enterprise applications that require high levels of privacy, security, scalability, and efficiency, while public blockchains are more suitable for decentralized applications that require openness, transparency, censorship-resistance, and innovation. Based on our analysis, we can offer the following recommendations for choosing the right blockchain solution for your needs:

- Consider the trade-offs between the benefits and drawbacks of each type of blockchain. Private blockchains offer more control, performance, and compliance, but at the cost of reduced decentralization, interoperability, and innovation. Public blockchains offer more freedom, diversity, and resilience, but at the cost of reduced privacy, speed, and efficiency.

- Evaluate the requirements and objectives of your use case. Private blockchains are ideal for use cases that involve sensitive data, regulated industries, or trusted parties, such as supply chain management, identity management, or banking. Public blockchains are ideal for use cases that involve public goods, social impact, or untrusted parties, such as crowdfunding, voting, or peer-to-peer transactions.

- Assess the availability and maturity of the platforms and tools that support each type of blockchain. Private blockchains are supported by well-established platforms and tools, such as Hyperledger Fabric, Corda, or Quorum, that offer enterprise-grade features and functionalities. Public blockchains are supported by emerging platforms and tools, such as Ethereum, Cardano, or Polkadot, that offer cutting-edge features and functionalities.

- Experiment with different blockchain solutions and learn from the best practices and experiences of others. Private blockchains can benefit from the lessons learned and innovations developed by the public blockchain community, such as smart contracts, governance models, or interoperability protocols. Public blockchains can benefit from the standards and regulations adopted and enforced by the private blockchain community, such as security audits, compliance frameworks, or identity solutions.

By following these recommendations, you can make an informed and strategic decision about which type of blockchain is best suited for your use case. Whether you choose a private or a public blockchain, you can leverage the power and potential of distributed ledger technologies to create value and impact for your organization and society.

Read Other Blogs