One of the most common and attractive forms of compensation that startups offer to their employees is stock options. Stock options give employees the right to buy a certain number of shares of the company at a predetermined price, usually lower than the market value, after a certain period of time. This way, employees can benefit from the growth and success of the company by owning a part of it. However, not all stock options are created equal, and there are some important factors that employees need to understand before accepting or exercising them. One of these factors is vesting.
Vesting is the process by which an employee earns the right to own their stock options over time. Vesting serves two main purposes: it aligns the interests of the employees and the company, and it prevents employees from leaving the company too soon.
- Alignment of interests: Vesting ensures that employees are committed to the long-term vision and goals of the company, and that they share the risks and rewards of ownership. If employees were granted their stock options upfront, they might be tempted to sell them as soon as the price goes up, or to leave the company for a better offer. By requiring employees to stay with the company for a certain period of time before they can own their stock options, vesting incentivizes them to work hard and contribute to the company's success.
- Retention of talent: Vesting also helps the company retain its valuable employees and avoid losing them to competitors. If employees were able to leave the company with their stock options at any time, they might be lured away by other companies that offer higher salaries or better benefits. By making employees wait for their stock options to vest, vesting encourages them to stay loyal and invested in the company.
Vesting can take different forms and have different terms depending on the company and the agreement. Some of the common types of vesting are:
- Cliff vesting: This means that the employee has to work for the company for a certain period of time, usually one year, before they can own any of their stock options. After the cliff period, the employee can own all of their stock options at once. For example, if an employee is granted 100 stock options with a one-year cliff, they will not own any of their stock options until they complete one year of service. After one year, they will own all 100 stock options.
- Graded vesting: This means that the employee can own a portion of their stock options gradually over time, usually on a monthly or quarterly basis. For example, if an employee is granted 100 stock options with a four-year vesting period and a 25% vesting rate per year, they will own 25 stock options after one year, 50 stock options after two years, 75 stock options after three years, and 100 stock options after four years.
- Milestone vesting: This means that the employee can own their stock options based on the achievement of certain goals or milestones, such as revenue, product launch, or customer acquisition. For example, if an employee is granted 100 stock options with a milestone vesting schedule, they might own 25 stock options after the company reaches $1 million in revenue, 25 stock options after the company launches its product, 25 stock options after the company acquires 10,000 customers, and 25 stock options after the company raises its next funding round.
Vesting is an important concept that employees need to understand before accepting or exercising their stock options. Vesting determines when and how employees can own their stock options, and how they can benefit from the company's growth and success. By knowing the vesting terms and conditions, employees can make informed decisions about their compensation and career.
Vesting agreements are contracts that grant employees or founders the right to acquire ownership of a company's shares over time. They are designed to incentivize long-term commitment and performance, as well as to protect the company from losing valuable equity to unproductive or disloyal members. There are different types of vesting agreements, each with its own advantages and disadvantages. In this segment, we will explore three common types of vesting agreements: stock options, restricted stock units, and founder shares.
1. Stock options are the right to buy a certain number of shares at a predetermined price, called the strike price, within a specified period of time, usually 10 years. Stock options are typically subject to a vesting schedule, which means that the employee or founder can only exercise them after meeting certain milestones, such as working for a certain number of years or achieving certain goals. Stock options are attractive because they offer the potential for high returns if the company's value increases over time. However, they also entail some risks and costs, such as:
- The employee or founder has to pay the strike price and taxes when exercising the options, which may be substantial if the company's value has risen significantly.
- The employee or founder may lose the options if they leave the company before they vest, or if the company goes bankrupt or is acquired by another entity.
- The employee or founder may face dilution if the company issues more shares to raise capital or reward other stakeholders, which reduces the percentage of ownership and value of the options.
- The employee or founder may have to comply with certain restrictions or regulations when selling the shares, such as lock-up periods, insider trading rules, or securities laws.
- The employee or founder may have to deal with complex accounting and tax issues, such as determining the fair market value of the options, reporting income and expenses, and filing appropriate forms.
For example, Alice is granted 10,000 stock options with a strike price of $1 per share and a four-year vesting schedule, with 25% vesting each year. After two years, Alice can exercise 5,000 options and buy 5,000 shares for $5,000. If the company's value has increased to $10 per share, Alice can sell the shares for $50,000 and make a profit of $45,000, minus taxes and fees. However, if the company's value has decreased to $0.5 per share, Alice's options are underwater and worthless, and she has lost the opportunity to invest elsewhere.
2. Restricted stock units (RSUs) are promises to award a certain number of shares or cash equivalent to the employee or founder after a vesting period. Unlike stock options, RSUs do not have a strike price and do not require the employee or founder to pay anything to receive the shares. RSUs are also typically subject to a vesting schedule, which may be based on time, performance, or both. RSUs are appealing because they offer a more stable and predictable form of compensation, as well as some benefits, such as:
- The employee or founder does not have to pay anything to receive the shares, which reduces the financial burden and risk.
- The employee or founder does not have to worry about the company's value fluctuating, as the RSUs are valued at the market price on the vesting date.
- The employee or founder does not have to deal with as many restrictions or regulations when selling the shares, as they are already taxed as ordinary income on the vesting date.
- The employee or founder may have more flexibility and control over when to sell the shares, as they can defer the vesting date or choose to receive cash instead of shares.
However, RSUs also have some drawbacks, such as:
- The employee or founder has to pay taxes on the RSUs as ordinary income on the vesting date, which may be high if the company's value has increased significantly.
- The employee or founder may forfeit the RSUs if they leave the company before they vest, or if the company goes bankrupt or is acquired by another entity.
- The employee or founder may face dilution if the company issues more shares to raise capital or reward other stakeholders, which reduces the percentage of ownership and value of the RSUs.
- The employee or founder may have to comply with certain accounting and tax issues, such as reporting income and expenses, and filing appropriate forms.
For example, Bob is granted 10,000 RSUs with a four-year vesting schedule, with 25% vesting each year. After two years, Bob receives 5,000 shares or cash equivalent, valued at the market price on the vesting date. If the company's value is $10 per share, Bob receives $50,000 worth of shares or cash, minus taxes and fees. However, if the company's value is $0.5 per share, Bob receives $2,500 worth of shares or cash, minus taxes and fees.
3. Founder shares are the shares that the founders of a company own when they start the business. Founder shares are usually issued at a very low or nominal price, such as $0.00001 per share, and represent a large percentage of the company's equity, such as 80% or more. Founder shares are different from stock options or RSUs, as they are not subject to a vesting schedule or any other conditions. Founder shares are advantageous because they give the founders full ownership and control of the company, as well as some benefits, such as:
- The founders do not have to pay anything to receive the shares, which reduces the financial burden and risk.
- The founders do not have to worry about the company's value fluctuating, as the founder shares are valued at the cost basis, which is very low or zero.
- The founders do not have to deal with any restrictions or regulations when selling the shares, as they are not taxed until they sell them.
- The founders may have more flexibility and control over when to sell the shares, as they can decide the timing and terms of the sale.
However, founder shares also have some challenges, such as:
- The founders may have to pay taxes on the founder shares as capital gains when they sell them, which may be high if the company's value has increased significantly.
- The founders may lose some or all of the founder shares if they leave the company, or if the company goes bankrupt or is acquired by another entity.
- The founders may face dilution if the company issues more shares to raise capital or reward other stakeholders, which reduces the percentage of ownership and value of the founder shares.
- The founders may have to comply with certain accounting and tax issues, such as reporting income and expenses, and filing appropriate forms.
For example, Carol and Dave are the founders of a company and own 10 million founder shares each, at a cost basis of $0.00001 per share. They own 80% of the company's equity, while the remaining 20% is reserved for future employees and investors. If the company's value is $100 million, Carol and Dave's founder shares are worth $40 million each, minus taxes and fees. However, if the company's value is $1 million, Carol and Dave's founder shares are worth $400,000 each, minus taxes and fees.
One of the most important aspects of vesting agreements is the vesting schedule, which determines how and when the stock options or ownership rights are granted to the employee or partner. There are different types of vesting schedules that can be used, depending on the goals and preferences of the parties involved. In this section, we will explore three common types of vesting schedules: cliff, graded, and performance-based.
- Cliff vesting is a type of vesting schedule where the employee or partner receives all of their stock options or ownership rights at once after a certain period of time, usually one or two years. This means that they have no vested interest in the company until they reach the cliff date, and then they have full ownership of their shares. This type of vesting schedule is often used to incentivize the employee or partner to stay with the company for at least the duration of the cliff period, and to reward them for their loyalty and commitment. For example, Alice joins a startup as a co-founder and receives 25% of the company's equity, subject to a two-year cliff vesting schedule. This means that Alice will not own any shares of the company until she completes two years of service, and then she will receive all of her 25% equity at once.
- Graded vesting is a type of vesting schedule where the employee or partner receives their stock options or ownership rights gradually over a period of time, usually four or five years. This means that they have a vested interest in the company that increases with each year of service, and that they can exercise their options or sell their shares as they vest. This type of vesting schedule is often used to balance the interests of the employee or partner and the company, and to encourage long-term growth and retention. For example, Bob joins a startup as a software engineer and receives 10,000 stock options, subject to a four-year graded vesting schedule. This means that Bob will vest 25% of his options (2,500) after one year of service, another 25% (2,500) after two years of service, and so on, until he vests all of his options after four years of service.
- performance-based vesting is a type of vesting schedule where the employee or partner receives their stock options or ownership rights based on the achievement of certain performance goals or milestones, such as revenue, profit, user growth, product launch, etc. This means that they have a vested interest in the company that depends on the success and performance of the company, and that they can exercise their options or sell their shares as they meet the goals or milestones. This type of vesting schedule is often used to align the incentives of the employee or partner and the company, and to motivate them to work hard and deliver results. For example, Carol joins a startup as a marketing manager and receives 5,000 stock options, subject to a performance-based vesting schedule. This means that Carol will vest 20% of her options (1,000) after the company reaches $1 million in revenue, another 20% (1,000) after the company reaches $5 million in revenue, and so on, until she vests all of her options after the company reaches $25 million in revenue.
FasterCapital provides you with the needed resources to start your own business and helps you secure different types of funding to get your business off the ground
One of the most important aspects of vesting is how it affects your taxes. Depending on the type of stock options you have, the timing of your exercise, and the value of your shares, you may face different tax consequences when you vest. In this section, we will explore the three main tax implications of vesting: ordinary income, capital gains, and alternative minimum tax (AMT). We will also provide some examples and tips to help you plan your tax strategy and optimize your vesting benefits.
- Ordinary income: This is the income you earn from your salary, wages, bonuses, commissions, and other sources of compensation. When you vest in stock options, you may have to report some or all of the value of the shares as ordinary income in the year you vest. This depends on whether your options are non-qualified stock options (NSOs) or incentive stock options (ISOs).
- NSOs: These are the most common type of stock options, and they are taxed as ordinary income when you exercise them. The amount of income is equal to the difference between the fair market value (FMV) of the shares at the time of exercise and the exercise price. For example, if you exercise 100 NSOs with an exercise price of $10 per share, and the FMV of the shares is $15 per share, you will have to report $500 ($15 - $10) x 100) as ordinary income. This income will be subject to federal, state, and local income taxes, as well as social Security and medicare taxes.
- ISOs: These are a special type of stock options that offer some tax advantages, but also some restrictions. If you meet certain holding period requirements, you can defer the taxation of your ISOs until you sell the shares. The holding period requirements are: (1) you must hold the shares for at least one year after the exercise date, and (2) you must hold the shares for at least two years after the grant date. If you meet these requirements, you will not have to report any income when you exercise your ISOs, and you will only pay capital gains tax when you sell the shares. However, if you sell the shares before meeting the holding period requirements, you will trigger a disqualifying disposition, and you will have to report some or all of the value of the shares as ordinary income in the year of sale. For example, if you exercise 100 ISOs with an exercise price of $10 per share, and the FMV of the shares is $15 per share, and you sell the shares within one year of exercise, you will have to report $500 ($15 - $10) x 100) as ordinary income. This income will be subject to federal, state, and local income taxes, as well as Social Security and Medicare taxes.
- Capital gains: This is the income you earn from selling an asset that has appreciated in value. When you sell your vested shares, you may have to report some or all of the gain as capital gains in the year of sale. The amount of gain is equal to the difference between the selling price and the FMV of the shares at the time of exercise (for NSOs) or the exercise price (for ISOs). The tax rate on capital gains depends on how long you held the shares before selling them. If you held the shares for more than one year, you will pay long-term capital gains tax, which is generally lower than ordinary income tax. If you held the shares for one year or less, you will pay short-term capital gains tax, which is the same as ordinary income tax. For example, if you sell 100 shares that you exercised at $10 per share, and the selling price is $20 per share, you will have a gain of $1,000 ($20 - $10) x 100). If you held the shares for more than one year, you will pay long-term capital gains tax on the $1,000. If you held the shares for one year or less, you will pay short-term capital gains tax on the $1,000.
- Alternative minimum tax (AMT): This is a parallel tax system that applies to certain taxpayers who have high incomes and certain tax preferences. The AMT is designed to ensure that these taxpayers pay a minimum amount of tax, regardless of their deductions and credits. When you exercise ISOs, you may trigger the AMT, even if you do not sell the shares. This is because the AMT treats the difference between the FMV of the shares at the time of exercise and the exercise price as a tax preference item, which increases your AMT income. If your AMT income exceeds a certain threshold, you will have to pay the AMT, in addition to your regular income tax. For example, if you exercise 100 ISOs with an exercise price of $10 per share, and the FMV of the shares is $15 per share, you will have an AMT preference item of $500 ($15 - $10) x 100). If your AMT income exceeds the AMT exemption amount, you will have to pay the AMT on the $500, in addition to your regular income tax. The AMT rate is 26% or 28%, depending on your income level. The AMT exemption amount and the AMT income threshold are adjusted annually for inflation.
As you can see, vesting can have significant tax implications, depending on the type of stock options you have, the value of the shares, and the timing of your exercise and sale. To optimize your tax strategy and minimize your tax liability, you should consult a tax professional who can advise you on the best course of action for your specific situation. You should also keep track of your vesting schedule, your exercise price, your FMV, and your holding period, as these factors will affect your tax outcome. Vesting can be a rewarding and lucrative way to gain ownership in your company, but it also comes with some tax challenges that you should be aware of and prepared for.
Read Other Blogs