Melanie Knight’s Post

View profile for Melanie Knight

Learning designer | Author of 'Learn About Learning' newsletter.

Here’s my visual summary of chapter 4 of ‘Design for How People Learn’ by Julie Dirksen. She emphasises in this chapter the importance of learning through real tasks, as close to the real-life environment as possible. Some of what I am reading is making me question both the way that we teach children in schools and much of the training that I have done as an adult. For example, I have had to sit through annual online health and safety training, where I watch a video and then complete a multiple choice quiz, including questions that are purely ‘recognise’ or ‘recall’ based with no practical application, for example, “What percentage of workplace injuries happen when working from height?” This makes assessment of the course easier to administer, but does not aid me in applying my learning to my everyday tasks at work. In Julie Dirksen’s shelf analogy, this becomes, at best, facts that are temporarily stored on a single shelf labelled ‘Things I have just learnt’, and is unlikely to be encoded effectively into long term memory or to impact my day-to-day practice. Indeed, I know there is much information that I have remembered for just long enough to get through a test, and then promptly forgotten again. A better way to apply learning about topics such as health and safety, using the principles of this chapter, would be to complete my own risk assessment of tasks that I do regularly which involve, for example, working at height. This would anchor the learning to the actual environment where it would be applied and provide a self-created job aid that could be referred to to reduce the need for recall. It would also personalise the learning and make it feel more relevant to my actual role and tasks, rather than a generic role. However, formal assessment of this task would require it to be judged by a person, rather than a computer, so it would be more costly to assess. This chapter also illustrates why just reading about soft skills such as managing conflict is unlikely to be particularly useful, as the skills are encoded in a calm environment that is very different to the high-pressure environment where they will need to be retrieved. She again emphasises the need for role play as a way to apply these skills in a context that is closer to the real-life environment. Other chapters: Chapter 1 https://lnkd.in/eYdEw3cs Chapter 2 https://lnkd.in/e2S9QRuE Chapter 3 https://lnkd.in/eDjxaF5x Chapter 4 https://lnkd.in/eY99EV3m Chapter 5 https://lnkd.in/evmPy5j3 #sketchnotes #designforhowpeoplelearn #instructionaldesign #memory

  • No alternative text description for this image
Naomi Freeman

AI & Product Leader | Women Who Code Engineers to Watch (2023) | Royal Bank of Canada Women of Influence Nominee (2021)

3y

Sketch notes make me so happy 😊 this is great work! Thanks for sharing

Phoenix Mancuso

Team Lead @ Louis Vuitton

3y

Interesting! Thank you!

Pearl Jantjies

Educator/ Proofreader/Editor/Social Justice Champion/

3y

Great piece! I love. Its egging me on

Ellen Betts

Head of Health and Wellbeing at NHS Blood and Transplant

3y
Like
Reply

I look forward to your succinct visual representation of each chapter. Thank you so much for sharing. Curious to know what program you use for these creations though.

Simcha W.

Learning Experience Designer | Putting PEOPLE First in Every Training Solution | Multi-Media Content Creator for Enhanced Impact

3y

Love your format and sharing! Thank you Melanie :) Dare to share what you are developing in? Design aesthetic is fun to follow.

Like
Reply
Nichole Mohamad, M.Ed

Education Program Manager at ASNT

3y

These sketch notes are amazing! I am starting a book study on this with my team in the coming weeks. Would you mind if I used your sketch notes to send out to my team?

Arathy Anil

Head of Partnerships and Operations at Fabsquad #influencermarketing

3y

Great piece! I am also looking forward to transitioning as an instructional designer and you inspire me to heighten my bars!

Michael Richter

Instructional Design | Learning Experience Design | eLearning Development | LMS Administration | Podcasting | Learning Technology

3y

I can’t wait to see all the pachyderms in your next sketch for chapter five (which I just read)!

Like
Reply
Avin Ramesh K V

Graduate Fire Engineer || Human Behaviour in Fire

3y

The sketch notes are beautiful. But I find it oversimplified as you have mentioned the process of encoding and retrieval as a linear process. As it is similar to the "book-shelf" analogy, people will miss the fact that memory is reconstructive. It would have been better if you had represented it with a feedback loop of retrieval process reconstructing the original memory.

See more comments

To view or add a comment, sign in

Explore content categories