How do you validate and verify CVSS scores for accuracy and reliability?

1 Step 1: Understand the CVSS components

CVSS consists of three components: base, temporal, and environmental. The base component measures the intrinsic characteristics of a vulnerability, such as the attack vector, the complexity, the scope, and the impact. The temporal component measures the current state of a vulnerability, such as the availability of exploits, the level of remediation, and the confidence in the score. The environmental component measures the specific impact of a vulnerability on a given system or network, such as the modified base metrics, the security requirements, and the collateral damage potential. Each component has a numeric score ranging from 0 to 10, and a vector string that represents the values of each metric.

2 Step 2: Check the source and date of the CVSS data

CVSS data can come from various sources, such as vendors, researchers, databases, or scanners. However, not all sources are equally credible, consistent, or updated. Therefore, you should always check the source and date of the CVSS data you use, and compare it with other sources if possible. For example, you can use the National Vulnerability Database (NVD) as a reference, as it provides official CVSS data for most vulnerabilities, along with detailed descriptions and references. You can also use other sources, such as CVE Details, CVEDetails, or VulnDB, to cross-check or supplement the CVSS data from the NVD.

3 Step 3: Adjust the temporal and environmental metrics

The temporal and environmental metrics of CVSS allow you to customize the score according to your own situation and needs. However, many sources and scanners only provide the base score, which may not reflect the actual risk or priority of a vulnerability. Therefore, you should always adjust the temporal and environmental metrics based on the current status of the vulnerability and the impact on your system or network. For example, you can increase the temporal score if there is a known exploit or a patch available, or decrease it if there is low confidence in the score. You can also increase or decrease the environmental score based on the modified base metrics, the security requirements, and the collateral damage potential of your system or network.

4 Step 4: Use a CVSS calculator or tool

To calculate or modify the CVSS score and vector string, you can use a CVSS calculator or tool. A CVSS calculator is a web-based or software-based application that allows you to input or edit the values of each metric and generate the corresponding score and vector string. A CVSS tool is a more advanced application that allows you to automate or integrate the CVSS calculation with other processes or systems. For example, you can use the NVD CVSS Calculator to manually calculate or modify the CVSS score and vector string for any vulnerability in the NVD database. You can also use other tools, such as VulnWhisperer, CVSS Manager, or CVSSKit, to automate or integrate the CVSS calculation with your vulnerability scanning or management tools.

5 Step 5: Compare and validate the CVSS score and vector string

Once you have calculated or modified the CVSS score and vector string, it’s important to compare and validate them with other sources or methods. This ensures the accuracy and reliability of the CVSS data, as well as helping to detect any discrepancies or errors. For instance, you can compare and validate the CVSS score and vector string with the original source of the vulnerability, such as the vendor or researcher who may have provided their own CVSS data. Additionally, you can consult the NVD or other databases who may have revised or corrected the CVSS data based on new information or feedback. Furthermore, you can refer to vulnerability scanners or tools that may have generated or modified the CVSS data based on their own algorithms or configurations. Finally, expert opinions or best practices may offer their own insights or recommendations on how to interpret or use the CVSS data.

6 Step 6: Document and communicate the CVSS score and vector string

The final step is to document and communicate the CVSS score and vector string to your stakeholders or audiences. This can help you explain and justify your vulnerability scanning and prioritization decisions, as well as share and collaborate with other teams or organizations. For example, you could include the score and vector string in vulnerability reports or dashboards with relevant details and references. Additionally, you could use them as criteria for scoring or ranking systems, such as risk scores, severity levels, or priority labels. Furthermore, they can be used as inputs or outputs for vulnerability management or remediation workflows, such as ticketing systems, patching systems, or risk management systems. Lastly, they can be used as standards for vulnerability assessment or compliance policies, such as security frameworks, regulations, or audits.

7 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?