ChatGPT vs. Amazon: Who Owns the First Click Now?

Happy Wednesday,

For 20+ years, e-commerce has been built around one assumption: people know what they’re looking for. You just have to make sure they find you.

That assumption no longer holds.

AI, especially conversational tools like ChatGPT, has introduced a new layer between customer intent and product selection. It’s not theoretical. It’s not years away. It’s already changing how people research, compare, and make purchasing decisions.

The traditional funnel is now fragmented at the very top.

We’ve Entered the Post-Search Era

For decades, the ecommerce journey has started the same way:

Search term → Filter results → Click product page → Buy.

Now?

It starts with a conversation.

Buyers describe what they want instead of searching for a product name. They ask for use-case solutions, not categories. Instead of typing “4K webcam for Zoom,” they type, “I need a webcam that works well in low light, is easy to install, and has a privacy shutter.” Budget under $200.”

And ChatGPT gives them a short list based on context, features, availability, and real reviews. Instead of scrolling through 72 product tiles, users receive concise answers. Just answers.

In this model, there’s no guarantee a user will ever see your homepage, click your ad, or browse your catalog.

The entire upstream experience is abstracted. That’s the disruption.

Amazon Still Fulfills, But It No Longer Leads

Let’s get this straight: Amazon isn’t going away, but its role is being redefined from discovery platform to fulfillment layer.

If a buyer has already made a decision on ChatGPT, Amazon is simply the platform where the transaction takes place. You’re no longer competing for attention there. You're simply the end of a path decided elsewhere.

And that "elsewhere" is increasingly AI-driven.

ChatGPT doesn’t care who pays the highest CPC or who has the best marketplace design. It cares about:

• What problem the user is trying to solve
• What product solves that problem
• What structured data backs up the claim

That's a major shift in the decision stack.

The New Discovery Stack Is Data, Not Design

AI doesn’t “see” your website. It doesn’t care how clean your UI is or how clever your copy sounds. It sees metadata, attributes, price points, availability, compatibility, reviews, and context.

And most e-commerce catalogs are not structured for that kind of visibility.

Here’s the new reality: If your product data isn’t readable, contextual, and API-accessible, you’re effectively invisible in the AI-powered funnel.

Think of ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, and future vertical LLMs as gatekeepers to buyer intent. If your data isn’t compatible with their logic, your products don’t exist.

Period.

What’s Changing? Let’s Be Specific.

This isn’t hype. Let’s break down what’s materially changing:

1. Buyers are prompting, not searching. Search is keyword-based. Prompting is intent-based. That changes how product discovery works at a core level. Rather than searching for "LED light strips 12 ft," users might ask, "How can I light up the edge of my deck without visible wiring?"
2. Answers are being generated, not just linked. Search results send traffic. ChatGPT offers recommendations. If you’re not in the answer, there’s no traffic coming your way.
3. Site visits happen after the decision. Your homepage is no longer where first impressions are made. It’s where final confirmations are done. That’s a fundamental loss of influence if you’re not already present upstream.
4. Plugins and APIs are doing the work. GPTs with plugins can pull live inventory, compare specs, show prices, and start checkout, all without ever visiting a traditional site. This is where Shopify, BigCommerce, and headless commerce platforms have a real edge, if you know how to leverage them.

AI Isn't a Channel. It’s a Competitive Filter.

Stop thinking of AI like another “thing to test.” It’s not a channel. It’s a structural interface shift. When buyers use AI to make product decisions, they’re implicitly asking:

• What’s the best fit?
• What’s available now?
• What solves my problem fastest?

And that means you’re no longer competing for clicks or shelf space.

You’re competing to be the one product that gets mentioned in a sentence. That’s the level of compression we’re dealing with.

What Retailers and Manufacturers Should Do Now

If you sell online and you’re ignoring this, you’re already late. But not too late.

Here’s what needs to happen in the next 6–12 months if you want to stay visible in this new ecosystem:

1. Make your product catalog AI-readable. Break out every spec. Every use case should be considered. Include every compatibility tag. Every material. Don’t bury that info in marketing copy. Make it machine-consumable.
2. Build or integrate an API layer. Your catalog needs to be accessible—whether through a GPT plugin, headless setup, or third-party middleware. If it’s not exposed, it won’t be considered.
3. Add real context to your PDPs. Why does this product exist? Who is it for? What problem does it solve? Answer those questions explicitly in language a buyer would use.
4. Start testing GPT-powered discovery. If you’re on Shopify or BigCommerce, start building plugins or GPTs. Create your conversational interfaces. Control your discovery layer.
5. Track how buyers describe problems, not just what they search. This is a mindset shift. Consider structuring your content and product taxonomy around problems and use cases, rather than solely focusing on product categories.

A New Playing Field for Challenger Brands

There’s good news in all of this. This shift levels the playing field.

Brands that couldn’t outspend competitors on Google Ads or Amazon Sponsored Listings can now win with better data, clearer answers, and smarter AI integration.

If your product is a better fit for a real problem and your data shows it, you can beat the market leaders with a ChatGPT result.

It’s not about who yells the loudest. It’s about who answers best.

Your Brand Has One Shot to Be Chosen

AI is not the future of ecommerce. It’s already restructuring the present.

Your job isn’t just to show up online anymore. Your role is to be considered within the 5 seconds that a buyer describes their needs to an AI model.

In that moment, your brand either fits or disappears.

If your product catalog isn’t structured, contextualized, and integrated, you will not be found. Not on Google. Not via marketplaces. Not by buyers asking smarter, more natural questions to systems like ChatGPT.

Once your competitor is included in the answer, you no longer have a second chance.

If you're curious about showing up in AI-powered product recommendations, not just search results, comment below, DM me directly, or contact us to start making your catalog AI-ready.

Until next time,

Duran Inci

P.S. Here are a few more ways that we can help you scale to 8 figures and beyond:

Join Successful Brands: 🏆 Discover how others have scaled to 8 figures with our help. Guarantee your 15%-50% growth today! 👉 See If You Qualify 👈

Success Stories: Real Results, Real Businesses: Curious how companies like yours achieved 8-figure growth? Dive into over 100+ case studies showcasing our proven strategies. 👉 Explore the Success Stories 👈