The Consistency Myth: Why You’re Not Broken, Just Misaligned

“Most people start with what they do. The more inspired start with why they do it.” That quote from Simon Sinek’s Start With Why (2009, p. 27) doesn’t just apply to business leaders or TED Talk stars. It applies to every person who’s ever tried to make a real change in their life. Because the problem isn’t that people are undisciplined. The problem is that their actions are disconnected from a vision that actually matters to them. And when your action is not rooted in something deeply meaningful, it’s only a matter of time before it fizzles out.

We’ve all lived this cycle. You get pumped about a new goal, maybe it's to finally get in shape, write that book, launch your side hustle, or even just wake up an hour earlier without hating the world. You start off on fire. You post about it. You buy the journal, the gear, maybe even a subscription to something expensive and inspiring. For a few days, you’re unstoppable. But then life kicks in. Your kid gets sick. Your boss dumps a project on you. You lose sleep. And suddenly, your dream starts collecting dust faster than your elliptical. You blame yourself. You call it laziness. You convince yourself you just weren’t cut out for consistency. But what if that’s a lie you’ve been sold? What if the truth is far more liberating? What if you’re not broken at all, you’re just bored with the way you started?

The heart of inconsistent personal development is misalignment. When your goals are built on ego or external validation, like weight loss for someone else’s approval or building a business to “prove” yourself, your unconscious mind will eventually reject them. It doesn’t want pressure. It wants purpose. The secret isn’t to hustle harder. It’s to align deeper. When your goals are anchored in a story that makes you feel something, consistency becomes a byproduct, not a punishment.

So, how do you make this shift?

Start by turning your goals into meaningful stories. Don’t just say you want to lose weight. Say, “I want to be the grandparent who plays on the floor with their grandkids without needing a break.” Don’t just say, “I want to write a book.” Say, “I want to tell the story that saved me, so it can save someone else.” When your goal becomes a narrative that stirs your spirit, the action required becomes sacred, not optional. As Brené Brown wrote in Daring Greatly (2012, p. 45), “Stories are just data with a soul.” Inject soul into your vision, and the action follows.

Next, make your steps embarrassingly small. The brain doesn’t care how big your goal is. It only cares how safe it feels. If you’re trying to overhaul your entire life overnight, your nervous system will hit the brakes. But if you whisper to yourself, “All I have to do is one push-up,” or “Just write one sentence,” suddenly there’s no threat. The door opens. Momentum kicks in. And the magic begins. BJ Fogg emphasized this in Tiny Habits (2020, p. 31) when he said, “Emotions create habits. Not repetition. Not frequency. Emotions.” So make your first step feel so light, it’s impossible not to take it, and then celebrate it like you just won a medal.

The third key is anchoring. You already have routines that work. You brush your teeth. You make coffee. You check your phone. So piggyback your new habit onto something you already do. “After I brush my teeth, I’ll do 10 squats.” “After I pour my coffee, I’ll write down three wins from yesterday.” Your brain loves predictability. Give it a rhythm to follow. James Clear calls this “habit stacking” in Atomic Habits (2018, p. 75), and it’s powerful because it removes the guesswork from when and where the habit should happen.

But don’t stop at action. Celebrate the identity you're building. When you show up, even if it’s just for five minutes, don’t say, “That wasn’t enough.” Say, “That’s who I am now.” Identity reinforcement is everything. Mel Robbins wrote in The High 5 Habit (2021, p. 12), “You are one high five away from changing your life.” It’s not the high five, it’s what it represents: self-recognition. Validation. Encouragement. Because when you start treating your small wins like proof that you’re becoming someone powerful, consistency feels rewarding, not rigid.

And finally, carve out time for weekly reflection. Not once a month. Not when things go wrong. Every week. Ask yourself, “Where did I win?” “Where did I struggle?” and “What’s one thing I can do better?” These aren’t journal prompts. They’re recalibration tools. They bring awareness. They bring ownership. They stop you from drifting into old habits and pull you back into alignment with your vision.

Here’s the truth: you don’t need a new planner, a stricter schedule, or a motivational coach screaming in your earbuds. You need alignment. You need a why that makes your hands tingle when you talk about it. A vision that grabs your heart and whispers, “This matters.” Because when your story makes sense to you, your steps start making sense too.

So if your goals have felt hollow, if your action has been inconsistent, don’t shame yourself. Realign yourself. Rewrite the story. Make it visceral. Make it personal. Make it impossible to ignore. And then, take that first small step in that new direction. Not because you “should,” but because you finally want to.

Because the habits that last aren’t the ones you force. They’re the ones that feel like coming home.

♻️ Repost to help someone. 🔔 Follow Larry Mullne for more.