The Curiosity Check: A Game-Changing Approach to High-Stakes Conversations

By Hemanth Reganti

In the fast-paced world of business leadership, we often find ourselves rushing into critical conversations armed with rehearsed arguments and anticipated rebuttals. Whether it's a make-or-break negotiation, a difficult performance discussion, or a strategic decision-making session, most leaders enter these high-stakes moments with their minds already made up. But what if this very approach is sabotaging our success?

A recent Harvard Business Review article by Jeff Wetzler introduces a revolutionary concept that challenges how we prepare for our most consequential conversations: the "Curiosity Check." This simple yet powerful framework can transform potential conflicts into opportunities for breakthrough insights and collaborative problem-solving.

This article is based on insights from Jeff Wetzler's Harvard Business Review piece "The Right Way to Prepare for a High-Stakes Conversation" (July 2, 2025). You can read the original article here: https://hbr.org/2025/07/the-right-way-to-prepare-for-a-high-stakes-conversation

The Hidden Cost of Certainty

Think about your last high-stakes conversation. Did you walk in convinced you already knew the outcome, the other party's position, or the optimal solution? If you're like most leaders, you probably spent considerable time preparing your arguments, anticipating objections, and rehearsing your key points.

While this type of preparation has its place, it comes at a significant cost. When we rely exclusively on this approach, we fall victim to what behavioral scientists call "confirmation bias" – a mindset where we not only seek information that confirms our existing beliefs but actively filter out disconfirming evidence.

This preparation gap creates a dangerous blind spot. Cognitive rigidity severely limits our ability to discover new and relevant information and collaborate effectively with others. In our rush to be right, we often miss the opportunity to be effective.

The Science Behind Curiosity

The solution lies in cultivating genuine curiosity, especially under conditions of stress or threat. Research shows that curiosity offers enormous benefits for leaders facing complex challenges:

• Enhanced Information Processing: Curiosity increases your ability to process new information and respond creatively to complex problems
• Neurological Advantages: It activates the brain's learning and reward centers, increasing your capacity for insight and creative problem-solving
• Improved Resilience: Curious individuals demonstrate greater resilience when facing unexpected information, such as pushback from direct reports, colleagues, or superiors

Yet despite study after study showing the cognitive, emotional, and relational benefits of curiosity, few executives have a reliable method for assessing and optimizing this mindset before critical interactions.

Introducing the Curiosity Check

To bridge this gap, Wetzler developed the Curiosity Check – a three-step process that takes no more than five minutes before any significant conversation. This framework helps leaders shift from a defensive, certainty-based mindset to one of genuine openness and discovery.

Step 1: Locate Your Current Mindset on the Curiosity Curve

The Curiosity Curve serves as your leadership equivalent to a pilot's most important gauge on the cockpit dashboard. This visual framework divides mindsets into six distinct zones:

Zones of Certainty:

• Self-Righteous Disdain: "I can't stand them!" / "They're mad, bad, or scary!"
• Confident Dismissal: "They're mistaken, incompetent, or out of line." / "I'm right!"
• Skeptical Tolerance: "I think they're wrong but I'll hear them out."

Zones of Curiosity:

• Cautious Openness: "Hmm...they could know something worth finding out."
• Genuine Interest: "I truly want to understand their views and experience."
• Fascinated Wonder: "Wow! There's so much I want to learn—from, with, and about them!"

The key insight here is recognizing where you honestly sit on this spectrum. Most leaders, when they're brutally honest with themselves, recognize they typically enter high-stakes conversations in one of the Zones of Certainty. While this positioning provides psychological comfort and apparent confidence, it undermines conversation effectiveness.

Step 2: Set Your Curiosity Intention

Once you know your starting point, use the Curiosity Curve to identify which mindset you want to adopt. It's often unrealistic to reach the zone of Fascinated Wonder immediately. Instead, commit to moving one or two zones to the right of where you begin.

For example, if you're starting from Confident Dismissal, aim for Cautious Openness. If you're at Skeptical Tolerance, try getting to Genuine Interest. The goal is to pick a mindset shift that's ambitious but feasible, and set your intention to anchor there.

Step 3: Ask Yourself Curious Questions to Make the Shift

While intention matters, you also need practical tools to help you realize it. "Curiosity Sparks" are small but targeted questions that can help shift your mindset rightward on the Curiosity Curve. Here are five powerful Curiosity Sparks to consider:

1. What might the other person be struggling with that I'm unaware of?
2. What good (but unspoken) concerns, reasons, or information might underlie their disagreement with me?
3. How might my words or actions be impacting them in ways I don't intend?
4. What incorrect assumptions might I be making about the situation, issue, or other person?
5. What unspoken insights or ideas might the other person have that could address our challenge?

Sometimes it's challenging to consider these Curiosity Sparks on your own, especially if you're stuck on the left side of the Curiosity Curve. In such cases, it helps to ask a trusted friend, colleague, mentor, or even an AI assistant to help you think them through.

Real-World Impact: The Curiosity Check in Action

The power of this approach becomes clear through real examples. Consider Sarah, a VP of finance preparing to deliver a harsh performance review to Michael, her historically highest-performing director who had been underperforming for six months despite multiple warnings.

Sarah had spent weeks documenting Michael's errors and preparing her "shape up or ship out" conversation. She anticipated every excuse Michael might offer and steeled herself to rebut them with facts and examples.

Before the conversation, Sarah conducted a quick Curiosity Check and assessed herself as being in Confident Dismissal – certain that Michael was coasting on past success and ignoring her guidance. Setting an intention to reach at least Cautious Openness, she used the Curiosity Spark: "What might Michael be struggling with that I'm unaware of?"

This small shift led her to start the conversation not with accusations but with genuine questions about what challenges Michael was facing. Within minutes, Michael revealed that he'd been secretly managing his partner's cancer treatment while trying to maintain his professional image and avoid burdening anyone else. Sarah's questions transformed what could have been an unnecessary termination into joint problem-solving about temporary adjustments and support systems, ultimately saving a valuable employee and strengthening their working relationship.

The Competitive Advantage of Curiosity

In another example, an executive team at a midsize tech company was deadlocked over whether to delay their next software release launch by six months. Engineering insisted they needed more time while marketing argued that the competitive window was closing. Just as tensions reached a boiling point, the engineering lead called a 10-minute break and asked his team to privately perform a Curiosity Check.

When they reconvened, the engineering lead began by admitting they'd been dismissive of marketing's urgency and asked them to elaborate on the market pressures they were seeing. This simple intervention revealed new data about competitors' offerings that convinced even the engineering team that their original approach would be too slow. By the end of the meeting, both teams collaborated on a creative solution: a phased launch that introduced some new features much sooner than planned while reserving more time for engineering to pressure-test the most complex features.

Making Curiosity a Choice

In a world where information is abundant but insight remains scarce, curiosity may be the ultimate competitive advantage. The question isn't whether you'll face disagreement and pushback in your next high-stakes conversation – it's whether you'll be mentally prepared to transform that friction into insight and constructive action.

Curiosity is fundamentally a choice, and that choice begins before you speak your first word. By honestly assessing where you sit on the Curiosity Curve, setting realistic intentions to move toward greater openness, and deploying targeted Curiosity Sparks, you can transform your most challenging interactions from battles to be won into opportunities for mutual discovery and collaborative problem-solving.

The next time you're preparing for a critical conversation, ask yourself: wouldn't you want to know if there's vital information you're missing? Just as you wouldn't fly on a plane that hadn't had a preflight check, why head into a high-stakes conversation without first checking your most vital mindset: curiosity?

The Curiosity Check offers a practical, evidence-based approach to ensuring you're mentally prepared for the conversations that matter most. In just five minutes, you can shift from defensive certainty to productive openness – and that shift might just change everything.

About the Original Research: This article is based on the groundbreaking work of Jeff Wetzler, author of "Ask: Tap Into the Hidden Wisdom of People Around You for Unexpected Breakthroughs in Leadership and Life" and co-CEO of Transcend. His original Harvard Business Review article provides the complete framework and additional insights. I encourage you to read the full piece: https://hbr.org/2025/07/the-right-way-to-prepare-for-a-high-stakes-conversation

What's your experience with high-stakes conversations? Have you found yourself stuck in the "Zones of Certainty"? I'd love to hear your thoughts and experiences in the comments below.

#Leadership #Communication #CuriousLeadership #HighStakesConversations #ExecutiveSkills #BusinessStrategy #ProfessionalDevelopment