From Gut Feel to Ground Truth
Matthew Woodget
CEO & Founder | Messaging Strategy & Go-To-Market Storytelling for Series A+ Startups | Narrative Development for Founders
How We Stress-Test Narrative Metrics Until They’re Boardroom-Ready
He stared at the slide like it had betrayed him.
Series B board prep.
Growth numbers up.
CAC in range.
Then came the question—from the investor who hadn’t smiled once:
“And how do you know this story is driving the lift?”
That’s the moment founders dread.
When “we think it’s working” isn’t enough.
When gut instinct gets cross-examined.
Why Founders Ask About Story—and What They Really Mean
When founders ask,
“Can story really move the needle?”
They’re not asking for inspiration.
They want evidence.
They want confidence that story-backed metrics won’t collapse under scrutiny.
Because here’s the shift:
Stories aren’t fluff.
They’re how the human brain converts risk into action.
But in a Series B boardroom?
They better be airtight.
Why Most Narrative Metrics Fail the Test
We’ve seen it too often:
Teams chasing “better messaging”…
Only to watch it fall apart when the CFO—or the lead investor—starts poking holes.
Common breakdowns:
✖️ Metrics built on anecdote, not analytics
✖️ Projected lifts based on hope, not testing
✖️ Story impact dismissed as “just marketing fluff”
And when the metrics don’t hold?
Story gets cut first.
The Ironclad AI Triangulation Protocol™
To fix this, we built a 4-phase stress-test system.
Every narrative assumption gets interrogated—by humans and machines.
Phase 1: The Perplexity Gauntlet
Deconstructs soft logic. Finds cracks in your assumptions.
Phase 2: Claude Crucible
Identifies blind spots. Challenges narratives over time, not just in the moment.
Phase 3: Rebuttal Challenge
Runs your story again—this time trying to disprove it.
Phase 4: Deep Dive Verification
Final audit. If it survives this? It’s boardroom-ready.
From Hope to High Performance
Right now, a client is using this to move demo conversions from 1.2% → 2.0–2.5%.
Not guessing.
Executing—with confidence.
A few anonymized results from past engagements:
🔼 635% increase in monthly page actions
🔼 278% lift in unique page views
🔼 350% increase in trial-to-paid conversions (Wistia case)
These aren’t one-offs.
They’re what happens when narrative becomes a system.
Why It Matters Now
You’re 6–9 months from Series B.
The story you tell will shape the round you raise.
But:
🟠 Story without rigor? Fluff.
🟠 Strategy without a reason why? Risk.
We offer a third path:
✅ A story you can believe in—because it’s been through hell and back.
What’s the Story You Hope No One Asks About?
If you’re a founder prepping for Series B, you’ve probably faced it:
The moment when your CAC’s clean, growth’s good—and the investor leans in:
“But how do you know this story is driving results?”
If you’ve been there—or know someone heading there—I’d love to hear:
💬 How do you stress-test your narrative?
👀 What questions have you been hit with in the boardroom?
💡 Or—what’s the one story metric you wish you had?
Drop it in the comments👇
(Or DM me if it's easier—happy to swap war stories or share what’s working.)
Because guessing isn’t a strategy.
Let’s build stories that scale—and stand up under pressure.
#FounderLife #SeriesA #TechCEO #StartupLeadership #ScaleUpStories
CEO, Executive Leadership Consulting | #1 Amazon Bestselling Author | Creator of Red Thread Leadership™
1moSo true, Matthew. The story is critical, but so are the metrics.
Founder, Community Builder, Award Winning Author 2024, Strategic Corporate Partner to Challenge Your Vision and Impact Your Growth: #everydayleaderschangetheworld #everydayleaders #melahniake #maxwellleadership #mlct
1moMatthew Woodget, I love these new tools because they clarify our solutions and reflect our current environment. Love this
Unlocking your potential and your organization’s ability to scale and thrive, because growth happens when we discover a better way.
1moThe shift from belief to proof is crucial for founders, especially as they prepare for Series B. Establishing clear metrics not only validates your narrative but also builds investor confidence. Understanding your team's unique strengths can further enhance this process. What specific metrics have you found most impactful in your journey?
Helping Women Business Leaders Build Even More Aligned Teams using my proprietary Heart Compass Method
1moMatthew, this really clarified something for me. Founders start with a vision-driven story, full of belief, passion, and potential. And that’s essential. What you're showing is how to keep that emotional core while grounding it in facts. It’s the shift from fiction to non-fiction, where the story still moves people but now it holds up under pressure too.
You want to lead cohesive teams that fulfill their potential and perform at the highest level. At WHY NOT Leadership - we help you unlock the secret to getting there faster!
1moMatthew, this is a compelling reminder that storytelling in the boardroom must be grounded in proof. A sharp and insightful approach to translating narrative into measurable performance—essential for Series B success.