Interview #162: How do you handle a non-performing team member?

Handling a non-performing team member is one of the most critical and sensitive responsibilities of a Test Lead or Manager. The goal is not only to improve individual performance but also to maintain team morale, productivity, and a positive work culture. It requires a mix of empathy, analysis, structured feedback, mentoring, and if needed, accountability. Below is a detailed step-by-step strategy on how to handle such situations effectively.

Disclaimer: For QA-Testing Jobs, WhatsApp us @ 91-9606623245

1. Identify and Validate the Performance Issue

The first step is to objectively identify the signs of underperformance. This may include:

• Missed deadlines or frequent delays in test deliverables.

• Low-quality work with frequent defects or incomplete testing.

• Lack of collaboration or communication with the team.

• Repeated failure to follow test processes or team standards.

• Disengagement, low participation in meetings, or negative attitude.

✅ Action:

• Collect data to support your observations (e.g., test logs, bug reports, timelines).

• Cross-check feedback with peers or other stakeholders to eliminate bias.

• Ensure the problem is not a one-time incident, but a consistent pattern.

2. Understand the Root Cause

Before jumping to conclusions, try to understand why the person is underperforming. Often, poor performance is a symptom of an underlying issue.

Possible causes:

• Lack of clarity about tasks or expectations.

• Insufficient training or technical skills.

• Personal or health issues affecting focus or motivation.

• Lack of interest or misalignment with role or project.

• Team conflicts or poor communication with leadership.

• Burnout or workload imbalance.

✅ Action:

• Schedule a one-on-one private meeting.

• Use open-ended, non-judgmental questions:

"How have you been feeling about your current work assignments?""Is there anything affecting your ability to meet expectations?"

• Show genuine concern and listen carefully.

3. Set Clear Expectations and Goals

Once the cause is better understood, it’s time to clarify what’s expected.

✅ Action:

• Define specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound (SMART) goals.

• Example:

“Complete regression suite execution and defect logging within 3 working days for the next two sprints.”

• Provide a written or shared improvement plan so there’s no ambiguity.

• Set milestones or checkpoints to monitor progress.

4. Provide Support and Mentorship

Sometimes, underperformance stems from a lack of skills or guidance. In such cases, support rather than reprimand is the key.

✅ Action:

• Pair them with a mentor or experienced team member.

• Provide access to training or resources (e.g., tutorials, tools, internal documentation).

• Reduce workload temporarily if needed to allow for learning.

• Encourage open communication — let them know it’s okay to ask for help.

5. Monitor Progress and Give Regular Feedback

Improvement takes time, but it should be tracked and acknowledged.

✅ Action:

• Set weekly or bi-weekly follow-ups.

• Give constructive feedback — highlight both improvements and areas still lacking.

• Recognize any positive change, no matter how small, to encourage motivation.

Example:

“Your defect logging last sprint was much clearer and more detailed — that’s a great improvement. Let’s now work on reducing test case execution time.”

6. Escalate if No Improvement Is Seen

If the team member fails to improve despite repeated support and clear expectations, you may need to take formal steps.

✅ Action:

• Document all conversations, action plans, and results.

• Involve HR or upper management if a performance improvement plan (PIP) is needed.

• Clearly communicate the consequences of continued underperformance (e.g., reassignment, disciplinary action).

This step should be handled professionally and compassionately, with a focus on fairness.

7. Maintain Team Morale and Balance

Underperformance by one person can affect team morale and project delivery.

✅ Action:

• Communicate transparently (without disclosing personal details) about changes in responsibilities if needed.

• Ensure the rest of the team is not unfairly burdened.

• Reinforce a culture of accountability, learning, and support.

8. Learn and Improve as a Manager

Every challenge is a leadership learning opportunity.

✅ Action:

• Reflect on whether the role, task allocation, onboarding, or communication could have been improved.

• Consider preventive steps for the future like:

• Better training programs

• Regular one-on-ones

• Peer reviews and early feedback loops

Conclusion

Handling a non-performing team member is about diagnosing the problem, acting with empathy, and applying structured improvement strategies. As a Test Lead or Manager, your role is to guide individuals toward success — not punish them. While some situations may require tough decisions, most can be resolved through effective communication, mentoring, and support. Managing these situations with professionalism strengthens both your leadership credibility and the overall performance of your team.