Legal Contracts 101 for Founders: The Hidden Landmine That Could Destroy Your Startup

Here's a sobering truth: That "legally binding" contract you signed with your biggest client? It might be worth less than the pixels it's displayed on.

I learned this the hard way during my entrepreneurial journey. Like most founders, I thought a signed agreement was bulletproof protection. Turns out, I was dangerously wrong.

After interviewing Aditya Pandranki, Founder and CEO of Doqfy, who processes thousands of contracts daily for banks and enterprises, I realise most founders are walking into a legal minefield without even knowing it.

The question isn't whether you'll face contract disputes. It's whether your agreements will actually protect you when you do.

This article draws heavily from my Founder Thesis episode with Aditya. You can listen to the full deep dive here: podm.in/doqfy

🚨 The Email Acceptance Trap

Picture this: You send a proposal via email. Your client replies "Agreed, let's proceed." You start work, deliver results, send an invoice. Then they refuse to pay.

Can you take them to court with that email chain?

Technically, yes. Practically? Good luck.

"Email acceptance is legally binding for internal understanding, but if you have to submit this in the court of law it can act as an evidence but it cannot stand as a contract because it's not defined as a contract. It's only an email communication."

Email acceptance shows intention, but it's just evidence. It cannot stand as a legally enforceable contract in Indian courts. When push comes to shove, you'll need something much stronger.

Here's what shocked me most: Even if both parties sign an electronic document, without proper stamp duty, courts can ask you to pay 10-15 times the original stamp duty as penalty before they'll even consider your case.

"Sometimes few contracts are done without the stamp duty and then there are scenarios where the court would ask you to go back to the stamp counter and then pay the stamp duty to accept the document in the court. So in those scenarios, usually if the stamp duty was supposed to... you people would end up paying 10 times to 15 times of the actual stamp duty."

Think about that for a moment. Your legal protection could cost you more than the dispute itself.

📋 What Actually Makes a Contract Valid?

"The basic needs of a contract is an offer, acceptance and a lawful consultation. So when these three things are covered and if both the parties agree to oblige to the requirements, then they can get into a contract and then execute the contract."

Every valid contract needs three fundamental elements:

1. Offer - A clear proposal with specific terms

2. Acceptance - Unambiguous agreement to those terms

3. Lawful Consideration - Something of value being exchanged

But here's where most founders stumble: Having these elements doesn't automatically make your contract court-enforceable.

For that, you need proper execution with stamp duty and valid signatures.

💰 The Stamp Duty Reality Check

Stamp duty isn't just government bureaucracy. It's what transforms your document from a "fancy email" into a legally binding contract.

"In order to get a legal binding of the contract, you must execute the contract with stamp duty appended to the agreement of the contract. Otherwise, it will not bring you a legal binding. It becomes a regular document."

But here's the founder's dilemma I've faced repeatedly:

Option A: Insist on stamp duty contracts and potentially slow down your sales cycle

Option B: Skip them and hope disputes never reach court

When I asked Aditya about this dilemma, his response was illuminating.

"When you start as a business, when you start putting the stamp duty, the counterpart will think that, oh, okay, this is a stamp duty is coming along with the agreement, then it's like, okay, there's one caveat which is coming on top of it. So nobody wants to get into kind of anticipated legal obligations."

Most B2B service companies choose Option B. In my hiring business, only 2-3 out of 50 clients insisted on stamp duty contracts—typically large, publicly listed companies with strict compliance requirements.

"As a listed company, any document that you're executing everything... it becomes the corporate governance of an organization and they want to follow the structure so that's why they have insisted you to put the stamp duty."

Why do we make this choice? Simple math. As a small entrepreneur, the cost of legal battles often exceeds what you're trying to recover.

But this creates a massive blind spot in our risk management.

🔐 Digital Signatures Decoded

Not all digital signatures are created equal. Here's what you need to know:

Electronic Signatures

• What they are: Image uploads or stylus-based signatures

• Legal validity: Limited (not valid for property conveyance, wills, or power of attorney)

• Best for: Standard B2B service agreements

• Verification: IP address, email, phone number capture

"Electronic signatures are not valid for conveyance of property so you have to have wet signatures for that... similarly if you are giving a power of attorney the electronic signature will not be accepted and one more thing is a will if somebody is writing a will electronic signature is not valid."

Aadhaar-Based Signatures

• What they are: OTP-verified signatures linked to Aadhaar

• Legal validity: Highest for individual contracts

• Mandated by: RBI for banking sector contracts

• Process: Enter Aadhaar number → Receive OTP → Validate → Sign

"As per the RBI, RBI has mandated to capture the signatures via Aadhaar for the banking industry. And it becomes the ultimate truth because the Aadhaar is the one thing that is getting into multiple identities of individuals and businesses."

Digital Signature Certificates (DSC)

• What they are: Encrypted signatures on physical USB tokens

• Legal validity: Required for MCA filings, tenders, corporate tax returns

• Types: Class 2 (individuals), Class 3 (corporations)

• Limitation: Requires software download, becoming obsolete

Pro tip: Choose signature type based on your industry and client requirements, not convenience.

🏗️ The Infrastructure Behind Legal Contracts

Understanding this system helped me appreciate why contract management is more complex than it appears.

"We cannot replace the government systems. We can only leverage the government system. So we are automating certain processes for procuring stamp papers... We have to get approvals from Stop Holding Corporation or NESL who actually provides these APIs to help us to provide these services to our customers."

Government Layer: Central Certifying Authority (CCA) sets framework

Private Layer: Companies like eMudra, Capricorn get licenses from CCA

Technology Layer: Platforms like Doqfy integrate with these certified authorities

Think of it like payment processing: Just as you can't directly integrate with Visa/Mastercard but need payment gateways, you can't directly access government systems but need certified intermediaries.

When I asked about market opportunity, Aditya's response was staggering.

"The addressable market, if you ask me, it's around like contract lifecycle management and contract execution and signature would combine around like 50 billion market across the globe... We have not even covered 1% of the market yet."

This complexity is exactly why the contract management market is worth $50 billion globally, with India barely scratching 1% penetration.

⚡ Beyond Signing: Contract Lifecycle Management

Here's what most founders miss: Signing is just the beginning.

"Contact life cycle management is from the base of your contract, like you have to create contracts for a business... collaborate within the organization, outside the organization to do the negotiations. Once the negotiations are complete, you can move this to the execution. Once the contract is executed, there is a certain lifetime of the contract."

Real contract management involves:

✅ Milestone Tracking - Payment releases based on deliverable completion

✅ Renewal Management - Automated alerts for contract expiration

✅ Obligation Monitoring - Ensuring both parties meet minimum commitments

✅ Integration Management - Connecting with your ERP/CRM systems

"For example, there is a software services segment. And so you will decide the payment releases depending upon the modules that the service provider is going to release... if all the stakeholder says that all the obligations are met, then it will trigger for the finance telling that you can go ahead and release the payments."

For example, if your vendor contract requires minimum monthly orders of ₹5 lakhs, how do you track compliance? Manual spreadsheets? That's where businesses start losing money through overlooked obligations.

🤖 AI is Revolutionizing Contract Management

The legal industry is experiencing its ChatGPT moment. AI is now handling:

Contract Drafting: Instead of starting from scratch, legal teams use AI to generate first drafts based on company policies and past agreements.

"With the help of prompt engineering, legal professionals can actually create contracts with a less turnaround time... each organization has their own style of doing the drafting... With the help of AI we have created a small language model which would help the legal professionals to create the contracts."

Policy Compliance: AI reviews incoming contracts against your internal policies, flagging discrepancies before human review.

"The AI system would review the contracts, you can actually define the policies. based upon the policies, if the contract that you have received from your counterpart is matching to your policies... If it is not matching, then it will trigger the anomalies or the highlights that is not matching with the policies."

Document Summarization: 300-page contracts get summarized into key points, saving hours of legal review time.

"A few contracts go beyond 400 page document and somebody is sitting and reviewing these contracts and understanding the summary of the contract is a tedious task. So we have integrated a system which can actually summarize the contacts for the legal positions."

Small vs. Large Language Models: Companies are building specialized models trained only on relevant legal data rather than using general-purpose AI, ensuring accuracy and compliance.

💡 Building Your Contract Strategy

Start Here - Risk Assessment:

• What's your average contract value?

• How often do disputes reach legal territory?

• What are your clients' compliance expectations?

• Can you absorb the cost of non-enforceable agreements?

Scale Gradually:

• Phase 1: Electronic signatures for standard agreements

• Phase 2: Stamp duty for high-value or high-risk contracts

• Phase 3: Automated lifecycle management as volume grows

Red Flags to Watch:

• Clients pushing back on basic legal requirements

• Handshake deals for significant commitments

• Missing renewal dates on critical vendor agreements

• No standardized contract templates

🎯 Industry-Specific Considerations

Banking/Financial Services: RBI mandates Aadhaar signatures, high compliance requirements

Real Estate: Physical presence still required for property registration, electronic signatures not valid for conveyance

B2B Services: Electronic signatures often sufficient, but stamp duty recommended for high-value agreements

SaaS/Technology: Focus on IP protection, data handling clauses, and jurisdiction specifications

⚠️ Common Pitfalls to Avoid

From my experience and Aditya's insights, here are the biggest mistakes:

1. Mixing Personal and Corporate Signatures - Use appropriate DSC class for corporate agreements

2. Ignoring State Variations - Stamp duty requirements differ significantly across states

"We do not have a uniform stamping mechanism. This is a state subject and this falls under the revenue department of each state and we do not have a uniform stamping mechanism like GST or in income tax."

3. Overlooking Renewal Dates - Missing contract renewals can disrupt business operations

4. Inadequate Record Keeping - Digital contracts need proper storage and backup systems

5. Underestimating Compliance Costs - Factor legal infrastructure into your startup budget

🔮 The Future is Digital-First

The contract management space is evolving rapidly:

• Government Digitization: Push toward uniform electronic stamp systems across states

• Mobile-First Solutions: Smartphone-based signing becoming mainstream

• Blockchain Integration: Smart contracts for automated execution

• Cross-Border Standardization: International compliance becoming easier

The companies that build robust legal infrastructure early will have significant competitive advantages as regulations tighten and business scales.

🎯 Your Next Steps

Immediate Actions:

1. Audit your existing client agreements for legal enforceability

2. Implement standardized contract templates

3. Choose appropriate signature technology for your business model

4. Set up renewal tracking systems

Strategic Planning:

1. Budget for legal infrastructure as you scale

2. Evaluate contract management platforms before you need them

3. Build relationships with legal counsel early

4. Train your team on compliance requirements

The reality is simple: Legal contracts aren't just paperwork. They're the foundation of your business relationships and your primary protection against disputes.

In my years as an entrepreneur, I've learned that cutting corners on legal infrastructure is like building on quicksand. It might hold initially, but when pressure comes, everything collapses.

Liked this story? Subscribe to our YouTube channel for more such inspiring content from Disruptive founders at: https://www.youtube.com/@founderthesis