Managing Perceptions for Project Success: How Stakeholders Shape Reality

Have you ever chosen to go over budget, time, or scope to deliver the value stakeholders expected? How did that decision shape their perception of success—and yours?

Written by Dave Garrett. This article was originally published on The PMI Blog.

Project success isn’t just about execution. Stakeholder perceptions play a critical role in determining whether a project is seen as valuable. Learn how to shape success narratives, manage perceptions, and align stakeholder expectations to maximize project impact.

Why perception matters in project success

Project leaders have been traditionally measured by their ability to deliver on time, in scope, and on budget. Today, it’s clear that managing the triple constraint is not enough. New research shows project success isn’t just about hitting targets—it’s about whether stakeholders perceive a project as valuable. For some high performing project professionals, this is nothing new. Yet, for many PMs who are “technically successful”, a broader perspective on what qualifies as success could offer a way to level up.

This shift in thinking is at the core of PMI’s latest research, which challenges traditional definitions of project success. The findings show that delivering value that is worth the effort and expense is what truly matters. While hard metrics remain essential, stakeholder perception plays a critical role in determining whether a project is seen as successful. In fact, those same perceptions often inform the goals and metrics tracked. The greater the overall alignment, the better our chances are of achieving success. If stakeholders don’t perceive the project’s outcomes as valuable, success remains elusive, even if all KPIs are met.

Managing stakeholder perceptions isn’t just helpful—it’s essential for the broader team’s commitment to value delivery and ensuring that your project, overall, is viewed as a success. Project professionals who understand this gain more influence and credibility, elevating their careers along with their projects.

The role of hard metrics: Why measurement matters (but isn’t enough)

PMI’s research found that projects with clear performance measurement systems are twice as likely to be perceived as successful. Hard metrics provide structure, accountability, and benchmarks for project execution.  Without them, it’s impossible to track progress effectively. Individuals or stakeholder groups may have additional hard metrics they perceive as key. Understanding those can help a project leader pick up on nuanced needs which can make a huge difference in perceived outcomes.

However, data alone doesn’t guarantee the project will be viewed as successful. If it did, success would just be ‘calculated’ and every well-executed project would be celebrated. Instead, stakeholder perceptions typically determine whether a project is seen as valuable.

Perception is not just important in the context of projects. It plays a trusted role in everyday judgements. Consider Amazon reviews: Consumers don’t just trust product specifications; they trust other people’s perceptions of a product’s quality. The same principle applies to project success—if key stakeholders don’t believe the project delivered value, the data won’t change their minds. However, influence from other human beings just might.

Research shows measurement should guide decisions, not just track them. A key finding of PMI’s research on project success is that project measurement systems must do more than track progress—they should align and guide decision-making. In fact, project success scores doubled when three conditions were met:

• Success criteria were established early.
• A measurement system was in place that guided decisions.
• Metrics were tracked throughout the entire project.

However, only 37% of projects currently follow all three of these practices, revealing a significant opportunity for improvement.

Thus, while hard metrics are essential, they must be defined, framed   and communicated in ways that resonate with stakeholders. This is where perception management comes in.

Perception is reality: How stakeholders define success

Stephen R. Covey once said, "We see the world, not as it is, but as we are—or, as we are conditioned to see it." This idea is particularly relevant in project management, where stakeholder perceptions are shaped by their experiences, biases, and expectations rather than just objective metrics. Rather than relying solely on structured data, stakeholder perceptions often emerge through informal conversations. For example, a project team might focus on meeting defined success metrics, but if executives or end-users discuss frustrations informally—whether in meetings, emails, or casual hallway conversations—those sentiments can outweigh formal project reports in shaping overall perception.

While project teams focus on delivering key metrics, stakeholders are informed by those same metrics. However, they make judgements about success or failure based on discussions, shared experiences, and how the project’s outcomes align with their expectations.   This means that managing perception isn’t just about presenting data—it’s about actively engaging in the conversations that shape success narratives.

Project success isn’t binary—it exists on a continuum shaped by different perspectives. PMI’s research found that projects with strong execution and outcome alignment had the highest perceived success rates. However, those perceptions are always colored by stakeholders experiences, expectations, and intuition—not just data.

A project that meets deadlines and budgets may still be seen as a failure if stakeholders feel the results weren’t worth the effort and expense. This is why perception plays a pivotal role—it influences whether a project is celebrated or dismissed.

To ensure success is recognized, project professionals must shape the narrative. This means engaging stakeholders early, understanding their point of view, continuously assessing how the project is perceived and often, aligning expectations. When project teams foster clear communication and demonstrate how outcomes align with stakeholder priorities, they increase the likelihood of success being acknowledged.

In practice, this requires more than just delivering results—it involves telling the story of success in a way that resonates with stakeholders. Managing perception isn’t about manipulation; it’s about ensuring that the value a project delivers is seen, understood, and appreciated.

Managing perceptions: A project leader’s responsibility

For a project to be recognized as successful, project leaders must proactively manage stakeholder perceptions. This requires a mix of strategy, communication, and relationship-building. Here’s how:

1. Align on success criteria early

• PMI’s research found that projects that define success upfront achieve significantly higher success scores.
• Project professionals can’t rely solely on the project sponsor’s perspective—they must engage multiple stakeholders to understand varied definitions of success.

2. Continuously reassess stakeholder perceptions

• Perceptions evolve—what stakeholders considered valuable at the start may shift over time.
• Regular check-ins ensure that stakeholders remain aligned with project goals and outcomes.
• Adjustments should be made proactively to prevent misalignment.

3. Storytelling with data: Framing metrics in a meaningful way

• Data must be contextualized to resonate with stakeholders. Instead of reporting raw figures, connect them to business objectives to ensure that they are presented within the context of the business.
• Example: Instead of saying, "Project X reduced costs by 10%," frame it as, "This project saved the company $2M annually, allowing for reinvestment in key growth areas."

4. Build trust through cognitive empathy

• Understanding how stakeholders think (cognitive empathy) allows project leaders to anticipate concerns and adjust communication accordingly.
• Leaders who demonstrate empathy build stronger relationships and foster trust, ensuring that stakeholders feel heard and valued.

Project success is dynamic: The need for continuous reassessment

Project success is not static—stakeholder perceptions evolve throughout a project’s lifecycle. PMI’s research underscores that as business conditions change, expectations may shift, requiring project leaders to continuously reassess and adjust. If project leaders fail to adjust, success can erode, even if initial metrics were met.

To maintain alignment and ensure long-term project success, project leaders must take proactive steps.

• Regularly reassess stakeholder priorities and expectations.
• Communicate evolving success narratives to maintain alignment.
• Be proactive in reframing project value as conditions change.

Conclusion: Project professionals must own the perception of success

Project success is no longer just about execution, it’s about delivering value that stakeholders recognize and appreciate.

Those who master both data-driven decision-making and perception management don’t just execute well, they become strategic partners, driving greater influence and career growth.

The best project leaders shape success—not just by delivering value, but by ensuring that value is visible, clear, and appreciated in a similar way by everyone involved. By balancing hard data with active perception management, project professionals maximize project success and elevate their impact.

Maximize your project success and deliver real value. Download the full report.