Maximizing Longevity – O&M Testing, Degradation Monitoring & Failure Analysis for PV Systems

This post will cover "O&M Testing" and "Failure Analysis & RCA," integrating relevant "Test Execution" details.

"Welcome to the final installment, Part 3, of our series on PV module testing!

Having covered factory (Part 1) and field installation testing (Part 2), we now turn to the long game: Operations & Maintenance (O&M) testing and what to do when modules underperform or fail.

1. Operations & Maintenance (O&M) Testing: Monitoring Long-Term Performance & Health

Purpose: To monitor the long-term performance of PV modules, identify degradation mechanisms (e.g., LID, PID, age-related wear), detect emerging failures, and schedule proactive maintenance to maximize energy yield, ensure safety, and extend asset lifespan.

Main Key Tests:

A. Periodic IV Curve Tracing (Module & String Level):

Methodology: Similar to commissioning IV tracing, performed at scheduled intervals (e.g., annually, biennially, or triggered by performance alerts). Data is meticulously corrected to STC and compared against baseline (commissioning) data and previous O&M tests.

Purpose: Tracks actual performance degradation rates over time, identifies underperforming strings/modules requiring further investigation. Essential for warranty claims and performance guarantees.

B. Thermal Imaging:

Methodology: Regular aerial (drone) or ground-based thermal scans under suitable irradiance conditions.

Purpose: Detects developing hotspots from cell defects, bypass diode issues, delamination, or worsening connection problems. Early detection can prevent irreversible damage or fire hazards.

C. Electroluminescence (EL) Imaging (Diagnostic):

Methodology: Used selectively for in-depth investigation of underperforming modules or strings identified by IV tracing or thermal imaging. Can pinpoint exact failure modes like new microcracks, PID effects, or cell shunts.

D. Degradation Analysis:

Methodology: Sophisticated analysis of long-term performance data (from SCADA, string monitoring, and periodic IV curves), corrected for irradiance, temperature, and soiling. Compares actual energy yield and degradation rates against warranted values and performance models.

Purpose: Quantifies long-term degradation, identifies systemic issues, and informs O&M strategies.

E. Hotspot Detection & Bypass Diode Functionality Tests:*

Methodology: Often combined. Thermal imaging identifies hotspots. For specific diode tests, one might shade sections of a module and check for correct voltage/current behavior using an IV curve tracer or dedicated diode tester if accessible. Shunted diodes show as cold spots or drain power. Open diodes lead to entire string sections dropping out if multiple cells are shaded/failed.

Purpose: Ensures bypass diodes are functioning to protect cells from reverse bias damage during partial shading.

F. Soiling Loss Measurement:

Methodology: Using reference cells (one cleaned, one soiled) or by measuring the Pmax difference between a soiled module and an adjacent freshly cleaned module.

Purpose: Quantifies energy loss due to dust, dirt, pollen, bird droppings, etc., to optimize cleaning schedules and ensure cost-effectiveness of cleaning.

Applicable Standards for O&M Testing:

IEC TS 61724 Series (Photovoltaic system performance):

IEC TS 61724-1: Monitoring.

IEC TS 61724-2: Capacity evaluation method.

IEC TS 61724-3: Energy evaluation method.

IEC 62446-2 (Grid-connected PV systems – Part 2: Maintenance of PV systems): Provides guidance on preventive and corrective maintenance, including recommended tests.

2. Failure Analysis & Root Cause Analysis (RCA)

When tests reveal underperformance or failures, a systematic RCA is crucial.

A. Common Failure Modes (Recap & O&M Context):

Delamination: Progresses over time, often accelerated by thermal cycling and humidity.

Potential Induced Degradation (PID): Can manifest significantly after a few years of operation if modules are susceptible and system grounding/potentials are unfavorable. EL is key for diagnosis.
Microcracks: Can propagate due to wind/snow loads, thermal cycling, leading to increased inactive cell areas over time.
Light Induced Degradation (LID) & Light and elevated Temperature Induced Degradation (LeTID): Initial stabilization losses, but LeTID can cause more prolonged degradation in some PERC cell technologies.
Snail Trails: Cosmetic but can indicate underlying moisture ingress.
Backsheet Cracking/Degradation: Becomes more prevalent in older modules or those with less durable backsheet materials, compromising safety and performance.
Hotspots & Bypass Diode Failures: Can develop due to accumulated stress, shading, or internal degradation.
Corrosion: Of ribbons, busbars, or J-box internals due to moisture ingress over years.

3. Root Cause Analysis (RCA) Methodology (During O&M):

Tier 1 (On-Site Diagnostics):

Performance Data Review (SCADA, Inverters): First indication of issues.
Targeted Visual Inspection: For modules/strings flagged by data.
On-Site IV Curve Tracing & EL/Thermal Imaging: As described above, focused on problematic areas.

Tier 2 (Advanced Diagnostics / Laboratory Analysis - for warranty claims or systemic issues):

If on-site tests are inconclusive or a deeper understanding is needed for warranty claims or to address widespread issues, modules may be sent to a lab.
High-Resolution EL/PL Imaging: More detailed defect mapping.
UV Fluorescence (UVF): Can highlight encapsulant issues, certain cell defects not visible in EL.
Insulation & Wet Leakage Tests: To quantify degradation of insulation.
Cross-Sectioning & Microscopy (SEM/EDX): To examine material interfaces (e.g., corrosion layers, crack propagation paths).
Destructive Cell Testing: If necessary, to analyze specific cell characteristics.

4. Mitigation Strategies (O&M Focus):

Proactive Monitoring & Predictive Maintenance: Using data analytics to anticipate failures.
Prompt Corrective Actions: Replacing faulty modules/components identified during inspections or through monitoring.
Optimized Cleaning Schedules: Based on soiling measurements.
PID Mitigation/Reversal: If PID is confirmed, implementing system-level solutions (e.g., specialized equipment or grounding changes if feasible and safe).
Documentation & Warranty Management: Keeping meticulous records of tests and failures for warranty claims.

5. Overall Conclusion for the Series:

"Across the entire lifecycle of a solar PV project, from the factory to decades of operation, rigorous and phase-appropriate testing is the cornerstone of quality, safety, reliability, and financial success. By understanding and implementing these diverse testing methodologies, industry professionals can effectively mitigate risks, optimize performance, and ensure their solar assets deliver on their promise of clean, sustainable energy for years to come. Investing in testing is investing in the future of solar.

6. Technical References:

IEC TS 61724 Series (Photovoltaic system performance):
IEC TS 61724-1: Monitoring.
IEC TS 61724-2:* Capacity evaluation method.
IEC TS 61724-3:* Energy evaluation method.
IEC 62446-2:* Grid-connected PV systems – Part 2: Maintenance of PV systems.
IEC TS 62782: Dynamic mechanical load testing for photovoltaic (PV) modules (relevant for understanding crack propagation).
IEC TS 62804 Series:* Photovoltaic (PV) modules - Test methods for the detection of potential-induced degradation (PID).
Peer-Reviewed Journals: (Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells)
Progress in Photovoltaics: Research and Applications
IEEE Journal of Photovoltaics
Technical Reports & Best Practices: From NREL, Fraunhofer ISE, TÜV Rheinland, PI Berlin on specific degradation modes (PID, LID/LeTID, backsheet durability etc.).

For more interesting topics about energy, kindly check our newsletter...👇

Energy Newsletter 👂👂👂👂👂

Ahmed Hamdy Abd Elrahman........✍️✍️✍️

"Please feel free to share your thoughts, suggestions, or any modifications regarding our recent discussions. Looking forward hearing your valuable comments!"