Navigating Business Ethics Across Asian Cultures

Indonesia has become a significant hub for foreign investment, with companies from Japan, South Korea, and China playing a crucial role in its economic landscape. These countries have deeply rooted business ethics, social norms, and cultural frameworks that influence their operations and interactions. For Indonesian professionals working with stakeholders from these nations, understanding these nuances can lead to stronger partnerships and more effective business practices.

Japanese Companies in Indonesia

Japan has been investing in Indonesia for decades, particularly in manufacturing, automotive, and infrastructure. Major companies such as Toyota, Honda, Mitsubishi, Yamaha, and Sumitomo have extensive operations in Indonesia. In the electronics sector, companies like Panasonic and Sony have long-established production facilities.

As of recent years, over 1,500 Japanese companies operate in Indonesia, contributing significantly to employment and technological development. Japan remains one of Indonesia’s top foreign investors, reflecting the strong economic ties between the two nations.

South Korean Companies in Indonesia

South Korean investment in Indonesia has grown substantially, particularly in the textile, electronics, and steel industries. Leading Korean firms, including Samsung, LG, Hyundai, Lotte, and POSCO, have established their presence in Indonesia, bolstering industrial and economic collaboration.

The South Korean government actively encourages investment in Indonesia, leading to over 2,000 Korean companies operating in the country, employing thousands of locals and fostering trade relations between the two nations.

Chinese Companies in Indonesia

China has rapidly expanded its footprint in Indonesia, particularly in infrastructure, energy, and digital technology sectors. With the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), Chinese investment in Indonesia has surged, leading to the establishment of around 1,000 Chinese companies as of recent years. These companies primarily invest in sectors such as mining, e-commerce (Alibaba, TikTok), and telecommunications (Huawei, ZTE).

China is now Indonesia’s largest trading partner, with growing collaborations in digital innovation, smart cities, and renewable energy projects.

Expatriate Communities from Japan, Korea, and China in Indonesia

With the influx of foreign investments, expatriates from Japan, Korea, and China have settled in Indonesia, facilitating business expansion and cross-cultural exchanges.

• Japanese Expatriates: Estimated at around 20,000 individuals, most of whom work in executive or managerial roles within Japanese multinational corporations.
• South Korean Expatriates: Indonesia hosts around 78,676 South Koreans, making them one of the largest foreign communities in the country.
• Chinese Expatriates: While the ethnic Chinese population in Indonesia is historically significant, the number of Chinese expatriates working in business and investment roles is estimated in the tens of thousands, particularly in urban hubs like Jakarta, Surabaya, and Batam.

1. The Importance of First Impressions and Greetings

Japan: A structured and polite greeting sets the tone for business interactions. Employees address their seniors with formal expressions like “Ohayo gozaimasu” (Good morning) and bow as a sign of respect.

South Korea: Deep bows and honorifics reinforce hierarchy. Titles such as “Sajangnim” (CEO) or “Seonsaengnim” (teacher/professor) are commonly used.

China: Greetings tend to be more relaxed, with efficiency prioritized over elaborate formality. However, a firm handshake and addressing colleagues by their titles are considered respectful.

For Indonesian professionals, balancing formality with warmth can help build rapport with counterparts from these countries.

2. The Role of Titles and Hierarchy in Communication

In hierarchical cultures like Japan and Korea, addressing superiors properly is crucial. In Japan, titles such as “Shacho” (President) or “Bucho” (Department Head) are essential in professional settings. China follows a similar structure but tends to have a more flexible approach depending on the industry.

Indonesia shares hierarchical traits but is generally more relaxed, especially in creative industries. However, when dealing with East Asian professionals, observing their preferred title usage can enhance mutual respect.

3. Punctuality and Work Ethic

Japan: Being on time—or arriving slightly early—is an unspoken rule. Tardiness is viewed as disrespectful.

South Korea & China: Punctuality is expected, though business practices in China may sometimes accommodate flexibility.

Indonesia: While punctuality is valued, many workplaces are more forgiving of minor delays. However, when working with Japanese or Korean colleagues, punctuality should be prioritized to foster trust and professionalism.

4. Decision-Making and Corporate Culture

• Japan: Decision-making is consensus-driven, emphasizing harmony and group approval (nemawashi process).
• South Korea: Decisions flow from top management down, with hierarchical structures dictating business interactions.
• China: Business is fast-paced, with decision-making often concentrated in the hands of key executives.
• Indonesia: A mix of collaborative and hierarchical structures, depending on the industry.

Understanding these differences can help Indonesian professionals adjust their expectations when negotiating or collaborating on projects.

5. Business Networking and Relationship Building

• Japan: Nominication (drinking and networking) is a common practice where business relationships are strengthened over meals.
• South Korea: Social drinking plays a significant role in solidifying business partnerships.
• China: Guanxi (personal connections) is critical in business dealings, often requiring informal networking outside office hours.
• Indonesia: Business relationships are built through social interactions, though alcohol may not always be involved due to cultural and religious considerations - coffee and food is a good combo!

Few Tips and Strategies for Indonesian Professionals Working with Japanese, Korean, and Chinese Companies

Indonesian professionals working with Japanese counterparts should maintain a high level of respect and formality in their communication. Punctuality is crucial, as lateness is viewed negatively. Additionally, structured reporting and consensus-based decision-making should be embraced, as these are integral aspects of Japanese corporate culture.

When dealing with Korean professionals, demonstrating dedication and loyalty to the company is important. Korean workplaces emphasize hierarchy, so addressing superiors appropriately and following traditional corporate structures will be beneficial. Adaptability in fast-paced environments is also essential, as decisions often come from senior management with strong authority.

Building strong personal relationships, or guanxi, is critical when working with Chinese professionals. Business negotiations can be rapid, so flexibility and quick decision-making skills are essential. While direct communication is often preferred, it should always be accompanied by respect and tact.

Last but not least, the rise of Japanese, Korean, and Chinese businesses in Indonesia presents immense opportunities for collaboration. However, success in these interactions requires cultural intelligence, adaptability, and a deep appreciation of ethical business practices.

By mastering the nuances of hierarchy, communication, punctuality, and networking, Indonesian professionals can foster strong, productive relationships with their East Asian counterparts, leading to long-term success in the global market.

Please share your experience below in the comment and feel free to add in case I'm missing anything!

Sinarmas, Korean investor kickstart $300m data center project

Indonesia Looks to Strengthen Economic Ties with Japan - Invest Indonesia

Chinese investment in Asia rose 37% in 2023, led by Indonesia - Nikkei Asia

Top Foreign Investors in Indonesia (by Country and Continent)

Indonesia's Economy is Still One of Asia's Fastest in 2024 - YouTube

China’s Investments in Indonesia: 2024 Outlook

The 2024 Outlook for Chinese Investment in Indonesia