Run Chart vs Control Chart: Know the Difference
Intelligence Quality
Top Lean Six Sigma Training, and Certification, Corporate Solutions, Business Transformation & Productivity Improvement.
In the domain of quality improvement and process monitoring, especially within Lean Six Sigma and Statistical Process Control (SPC), two commonly used tools are the Run Chart and the Control Chart. While they might look similar at a glance, these charts serve distinctly different purposes.
Understanding when and how to use each of these charts is critical for anyone working to improve operational efficiency, reduce variation, and sustain quality outcomes. Let’s explore these tools in depth and see how they compare.
What is a Run Chart?
A Run Chart is one of the simplest graphical tools used to analyze data over time. It is a line graph that plots individual data points in chronological order. The purpose of a run chart is to help users observe trends, shifts, or patterns in a process.
Unlike more advanced charts, a run chart does not include control limits. Instead, it typically features a median line, helping you identify if the data is behaving consistently or showing signs of drift.
This tool is especially useful when starting an analysis and looking for early indicators of change or variability. It's easy to create, interpret, and communicate, even with people who are not familiar with statistics.
What is a Control Chart?
A Control Chart, also known as a Shewhart Chart, builds on the structure of a run chart by adding statistical control limits. These limits include a centerline (mean) and upper and lower control limits (UCL and LCL), which are calculated based on the natural variation of the process.
The core purpose of a control chart is to distinguish between common cause variation (natural and expected) and special cause variation (unexpected and assignable). It allows you to assess whether a process is stable and predictable, or out of control due to unusual fluctuations.
Control charts are widely used in ongoing monitoring of key performance indicators and are a fundamental tool in quality assurance programs.
Main Differences Between Run Charts and Control Charts
While both tools are used to track process behavior over time, there are a few critical differences:
Purpose: Run charts are used to identify trends and changes in data, while control charts are used to determine whether a process is statistically in control.
Visual Structure: Run charts include a basic median line and show time-series data without statistical boundaries. Control charts include statistically calculated upper and lower control limits that help identify special cause variation.
Analytical Power: Run charts are simpler and good for visual trend spotting, but control charts provide deeper insights into process behavior and allow for real-time process control.
Ease of Use: Run charts are easier to create and require less data. Control charts need more historical data and a basic understanding of statistics.
Application Stage: Run charts are often used early in process improvement to spot potential issues. Control charts are typically applied in the later stages to monitor process stability after improvements are made.
When to Use Each Chart
You should use a Run Chart when you're at the beginning of your analysis, or when you're communicating results with stakeholders unfamiliar with statistical concepts. It's especially useful for identifying patterns, upward or downward trends, and shifts in performance.
On the other hand, a Control Chart is more appropriate when you need to verify that your process is operating consistently over time, particularly after implementing changes. It is the go-to tool when you're aiming to sustain process improvements, enforce control, and reduce variation.
Example: Healthcare Scenario
Consider a hospital trying to monitor patient discharge times. Initially, they use a run chart to plot average discharge times daily for a month. Over time, they notice a subtle increase. However, the run chart doesn't reveal whether this increase is due to normal variation or something unusual.
So they move to a control chart. After calculating control limits based on previous discharge data, they observe that several recent points fall outside the upper control limit. Investigation reveals a recent software change in the discharge documentation process. This example highlights how a control chart can pinpoint when a process deviates from its normal behavior and help uncover the root cause.
How They Fit Into Lean Six Sigma
In the Measure phase of a Lean Six Sigma project, Run Charts can be used to establish a baseline and visualize the current process behavior. They help teams understand "what's going on."
Later, in the Control phase, Control Charts are crucial to verify whether improvements are sustained. They help you maintain gains and alert you when performance begins to drift outside acceptable limits. Without a control chart, it’s nearly impossible to ensure long-term process control in a statistically sound way.
Conclusion:
Both Run Charts and Control Charts are valuable tools in the process improvement toolbox, but they serve very different purposes. Run Charts provide a straightforward view of process behavior over time, making them perfect for detecting visible trends and early changes. Control Charts go further by applying statistical rules to highlight when variation is no longer random, allowing you to take corrective action.
By understanding the difference, and knowing when to use which tool, you’ll make smarter decisions, catch issues earlier, and deliver more reliable process improvements.
Let’s Connect:
Reach out for Expert Training & Consulting solutions!!!
IQ Whatsapp Channel: https://whatsapp.com/channel/0029Vb5awT09Bb5wmPDi662C