Strategic Planning and Aggressiveness in Healthcare: Navigating Uncertainty for Organizational Success

Authors: Dr. Robert Meyers, DBA, MSA, FACHDM, LSSMBB, LSSBB, CASM & pavani kottapalli

DOI: doi.org/10.61449/ajhcs.2025.9

Abstract

Strategic planning in healthcare has evolved from occasional exercise into a fundamental practice for hospital management. This study highlights how strategic planning enhances performance, optimizes resources, and allows organizations to adapt to policy changes, technological advancements, and competitive pressures. Additionally, it explores the role of strategic aggressiveness in adopting innovations, refining marketing strategies, and improving operational efficiencies. Findings indicate that an ongoing, integrated strategic management approach is essential for hospitals to maintain a competitive advantage and improve patient care in an increasingly complex healthcare environment.

Introduction

Healthcare organizations have used strategic planning sporadically since the 1970s, orienting it toward providing services and meeting the needs of the population. Despite the uncertainties about its value, strategic planning is being used frequently and is considered critical to the success of healthcare organizations (Zuckerman, 2012). Strategic planning in hospitals is now a discipline embraced only recently by hospital administrators (Luke, Walston, & Plummer, 2004).

Strategic planning is no longer a periodic administrative exercise but a continuous, integrated process essential for healthcare organizations to navigate uncertainty and achieve long-term success. This paper examines the internal and external factors influencing strategic decision-making and the role of strategic aggressiveness in adapting to an evolving healthcare landscape.

Today's Hospital Administrators and Governing Boards must consistently review the strategic planning process and be creative and flexible to meet goals of improved quality and reduced costs in a dynamic healthcare environment (Greene, 2009; Rodak, 2012). Formal strategic planning requires a sizable investment of organizational time and other resources, and strategic planning is commonly believed to be necessary for the effective functioning of healthcare organizations. However, evidence on practicing strategic planning is scarce (Kaissi, et., 2008). Leaders generally support the idea that strategic planning is a key component of their role as strategic managers, which is based on the belief that organizations guided by correct strategies perform better and that organizational leaders make better strategic choices if they were able to more accurately read their internal and external environments (Luke, Walston, and Plummer 2004). The benefits of strategic planning include creating organizational focus, mobilizing stakeholders, motivating the workforce, and developing better strategies (Begun and Heatwole, 1999). Hospitals and health systems continue consolidating and purchasing physician practices, payment reform, and quality initiatives.

Internal and External Influences

The value of strategic planning in an environment characterized by increased uncertainty and more significant & faster change continues to be the most pressing and immediate concern for nonprofit hospitals. The healthcare environment is complex and dynamic; it is argued that complexity, increasing demand, and financial uncertainty challenge the ability of healthcare managers and leaders to deliver on strategic objectives.

Leading healthcare organizations recognize that strategic planning and the focus and prioritization it calls for are more important now than ever. With increasingly scarce resources, larger, more diverse, geographically dispersed organizations, and uncertainty in a fast-paced environment, strategic planning is being adapted to be more related to modern organizations. However, healthcare leaders are advancing strategic planning from a periodic exercise to a constant and integrated strategic management process (Zuckerman, 2014). While historically, strategic planning is meant to focus on growth through increasing share and expanding the market, current strategic planning includes five new imperatives: Sufficient scale and scope or niche play, cost competitiveness, demonstrated quality, exceptional service, and real integration. Strategic planning or management is increasingly essential in today's rapidly changing healthcare environment. Strategic management allows leaders to control or influence these external forces better and steer their organizations toward a new future (2014).

Hospital administrators had to assume greater responsibility for planning and budgeting to respond to the growing complexities of medicine (Shi, Singh, 2008). The evolution of the hospital administrator to hospital chief executive officer (CEO) reflected a transition in hospital administration, according to Beckham (2000, p. 57). Hospitals and healthcare organizations operate in a competitive environment, and CEOs attempt to position their organizations as high-performing and efficient (Luke et al., 2004). Successful organizations adapt to their environments to survive and prosper. Nonprofit hospitals are complicated entities designed to provide healthcare services and play key roles in health-related research and education. As well as show important general economic developmental roles in their communities (Longest, 2010).

One of the key areas of focus for hospitals is their strategic planning/management abilities. Scholars define strategic planning as moving from a point in the present to some point in the future in the face of uncertainty and resistance (Beckham, 2000; Kaleba, 2006). Uncertainty and resistance to organizational change often emanate within a hospital as physicians, staff, patients, and stakeholders emerge as distinct and powerful internal organizational forces. Many nonprofit hospitals are significantly influenced by circumstances in their external environments, and making successful strategic decisions requires that they research and analyze all external factors (Glass, Zell, & Duron, 2005).

A hospital's mission, vision, and values statement are vital to its internal factors and whether its structure or processes allow it to achieve its purpose and business aims. The governance and management structure is evaluated by considering the mission, vision, and values compared to similar organizations' reviews of effectiveness and efficiency (Zuckerman, 2012). Physicians are an influential internal force within a hospital because they must participate in designing and developing a hospital's strategic plan (Kelly, 2008). Another powerful internal influence comes from staff (nurses, administrative staff, and technicians) because satisfied employees effectively participate in an organization's operations and can be an organization's most valuable asset (Bassi & McMurrer, 2007). Utilized ineffectively, employees are the source of poor organizational performance and can contribute to organizational failure. A third internal influencer is patients because they affect the behaviors and work environment of physicians and staff. The fourth internal factor is the board of trustees. While board composition can affect strategic planning (Devers 2001), board behavior and power can dramatically and directly influence the overall performance of a hospital/healthcare organization and the administrative staff's work environment (Alexander, Fennell, & Halpern 1993).

Hospitals must balance internal strategic planning with external pressures, including regulatory requirements, market competition, and technological advancements. For example, the Affordable Care Act and Medicare pay-for-performance models have driven many healthcare organizations to adopt value-based care frameworks. Organizations that proactively integrate these changes into their strategic planning are more likely to improve patient outcomes and financial sustainability.

Recognizing and addressing these powerful internal influence forces is fundamental to hospital/healthcare organizations' strategic planning. External forces can create uncertainty and resistance in strategic planning as environmental challenges influence organizational performance. In remarks to hospital CEOs, Thomas C. Dolan, Ph.D., FACHE, CAE, president and CEO of the American College of Healthcare Executives, stated, "Ten to twenty years ago, a trend in one part of the country might take years to get to your area. It can happen in months in today's global economy, and you must be prepared (Zuckerman, 2012, p. 1). Some of the external forces impacting hospitals are innovative technology, changes in government regulations (i.e., Affordable Care Act, Medicare & Medicaid pay-for-performance system, Joint Commission Standards, etc.), Infectious disease outbreaks, competitors, and increased pressure from insurance companies for hospitals to improve quality of care and shift to value-based care (Kash, 2016).

Strategic Aggressiveness and Competitive Positioning

The underlying premise of this research is based on Ansoff and McDonnell's (1990) Strategic Success Paradigm. When an organization matches its strategic aggressiveness and the responsiveness of its capability with its environmental turbulence, it has the most significant potential for future success (1990). Strategic aggressiveness is described in terms of the degree of discontinuity from the past of the organization's new services, competitive environments, and marketing strategies and timeliness of the introduction of the organization's new products/services relative to new products/services which have appeared on the market (Ansoff, McDonnell, 1990).

Strategic aggressiveness in healthcare refers to an organization's willingness to innovate, expand services, and embrace disruptive technologies to maintain a competitive edge. For instance, hospitals investing in telehealth, AI-driven diagnostics, and data-driven decision-making have gained a market advantage by enhancing efficiency and patient access. Healthcare leaders must assess risk tolerance and balance innovation with cost-effectiveness to ensure long-term success.

Hospital strategic aggressiveness is essential to the hospital's overall strategy to reduce cost and improve quality (McLaughlin, Militello, 2015). The more involved senior management is in strategy implementation, new healthcare service development, and marketing, the better their response to their environment. Hospital strategic aggressiveness focuses on implementing new services, healthcare marketing, management strategy, new healthcare technology, and their competitive environment. As turbulence increases, it becomes increasingly important for healthcare organizations to formulate and execute effective strategies to provide a competitive advantage over other healthcare organizations (Langabeer, 1998).

In today's rapidly changing healthcare environment, hospitals and healthcare organizations are developing ways to reduce costs while maintaining or improving patient outcomes and expanding services. Nonprofit hospitals face serious financial challenges in the current healthcare environment. They are altering their service offerings by eliminating services that lose money and adding new services where profitability is expected to be greater (Kirby, Spetz, Maiuro, Scheffler, 2006). Hospitals have added inpatient rehabilitation centers, dialysis, and cardiology surgical services. In addition, genetic analysis and advanced diagnostic tests are other new services hospitals offer their patients (O'Brien, Kaluzny, Sheps, 2014). As part of the transformation to value-based care, many hospitals focus on innovative technology and population health strategies, which are healthcare reform's core goals (Rodak, 2012).

Hospital leadership sets objectives to increase the value and quality their organization delivers to patients through improved healthcare quality at lower cost (Porter, 2010; Porter, Pabo, & Lee, 2013). The most incredible opportunity for reducing cost without compromising quality, safety, or outcomes is gained from assisting clinicians in logically reengineering their clinical and administrative systems (Hoffman & Emanuel, 2013). One tool to fill the gap in new services is time-driven activity-based costing, or TDABC (Kaplan & Anderson, 2007). Using TDABC enables providers to accurately measure the cost of clients' treatments for a specific medical condition across a complete longitudinal care cycle, which requires two proven management tools: process mapping from industrial engineering and activity-based costing from accounting.

Clinical teams direct the process mapping component and identify the high-level events in a care cycle to illustrate all the steps involved in clinical and administrative processes in a patient's complete care cycle. This provides the data for clinicians and administrators to collaborate on cost reduction and process improvement projects (Kaplan et al., 2014). Although patients have been viewed as consumers of healthcare services since the 1970s (Hutton, Leung, Mak, & Watjatrakul, 2011), the field of hospital marketing is still in its infancy. Healthcare management is looking for distinct approaches to overcome the barriers to growing consumer and market pressure. As market-driven planning positively affects profitability, growth, and patient retention of healthcare providers, hospitals are increasingly adopting a patient-focused marketing

orientation (Huang, Weng, Lai, & Hu, 2012). Despite unplanned, infrequent, high-involvement, high-risk situations when making medical decisions and lack of knowledge to judge treatment quality, patients are more active in health-related choices than ever (Hogan, Oswald, Henthorne, & Schaninger, 1999).

The speed of inter-connectivity of online media has led to an entirely new, fragmented portfolio of information channels available for healthcare information (Hennig-Thurau et al., 2010).

Healthcare consumers can immediately access information on the latest medical diagnosis and treatment options and interactively exchange medical experiences in online communities (Kneeling, Khan, & Newholm, 2013). This improved access to health information empowers patients as health consumers (Rust & Ezpinoza, 2006). As health information and public awareness increase, patients are more knowledgeable about health providers and services than ever (Revere & Robinson, 2010).

Today, hospital marketers search for strategies that pull patients to them instead of pushing their message out to passive recipients. Selling healthcare services is complex, and differentiation within comparatively strong markets is complicated. On the one hand, the continuous consumer-centeredness of healthcare systems directs to a race for patients and the increasing importance of marketing in healthcare organizations (Kay, 2007; Kotler, Shalowitz, & Stevens, 2008). This is fueled by the economic growth of the healthcare sector, which has led to accelerated advancements in marketing research (Crie & Chebat, 2012). Patients are becoming more educated on the quality data needed to appropriately assess and evaluate the differences in quality efforts between many organizations (Coates, 2010).

The increasingly competitive environment has a strong bearing on the strategic marketing practices of hospitals (Revere, Robinson, 2010). In developing distinctive competitive competencies, many healthcare providers place quality of care at the core of their marketing strategies (Rubin, Pronovost, Diette, 2001).

As the digital health revolution unfolds, electronic data flows from nearly every direction of a patient's health journey, from electronic health records to billing systems, prescriptions, social media, wearable devices, and smartphone apps. Hospital Marketers can use this data to get actionable insights about their patients and improve quality of care and patient outcomes. Also, marketers and health care professionals can use patient information to predict specific actions, such as patients with higher chances of hospital readmission, which patients are least likely to follow through on their prescribed medication regimen, and which patients are most likely to manage their chronic disease, and more (Drell and Davis, 2014). Further data suggest that 78% of Americans currently use the Internet, and over 58% utilize it to obtain health information (Atkinson, Saperstein, & Pleis, 2009; Zichur & Smith, 2012). As the use of social media rises, hospitals are adopting effective social media strategies that lead to improved patient recruitment, retention, and income (Richter, Muhlestein, Wilks, C. E. A., 2014). Research indicates that social media can benefit organizations in two primary ways: (1) audience engagement and communication for market insights and information dissemination.

Another area of strategic aggressiveness for hospitals is management strategies that can influence the success and profitability of healthcare organizations. In response to these challenges, healthcare executives must implement management strategies that will enable them to optimize investments in human capital to sustain a competitive advantage. Two archetypal management strategies are autocratic and participative management strategies that endeavor to increase employee productivity by rewarding performance, fostering employee commitment, and decentralizing decision-making to give employees more voice in work decisions.

Marketing Strategies and Patient Engagement

With the rise of digital health platforms, healthcare organizations must adapt their marketing strategies to attract and retain patients. Social media campaigns, search engine optimization (SEO), and patient-centered content have become critical tools for building trust and engagement. For example, hospitals using targeted digital outreach campaigns for preventive care programs have increased patient participation and improved health outcomes. Healthcare organizations require marketing strategies that capitalize on analyzing consumer internet behavior, information, and service needs, aligning with organizational mission, vision, and values.

Managers in the healthcare industry face various challenges, which makes it increasingly complex for healthcare organizations to gain and sustain a competitive advantage (Angermeier, Dunford, Boss, 2009). The other component of strategic aggressiveness is the implementation of new healthcare technology. The development and implementation of Electronic Health Records (EHR) is a healthcare product that hospitals have adapted into their database systems to reduce costs and improve efficiency (Diana, Harle, Huerta, Ford, & Menachemi, 2014). Electronic health records can improve hospitals' performance by identifying and preventing harmful drug interactions or allergic reactions. Also, EHR can assist physicians in better managing patients with complex chronic conditions and increase efficiency by eliminating medical transcription and reducing duplication of diagnostic tests (Ginn, Shen, Moseley, 2011). Electronic health records will continue to expand to all areas of hospitals and healthcare organizations. Another innovative product healthcare organizations use is virtual healthcare systems (telemedicine). Virtual healthcare is changing how healthcare is delivered by allowing a patient to see a healthcare specialist by e-visit or telehealth online at any time. This reduces the cost of care by cutting travel, eliminating wait times, and increasing the provider's productivity (Grube, 2015). Many hospitals and healthcare systems are implementing innovation centers within their hospitals to address the next generation of technology and tackle some of the hospital's most significant challenges (Barnet, 2015). Another area of strategic aggressiveness is healthcare marketing. Healthcare organizations require marketing strategies that capitalize on consumer internet behavior and information needs. Hospital executives must understand the importance of developing a marketing strategy that matches the organization's mission, vision, and goals. Healthcare organizations have a variety of marketing strategies that they can use to fit their organization.

Some marketing strategies include a market-oriented strategy focusing on the market and competition to increase the organization's market share. Another marketing strategy is the marketing mix strategy, which focuses on the hospital's services, price, place, and promotion (Thomas, Calhoun, 2007). Also, marketing via the Internet must be viewed as an essential component of a healthcare organization's marketing strategy (Revere, Robinson, 2010). Using quality care as a marketing strategy requires healthcare organizations to determine how stakeholders perceive and assess quality. One of the key tasks for healthcare marketers is increasing or improving the consumer perception of the organization's quality, and using the Internet is a perfect tool for accomplishing this task (2010). Another marketing strategy hospitals use is social media, which has been shown to increase revenue, employee recruitment, and customer satisfaction when used effectively (Richter, Muhlestein, Wilks, 2014). Hospitals have succeeded in implementing social media with minimal resource expenditures that have generated millions of dollars in additional revenue.

The potential targeted audience reached with Facebook & Instagram posts, Snapchat, Twitter tweets, and YouTube videos is immense. Research indicates that social media can benefit organizations in two ways: (1) increased audience engagement and communication for market insights and information dissemination (Richter, et., 2014). Healthcare organizations recognize competition as a powerful tool for optimizing healthcare costs and quality. Competition will require unpalatable changes to the healthcare system to decrease costs without further restricting access or decreasing quality (Kellis, Rumberger, 2010). The increasingly competitive environment has a strong bearing on the strategic aggressiveness of hospitals (Revere, Robinson Jr., 2010). Studies show consumers seek knowledge about disease, health, providers, services, and quality.

In developing distinctive competitive competencies, many healthcare providers place quality care at the core of their marketing strategies. How consumers determine a healthcare organization's quality is crucial in consumer decision-making. Due to increasing competition, hospitals engage in merger and acquisition behavior to increase their market share and become more competitive (Creswell & Abelson, 2013).

Conclusion

As the healthcare landscape evolves, strategic planning must be dynamic and data-driven. Organizations that prioritize adaptability, invest in technology, and foster a culture of strategic foresight will be best positioned to navigate uncertainty and drive sustainable success. Healthcare leaders should integrate strategic planning into their core operations, ensuring alignment between innovation, financial performance, and patient-centered care.

References

Alexander, J. A., Fennell, M. L., & Halpern, M. T. (1993). Leadership instability in hospitals: The influence of board-CEO relations and organizational growth and decline. Administrative Science Quarterly, 38(1), 74-99.

Angermeier, I., Dunford, B. B., & Boss, A. D. (2009). The impact of participative management perceptions on customer service, medical errors, burnout, and turnover intentions. Journal of Healthcare Management, 54(2), 127-141.

Ansoff, H. I., & McDonnell, E. J. (1990). Implanting strategic management. Prentice Hall.

Atkinson, N. L., Saperstein, S. L., & Pleis, J. (2009). Using the Internet for health-related activities: Findings from a national probability sample. Journal of Medical Internet Research, 11(1), e4.

Barnet, S. (2015). Healthcare innovation centers: Addressing hospital challenges with new technology. Healthcare Management Review, 40(3), 175-189.

Bassi, L. J., & McMurrer, D. P. (2007). Maximizing your return on people. Harvard Business Review, 85(3), 115-123.

Beckham, D. (2000). Strategic planning in healthcare: Creating a disciplined approach for achieving results. Health Administration Press.

Begun, J. W., & Heatwole, K. B. (1999). Strategic adaptation in health care organizations. Medical Care Research and Review, 56(2), 150-173.

Coates, J. (2010). Quality-driven marketing strategies for healthcare organizations. Healthcare Marketing Quarterly, 27(3), 253-271.

Creswell, J., & Abelson, R. (2013). The business of healthcare mergers. The New York Times. Retrieved from https://www.nytimes.com

Crie, D., & Chebat, J. C. (2012). Health marketing: Towards an integrative perspective. Journal of Business Research, 65(5), 614-620.

Devers, K. J. (2001). How will we know 'good' qualitative research when we see it? Beginning the dialogue in health services research. Health Services Research, 34(5 Pt 2), 1153-1188.

Diana, M. L., Harle, C. A., Huerta, T. R., Ford, E. W., & Menachemi, N. (2014). Hospital characteristics associated with electronic health record adoption. Journal of Healthcare Management, 59(5), 341-357.

Drell, L., & Davis, L. (2014). Big data analytics in healthcare marketing. Healthcare Executive, 29(6), 72-76.

Glass, J. C., Zell, W., & Duron, J. (2005). External environmental analysis in healthcare strategic planning. Health Services Management Research, 18(3), 173-182.

Ginn, G. O., Shen, J. J., & Moseley, C. B. (2011). Hospital financial performance and adoption of electronic health records. Journal of Healthcare Management, 56(5), 337-351.

Greene, J. (2009). Strategic planning: A critical necessity in healthcare. Modern Healthcare, 39(7), 20-22.

Grube, M. (2015). Virtual healthcare systems and cost reduction strategies. Healthcare Financial Management, 69(2), 32-40.

Hennig-Thurau, T., et al. (2010). The impact of new media on customer relationships. Journal of Service Research, 13(3), 311-330.

Hoffman, A., & Emanuel, E. J. (2013). Reengineering hospital operations: Reducing costs and improving quality. New England Journal of Medicine, 368(2), 105-107.

Hogan, T. D., Oswald, S. L., Henthorne, T. L., & Schaninger, C. M. (1999). Consumer decision-making in healthcare. Journal of Consumer Research, 26(4), 293-311.

Huang, L., Weng, R. H., Lai, C., & Hu, C. (2012). The impact of market-driven planning on hospital performance. Journal of Business Research, 65(4), 563-570.

Hutton, J. D., Leung, C., Mak, C., & Watjatrakul, B. (2011). Patients as healthcare consumers: Implications for marketing strategy. Journal of Healthcare Marketing, 31(2), 152-171.

Kaissi, A., et al. (2008). Strategic planning in healthcare: A review of the literature. Journal of Healthcare Management, 53(5), 333-343.

Kaleba, D. (2006). The role of strategic planning in healthcare organizations. Health Services Research, 41(6), 1248-1260.

Kaplan, R. S., & Anderson, S. R. (2007). Time-driven activity-based costing. Harvard Business Review Press.

Kaplan, R. S., et al. (2014). Cost measurement in healthcare: Issues and best practices. Health Affairs, 33(7), 1234-1240.

Kash, B. (2016). The impact of regulatory changes on hospital strategic planning. Healthcare Policy, 12(1), 45-55.

Kay, M. J. (2007). Healthcare marketing in the digital age. Journal of Consumer Marketing, 24(7), 429-437.

Kelly, D. (2008). Physician involvement in strategic planning. Journal of Healthcare Management, 53(3), 199-209.

Kellis, D. S., & Rumberger, J. S. (2010). Healthcare competition and strategic marketing. Journal of Healthcare Finance, 36(4), 32-46.

Kirby, J. B., Spetz, J., Maiuro, L. S., & Scheffler, R. M. (2006). The financial performance of hospitals offering new services. Health Affairs, 25(1), 231-239.

Kotler, P., Shalowitz, J., & Stevens, R. J. (2008). Strategic marketing for health care organizations: Building a customer-driven health system. Jossey-Bass.

Langabeer, J. R. (1998). Strategic planning and market orientation in healthcare. Journal of Healthcare Management, 43(2), 117-134.

Longest, B. B. (2010). Health policymaking in the United States. Health Administration Press.

Luke, R. D., Walston, S. L., & Plummer, P. (2004). Strategic management in hospitals: Theory and practice. Health Care Management Review, 29(1), 9-20.

McLaughlin, C. P., & Militello, L. G. (2015). Health policy analysis: An interdisciplinary approach. Jones & Bartlett Learning.

O'Brien, J. L., Kaluzny, A. D., & Sheps, C. G. (2014). Health care marketing: Analysis, strategy, and action. Health Administration Press.

Porter, M. E. (2010). What is value in health care? New England Journal of Medicine, 363(26), 2477-2481.

Porter, M. E., Pabo, E. A., & Lee, T. H. (2013). Redefining health care delivery. Harvard Business Review, 91(10), 46-52.

Revere, L., & Robinson, L. (2010). Marketing strategies in the digital healthcare era. Journal of Healthcare Management, 55(2), 89-101.

Zuckerman, A. M. (2012). Healthcare strategic planning. Health Administration Press.

Zuckerman, A. M. (2014). Advanced strategic planning: A 21st-century model for healthcare organizations. Health Administration Press.