Why Customers Never Buy What You Think You're Selling

Peter Drucker's observation that "the customer rarely buys what the company thinks it is selling" is the fundamental paradox at the heart of modern brand strategy.

This paradox explains why some brands command extraordinary pricing power while others languish as commodities, despite technical parity. It reveals why certain brands inspire cultlike devotion while others struggle for basic recognition. Most importantly, it exposes the critical disconnect between how organizations perceive their value and how customers actually experience it.

The Transformation Economy

We no longer live in a product economy, a service economy, or even an experience economy. We inhabit a transformation economy where customers purchase one thing above all else: progress toward their aspirational identity.

Consider three brands that have masterfully navigated this reality:

Peloton fundamentally understood they weren't selling exercise equipment—the market was already saturated with technically superior bikes at lower price points. What they recognized was that their core demographic wasn't buying a workout; they were purchasing membership in an aspirational tribe. The bike isn't the product; it's the physical manifestation of an identity narrative.

Airbnb transcended hospitality by realizing travelers don't merely buy accommodation; they purchase the feeling of "belonging anywhere." This insight allowed them to command premium pricing for physical spaces that, objectively speaking, often offer fewer amenities than similarly priced hotels. The transformation from tourist to temporary local is what customers truly value.

Tesla sells climate identity signaling and technological progressivism far more than they sell transportation. The vehicle serves primarily as the vessel for an identity narrative that allows owners to position themselves as forward-thinking, environmentally conscious, and technologically sophisticated. The car isn't the product; the identity is.

The Strategic Blindspot

If this transformation perspective is so powerful, why do so many sophisticated organizations miss it? The answer lies in what I call the Identity Gap—the space between what organizations believe they offer and what customers actually seek.

This gap persists for four key reasons:

1. Organizational Narcissism: Companies fall in love with their own creation narratives and internal challenges, while customers evaluate offerings exclusively through their personal identity structures.

2. Technical Seduction: Particularly in founder-led organizations, the elegance of technical solutions creates an irresistible gravitational pull toward feature-focused communication—precisely when emotional resonance is required.

3. Rationality Illusion: Despite overwhelming neurological evidence to the contrary, brands persist in crafting rational value propositions for fundamentally emotional, identity-based purchase decisions.

4. Expertise Curse: The deeper an organization's expertise, the more they communicate in ways that are compelling to insiders but impenetrable to customers.

Bridging the Identity Gap

The brands that achieve extraordinary outcomes have mastered a critical shift in perspective. Instead of asking, "What do we sell?" they relentlessly pursue the question:

"Who does our customer aspire to become, and how does our brand facilitate that identity transformation?"

This shift—from functional delivery to identity enablement—requires a fundamental reorientation around three principles:

1. Identity Cartography: Map the emotional journey from your customer's current identity to their aspirational identity. What stands in their way? What social proof do they require? What permission do they need?

2. Transformation Architecture: Position your product not as the hero but as the transformational agent that facilitates the customer's journey. You're not selling a solution; you're enabling an identity.

3. Narrative Integration: Help customers integrate your brand into their personal narrative. The most powerful brands don't interrupt stories; they become essential characters within them.

The Executive Imperative

For executives and brand strategists, this perspective demands a new set of questions:

• What identity does your customer aspire to hold?

• What transformation are they actually purchasing from you?

• How does your offering facilitate that identity shift?

• What narrative do they tell themselves about that transformation?

When a brand successfully answers these questions, something remarkable happens. Price sensitivity diminishes. Customer acquisition costs decrease. Word-of-mouth accelerates. Competition becomes less relevant.

The organizations that thrive in 2025 and beyond will be those that understand they're not in the business of making products but in the business of enabling identities. They recognize that behind every transaction lies an aspiration—and their success depends not on what they believe they're selling, but on what transformation their customers are actually buying.

In closing, consider this: Your customers don't want your product. They want to become someone your product helps them be.

The question is: Do you know who that is?

xx,

Camille

PS. My Social Media Masterclass is now available for download! Access it here to turn your socials into a brand growth machine.