Why Leadership Feels Foreign (Until It Doesn’t)

Why Leadership Feels Foreign (Until It Doesn’t)

How perception, pressure, and personal identity shape the leaders we become

Leadership is everywhere. We see it in boardrooms and classrooms, on news headlines, and even in the grocery store aisle when a parent is calmly—or not so calmly—navigating a child’s meltdown.

Leadership isn’t hidden. It’s loud, visible, and constant. Yet, for many new and emerging leaders, it still feels foreign.

Why?

Because what we see, what we’re taught, and how we’re wired to lead rarely align. That disconnect creates internal tension, external confusion, and, in too many cases, poor performance.


🧭 The Mental Map of Leadership

Most of us start our leadership journey with a mental model—an image shaped by experience. Maybe it was the coach who motivated us, the first manager who challenged us, or even the leader we promised we’d never become.

That early perception becomes a sort of compass—until we step into leadership ourselves.

Then the noise begins:

“Here’s how you should lead...” “These are the top 10 traits of successful leaders...” “Follow this framework for results...”

We’re bombarded by books, courses, consultants, and a constant stream of "expert advice." The result? Most leaders try to patch together a style like a mosaic—built from fragments of what they’ve seen, read, or been told.

And when the pressure hits? We tend to revert to what feels safest: control over connection or authority over authenticity.


📊 The Cost of Misalignment

This isn’t just a personal struggle—it’s an organizational issue.

  • 38% of new leaders fail within their first 18 months due to misalignment between expectations and preparedness (Center for Creative Leadership, 2023).
  • Only 40% of leaders report feeling effective in their roles (DDI, 2023 Global Leadership Forecast).
  • Just 12% of companies believe they have strong leadership pipelines.
  • Only 1 in 10 people naturally possess the talent to lead others effectively, yet most are promoted based on tenure, not readiness (Gallup, 2019).

In short, we’re equipping people to perform tasks—but not to lead teams. This misalignment creates burnout, disengagement, and missed potential at every level of an organization.


🔄 What We See Shapes What We Do

Let’s be honest: leadership isn’t always modeled well.

We see CEOs navigating crises, political leaders pointing fingers, supervisors reacting under stress, and businesses raising prices in tough times. These reactive, stress-based behaviors make an impression. Over time, we absorb them—and too often, we emulate them.

Why? Because under pressure, defaulting to “just do what I say” feels efficient. But true leadership isn’t about efficiency. It’s about effectiveness, empathy, and influence.

As Simon Sinek wisely said:

“Leadership is not about being in charge. It is about taking care of those in your charge.”

That kind of leadership demands self-awareness, emotional intelligence, and courage—not just charisma or control.


🔍 So Why Does Leadership Still Feel Foreign?

Because many leaders haven’t been given the space—or permission—to define leadership on their own terms.

Instead, we often:

  • Imitate others, assuming they know what they’re doing
  • Strive for perfection, rather than creating space for learning
  • Default to control, because it feels safer
  • Follow what we’ve seen, even if it no longer serves us

The result? Leadership begins to feel like a performance, not a practice.


🧭 Redefining Leadership—So It Feels Like Home

At 1LEAD, we believe leadership isn’t foreign. It’s just filtered—through perception, tradition, and pressure.

Real leadership emerges when you give yourself permission to lead from a place of alignment, not assumption.


✨ A Final Encouragement to Every Leader Reading This:

  • Don’t assume the easiest path is the right one
  • Don’t simply copy what you’ve seen—adapt, apply, fail, and grow
  • Don’t build walls—build bridges that invite collaboration
  • Don’t fake it—lead with authenticity


📩 Ready to align your leadership with who you truly are?

Let’s connect and help you uncover a leadership style that feels real, relevant, and results-driven.

🔗 www.1LEADconsulting.com 📧 Email: jasonwyatt@1leadconsulting.com

At 1LEAD, we help leaders shift from confusion to clarity—equipping them with tools, strategies, and coaching to lead from within and ignite lasting impact.


#LeadershipDevelopment #AuthenticLeadership #ExecutiveCoaching #1LEAD #JunkDrawerLeadership #LeadershipUnleashed #CoachingCulture #HRLeadership #TeamSuccess

To view or add a comment, sign in

Others also viewed

Explore topics