Why Pumps Leak When They’re Not Even Running

Understanding the Root Cause of Idle Leaks in Industrial Pumps

Leaks in pumps are often expected during operation, but what about when the equipment is completely still? It might seem harmless a few drops here and there but leaks that occur while the pump is off can be a warning sign. These are called static leaks, and while they're easy to miss, they often hint at deeper issues in your pump system.

In this article, I’ll break down why these leaks happen, where they typically come from, and most importantly, what you can do to prevent them. Whether you’re a hands-on technician or a seasoned reliability engineer, these insights can help you stay ahead of costly failures.

Leaks Don’t Wait for Operation

When a pump isn’t running, we assume it’s at rest no stress, no wear. But even in this idle state, several forces are at play: gravity, time, pressure differentials between process and atmosphere, and material fatigue.

Static leaks typically fall into two categories:

• Leaks through the pump casing or gaskets

• Leaks past the mechanical seal

Let's take a deeper look at both.

Casing and Gasket Leaks

Gaskets are designed to compress between two surfaces, forming a barrier that keeps fluids where they belong. But in idle pumps, the absence of internal pressure means there's less compression helping the gasket do its job. Combine that with time and environmental conditions, and problems start to creep in.

Common Causes

• Aged or Compressed Gaskets: Over time, elastomers can harden or take a permanent set, especially if they’ve been under compression without any relaxation cycles. This is made worse if the gasket material isn’t compatible with the chemicals or temperatures it’s exposed to. What starts as slight weeping can evolve into a visible leak.

• Worn Sealing Faces: Flange faces can corrode, pit, or become scratched due to poor maintenance practices, improper disassembly, or even overtightening bolts. Even tiny imperfections often invisible to the eye can break the seal, especially in low-pressure idle conditions.

• Loose or Uneven Bolt Tension: Thermal expansion and contraction cause bolts to lose torque over time. If the torque pattern isn’t balanced during installation, uneven loading can deform the flange or gasket, creating leak paths.

Expert Tip

Even stainless-steel fasteners can gall or lose strength if over-torqued. Use calibrated torque wrenches and anti-seize compounds where applicable.

What Professionals Should Do

• Use Torque Sequences: Follow cross-pattern torque sequences in multiple stages to ensure even pressure distribution. Consider retorquing bolts after the system has cooled down from its first heat cycle.

• Document Gasket Lifespan: Implement a gasket life tracking log. Knowing how long a specific gasket type lasts under your process conditions helps schedule proactive replacements before failure.

• Upgrade Material If Needed: If gaskets are repeatedly failing during idle periods, consider moving to a higher-grade material like expanded PTFE, graphite, or spiral-wound options with better creep resistance and chemical stability.

Mechanical Seal Leaks

Mechanical seals are designed to hold pressure and keep fluids contained at the pump shaft. They work using finely lapped, extremely flat faces in constant contact. But during idle periods, several challenges emerge.

Common Causes

• Elastomer Shrinkage or Chemical Attack: O-rings and secondary seals degrade in the presence of heat and aggressive chemicals. During downtime, without lubrication or movement, they may become brittle or lose contact pressure.

• Build-up Inside the Seal Chamber: Static fluids can allow solids or scale to settle between seal faces. On startup, these obstructions can scratch the faces or prevent full contact, making even a new seal fail prematurely.

• Seal Spring Relaxation: Springs inside the seal lose tension over time, especially under constant preload. This results in reduced closing force between faces, which is crucial when there's no internal pressure to assist sealing.

Expert Tip

Consider using cartridge seals with integrated flushing or quenching plans. These helps keep debris from settling during downtime and maintain a clean sealing environment.

What Professionals Should Do

• Disassemble and Inspect Annually (or more often): A clean seal doesn't mean a healthy seal. Look for signs like hardening, chalky residue, or even discoloration these are precursors to failure.

• Use Storage and Startup Protocols: For pumps that sit idle for long periods, rotate the shaft manually every few weeks to keep faces free from sticking and prevent elastomer compression-set. Prior to startup, consider a brief flush with clean fluid.

• Upgrade Seal Plan if Needed: API seal plans (e.g., Plan 62, Plan 23) can help mitigate idle leaks by maintaining environment control within the seal chamber. Discuss with your seal vendor which plan suits your application.

Go Beyond the Leak Ask Why

Fixing the leak is not the same as fixing the problem. Industry pros know that every leak is a symptom, not the root issue. Ask yourself:

• Was the seal exposed to temperatures outside its spec?

• Could the casing misalignment be causing gasket deformation?

• Are vibration or pressure fluctuations degrading components faster than expected?

Conducting a root cause analysis on even minor leaks can prevent larger failures. Idle pump leaks are often the canary in the coal mine they warn of deeper system-level issues.

The Bottom Line

A leaking idle pump may not seem urgent, but it is a clear sign of mechanical degradation. Left unresolved, it can lead to corrosion, contamination, equipment damage, and safety risks.

Proactive professionals use these signs to their advantage checking materials, verifying assembly practices, and reassessing maintenance schedules. When you stop thinking of leaks as “normal,” you start improving reliability at the source.

🔔 Subscribe to this newsletter for more practical, field-proven insights on pump performance and reliability.

💬 Got experience chasing down idle leaks? What worked or didn’t for you? Share your thoughts below and let’s build stronger systems together.

#PumpMaintenance #MechanicalSeals #StaticLeaks #IdlePumpFailures #GasketSelection #SealEngineering #MaintenanceStrategy #ReliabilityEngineering