Title:GRB 170817A-GW170817-AT 2017gfo and the observations of NS-NS and NS-WD mergers

Abstract:The LIGO-Virgo Collaboration has announced the detection GW170817 and associated it with GRB 1709817A observed by the Fermi satellite and with the kilonova AT 2017gfo. We compare and contrast in this article the gravitational-wave and the electromagnetic emission associated with the sources GW170817A-GRB 170817A-AT 2017gfo with the ones observed in neutron star-neutron star (NS-NS) mergers, leading to a massive NS (the short gamma-ray flashes -- S-GRFs), the ones leading to a black hole (the short gamma-ray bursts -- S-GRBs) and we also consider the case of NS-white dwarf mergers (NS-WD; the gamma-ray flashes -- GRFs). As a byproduct of our analysis, we evidence a possible kilonova signature in S-GRBs associated with GRB 090510A, after we recall the examples occurring in S-GRF and GRFs. We show that the gravitational-wave emission of GW170817A could be compatible with the ones expected from S-GRFs and GRFs, but their gamma- and X-ray emissions are incompatible. With respect to GRFs, neither the gravitational-wave emission nor the X and gamma-rays are compatible. The expected rate of the particular kilonova AT 2017gfo excludes its association with any of the above subclasses and points to the existence of a new subclass of less energetic, numerous systems with softer spectra, possibly leading to the formation of a single spinning NS.