Hacker News has collectively answered this question by consistently voting up the archive.is links in the comments of every paywalled article posted here.
New sites have collectively decided to require people use those services because they can't fathom not enshittifying everything until it's an unusable transaction hellscape.
I never really minded magazine ads or even television ads. They might have tried to make me associate boobs with a brand of soda but they didn't data mine my life and track me everywhere. I'd much rather have old fashioned manipulation than pervasive and dangerous surveillance capitalism.