I used to be nice. Not anymore. At least, I try hard NOT to be. What’s more, I don’t trust nice people—and neither should you. That’s because “nice” is not a trait; it’s a tactic. And it’s thin at best. Look, we’ve all done it! I’m a total people pleaser (read: Libra sun, Libra rising, Libra sleeping), and have defaulted to nice, which is what I was essentially trained to be. But nice is way, way overrated. It’s also conditional. Inconsistent. Moody, even. Insubstantial. A non-compliment. And it could be hurting you at work. In a piece in HR Executive, (“Stop being nice, start being kind: Why real connection at work matters”), Maria O'Keefe explains that being nice is part of our nature: “avoiding conflict, smoothing things over and keeping everyone comfortable.” But, she adds, this can backfire at work because “this well-intentioned niceness can actually hold people back and even sabotage progress.” What’s better than nice? Kind. As my friend and colleague Tara Cousineau, PhD, author of The Kindness Cure, has said many times, kindness is a practice that we all benefit from. How to know the difference? Nice is transactional (if you’re nice maybe you’ll get what you want). It’s also judgy. I know plenty of people who are “nice” but scratch the surface and you’ll find something else altogether. Nice is the lowest common denominator, right there along basic decency and courteousness; kindness requires honesty and courage. In The Gateless Method created by Suzanne Kingsbury, which I’ve taken in-house to teams and orgs of all stripes, the container is KEY. We’re not about being “nice,” but about highlighting and encouraging strength. This framework for creating, writing, collaborating, problem solving, requires kindness in order to adhere to the rules of the room. When we practice this method of generation and feedback, the room transforms; the energy shifts. People start to see their work and each other differently. They treat each other differently, and the effect is palpable: They’re more open, more vulnerable, more willing to share. And when you have begun to build a foundation of consistent kindness, you don’t have to worry about how to say something “nicely.” Because when people feel seen, heard, supported, they’re more open to the real conversations, the ones that require both kindness and courage. #kindness #vulnerability #connectionsatwork
Recovering pleaser here and this resonates!
Terri Trespicio Being honest (sincere, truthful, etc.) is better than being nice. However, you can be nice while being honest. But yeah, if that niceness comes with being sugary or saccharine-esque, the skeptical & cynical New Yorker in me comes out hard. As Dalton (played by the late great Patrick Swayze) said in his role in the great movie Road House, "I want you to be nice, until it's time to not be nice"
What is it the kiddos say… nice is beige, nice is basic? Nice is bland. It's fat free frozen vanilla yogurt—everything of interest has been stripped out. Love this distinction between nice and kindness.
Love the distinction. And so true. Btw a friend of mine spoke about this with her four co-hosts of their podcast “The 5 of Us” episode 38 / Feb 2024 if you’re interested.
LOVE this - have always disliked the word 'nice' - its so bland and non descriptive and reminds me of that type of person who says "have a blessed day" (but do they mean it??) Kindess rules.
What an important distinction - very well said!
Personality Branding for ambitious humans who actually want to sound like themselves on LinkedIn (and everywhere else) | Speaker | Will work for Bordeaux, Barolo, Barbera...
2wNo one has ever called me nice Terri Trespicio LOL - and it's a badge of honor. Not because there's anything wrong with it, but for the reason you explained, it's not a trait. Niceness never gets you noticed. And being nice isn't how you connect. Being real is. Being genuine. Curious. Inquisitive. Those beat nice any day of the week. #notnice