10 Things Every Producer Can Do to Begin Building a Niche This Summer

For years, producers were told to cast a wide net. “Go after anyone with a pulse and a premium” was the strategy. The thinking was simple: the more people you talk to, the more deals you’ll close. But that thinking no longer holds up in today’s complex, competitive, and commoditized marketplace.

Clients don’t want generalists. They want experts. They want someone who understands their business, their risks, and their industry inside and out. That’s why the most successful commercial insurance producers today are those who dominate a specific niche.

If you’ve been operating as a generalist but know you’re capable of more, this summer is your opportunity to make the pivot. Here are ten things every producer can do right now to start building a niche-focused book of business that will set them up for long-term success in Q4 and the new year.

1. Commit to Specializing in One Niche

Before you can build a niche, you have to make the decision to own one. This requires a mindset shift. Stop thinking like a jack-of-all-trades and start thinking like a specialist who solves very specific problems for a very specific industry.

Look at your current book. Are there clusters of similar accounts? Are there certain industries where you already have a win or two under your belt? Maybe you’ve had more traction with HVAC contractors, social service organizations, or logistics companies.

Pick one niche and commit to learning everything about it. You don’t have to have 100 clients in that space to get started—you just need to decide that this is where you’re going to focus.

2. Study the Industry Inside and Out

Once you’ve selected a niche, you need to learn it like an insider. That means going beyond just knowing what coverage forms apply. You should understand how they make money, where they lose money, what keeps their executives up at night, and what compliance issues they struggle with.

Use the summer to do a deep dive. Read trade publications. Join industry associations. Follow thought leaders on LinkedIn. Subscribe to podcasts and YouTube channels in the space. Study OSHA citations and loss trends for the vertical. Learn their vocabulary so you can speak their language fluently in meetings.

The more you understand the industry, the more valuable your insights will be when you get in front of a prospect.

3. Build a Hit List of Ideal Prospects

Now that you know who you want to serve and what matters to them, it’s time to create a focused list of target accounts.

Start local. Pull lists from your CRM, LinkedIn Sales Navigator, your local Chamber of Commerce, or tools like ReferenceUSA. Look for companies that fit your ideal profile—industry, employee count, revenue range, and renewal timeline.

Keep your list manageable. Focus on 50 to 100 high-probability accounts you can go deep on. Research each one individually. Know who the decision-makers are, when their policies renew, and how you might approach them with insight rather than a quote.

Your niche hit list is your new territory. Own it.

4. Develop a Niche-Focused Value Proposition

Generalists talk about coverages. Niche producers talk about solving specific business problems for specific types of clients.

Craft a short, powerful positioning statement that communicates your value to this niche. For example:

“We help plumbing contractors reduce jobsite injury costs and avoid audit surprises by implementing proactive risk management programs before renewal.”

Your value proposition should make it crystal clear who you serve, how you help, and why it matters. This becomes the foundation of your email scripts, your marketing drops, your social media content, and your cold calls.

If you want to be seen as the go-to expert, your message needs to sound like one.

5. Start Creating Content That Speaks to Your Niche

Summer is the ideal time to start building a content library that will establish your expertise.

Write blog posts that answer the questions your niche is asking. Record short videos explaining common coverage gaps, risk issues, or compliance changes. Create downloadable checklists, safety guides, or claim prevention resources tailored to your industry of focus.

You don’t need to be a marketing expert to do this. Just speak from your growing knowledge and experience. The goal is to show up consistently as someone who understands the challenges your prospects face and has practical solutions.

By the time Q4 rolls around, your name should already be showing up in their inbox, LinkedIn feed, or Google search results.

6. Leverage Existing Clients as Case Studies and Connectors

If you already have one or two clients in the niche, use them as anchors.

Ask if you can write a case study highlighting the results you’ve helped them achieve. Feature that story in your prospecting outreach and on your website or social channels. Better yet, ask for an introduction to someone else in their network—many industries are tightly connected.

You can also ask for testimonials or host a recorded Q&A session with the client where they talk about how working with a niche-focused advisor made a difference.

One happy client can open the door to ten more when you’re committed to dominating a specific industry.

7. Customize Your Sales Process for the Niche

Your sales process should evolve as you specialize. Instead of leading with a BOR or quote, lead with a risk assessment or business review tailored to the niche.

For example, if you’re targeting manufacturing companies, create a risk scorecard that evaluates common exposures like machine guarding, ergonomic practices, subcontractor agreements, and Mod accuracy. If you’re targeting restaurants, focus on food safety protocols, EPLI exposure, and third-party delivery risks.

When your sales process feels customized to the industry, prospects are far more likely to trust that you understand their world.

Use the summer to build the tools, questionnaires, and deliverables that support this tailored approach.

8. Partner with Industry Vendors and Associations

Niche producers are not just better at selling insurance—they’re better at building ecosystems.

Reach out to accountants, attorneys, payroll providers, equipment vendors, or consultants who also serve your target vertical. Explore ways to cross-refer, co-host events, or share insights. If there’s a local or regional trade association, become a member or even a sponsor.

The more you immerse yourself in the ecosystem your clients live in, the more visible and credible you become.

These partnerships often lead to faster trust, higher-quality referrals, and deeper insight into what your clients actually need.

9. Use Summer to Create a Niche Prospecting Campaign

Rather than just making cold calls or sending random emails, use your niche focus to design an intentional summer prospecting campaign.

Here’s a simple example of a 30-day niche campaign:

• Week 1: Send a personalized letter or niche-specific leave-behind

• Week 2: Follow up with a call offering a free risk assessment or Mod analysis

• Week 3: Send a piece of content you created that’s relevant to their business

• Week 4: Stop by in person with a second piece of industry insight

Document your outreach, track your responses, and set appointments for deeper conversations in September or October. The key is consistency and relevance.

10. Plan for Q4 and Q1 Appointments Now

The real power of a niche strategy is in its compounding effect. When you show up as an expert in Q4, people remember. When you follow up in Q1 with case studies, custom solutions, and insights tailored to their industry, people take action.

But this kind of momentum does not happen by accident. You need to plan for it.

Use the summer to preload your calendar with appointments in Q4 and early Q1. Set up risk assessments, drop-bys, or educational webinars. Let your prospects know you specialize in their space and that now is the perfect time to get ahead of renewal season.

The producers who dominate Q4 are the ones who used their summer to build systems, sharpen positioning, and focus their activity.

Final Thoughts: This Summer, Become the Expert

Becoming a niche producer is not just about selling more insurance. It is about changing the way you operate. It is about moving from transaction to transformation—from quoting to consulting.

The summer is your opportunity to make that shift. While generalists spin their wheels chasing anything that moves, you can spend these next few months building the foundation for long-term success in one vertical.

Pick a niche. Learn it. Own it. Serve it better than anyone else.

And when the fourth quarter hits, you will not be the agent making cold calls. You will be the expert your prospects are already watching.

If you found this information useful, please consider subscribing and sharing with your peers. I publish a new edition of The Revenue Roadmap each Tuesday morning.