SlideShare a Scribd company logo
C h a p t e r Three
Transportation and Assignment Problem
3.1.Transportation problem
 One important application of linear programming is the
area of physical distribution (transportation) of goods
from several supply centers (origins) to several demand
centers (destinations).
 Transportation problem involves a large number of
variables (transportation/shipping routes) and constraints,
it takes along time to solve it.
 Therefore, other methods (transportation algorithm)
havebeen developed for this purpose.




Objective:
amount of
the objective
commodities
is to determine the
which should be
transpor ted from several sources to different
destinations, atthe minimum transportation
cost and /or time.
Sources or origins are the places where goods
originate from (like plants,warehouses etc)
Destinations are placeswhere goods are to be shipped.
It can also be applied to the maximization of some total
value or utility,in such awaythatthe profit is maximized.
3.1.1. GeneralTransportation
Problem Model
The transportation algorithm requires the
assumptions that:
All goods are homogeneous, so that anyoriginis
capableofsupplyingtoanydestination.
Transportation costs are alinear function of (or
directlyproportionalto) the quantity shipped over
any route.
Each sourcehas a fixedsupplyofunits,where this
entire supply must be distributed to the
destinations.
Similarly, each destination has a fixed demand for
units, where this entire demand must be received
from the sources.
A transportation problem model, which has ‘m’ sending
locations (origins) and ‘n’ receiving locations
(destinations), provides a framework for presenting all
relevant data. These are:
Quantity supply of each origin (SSi)
Quantity demand of each destination (DDi)
Unit transportation cost from each origin to each
destination (Cij)
Where:
SSi -istotalquantityofcommodityavailableatoriginI
(totalsupplyoforigini).
ddj-istotalquantityofcommoditiesneededat
destinations j(total demand of destination j).
Cij -measures thecostsoftransportingoneunitof
commodityfromsourceitodestinationj.
Xij -isthequantityofcommoditiestransportedfrom
ithorigintojthdestination.
The Linear ProgrammingRepresentation of a
Transportation Model
Minimize (total transportation cost)
Z=C11X11+C12X12+C13X13+….+CmnXmn
Subject to:
Capacity constraints (SS constraints)
X11+X12+----+X1n=SS1
X21+X22+----+X2n=SS2
. . . .
. . . .
Xm1+Xm2+.---+Xmn=SSm
Requirements constraints (DD constraint)
X11+X21+----+Xm1=SS1
X21+X22+----+Xm2=SS2
. . . .
. . .
. . .
.
.
Xn1+Xn2+.---+Xnm=SSn
Xij ≥ 0 for all i and j
Before applying the transportation techniques
(methods) to solve a specific problem, the
problem should satisfy the following
conditions.
Supplies(SS)and requirements(DD) must be
expressed in the same unit.
Thisconditionmeansthatshipmentsreceivedatany
destinationfromdifferentsources mustbe
indistinguishable.
In otherwords,allshipmentmustbemeasuredin
homogenous units.
T
otalsupplymustequaltototaldemand∑SS= ∑DD
Theproblemsatisfyingthisconditioniscalled
balanced transportation problem; otherwiseitis
knownas unbalanced transportation problem.
The condition ∑SS= ∑DD isthenecessary and
sufficient condition fortheexistenceoffeasible
solutiontothetransportation problem.
5.1.2. Methods of Solving
Transportation Problem
Methods to get the initial solution: even if
there are different methods of such types, the
following three common methods can be used.
The North-West Corner Method
(NWC)
Minimum cost method (MCM), and
The Vogel’sApproximationMethod
(VAM).
1.North West Corner method
1st. Balance the problem.That isseewhetherΣDD =
ΣSS.
 If not open a dummy column or dummy row
as the case maybe and balance the problem.
2nd. Allocate as much as possible to the selected
cell,and adjust the associated amounts of supply
and demand by subtracting the allocated amount.
Since :The method starts at the northwest-corner
cell (route) of the tableau (variable X11).
3rd. Cross out the row or column with zero supply
or demand to indicate that no further
assignments can be made in that row or column.
If both arow and acolumn net to zero
simultaneously, crossoutoneonly
,and leaveazero
supply (demand) in the uncrossed-out row
(column).
4th Ifexactlyonerow or column is leftuncrossed
out,stop.
Otherwise, move to the cell to the right ifacolumn
has just been crossed out or below ifarow has
been crossed out. Go to step 1.
5th Make sure that allthe rim conditions are satisfied
and (m+n-1) cells are allocated.
6th Once allthe allocations are over
,i.e.,bothrim
requirement(columnandrowi.e.,availabilityand
requirement constraints) are satisfied, write
allocations and calculate the cost of
transportation.
Example 1.
Let us consider an example atthis juncture to
illustrate the application of NWC rule
To
From
D1 D2 D3 Total supply
S1 X11 5 X12 6 X13 7 70
S2 X21 4 X22 2 X32 5 30
S3 X31 1 X32 5 X33 4 50
Total Demand 65 42 43 150
150
ΣDD = ΣSS .The North West Cornercell X11 is chosen for
allocation..
The origin S1 has 70 items and the destination D1
requires only 65 items.
Hence it is enough to allot65 itemsfrom S1 toD1.
The origin S1 which is alivewith 5 more items can
supply to the destination to the right is alivewith
5 moreitemscan supplyto the destination to the
right of D1 namely D2 whose requirement is 42. So,
we supply 5 itemstoD2 therebytheoriginS1 is
exhausted.
D2 requires 37 items more. Now consider the
origin S2 that has 30 items to spare.We allot 30
itemstothecell(X22) so that the origin S2 is
exhausted.
Then, move to origin S3 and supply 7 more items
to the destination D2. Now the requirement of the
destination D2 is complete and S3 isleft with 43
items and the same can be allotted to the
destination D3.
Now the origin S3 is emptied and the requirement
atthe destination D3 is also complete.This
completes the initial solution to the problem
To
From
D1 D2 D3 Total supply
S1 65 5 5 6 7 70
S2 4 30 2 5 30
S3 1 7 5 43 4 50
Total Demand 65 42 43
150
150
The total cost of transportation by this method will be:
(65 × 5) + (5 × 6) + (30 × 2) + (7 × 5) + (43× 4) = 325 + 30 + 60 + 35
+ 172 = 622.
Example 2.
To
From
X Y Z Dummy Availability
A 7 4 3 3 2 0 10
B
5 8 6 1 0 8
C
6 1 4 4 3 0 5
D
3 5
1 4
5
0
6
Requirement 7 12 5 5 29
The total cost of transportation by this method will be:
(7x4)+(3x3)+(8x6)+(1x4)+(4x3)+(1x4)+(5x0) = 105
Tra
nsp
orta
tion
-20
Example 3
Destination
Supply
Source N S E W
A
16 13 22 17
200
100 100
B
14 13 19 15
350
40 300 10
C
9 20 23 10
150
150
Dummy
0 0 0 0
90
90
Demand 100 140 300 250
Z = 10770
2.Least-Cost Method
Steps in Least-Cost Method:
Step 1: Determine the least cost among all the
rows of the transportation table.
Step 2: Identify the row and allocate the
maximum feasible quantity in the cell
corresponding to the least cost in the row.
Then eliminate that row (column) when an
allocation is made.
Step 3:Repeat steps 1 and 2 for the reduced
transportation table until allthe available quantities
are distributed to the required places.
If the minimum cost is not unique, the tie can be
broken arbitrarily.
Step 4: Make sure that allthe rim conditions are
satisfied and (m+n-1) cells are allocated.
To
From
D1 D2 D3 Total supply
S1 5 7 8 70
S2 4 4 6 30
S3 6 7 7 50
Total Demand 65 42 43 150
150
We examine the rows S1, S2 and S3, 4 istheleast
costelementinthecell(S2, D1)and
(S2, D2) and the tie can be brokenarbitrarily.Select
(S2,D1).
The originS2 can supply30 itemstoD1 andthus
originS2 is exhausted.
D1 stillrequires35 moreunits.Hence, shade the row
S2. Shading S2, we observe that 5 istheleastelement
inthecell(S1, D1) and examine the supply atS1 and
demand at D1.
The destination D1 requires 35 itemsand this
requirementissatisfiedfromS1 so that the column D1
is shaded next.
Next, we choose 7 as leastelementcorrespondingto
thecell(S1, D2).
We supply35 unitsfromS1 toD2. Now, only one row
is left behind.
Hence, weallow7 itemsfromS3 toD2 and43 itemsS3
to D3.
To
From
D1 D2 D3 Total supply
S1 35 5 35 7 8 70
S2 30 4 4 6 30
S3 6 7 7 43 7 50
Total Demand 65 42 43
150
150
The cost of the allocation by the least cost method is
(35 x 5) + (35 x 7) + (30 x 4) + (7 x 7) + (43 x 7) = 890
Example 2
T
o (A)
Albuquerque
(B)
Boston
(C)
Cleveland
(D) Des Moines
(E) Evansville
(F) Fort Lauder
Warehouse
requirement 300 200 200
Factory
capacity
300
300
100
700
$5
$5
$4
$4
$3
$3
$9
$8
$7
From
100
First, $3 is the lowest cost cell so ship 100 units fromDes
Moines to Cleveland and cross off the first row as Des
Moines is satisfied
Figure C.4
© 2011 Pearson Education
T
o (A)
Albuquerque
(B)
Boston
(C)
Cleveland
(D) Des Moines
(E) Evansville
(F) Fort Lauderdale
Warehouse
requirement 300 200 200
Factory
capacity
300
300
100
700
$5
$5
$4
$4
$3
$3
$9
$8
$7
From
100
100
Second, $3 is again the lowest cost cell so ship 100 units
from Evansville to Cleveland and cross off column C as
Cleveland is satisfied
Figure C.4
© 2011 Pearson Education
T
o (A)
Albuquerque
(B)
Boston
(C)
Cleveland
(D) Des Moines
(E) Evansville
(F) Fort Lauderdale
Warehouse
requirement 300 200 200
Factory
capacity
300
300
100
700
$5
$5
$4
$4
$3
$3
$9
$8
$7
From
100
100
200
Third, $4 is the lowest cost cell soship 200 units from
Evansville to Boston and cross off column B and row E as
Evansville and Boston are satisfied
Figure C.4
© 2011 Pearson Education
T
o (A)
Albuquerque
(B)
Boston
(C)
Cleveland
(D) Des Moines
(E) Evansville
(F) Fort Lauderdale
Warehouse
requirement 300 200 200
Factory
capacity
300
300
100
700
$5
$5
$4
$4
$3
$3
$9
$8
$7
From
100
100
200
300
Finally,ship 300 units fromAlbuquerque to Fort Lauder
as this is the only remaining cell to completethe
allocations
Figure C.4
© 2011 Pearson Education
T
o (A)
Albuquerque
(B)
Boston
(C)
Cleveland
(D) Des Moines
(E) Evansville
(F) Fort Lauderdale
Warehouse
requirement 300 200 200
Factory
capacity
300
300
100
700
$5
$5
$4
$4
$3
$3
$9
$8
$7
From
100
100
200
300
Total Cost
Figure C.4
© 2011 Pearson Education
= $3(100) + $3(100) + $4(200) + $9(300)
= $4,100
3.Vogel Approximation Method
Steps inVAM:
Step 1: For each row (column), determine apenalty measure
by subtractingthesmallestunitcostelementintherow(column)
fromthenextsmallestunitcostelementinthesamerow
(column).
Step 2: Identify the row or column withthelargestpenalty.If
there isa tie (equal penalty) it can be broken by selectingthe
cellwheremaximumallocationcan bemade.
Allocate as much as possible to thevariablewiththeleastunit
costintheselectedrowor column.
Adjustthesupplyand demand,and crossoutthesatisfiedrowor
column.
If arow and acolumn are satisfied simultaneously, only one of
the two is crossed out, and the remaining row (column) is
assigned zero supply (demand).
Step 3:
(a)Ifexactlyoneroworcolumnwithzerosupply
ordemandremainsuncrossed out,stop.
(b)Ifonerow(column)withpositivesupply
(demand)remainsuncrossedout,determinethe
basicvariablesintherow(column)bytheleast-
costmethod. Stop.
(c)Ifalltheuncrossedoutrowsandcolumnshave
(remaining)zerosupplyanddemand,determine
thezerobasicvariablesbytheleast-costmethod.
Stop.
(d) Otherwise,gotostep 1.
Step 4: Make sure that alltherimconditionsare
satisfied and cellsareallocated.
To
From
D1 D2 D3 Total
supply
Row penalty
S1 65 5 5 7 8 70 2 2(ii) 1(iii) 0
S2 4 30 4 6 30 0 0 0 0
S3
6 7 7 43 7 50 1 1 0 0
Total
Demand
65 42 43 150
Column
penalty
1 3(i) 1
1 0 1
0 0 1
The cost of allocation (i.e., the associated objective value) by Vogel's
Approximation Method will be: (65× 5) + (5× 7) + (30 × 4) + (7 × 7) + (43× 7) =
325 + 35 +120 + 49 + 301 = 830.
The differencebetweenthesmallestand nexttothe
smallestelementineach rowand ineach columnis
calculated.
We choose the maximum from among the
differences.
The first individual allocation will be to the
smallest cost of a row or column with the
largest difference.
So we select the column D2 (penalty = 3) for the first
individual allocation, and allocate to (S2, D2) as much
as we can,since this cell has the least cost location.
Thus 30 units from S2 are allocated to D2.This exhausts
the supply from S2. However
, there is still a demand of
12 unitsfrom D2.
The allocations to other cells in that column are 0.The
next step is to cross out row S2 (as it is exhausted).
The next largest unit difference corresponds to the
row S1.This leads to an allocation in the corresponding
minimumcostlocationinrowS1, namelycell(S1, D1).
The maximum possible allocation is only 65 as required
byW1 fromS1 and allocation of 0 to others in the row
S1. Column D1 is thus crossed out.
Maximum difference is 1 in row S3 and in column D3.
Select arbitrarily S3 and allot the least cost cell (S1, D2)
5 units. Cross out row S1 for it is alreadyexhausted.
Now, we haveonly one row S3 and two columns D2
and D3 indicating that the entire availableamount from
S3 has to be moved to D2 and D3 as per their
requirements.
T
ra
Vogel’sMethod (1): calculate differences
Destination
nsp
orta
tion
-37
Supply diff
Source N S E W
A
16 13 22 17
200 3
B
14 13 19 15
350 1
C
9 20 23 10
150 1
Dummy
0 0 0 0
90 0
Demand 100 140 300 250
diff 9 13 19 10
T
ra
Vogel’
s Method (2):select xDummyE as basic
variable
Supply diff
Source N
Destination
S E W
Demand 100 140 300 250
diff 9 13 19 10
A
16 13 22 17
200 3
B
14 13 19 15
350 1
C
9 20 23 10
150 1
Dummy
0 0 0 0
90 0
90
nsp
orta
tion
-38
Vogel’sMethod (3): update supply,demand
and differences
Destination
Supply diff
Source N S E W
A
16 13 22 17
200 3
B
14 13 19 15
350 1
C
9 20 23 10
150 1
Dummy
0 0 0
90
0
--- ---
Demand 100 140 210 250
diff 5 0 3 5 Tra
nsp
orta
tion
-39
Vogel’
s Method (4):select xCN as basic variable
Destination
Supply diff
Source N S E W
A
16 13 22 17
200 3
B
14 13 19 15
350 1
C
9
100
20 23 10
150 1
Dummy
0 0 0
90
0
--- ---
Demand 100 140 210 250
diff 5 0 3 5 Tra
nsp
orta
tion
-40
Vogel’sMethod (5): update supply,demand
and differences
Destination
Supply diff
Source N S E W
A
16 13 22 17
200 4
B
14 13 19 15
350 2
C
9
100
20 23 10
50 10
Dummy
0 0 0
90
0
--- ---
Demand --- 140 210 250
diff --- 0 3 5 Tra
nsp
orta
tion
-41
Vogel’
s Method (6):select xCW as basic
variable
Destination
Supply diff
Source N S E W
A
16 13 22 17
200 4
B
14 13 19 15
350 2
C
9
100
20 23 10
50
50 10
Dummy
0 0 0
90
0
--- ---
Demand --- 140 210 250
diff --- 0 3 5 Tra
nsp
orta
tion
-42
Vogel’sMethod (7): update supply,demand
and differences
Destination
Supply diff
Source N S E W
A
16 13 22 17
200 4
B
14 13 19 15
350 2
C
9
100
20 23 10
50
--- ---
Dummy
0 0 0
90
0
--- ---
Demand --- 140 210 200
diff --- 0 3 2 Tra
nsp
orta
tion
-43
Vogel’
s Method (8):select xAS as basic
variable
Destination
Supply diff
Source N S E W
A
16 13
140
22 17
200 4
B
14 13 19 15
350 2
C
9
100
20 23 10
50
--- ---
Dummy
0 0 0
90
0
--- ---
Demand --- 140 210 200
diff --- 0 3 2 Tra
nsp
orta
tion
-44
Vogel’sMethod (9): update supply,demand
and differences
Destination
Supply diff
Source N S E W
A
16 13
140
22 17
60 5
B
14 13 19 15
350 4
C
9
100
20 23 10
50
--- ---
Dummy
0 0 0
90
0
--- ---
Demand --- --- 210 200
diff --- --- 3 2 Tra
nsp
orta
tion
-45
Vogel’
s Method (10):select xAW as basic
variable
Destination
Supply diff
Source N S E W
A
16 13
140
22 17
60 60 5
B
14 13 19 15
350 4
C
9
100
20 23 10
50
--- ---
Dummy
0 0 0
90
0
--- ---
Demand --- --- 210 200
diff --- --- 3 2 Tra
nsp
orta
tion
-46
Vogel’sMethod (11): update supply,demand
and differences
Destination
Supply diff
Source N S E W
A
16 13
140
22 17
60 --- ---
B
14 13 19 15
350 4
C
9
100
20 23 10
50
--- ---
Dummy
0 0 0
90
0
--- ---
Demand --- --- 210 140
diff --- --- Tra
nsp
orta
tion
-47
Vogel’
s Method (12):select xBW and xBE as
basic variables
Destination
Supply diff
Source N S E W
A
16 13
140
22 17
60 --- ---
B
14 13 19
210
15
140 ---
C
9
100
20 23 10
50
--- ---
Dummy
0 0 0
90
0
--- ---
Demand --- --- --- ---
diff --- ---
Z = 10330
Tra
nsp
orta
tion
-48
3.2.Assignment problem
In many business situations, management
needs to assign - personnel to jobs, - jobs
to machines, - machines to job locations,
or - salespersons to territories.
Consider the situation of assigning n jobston
machines.
When ajob i (=1,2,....,n)is assigned to
machine j(=1,2, .....n)that incurs acost Cij.
The objective is to assign the jobs to
machines at the least possible total cost.
This situation is aspecial case of the
transportation model and it is known as the
assignment problem.
Here, jobs represent “sources”and
machines represent“destinations.”
The supplyavailableateach sourceis1 unitand
demand at each destination is 1 unit.
Formulation/construction of the
model
The assignment model can be expressed mathematically as
follows:
Xij= 0, ifthejobjisnotassignedtomachine i
1,ifthejobjisassignedtomachine I
Now the problem is which work isto be assigned to whom
so that the cost of completion of work will be minimum.
To minimize z (cost)
where xij =
1; if ith person is assigned jthwork
0; if ith person is not assigned the jthwork
i.e., ith person will doonly one work.
i.e., jth work will be done only by oneperson.
Example
A farm produce different agricultural products and that
Products are manufactured on five different assembly lines
(1,2,3,4,5).
When manufacturing is finished, products are transported from
the assembly lines to one of the five different potential customers
(A,B,C,D,E).
Transporting products from five assembly lines to five inspection
areas requires different times (in minutes)
potential customers
Methods of solvingAP
(The Hungarian Method)
In order to find the proper assignment itis
essential for us to know the Hungarian method.
Step I
(A) Row reduction:
Select the smallest value in each row.
Subtract this value from each value in that row in
the cost matrix.
(B) Column reduction:
After completion of row reduction, subtract the
minimum entry of each column from all the
entries of the respective column.
Step II
Zero assignment:
(A) Starting with first row of the matrix received in
first step,examine the rows one byone until a
row containing exactly one zero is found.
 Then an experimental assignment indicated
by‘ ’ismarked to that zero.
 Now cross all the zeros in the column in which
the assignment is made.
 Cross out zero, if there are other zero in ether
column or row.
 This procedure should be adopted for each
row assignment.
(B) When the rows has been
completely an identical
procedure is
set of
examined,
applied successively to
columns.
Starting with column 1, examine all
columns until a column containing
exactly one zero is found.
Then makean experimentalassignmentinthat
position and
Cross otherzeros intherowinwhichthe
assignmentwas made.
Continue these successive operations on rows and
columns until all zero’shave either been
assigned or corssed-out.
Now there are two possibilities:
(a)Either all the zeros are assigned or crossed
out, i.e.,we get the maximal assignment.
or
(b)At least two zeros are remained by
assignment or bycrossing out in each row or
column.
In this situation we try to exclude some of the
zeros bytrial and error method.
This completes the second step.
After this step we can get two situations.
(i) Totalassigned zero’s= n
The assignment is optimal.
(ii)Totalassigned zero’s< n
Use step III and onwards.
Since n= # of assignments
Step III
Draw of minimum lines to cover zero’s :
In order to cover all the zero’sat least
once you may adopt the following
procedure.
(i)Marks (√) to allrows in which the assignment
has not been done.
(ii) See thepositionofzeroinmarked(√) rowand then
mark (√) to the corresponding column.
(iii)See the marked (√) column and find the
position of assigned zero’sand then mark (√) to
thecorrespondingrowswhicharenotmarked tillnow
.
(iv)Repeattheprocedure(ii)and (iii)tillthecompletion
of marking.
(v)Draw the lines through unmarkedrowsand
marked columns.
Note: If the above method does not work then
make an arbitraryassignmentandthenfollowstepIV
.
Step IV
Select the smallest element from the uncovered
elements :
(i)Subtract this smallest element from all those
elements which are not covered.
(ii)Add this smallest element to all those
elements which are at the intersection of two
lines.
Step V
Thus we haveincreasedthenumberof zero’s.
Now, modifythematrixwiththehelpofstepII and
findtherequired assignment.
Finally calculate the total minimized cost by
summing up numbers from the original table
Example 1.
Four persons A,B,C and D are to be assigned four
jobs I, II, III and IV
. The cost matrix is given as
under
, find the proper assignment.
Man
Jobs
A B C D
I 8 10 17 9
II 3 8 5 6
III 10 12 11 9
IV 6 13 9 7
Solution :
In order to find the proper assignment we apply the
Hungarian algorithm as follows:
I (A) Row reduction
Man
A B C D
Jobs
I 0 2 9 1
II 0 5 2 3
III 1 3 2 0
IV 0 7 3 1
Man
Jobs
A B C D
I 0 0 7 1
II 0 3 0 3
III 1 1 0 0
IV 0 5 1 1
I (B) Column reduction
II Zero assignment:
Man
Jobs
A B C D
I 0 0 7 1
II 0 3 0 3
III 1 1 0 0
IV 0 5 1 1
In this way allthe zero’s are either crossed out or assigned. Also
total assigned zero’s = 4 (i.e.,number of rows or columns).
Thus, the assignment is optimal.
From the table we get:
I B;
II. C:
III. D and
IV A. T
otal minimized cost = 10+5+9+6= 30
Example 2:
There are five machines and five jobs are to be
assigned and the associated cost matrix is as
follows. Find the proper assignment.
machines
Jobs
I II III IV V
A 6 12 3 11 15
B 4 2 7 1 10
C 8 11 10 7 11
D 16 19 12 23 21
E 9 5 7 6 10
Solution:
In order to find the proper assignment, we apply the
Hungarian method as follows:
I A (Rowreduction)
machines
Jobs
I II III IV V
A 3 9 0 8 12
B 3 1 6 0 9
C 1 4 3 0 4
D 4 7 0 11 9
E 4 0 2 1 5
machines
J
obs
I II III IV V
A 2 9 0 8 8
B 2 1 6 0 5
C 0 4 3 0 0
D 3 7 0 11 5
E 3 0 2 1 1
II (Zero assignment)
IB (Column reduction) machines
I II III IV V
A 2 9 0 8 8
Jobs
B 2 1 6 0 5
C 0 4 3 0 0
D 3 7 0 11 5
E 3 0 2 1 1
From the last table we see that allthe zeros are
either assigned or crossed out, butthetotalnumber
ofassignment,i.e.,4<5 (numberofjobstobeassigned
to machines).
Therefore, we haveto follow step III and onwards
as follows:
machines
I II III √ 2nd IV V
A 2 9 0 8 8 √3rd
Jobs
B 2 1 6 0 5
C 0 4 3 0 0
D 3 7 0 11 5 √ 1st
E 3 0 2 1 1
Step IV:Here, the smallest element among the uncovered
elements is 2.
(i)Subtract 2 from all those elements which are not
covered.
(ii)Add 2 to those entries which are at the
junction(intersection ) of two lines.
Make as it is rows that pass single line .
machines
Jobs
I II III IV V
A 0 7 0 6 6
B 2 1 8 0 5
C 0 4 5 0 0
D 1 5 0 9 3
E 3 0 4 1 1
Step V.using step II again
machines
Jobs
I II III IV V
A 0 7 0 6 6
B 2 1 8 0 5
C 0 4 5 0 0
D 1 5 0 9 3
E 3 0 4 1 1
Thus, we have got five assignments as required bythe
problem.
The assignment is as follows:
A I, B  IV, C V,D  III and E  II.
Thus from
the cost matrix the minimum cost = 6+1+11+12+5=35.
START
Construct the effectiveness matrix if not already given
Row reduction
Column reduction
Is zero assignment
possible
(i) Draw minimum number of lines to cover
all the zeros
(ii)Choose the least uncovered element
(iii)Subtract this from the uncovered
elements and add it to the elements at
intersection of the lines.
ASSIGNMENT
Put square over the zero and
cross out all zeros (if any) of
the corresponding column.
SOLUTION
Add the elements of the given
matrix correspond to each
square from original table
STOP
Is Zero
assignment
Possible
Y
es
No
No
Y
es

More Related Content

DOCX
Persamaan Diferensial
PDF
Drawing specs bio seven septic tank (bfs series)
DOCX
Ekonomi teknik 1
PDF
unit2 linear programming problem in .pdf
PDF
unit-5 Transportation problem in operation research ppt.pdf
PDF
Unit.5. transportation and assignment problems
PPTX
Transportation, Transshipment and Assignment Problem.pptx
DOCX
OR 14 15-unit_2
Persamaan Diferensial
Drawing specs bio seven septic tank (bfs series)
Ekonomi teknik 1
unit2 linear programming problem in .pdf
unit-5 Transportation problem in operation research ppt.pdf
Unit.5. transportation and assignment problems
Transportation, Transshipment and Assignment Problem.pptx
OR 14 15-unit_2

Similar to OR CH 3 Transportation and assignment problem.pptx (20)

PPTX
4 Tranportation Proplem Final 1 special notes
PPT
Bba 3274 qm week 9 transportation and assignment models
PPT
Transportation problem
PPTX
AUG19-22-UNIT 3 - Transportation and Assignment Problems_2022.pptx
PDF
A NEW APPROACH FOR SOLVING TRANSPORTATION PROBLEM
PPTX
Deepika(14 mba5012) transportation ppt
PPTX
QABD Transportation problems-UNIT-3.pptx
PPTX
LP network chapter 5 transportation and assignment problem
PPTX
03-Unit Three -OR.pptx
PDF
Lecture (3) _transportation problem31-10-2020.pdf
DOC
Transportation and assignment_problem
PPS
Greedy Algorithms with examples' b-18298
PPT
Transportation winston
PPT
Top school in delhi ncr
PPTX
07. Transportation Problem.pptx
PPTX
Transportation Problem in Decision Science.pptx
PPT
Transportation problem. supply chain managementppt
PPT
Operations Research
PPT
Operations Research
PDF
Transportation problems in operation research.pdf
4 Tranportation Proplem Final 1 special notes
Bba 3274 qm week 9 transportation and assignment models
Transportation problem
AUG19-22-UNIT 3 - Transportation and Assignment Problems_2022.pptx
A NEW APPROACH FOR SOLVING TRANSPORTATION PROBLEM
Deepika(14 mba5012) transportation ppt
QABD Transportation problems-UNIT-3.pptx
LP network chapter 5 transportation and assignment problem
03-Unit Three -OR.pptx
Lecture (3) _transportation problem31-10-2020.pdf
Transportation and assignment_problem
Greedy Algorithms with examples' b-18298
Transportation winston
Top school in delhi ncr
07. Transportation Problem.pptx
Transportation Problem in Decision Science.pptx
Transportation problem. supply chain managementppt
Operations Research
Operations Research
Transportation problems in operation research.pdf
Ad

More from AbdiMuceeTube (13)

PPTX
Fundamentals of Accounting II, Chapter 3 payroll.pptx
PPTX
New Microsoft PowerPoint Presentation.pptx
PPTX
Chapter-1-Capital Structure Policy and Leverage.pptx
PPT
16450253.ppt
PPTX
04-Unit Four - OR.pptx
PPT
370_13735_EA221_2010_1__1_1_Linear programming 1.ppt
PDF
OR_L03.pdf
PPTX
Chapter 4 Audit of acquisition and payment cycle.pptx
PPTX
PPT-Introduction to Economics last-1.pptx
PPTX
adv ass.pptx
DOCX
TP AUDITContents.docx
DOCX
government-accounting-1.docx
PPTX
CH-1 Advanced FA .pptx
Fundamentals of Accounting II, Chapter 3 payroll.pptx
New Microsoft PowerPoint Presentation.pptx
Chapter-1-Capital Structure Policy and Leverage.pptx
16450253.ppt
04-Unit Four - OR.pptx
370_13735_EA221_2010_1__1_1_Linear programming 1.ppt
OR_L03.pdf
Chapter 4 Audit of acquisition and payment cycle.pptx
PPT-Introduction to Economics last-1.pptx
adv ass.pptx
TP AUDITContents.docx
government-accounting-1.docx
CH-1 Advanced FA .pptx
Ad

Recently uploaded (20)

PDF
4a Probability-of-Failure-Based Decision Rules to Manage Sequence Risk in Ret...
PDF
THE EFFECT OF FOREIGN AID ON ECONOMIC GROWTH IN ETHIOPIA
PDF
International Financial Management, 9th Edition, Cheol Eun, Bruce Resnick Tuu...
PDF
Truxton Capital: Middle Market Quarterly Review - August 2025
PPT
Fundamentals of Financial Management Chapter 3
PPTX
PPT-Lesson-2-Recognize-a-Potential-Market-2-3.pptx
PDF
DTC TRADIND CLUB MAKE YOUR TRADING BETTER
PDF
1a In Search of the Numbers ssrn 1488130 Oct 2009.pdf
PDF
HCWM AND HAI FOR BHCM STUDENTS(1).Pdf and ptts
PPTX
General-Characteristics-of-Microorganisms.pptx
PDF
2a A Dynamic and Adaptive Approach to Distribution Planning and Monitoring JF...
PPTX
Q1 PE AND HEALTH 5 WEEK 5 DAY 1 powerpoint template
PPTX
Role and functions of International monetary fund.pptx
PDF
Financial discipline for educational purpose
PPTX
Grp C.ppt presentation.pptx for Economics
PDF
Pitch Deck.pdf .pdf all about finance in
PPTX
Maths science sst hindi english cucumber
PPTX
28 - relative valuation lecture economicsnotes
PDF
The Right Social Media Strategy Can Transform Your Business
4a Probability-of-Failure-Based Decision Rules to Manage Sequence Risk in Ret...
THE EFFECT OF FOREIGN AID ON ECONOMIC GROWTH IN ETHIOPIA
International Financial Management, 9th Edition, Cheol Eun, Bruce Resnick Tuu...
Truxton Capital: Middle Market Quarterly Review - August 2025
Fundamentals of Financial Management Chapter 3
PPT-Lesson-2-Recognize-a-Potential-Market-2-3.pptx
DTC TRADIND CLUB MAKE YOUR TRADING BETTER
1a In Search of the Numbers ssrn 1488130 Oct 2009.pdf
HCWM AND HAI FOR BHCM STUDENTS(1).Pdf and ptts
General-Characteristics-of-Microorganisms.pptx
2a A Dynamic and Adaptive Approach to Distribution Planning and Monitoring JF...
Q1 PE AND HEALTH 5 WEEK 5 DAY 1 powerpoint template
Role and functions of International monetary fund.pptx
Financial discipline for educational purpose
Grp C.ppt presentation.pptx for Economics
Pitch Deck.pdf .pdf all about finance in
Maths science sst hindi english cucumber
28 - relative valuation lecture economicsnotes
The Right Social Media Strategy Can Transform Your Business

OR CH 3 Transportation and assignment problem.pptx

  • 1. C h a p t e r Three Transportation and Assignment Problem
  • 2. 3.1.Transportation problem  One important application of linear programming is the area of physical distribution (transportation) of goods from several supply centers (origins) to several demand centers (destinations).  Transportation problem involves a large number of variables (transportation/shipping routes) and constraints, it takes along time to solve it.  Therefore, other methods (transportation algorithm) havebeen developed for this purpose.
  • 3.     Objective: amount of the objective commodities is to determine the which should be transpor ted from several sources to different destinations, atthe minimum transportation cost and /or time. Sources or origins are the places where goods originate from (like plants,warehouses etc) Destinations are placeswhere goods are to be shipped. It can also be applied to the maximization of some total value or utility,in such awaythatthe profit is maximized.
  • 4. 3.1.1. GeneralTransportation Problem Model The transportation algorithm requires the assumptions that: All goods are homogeneous, so that anyoriginis capableofsupplyingtoanydestination. Transportation costs are alinear function of (or directlyproportionalto) the quantity shipped over any route. Each sourcehas a fixedsupplyofunits,where this entire supply must be distributed to the destinations. Similarly, each destination has a fixed demand for units, where this entire demand must be received from the sources.
  • 5. A transportation problem model, which has ‘m’ sending locations (origins) and ‘n’ receiving locations (destinations), provides a framework for presenting all relevant data. These are: Quantity supply of each origin (SSi) Quantity demand of each destination (DDi) Unit transportation cost from each origin to each destination (Cij)
  • 6. Where: SSi -istotalquantityofcommodityavailableatoriginI (totalsupplyoforigini). ddj-istotalquantityofcommoditiesneededat destinations j(total demand of destination j). Cij -measures thecostsoftransportingoneunitof commodityfromsourceitodestinationj. Xij -isthequantityofcommoditiestransportedfrom ithorigintojthdestination.
  • 7. The Linear ProgrammingRepresentation of a Transportation Model
  • 8. Minimize (total transportation cost) Z=C11X11+C12X12+C13X13+….+CmnXmn Subject to: Capacity constraints (SS constraints) X11+X12+----+X1n=SS1 X21+X22+----+X2n=SS2 . . . . . . . . Xm1+Xm2+.---+Xmn=SSm Requirements constraints (DD constraint) X11+X21+----+Xm1=SS1 X21+X22+----+Xm2=SS2 . . . . . . . . . . . . Xn1+Xn2+.---+Xnm=SSn Xij ≥ 0 for all i and j
  • 9. Before applying the transportation techniques (methods) to solve a specific problem, the problem should satisfy the following conditions. Supplies(SS)and requirements(DD) must be expressed in the same unit. Thisconditionmeansthatshipmentsreceivedatany destinationfromdifferentsources mustbe indistinguishable. In otherwords,allshipmentmustbemeasuredin homogenous units.
  • 10. T otalsupplymustequaltototaldemand∑SS= ∑DD Theproblemsatisfyingthisconditioniscalled balanced transportation problem; otherwiseitis knownas unbalanced transportation problem. The condition ∑SS= ∑DD isthenecessary and sufficient condition fortheexistenceoffeasible solutiontothetransportation problem.
  • 11. 5.1.2. Methods of Solving Transportation Problem Methods to get the initial solution: even if there are different methods of such types, the following three common methods can be used. The North-West Corner Method (NWC) Minimum cost method (MCM), and The Vogel’sApproximationMethod (VAM).
  • 12. 1.North West Corner method 1st. Balance the problem.That isseewhetherΣDD = ΣSS.  If not open a dummy column or dummy row as the case maybe and balance the problem. 2nd. Allocate as much as possible to the selected cell,and adjust the associated amounts of supply and demand by subtracting the allocated amount. Since :The method starts at the northwest-corner cell (route) of the tableau (variable X11).
  • 13. 3rd. Cross out the row or column with zero supply or demand to indicate that no further assignments can be made in that row or column. If both arow and acolumn net to zero simultaneously, crossoutoneonly ,and leaveazero supply (demand) in the uncrossed-out row (column). 4th Ifexactlyonerow or column is leftuncrossed out,stop. Otherwise, move to the cell to the right ifacolumn has just been crossed out or below ifarow has been crossed out. Go to step 1.
  • 14. 5th Make sure that allthe rim conditions are satisfied and (m+n-1) cells are allocated. 6th Once allthe allocations are over ,i.e.,bothrim requirement(columnandrowi.e.,availabilityand requirement constraints) are satisfied, write allocations and calculate the cost of transportation. Example 1. Let us consider an example atthis juncture to illustrate the application of NWC rule
  • 15. To From D1 D2 D3 Total supply S1 X11 5 X12 6 X13 7 70 S2 X21 4 X22 2 X32 5 30 S3 X31 1 X32 5 X33 4 50 Total Demand 65 42 43 150 150 ΣDD = ΣSS .The North West Cornercell X11 is chosen for allocation..
  • 16. The origin S1 has 70 items and the destination D1 requires only 65 items. Hence it is enough to allot65 itemsfrom S1 toD1. The origin S1 which is alivewith 5 more items can supply to the destination to the right is alivewith 5 moreitemscan supplyto the destination to the right of D1 namely D2 whose requirement is 42. So, we supply 5 itemstoD2 therebytheoriginS1 is exhausted.
  • 17. D2 requires 37 items more. Now consider the origin S2 that has 30 items to spare.We allot 30 itemstothecell(X22) so that the origin S2 is exhausted. Then, move to origin S3 and supply 7 more items to the destination D2. Now the requirement of the destination D2 is complete and S3 isleft with 43 items and the same can be allotted to the destination D3. Now the origin S3 is emptied and the requirement atthe destination D3 is also complete.This completes the initial solution to the problem
  • 18. To From D1 D2 D3 Total supply S1 65 5 5 6 7 70 S2 4 30 2 5 30 S3 1 7 5 43 4 50 Total Demand 65 42 43 150 150 The total cost of transportation by this method will be: (65 × 5) + (5 × 6) + (30 × 2) + (7 × 5) + (43× 4) = 325 + 30 + 60 + 35 + 172 = 622.
  • 19. Example 2. To From X Y Z Dummy Availability A 7 4 3 3 2 0 10 B 5 8 6 1 0 8 C 6 1 4 4 3 0 5 D 3 5 1 4 5 0 6 Requirement 7 12 5 5 29 The total cost of transportation by this method will be: (7x4)+(3x3)+(8x6)+(1x4)+(4x3)+(1x4)+(5x0) = 105
  • 20. Tra nsp orta tion -20 Example 3 Destination Supply Source N S E W A 16 13 22 17 200 100 100 B 14 13 19 15 350 40 300 10 C 9 20 23 10 150 150 Dummy 0 0 0 0 90 90 Demand 100 140 300 250 Z = 10770
  • 21. 2.Least-Cost Method Steps in Least-Cost Method: Step 1: Determine the least cost among all the rows of the transportation table. Step 2: Identify the row and allocate the maximum feasible quantity in the cell corresponding to the least cost in the row. Then eliminate that row (column) when an allocation is made.
  • 22. Step 3:Repeat steps 1 and 2 for the reduced transportation table until allthe available quantities are distributed to the required places. If the minimum cost is not unique, the tie can be broken arbitrarily. Step 4: Make sure that allthe rim conditions are satisfied and (m+n-1) cells are allocated.
  • 23. To From D1 D2 D3 Total supply S1 5 7 8 70 S2 4 4 6 30 S3 6 7 7 50 Total Demand 65 42 43 150 150
  • 24. We examine the rows S1, S2 and S3, 4 istheleast costelementinthecell(S2, D1)and (S2, D2) and the tie can be brokenarbitrarily.Select (S2,D1). The originS2 can supply30 itemstoD1 andthus originS2 is exhausted. D1 stillrequires35 moreunits.Hence, shade the row S2. Shading S2, we observe that 5 istheleastelement inthecell(S1, D1) and examine the supply atS1 and demand at D1.
  • 25. The destination D1 requires 35 itemsand this requirementissatisfiedfromS1 so that the column D1 is shaded next. Next, we choose 7 as leastelementcorrespondingto thecell(S1, D2). We supply35 unitsfromS1 toD2. Now, only one row is left behind. Hence, weallow7 itemsfromS3 toD2 and43 itemsS3 to D3.
  • 26. To From D1 D2 D3 Total supply S1 35 5 35 7 8 70 S2 30 4 4 6 30 S3 6 7 7 43 7 50 Total Demand 65 42 43 150 150 The cost of the allocation by the least cost method is (35 x 5) + (35 x 7) + (30 x 4) + (7 x 7) + (43 x 7) = 890
  • 27. Example 2 T o (A) Albuquerque (B) Boston (C) Cleveland (D) Des Moines (E) Evansville (F) Fort Lauder Warehouse requirement 300 200 200 Factory capacity 300 300 100 700 $5 $5 $4 $4 $3 $3 $9 $8 $7 From 100 First, $3 is the lowest cost cell so ship 100 units fromDes Moines to Cleveland and cross off the first row as Des Moines is satisfied Figure C.4 © 2011 Pearson Education
  • 28. T o (A) Albuquerque (B) Boston (C) Cleveland (D) Des Moines (E) Evansville (F) Fort Lauderdale Warehouse requirement 300 200 200 Factory capacity 300 300 100 700 $5 $5 $4 $4 $3 $3 $9 $8 $7 From 100 100 Second, $3 is again the lowest cost cell so ship 100 units from Evansville to Cleveland and cross off column C as Cleveland is satisfied Figure C.4 © 2011 Pearson Education
  • 29. T o (A) Albuquerque (B) Boston (C) Cleveland (D) Des Moines (E) Evansville (F) Fort Lauderdale Warehouse requirement 300 200 200 Factory capacity 300 300 100 700 $5 $5 $4 $4 $3 $3 $9 $8 $7 From 100 100 200 Third, $4 is the lowest cost cell soship 200 units from Evansville to Boston and cross off column B and row E as Evansville and Boston are satisfied Figure C.4 © 2011 Pearson Education
  • 30. T o (A) Albuquerque (B) Boston (C) Cleveland (D) Des Moines (E) Evansville (F) Fort Lauderdale Warehouse requirement 300 200 200 Factory capacity 300 300 100 700 $5 $5 $4 $4 $3 $3 $9 $8 $7 From 100 100 200 300 Finally,ship 300 units fromAlbuquerque to Fort Lauder as this is the only remaining cell to completethe allocations Figure C.4 © 2011 Pearson Education
  • 31. T o (A) Albuquerque (B) Boston (C) Cleveland (D) Des Moines (E) Evansville (F) Fort Lauderdale Warehouse requirement 300 200 200 Factory capacity 300 300 100 700 $5 $5 $4 $4 $3 $3 $9 $8 $7 From 100 100 200 300 Total Cost Figure C.4 © 2011 Pearson Education = $3(100) + $3(100) + $4(200) + $9(300) = $4,100
  • 32. 3.Vogel Approximation Method Steps inVAM: Step 1: For each row (column), determine apenalty measure by subtractingthesmallestunitcostelementintherow(column) fromthenextsmallestunitcostelementinthesamerow (column). Step 2: Identify the row or column withthelargestpenalty.If there isa tie (equal penalty) it can be broken by selectingthe cellwheremaximumallocationcan bemade. Allocate as much as possible to thevariablewiththeleastunit costintheselectedrowor column. Adjustthesupplyand demand,and crossoutthesatisfiedrowor column. If arow and acolumn are satisfied simultaneously, only one of the two is crossed out, and the remaining row (column) is assigned zero supply (demand).
  • 33. Step 3: (a)Ifexactlyoneroworcolumnwithzerosupply ordemandremainsuncrossed out,stop. (b)Ifonerow(column)withpositivesupply (demand)remainsuncrossedout,determinethe basicvariablesintherow(column)bytheleast- costmethod. Stop. (c)Ifalltheuncrossedoutrowsandcolumnshave (remaining)zerosupplyanddemand,determine thezerobasicvariablesbytheleast-costmethod. Stop. (d) Otherwise,gotostep 1. Step 4: Make sure that alltherimconditionsare satisfied and cellsareallocated.
  • 34. To From D1 D2 D3 Total supply Row penalty S1 65 5 5 7 8 70 2 2(ii) 1(iii) 0 S2 4 30 4 6 30 0 0 0 0 S3 6 7 7 43 7 50 1 1 0 0 Total Demand 65 42 43 150 Column penalty 1 3(i) 1 1 0 1 0 0 1 The cost of allocation (i.e., the associated objective value) by Vogel's Approximation Method will be: (65× 5) + (5× 7) + (30 × 4) + (7 × 7) + (43× 7) = 325 + 35 +120 + 49 + 301 = 830.
  • 35. The differencebetweenthesmallestand nexttothe smallestelementineach rowand ineach columnis calculated. We choose the maximum from among the differences. The first individual allocation will be to the smallest cost of a row or column with the largest difference. So we select the column D2 (penalty = 3) for the first individual allocation, and allocate to (S2, D2) as much as we can,since this cell has the least cost location. Thus 30 units from S2 are allocated to D2.This exhausts the supply from S2. However , there is still a demand of 12 unitsfrom D2.
  • 36. The allocations to other cells in that column are 0.The next step is to cross out row S2 (as it is exhausted). The next largest unit difference corresponds to the row S1.This leads to an allocation in the corresponding minimumcostlocationinrowS1, namelycell(S1, D1). The maximum possible allocation is only 65 as required byW1 fromS1 and allocation of 0 to others in the row S1. Column D1 is thus crossed out. Maximum difference is 1 in row S3 and in column D3. Select arbitrarily S3 and allot the least cost cell (S1, D2) 5 units. Cross out row S1 for it is alreadyexhausted. Now, we haveonly one row S3 and two columns D2 and D3 indicating that the entire availableamount from S3 has to be moved to D2 and D3 as per their requirements.
  • 37. T ra Vogel’sMethod (1): calculate differences Destination nsp orta tion -37 Supply diff Source N S E W A 16 13 22 17 200 3 B 14 13 19 15 350 1 C 9 20 23 10 150 1 Dummy 0 0 0 0 90 0 Demand 100 140 300 250 diff 9 13 19 10
  • 38. T ra Vogel’ s Method (2):select xDummyE as basic variable Supply diff Source N Destination S E W Demand 100 140 300 250 diff 9 13 19 10 A 16 13 22 17 200 3 B 14 13 19 15 350 1 C 9 20 23 10 150 1 Dummy 0 0 0 0 90 0 90 nsp orta tion -38
  • 39. Vogel’sMethod (3): update supply,demand and differences Destination Supply diff Source N S E W A 16 13 22 17 200 3 B 14 13 19 15 350 1 C 9 20 23 10 150 1 Dummy 0 0 0 90 0 --- --- Demand 100 140 210 250 diff 5 0 3 5 Tra nsp orta tion -39
  • 40. Vogel’ s Method (4):select xCN as basic variable Destination Supply diff Source N S E W A 16 13 22 17 200 3 B 14 13 19 15 350 1 C 9 100 20 23 10 150 1 Dummy 0 0 0 90 0 --- --- Demand 100 140 210 250 diff 5 0 3 5 Tra nsp orta tion -40
  • 41. Vogel’sMethod (5): update supply,demand and differences Destination Supply diff Source N S E W A 16 13 22 17 200 4 B 14 13 19 15 350 2 C 9 100 20 23 10 50 10 Dummy 0 0 0 90 0 --- --- Demand --- 140 210 250 diff --- 0 3 5 Tra nsp orta tion -41
  • 42. Vogel’ s Method (6):select xCW as basic variable Destination Supply diff Source N S E W A 16 13 22 17 200 4 B 14 13 19 15 350 2 C 9 100 20 23 10 50 50 10 Dummy 0 0 0 90 0 --- --- Demand --- 140 210 250 diff --- 0 3 5 Tra nsp orta tion -42
  • 43. Vogel’sMethod (7): update supply,demand and differences Destination Supply diff Source N S E W A 16 13 22 17 200 4 B 14 13 19 15 350 2 C 9 100 20 23 10 50 --- --- Dummy 0 0 0 90 0 --- --- Demand --- 140 210 200 diff --- 0 3 2 Tra nsp orta tion -43
  • 44. Vogel’ s Method (8):select xAS as basic variable Destination Supply diff Source N S E W A 16 13 140 22 17 200 4 B 14 13 19 15 350 2 C 9 100 20 23 10 50 --- --- Dummy 0 0 0 90 0 --- --- Demand --- 140 210 200 diff --- 0 3 2 Tra nsp orta tion -44
  • 45. Vogel’sMethod (9): update supply,demand and differences Destination Supply diff Source N S E W A 16 13 140 22 17 60 5 B 14 13 19 15 350 4 C 9 100 20 23 10 50 --- --- Dummy 0 0 0 90 0 --- --- Demand --- --- 210 200 diff --- --- 3 2 Tra nsp orta tion -45
  • 46. Vogel’ s Method (10):select xAW as basic variable Destination Supply diff Source N S E W A 16 13 140 22 17 60 60 5 B 14 13 19 15 350 4 C 9 100 20 23 10 50 --- --- Dummy 0 0 0 90 0 --- --- Demand --- --- 210 200 diff --- --- 3 2 Tra nsp orta tion -46
  • 47. Vogel’sMethod (11): update supply,demand and differences Destination Supply diff Source N S E W A 16 13 140 22 17 60 --- --- B 14 13 19 15 350 4 C 9 100 20 23 10 50 --- --- Dummy 0 0 0 90 0 --- --- Demand --- --- 210 140 diff --- --- Tra nsp orta tion -47
  • 48. Vogel’ s Method (12):select xBW and xBE as basic variables Destination Supply diff Source N S E W A 16 13 140 22 17 60 --- --- B 14 13 19 210 15 140 --- C 9 100 20 23 10 50 --- --- Dummy 0 0 0 90 0 --- --- Demand --- --- --- --- diff --- --- Z = 10330 Tra nsp orta tion -48
  • 49. 3.2.Assignment problem In many business situations, management needs to assign - personnel to jobs, - jobs to machines, - machines to job locations, or - salespersons to territories. Consider the situation of assigning n jobston machines. When ajob i (=1,2,....,n)is assigned to machine j(=1,2, .....n)that incurs acost Cij. The objective is to assign the jobs to machines at the least possible total cost.
  • 50. This situation is aspecial case of the transportation model and it is known as the assignment problem. Here, jobs represent “sources”and machines represent“destinations.” The supplyavailableateach sourceis1 unitand demand at each destination is 1 unit. Formulation/construction of the model
  • 51. The assignment model can be expressed mathematically as follows: Xij= 0, ifthejobjisnotassignedtomachine i 1,ifthejobjisassignedtomachine I Now the problem is which work isto be assigned to whom so that the cost of completion of work will be minimum.
  • 52. To minimize z (cost) where xij = 1; if ith person is assigned jthwork 0; if ith person is not assigned the jthwork i.e., ith person will doonly one work. i.e., jth work will be done only by oneperson.
  • 53. Example A farm produce different agricultural products and that Products are manufactured on five different assembly lines (1,2,3,4,5). When manufacturing is finished, products are transported from the assembly lines to one of the five different potential customers (A,B,C,D,E). Transporting products from five assembly lines to five inspection areas requires different times (in minutes) potential customers
  • 54. Methods of solvingAP (The Hungarian Method) In order to find the proper assignment itis essential for us to know the Hungarian method. Step I (A) Row reduction: Select the smallest value in each row. Subtract this value from each value in that row in the cost matrix. (B) Column reduction: After completion of row reduction, subtract the minimum entry of each column from all the entries of the respective column.
  • 55. Step II Zero assignment: (A) Starting with first row of the matrix received in first step,examine the rows one byone until a row containing exactly one zero is found.  Then an experimental assignment indicated by‘ ’ismarked to that zero.  Now cross all the zeros in the column in which the assignment is made.  Cross out zero, if there are other zero in ether column or row.  This procedure should be adopted for each row assignment.
  • 56. (B) When the rows has been completely an identical procedure is set of examined, applied successively to columns. Starting with column 1, examine all columns until a column containing exactly one zero is found. Then makean experimentalassignmentinthat position and Cross otherzeros intherowinwhichthe assignmentwas made.
  • 57. Continue these successive operations on rows and columns until all zero’shave either been assigned or corssed-out. Now there are two possibilities: (a)Either all the zeros are assigned or crossed out, i.e.,we get the maximal assignment. or (b)At least two zeros are remained by assignment or bycrossing out in each row or column. In this situation we try to exclude some of the zeros bytrial and error method. This completes the second step.
  • 58. After this step we can get two situations. (i) Totalassigned zero’s= n The assignment is optimal. (ii)Totalassigned zero’s< n Use step III and onwards. Since n= # of assignments Step III Draw of minimum lines to cover zero’s : In order to cover all the zero’sat least once you may adopt the following procedure.
  • 59. (i)Marks (√) to allrows in which the assignment has not been done. (ii) See thepositionofzeroinmarked(√) rowand then mark (√) to the corresponding column. (iii)See the marked (√) column and find the position of assigned zero’sand then mark (√) to thecorrespondingrowswhicharenotmarked tillnow . (iv)Repeattheprocedure(ii)and (iii)tillthecompletion of marking. (v)Draw the lines through unmarkedrowsand marked columns. Note: If the above method does not work then make an arbitraryassignmentandthenfollowstepIV .
  • 60. Step IV Select the smallest element from the uncovered elements : (i)Subtract this smallest element from all those elements which are not covered. (ii)Add this smallest element to all those elements which are at the intersection of two lines. Step V Thus we haveincreasedthenumberof zero’s. Now, modifythematrixwiththehelpofstepII and findtherequired assignment. Finally calculate the total minimized cost by summing up numbers from the original table
  • 61. Example 1. Four persons A,B,C and D are to be assigned four jobs I, II, III and IV . The cost matrix is given as under , find the proper assignment. Man Jobs A B C D I 8 10 17 9 II 3 8 5 6 III 10 12 11 9 IV 6 13 9 7 Solution : In order to find the proper assignment we apply the Hungarian algorithm as follows:
  • 62. I (A) Row reduction Man A B C D Jobs I 0 2 9 1 II 0 5 2 3 III 1 3 2 0 IV 0 7 3 1 Man Jobs A B C D I 0 0 7 1 II 0 3 0 3 III 1 1 0 0 IV 0 5 1 1 I (B) Column reduction
  • 63. II Zero assignment: Man Jobs A B C D I 0 0 7 1 II 0 3 0 3 III 1 1 0 0 IV 0 5 1 1 In this way allthe zero’s are either crossed out or assigned. Also total assigned zero’s = 4 (i.e.,number of rows or columns). Thus, the assignment is optimal. From the table we get: I B; II. C: III. D and IV A. T otal minimized cost = 10+5+9+6= 30
  • 64. Example 2: There are five machines and five jobs are to be assigned and the associated cost matrix is as follows. Find the proper assignment. machines Jobs I II III IV V A 6 12 3 11 15 B 4 2 7 1 10 C 8 11 10 7 11 D 16 19 12 23 21 E 9 5 7 6 10
  • 65. Solution: In order to find the proper assignment, we apply the Hungarian method as follows: I A (Rowreduction) machines Jobs I II III IV V A 3 9 0 8 12 B 3 1 6 0 9 C 1 4 3 0 4 D 4 7 0 11 9 E 4 0 2 1 5
  • 66. machines J obs I II III IV V A 2 9 0 8 8 B 2 1 6 0 5 C 0 4 3 0 0 D 3 7 0 11 5 E 3 0 2 1 1 II (Zero assignment) IB (Column reduction) machines I II III IV V A 2 9 0 8 8 Jobs B 2 1 6 0 5 C 0 4 3 0 0 D 3 7 0 11 5 E 3 0 2 1 1
  • 67. From the last table we see that allthe zeros are either assigned or crossed out, butthetotalnumber ofassignment,i.e.,4<5 (numberofjobstobeassigned to machines). Therefore, we haveto follow step III and onwards as follows: machines I II III √ 2nd IV V A 2 9 0 8 8 √3rd Jobs B 2 1 6 0 5 C 0 4 3 0 0 D 3 7 0 11 5 √ 1st E 3 0 2 1 1
  • 68. Step IV:Here, the smallest element among the uncovered elements is 2. (i)Subtract 2 from all those elements which are not covered. (ii)Add 2 to those entries which are at the junction(intersection ) of two lines. Make as it is rows that pass single line . machines Jobs I II III IV V A 0 7 0 6 6 B 2 1 8 0 5 C 0 4 5 0 0 D 1 5 0 9 3 E 3 0 4 1 1
  • 69. Step V.using step II again machines Jobs I II III IV V A 0 7 0 6 6 B 2 1 8 0 5 C 0 4 5 0 0 D 1 5 0 9 3 E 3 0 4 1 1 Thus, we have got five assignments as required bythe problem. The assignment is as follows: A I, B  IV, C V,D  III and E  II. Thus from the cost matrix the minimum cost = 6+1+11+12+5=35.
  • 70. START Construct the effectiveness matrix if not already given Row reduction Column reduction Is zero assignment possible (i) Draw minimum number of lines to cover all the zeros (ii)Choose the least uncovered element (iii)Subtract this from the uncovered elements and add it to the elements at intersection of the lines. ASSIGNMENT Put square over the zero and cross out all zeros (if any) of the corresponding column. SOLUTION Add the elements of the given matrix correspond to each square from original table STOP Is Zero assignment Possible Y es No No Y es