SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 
Cloud Foundry and OpenStack - How They Fit 
Apps 
Jason Anderson, Animesh Singh 
@andersonljason, @animeshsingh 
Cloud Expo, Santa Clara 
Nov 4, 2014
2 
What Is OpenStack? 
• An open source cloud computing platform for public & private clouds 
• IaaS for managing compute, storage, and networking resource 
• Standard and massively scalable cloud operating system 
• Largest open source Cloud project (76K commits, 2K contributors)
3 
OpenStack Architecture 
• A collection of well integrated projects (github.com/openstack): 
• Compute (Nova) 
• Networking (Neutron) 
• Block Storage (Cinder) 
• Object Storage (Swift) 
• Identity (Keystone) 
• Image Service (Glance) 
• Dashboard (Horizon) 
• …and others
4 
What is Cloud Foundry? 
• An open cloud platform which suffices the increasing appetite for 
cloud-based mobile, social and analytics applications from line-of-business 
executives 
• Provides developers easy access to services (e.g. databases, 
messaging services, caching) and facilitates agile development 
• Cloud Foundry has a compelling community and emerging 
ecosystem as well as a mature set of capabilities and robustness 
TOTAL CONTRIBUTORS 1.3K LINES OF CODE 711K PULL REQUESTS 3K 
Platinum Founding Sponsors
5 
Cloud Foundry Architecture 
• Another collection of integrated projects (github.com/cloudfoundry) 
• Each component can be scaled independently 
• Robust architecture with fault tolerant properties 
Router 
UAA 
DEA 
Pool 
Service 
Gateway 
Apps 
Service 
Connector 
Health 
Manager 
Cloud 
Controller 
Messaging 
Build 
Packs 
Service 
Nodes
6 
IBM Bluemix (powered by Cloud Foundry) 
• IBM’s hosted Platform as a Services offering 
• IBM and partner cloud services (e.g. Cloudant, New Relic, Twilio) 
• Integrated DevOps with both Browser and Eclipse-based tools 
Come experiment at http://bluemix.net
7 
Integrate!
Cloud Foundry – OpenStack Integration 
8 
Pla%orm 
as 
a 
Service 
Cloud 
Integra3on 
Infrastructure 
as 
a 
Service 
BOSH 
Cloud 
Provider 
Interface
9 
BOSH Deployment Process 
Deployment Manifest 
• Release name/ 
version 
• # VMs, job params 
• Stemcells to use 
Stemcell 
• Base OS 
• BOSH agent 
Release 
• Name 
• Software packages 
• Config templates 
• Scripts 
Deployed 
Cloud Foundry 
BOSH 
Virtual Machine 
• Configuration 
• Software Packages 
Virtual Machine 
• Configuration 
• Software Packages 
Virtual Machine 
• Configuration 
• Software Packages 
Virtual Machine 
• Configuration 
• Software packages
10 
Automate (Leverage the Power of Community)!
11 
Leverage the Open Source Community for Automation! 
Deploy Cloud Foundry and OpenStack using Open Source 
• Open technologies provides the power and flexibility to seamlessly 
integrate them together 
• Lets see some examples of the power of open technologies to go from 
bare metal hardware to a deployed Cloud Foundry ready to push apps
12 
Chef for OpenStack Install Automation 
OpenStack Installation 
• Leverage the open source Chef cloud infrastructure automation 
framework 
• Requires information about hardware, network environment and 
software repositories 
Setup Controller 
Setup Compute 
Setup Network 
Setup Storage 
From 1 week down to 20 minutes
13 
Fog for OpenStack Discovery / Setup Automation 
OpenStack Discovery / Cloud Foundry Pre-Req Setup 
• Leverage the open source Fog gem to discover / setup OpenStack 
artifacts in an automated manner (requires OpenStack credentials) 
• Setup according to best practices and guidelines – still giving users the 
flexibility to change if desired 
Discover / Create 
Security Credentials 
Discover / Create VM 
Configuration Sizes 
Discover / Create 
Network Subnets 
Discover / Create Network 
Security Rules 
Discover / Create DHCP, 
DNS Gateway & Public IPs 
From 1 hour down to milliseconds
14 
BOSH / Ruby for Cloud Foundry Automation 
Cloud Foundry Deployment Automation 
• Automate base OS image or Stemcell modification 
• Automate manifest file generation using Ruby ERB templates 
• Automate upload of Cloud Foundry core release, services and runtime 
frameworks, followed by Cloud Foundry deployment 
RUBY 
BOSH 
Stemcell Creation/ 
Modification and Upload 
Generate BOSH and 
Cloud Foundry Manifest 
Deploy Microbosh 
Upload Cloud 
Foundry core, 
Services and runtime 
Deploy Cloud Foundry 
From 1 week down to 40 minutes
15 
Open is the Only Way! 
Automate end to end deployments in under an hour! 
• Previous example signify the power of Open source community 
• Leveraging tools like Chef, Fog, BOSH, Ruby ERB from the community 
can help create powerful automation which can be repeatedly and 
consistently replicated in under an hour! 
BOSH 
RUBY 
From 2 week down to 1 hour
16 
Maintain the Deployment!
17 
Deployment Maintenance 
• After Cloud Foundry and OpenStack are deployed, maintenance and 
updates activities are required 
• BOSH not only handles deployment but also the instance’s lifecycle 
operations going forward 
• Example updates: 
• Cloud Foundry release 
• Stemcell (with customization) 
• VM configuration size 
• Number of DEAs 
• Domain name 
• Router floating IP
18 
Maintenance Automation 
• Updates can be automated using code from the initial automated 
deployment (e.g. bosh deploy) 
• To ensure application availability throughout the update, leverage 
JMeter to test application responsiveness (100 user agents making 
requests twice a second)
19 
Scale!
20 
Scaling Number of Apps on Cloud Foundry 
• Sample sizing for 1000 small applications 
• Total Resources: 160 VCPU, 500GB Memory, 1.5TB of VM disk
21 
Scaling OpenStack 
• Optimize Internal Communication 
• Configure OpenStack for scaled concurrency 
• Optimize Performance 
• Configure OpenStack scheduler to evenly distribute load 
• Setup Highly Available Architecture for PaaS workloads 
Load Balancer 
Nodes 
Data 
Nodes 
3x 
Storage 
Compute 
15x Nodes 
Nodes 
2x 
Controller 
Nodes 
2x 6x
22 
Scaling Cloud Foundry / BOSH 
• Optimize Internal Communication 
• Configure messaging bus for VM communication 
• Optimized routing and bandwidth allocation 
• Isolate Cloud Foundry components using multiple networks 
• Maintain Cloud Foundry’s Highly Available Architecture 
Service 
Gateways 
3x 
Routers 10x 
Service 
Nodes 
15x 
DEAs 
20x 
Cloud 
Controllers 
2x
23 
Summary 
Why Cloud Foundry and OpenStack are a great fit? 
• 100% Open PaaS and IaaS solutions (no vendor lock-ins) with a 
growing community of contributors and sponsors on both sides 
• Power of Open Source community can be leveraged to automate the 
deployment and lifecycle management of Cloud Foundry on OpenStack 
• OpenStack meets Cloud Foundry integration requirements, and is 
totally configurable and adaptable to handle the scale of a PaaS 
solution like Cloud Foundry 
Bottom Line: Cloud Foundry and OpenStack are a great match!
24 
What’s next? Join us at our Silicon Valley Meetups 
http://www.meetup.com/Bluemix/ 
http://www.meetup.com/CloudFoundry/ 
For more technical details, refer to the slides and video here 
http://www.slideshare.net/AnimeshSingh/optimizing-cloud-foundry-and-openstack-for-large-scale-deployments 
https://www.openstack.org/assets/presentation-media/A-Practical-Approach-to-HA-Final.pdf 
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jCwtV9n_ak4 
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FsrCGkBo4Vg

More Related Content

PPTX
Cloud Foundry and OpenStack - A Marriage Made in Heaven! (Cloud Foundry Summi...
PPTX
Pairs OpenStack Summit Summary
PPTX
Openstack Fundamentals by CloudZone @Back2School
PDF
2011 Essex Summit: Openstack/Hyper-V clouds
PPTX
OpenStack Kolla Introduction
PDF
Magnum Networking Update
PPTX
Cloudexpowest opensourcecloudcomputing-1by arun kumar
PDF
Docker Meetup Bangalore - Docker + Openstack
Cloud Foundry and OpenStack - A Marriage Made in Heaven! (Cloud Foundry Summi...
Pairs OpenStack Summit Summary
Openstack Fundamentals by CloudZone @Back2School
2011 Essex Summit: Openstack/Hyper-V clouds
OpenStack Kolla Introduction
Magnum Networking Update
Cloudexpowest opensourcecloudcomputing-1by arun kumar
Docker Meetup Bangalore - Docker + Openstack

What's hot (20)

PPTX
Running OpenStack on Amazon AWS, Alex Fishman
PDF
Hacking apache cloud stack
PPTX
DEVNET-1183 OpenShift + Kubernetes + Docker
PDF
dodai_grizzly.pdf
PDF
Heat - keep the clouds up
ODP
Red Hat OpenStack Deployment
PPTX
Kolla talk at OpenStack Summit 2017 in Sydney
PDF
Mastering OpenStack - Episode 05 - Controller Nodes
PDF
OpenStack Watcher
PPTX
Introducing container as-a-service support to apache libcloud
PDF
Mastering OpenStack - Episode 11 - Scaling Out
PPTX
OpenStack in an Ever Expanding World of Possibilities - Vancouver 2015 Summit
PDF
Mastering OpenStack - Episode 13 - Network Design
PDF
CloudStack Hyderabad Meetup: How the Apache community works
PPTX
OpenStack Heat
PDF
Crowbar2 update
PPTX
Project RedDwarf - Database Services in the Cloud.pptx
PPTX
Openstack portal-bestpractices-campbell mcneill
PPTX
Containerization with Microsoft Azure
Running OpenStack on Amazon AWS, Alex Fishman
Hacking apache cloud stack
DEVNET-1183 OpenShift + Kubernetes + Docker
dodai_grizzly.pdf
Heat - keep the clouds up
Red Hat OpenStack Deployment
Kolla talk at OpenStack Summit 2017 in Sydney
Mastering OpenStack - Episode 05 - Controller Nodes
OpenStack Watcher
Introducing container as-a-service support to apache libcloud
Mastering OpenStack - Episode 11 - Scaling Out
OpenStack in an Ever Expanding World of Possibilities - Vancouver 2015 Summit
Mastering OpenStack - Episode 13 - Network Design
CloudStack Hyderabad Meetup: How the Apache community works
OpenStack Heat
Crowbar2 update
Project RedDwarf - Database Services in the Cloud.pptx
Openstack portal-bestpractices-campbell mcneill
Containerization with Microsoft Azure
Ad

Viewers also liked (15)

PPTX
Toward Single Neuron Gene Expression Analysis for Studying Behavior
PDF
Spivak
PDF
Levesys company brochure
PDF
Wordpress.com presentation
PPTX
WebQuest
PPTX
معا لنجعل الإنترنت في الإمارات أفضل استخداما
PDF
Levesys A-Z OF CONSTRUCTION SOFTWARE
PDF
Add Watson to your Apps
PPTX
Pathak khyati33 ppt
PPTX
PPTX
الدرس الأول الثقافة الأمنية 12 أدبي 4
PDF
شروط الملصق أو البوستر
PPTX
المجلة الفيزيائية
PDF
บทที่ 1เทคโนโลยี สาระสนเทศสมัยใหม่
PDF
บทที่ 1เทคโนโลยีสาระสนเทศสมัยใหม่
Toward Single Neuron Gene Expression Analysis for Studying Behavior
Spivak
Levesys company brochure
Wordpress.com presentation
WebQuest
معا لنجعل الإنترنت في الإمارات أفضل استخداما
Levesys A-Z OF CONSTRUCTION SOFTWARE
Add Watson to your Apps
Pathak khyati33 ppt
الدرس الأول الثقافة الأمنية 12 أدبي 4
شروط الملصق أو البوستر
المجلة الفيزيائية
บทที่ 1เทคโนโลยี สาระสนเทศสมัยใหม่
บทที่ 1เทคโนโลยีสาระสนเทศสมัยใหม่
Ad

Similar to Cloud Foundry and OpenStack: How They Fit - Cloud Expo 2014 (20)

PPTX
Cloud Foundry and OpenStack – Marriage Made in Heaven !
PPTX
Cloud Foundry and OpenStack - A Marriage Made in Heaven! (Cloud Foundry Summi...
PPTX
Automated Lifecycle Management - CloudFoundry on OpenStack
PPTX
Optimizing Cloud Foundry and OpenStack for large scale deployments
PDF
OpenStack and Cloud Foundry - Pair the leading open source IaaS and PaaS
PDF
As a Service: Cloud Foundry on OpenStack - Lessons Learnt
PDF
Cloud Foundry Introduction and Overview
PPTX
Cloud foundry integration-with-openstack-and-docker-bangalorecf-meetup
PDF
Cloud Foundry Overview
PPT
IBM Open Cloud Update XCITE Fall 2014
PDF
MNAssociationEnterpriseArchitectsCloudFoundryJuly2017
PDF
Lessions from building a high available cloud foudry on top of open stack
PPTX
Cloud Foundry: Hands-on Deployment Workshop
PDF
Cloud foundry Docker Openstack - Leading Open Source Triumvirate
PDF
Building a PaaS Platform like Bluemix on OpenStack
PDF
PHP Buildpacks in the Cloud on Bluemix
 
PDF
Cloud Foundry for PHP developers
PDF
Cloud Foundry BOSH CPI for OpenStack
PDF
Structure and Opinions - Software Deployments with Cloud Foundry
PDF
Application M&O on OpenStack
Cloud Foundry and OpenStack – Marriage Made in Heaven !
Cloud Foundry and OpenStack - A Marriage Made in Heaven! (Cloud Foundry Summi...
Automated Lifecycle Management - CloudFoundry on OpenStack
Optimizing Cloud Foundry and OpenStack for large scale deployments
OpenStack and Cloud Foundry - Pair the leading open source IaaS and PaaS
As a Service: Cloud Foundry on OpenStack - Lessons Learnt
Cloud Foundry Introduction and Overview
Cloud foundry integration-with-openstack-and-docker-bangalorecf-meetup
Cloud Foundry Overview
IBM Open Cloud Update XCITE Fall 2014
MNAssociationEnterpriseArchitectsCloudFoundryJuly2017
Lessions from building a high available cloud foudry on top of open stack
Cloud Foundry: Hands-on Deployment Workshop
Cloud foundry Docker Openstack - Leading Open Source Triumvirate
Building a PaaS Platform like Bluemix on OpenStack
PHP Buildpacks in the Cloud on Bluemix
 
Cloud Foundry for PHP developers
Cloud Foundry BOSH CPI for OpenStack
Structure and Opinions - Software Deployments with Cloud Foundry
Application M&O on OpenStack

Recently uploaded (20)

PDF
Reach Out and Touch Someone: Haptics and Empathic Computing
PDF
Architecting across the Boundaries of two Complex Domains - Healthcare & Tech...
PDF
7 ChatGPT Prompts to Help You Define Your Ideal Customer Profile.pdf
PPTX
Understanding_Digital_Forensics_Presentation.pptx
PDF
Shreyas Phanse Resume: Experienced Backend Engineer | Java • Spring Boot • Ka...
PPTX
20250228 LYD VKU AI Blended-Learning.pptx
PPTX
Detection-First SIEM: Rule Types, Dashboards, and Threat-Informed Strategy
PPTX
Effective Security Operations Center (SOC) A Modern, Strategic, and Threat-In...
PDF
Chapter 3 Spatial Domain Image Processing.pdf
PDF
Per capita expenditure prediction using model stacking based on satellite ima...
PDF
Network Security Unit 5.pdf for BCA BBA.
DOCX
The AUB Centre for AI in Media Proposal.docx
PDF
Blue Purple Modern Animated Computer Science Presentation.pdf.pdf
PPTX
VMware vSphere Foundation How to Sell Presentation-Ver1.4-2-14-2024.pptx
PDF
Empathic Computing: Creating Shared Understanding
PDF
KodekX | Application Modernization Development
PPTX
MYSQL Presentation for SQL database connectivity
PPTX
Digital-Transformation-Roadmap-for-Companies.pptx
PDF
Agricultural_Statistics_at_a_Glance_2022_0.pdf
PDF
Bridging biosciences and deep learning for revolutionary discoveries: a compr...
Reach Out and Touch Someone: Haptics and Empathic Computing
Architecting across the Boundaries of two Complex Domains - Healthcare & Tech...
7 ChatGPT Prompts to Help You Define Your Ideal Customer Profile.pdf
Understanding_Digital_Forensics_Presentation.pptx
Shreyas Phanse Resume: Experienced Backend Engineer | Java • Spring Boot • Ka...
20250228 LYD VKU AI Blended-Learning.pptx
Detection-First SIEM: Rule Types, Dashboards, and Threat-Informed Strategy
Effective Security Operations Center (SOC) A Modern, Strategic, and Threat-In...
Chapter 3 Spatial Domain Image Processing.pdf
Per capita expenditure prediction using model stacking based on satellite ima...
Network Security Unit 5.pdf for BCA BBA.
The AUB Centre for AI in Media Proposal.docx
Blue Purple Modern Animated Computer Science Presentation.pdf.pdf
VMware vSphere Foundation How to Sell Presentation-Ver1.4-2-14-2024.pptx
Empathic Computing: Creating Shared Understanding
KodekX | Application Modernization Development
MYSQL Presentation for SQL database connectivity
Digital-Transformation-Roadmap-for-Companies.pptx
Agricultural_Statistics_at_a_Glance_2022_0.pdf
Bridging biosciences and deep learning for revolutionary discoveries: a compr...

Cloud Foundry and OpenStack: How They Fit - Cloud Expo 2014

  • 1. 1 Cloud Foundry and OpenStack - How They Fit Apps Jason Anderson, Animesh Singh @andersonljason, @animeshsingh Cloud Expo, Santa Clara Nov 4, 2014
  • 2. 2 What Is OpenStack? • An open source cloud computing platform for public & private clouds • IaaS for managing compute, storage, and networking resource • Standard and massively scalable cloud operating system • Largest open source Cloud project (76K commits, 2K contributors)
  • 3. 3 OpenStack Architecture • A collection of well integrated projects (github.com/openstack): • Compute (Nova) • Networking (Neutron) • Block Storage (Cinder) • Object Storage (Swift) • Identity (Keystone) • Image Service (Glance) • Dashboard (Horizon) • …and others
  • 4. 4 What is Cloud Foundry? • An open cloud platform which suffices the increasing appetite for cloud-based mobile, social and analytics applications from line-of-business executives • Provides developers easy access to services (e.g. databases, messaging services, caching) and facilitates agile development • Cloud Foundry has a compelling community and emerging ecosystem as well as a mature set of capabilities and robustness TOTAL CONTRIBUTORS 1.3K LINES OF CODE 711K PULL REQUESTS 3K Platinum Founding Sponsors
  • 5. 5 Cloud Foundry Architecture • Another collection of integrated projects (github.com/cloudfoundry) • Each component can be scaled independently • Robust architecture with fault tolerant properties Router UAA DEA Pool Service Gateway Apps Service Connector Health Manager Cloud Controller Messaging Build Packs Service Nodes
  • 6. 6 IBM Bluemix (powered by Cloud Foundry) • IBM’s hosted Platform as a Services offering • IBM and partner cloud services (e.g. Cloudant, New Relic, Twilio) • Integrated DevOps with both Browser and Eclipse-based tools Come experiment at http://bluemix.net
  • 8. Cloud Foundry – OpenStack Integration 8 Pla%orm as a Service Cloud Integra3on Infrastructure as a Service BOSH Cloud Provider Interface
  • 9. 9 BOSH Deployment Process Deployment Manifest • Release name/ version • # VMs, job params • Stemcells to use Stemcell • Base OS • BOSH agent Release • Name • Software packages • Config templates • Scripts Deployed Cloud Foundry BOSH Virtual Machine • Configuration • Software Packages Virtual Machine • Configuration • Software Packages Virtual Machine • Configuration • Software Packages Virtual Machine • Configuration • Software packages
  • 10. 10 Automate (Leverage the Power of Community)!
  • 11. 11 Leverage the Open Source Community for Automation! Deploy Cloud Foundry and OpenStack using Open Source • Open technologies provides the power and flexibility to seamlessly integrate them together • Lets see some examples of the power of open technologies to go from bare metal hardware to a deployed Cloud Foundry ready to push apps
  • 12. 12 Chef for OpenStack Install Automation OpenStack Installation • Leverage the open source Chef cloud infrastructure automation framework • Requires information about hardware, network environment and software repositories Setup Controller Setup Compute Setup Network Setup Storage From 1 week down to 20 minutes
  • 13. 13 Fog for OpenStack Discovery / Setup Automation OpenStack Discovery / Cloud Foundry Pre-Req Setup • Leverage the open source Fog gem to discover / setup OpenStack artifacts in an automated manner (requires OpenStack credentials) • Setup according to best practices and guidelines – still giving users the flexibility to change if desired Discover / Create Security Credentials Discover / Create VM Configuration Sizes Discover / Create Network Subnets Discover / Create Network Security Rules Discover / Create DHCP, DNS Gateway & Public IPs From 1 hour down to milliseconds
  • 14. 14 BOSH / Ruby for Cloud Foundry Automation Cloud Foundry Deployment Automation • Automate base OS image or Stemcell modification • Automate manifest file generation using Ruby ERB templates • Automate upload of Cloud Foundry core release, services and runtime frameworks, followed by Cloud Foundry deployment RUBY BOSH Stemcell Creation/ Modification and Upload Generate BOSH and Cloud Foundry Manifest Deploy Microbosh Upload Cloud Foundry core, Services and runtime Deploy Cloud Foundry From 1 week down to 40 minutes
  • 15. 15 Open is the Only Way! Automate end to end deployments in under an hour! • Previous example signify the power of Open source community • Leveraging tools like Chef, Fog, BOSH, Ruby ERB from the community can help create powerful automation which can be repeatedly and consistently replicated in under an hour! BOSH RUBY From 2 week down to 1 hour
  • 16. 16 Maintain the Deployment!
  • 17. 17 Deployment Maintenance • After Cloud Foundry and OpenStack are deployed, maintenance and updates activities are required • BOSH not only handles deployment but also the instance’s lifecycle operations going forward • Example updates: • Cloud Foundry release • Stemcell (with customization) • VM configuration size • Number of DEAs • Domain name • Router floating IP
  • 18. 18 Maintenance Automation • Updates can be automated using code from the initial automated deployment (e.g. bosh deploy) • To ensure application availability throughout the update, leverage JMeter to test application responsiveness (100 user agents making requests twice a second)
  • 20. 20 Scaling Number of Apps on Cloud Foundry • Sample sizing for 1000 small applications • Total Resources: 160 VCPU, 500GB Memory, 1.5TB of VM disk
  • 21. 21 Scaling OpenStack • Optimize Internal Communication • Configure OpenStack for scaled concurrency • Optimize Performance • Configure OpenStack scheduler to evenly distribute load • Setup Highly Available Architecture for PaaS workloads Load Balancer Nodes Data Nodes 3x Storage Compute 15x Nodes Nodes 2x Controller Nodes 2x 6x
  • 22. 22 Scaling Cloud Foundry / BOSH • Optimize Internal Communication • Configure messaging bus for VM communication • Optimized routing and bandwidth allocation • Isolate Cloud Foundry components using multiple networks • Maintain Cloud Foundry’s Highly Available Architecture Service Gateways 3x Routers 10x Service Nodes 15x DEAs 20x Cloud Controllers 2x
  • 23. 23 Summary Why Cloud Foundry and OpenStack are a great fit? • 100% Open PaaS and IaaS solutions (no vendor lock-ins) with a growing community of contributors and sponsors on both sides • Power of Open Source community can be leveraged to automate the deployment and lifecycle management of Cloud Foundry on OpenStack • OpenStack meets Cloud Foundry integration requirements, and is totally configurable and adaptable to handle the scale of a PaaS solution like Cloud Foundry Bottom Line: Cloud Foundry and OpenStack are a great match!
  • 24. 24 What’s next? Join us at our Silicon Valley Meetups http://www.meetup.com/Bluemix/ http://www.meetup.com/CloudFoundry/ For more technical details, refer to the slides and video here http://www.slideshare.net/AnimeshSingh/optimizing-cloud-foundry-and-openstack-for-large-scale-deployments https://www.openstack.org/assets/presentation-media/A-Practical-Approach-to-HA-Final.pdf https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jCwtV9n_ak4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FsrCGkBo4Vg