The Green Lab - [03 A] Experiment planning

1 Het begint met een idee
Experiment planning
Ivano Malavolta

Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam
Experiment planning
Context selection
Research questions and hypotheses formulation
Variables selection
Subjects selection
2 Ivano Malavolta / S2 group / Empirical software engineering
Roadmap

Recall

● Experiment scoping describes WHY we run an experiment
● The planning determines HOW the experiment will be executed
○ Be careful here → the result of the experiment can be disturbed (or
even destroyed) if not planned properly
Scoping VS planning

Planning phases
Scope of this
lecture

Context selection

We already heard about context...

CONTEXT: the environment in which the experiment is
performed
Our goal here is to achieve the most general results
→ optimum: large real software projects, with practitioners
Many risks involved….
Context selection

Context selection dimensions
RealityLab
● Off-line ● On-line
● Students ● Professionals
● Toy problem ● Real problem
● Specific ● General

Quick exercise
Think about the Progressive web app case study
and formulate a potential context for an experiment

Research questions and hypotheses formulation

Research questions detail the specific objectives of the empirical
study
Incepted from the study definition
Starting point to identify the variables of interest of your study
Research questions formulation

Research questions should be as clear as possible
→ they will guide the whole experiment
Avoid questions you cannot answer
○ What is the best JavaScript framework in terms of performance?
○ What is the most productive programming language?
○ ...
Golden words: to what extent..., what is the impact of X to Y,
what are the traits of Xs, what are the characteristics of T...
Remind that in your report you will come back to them and
explicitly answer each of them in details
Suggestions

Example: CHABADA

16
Example: CHABADA

17
Example: CHABADA

Example: CHABADA

From research questions to hypotheses
● When a research question is going to be addressed by
applying a statistical test, it would be helpful to formulate
an hypothesis
● Very useful to select what kind of statistical procedure you
need to use
Not needed in all cases

Hypotheses formulation
● Conjecture (P)
○ Administration of treatment has influence on some
feature
● Consequence (Q)
○ We observe a difference in terms of some feature
P → Q

Hypothesis: a formal statement about a phenomenon
● Null hypothesis H0
: no real trends or patterns in the
experiment setting (aka ~Q)
● Alternative hypothesis Ha
: there are real trends or
patterns in the experiment setting (aka Q)

Falsification (modus tollens)
● We aim at verifying the null hypothesis (~Q)
○ we test the null hypothesis H0
We can reject the null hypothesis → we can draw conclusions
This comes from Popper (1959): any statement in a scientific
field is true until anybody can contradict it
● Aiming at verifying Q is WRONG
○ Provides no insight on the conjecture

Example
● Question:
○ Do green algorithms improve software energy efficiency?
● Consequence (Q):
○ (when applying green algorithms) we observe a reduction
of energy consumption
● Conjecture (P):
○ applying green algorithms reduces energy consumption

Example
● Null hypothesis (￢Q): there is no reduction in terms of
energy consumption
H0
: mean(Ega
) >= mean(Enormal
)
● Alternative hypothesis (Q): the energy consumption
resulting from an application that uses green algorithms is
lower
Ha
: mean(Ega
) < mean(Enormal
)

What can happen now?
● We confirm the null hypothesis (~Q)
○ ~Q → ~P
○ our conjecture P has been falsified → green algorithms do
not reduce energy consumption (~P)
● We reject the null hypothesis (~Q)
○ Q = true
○ our conjecture P has been corroborated → we are more
confident that it is likely that green algorithms reduce energy
consumption (P)

Example 2

28
Other examples of hypotheses

Variables selection

Recap

Variables selection
● The choice of independent and dependent variables is
usually done in parallel
● Some variables cannot be measured directly (e.g.
productivity, code quality, effort...)
○ We use proxies to estimate them
■ proxies introduce a construct validity threat: is what we are
measuring a good representation of our variable?

Variables selection
● Independent variables should have some effect on the
dependent ones
→ do not choose variables randomly, think about your RQs
● After choosing the variables you have to define their types,
scales, ranges → this is part of measurement theory

● Often there is only 1 dependent variable (the main factor)
○ e.g., power consumption
● Often one level for the control group
○ e.g. use of old/traditional technique/tool
● One or more levels for experimental groups
○ e.g. use of new technique(s) tool(s)
Other independent variables are the co-factors

Our main factor is not the only variable influencing the dependent
variable(s)
○ e.g., network instability of your experimental environment, usage
patterns of the analysed website, skills of subjects, analyzed system,
experience of developers, ...
We will never account for all possible co-factors
Your best friend here is randomization
In a good experiment:
● limit their effect through a good experimental design
● able to separate their effect from main factors
● analyze the interaction with main factor
34
Co-factors

Example

Subjects selection

Subjects selection
● Population: the complete set of items of interest for our
experiment
○ e.g. open-source software applications
○ e.g., all existing progressive web apps
● Sample: representative selection of individuals for that
population
○ e.g. Apache, MySQL
○ e.g. progressive web apps mined from Alexa’s list

Sampling techniques
● Probability Sampling: the probability of selecting each
subject in the population is known
○ Simple Random Sampling: random selection from the population,
probability is 1/total
○ Stratified random sampling: the population is divided into groups
with a known distribution between the groups. Random sampling
is then applied within each group
● Non-probability sampling: the probability of selecting
each subject out of the population is unknown
○ Convenience: the most convenient (cost/distance/ complexity)
subjects are selected [usually it is the only way to go]
○ Quota: you select samples from groups of subjects (e.g. male vs
females, open-source vs closed source)

How big should be a sample?
● Sample size: the larger, the better (more general results)
● If the population has a high variation a larger sample size is
needed
● Data analysis may influence sample size
○ some statistical tests have meaning only on large
samples

You know how to:
● define the context of your experiment
● define research questions and hypotheses
● define independent and dependent variables
● strategies for selecting subjects
Next step
Measurement theory → how to define the “type” of variables
What this lecture means to you?

Readings
Chapter 8

Some contents of this part of lecture extracted from:
● Giuseppe Procaccianti’s lectures at VU
● Massimiliano Di Penta’s lectures at GSSI (Italy)
Acknowledgements

The Green Lab - [03 A] Experiment planning

More Related Content

What's hot (20)

Viewers also liked (13)

Similar to The Green Lab - [03 A] Experiment planning (20)

More from Ivano Malavolta (20)

Recently uploaded (20)

The Green Lab - [03 A] Experiment planning