“Now what’s going to happen to us without barbarians?
                  Those people were a kind of solution.”
                                                               - Cavafy (1904)



                                                  Maulik Bhadreshkumar Bhatt,
                                                  M.A. Part – II, Sem – IV,
                                                  Roll No - 03
                                                  Paper – E-E-405-D- The African Literature,
                                                  Unit – 03 – Waiting for the Barbarians,
                                                  Department of English,
                                                  Bhavnagar University.


24-Mar-12                       Department of English                                    1
 Self – Other Binary

 Magistrate / Colonel Joll
 Excavation of the nearby ruin of a former civilization
 Enigmatic washing and oiling “ritual” with a naked barbarian girl

 Alterity is Inter-subjective for him
 Self and other – inseparable – if distinct

Mikhail Bakhtin‟s view – self-other interdependence and interanimation

“I am conscious of myself only while revealing myself to another, through another, and
with the help of another… A person has no internal sovereign territory, he is wholly and
always on the boundary; looking inside himself, he looks into the eyes of another or with
the eyes of another… I cannot manage without another, I cannot become myself without
another; I must find myself in another by finding another in myself” (Shaffer, 134)

 Mutual reflection and mutual acceptance
 In order to understand – Locate outside – time, space and culture
 Life is Dialogical – to dialogue/commune



 24-Mar-12                             Department of English                                2
 Magistrate‟s relationship with a Barbarian Girl linked with that of Third Bureau‟s.
 Both trying to „trespass into the forbidden‟
 Girl – Indecipherable – unreadable – obscure – opaque – blank – incomplete


“There is only blankness and desolation that that there has to be such blankness”
(Coetzee, 79)


 Magistrate – A man who has lost his way long ago but presses on along a road that may
lead nowhere.
Anatomizes the difficulty faced by even the most well-intentioned Self in in
understanding and valuing the other


The empire projects its own barbarism onto the other beyond the borders



24-Mar-12                             Department of English                               3
References:
Cavafy, Constantine P. Waiting for the Barbarians, 1904, Print.
Coetzee, J.M., Waiting for the Barbarians, 79. 1980, Print.
Shaffer, W. Brian., Reading the Novel in English, 121-137, 2006, Print.




24-Mar-12                           Department of English                 4

More Related Content

PPTX
Politics of difference in 'Waiting for Barbarians'
PPT
A Million Lies
PPTX
Cultural studies barker & jane ch3
PPTX
Paper 09, roll no 03
PPTX
1.2.3.306.uma.dhara.maulik.bus.eng
PPTX
Bhatt maulik iv, 03, 2012
PPTX
hebreism and hellenism by matthew arnold
PPTX
Bhatt maulik o3
Politics of difference in 'Waiting for Barbarians'
A Million Lies
Cultural studies barker & jane ch3
Paper 09, roll no 03
1.2.3.306.uma.dhara.maulik.bus.eng
Bhatt maulik iv, 03, 2012
hebreism and hellenism by matthew arnold
Bhatt maulik o3

More from maulikbhatt (15)

PPTX
03.401.bhatt.maulik
PPTX
3.305.bhatt.maulik
PPTX
3.304.bhatt.maulik
PPTX
3.303.bhatt.maulik
PPTX
3.302.bhatt.maulik
PPT
3.301.bhatt.maulik
PPTX
Paper 10 a, roll no 03
PPTX
Paper 08, roll no 03
PPTX
Paper 07, roll no 03
PPTX
Paper 06, roll no 03
PPTX
Translation studies
PPTX
Fielding’s art of characterization
PPTX
Aristotle's poetics
PPTX
Hamlet
PPTX
My first ppt presentation
03.401.bhatt.maulik
3.305.bhatt.maulik
3.304.bhatt.maulik
3.303.bhatt.maulik
3.302.bhatt.maulik
3.301.bhatt.maulik
Paper 10 a, roll no 03
Paper 08, roll no 03
Paper 07, roll no 03
Paper 06, roll no 03
Translation studies
Fielding’s art of characterization
Aristotle's poetics
Hamlet
My first ppt presentation
Ad

Recently uploaded (20)

PDF
David L Page_DCI Research Study Journey_how Methodology can inform one's prac...
PDF
Empowerment Technology for Senior High School Guide
PDF
CISA (Certified Information Systems Auditor) Domain-Wise Summary.pdf
PPTX
Computer Architecture Input Output Memory.pptx
PDF
International_Financial_Reporting_Standa.pdf
PDF
Vision Prelims GS PYQ Analysis 2011-2022 www.upscpdf.com.pdf
PDF
Journal of Dental Science - UDMY (2021).pdf
PPTX
Module on health assessment of CHN. pptx
PDF
BP 704 T. NOVEL DRUG DELIVERY SYSTEMS (UNIT 2).pdf
PDF
Journal of Dental Science - UDMY (2022).pdf
PDF
English Textual Question & Ans (12th Class).pdf
PDF
CRP102_SAGALASSOS_Final_Projects_2025.pdf
PDF
LIFE & LIVING TRILOGY - PART - (2) THE PURPOSE OF LIFE.pdf
PDF
IP : I ; Unit I : Preformulation Studies
PPTX
What’s under the hood: Parsing standardized learning content for AI
DOCX
Cambridge-Practice-Tests-for-IELTS-12.docx
PDF
BP 704 T. NOVEL DRUG DELIVERY SYSTEMS (UNIT 1)
PPTX
A powerpoint presentation on the Revised K-10 Science Shaping Paper
PDF
Literature_Review_methods_ BRACU_MKT426 course material
PDF
BP 505 T. PHARMACEUTICAL JURISPRUDENCE (UNIT 2).pdf
David L Page_DCI Research Study Journey_how Methodology can inform one's prac...
Empowerment Technology for Senior High School Guide
CISA (Certified Information Systems Auditor) Domain-Wise Summary.pdf
Computer Architecture Input Output Memory.pptx
International_Financial_Reporting_Standa.pdf
Vision Prelims GS PYQ Analysis 2011-2022 www.upscpdf.com.pdf
Journal of Dental Science - UDMY (2021).pdf
Module on health assessment of CHN. pptx
BP 704 T. NOVEL DRUG DELIVERY SYSTEMS (UNIT 2).pdf
Journal of Dental Science - UDMY (2022).pdf
English Textual Question & Ans (12th Class).pdf
CRP102_SAGALASSOS_Final_Projects_2025.pdf
LIFE & LIVING TRILOGY - PART - (2) THE PURPOSE OF LIFE.pdf
IP : I ; Unit I : Preformulation Studies
What’s under the hood: Parsing standardized learning content for AI
Cambridge-Practice-Tests-for-IELTS-12.docx
BP 704 T. NOVEL DRUG DELIVERY SYSTEMS (UNIT 1)
A powerpoint presentation on the Revised K-10 Science Shaping Paper
Literature_Review_methods_ BRACU_MKT426 course material
BP 505 T. PHARMACEUTICAL JURISPRUDENCE (UNIT 2).pdf
Ad

03.405.bhatt.maulik

  • 1. “Now what’s going to happen to us without barbarians? Those people were a kind of solution.” - Cavafy (1904) Maulik Bhadreshkumar Bhatt, M.A. Part – II, Sem – IV, Roll No - 03 Paper – E-E-405-D- The African Literature, Unit – 03 – Waiting for the Barbarians, Department of English, Bhavnagar University. 24-Mar-12 Department of English 1
  • 2.  Self – Other Binary  Magistrate / Colonel Joll  Excavation of the nearby ruin of a former civilization  Enigmatic washing and oiling “ritual” with a naked barbarian girl  Alterity is Inter-subjective for him  Self and other – inseparable – if distinct Mikhail Bakhtin‟s view – self-other interdependence and interanimation “I am conscious of myself only while revealing myself to another, through another, and with the help of another… A person has no internal sovereign territory, he is wholly and always on the boundary; looking inside himself, he looks into the eyes of another or with the eyes of another… I cannot manage without another, I cannot become myself without another; I must find myself in another by finding another in myself” (Shaffer, 134)  Mutual reflection and mutual acceptance  In order to understand – Locate outside – time, space and culture  Life is Dialogical – to dialogue/commune 24-Mar-12 Department of English 2
  • 3.  Magistrate‟s relationship with a Barbarian Girl linked with that of Third Bureau‟s.  Both trying to „trespass into the forbidden‟  Girl – Indecipherable – unreadable – obscure – opaque – blank – incomplete “There is only blankness and desolation that that there has to be such blankness” (Coetzee, 79)  Magistrate – A man who has lost his way long ago but presses on along a road that may lead nowhere. Anatomizes the difficulty faced by even the most well-intentioned Self in in understanding and valuing the other The empire projects its own barbarism onto the other beyond the borders 24-Mar-12 Department of English 3
  • 4. References: Cavafy, Constantine P. Waiting for the Barbarians, 1904, Print. Coetzee, J.M., Waiting for the Barbarians, 79. 1980, Print. Shaffer, W. Brian., Reading the Novel in English, 121-137, 2006, Print. 24-Mar-12 Department of English 4