SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Chapter 27
        The C Programming Language


                       Bjarne Stroustrup
                    www.stroustrup.com/Programming




Dennis M. Ritchie
Abstract
   This lecture gives you the briefest introduction to C
    from a C++ point of view. If you need to use this
    language, read an introductory book (e.g. K&R). This
    lecture gives you a hint what to look for.
   C is C++’s closest relative, and compatible in many
    areas, so much of your C++ knowledge carries over.




                    Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11             2
Overview
   C and C++
   Function prototypes
   printf()/scanf()
   Arrays and strings
   Memory management
   Macros
   const
   C/C++ interoperability



                   Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11   3
dmr
                         C and C++
ken
bwk
bs
doug
…




    Both were “born” in the Computer Science Research Department of
     Bell Labs in Murray Hill, NJ
                        Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11                 4
Modern C and C++ are siblings




        Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11   5
C and C++
   In this talk, I use “C” to mean “ISO C89”
       That’s by far the most commonly used definition of C
            Classic C has mostly been replaced (though amazingly not completely)
            C99 is not yet widely used
   Source compatibility
       C is (almost) a subset of C++
            Example of exception: int f(int new, int class, int bool); /* ok in C */
       (Almost) all constructs that are both C and C++ have the same meaning
        (semantics) in both languages
            Example of exception: sizeof('a') /* 4 in C and 1 in C++ */
   Link compatibility
       C and C++ program fragments can be linked together in a single program
            And very often are
   C++ was designed to be “as close as possible to C, but no closer”
       For ease of transition
       For co-existence
       Most incompatibilities are related to C++’s stricter type checking
                              Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11                                   6
C and C++
   Both defined/controlled by ISO standards committees
       Separate committees
            Unfortunately, leading to incompatibilities
       Many supported implementations in use
       Available on more platforms than any other languages
   Both primarily aimed at and are heavily used for hard system
    programming tasks, such as
       Operating systems kernels
       Device drivers
       Embedded systems
       Compilers
       Communications systems


                             Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11               7
C and C++
   Here we
       assume you know C++ and how to use it
       describe the differences between C and C++
       describe how to program using the facilities offered by C
            Our ideal of programming and our techniques remain the same, but
             the tool available to express our ideas change
       describe a few C “traps and pitfalls”
       don’t go into all the details from the book
            Compatibility details are important, but rarely interesting




                            Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11                         8
C and C++
   C++ is a general-purpose programming language
    with a bias towards systems programming that
       is a better C
       supports data abstraction
       supports object-oriented programming
       supports generic programming


                       C:
                                Functions and structs
                                Machine model (basic types and operations)
                                Compilation and linkage model


                      Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11                            9
Missing in C (from a C++ perspective)
   Classes and member functions
        Use struct and global functions
   Derived classes and virtual functions
        Use struct , global functions, and pointers to functions
        You can do OOP in C, but not cleanly, and why would you want to?
        You can do GP in C, but why would you want to?
   Templates and inline functions
        Use macros
   Exceptions
        Use error-codes, error-return values, etc.
   Function overloading
        Give each function a separate name
   new/delete
        Use malloc()/free()
   References
        Use pointers
   const in constant expressions
        Use macros
                               Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11                      10
Missing in C (from a C++ perspective)
   With no classes, templates, and exceptions, C can’t
    provide most C++ standard library facilities
       Containers
            vector, map, set, string, etc.
            Use arrays and pointers
            Use macros (rather than parameterization with types)
       STL algorithms
            sort(), find(), copy(), …
            Not many alternatives
            use qsort() where you can
            Write your own, use 3rd party libraries
       Iostreams
            Use stdio: printf(), getch(), etc.
       Regular expression
            Use a 3rd party library

                              Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11               11
C and C++
   Lots of useful code is written in C
       Very few language features are essential
            In principle, you don’t need a high-level language, you could write
             everything in assembler (but why would you want to do that?)
   Emulate high-level programming techniques
       As directly supported by C++ but not C
   Write in the C subset of C++
       Compile in both languages to ensure consistency
   Use high compiler warning levels to catch type errors
   Use “lint” for large programs
       A “lint” is a consistency checking program
   C and C++ are equally efficient
       If you think you see a difference, suspect differences in default optimizer
        or linker settings Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11                             12
Functions
   There can be only one function of a given name
   Function argument type checking is optional
   There are no references (and therefore no pass-by-reference)
   There are no member functions
   There are no inline functions (except in C99)
   There is an alternative function definition syntax




                      Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11                      13
Function prototypes
                 (function argument checking is optional)

/* avoid these mistakes – use a compiler option that enforces C++ rules */
int g(int);       /* prototype – like C++ function declaration */
int h();          /* not a prototype – the argument types are unspecified */
int f(p,b) char* p; char b;            /* old style definition – not a prototype */
{ /* … */ }
int my_fct(int a, double d, char* p)         /* new style definition – a prototype */
{
    f();          /* ok by the compiler! But gives wrong/unexpected results */
    f(d,p);       /* ok by the compiler! But gives wrong/unexpected results */
    h(d);         /* ok by the compiler! But may give wrong/unexpected results */
    ff(d);        /* ok by the compiler! But may give wrong/unexpected results */
    g(p);         /* error: wrong type */
    g();          /* error: argument missing */
}
                              Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11                                 14
printf() – many people’s favorite C function
                                                                      Format string

/* no iostreams – use stdio */
#include<stdio.h>      /* defines int printf(const char* format, …); */

int main(void)
{
    printf("Hello, worldn");
    return 0;                                        Arguments to be formatted
}
void f(double d, char* s, int i, char ch)
{
   printf("double %g string %s int %i char %cn", d, s, i, ch);
   printf("goof %sn", i); /* uncaught error */
}

                                   Formatting characters
Format strings
                           Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11                                    15
scanf() and friends
/* the most popular input functions from <stdio.h>: */
int i = getchar(); /* note int, not char;
                       getchar() returns EOF when it reaches end of file */
p = gets();         /* read 'n' terminated line into char array pointed to by p */

void f(int* pi, char* pc, double* pd, char* ps)
{ /* read into variables whose addresses are passed as pointers: */
    scanf("%i %c %g %s", pi, pc, pd, ps);
    /* %s skips initial whitespace and is terminated by whitespace */
}
int i; char c; double d; char s[100]; f(&i, &c, &d, s); /* call to assign to i, c, d, and s */

   Don’t ever use gets() or scanf("%s")!
      Consider them poisoned
      They are the source of many security violations
      An overflow is easily arranged and easily exploitable
      Use getchar()


                               Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11                                    16
printf() and scanf() are not type safe

    double d = 0;
    int s = 0;
    printf("d: %d , s: %sn", d, s);      /* compiles and runs
                                             the result might surprise you */


                                   “s” for “string”

     “d” for “decimal”, not “double”
    Though error-prone, printf() is convenient for built-in types
    printf() formats are not extensible to user-defined types
        E.g. no %M for My_type values
    Beware: a printf () with a user-supplied format string is a cracker tool

                               Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11                          17
Arrays and pointers
   Defined almost exactly as in C++
   In C, you have to use them essentially all the time
       because there is no vector, map, string, etc.
   Remember
       An array doesn’t know how long it is
       There is no array assignment
            use memcpy()
       A C-style string is a zero-terminated array




                            Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11       18
C-style strings
   In C a string (called a C-string or a C-style string in C++
    literature) is a zero-terminated array of characters
    char* p = "asdf";
    char s[ ] = "asdf";



      p:                           'a'    's'    'd'    'f'    0


                             s:     'a'    's'    'd'    'f'   0




                          Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11                  19
C-style strings
   Comparing strings
    #include <string.h>
    if (s1 = = s2) {                   /* do s1 and s2 point to the same array?
                                          (typically not what you want) */
    }
    if (strcmp(s1,s2) = = 0) { /* do s1 and s2 hold the same characters? */
    }

   Finding the lengths of a string
    int lgt = strlen(s);    /* note: goes through the string at run time
                               looking for the terminating 0 */
   Copying strings
    strcpy(s1,s2);          /* copy characters from s2 into s1
                               be sure that s1 can hold that many characters */

                            Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11                               20
C-style strings
   The string copy function strcpy() is the archetypical
    C function (found in the ISO C standard library)
   Unless you understand the implementation below,
    don’t claim to understand C:

        char* strcpy(char *p, const char *q)
        {
            while (*p++ = *q++);
            return p;
        }


   For an explanation see for example K&R or TC++PL
                       Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11              21
Standard function libraries
   <stdio.h>     printf(), scanf(), etc.
   <string.h>   strcmp(), etc.
   <ctype.c>    isspace(), etc.
   <stdlib.h>   malloc(), etc.
   <math.h>     sqrt(), etc.


   Warning: By default, Microsoft tries to force you to use safer,
    but non-standard, alternatives to the unsafe C standard library
    functions




                         Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11                  22
Free store: malloc()/free()
#include<stdlib.h>
void f(int n) {
   /* malloc() takes a number of bytes as its argument */
   int* p = (int*)malloc(sizeof(int)*n);     /* allocate an array of n ints */
   /* … */
   free(p);       /* free() returns memory allocated by malloc() to free store */
}




                           Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11                            23
Free store: malloc()/free()
   Little compile-time checking
    /* malloc() returns a void*. You can leave out the cast of malloc(), but don’t
       */
    double* p = malloc(sizeof(int)*n);      /* probably a bug */
   Little run-time checking
    int* q = malloc(sizeof(int)*m); /* m ints */
    for (int i=0; i<n; ++i) init(q[i]);
   No initialization/cleanup
       malloc() doesn’t call constructors
       free() doesn’t call destructors
       Write and remember to use your own init() and cleanup()
   There is no way to ensure automatic cleanup
   Don’t use malloc()/free() in C++ programs
       new/delete are as fast and almostOct'11 better
                           Stroustrup/PPP - always                            24
Uncast malloc()
   The major C/C++ incompatibility in real-world code
       Not-type safe
       Historically a pre-standard C compatibility hack/feature
   Always controversial
       Unnecessarily so IMO

void* alloc(size_t x);      /* allocate x bytes
                              in C, but not in C++, void* converts to any T* */
void f (int n)
{
   int* p = alloc(n*sizeof(int));                 /* ok in C; error in C++ */
   int* q = (int*)alloc(n*sizeof(int));           /* ok in C and C++ */
   /* … */
}                         Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11                               25
void*
   Why does void* convert to T* in C but not in C++?
       C needs it to save you from casting the result of malloc()
       C++ does not: use new
   Why is a void* to T* conversion not type safe?
    void f()
      {
        char i = 0;
        char j = 0;
        char* p = &i;
        void* q = p;
        int* pp = q;       /* unsafe, legal C; error in C++ */
        *pp = -1;          /* overwrite memory starting at &i */
      }
                           Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11                   26
Comments
   // comments were introduced by Bjarne Stroustrup into C++
    from C’s ancestor BCPL when he got really fed up with typing
    /* … */ comments
   // comments are accepted by most C dialects including the new
    ISO standard C (C99)




                      Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11                  27
const
// in C, a const is never a compile time constant
const int max = 30;
const int x;        // const not initialized: ok in C (error in C++)

void f(int v)
{
   int a1[max]; // error: array bound not a constant (max is not a constant!)
   int a2[x];   // error: array bound not a constant (here you see why)
   switch (v) {
   case 1:
         // …
   case max:    // error: case label not a constant
         // …
   }
}                        Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11                           28
Instead of const use macros
#define max 30

void f(int v)
{
   int a1[max];   // ok
   switch (v) {
   case 1:
         // …
   case max:      // ok
         // …
   }
}



                          Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11   29
Beware of macros
#include "my_header.h"
// …
int max(int a, int b) { return a>=b?a:b; } // error: “obscure error message”

   As it happened my_header.h contained the macro max from the previous
    slide so what the compiler saw was
          int 30(int a, int b) { return a>=b?a:b; }
   No wonder it complained!
   There are tens of thousands of macros in popular header files.
   Always define macros with ALL_CAPS names, e.g.
         #define MY_MAX 30
    and never give anything but a macro an ALL_CAPS name
   Unfortunately, not everyone obeys the ALL_CAPS convention


                          Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11                        30
C/C++ interoperability
   Works because of shared linkage model
   Works because a shared model for simple objects
       built-in types and structs/classes
   Optimal/Efficient
       No behind-the-scenes reformatting/conversions




                        Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11         31
Calling C from C++
   Use extern "C" to tell the C++ compiler to use C calling
    conventions


       // calling C function from C++:

       extern "C" double sqrt(double);         // link as a C function

       void my_c_plus_plus_fct()
       {
                double sr = sqrt(2);
                // …
       }

                          Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11                        32
Calling C++ from C
   No special action is needed from the C compiler

    /* call C++ function from C: */

    int call_f(S* p, int i); /* call f for object pointed to by p with argument i */
    struct S* make_S(int x, const char* p); /* make S( x,p) on the free store */

    void my_c_fct(int i)
    {
                 /* … */
                 struct S* p = make_S(17, "foo");
                 int x = call_f(p,i);
                 /* … */
    }                     Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11                             33
Word counting example (C++ version)

#include<map>
#include<string>
#include<iostream>
using namespace std;
int main()
{
    map<string,int> m;
    string s;
    while (cin>>s) m[s]++;         // use getline() if you really want lines
    for(map<string,int>::iterator p = m.begin(); p!=m.end(); ++p)
         cout << p->first << " : " << p->second << "n";
}
                        Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11                                34
Word counting example (C version)
// word_freq.c
// Walter C. Daugherity

#include <stdio.h>
#include <stdlib.h>
 #include <string.h>

#define MAX_WORDS 1000 /* max unique words to count */
#define MAX_WORD_LENGTH 100

#define STR(s) #s            /* macros for scanf format */
#define XSTR(s) STR(s)

typedef struct record{
    char word[MAX_WORD_LENGTH + 1];
    int count;
} record;
                          Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11            35
Word counting example (C version)
int main()
{
    // … read words and build table …
    qsort(table, num_words, sizeof(record), strcmp);
    for(iter=0; iter<num_words; ++iter)
           printf("%s %dn",table[iter].word,table[iter].count);
    return EXIT_SUCCESS;
}




                         Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11                   36
Word counting example (most of main)
record table[MAX_WORDS + 1];
int num_words = 0;
char word[MAX_WORD_LENGTH + 1];
int iter;
while(scanf("%" XSTR(MAX_WORD_LENGTH) "s", word) != EOF) {
   for(iter = 0; iter < num_words && strcmp(table[iter].word, word); ++iter);
   if(iter == num_words) {
       strncpy(table[num_words].word, word, MAX_WORD_LENGTH + 1);
       table[num_words++].count = 1;
   }
   else table[iter].count++;
   if(num_words > MAX_WORDS){
       printf("table is fulln");
       return EXIT_FAILURE;
   }
}
                        Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11                                 37
Word counting example (C version)
   Comments
       In (some) colloquial C style (not written by BS)
       It’s so long and complicated! (my first reaction – BS)
       See, you don’t need any fancy and complicated language features!!!
        (not my comment – BS)
       IMHO not a very good problem for using C
            Not an atypical application, but not low-level systems programming
       It’s also C++ except that in C++, the argument to qsort() should be
        cast to its proper type:
            (int (*)(const void*, const void*))strcmp
       What are those macros doing?
       Maxes out at MAX_WORD words
       Doesn’t handle words longer than MAX_WORD_LENGTH
       First reads and then sorts
            Inherently slower than the colloquial C++ version (which uses a map)
                               Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11                              38
More information
   Kernighan & Ritchie: The C Programming Language
        The classic
   Stroustrup: TC++PL, Appendix B: Compatibility
        C/C++ incompatibilities, on my home pages
   Stroustrup: Learning Standard C++ as a New Language.
        Style and technique comparisons
        www.research.att.com/~bs/new_learning.pdf
   Lots of book reviews: www.accu.org




                            Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11        39

More Related Content

PDF
C programming day#1
PPT
Csdfsadf
PDF
RAII and ScopeGuard
PPT
Glimpses of C++0x
PPT
PDF
Object-Oriented Programming in Modern C++. Borislav Stanimirov. CoreHard Spri...
PDF
Difference between c# generics and c++ templates
C programming day#1
Csdfsadf
RAII and ScopeGuard
Glimpses of C++0x
Object-Oriented Programming in Modern C++. Borislav Stanimirov. CoreHard Spri...
Difference between c# generics and c++ templates

What's hot (20)

PDF
(8) cpp abstractions separated_compilation_and_binding_part_i
PDF
TDD in C - Recently Used List Kata
DOCX
C LANGUAGE UNIT-1 PREPARED BY MVB REDDY
DOCX
C language tutorial
PDF
C fundamentals
PPT
Introduction to c programming
PDF
An Execution-Semantic and Content-and-Context-Based Code-Clone Detection and ...
PPTX
C Programming Language Tutorial for beginners - JavaTpoint
PPTX
C and C ++ Training in Ambala ! BATRA COMPUTER CENTRE
PDF
C++ idioms by example (Nov 2008)
PDF
Differences between c and c++
PPTX
C vs c++
PPT
13 graph classes_2
PDF
02 c++g3 d
PPTX
C vs c++
DOC
Basic c
PPTX
C Programming Language Step by Step Part 1
PDF
AspectC++: Language Proposal and Prototype Implementation
PDF
08 -functions
(8) cpp abstractions separated_compilation_and_binding_part_i
TDD in C - Recently Used List Kata
C LANGUAGE UNIT-1 PREPARED BY MVB REDDY
C language tutorial
C fundamentals
Introduction to c programming
An Execution-Semantic and Content-and-Context-Based Code-Clone Detection and ...
C Programming Language Tutorial for beginners - JavaTpoint
C and C ++ Training in Ambala ! BATRA COMPUTER CENTRE
C++ idioms by example (Nov 2008)
Differences between c and c++
C vs c++
13 graph classes_2
02 c++g3 d
C vs c++
Basic c
C Programming Language Step by Step Part 1
AspectC++: Language Proposal and Prototype Implementation
08 -functions
Ad

Viewers also liked (7)

PPT
PPT
C tutorial
PPTX
English Class
PPT
Letterwriting ppt
ODP
An introduction to KOER December 2013
PDF
Study: The Future of VR, AR and Self-Driving Cars
PDF
Hype vs. Reality: The AI Explainer
C tutorial
English Class
Letterwriting ppt
An introduction to KOER December 2013
Study: The Future of VR, AR and Self-Driving Cars
Hype vs. Reality: The AI Explainer
Ad

Similar to 27 c (20)

PPT
THE C PROGRAMMING LANGUAGE PPT CONTAINS THE BASICS OF C
PPT
27_C.ppt
PDF
C som-programmeringssprog-bt
PPTX
cmp104 lec 8
PDF
Essential c
PDF
Essential c
PDF
Essential c
PDF
Essential c
PDF
Essential c notes singh projects
PDF
C++primer
PPTX
High performance computing seminar1.pptx
PDF
88 c-programs
PDF
88 c programs 15184
PPTX
C101 – Intro to Programming with C
PPTX
C++ l 1
PPT
PDF
Fundamentals C programming and strong your skills.
PDF
basicsCC++1.pdf in Pakistan and its parts
PDF
01Introsystem programming to study computer .pdf
THE C PROGRAMMING LANGUAGE PPT CONTAINS THE BASICS OF C
27_C.ppt
C som-programmeringssprog-bt
cmp104 lec 8
Essential c
Essential c
Essential c
Essential c
Essential c notes singh projects
C++primer
High performance computing seminar1.pptx
88 c-programs
88 c programs 15184
C101 – Intro to Programming with C
C++ l 1
Fundamentals C programming and strong your skills.
basicsCC++1.pdf in Pakistan and its parts
01Introsystem programming to study computer .pdf

Recently uploaded (20)

PPTX
Modernising the Digital Integration Hub
PPTX
O2C Customer Invoices to Receipt V15A.pptx
PDF
DP Operators-handbook-extract for the Mautical Institute
PPTX
TLE Review Electricity (Electricity).pptx
PDF
A contest of sentiment analysis: k-nearest neighbor versus neural network
PDF
NewMind AI Weekly Chronicles – August ’25 Week III
PPTX
TechTalks-8-2019-Service-Management-ITIL-Refresh-ITIL-4-Framework-Supports-Ou...
PPTX
Tartificialntelligence_presentation.pptx
PDF
project resource management chapter-09.pdf
PDF
Univ-Connecticut-ChatGPT-Presentaion.pdf
PDF
Assigned Numbers - 2025 - Bluetooth® Document
PDF
WOOl fibre morphology and structure.pdf for textiles
PDF
Hindi spoken digit analysis for native and non-native speakers
PDF
How ambidextrous entrepreneurial leaders react to the artificial intelligence...
PDF
A novel scalable deep ensemble learning framework for big data classification...
PDF
gpt5_lecture_notes_comprehensive_20250812015547.pdf
PDF
Getting started with AI Agents and Multi-Agent Systems
PPTX
Chapter 5: Probability Theory and Statistics
PDF
Enhancing emotion recognition model for a student engagement use case through...
PPTX
OMC Textile Division Presentation 2021.pptx
Modernising the Digital Integration Hub
O2C Customer Invoices to Receipt V15A.pptx
DP Operators-handbook-extract for the Mautical Institute
TLE Review Electricity (Electricity).pptx
A contest of sentiment analysis: k-nearest neighbor versus neural network
NewMind AI Weekly Chronicles – August ’25 Week III
TechTalks-8-2019-Service-Management-ITIL-Refresh-ITIL-4-Framework-Supports-Ou...
Tartificialntelligence_presentation.pptx
project resource management chapter-09.pdf
Univ-Connecticut-ChatGPT-Presentaion.pdf
Assigned Numbers - 2025 - Bluetooth® Document
WOOl fibre morphology and structure.pdf for textiles
Hindi spoken digit analysis for native and non-native speakers
How ambidextrous entrepreneurial leaders react to the artificial intelligence...
A novel scalable deep ensemble learning framework for big data classification...
gpt5_lecture_notes_comprehensive_20250812015547.pdf
Getting started with AI Agents and Multi-Agent Systems
Chapter 5: Probability Theory and Statistics
Enhancing emotion recognition model for a student engagement use case through...
OMC Textile Division Presentation 2021.pptx

27 c

  • 1. Chapter 27 The C Programming Language Bjarne Stroustrup www.stroustrup.com/Programming Dennis M. Ritchie
  • 2. Abstract  This lecture gives you the briefest introduction to C from a C++ point of view. If you need to use this language, read an introductory book (e.g. K&R). This lecture gives you a hint what to look for.  C is C++’s closest relative, and compatible in many areas, so much of your C++ knowledge carries over. Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 2
  • 3. Overview  C and C++  Function prototypes  printf()/scanf()  Arrays and strings  Memory management  Macros  const  C/C++ interoperability Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 3
  • 4. dmr C and C++ ken bwk bs doug …  Both were “born” in the Computer Science Research Department of Bell Labs in Murray Hill, NJ Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 4
  • 5. Modern C and C++ are siblings Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 5
  • 6. C and C++  In this talk, I use “C” to mean “ISO C89”  That’s by far the most commonly used definition of C  Classic C has mostly been replaced (though amazingly not completely)  C99 is not yet widely used  Source compatibility  C is (almost) a subset of C++  Example of exception: int f(int new, int class, int bool); /* ok in C */  (Almost) all constructs that are both C and C++ have the same meaning (semantics) in both languages  Example of exception: sizeof('a') /* 4 in C and 1 in C++ */  Link compatibility  C and C++ program fragments can be linked together in a single program  And very often are  C++ was designed to be “as close as possible to C, but no closer”  For ease of transition  For co-existence  Most incompatibilities are related to C++’s stricter type checking Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 6
  • 7. C and C++  Both defined/controlled by ISO standards committees  Separate committees  Unfortunately, leading to incompatibilities  Many supported implementations in use  Available on more platforms than any other languages  Both primarily aimed at and are heavily used for hard system programming tasks, such as  Operating systems kernels  Device drivers  Embedded systems  Compilers  Communications systems Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 7
  • 8. C and C++  Here we  assume you know C++ and how to use it  describe the differences between C and C++  describe how to program using the facilities offered by C  Our ideal of programming and our techniques remain the same, but the tool available to express our ideas change  describe a few C “traps and pitfalls”  don’t go into all the details from the book  Compatibility details are important, but rarely interesting Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 8
  • 9. C and C++  C++ is a general-purpose programming language with a bias towards systems programming that  is a better C  supports data abstraction  supports object-oriented programming  supports generic programming C:  Functions and structs  Machine model (basic types and operations)  Compilation and linkage model Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 9
  • 10. Missing in C (from a C++ perspective)  Classes and member functions  Use struct and global functions  Derived classes and virtual functions  Use struct , global functions, and pointers to functions  You can do OOP in C, but not cleanly, and why would you want to?  You can do GP in C, but why would you want to?  Templates and inline functions  Use macros  Exceptions  Use error-codes, error-return values, etc.  Function overloading  Give each function a separate name  new/delete  Use malloc()/free()  References  Use pointers  const in constant expressions  Use macros Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 10
  • 11. Missing in C (from a C++ perspective)  With no classes, templates, and exceptions, C can’t provide most C++ standard library facilities  Containers  vector, map, set, string, etc.  Use arrays and pointers  Use macros (rather than parameterization with types)  STL algorithms  sort(), find(), copy(), …  Not many alternatives  use qsort() where you can  Write your own, use 3rd party libraries  Iostreams  Use stdio: printf(), getch(), etc.  Regular expression  Use a 3rd party library Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 11
  • 12. C and C++  Lots of useful code is written in C  Very few language features are essential  In principle, you don’t need a high-level language, you could write everything in assembler (but why would you want to do that?)  Emulate high-level programming techniques  As directly supported by C++ but not C  Write in the C subset of C++  Compile in both languages to ensure consistency  Use high compiler warning levels to catch type errors  Use “lint” for large programs  A “lint” is a consistency checking program  C and C++ are equally efficient  If you think you see a difference, suspect differences in default optimizer or linker settings Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 12
  • 13. Functions  There can be only one function of a given name  Function argument type checking is optional  There are no references (and therefore no pass-by-reference)  There are no member functions  There are no inline functions (except in C99)  There is an alternative function definition syntax Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 13
  • 14. Function prototypes (function argument checking is optional) /* avoid these mistakes – use a compiler option that enforces C++ rules */ int g(int); /* prototype – like C++ function declaration */ int h(); /* not a prototype – the argument types are unspecified */ int f(p,b) char* p; char b; /* old style definition – not a prototype */ { /* … */ } int my_fct(int a, double d, char* p) /* new style definition – a prototype */ { f(); /* ok by the compiler! But gives wrong/unexpected results */ f(d,p); /* ok by the compiler! But gives wrong/unexpected results */ h(d); /* ok by the compiler! But may give wrong/unexpected results */ ff(d); /* ok by the compiler! But may give wrong/unexpected results */ g(p); /* error: wrong type */ g(); /* error: argument missing */ } Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 14
  • 15. printf() – many people’s favorite C function Format string /* no iostreams – use stdio */ #include<stdio.h> /* defines int printf(const char* format, …); */ int main(void) { printf("Hello, worldn"); return 0; Arguments to be formatted } void f(double d, char* s, int i, char ch) { printf("double %g string %s int %i char %cn", d, s, i, ch); printf("goof %sn", i); /* uncaught error */ } Formatting characters Format strings Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 15
  • 16. scanf() and friends /* the most popular input functions from <stdio.h>: */ int i = getchar(); /* note int, not char; getchar() returns EOF when it reaches end of file */ p = gets(); /* read 'n' terminated line into char array pointed to by p */ void f(int* pi, char* pc, double* pd, char* ps) { /* read into variables whose addresses are passed as pointers: */ scanf("%i %c %g %s", pi, pc, pd, ps); /* %s skips initial whitespace and is terminated by whitespace */ } int i; char c; double d; char s[100]; f(&i, &c, &d, s); /* call to assign to i, c, d, and s */  Don’t ever use gets() or scanf("%s")!  Consider them poisoned  They are the source of many security violations  An overflow is easily arranged and easily exploitable  Use getchar() Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 16
  • 17. printf() and scanf() are not type safe double d = 0; int s = 0; printf("d: %d , s: %sn", d, s); /* compiles and runs the result might surprise you */ “s” for “string” “d” for “decimal”, not “double”  Though error-prone, printf() is convenient for built-in types  printf() formats are not extensible to user-defined types  E.g. no %M for My_type values  Beware: a printf () with a user-supplied format string is a cracker tool Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 17
  • 18. Arrays and pointers  Defined almost exactly as in C++  In C, you have to use them essentially all the time  because there is no vector, map, string, etc.  Remember  An array doesn’t know how long it is  There is no array assignment  use memcpy()  A C-style string is a zero-terminated array Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 18
  • 19. C-style strings  In C a string (called a C-string or a C-style string in C++ literature) is a zero-terminated array of characters char* p = "asdf"; char s[ ] = "asdf"; p: 'a' 's' 'd' 'f' 0 s: 'a' 's' 'd' 'f' 0 Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 19
  • 20. C-style strings  Comparing strings #include <string.h> if (s1 = = s2) { /* do s1 and s2 point to the same array? (typically not what you want) */ } if (strcmp(s1,s2) = = 0) { /* do s1 and s2 hold the same characters? */ }  Finding the lengths of a string int lgt = strlen(s); /* note: goes through the string at run time looking for the terminating 0 */  Copying strings strcpy(s1,s2); /* copy characters from s2 into s1 be sure that s1 can hold that many characters */ Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 20
  • 21. C-style strings  The string copy function strcpy() is the archetypical C function (found in the ISO C standard library)  Unless you understand the implementation below, don’t claim to understand C: char* strcpy(char *p, const char *q) { while (*p++ = *q++); return p; }  For an explanation see for example K&R or TC++PL Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 21
  • 22. Standard function libraries  <stdio.h> printf(), scanf(), etc.  <string.h> strcmp(), etc.  <ctype.c> isspace(), etc.  <stdlib.h> malloc(), etc.  <math.h> sqrt(), etc.  Warning: By default, Microsoft tries to force you to use safer, but non-standard, alternatives to the unsafe C standard library functions Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 22
  • 23. Free store: malloc()/free() #include<stdlib.h> void f(int n) { /* malloc() takes a number of bytes as its argument */ int* p = (int*)malloc(sizeof(int)*n); /* allocate an array of n ints */ /* … */ free(p); /* free() returns memory allocated by malloc() to free store */ } Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 23
  • 24. Free store: malloc()/free()  Little compile-time checking /* malloc() returns a void*. You can leave out the cast of malloc(), but don’t */ double* p = malloc(sizeof(int)*n); /* probably a bug */  Little run-time checking int* q = malloc(sizeof(int)*m); /* m ints */ for (int i=0; i<n; ++i) init(q[i]);  No initialization/cleanup  malloc() doesn’t call constructors  free() doesn’t call destructors  Write and remember to use your own init() and cleanup()  There is no way to ensure automatic cleanup  Don’t use malloc()/free() in C++ programs  new/delete are as fast and almostOct'11 better Stroustrup/PPP - always 24
  • 25. Uncast malloc()  The major C/C++ incompatibility in real-world code  Not-type safe  Historically a pre-standard C compatibility hack/feature  Always controversial  Unnecessarily so IMO void* alloc(size_t x); /* allocate x bytes in C, but not in C++, void* converts to any T* */ void f (int n) { int* p = alloc(n*sizeof(int)); /* ok in C; error in C++ */ int* q = (int*)alloc(n*sizeof(int)); /* ok in C and C++ */ /* … */ } Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 25
  • 26. void*  Why does void* convert to T* in C but not in C++?  C needs it to save you from casting the result of malloc()  C++ does not: use new  Why is a void* to T* conversion not type safe? void f() { char i = 0; char j = 0; char* p = &i; void* q = p; int* pp = q; /* unsafe, legal C; error in C++ */ *pp = -1; /* overwrite memory starting at &i */ } Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 26
  • 27. Comments  // comments were introduced by Bjarne Stroustrup into C++ from C’s ancestor BCPL when he got really fed up with typing /* … */ comments  // comments are accepted by most C dialects including the new ISO standard C (C99) Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 27
  • 28. const // in C, a const is never a compile time constant const int max = 30; const int x; // const not initialized: ok in C (error in C++) void f(int v) { int a1[max]; // error: array bound not a constant (max is not a constant!) int a2[x]; // error: array bound not a constant (here you see why) switch (v) { case 1: // … case max: // error: case label not a constant // … } } Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 28
  • 29. Instead of const use macros #define max 30 void f(int v) { int a1[max]; // ok switch (v) { case 1: // … case max: // ok // … } } Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 29
  • 30. Beware of macros #include "my_header.h" // … int max(int a, int b) { return a>=b?a:b; } // error: “obscure error message”  As it happened my_header.h contained the macro max from the previous slide so what the compiler saw was int 30(int a, int b) { return a>=b?a:b; }  No wonder it complained!  There are tens of thousands of macros in popular header files.  Always define macros with ALL_CAPS names, e.g. #define MY_MAX 30 and never give anything but a macro an ALL_CAPS name  Unfortunately, not everyone obeys the ALL_CAPS convention Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 30
  • 31. C/C++ interoperability  Works because of shared linkage model  Works because a shared model for simple objects  built-in types and structs/classes  Optimal/Efficient  No behind-the-scenes reformatting/conversions Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 31
  • 32. Calling C from C++  Use extern "C" to tell the C++ compiler to use C calling conventions // calling C function from C++: extern "C" double sqrt(double); // link as a C function void my_c_plus_plus_fct() { double sr = sqrt(2); // … } Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 32
  • 33. Calling C++ from C  No special action is needed from the C compiler /* call C++ function from C: */ int call_f(S* p, int i); /* call f for object pointed to by p with argument i */ struct S* make_S(int x, const char* p); /* make S( x,p) on the free store */ void my_c_fct(int i) { /* … */ struct S* p = make_S(17, "foo"); int x = call_f(p,i); /* … */ } Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 33
  • 34. Word counting example (C++ version) #include<map> #include<string> #include<iostream> using namespace std; int main() { map<string,int> m; string s; while (cin>>s) m[s]++; // use getline() if you really want lines for(map<string,int>::iterator p = m.begin(); p!=m.end(); ++p) cout << p->first << " : " << p->second << "n"; } Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 34
  • 35. Word counting example (C version) // word_freq.c // Walter C. Daugherity #include <stdio.h> #include <stdlib.h> #include <string.h> #define MAX_WORDS 1000 /* max unique words to count */ #define MAX_WORD_LENGTH 100 #define STR(s) #s /* macros for scanf format */ #define XSTR(s) STR(s) typedef struct record{ char word[MAX_WORD_LENGTH + 1]; int count; } record; Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 35
  • 36. Word counting example (C version) int main() { // … read words and build table … qsort(table, num_words, sizeof(record), strcmp); for(iter=0; iter<num_words; ++iter) printf("%s %dn",table[iter].word,table[iter].count); return EXIT_SUCCESS; } Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 36
  • 37. Word counting example (most of main) record table[MAX_WORDS + 1]; int num_words = 0; char word[MAX_WORD_LENGTH + 1]; int iter; while(scanf("%" XSTR(MAX_WORD_LENGTH) "s", word) != EOF) { for(iter = 0; iter < num_words && strcmp(table[iter].word, word); ++iter); if(iter == num_words) { strncpy(table[num_words].word, word, MAX_WORD_LENGTH + 1); table[num_words++].count = 1; } else table[iter].count++; if(num_words > MAX_WORDS){ printf("table is fulln"); return EXIT_FAILURE; } } Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 37
  • 38. Word counting example (C version)  Comments  In (some) colloquial C style (not written by BS)  It’s so long and complicated! (my first reaction – BS)  See, you don’t need any fancy and complicated language features!!! (not my comment – BS)  IMHO not a very good problem for using C  Not an atypical application, but not low-level systems programming  It’s also C++ except that in C++, the argument to qsort() should be cast to its proper type:  (int (*)(const void*, const void*))strcmp  What are those macros doing?  Maxes out at MAX_WORD words  Doesn’t handle words longer than MAX_WORD_LENGTH  First reads and then sorts  Inherently slower than the colloquial C++ version (which uses a map) Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 38
  • 39. More information  Kernighan & Ritchie: The C Programming Language  The classic  Stroustrup: TC++PL, Appendix B: Compatibility  C/C++ incompatibilities, on my home pages  Stroustrup: Learning Standard C++ as a New Language.  Style and technique comparisons  www.research.att.com/~bs/new_learning.pdf  Lots of book reviews: www.accu.org Stroustrup/PPP - Oct'11 39