And You Welcomed Me - Reflection Questions
Download as PPT, PDF0 likes651 views
The document discusses the church's unique perspective on migration and its implications for the immigration debate, emphasizing the theological basis for viewing migrants through a lens of hospitality and solidarity. It suggests exercises for reflection and engagement, such as reading pastoral letters, watching films, and evaluating personal experiences and assumptions about immigration. The document also encourages exploration of the roles of stakeholders in migration and the concept of 'authentic development' as it relates to economic and social contributions by immigrants.
And You Welcomed Me - Reflection Questions
- 2. Rev. Lo Biondo and Rev. Ryscavage contend that the Church has a unique and broader perspective on migration and refugees than many others who comment on this phenomenon. How do the assumptions and even the language used by the Church in discussing migration differ from that used by economists, politicians and others?
- 3. What assumptions do you bring to a conversation about immigration? How does your faith inform those assumptions?
- 4. What role do you think is appropriate for the Church - both clergy and the laity - to play in the current immigration debate? Why?
- 5. ADDITIONAL EXERCISE Read the 2003 Pastoral Letter by the US and Mexican Bishops: Strangers No Longer: Together on the Journey of Hope http://www.usccb.org/mrs/stranger.shtml
- 6. Reflect upon and imagine the Judgment Day passage in the Bible (Matthew 25:31-45). Imagine being Christ as a stranger; or one of those assembled. Consider acting the passage out as a group and discussing how you feel playing the roles.
- 11. Take some time to reflect upon the barriers in our lives: barriers between ourselves and our newcomer neighbors; barriers between our lives and our God; barriers between the way we (as US residents) view immigrants and the way we (as people of faith) view immigrants. What lies behind many of these barriers?
- 12. What are the basic theological premises for the Church’s teaching on migration, as expressed by Rev. Groody?
- 13. How does migration serve as a metaphor for faith? Does this resound with your faith experience? Why or why not?
- 14. ADDITIONAL EXERCISE: Watch Rev. Groody’s film Dying to Live and use the discussion guide to explore it further. Dying to Live http://www.dyingtolive.nd.edu
- 15. What are two explanations as to why people migrate? Do you know any immigrants and the reasons they migrated? Consider sharing one or two of their stories.
- 16. What risks and sacrifices do migrants make in order to migrate? Have you ever made a similar life-altering sacrifice? If so, how did it impact your family? Faith? Fortune?
- 17. Consider the primary and secondary interests of stakeholders in migration: the migrant himself/herself; the migrant’s family; sending and receiving communities, and sending and receiving governments, businesses who hire them, etc. Construct a chart illustrating the primary and secondary interests of the stakeholders. What interests do all stakeholders share? How do their priorities differ? Given your analysis of these interests, what do they suggest to you about the principle of subsidiarity?
- 18. ADDITIONAL EXERCISE: Listen to the webcast of the CATO Institute: Immigrants: Your Country Needs Them about the book by that title by Philippe Legrain. The webcast addresses many of the economic concerns regarding immigration. http://www.cato.org/event.php?eventid=3894
- 19. What is meant by the concept of “authentic development”? How is it distinct from purely economic development?
- 20. How does the concept of “authentic development” impact your perception of poverty, at home and abroad? Your thoughts about your government’s policy priorities?
- 21. How do immigrants contribute to their home communities? Do they contribute to the common good and, if so, in what ways?
- 22. ADDITIONAL EXERCISE: Watch the film Fast Food Nation . Discuss the role immigrants play in the United States’ food industry. Discuss also the risks migrants take on their journeys and while working in the United States.
- 23. Some have defined citizenship as “the right to have rights.” Yet the US Constitution and Catholic social thought assert that rights are inherent in all people regardless of their legal status. Discuss this contradiction and its implications for migrants and US immigration policy.
- 24. The Church acknowledges that undocumented immigrants have broken the law, but teaches that people must provide for their families and seek to keep them together. How does this teaching apply to a person like Don Chuy?
- 25. Kerwin notes that security experts in the United States after September 11, 2001, called for a “draining of the swamp” (i.e. legalizing unauthorized migrants) in order to allow law enforcement to focus its attention on individuals who present a danger (e.g. drug smugglers, human traffickers, terrorists). Does this change your perspective on immigration and security? Discuss.
- 26. ADDITIONAL EXERCISE: Watch the film The Visitor and use the discussion guide by Education for Justice: http://www.educationforjustice.org/system/files/TheVisitor08.pdf
- 27. Discuss the migration of your ancestors to the United States. (You may have to do a little research.) Were they among the marginalized Irish or Italian-Catholics? Did they arrive before or after visa quotas were set in 1924? How did your ancestors and subsequent generations mainstream into American culture?
- 28. Gerschutz and Lorentzen posit that churches have a vital role to play in integrating migrants–from a socio-cultural, pastoral, and theological perspective. Does your church have experience with programs to integrate newcomers? If so, how has this changed your community? What tensions have you had to confront? What gifts have newcomers and diverse ethnicities brought to your community. If not, is there an opportunity to enhance interaction between newcomers and your community?
- 29. ADDITIONAL EXERCISE: Attend mass in a language you don’t understand. What new stands out to you about the mass? In what ways do you feel like an outsider? An insider?
- 30. What do you understand hospitality to mean? How does it differ with the concept of solidarity?
- 31. Rev. O’Neill posits that hospitality to and solidarity with the stranger among us is central to our faith–indeed, what it means to be Christian. Discuss.
- 32. ADDITIONAL EXERCISE: Reflect upon and imagine the biblical passage of the Good Samaritan (Luke 10:25-37). Imagine being the Samaritan in the story; or the lawyer; or the priest. Consider acting the passage out as a group and discussing how you feel playing the roles.