Chapter 1: Thinking
    Critically with
Psychological Science
      Aaron Biggar
     AP Psychology
I. The Need for
Psychological Science
98% Certainty
1. The area of the US in square miles?
2. The population of Afghanistan in 2001?
3. American battle deaths in Spanish-
   American War?
4. GM advertising budget in 1999?
5. Female officers in US Army in 2000?
98% Certainty
1.   Area of US:          3.6 million sq. miles
2.   Afghan population:   26.8 million
3.   Battle deaths:       385
4.   GM advertising:      $2.9 billion
5.   Female officers:     9.953
I. The Need for Psychological Science
A. Limits of intuition and common sense
   1. Hindsight bias
   2. Overconfidence
I. The Need for Psychological Science
A. Limits of intuition and common sense
B. Scientific attitude
C. Scientific method
   1. Theory & hypothesis
   2. Operational definitions
   3. Replication
   4. Goals:
II. Description
II. Description
A. Case studies
B. Surveys (questionnaires & interviews)
   1. Wording effects
72% interested in “plants & trees”
39% interested in “botany”

62% whites agree “problems faced by blacks
brought on by blacks themselves” (white
interviewer)
46% whites agree with black interviewer

A majority oppose an amendment
“prohibiting abortions”
A majority support “protecting the life of an
unborn child”
1. Is the Mississippi River longer or
   shorter than 500 miles?

2. How many miles long is it?
1. Is the Mississippi River longer or
   shorter than 3000 miles?

2. How many miles long is it?
II. Description
A. Case studies
B. Surveys (questionnaires & interviews)
   1. Wording effects
   2. Samples & populations
      a. False consensus & other biases
      b. Random & representative
         techinques
Ap psy methods, stats
II. Description
A. Case studies
B. Surveys (questionnaires & interviews)
C. Naturalistic observation & observer
   effects
III. Correlation
III. Correlation
A. Positive & negative
B. Scatterplots
Ap psy methods, stats
III. Correlation
A. Positive & negative
B. Scatterplots
C. Correlation coefficient (r)
III. Correlation
A. Positive & negative
B. Scatterplots
C. Correlation coefficient (r)
D. Causation v. predictive value




Correlation between TV watching & GPA
Ap psy methods, stats
Ap psy methods, stats
Ap psy methods, stats
III. Correlation
A. Positive & negative
B. Scatterplots
C. Correlation coefficient (r)
D. Causation v. predictive value
E. Illusory correlation
F. Order in random events
IV. Experimentation
IV. Experimentation
Purpose of an expt:
General hypothesis: food effects learning
Specific (operationalized) hypothesis:
students who eat an oatmeal raisin cookie
before class each day will have higher
average scores on the semester final than
students who don’t eat a cookie.
Eating cookies before class each day will
lead to higher average scores.

Variables:
     Independent (IV)
           Controlled by experimenter
           The “cause” variable

    Dependent (DV)
        Predicted by experimenter
        The “effect” variable
Eating cookies before class each day
will lead to higher average scores.
What if kids get cookies and A’s?
Groups (conditions): to establish different
levels of the IV
     Experimental group
           Exposed to IV
           Get cookie
     Control group
     Not exposed to IV
     No cookie
Eating cookies before class each day
 will lead to higher average scores.
                               Confounding
               IV        DV
                                Variables

Expt. Gp.    Cookie      95%   Environmental

Cntrl. Gp.   No Cookie   82%   Expectations

                               Individual
                               differences
Random Sampling
    To select participants from population
    Allows you generalize results


Random Assignment
    To divide participants into groups
    Controls confounding variables
Eating cookies before class each day
 will lead to higher average scores.
               IV        DV

Expt. Gp.    Cookie      95%
Cntrl. Gp.   No Cookie   82%

                         85%

                         93%
Statistical Significance
p value
  likelihood a result is caused by chance
  can be no greater than 5%
  p ≤ .05
Replication
 Non-replicated results are preliminary.

 Linus Pauling (1970). Vitamin C prevents
 colds.
            IV          DV

Expt. Gp.    Vit C       Expt. Gp.
                           45%
Cntrl. Gp.   Placebo    Fewer colds
Experimental Design Terms
•   Hypothesis
•   Operational definitions
•   Participant selection
•   IV & DV
•   Experimental & control groups
•   Confounding variables
•   Random assignment
•   Placebo control
•   Double blind procedure
•   Statistical significance (p value)
•   Replication
Quasi-experiments
• Men are better drivers than women.
• Cigarette smoking causes lung cancer.
V. Statistical Reasoning
V. Statistical Reasoning
A. Describing data
   1. Frequency distributions
Multiple Choice                            Composite
                            Essay
13 A+ 40                                13    A+
12 A 39      4 41%        A 12 23 52%   12     A 11 39%
      38    11           A- 11 10       11    A- 14
11 A- 37    11           B+ 10 15       10    B+ 9
10 B+ 36     6           B 9 5 41%       9    B 12 45%
 9 B 35      4 31%       B- 8 6          8    B- 8
      34     5           C+ 7 2          7    C+ 2
 8 B- 33     5           C 6 1 5%        6    C+ 2 11%
 7 C+ 32     4           C- 5            5    C- 3
 6 C 31      3 19%       D+ 4 2          4    D+
      30     3           D 3      3%     3    D 3 5%
 5 C- 29     2           D- 2            2    D-
 4 D+ 28                  F 1     0%     1     F    0%
 3 D 27      4      8%       0
      26     1                                Mean=9.3
 2 D- 25                   Mean=10.2           SD=2.3
 1 F 24             2%      SD=2.0
      <24    1

   Mean=34.3
    SD=4.2
V. Statistical Reasoning
A. Describing data
   1. Frequency distributions
   2. Histograms & frequency polygons
Histogram
                         50
Percentage of students
                         40

                         30

                         20

                         10

                         0
                              A      B            C   D
                                         Grades
Frequency Polygon
                         50
Percentage of students
                         40

                         30

                         20

                         10

                         0
                              A   B            C   D
                                      Grades
V. Statistical Reasoning
A. Describing data
B. Measures of central tendency

      Mode=most common=4
4     Mean=arithmetic average=20/5=4
3
5     Median=middle score=4
4
4
Central Tendency
     1968 TOPPS Baseball Cards
Nolan Ryan         $1500     Elston Howard         $2.25
Billy Williams     $8        Jim Bouton            $2
Luis Aparicio      $5        Rocky Colavito        $2
Harmon Killebrew   $5        Boog Powell           $2
Orlando Cepeda     $3.50     Luis Tiant            $2
Maury Wills        $3.50     Tim McCarver          $1.75
Jim Bunning        $3        Tug McGraw            $1.75
Tony Conigliaro    $3        Joe Torre             $1.5
Tony Oliva         $3        Rusty Staub           $1.25
Lou Pinella        $3        Curt Flood            $1
Mickey Lolich      $2.50
                           With Ryan:         Without Ryan:
                           Median=$2.50       Median=$2.38
                           Mean=$74.14        Mean=$2.85
Ap psy methods, stats
V. Statistical Reasoning
A. Describing data
B. Measures of central tendency
C. Measures of variation
   1. Range
   2. Variance & standard deviation
Standard Deviation
  Punt    Deviation    Deviation
Distance from Mean     Squared

  36        -4            16       std. dev.=
  38        -2             4
                                   variance=
  41        +1             1
  45        +5            25
                                   11.5=3.4 yds
Mean=                     46
160/4=
40 yds                46/4=11.5=
                       variance
V. Statistical Reasoning
A. Describing data
B. Measures of central tendency
C. Measures of variation
D. Characteristics of the normal curve
V. Statistical Reasoning
A. Describing data
B. Measures of central tendency
C. Measures of variation
D. Characteristics of the normal curve
E. Inference
    1. Does the sample represent the pop.?
       a. Non-biased sample-good
       b. Low variability-good
       c. Larger samples-good
V. Statistical Reasoning
E. Inference
    1. Does the sample represent the pop.?
    2. Are differences between groups
       statistically significant?
       a. Big differences-good
       b. Low variability-good
       c. Big groups-good
VI. FAQs
VI. FAQs
A. Can lab expts illuminate real life?
B. Does behavior depend on one’s culture?
C. Does behavior vary with gender?
D. Why do psychologists study animals?
E. Is it ethical to experiment on animals?
F. Is it ethical to experiment on people?
G. Is psychology free of value judgments?
H. Is psychology potentially dangerous?
VI. FAQs
F. Is it ethical to experiment on people?
   Yes, if the APA’s ethical guidelines are
   followed.
    1. Informed consent
    2. Protection from harm
    3. Confidentiality
    4. Debriefing
How should participants be
            chosen?
• Good answers use and make clear your
  understanding of the terms “sample” and
  “population.”
• Good answers explain how to draw a
  random sample.
• Ex. “All the assembly line workers for a
  company could be the population. I would
  draw a random sample of 40 of them by
  picking names from a hat.”
Create operationalized hypothesis
• Good answers make an educated guess
  (“Workers who are complimented will work
  harder”)
• Good answers develop specific, measurable
  ways to define compliments and hard work.
• Ex. “10 compliments will be given at 4 specific
  times.” “Supervisors will give compliments from
  a pre-developed list.” “Hard work will be
  measured by using the number of items
  produced each hour.”
Identify IV & DV
• IV=compliments
• DV=work effort
• Do not propose a direction when stating
  the variable (“the DV is an increase in
  work.”)
• People are never the variables (“the IV is
  the people who get complimented.”)
Describe the groups
• Experimental group gets compliments.
• Control group doesn’t get compliments.
• Use the terms!
Confounding variables
• Do not confuse random assignment with
  random sampling.
• Be reasonable!!!
• “The company policy will be to have
  people sleep in a hotel with no TV or
  radio.”
• “I will provide a seminar on the importance
  of sleep.”
• “All workers must be paid the same.”

More Related Content

PPT
2008 pratice exam answers
PDF
Prologue & Chapter 1 AP Psychology
PDF
Systems
DOCX
Chap3.consciousness
PPT
AP Psych Review
PPTX
Operant conditioning quiz answers
PDF
Bcba supervision form
PPTX
Intro
2008 pratice exam answers
Prologue & Chapter 1 AP Psychology
Systems
Chap3.consciousness
AP Psych Review
Operant conditioning quiz answers
Bcba supervision form
Intro

Viewers also liked (13)

DOCX
Chapter9.meetingessentials
PPTX
Psychology Snowmen
PPT
Chapter 13 Personality
PPT
Prologue, Myers Psychology 9e
PPT
Ch. 7 AP Psych
PPT
Psychology Therapy
PPT
PPT
Psychological Disorders
PPT
Chapter 1, Myers Psychology 9e
PPT
CH 4 Nature Nurture
PPT
Chapter 2, Myers Psychology 9e
PPT
Ch. 12: Emotions, Stress, & Health
PPTX
Statistics
Chapter9.meetingessentials
Psychology Snowmen
Chapter 13 Personality
Prologue, Myers Psychology 9e
Ch. 7 AP Psych
Psychology Therapy
Psychological Disorders
Chapter 1, Myers Psychology 9e
CH 4 Nature Nurture
Chapter 2, Myers Psychology 9e
Ch. 12: Emotions, Stress, & Health
Statistics
Ad

Similar to Ap psy methods, stats (20)

PPTX
Analyzing quantitative
PDF
Rm psych stats & graphs
PPT
Intro statistics
PPTX
Introduction-to-Statistics.pptx
PDF
Gaise pre k-12_full
PDF
Nov 4 Normal Distribution
PPTX
Basic Statistics
PPTX
Chahine Hypothesis Testing,
DOCX
104774013 mb0040-mb0040-–-statistics-for-management-november-2012
PPTX
Basic statistics
PPTX
ppt01. A review to statistics and probability.pptx
DOCX
Check your solutions from the practice. Please be sure you f.docx
PDF
PPTX
REVIEWCOMPREHENSIVE-EXAM. BY bjohn MBpptx
PPT
Advanced statistics for librarians
DOC
Module stats
DOC
Module
PPT
Statistics trinity college
PPT
Statistics trinity college
PPT
Chapter 3
Analyzing quantitative
Rm psych stats & graphs
Intro statistics
Introduction-to-Statistics.pptx
Gaise pre k-12_full
Nov 4 Normal Distribution
Basic Statistics
Chahine Hypothesis Testing,
104774013 mb0040-mb0040-–-statistics-for-management-november-2012
Basic statistics
ppt01. A review to statistics and probability.pptx
Check your solutions from the practice. Please be sure you f.docx
REVIEWCOMPREHENSIVE-EXAM. BY bjohn MBpptx
Advanced statistics for librarians
Module stats
Module
Statistics trinity college
Statistics trinity college
Chapter 3
Ad

Ap psy methods, stats

  • 1. Chapter 1: Thinking Critically with Psychological Science Aaron Biggar AP Psychology
  • 2. I. The Need for Psychological Science
  • 3. 98% Certainty 1. The area of the US in square miles? 2. The population of Afghanistan in 2001? 3. American battle deaths in Spanish- American War? 4. GM advertising budget in 1999? 5. Female officers in US Army in 2000?
  • 4. 98% Certainty 1. Area of US: 3.6 million sq. miles 2. Afghan population: 26.8 million 3. Battle deaths: 385 4. GM advertising: $2.9 billion 5. Female officers: 9.953
  • 5. I. The Need for Psychological Science A. Limits of intuition and common sense 1. Hindsight bias 2. Overconfidence
  • 6. I. The Need for Psychological Science A. Limits of intuition and common sense B. Scientific attitude C. Scientific method 1. Theory & hypothesis 2. Operational definitions 3. Replication 4. Goals:
  • 8. II. Description A. Case studies B. Surveys (questionnaires & interviews) 1. Wording effects
  • 9. 72% interested in “plants & trees” 39% interested in “botany” 62% whites agree “problems faced by blacks brought on by blacks themselves” (white interviewer) 46% whites agree with black interviewer A majority oppose an amendment “prohibiting abortions” A majority support “protecting the life of an unborn child”
  • 10. 1. Is the Mississippi River longer or shorter than 500 miles? 2. How many miles long is it?
  • 11. 1. Is the Mississippi River longer or shorter than 3000 miles? 2. How many miles long is it?
  • 12. II. Description A. Case studies B. Surveys (questionnaires & interviews) 1. Wording effects 2. Samples & populations a. False consensus & other biases b. Random & representative techinques
  • 14. II. Description A. Case studies B. Surveys (questionnaires & interviews) C. Naturalistic observation & observer effects
  • 16. III. Correlation A. Positive & negative B. Scatterplots
  • 18. III. Correlation A. Positive & negative B. Scatterplots C. Correlation coefficient (r)
  • 19. III. Correlation A. Positive & negative B. Scatterplots C. Correlation coefficient (r) D. Causation v. predictive value Correlation between TV watching & GPA
  • 23. III. Correlation A. Positive & negative B. Scatterplots C. Correlation coefficient (r) D. Causation v. predictive value E. Illusory correlation F. Order in random events
  • 25. IV. Experimentation Purpose of an expt: General hypothesis: food effects learning Specific (operationalized) hypothesis: students who eat an oatmeal raisin cookie before class each day will have higher average scores on the semester final than students who don’t eat a cookie.
  • 26. Eating cookies before class each day will lead to higher average scores. Variables: Independent (IV) Controlled by experimenter The “cause” variable Dependent (DV) Predicted by experimenter The “effect” variable
  • 27. Eating cookies before class each day will lead to higher average scores. What if kids get cookies and A’s? Groups (conditions): to establish different levels of the IV Experimental group Exposed to IV Get cookie Control group Not exposed to IV No cookie
  • 28. Eating cookies before class each day will lead to higher average scores. Confounding IV DV Variables Expt. Gp. Cookie 95% Environmental Cntrl. Gp. No Cookie 82% Expectations Individual differences
  • 29. Random Sampling To select participants from population Allows you generalize results Random Assignment To divide participants into groups Controls confounding variables
  • 30. Eating cookies before class each day will lead to higher average scores. IV DV Expt. Gp. Cookie 95% Cntrl. Gp. No Cookie 82% 85% 93%
  • 31. Statistical Significance p value likelihood a result is caused by chance can be no greater than 5% p ≤ .05
  • 32. Replication Non-replicated results are preliminary. Linus Pauling (1970). Vitamin C prevents colds. IV DV Expt. Gp. Vit C Expt. Gp. 45% Cntrl. Gp. Placebo Fewer colds
  • 33. Experimental Design Terms • Hypothesis • Operational definitions • Participant selection • IV & DV • Experimental & control groups • Confounding variables • Random assignment • Placebo control • Double blind procedure • Statistical significance (p value) • Replication
  • 34. Quasi-experiments • Men are better drivers than women. • Cigarette smoking causes lung cancer.
  • 36. V. Statistical Reasoning A. Describing data 1. Frequency distributions
  • 37. Multiple Choice Composite Essay 13 A+ 40 13 A+ 12 A 39 4 41% A 12 23 52% 12 A 11 39% 38 11 A- 11 10 11 A- 14 11 A- 37 11 B+ 10 15 10 B+ 9 10 B+ 36 6 B 9 5 41% 9 B 12 45% 9 B 35 4 31% B- 8 6 8 B- 8 34 5 C+ 7 2 7 C+ 2 8 B- 33 5 C 6 1 5% 6 C+ 2 11% 7 C+ 32 4 C- 5 5 C- 3 6 C 31 3 19% D+ 4 2 4 D+ 30 3 D 3 3% 3 D 3 5% 5 C- 29 2 D- 2 2 D- 4 D+ 28 F 1 0% 1 F 0% 3 D 27 4 8% 0 26 1 Mean=9.3 2 D- 25 Mean=10.2 SD=2.3 1 F 24 2% SD=2.0 <24 1 Mean=34.3 SD=4.2
  • 38. V. Statistical Reasoning A. Describing data 1. Frequency distributions 2. Histograms & frequency polygons
  • 39. Histogram 50 Percentage of students 40 30 20 10 0 A B C D Grades
  • 40. Frequency Polygon 50 Percentage of students 40 30 20 10 0 A B C D Grades
  • 41. V. Statistical Reasoning A. Describing data B. Measures of central tendency Mode=most common=4 4 Mean=arithmetic average=20/5=4 3 5 Median=middle score=4 4 4
  • 42. Central Tendency 1968 TOPPS Baseball Cards Nolan Ryan $1500 Elston Howard $2.25 Billy Williams $8 Jim Bouton $2 Luis Aparicio $5 Rocky Colavito $2 Harmon Killebrew $5 Boog Powell $2 Orlando Cepeda $3.50 Luis Tiant $2 Maury Wills $3.50 Tim McCarver $1.75 Jim Bunning $3 Tug McGraw $1.75 Tony Conigliaro $3 Joe Torre $1.5 Tony Oliva $3 Rusty Staub $1.25 Lou Pinella $3 Curt Flood $1 Mickey Lolich $2.50 With Ryan: Without Ryan: Median=$2.50 Median=$2.38 Mean=$74.14 Mean=$2.85
  • 44. V. Statistical Reasoning A. Describing data B. Measures of central tendency C. Measures of variation 1. Range 2. Variance & standard deviation
  • 45. Standard Deviation Punt Deviation Deviation Distance from Mean Squared 36 -4 16 std. dev.= 38 -2 4 variance= 41 +1 1 45 +5 25 11.5=3.4 yds Mean= 46 160/4= 40 yds 46/4=11.5= variance
  • 46. V. Statistical Reasoning A. Describing data B. Measures of central tendency C. Measures of variation D. Characteristics of the normal curve
  • 47. V. Statistical Reasoning A. Describing data B. Measures of central tendency C. Measures of variation D. Characteristics of the normal curve E. Inference 1. Does the sample represent the pop.? a. Non-biased sample-good b. Low variability-good c. Larger samples-good
  • 48. V. Statistical Reasoning E. Inference 1. Does the sample represent the pop.? 2. Are differences between groups statistically significant? a. Big differences-good b. Low variability-good c. Big groups-good
  • 50. VI. FAQs A. Can lab expts illuminate real life? B. Does behavior depend on one’s culture? C. Does behavior vary with gender? D. Why do psychologists study animals? E. Is it ethical to experiment on animals? F. Is it ethical to experiment on people? G. Is psychology free of value judgments? H. Is psychology potentially dangerous?
  • 51. VI. FAQs F. Is it ethical to experiment on people? Yes, if the APA’s ethical guidelines are followed. 1. Informed consent 2. Protection from harm 3. Confidentiality 4. Debriefing
  • 52. How should participants be chosen? • Good answers use and make clear your understanding of the terms “sample” and “population.” • Good answers explain how to draw a random sample. • Ex. “All the assembly line workers for a company could be the population. I would draw a random sample of 40 of them by picking names from a hat.”
  • 53. Create operationalized hypothesis • Good answers make an educated guess (“Workers who are complimented will work harder”) • Good answers develop specific, measurable ways to define compliments and hard work. • Ex. “10 compliments will be given at 4 specific times.” “Supervisors will give compliments from a pre-developed list.” “Hard work will be measured by using the number of items produced each hour.”
  • 54. Identify IV & DV • IV=compliments • DV=work effort • Do not propose a direction when stating the variable (“the DV is an increase in work.”) • People are never the variables (“the IV is the people who get complimented.”)
  • 55. Describe the groups • Experimental group gets compliments. • Control group doesn’t get compliments. • Use the terms!
  • 56. Confounding variables • Do not confuse random assignment with random sampling. • Be reasonable!!! • “The company policy will be to have people sleep in a hotel with no TV or radio.” • “I will provide a seminar on the importance of sleep.” • “All workers must be paid the same.”