SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Application Profiling
          for
Memory & Performance
Srinath Perera   Pradeep Fernando   Dinuka Malalanayke
  WSO2 Inc           WSO2 Inc           WSO2 Inc
Understanding Server Performance
When Concurrency Increases?
•   Throughput increases, but where will it stop?
•   When there are contention for the server
•   Contention for what?
    o   CPU
    o   Memory
    o   Disk - I/O
    o   Network -I/O
•   If your server running on full capacity, there should be at
    least one resource under contention.
How to measure Contention?

•   CPU - CPU or load average
•   Memory - GC logs, monitor memory, sometime swapping
•   Disk I/O - IOPS per seconds, load average
•   Network I/O - network utilization, load average
•   What is load average? length of processor queue of the OS
•   How much load average is too much?
    o   Load average = number of cores (machine is fully used)
    o   Load average = 2* number of cores (machine is loaded)
If you cannot find contention
•   Either load is too small
•   You have too much locks. Look for lock profile
•   Server might be processing with too less threads (IO and
    CPU thread switches)
Performance Tuning
•   Increase throughput/ latency or both
•   Know that latency vs. throughput is often a tradeoff
•   Run the system and see how it does, make sure you are
    putting in enough load
•   Verify where is the bottleneck? is it CPU, memory, network,
    or disk
•   Start tuning
Tuning

•   When you tune, bottlenecks will shift, you will have to shift
    your focus
•   Can you tune settings (Application, JVM, OS) to improve and
    shift the bottleneck? play with parameters .. we call this
    parameter sweep
•   Then focus on the code, look for right profile
    o   CPU profile
    o   Memory/ Allocation profile
    o   Network profile
    o   IO profile
    o   Database profile
Programmer Nightmares
Programmer Nightmares

                  ClassCastException
                        Permgen Errors
            DeadLocks
                           NullPointer
     Unacceptable Latency
     CPU spin       OutofMemoryException
            ArrayIndexOutOfBoundsException

[image] http://www1.free-clipart.net/gallery2/clipart/Holidays/Halloween/Ghost_-_Boo.jpg
Introducing: Profiling...


•   Best thing would be to write bug free, high performant code
•   Normally development happens in iterative manner - get
    something to work and improve on that.
•   Basic profiling can help you to eliminate most of the memory
    and performance issues.
Right Tools...
•       There are many commercial and open source tools
•       We are going to use,
         o       Jprofiler by ejTechnologies
                     CPU, Memory, Allocation, Network, DB
         o       Eclipse Memory Analyzer tool
                     Find memory leaks
         o       Standard JDK tooling - Jconsole
                     Basic stats




    [image] http://writingsongs.com/pictures/toolbox.jpg
Environment Setup
    With WSO2 Carbon
Setting up JProfiler
•   Profiling modes local/remote
•   Applying common filters for WSO2 products
•   Different views..
JProfiler Contd.
CPU view
 - Call trees, Hot spots
Memory view
 - Allocation Hot spots, Recorded objects, Heap walker
VM telemetry view
 - Memory, Threads status graphs
Probes
  - JDBC , Sockets
JConsole
•   Connect to the running instance local/remote
•   Different memory banks
•   Getting most out of Mbeans.
•   Getting a memory dump and analyzing with Eclipse MAT.
•   Remote JMX URL gets printed in the console during server
    startup:

       JMX Service URL : service:jmx:rmi://localhost:11111/jndi/rmi://localhost:9999/jmxrmi
       username : admin password : admin
JConsole
Memory Analyzer Tool
•   Analyze heap dumps.
•   Identifying OOM issues are trivial with basic leak report.
Usual Suspects

 Some of the common issues...
Permgen Errors
•   Permgen space relates to the 'Programme code' part, a.k.a -
    Loaded classes.
•   ClassLoader leaks
•   Typically happens in Container environments
•   Can uncover by doing deploy/redeploy cycles.
•   If one of the application objects get referenced by an object,
    outside the application, permgen error waiting to happen.
Permgen Errors

Container

                  URLClassLoader              Application




                                       Application Objects
    Container provided
         Objects
Memory Leaks - OOM
•   Languages like C, gave the control of memory to the
    programmer.
•   Java is a managed memory, language.
•   Still the JVM can't free up the memory, if the application is
    holding on to the objects.
•   Unnecessary accumulation of objects,
    o   Object creation for each and every connection
    o   Slow output rate in the input/output system
    o   Collecting clusterwide messages without an upper bound.
DeadLocks

                          Resource A




                          Resource B




•   Re-designing the lock acquiring sequence
•   Using LockManagers that keeps track of lock acquisition
Liveness issues...


•   Starvation - A thread can starve for CPU cycles, if it is
    blocked by a lock-wait.
•   Poor Responsiveness
•   LiveLock scenarios
Programming Best Practices


•   Think about memory aspects/ data retrieval process while
    writing code.
•   Optimize the critical Path (look at CPU profile).
•   Make use of Standard libs as much as possible.
•   Profile your apps before releasing them to production.
WSO2 make use of profiling ?
Identity Server - Losing weight




• Carbon server optimized to run in constrained memory
  environment.
• No front end components - 'createWorker' ant task.
• Selective Admin service loading. -Doptimized=true
• Removed unwanted functionality based on the use-case,
  (p2 - provisioning, etc)
Raspberry-Pi Clusters


   •   Application server
       cluster running on R-
       Pis.
   •   Powering the
       WSO2Con 2013
       mobile app
   •   512MB of RAM and
       ARM processor.
Demo

CPU spin and Memory leak scenario
Questions
Thank You

More Related Content

PPT
How To Scale v2
PDF
Marketing Automation at Scale: How Marketo Solved Key Data Management Challen...
PPTX
X-DB Replication Server and MMR
PDF
PostreSQL HA and DR Setup & Use Cases
PDF
Storing and processing data with the wso2 platform
PDF
Azure appfabric caching intro and tips
PDF
KoprowskiT_SPBizConference_2AMaDisasterJustBegan
PPTX
From distributed caches to in-memory data grids
How To Scale v2
Marketing Automation at Scale: How Marketo Solved Key Data Management Challen...
X-DB Replication Server and MMR
PostreSQL HA and DR Setup & Use Cases
Storing and processing data with the wso2 platform
Azure appfabric caching intro and tips
KoprowskiT_SPBizConference_2AMaDisasterJustBegan
From distributed caches to in-memory data grids

What's hot (20)

PDF
Postgres on OpenStack
 
PDF
Evaluating NoSQL Performance: Time for Benchmarking
PDF
Java troubleshooting thread dump
PDF
Distributed Caching Essential Lessons (Ts 1402)
PPTX
Dell emc back up solution in azure cloud
PDF
The Java Content Repository
PDF
MariaDB on Docker
PDF
A Tale of 2 Systems
PPTX
IaaS for DBAs in Azure
PDF
SAP HANA System Replication (HSR) versus SAP Replication Server (SRS)
PDF
Built-in Replication in PostgreSQL
PDF
Remote DBA Experts SQL Server 2008 New Features
PDF
004 architecture andadvanceduse
PDF
Best Practices of HA and Replication of PostgreSQL in Virtualized Environments
PDF
Power BI with Essbase in the Oracle Cloud
PDF
Scalable Integration with JBoss Fuse
PPTX
001 hbase introduction
PDF
Scaling Out Tier Based Applications
PDF
Enterprise PostgreSQL - EDB's answer to conventional Databases
PPTX
System design for video streaming service
Postgres on OpenStack
 
Evaluating NoSQL Performance: Time for Benchmarking
Java troubleshooting thread dump
Distributed Caching Essential Lessons (Ts 1402)
Dell emc back up solution in azure cloud
The Java Content Repository
MariaDB on Docker
A Tale of 2 Systems
IaaS for DBAs in Azure
SAP HANA System Replication (HSR) versus SAP Replication Server (SRS)
Built-in Replication in PostgreSQL
Remote DBA Experts SQL Server 2008 New Features
004 architecture andadvanceduse
Best Practices of HA and Replication of PostgreSQL in Virtualized Environments
Power BI with Essbase in the Oracle Cloud
Scalable Integration with JBoss Fuse
001 hbase introduction
Scaling Out Tier Based Applications
Enterprise PostgreSQL - EDB's answer to conventional Databases
System design for video streaming service
Ad

Similar to Application Profiling for Memory and Performance (20)

PPTX
Application Profiling for Memory and Performance
PDF
Deployment
KEY
Deployment Strategy
KEY
Deployment Strategies (Mongo Austin)
KEY
Deployment Strategies
PPTX
Attack on the Core
PDF
"You Don't Know NODE.JS" by Hengki Mardongan Sihombing (Urbanhire)
PPTX
Using the big guns: Advanced OS performance tools for troubleshooting databas...
PPTX
Fastest Servlets in the West
PPTX
Computer system organization
PPT
Compilers and interpreters
PDF
Experiences with Debugging Data Races
PDF
TechGIG_Memory leaks in_java_webnair_26th_july_2012
PDF
Machine Learning With H2O vs SparkML
PPTX
Azug - successfully breeding rabits
PDF
NSC #2 - D3 02 - Peter Hlavaty - Attack on the Core
PPTX
Scaling apps for the big time
PPTX
Spark Tips & Tricks
PDF
Oracle WebLogic Diagnostics & Perfomance tuning
PPTX
Ice Age melting down: Intel features considered usefull!
Application Profiling for Memory and Performance
Deployment
Deployment Strategy
Deployment Strategies (Mongo Austin)
Deployment Strategies
Attack on the Core
"You Don't Know NODE.JS" by Hengki Mardongan Sihombing (Urbanhire)
Using the big guns: Advanced OS performance tools for troubleshooting databas...
Fastest Servlets in the West
Computer system organization
Compilers and interpreters
Experiences with Debugging Data Races
TechGIG_Memory leaks in_java_webnair_26th_july_2012
Machine Learning With H2O vs SparkML
Azug - successfully breeding rabits
NSC #2 - D3 02 - Peter Hlavaty - Attack on the Core
Scaling apps for the big time
Spark Tips & Tricks
Oracle WebLogic Diagnostics & Perfomance tuning
Ice Age melting down: Intel features considered usefull!
Ad

More from WSO2 (20)

PDF
Demystifying CMS-0057-F - Compliance Made Seamless with WSO2
PDF
Quantum Threats Are Closer Than You Think – Act Now to Stay Secure
PDF
Modern Platform Engineering with Choreo - The AI-Native Internal Developer Pl...
PDF
Application Modernization with Choreo - The AI-Native Internal Developer Plat...
PDF
Build Smarter, Deliver Faster with Choreo - An AI Native Internal Developer P...
PDF
Platformless Modernization with Choreo.pdf
PDF
Application Modernization with Choreo for the BFSI Sector
PDF
Choreo - The AI-Native Internal Developer Platform as a Service: Overview
PDF
[Roundtable] Choreo - The AI-Native Internal Developer Platform as a Service
PPTX
WSO2Con 2025 - Building AI Applications in the Enterprise (Part 1)
PPTX
WSO2Con 2025 - Building Secure Business Customer and Partner Experience (B2B)...
PPTX
WSO2Con 2025 - Building Secure Customer Experience Apps
PPTX
WSO2Con 2025 - AI-Driven API Design, Development, and Consumption with Enhanc...
PPTX
WSO2Con 2025 - AI-Driven API Design, Development, and Consumption with Enhanc...
PPTX
WSO2Con 2025 - Unified Management of Ingress and Egress Across Multiple API G...
PPTX
WSO2Con 2025 - How an Internal Developer Platform Lets Developers Focus on Code
PPTX
WSO2Con 2025 - Architecting Cloud-Native Applications
PDF
Mastering Intelligent Digital Experiences with Platformless Modernization
PDF
Accelerate Enterprise Software Engineering with Platformless
PDF
WSO2Con2024 - WSO2's IAM Vision: Identity-Led Digital Transformation
Demystifying CMS-0057-F - Compliance Made Seamless with WSO2
Quantum Threats Are Closer Than You Think – Act Now to Stay Secure
Modern Platform Engineering with Choreo - The AI-Native Internal Developer Pl...
Application Modernization with Choreo - The AI-Native Internal Developer Plat...
Build Smarter, Deliver Faster with Choreo - An AI Native Internal Developer P...
Platformless Modernization with Choreo.pdf
Application Modernization with Choreo for the BFSI Sector
Choreo - The AI-Native Internal Developer Platform as a Service: Overview
[Roundtable] Choreo - The AI-Native Internal Developer Platform as a Service
WSO2Con 2025 - Building AI Applications in the Enterprise (Part 1)
WSO2Con 2025 - Building Secure Business Customer and Partner Experience (B2B)...
WSO2Con 2025 - Building Secure Customer Experience Apps
WSO2Con 2025 - AI-Driven API Design, Development, and Consumption with Enhanc...
WSO2Con 2025 - AI-Driven API Design, Development, and Consumption with Enhanc...
WSO2Con 2025 - Unified Management of Ingress and Egress Across Multiple API G...
WSO2Con 2025 - How an Internal Developer Platform Lets Developers Focus on Code
WSO2Con 2025 - Architecting Cloud-Native Applications
Mastering Intelligent Digital Experiences with Platformless Modernization
Accelerate Enterprise Software Engineering with Platformless
WSO2Con2024 - WSO2's IAM Vision: Identity-Led Digital Transformation

Application Profiling for Memory and Performance

  • 1. Application Profiling for Memory & Performance Srinath Perera Pradeep Fernando Dinuka Malalanayke WSO2 Inc WSO2 Inc WSO2 Inc
  • 3. When Concurrency Increases? • Throughput increases, but where will it stop? • When there are contention for the server • Contention for what? o CPU o Memory o Disk - I/O o Network -I/O • If your server running on full capacity, there should be at least one resource under contention.
  • 4. How to measure Contention? • CPU - CPU or load average • Memory - GC logs, monitor memory, sometime swapping • Disk I/O - IOPS per seconds, load average • Network I/O - network utilization, load average • What is load average? length of processor queue of the OS • How much load average is too much? o Load average = number of cores (machine is fully used) o Load average = 2* number of cores (machine is loaded)
  • 5. If you cannot find contention • Either load is too small • You have too much locks. Look for lock profile • Server might be processing with too less threads (IO and CPU thread switches)
  • 6. Performance Tuning • Increase throughput/ latency or both • Know that latency vs. throughput is often a tradeoff • Run the system and see how it does, make sure you are putting in enough load • Verify where is the bottleneck? is it CPU, memory, network, or disk • Start tuning
  • 7. Tuning • When you tune, bottlenecks will shift, you will have to shift your focus • Can you tune settings (Application, JVM, OS) to improve and shift the bottleneck? play with parameters .. we call this parameter sweep • Then focus on the code, look for right profile o CPU profile o Memory/ Allocation profile o Network profile o IO profile o Database profile
  • 9. Programmer Nightmares ClassCastException Permgen Errors DeadLocks NullPointer Unacceptable Latency CPU spin OutofMemoryException ArrayIndexOutOfBoundsException [image] http://www1.free-clipart.net/gallery2/clipart/Holidays/Halloween/Ghost_-_Boo.jpg
  • 10. Introducing: Profiling... • Best thing would be to write bug free, high performant code • Normally development happens in iterative manner - get something to work and improve on that. • Basic profiling can help you to eliminate most of the memory and performance issues.
  • 11. Right Tools... • There are many commercial and open source tools • We are going to use, o Jprofiler by ejTechnologies  CPU, Memory, Allocation, Network, DB o Eclipse Memory Analyzer tool  Find memory leaks o Standard JDK tooling - Jconsole  Basic stats [image] http://writingsongs.com/pictures/toolbox.jpg
  • 12. Environment Setup With WSO2 Carbon
  • 13. Setting up JProfiler • Profiling modes local/remote • Applying common filters for WSO2 products • Different views..
  • 14. JProfiler Contd. CPU view - Call trees, Hot spots Memory view - Allocation Hot spots, Recorded objects, Heap walker VM telemetry view - Memory, Threads status graphs Probes - JDBC , Sockets
  • 15. JConsole • Connect to the running instance local/remote • Different memory banks • Getting most out of Mbeans. • Getting a memory dump and analyzing with Eclipse MAT. • Remote JMX URL gets printed in the console during server startup: JMX Service URL : service:jmx:rmi://localhost:11111/jndi/rmi://localhost:9999/jmxrmi username : admin password : admin
  • 17. Memory Analyzer Tool • Analyze heap dumps. • Identifying OOM issues are trivial with basic leak report.
  • 18. Usual Suspects Some of the common issues...
  • 19. Permgen Errors • Permgen space relates to the 'Programme code' part, a.k.a - Loaded classes. • ClassLoader leaks • Typically happens in Container environments • Can uncover by doing deploy/redeploy cycles. • If one of the application objects get referenced by an object, outside the application, permgen error waiting to happen.
  • 20. Permgen Errors Container URLClassLoader Application Application Objects Container provided Objects
  • 21. Memory Leaks - OOM • Languages like C, gave the control of memory to the programmer. • Java is a managed memory, language. • Still the JVM can't free up the memory, if the application is holding on to the objects. • Unnecessary accumulation of objects, o Object creation for each and every connection o Slow output rate in the input/output system o Collecting clusterwide messages without an upper bound.
  • 22. DeadLocks Resource A Resource B • Re-designing the lock acquiring sequence • Using LockManagers that keeps track of lock acquisition
  • 23. Liveness issues... • Starvation - A thread can starve for CPU cycles, if it is blocked by a lock-wait. • Poor Responsiveness • LiveLock scenarios
  • 24. Programming Best Practices • Think about memory aspects/ data retrieval process while writing code. • Optimize the critical Path (look at CPU profile). • Make use of Standard libs as much as possible. • Profile your apps before releasing them to production.
  • 25. WSO2 make use of profiling ?
  • 26. Identity Server - Losing weight • Carbon server optimized to run in constrained memory environment. • No front end components - 'createWorker' ant task. • Selective Admin service loading. -Doptimized=true • Removed unwanted functionality based on the use-case, (p2 - provisioning, etc)
  • 27. Raspberry-Pi Clusters • Application server cluster running on R- Pis. • Powering the WSO2Con 2013 mobile app • 512MB of RAM and ARM processor.
  • 28. Demo CPU spin and Memory leak scenario