Rethinking the U.S.  “Textile Industry” Subhash K. Batra NCRC, NCSU, Raleigh, NC, USA HCTAR, Cambridge, MA, USA and David Brookstein Philadelphia University, Philadelphia, USA HCTAR, Cambridge, MA, USA
The Problem Public Image:  “Textile industry is in demise.” View supported by many economic studies. Kiekens (AUTEX I) discussed the impact on textile education; offered “European Strategy” U.S. Response:  Continually Evolving TC*TC (1979 NSF study, 1981, DoC, labor unions, industry) HCTAR (1990, Sloan Foundation) NCRC (1991, NSF, NC, Industry) NTC (1992, DoC…) DoD initiatives, etc.
Some Basic Questions What is “fiber?” “textile?” Fiber  ( fibra, ca. 1540) :   a unit of matter…flexibility, fineness, high length/thickness (e.g. T I – broad agreement). Min. length for spinnability requirements (e.g. ASTM) wood pulp fiber, monofilaments, wires? Textile  ( textilis, ca. 1626 ) :  a woven or knit cloth; fiber, filament, or yarn used in making cloth (MW);…generally applied to:  (1) staple fibers and filaments…for conversion to or use as yarns, or for…nonwoven fabrics, (2) yarns…from natural or manufactured fibers, (3) fabrics and other…products made from fibers…, and from yarns, and (4) garments and other articles…from one or more of the above…, and…when the products retain the flexibility and drape of the original fabrics.”  And, as an adjective the definition is:  “of or pertaining to textiles.” (ASTM)
Confusion … even among the learned, no unanimity on definition nor clarity on what final products to include. Why?  The burden of history: Weaving (basketry)…Neo. cultures of 5000 BC Cotton, silk, wool, and flax fibers woven in Egypt, cotton in India and silk in China by 3000 BC [EB] Strings, ropes, nets, laces, knits followed. Cottage industry – few tools much labor. I R (1760-1840, England) ushered in steam power, factory system, technological inventions… birth of the textile industry .
History Before WWII:  1.  Raw material from natural sources; 2.  All fiber and end products consumed largely in clothing and furnishings. Ergo:  fibers included in the definition of textiles…nowhere else to go. Was the farming sector part of the textile industry?  No. Post WWII:  chemical industry – regenerated-modified-synthesized polymeric fiber industry. Output focus:  substitution market in textiles – inclusion in the textile industry. Post WWII, consolidation and expansion of the industry …emergence of large multi-divisional conglomerates, etc. Success of the manufactured fibers…broader range of products/markets…inclusion under the ever expanding “textile umbrella.”  Ergo:  complexity.
Yarn Production Industrial Fabric Production Weaving  Knitting  Non-Woven Dyeing and Finishing Home Furnishings (H. F.) Apparel Non Textile Uses Domestic Distribution Wholesalers, Retailers Agriculture Chemical Textile Mills Fiber Exports Fiber Imports Yarn Exports Yarn Imports Fabric Exports Fabric Imports Exports Imports Exports History… Self-Perception  (NAE 1983) Fiber Production Natural Man Made
History… Acquisition of political clout (Rose 2000) Protection from international competition A. Import tariffs (1961…) STA, LTA B.  Bilateral quota control MFA, etc. And yet, … deficit continues to grow. (ATMI 2002) $60.76B in 2000, $62.46B in 2001; 5-6% textile, the rest is clothing. Enormous socio-economic impact – sad. So what’s next?
Bad News/Good News Bad News: The imperative:  continuing improvement in global human well being – more even distribution of the economic pie – the international trade disputes will continue – the U.S. textile industry, as we know it, will continue to face competition…sheer market size of U.S. a strong magnet. Good News: Per capita fiber consumption continues to grow:  U.S. 88 lbs. (2000); World average about 19 lbs. (2000); PRC about 14 lbs. (2000) U.S. apparent fiber cons.:  24.3B lbs. (2000); mill fiber cons.:  was about 16B lbs. (Feb. 2000). [52%, apparel and furnishings (not c & r); 48% in c & r plus “industrial,” was 44% in 1995] Data conservative…no glass, aramids, metal, fiber-optic, ceramic and other specialty fibers.
More Good News… Dr. Aneja has made a compelling case for the manufactured fiber industry. Fibers can be engineered to “meet” specs. Using them, products can be engineered to meet specs. Evolution of fibers as engineering materials. Looked at this way, the market for engineered fiber-based products in 2000 was [Rigby 2002]: Americas ~ 5.08MM tons (3.4% p.a. to 2010) Global ~ 16.69MM tons (3.8% p.a. to 2010)
To gain a healthier perspective for the future, we need a paradigm shift. The new paradigm:  We are in the business of producing/engineering/sourcing fibers and converting them into products useful to society.
In the New Paradigm: (Product vs. Technology) Fiber Industry   “ Textile Industry” Engineering with Fibers,  or  Fiber-Based Products Industry
Fiber Industry Agriculture Plants/Trees Seed (cotton, kapok, coconut) Stem/trunk (wood pulp, bast fibers, Manila hemp) Leaves (sisal, henequen, …) Animal hair (wool, cashmere, mohair, …) Manufactured (MF) Organic/Polymeric Regenerated cellulose & derivatives (rayon, acetate, …) Synthetic: Aramids Nylons (N6, N66,…) Acrylics/Modacrylics Polyesters Polyolefins Carbon/Graphite Elastomeric PLA, etc. Inorganic Glass  (fiberglass, optical glass) Metals (steel, copper, alloys…) Ceramics
  *  EwF: Reinforced “Rigid” Composites :  As defined by FEB in 66 b.  *EwF: Ropes, Cordage, Fishline, etc.  As defined by FEB in 70 but include all ropes including marine ropes.  *EwF: Floor & Wall Coverings : As defined by FEB in 51,52.  *EwF:  Pneumatic Tires :  As defined by FEB in 63.   *EwF: Flexible, Reinforced Rubber Composites : As defined by FEB in 64, 65.  *EwF: Paper : Wetlaid wood pulp.  * “ Textiles :”  Fabrics made by weaving, knitting, braiding, etc. (not nonwovens) for consumer apparel & accessories and residential furnishings.  *EwF :  yarns/wovens/knits/braids for engineered structural use, commercial interiors & apparel   designed to meet strict, objectively measurable (engineering or performance) specifications. * Flexible, Reinforced Rubber Composites : As defined by FEB 64, 65.  * Reinforced “Rigid” Composites : Relatively hard matrix reinforced by fibers, and/or precursor EwF structures, and/or Nonwovens.   Fiber Industry EwF: Nonwovens (Fiberwebs, etc.)   EwF: Reinforced “rigid” matrix composites   EwF: Flexible Reinforced Rubber Composites   EwF: Ropes, Cordage, Fishline EwF: Floor & Wall Coverings EwF: Paper EwF: Communication Industry EwF: Engineered/Structured Fibrous Pre-Forms (Yarns/Wovens/ Knits/Braids for Comm. Apparel, Interiors & other Structural Use) “ Textiles:” Wovens, Knits, Braids, etc. for Consumer Apparel & Residential Interiors EwF: Pneumatic Tires/Tyres
Justification? Existence of independent trade unions, expressing divergent interests. INDA is trade association of the nonwovens industry. TAPPI is association for professionals working in the pulp and paper industry; it also often serves as a trade association. IFAI is a broad umbrella organization with the following divisions: American Casual Furniture Fabric Association Automotive Textiles, Plastics and Coatings Association Banner & Flag Association Geo-synthetic Materials Association Marine Fabricators Association Narrow Fabrics Institute Professional Awning Manufacturers Association Safety & Protective Products Division Tent Rental Division Truck Cover & Tarp Association United States Industrial Fabrics Institute
Justification?  (continued) ATMI…represents “mill firms which operate machinery in the United States for the manufacture or processing of textile products (except those who produce man-made fibers and yarn by a chemical process).” AFMA “is the trade association for U.S. companies that manufacture synthetic and cellulosic fibers.” Carpet and Rug Institute “is the national trade association representing the carpet and rug industry.” Dalton Floor Covering Market Association is an “association who’s goal is to market industry member services to the world.” The National Cotton Council and Cotton Incorporated, semi-governmental organizations devoted to the promotion of cotton and protecting interests of the cotton farmers.
The schema recognizes fibers as engineering materials. Broadens the scope of the “Fiber Industry.” Restricted definition of “Textiles,” recognizes the economic importance of the other fiber-based products industries  or “Engineering with Fibers Industry” and frees them from the instabilities and turmoil of the “textile-apparel” connection. Could facilitate better understanding of the supply chain relationships and strategic planning. Could provide educational institutions a better paradigm view for developing appropriate & focused programs to meet the human resource needs of the selected segments of the industry.
Could facilitate development of the relevant design science…to gain competitive advantage in the market place. Need:  a great deal more study and debate. Lead vs. follow. Join us. ( [email_address] ;  brooksteind@ philau .edu )
“ Nothing will ever be attempted if all possible objections must be first overcome.”  (Samuel Johnson) “ Truth is ever to be found in the simplicity, and not in the multiplicity and confusion of things.”  (Sir Isaac Newton) “ A man with a new idea is a crank – until he succeeds.”  (Mark Twain) “ Thus, the task is, not so much to see what no one has yet seen; but to think what nobody has yet thought, about that which everybody sees.”  (Erwin Schrodinger) “ There must be no barriers to freedom on inquiry.  There is no place for dogma in science.  The scientist is free, and must be free to ask any question, to doubt any assertion, to seek for any evidence, to correct any errors.”  (J. Robert Oppenheimer)

More Related Content

PPT
Medical textiles
PPTX
New Medical Textile.
PDF
Medical textiles
PDF
Tech-Tex.pdf
PPTX
4 faheem-ud-din
PPTX
Latest development in textile finishing
PDF
Cellulosic Textile Fibres _ A Review_Hämäläinen Anu
Medical textiles
New Medical Textile.
Medical textiles
Tech-Tex.pdf
4 faheem-ud-din
Latest development in textile finishing
Cellulosic Textile Fibres _ A Review_Hämäläinen Anu

Similar to Autex Ii Presentation Revised(2) (20)

PDF
medical textile yashasvi
PPTX
Technical textiles
PPTX
Introduction totextiles-1.pptx
DOCX
Textile Brochure
PDF
Analysis on the Defects in Yarn Manufacturing Process & its Prevention in Tex...
PPTX
Technical textile.lecture 01
PPTX
What are textiles?
PDF
Lowell Mills
PPTX
nanotechnology-ppt.pptx
PPTX
The Basic concept of man made fibre.pptx
PPTX
Basic concept of man made fiber
PPTX
nanotechnology-ppt[1].pptx
PPTX
non woven ppt
PDF
I0342047060
PPTX
Seminar Presentation on Nanotechnology.pptx
PPTX
nano technology nano technology nano.pptx
PDF
nanotechnology-ppt {DEMO}.pdf
PPTX
Role of textiles in our day to day life.pptx
DOCX
Analysis of textile industry of Pakistan
medical textile yashasvi
Technical textiles
Introduction totextiles-1.pptx
Textile Brochure
Analysis on the Defects in Yarn Manufacturing Process & its Prevention in Tex...
Technical textile.lecture 01
What are textiles?
Lowell Mills
nanotechnology-ppt.pptx
The Basic concept of man made fibre.pptx
Basic concept of man made fiber
nanotechnology-ppt[1].pptx
non woven ppt
I0342047060
Seminar Presentation on Nanotechnology.pptx
nano technology nano technology nano.pptx
nanotechnology-ppt {DEMO}.pdf
Role of textiles in our day to day life.pptx
Analysis of textile industry of Pakistan
Ad

More from FNian (20)

PPT
Wipro Media Q1 0809
PPT
Watts Brief
PPT
The Role Of Business In Society Presentation At
PPT
Unit C Eco Toolbox
PPT
Singapore Jakarta Conf
PPT
Syndication Pp
PPT
Integration of internal database system
PPT
Analyse sourcing and manufacturing strategies
PPT
Scitc 2006 India 2005 And Future
PPT
Miller China Trade
PPT
Developing a market plan
PPT
Gianelle Tattara
PPT
Gp Industry
PPT
House
PPT
How To Biuld Internal Rating System For Basel Ii
PPT
Gujarat
PPT
Ietp Session 2 June 28
PPT
India An Overview
PPT
Intra Industry
PPT
Innovation Class 6
Wipro Media Q1 0809
Watts Brief
The Role Of Business In Society Presentation At
Unit C Eco Toolbox
Singapore Jakarta Conf
Syndication Pp
Integration of internal database system
Analyse sourcing and manufacturing strategies
Scitc 2006 India 2005 And Future
Miller China Trade
Developing a market plan
Gianelle Tattara
Gp Industry
House
How To Biuld Internal Rating System For Basel Ii
Gujarat
Ietp Session 2 June 28
India An Overview
Intra Industry
Innovation Class 6
Ad

Recently uploaded (20)

PPTX
chapter 2 entrepreneurship full lecture ppt
PDF
Kishore Vora - Best CFO in India to watch in 2025.pdf
PPTX
interschool scomp.pptxzdkjhdjvdjvdjdhjhieij
PDF
1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Aug 2025.pdf
PPTX
CTG - Business Update 2Q2025 & 6M2025.pptx
PPTX
BUSINESS CYCLE_INFLATION AND UNEMPLOYMENT.pptx
PPTX
svnfcksanfskjcsnvvjknsnvsdscnsncxasxa saccacxsax
PPT
Lecture notes on Business Research Methods
PPTX
Slide gioi thieu VietinBank Quy 2 - 2025
PPTX
2 - Self & Personality 587689213yiuedhwejbmansbeakjrk
PDF
THE COMPLETE GUIDE TO BUILDING PASSIVE INCOME ONLINE
PDF
#1 Safe and Secure Verified Cash App Accounts for Purchase.pdf
PDF
income tax laws notes important pakistan
DOCX
FINALS-BSHhchcuvivicucucucucM-Centro.docx
PPTX
Board-Reporting-Package-by-Umbrex-5-23-23.pptx
PDF
Ron Thomas - Top Influential Business Leaders Shaping the Modern Industry – 2025
PPTX
Astra-Investor- business Presentation (1).pptx
PDF
Keppel_Proposed Divestment of M1 Limited
PDF
Environmental Law Communication: Strategies for Advocacy (www.kiu.ac.ug)
PPTX
Slide gioi thieu VietinBank Quy 2 - 2025
chapter 2 entrepreneurship full lecture ppt
Kishore Vora - Best CFO in India to watch in 2025.pdf
interschool scomp.pptxzdkjhdjvdjvdjdhjhieij
1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Aug 2025.pdf
CTG - Business Update 2Q2025 & 6M2025.pptx
BUSINESS CYCLE_INFLATION AND UNEMPLOYMENT.pptx
svnfcksanfskjcsnvvjknsnvsdscnsncxasxa saccacxsax
Lecture notes on Business Research Methods
Slide gioi thieu VietinBank Quy 2 - 2025
2 - Self & Personality 587689213yiuedhwejbmansbeakjrk
THE COMPLETE GUIDE TO BUILDING PASSIVE INCOME ONLINE
#1 Safe and Secure Verified Cash App Accounts for Purchase.pdf
income tax laws notes important pakistan
FINALS-BSHhchcuvivicucucucucM-Centro.docx
Board-Reporting-Package-by-Umbrex-5-23-23.pptx
Ron Thomas - Top Influential Business Leaders Shaping the Modern Industry – 2025
Astra-Investor- business Presentation (1).pptx
Keppel_Proposed Divestment of M1 Limited
Environmental Law Communication: Strategies for Advocacy (www.kiu.ac.ug)
Slide gioi thieu VietinBank Quy 2 - 2025

Autex Ii Presentation Revised(2)

  • 1. Rethinking the U.S. “Textile Industry” Subhash K. Batra NCRC, NCSU, Raleigh, NC, USA HCTAR, Cambridge, MA, USA and David Brookstein Philadelphia University, Philadelphia, USA HCTAR, Cambridge, MA, USA
  • 2. The Problem Public Image: “Textile industry is in demise.” View supported by many economic studies. Kiekens (AUTEX I) discussed the impact on textile education; offered “European Strategy” U.S. Response: Continually Evolving TC*TC (1979 NSF study, 1981, DoC, labor unions, industry) HCTAR (1990, Sloan Foundation) NCRC (1991, NSF, NC, Industry) NTC (1992, DoC…) DoD initiatives, etc.
  • 3. Some Basic Questions What is “fiber?” “textile?” Fiber ( fibra, ca. 1540) : a unit of matter…flexibility, fineness, high length/thickness (e.g. T I – broad agreement). Min. length for spinnability requirements (e.g. ASTM) wood pulp fiber, monofilaments, wires? Textile ( textilis, ca. 1626 ) : a woven or knit cloth; fiber, filament, or yarn used in making cloth (MW);…generally applied to: (1) staple fibers and filaments…for conversion to or use as yarns, or for…nonwoven fabrics, (2) yarns…from natural or manufactured fibers, (3) fabrics and other…products made from fibers…, and from yarns, and (4) garments and other articles…from one or more of the above…, and…when the products retain the flexibility and drape of the original fabrics.” And, as an adjective the definition is: “of or pertaining to textiles.” (ASTM)
  • 4. Confusion … even among the learned, no unanimity on definition nor clarity on what final products to include. Why? The burden of history: Weaving (basketry)…Neo. cultures of 5000 BC Cotton, silk, wool, and flax fibers woven in Egypt, cotton in India and silk in China by 3000 BC [EB] Strings, ropes, nets, laces, knits followed. Cottage industry – few tools much labor. I R (1760-1840, England) ushered in steam power, factory system, technological inventions… birth of the textile industry .
  • 5. History Before WWII: 1. Raw material from natural sources; 2. All fiber and end products consumed largely in clothing and furnishings. Ergo: fibers included in the definition of textiles…nowhere else to go. Was the farming sector part of the textile industry? No. Post WWII: chemical industry – regenerated-modified-synthesized polymeric fiber industry. Output focus: substitution market in textiles – inclusion in the textile industry. Post WWII, consolidation and expansion of the industry …emergence of large multi-divisional conglomerates, etc. Success of the manufactured fibers…broader range of products/markets…inclusion under the ever expanding “textile umbrella.” Ergo: complexity.
  • 6. Yarn Production Industrial Fabric Production Weaving Knitting Non-Woven Dyeing and Finishing Home Furnishings (H. F.) Apparel Non Textile Uses Domestic Distribution Wholesalers, Retailers Agriculture Chemical Textile Mills Fiber Exports Fiber Imports Yarn Exports Yarn Imports Fabric Exports Fabric Imports Exports Imports Exports History… Self-Perception (NAE 1983) Fiber Production Natural Man Made
  • 7. History… Acquisition of political clout (Rose 2000) Protection from international competition A. Import tariffs (1961…) STA, LTA B. Bilateral quota control MFA, etc. And yet, … deficit continues to grow. (ATMI 2002) $60.76B in 2000, $62.46B in 2001; 5-6% textile, the rest is clothing. Enormous socio-economic impact – sad. So what’s next?
  • 8. Bad News/Good News Bad News: The imperative: continuing improvement in global human well being – more even distribution of the economic pie – the international trade disputes will continue – the U.S. textile industry, as we know it, will continue to face competition…sheer market size of U.S. a strong magnet. Good News: Per capita fiber consumption continues to grow: U.S. 88 lbs. (2000); World average about 19 lbs. (2000); PRC about 14 lbs. (2000) U.S. apparent fiber cons.: 24.3B lbs. (2000); mill fiber cons.: was about 16B lbs. (Feb. 2000). [52%, apparel and furnishings (not c & r); 48% in c & r plus “industrial,” was 44% in 1995] Data conservative…no glass, aramids, metal, fiber-optic, ceramic and other specialty fibers.
  • 9. More Good News… Dr. Aneja has made a compelling case for the manufactured fiber industry. Fibers can be engineered to “meet” specs. Using them, products can be engineered to meet specs. Evolution of fibers as engineering materials. Looked at this way, the market for engineered fiber-based products in 2000 was [Rigby 2002]: Americas ~ 5.08MM tons (3.4% p.a. to 2010) Global ~ 16.69MM tons (3.8% p.a. to 2010)
  • 10. To gain a healthier perspective for the future, we need a paradigm shift. The new paradigm: We are in the business of producing/engineering/sourcing fibers and converting them into products useful to society.
  • 11. In the New Paradigm: (Product vs. Technology) Fiber Industry “ Textile Industry” Engineering with Fibers, or Fiber-Based Products Industry
  • 12. Fiber Industry Agriculture Plants/Trees Seed (cotton, kapok, coconut) Stem/trunk (wood pulp, bast fibers, Manila hemp) Leaves (sisal, henequen, …) Animal hair (wool, cashmere, mohair, …) Manufactured (MF) Organic/Polymeric Regenerated cellulose & derivatives (rayon, acetate, …) Synthetic: Aramids Nylons (N6, N66,…) Acrylics/Modacrylics Polyesters Polyolefins Carbon/Graphite Elastomeric PLA, etc. Inorganic Glass (fiberglass, optical glass) Metals (steel, copper, alloys…) Ceramics
  • 13.   * EwF: Reinforced “Rigid” Composites : As defined by FEB in 66 b. *EwF: Ropes, Cordage, Fishline, etc. As defined by FEB in 70 but include all ropes including marine ropes. *EwF: Floor & Wall Coverings : As defined by FEB in 51,52. *EwF: Pneumatic Tires : As defined by FEB in 63. *EwF: Flexible, Reinforced Rubber Composites : As defined by FEB in 64, 65. *EwF: Paper : Wetlaid wood pulp. * “ Textiles :” Fabrics made by weaving, knitting, braiding, etc. (not nonwovens) for consumer apparel & accessories and residential furnishings. *EwF : yarns/wovens/knits/braids for engineered structural use, commercial interiors & apparel designed to meet strict, objectively measurable (engineering or performance) specifications. * Flexible, Reinforced Rubber Composites : As defined by FEB 64, 65. * Reinforced “Rigid” Composites : Relatively hard matrix reinforced by fibers, and/or precursor EwF structures, and/or Nonwovens.   Fiber Industry EwF: Nonwovens (Fiberwebs, etc.)   EwF: Reinforced “rigid” matrix composites   EwF: Flexible Reinforced Rubber Composites   EwF: Ropes, Cordage, Fishline EwF: Floor & Wall Coverings EwF: Paper EwF: Communication Industry EwF: Engineered/Structured Fibrous Pre-Forms (Yarns/Wovens/ Knits/Braids for Comm. Apparel, Interiors & other Structural Use) “ Textiles:” Wovens, Knits, Braids, etc. for Consumer Apparel & Residential Interiors EwF: Pneumatic Tires/Tyres
  • 14. Justification? Existence of independent trade unions, expressing divergent interests. INDA is trade association of the nonwovens industry. TAPPI is association for professionals working in the pulp and paper industry; it also often serves as a trade association. IFAI is a broad umbrella organization with the following divisions: American Casual Furniture Fabric Association Automotive Textiles, Plastics and Coatings Association Banner & Flag Association Geo-synthetic Materials Association Marine Fabricators Association Narrow Fabrics Institute Professional Awning Manufacturers Association Safety & Protective Products Division Tent Rental Division Truck Cover & Tarp Association United States Industrial Fabrics Institute
  • 15. Justification? (continued) ATMI…represents “mill firms which operate machinery in the United States for the manufacture or processing of textile products (except those who produce man-made fibers and yarn by a chemical process).” AFMA “is the trade association for U.S. companies that manufacture synthetic and cellulosic fibers.” Carpet and Rug Institute “is the national trade association representing the carpet and rug industry.” Dalton Floor Covering Market Association is an “association who’s goal is to market industry member services to the world.” The National Cotton Council and Cotton Incorporated, semi-governmental organizations devoted to the promotion of cotton and protecting interests of the cotton farmers.
  • 16. The schema recognizes fibers as engineering materials. Broadens the scope of the “Fiber Industry.” Restricted definition of “Textiles,” recognizes the economic importance of the other fiber-based products industries or “Engineering with Fibers Industry” and frees them from the instabilities and turmoil of the “textile-apparel” connection. Could facilitate better understanding of the supply chain relationships and strategic planning. Could provide educational institutions a better paradigm view for developing appropriate & focused programs to meet the human resource needs of the selected segments of the industry.
  • 17. Could facilitate development of the relevant design science…to gain competitive advantage in the market place. Need: a great deal more study and debate. Lead vs. follow. Join us. ( [email_address] ; brooksteind@ philau .edu )
  • 18. “ Nothing will ever be attempted if all possible objections must be first overcome.” (Samuel Johnson) “ Truth is ever to be found in the simplicity, and not in the multiplicity and confusion of things.” (Sir Isaac Newton) “ A man with a new idea is a crank – until he succeeds.” (Mark Twain) “ Thus, the task is, not so much to see what no one has yet seen; but to think what nobody has yet thought, about that which everybody sees.” (Erwin Schrodinger) “ There must be no barriers to freedom on inquiry. There is no place for dogma in science. The scientist is free, and must be free to ask any question, to doubt any assertion, to seek for any evidence, to correct any errors.” (J. Robert Oppenheimer)