SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Copyright
by
Joseph C. Colarusso
2015
COLARUSSO DISSERTATION 5.12.15
EUGENE “GENE” AMMONS: THE COALESCENCE OF SWING,
RHYTHM AND BLUES, AND BEBOP IN MODERN JAZZ
by
Joseph C. Colarusso
M.M. Performance Jazz Emphasis, University of Texas at Austin, 2003
B.M. Performance Jazz Emphasis, University of Texas at Austin, 1996
Nontreatise Lecture Recital Document
Presented to the Faculty of the Graduate School of
The University of Texas at Austin
in Partial Fulfillment
of the Requirements
for the Degree of
Doctor of Musical Arts in Performance (Jazz Emphasis)
The University of Texas at Austin
May 2015
Dedication
This paper is dedicated to my wife, Xochitl, and our girls, Xoey and Lila,
with all of my love.
v
Acknowledgements
First, I would like to thank my wife, Xochitl, for her abundant love and support
while I worked on this project. I would also like to thank our daughters, Xoey and Lila,
for the endless reserves of inspiration that they give me for this and all endeavors. Special
thanks to my parents, Joe and Barbara Colarusso, for being the best parents, teachers and
role models that anyone could ever ask for. I would like to express my deepest gratitude
and appreciation to my committee supervisor and studio teacher, John Mills, for patiently
teaching me over a number of years, and for being the highest caliber of music educator
both in the classroom and on the bandstand. Thanks to my co-supervisor, Jeff Hellmer,
for teaching me how to rehearse and play in a big band. My students will reap the
benefits of his exceptional and unparalleled jazz ensemble pedagogy. Additionally, I am
indebted to the rest of my committee members from the Butler School of Music; John
Fremgen, Michael Tusa, and Eric Drott. They are leading scholars in their respective
fields; moreover, they were an invaluable part of my music education. I would also like
to express my gratitude to Morris Stevens, Jr. for serving as my outside committee
member, and I look forward to continuing my education with him as we work together at
St. Edward’s University. Lastly, I would like to thank everyone else who has ever helped
me to maximize my potential as a musician, student, educator, and human being.
vi
Abstract
EUGENE “GENE” AMMONS: THE COALESCENCE OF SWING,
RHYTHM AND BLUES, AND BEBOP IN MODERN JAZZ
Joseph C. Colarusso, D.M.A.
The University of Texas at Austin, 2015
Supervisor: John Mills
This research project is an exploration of the life and music of Eugene “Gene”
Ammons. Though he has been largely overlooked and underrated by many jazz critics
and historians, Gene Ammons’ impact on the evolution of jazz and his pervading
influence on the jazz saxophonists that came after him is an undercurrent that reaches far
and wide. The son of famous boogie-woogie pianist Albert Ammons, Gene Ammons
evolved into a saxophone player whose style was steeped in the rhythm and blues
tradition. At the same time, a jazz revolution was taking place as musicians like Charlie
Parker and Dizzy Gillespie were pioneering the new bebop language. Ammons, having
cut his teeth as the solo tenor saxophonist in the Billy Eckstine Orchestra, soon became a
master of the new jazz language. He successfully married traditional swing with
emotional rhythm and blues and sophisticated bebop, a skill that set him apart from jazz
musicians confined to one niche or subgenre in jazz. Ultimately, Ammons’ developed
vii
style was a paragon of soul jazz, spreading throughout the Hard Bop Era. I will use
historical data along with analysis of Ammons’ solo transcriptions to present Gene
Ammons as one of the unsung heroes of the saxophone, with his musical contributions
meriting consideration within the narrative of modern jazz.
viii
Table of Contents
List of Tables .......................................................................................................... x!
List of Examples .................................................................................................... xi!
Chapter 1 Introduction ........................................................................................... 1!
Chapter 2 Biographical Overview ......................................................................... 5
Chapter 3 The Sound and Vocality of Gene Ammons ........................................ 17
Sound ........................................................................................................... 17
Vocality........................................................................................................ 19
Chapter 4 Rhythmic Devices ............................................................................... 24
The Eighth-Note Feel and the Rhythmic Pocket ......................................... 24
Hemiola........................................................................................................ 27
Chapter 5 Gene Ammons' Vocabulary: The Coalescence of Swing, Rhythm
and Blues, and Bebop .................................................................................. 32
Elements of Swing: The Influence of Lester Young ................................... 32
6/9 Common Language: The Major Pentatonic Scale ........................ 34
Dominant7(!5): The Creation and Resolution of Tension.................. 38
Elements of Rhythm and Blues: The Milieu of Illinois Jacquet and
Red Prysock ................................................................................................. 43
Use of the Blues Scale ........................................................................ 46
Prolongation of One Repeated Note ................................................... 49
Motivic Repetition/Development........................................................ 56
Elements of Bebop: The Influence of Charlie Parker and Sonny Stitt ........ 59
Surround Tones................................................................................... 60
Scalar Versus Arpeggiated Diminished Chords ................................. 62
Double-time passages ......................................................................... 65
Harmonic Devices: Passing Chords.................................................... 67
Diminished Passing Chords....................................................... 68
Minor Passing Chords: iii7-!iii7 and the Use of Sequences...... 69
ix
Chapter 6 Conclusion........................................................................................... 74
Appendix A Complete Solo Transcriptions of Gene Ammons ........................... 78
Appendix B Solo Transcriptions of Lester Young, Illinois Jacquet and
Red Prysock Completed in a Comparative Study of Gene Ammons ........ 102!
Bibliography ....................................................................................................... 116
Selected Discography.......................................................................................... 120!
Curriculum Vitae for Joseph Colarusso.............................................................. 122!
x
List of Tables
Table 2.1:!Musicians Who Studied with Captain Walter Dyett.............................. 7!
Table 2.2:!Musicians Who Played in the Billy Eckstine Orchestra...................... 11
Table 5.1:!Chord Changes for 'Bird Blues' ........................................................... 68!
!
xi
List of Examples
Example 4.1: Gene Ammons, "Please Send Me Someone to Love,"
mm. 89-93.. ........................................................................................ 27
Example 4.2: Charlie Parker, "Moose the Mooch," mm. 29-32........................... 28
Example 4.3: Gene Ammons, "Blues Up and Down" (1961), mm. 176-180....... 29
Example 4.4: Gene Ammons, "Blues Up and Down" (1961), mm. 441-445....... 29
Example 4.5: Gene Ammons, "Anna," mm. 53-55............................................... 30
Example 5.1: Lester Young, "Lester Leaps In," mm. 4-7..................................... 35
Example 5.2: Lester Young, "Lester Leaps In," mm. 129-132............................. 36
Example 5.3: Gene Ammons, "Blowing the Blues Away," mm. 37-39............... 36
Example 5.4: Gene Ammons, "St. Louis Blues," mm. 1-5................................... 37
Example 5.5: Gene Ammons, "Red Top," mm. 41-42 ......................................... 37
Example 5.6: Gene Ammons, "Blues Up and Down" (1950), mm. 1-4............... 38
Example 5.7: Lester Young, "Lester Leaps In," mm. 57-61................................. 39!
Example 5.8: Gene Ammons, "Blowing the Blues Away," mm. 39-41............... 40
Example 5.9: Gene Ammons, "St. Louis Blues," mm. 15-17............................... 41
Example 5.10: Gene Ammons, "Juggernaut," mm. 86-90.................................... 41
Example 5.11: Gene Ammons, "Blues Up and Down" (1961), mm. 213-215..... 42
Example 5.12: Illinois Jacquet, "Flying Home," mm. 26-29................................ 47
Example 5.13: Gene Ammons, "Please Send Me Someone to Love,"
mm. 33-35 .......................................................................................... 48
Example 5.14: Gene Ammons, "Please Send Me Someone to Love,"
mm. 67-69 .......................................................................................... 49
Example 5.15: Gene Ammons, "Please Send Me Someone to Love,"
mm. 45-49 .......................................................................................... 49
Example 5.16: Illinois Jacquet, "Flying Home," mm. 33-49................................ 51
Example 5.17: Red Prysock, "Blow Your Horn," mm. 168-183.......................... 52
xii
Example 5.18: Gene Ammons, "Blues Up and Down" (1961), mm. 96-108....... 53
Example 5.19: Gene Ammons, "Blues Up and Down" (1961), mm. 109-120..... 54
Example 5.20: Gene Ammons, "Blues Up and Down" (1961), mm. 205-209..... 55
Example 5.21: Gene Ammons, "Blues Up and Down" (1961), mm. 456-468..... 55
Example 5.22: Gene Ammons, "Blues Up and Down" (1961), mm. 469-480..... 56
Example 5.23: Red Prysock, "Blow Your Horn," mm. 60-63.............................. 57
Example 5.24: Gene Ammons, "Blues Up and Down" (1961), mm. 120-125..... 57
Example 5.25: Gene Ammons, "Blues Up and Down" (1961), mm. 168-180..... 58
Example 5.26: Gene Ammons, "Blues Up and Down" (1961), mm. 192-204..... 59
Example 5.27: Charlie Parker, "Thriving From a Riff," mm. 41-43 .................... 61
Example 5.28: Gene Ammons, "Blowing the Blues Away," mm. 46-48............. 61
Example 5.29: Gene Ammons, "Juggernaut," mm. 72-73.................................... 62
Example 5.30: Sonny Stitt, "Blues Up and Down" (1950), mm. 16-19 ............... 63
Example 5.31: Gene Ammons, "Please Send Me Someone to Love,"
mm. 57-58 .......................................................................................... 64
Example 5.32: Gene Ammons, "Please Send Me Someone to Love,"
mm. 89-90 .......................................................................................... 64
Example 5.33: Charlie Parker, "Blues for Alice," mm. 20-23.............................. 65
Example 5.34: Gene Ammons, "Juggernaut," mm. 39-42.................................... 66
Example 5.35: Gene Ammons, "Please Send Me Someone to Love,"
mm. 89-93 .......................................................................................... 67
Example 5.36: Gene Ammons, "Blues Up and Down" (1961), mm. 1-5............. 69
Example 5.37: Sonny Stitt, "Blues Up and Down" (1950), mm. 37-41 ............... 69
Example 5.38: Charlie Parker, "Moose the Mooch," mm. 57-61......................... 70
Example 5.39: Gene Ammons, "Red Top," mm. 37-40 ....................................... 71
xiii
Example 5.40: Gene Ammons, "Blues Up and Down" (1961), mm. 187-191..... 72
Example 5.41: Gene Ammons, "Anna," mm. 53-55............................................. 72
!
!
!
!
!
1
CHAPTER 1
Introduction
Eugene “Gene” Ammons (1925-1974) was a bebop saxophonist with roots that
were heavily steeped in the urban blues tradition that would ultimately become rhythm
and blues. From an early age up through musical maturity, his parents, teachers, mentors
and colleagues gave him the tools and opportunities that would position him for success
in the world of music. These pivotal experiences in Ammons’ education and career,
presented in Chapter 2, molded him into one of the unsung heroes of the Modern Jazz
Era1, and his contribution to the narrative of jazz merits more consideration than it has
been given to date.
The saxophone is an instrument that can be played in a highly individualistic
manner. Whereas many other instrumentalists distinguish themselves through their
unique vocabulary, exceptional saxophonists can often be identified solely by the quality
of their sound. John Coltrane, Stan Getz and Michael Brecker could easily be picked out
of an aural lineup, even if they were playing long tones. Gene Ammons is another great
tenor saxophonist who fits into this ‘exceptional tone’ category. In terms of style, he was
influenced by the Swing-Era tenor giants, Lester Young and Coleman Hawkins, and this
paper will address these significant qualities in his playing.2 In 2008, three-time Grammy
award-winning jazz vocalist Nancy Wilson hosted a one-hour documentary on Gene
Ammons for National Public Radio, putting his sound and style into historical
perspective. According to Wilson, Ammons played with Coleman Hawkins’ big, hot
1 Jazz from the Bebop Era (beginning in the early-mid 1940s) up to the present will hereafter be referred to
as ‘modern jazz.’
2 Ed Enright, “Gene Ammons: Ultimate Redemption,” Down Beat, August 1, 2012, accessed January 31,
2015, http://www.downbeat.com/default.asp?sect=stories&subsect=story_detail&sid=1125.
2
sound and Lester Young’s sense of lyricism.3 Chapter 3 of this document will discuss
Ammons’ sound (tonal concept) and his vocality (sense of lyricism). An examination of
prevalent rhythmic devices ingrained in his style is presented in Chapter 4.
In addition to having an enormous and distinctive sound, Ammons possessed the
ability to synthesize elements of swing, rhythm and blues, and bebop. This resulted in his
composite vocabulary, discussed in Chapter 5, that was both unique and accessible to
audiences over multiple demographics. His swing vernacular included frequent use of
melodic ideas that ‘blanket’4 the chord changes with the major pentatonic scale whose
root is tonic in the parent key. This approach is known in some circles as ‘6/9 common
language.’ That combined with his extensive use of dominant7(!5) chords pays homage
to Lester Young’s approach to improvisation. Ammons’ frequent use of blues
vocabulary, prolongation of a single repeated note, and motivic repetition prove that the
saxophonist was also greatly influenced by the rhythm and blues movement. Lastly,
Ammons’ penchant for the new bebop, or ‘bop,’ language is illustrated in his use of
surround tones, employment of double-time passages, and treatment of diminished and
minor passing chords.
At closer examination, it is easy to see the tremendous impact that Gene Ammons
had on the evolution of jazz music and its musicians. During his tenure with Billy
Eckstine’s band, he contributed greatly to the establishment of the dueling tenor
saxophone format known as the ‘tenor battle.’ The saxophonist’s widow, Mildred
Ammons, described the symbiotic relationship between her late husband and Sonny Stitt.
She recounted that the Gene Ammons/Sonny Stitt collaborations showcased Ammons’
3 Nancy Wilson, “Gene Ammons: ‘The Jug’,” NPR’s Jazz Profiles, February 20, 2008, accessed April 12,
2014, http://www.npr.org/2008/02/20/19172123/gene-ammons-the-jug.
4 Blanketing chord changes involves using one common scale or set of pitches to play over multiple chords.
3
big sound and Stitt’s flashy technique, and together their styles complemented each
other.5
Ultimately, Ammons used his developed amalgamation of swing, rhythm and
blues, and bebop sound and vocabulary to become a pivotal player of soul jazz in the
Hard Bop Era. The groove-oriented subgenre known as soul jazz began to thrive in the
early 1960s.6 However, the saxophonist was forced to assert his influence on this new
subgenre by proxy while spending the majority of the sixties in federal prison on drug
charges. He died in 1974 at the premature age of forty-nine.
Much has been written about Ammons’ contemporaries such as Dexter Gordon,
John Coltrane, and Stan Getz; however, Gene Ammons is mysteriously underrepresented
in jazz history texts. It is possible that his identification with the rhythm and blues style
worked to his detriment when being considered by jazz critics. Doug Miller, lecturer and
saxophonist with the Count Basie Orchestra, published an article in Popular Music in
1995 in which he states:
Saxophonists, particularly jazz tenorists who crossed over into R&B, were
criticised for playing ‘rock and roll.’ Sam ‘The Man’ Taylor, for example, was
called to account in a discussion sponsored by Down Beat magazine. Others were
labeled by jazz critics as ‘extrovert moderns’ or ‘ audience getters.’7
Nancy Wilson asserts that Ammons possessed musical gifts commensurate with those of
other jazz icons of the forties, fifties and sixties; however, he “rarely got a second look by
5 Wilson, “Gene Ammons: ‘The Jug’”.
6 Nick Morrison, “Soul Jazz: Where Jazz, Blues and Gospel Meet,” NPR’s Take Five: A Jazz Sampler,
January 4, 2010, accessed February 4, 2015, http://www.npr.org/2010/01/04/98279702/soul-jazz-where-
jazz-blues-and-gospel-meet.
7 Doug Miller, “The Moan Within the Tone: African Retentions in Rhythm and Blues Saxophone Style in
Afro-American Popular Music,” Popular Music 14, no. 2 (May, 1995): 169, accessed February 16, 2014,
http://www.jstor.org/stable/853397.
4
many of the jazz writers and critics of his era.”8 Additionally, jazz critics of the 1950s
and 1960s showed an inclination to reserve their praise for artists that were clear
innovators, rather than acknowledging those performers that assimilate on a very high
level such as Ammons. Because Albert Ammons was generally accepted to be one of the
preeminent boogie-woogie pianists of the day, it is also possible that Gene Ammons
faced the burden of living in his father’s artistic shadow.
I believe, however, that Ammons’ inclination to play fearlessly across
styles/genres, without worrying about being a purist in any one particular style, set him
apart from many of his contemporaries who could easily be pigeonholed into one
category or another. For this reason, I have decided to explore Ammons in depth. Though
he recorded up until shortly before his death in 1974, this paper addresses his recordings
from 1944 to 1962. These were his developmental, evolutionary years. All of the
transcriptions presented in this paper, whether excerpted as examples or compiled in
complete form in the Appendices, are written for either B! tenor saxophone or E! alto
saxophone (rather than notating concert or sounding pitches) in an attempt to reflect
performance practice on these instruments. Through my extensive analysis of Ammons’
sound and approach to improvisation, I hope to provide an account of the saxophonist’s
significant contributions to the transition from swing to modern jazz.
8 Wilson, “Gene Ammons: ‘The Jug’”.
5
CHAPTER 2
Biographical Overview
Gene Ammons was born on April 14, 1925 on the south side of Chicago in a
neighborhood known as Bronzeville. Black émigrés had been moving north from the
Gulf Coast in droves during the 1920s, settling, among other places, on the south side of
Chicago. A newspaper writer named James J. Gentry witnessed this transformation on the
south side of town and gave the neighborhood its moniker. The south side of Chicago
was the original Bronzeville; however, Bronzevilles were established in other northern
cities including Detroit, Indianapolis and Milwaukee. Across the segregated North, these
neighborhoods served as black towns within white cities.9
Ammons was from a musical family. Both of his parents were pianists; moreover,
his father was the famous boogie-woogie pianist, Albert Ammons. To date, much more
can be found in the histories on Albert Ammons than on his son, Gene. Pianists like
Albert Ammons, Pete Johnson, Meade “Lux” Lewis and Camille Howard were playing
left-hand ostinato patterns that would define the boogie-woogie style and, ultimately,
serve as the most essential rhythmic figure of rock and roll guitar.10 It was Albert
Ammons who first introduced the younger Ammons to boogie-woogie and the blues. The
pianist spent a lot of time on the road performing; however, when he was home, Meade
9 Preston Lauterbach, The Chitlin’ Circuit: And the Road to Rock ‘n’ Roll (New York: W.W. Norton and
Company, 2011), 15.
10 Robert Walser, “The Rock and Roll Era,” in The Cambridge History of American Music, ed. Dave
Nicholls (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 1998), 348.
6
“Lux” Lewis and Pete Johnson were frequent visitors at the Ammons house.11 Albert
Ammons’ boogie-woogie piano playing undoubtedly influenced his sons’ eventual
penchant for fusing the bebop elements that the young saxophonist acquired later with the
blues elements introduced at home.
Like many other saxophonists of his era, Gene Ammons began his music
education on clarinet, making the transition to the tenor saxophone shortly thereafter.12
He attended DuSable High School and studied music under the baton of the renowned
Captain Walter Henri Dyett.13 An alumnus of The University of California at Berkeley,
“Captain” Walter Dyett was given his nickname when he began conducting the Eighth
Regiment Army Band of the Illinois National Guard. Dyett, a violinist, began playing
with Erskine Tate a few years after moving to Chicago in 1921. During his tenure at
DuSable High School, he became famous for his high musical standards. He was a strict
disciplinarian, whose pedagogy included lots of yelling and swearing; however, he was
also remembered by his students for his ability to motivate. Tenor saxophonist and
DuSable alumnus Bill Adkins claimed that the band director could not say good morning
without cursing. Adkins also states that Dyett was a remarkable communicator who
would have been successful teaching any subject.14 The bandmaster schooled a
remarkable number of student musicians who would soon become famous, many of
whom are listed below in Table 2.1. Among others, this list includes jazz saxophone
11 Wilson, “Gene Ammons: ‘The Jug’”.
12 Dan Morgenstern, Living with Jazz (New York: Pantheon Books, 2004), 229.
13 Richard Wang, “Captain Walter Dyett,” Chicago Jazz Magazine (May 27, 2008),
http://www.chicagojazz.com/thescene/captain-walter-dyett-86.html.
14 Timuel D. Black, Jr., Bridges of Memory: Chicago's Second Generation of Black Migration (Evanston,
Il: Northwestern University Press, 2007), 82-83.
7
legends Gene Ammons, Johnny Griffin, Eddie Harris, Von Freeman and Clifford Jordan;,
Count Basie trumpeter George T. “Sonny” Cohn and Duke Ellington trumpeter Ray
Nance; jazz vocal icons Johnny Hartman, Nathaniel Adams Coles (known professionally
as Nat King Cole) and Dinah Washington; famous jazz bassists Milt Hinton and Wilbur
Ware; and drummers Jerome Cooper, Wilbur Campbell and Walter “Baby Sweets”
Perkins. Saxophonists John Gilmore (Sun Ra), Joseph Jarmon (Art Ensemble of Chicago)
and experimental violinist Leroy Jenkins would eventually emerge as important avant-
garde voices. Other commercially successful graduates from DuSable High School
include rock and roll guitarist and vocalist Bo Diddley, as well as comedian and actor
Redd Foxx. Dr. Emil Hamberlin was a teacher a DuSable High School for over thirty
years. In a 1996 interview, he claimed that most all of the black students at DuSable High
School were “aggressively academic,” because they realized that education was their way
out of poverty.15
Table 2.1: Musicians who studied with Captain Walter Dyett
Gene Ammons Red Foxx Clifford Jordan
Ronnie Boykins Von Freeman King Kolax
Oscar Brashear John Gilmore Claude McLin
Homer Brown Bennie Green Jessie Miller
Wilbur Campbell Johnny Griffin Ray Nance
Sonny Cohn Eddie Harris Pat Patrick
Nat King Cole Johnny Hartman Walter Perkins
Jerome Cooper Milt Hinton Julian Priester
Richard Davis Fred Hopkins Wilbur Ware
Bo Diddley Joseph Jarman Dinah Washington
Dorothy Donegan Leroy Jenkins John Young
15 Black, Bridges of Memory: Second Generation, 212-213.
8
Historian and author Dempsey Travis claimed that “DuSable High School
produced more jazz musicians in the 1930s and 40s under the direction of Captain Walter
Dyett than any other institution in the country.”16 At DuSable High, Dyett directed the
beginner band, concert band, honors band, booster band, ROTC band and the orchestra.
In 1936, the band director began producing the school’s annual Hi-Jinks musicals, a
tradition that continued well into the 1960s after he retired. Because of Dyett, DuSable
High School became so widely known for its musical talent that famous jazz musicians
such as Duke Ellington would drop in to scout talent and meet with the students.17 In
2008, the Institute of Chicago organized a celebration of Captain Dyett and his career as a
public school music teacher. The commemoration included naming a plaza after Dyett
and unveiling a statue of him. Like so many other great musicians from the south side of
Chicago, Gene Ammons learned to hone his musical craft into art under the tutelage of
Captain Walter Dyett.
While still attending DuSable High School, Ammons joined trumpeter King
Kolax’s band and soon became the band’s featured soloist on the tenor saxophone. Kolax
was born William Little in Kansas City in 1912, but his family moved to Chicago where
he too studied music under the direction of Captain Walter Dyett.18 Kolax’s band was a
staging ground for many notable jazz icons including Charlie Parker, Nat “King” Cole,
16 Dempsey J. Travis, An Autobiography of Black Jazz, 1st
ed. (Chicago: Urban Research Institute, Inc.,
1983), 208.
17 Timuel D. Black, Jr., Bridges of Memory: The First Wave of Black Migration (Evanston, Il:
Northwestern University Press, 2003), 181-182.
18 Robert L. Campbell, Armin Büttner and Robert Pruter, “The King Kolax Discography,” Clemson
University, August 20, 2013, accessed February 15, 2015, http://myweb.clemson.edu/~campber/kolax.html.
9
John Coltrane, and Cannonball Adderley. Shortly after joining Kolax’s band, Ammons
left school on a national tour with him which included multiple engagements at the
famous Savoy Ballroom.19 In 1944, Billy Eckstine heard Ammons perform with Kolax
and hired the saxophonist on the spot.
Dubbed the “Sepia Sinatra” by Down Beat magazine, vocalist and trumpeter
William Clarence “Billy” Eckstine left the Earl Hines Orchestra in 1943 with the hopes
of putting his own band together.20 The following year he formed his own group and,
though it was only extant from 1944 to 1947, his ensemble was an all-star band
comprised of some of the top bebop musicians around at that time. Some historians such
as Kenny Mathieson claim that his band was a “crucial staging post on the way to
bebop.”21 Nancy Wilson described the group as fertile ground for the imminent bebop
revolution.22 Jazz historian and former editor for Metronome and Down Beat magazines,
Dan Morgenstern, makes this claim as well, calling the band the “chief incubator of
budding bebop talent.”23 Other historians such as Barry Kernfeld go one step further,
claiming that the Billy Eckstine Orchestra was indeed the first bebop band.24
An extraordinary number of jazz legends, listed below in Table 2.2, performed
with the Billy Eckstine Orchestra. This included bebop pioneers such as Charlie Parker
and Sonny Stitt on the alto saxophone; Gene Ammons, Charlie Rouse, Wardell Gray, Eli
19 Barry Kernfeld, “Ammons, Gene,” American Nation Biography Online, February, 2000, accessed
February 11, 2015, http://www.anb.org.ezproxy.lib.utexas.edu/articles/18/18-02717.html.
20 Cary Ginell, Mr. B: The Music and Life of Billy Eckstine (Milwaukee: Hal Leonard Books, 2013), 53.
21 Kenny Mathieson, Cookin’: Hard Bop and Soul Jazz, 1954-65 (Edinburgh, UK: Canongate Books,
2002), 71.
22 Wilson, “Gene Ammons: ‘The Jug’”.
23 Morgenstern, Living with Jazz, 230.
24 Kernfeld, “Ammons, Gene”.
10
“Lucky” Thompson and Dexter Gordon on the tenor saxophone; as well as John Burkes
“Dizzy” Gillespie, Miles Davis and Fats Navarro on the trumpet. The influential jazz
vocalist Sarah Vaughan also worked with the Eckstine band. Some of the band members
went on to achieve success in other genres as well. Art Blakely became an iconic hard
bop drummer, founding and leading the Jazz Messengers for over thirty-five years.
Saxophonists Ammons and Lucky Thompson gained recognition as rhythm and blues
artists, and Dexter Gordon became a hard bop legend. Miles Davis was influential across
numerous genres beyond bebop, most notably cool jazz, hard bop, modal jazz and fusion.
According to Barry Kernfeld, Eckstine had originally hired Charlie Parker on alto
saxophone and Charlie Rouse on tenor saxophone; however, Rouse was apparently so
captivated by Parker’s playing that he couldn’t focus on his own parts. Consequently, he
was fired and replaced by Ammons, who served as the principal soloist with Eckstine’s
band from late 1944 until the band broke up in 1947. He shines on a number of the
orchestra’s hits including “Blowing the Blues Away,” “I Love the Rhythm in a Riff,”
“Second Balcony Jump,” “Cool Breeze” and “Oop Bop Sh’bam.” Additionally, Ammons
was featured along with Eckstine in the 1946 film Rhythm in a Riff.25 It was during his
tenure with the band that he earned the nickname “Jug.” The bandleader had ordered
straw hats for the guys and was surprised at the unusually large size of the saxophonist’s
head, at which time he declared that Ammons had a head like a jug.26
25 Kernfeld, “Ammons, Gene”.
26 Bruce Walker, “Gene Ammons Biography,” Index of Musician Biographies, 2015, accessed February
22, 2015, http://www.musicianguide.com/biographies/1608003392/Gene-Ammons.html.
11
Table 2.2: Musicians who played in the Billy Eckstine Orchestra
Gene Ammons Wardell Gray Sonny Stitt
Art Blakey Budd Johnson Eli “Lucky” Thompson
Tadd Dameron Howard McGhee Jerry Valentine
Miles Davis Fats Navarro Sarah Vaughan
Dizzy Gillespie Charlie Parker
Dexter Gordon Charlie Rouse
In early 1947, Ammons was making his mark as a soloist in jam sessions at
Chicago’s Jumptown Club alongside contemporaries such as Miles Davis and Sonny
Stitt. He led his own small groups from the middle of 1947 until the spring of 1949.
Albert Ammons had been a recording artist for Mercury Records and, like his father,
Gene Ammons began to record for Mercury as well. In the summer of 1947, the record
label brought father and son together in the studio to record “Hiroshima” and “St. Louis
Blues.” There are very few recordings of Gene and Albert Ammons together, all of which
were recorded for Mercury Records over two recording dates. These include Mercury
8140 (“Why I’m Leaving You”), Mercury 8022 (“Swanee River Boogie” and “I Don’t
Want to See You”), Mercury 70158X45 (“Swanee River Boogie” and “I Don’t Want to
See You” from the same session); all recorded on July 2, 1946. Gene and Albert
Ammons’ last recorded collaboration took place on August 6, 1947, producing Mercury
8053 (“St. Louis Blues” and “Shufflin’ the Boogie”) and Mercury 8063 (“S.P. Blues” and
“Hiroshima”).27 Gene Ammons also had his first hit as leader in 1947. Entitled “Red
Top,” the tune was named after his wife, Mildred.28
27 Jazz Discography Project, “Gene Ammons Catalog,” Jazz Discography Project, last modified July 26,
2001, accessed March 19, 2015, http://www.jazzdisco.org/gene-ammons/catalog/.
28 Kernfeld, “Ammons, Gene”.
12
In 1949, Stan Getz left Woody Herman’s illustrious Second Herd, also known as
the Four Brothers Band. That spring, Gene Ammons replaced Getz as Herman’s principal
saxophone soloist in the Second Herd; however, his tenure with the band was short-lived.
He left the band in early September of 1949 and was replaced by Billy Mitchell.29
Ammons’ brief experience with Woody Herman would be his last stint as a sideman.30
In 1950, Ammons began what was to become a long-standing partnership with
fellow Eckstine alumnus, Sonny Stitt. Although the Ammons/Stitt Septet was only
together formally for two years, the two saxophonists reunited several times during their
lives to perform and record. Stitt was very competitive, always flaunting his virtuosic
technique and inexhaustible vocabulary. Ammons had the enormous sound and an ability
to hush an audience with one note. Together, they complimented each other and they took
their show to cities in the North. From 1950 to 1951, the Ammons/Stitt Septet performed
frequently in Detroit, Philadelphia, New York City and Boston; however, the majority of
their gigs throughout this time were at Birdland in New York. It was during this period
that the two tenor saxophonists recorded their first version of “Blues Up and Down.”
After the Ammons/Stitt Septet formally dissolved in 1952, Ammons continued
enjoying success on the road and in the studio, recording frequently on the Prestige label.
Sadly, however, he had also begun using heroin. Dan Morgenstern maintains that the
saxophonist stayed clean throughout his time with the Billy Eckstine Orchestra and with
29 Kernfeld, “Ammons, Gene”.
30 Morgenstern, Living with Jazz, 230.
13
Woody Herman’s Second Herd.31 The accuracy of this statement, however, could be
challenged. Miles Davis claims in his autobiography that he himself began using heroin
while playing in Eckstine’s band (which was defunct by the end of 1947), and that
Ammons was the person who introduced him to the drug.32 Moreover, circumstances in
Herman’s band make it difficult to believe that Ammons wasn’t using heroin in the late
1940s. According to Stan Getz, heroin use was rampant in the Second Herd.33 Indeed,
Stan Getz and Serge Chaloff were both notorious for their addiction. By his own account,
however, Ammons started using heroin sometime in the early 1950s.34
In 1958, Ammons was sent to the Statesville Penitentiary near Joliet, Illinois on a
conviction for possession of narcotics. He was paroled two years later in June of 1960. It
was during this brief respite from jail time that Ammons made his seminal recording Boss
Tenor with Tommy Flanagan on piano, Doug Watkins on bass, Art Taylor on drums and
Ray Barretto on congas. This recording included one of Ammons’ biggest hits,
“Canadian Sunset.” Unfortunately, one of the terms of his parole involved his exclusion
from performing in clubs. After repeatedly asking in vain for consent to make a living
playing his saxophone, he ultimately began gigging without permission. His parole was
promptly revoked and he went back to prison to serve the remaining five months of his
original sentence. He was released for the second time in January of 1961.35
31 Morgenstern, Living with Jazz, 230.
32 Miles Davis and Quincy Troupe, Miles: The Autobiography (New York: Simon and Schuster, 1989), 96.
33John Twomey, “Stan Getz- 'The Sound': Pioneer of Cool, Bossa Nova and Modern Jazz,” 2004, accessed
February 23, 2015, http://www.stangetz.net/bio.html.
34 Kernfeld, “Ammons, Gene”.
35 Morgenstern, Living with Jazz, 231.
14
After his second release from federal prison, Ammons began recording
extensively on the Verve and Prestige labels. The saxophonist was at the height of his
career, making hit records like Boss Tenors, recorded with Sonny Stitt in August of 1961
and Up Tight!, recorded in October of the same year. With the terms of his parole now
lifted, he appeared often at McKie’s Lounge in Chicago with fellow saxophonists Dexter
Gordon, Sonny Stitt and James Moody. The Hammond B-3 organ had begun replacing
the piano in smaller jazz combos. Organists like Jimmy Smith, Richard “Groove” Holmes
and “Brother” Jack McDuff were connecting jazz fans to rhythm and blues, and Gene
Ammons was enthusiastic about the evolution of the Soul Jazz movement. He cut several
records during this time with his organ combos including Live! In Chicago with organist
Eddie Buster in August 1961, Twisting the Jug with Jack McDuff in November 1961,
Brother Jack Meets the Boss with McDuff in January 1962 and Preachin’ with Clarence
“Sleepy” Anderson on organ in May 1962.
Jazz historian and record producer, Bob Porter, claims that Ammons was at the
height of his musical career from 1961 to 1962. Porter also states that the saxophonist
was strung out on heroin that entire time.36 In September of 1962, Ammons was arrested
again, this time on the much more consequential charge of selling narcotics. Porter insists
that Ammons was set up and that someone in Cook County, Illinois “had it in” for him.37
Dan Morgenstern states, “it was a clear case of entrapment, including extortion of a bribe
36 Wilson, “Gene Ammons: ‘The Jug’”.
37 Ibid.
15
($5,000 according to Gene), but there was no mercy.”38 Illinois’ narcotics laws were
strict, and Ammons was sentenced to another ten to twelve years back at Statesville
Penitentiary. He ended up serving seven years of that sentence, from September 1962 to
October of 1969.
While in prison serving this extended sentence, Ammons managed to keep his
music career alive. At Statesville, he was permitted to practice his saxophone.
Additionally, he was in charge of the music library and he directed the prison band.
Outside of prison, Bob Weinstock, founder and executive producer at Prestige Records,
was working to keep the Ammons name alive. Weinstock, whether because of some
feeling of foreboding or otherwise, had recorded the saxophonist extensively between
1961 and 1962; however, he did not release these recordings immediately. Instead, he
released them gradually and systematically during Ammons’ seven-year stay at
Statesville. Some of these Prestige releases include Velvet Soul (1964), Late Hour Special
(1964), Sock! (1965), Angel Eyes (1965) and Boss Soul! (1966).39
Twelve days after his release in October of 1969, Ammons began resurrecting his
career at the Plugged Nickel in Chicago with Kolax on the trumpet. The following month,
the saxophonist did a two-day session for Prestige which produced The Boss Is Back! and
Brother Jug!. The New York State Liquor Board ruled against allowing him to perform
in New York City after his discharge from prison; however, he was received warmly
everywhere else. He continued to collaborate with other formidable saxophonists on
38 Morgenstern, Living with Jazz, 231.
39 Discogs, “Gene Ammons Discography,” 2015, accessed February 24, 2015,
http://www.discogs.com/artist/45107-Gene-Ammons.
16
performance dates at venues such as the North Park Hotel in Chicago where he
performed with Dexter Gordon and Don Byas. In 1973, Ammons recorded one last time
with Sonny Stitt on Together Again for the Last Time. Poetically, the last song Ammons
ever recorded was the title track to his final record, Goodbye. Shortly thereafter, he was
diagnosed with bone cancer and, on August 6, 1974, he passed. To the jazz community,
he bequeathed a legacy of earthy and visceral saxophonists that would pride themselves
in emulating the Gene Ammons sound.
17
CHAPTER 3
The Sound and Vocality of Gene Ammons
Perhaps the most distinguishing characteristics of Gene Ammons’ music are his
sound and vocality; moreover, many saxophonists have since tried to emulate his timbral
and lyrical qualities. While these two traits are used together to produce a sonic identity
on the saxophone, this chapter will unpack the two elements separately. Sound, used here
interchangeably with tone quality or timbre, can be manipulated with physical
adjustments to the diaphragm and throat position to shape or color the timbre of notes.
Additionally, the selection of particular reeds, mouthpieces and horns can influence a
saxophonist’s sound. Vocality, as it applies to Ammons, is a lyrical quality that can be
traced back to its origins in African vocal music, Afro-American preaching styles and
gospel music.
Sound
Nancy Wilson described Ammons’ sound as being “titanic-like.” According to
Chicago radio host John Corbett, Ammons could be picked out of a crowd, even if he was
playing long tones, because of the way that he attended to his sound. Trumpeter Lonnie
Hillyer recalls an experience playing with Charles Mingus’ band. Ammons was also on
that gig; and, according to Hillyer, the saxophonist hushed the audience with one note.40
Likewise, pianist Junior Mance claimed that Ammons had the biggest tenor sound that he
40 Paul F. Berliner, Thinking in Jazz: The Infinite Art of Improvisation (Chicago: The University of
Chicago Press, 1994), 256.
18
had ever heard in his life. He stated that the saxophonist would buy a mouthpiece and file
it wide open in an effort to realize his tonal concept, making the mouthpiece unplayable
for anyone else.41
Before Ammons, many saxophonists, Lester Young included, were gravitating
toward the lighter, cleaner sounds of Rudy Wiedoft, Frankie Trumbauer, Bud Freeman
and Jimmy Dorsey. According to Doug Miller, however, numerous aspiring black
saxophonists, especially those that were contributing to the establishment of the rhythm
and blues style, were interested in imitating the “fatter, earthier sound” already modeled
by Sidney Bechet and Coleman Hawkins. This ‘Afro-American’ saxophone sound was
strengthened by managing an increase of the air column to produce a more balanced
relationship between a note’s fundamental harmonic and the overtones above the
fundamental. As a result, the center of resonance was forced out of the neck of the
saxophone and further into the body of the horn. More than any other Swing-Era
saxophonist, Hawkins’ tone quality served as a model for the next generation of
saxophone players, including Arnett Cobb, Illinois Jacquet, Al Sears and Buddy Tate.42
Hawkins’ tonal influence was a point of departure that led to the evolution of a rhythm
and blues saxophone tradition.
Ammons’ timbral concept also stemmed from the Hawkins school of tone
production. Additionally, his instrumental setup helped the saxophonist produce his
massive sound on the horn. He played a Conn 10M saxophone, a popular choice among
41 Wilson, “Gene Ammons: ‘The Jug’”.
42 Miller, “Moan Within the Tone,” 157-158.
19
saxophonists looking for a hot sound. He favored playing on Brilhart mouthpieces as
well. The white Brilhart Tonalin mouthpiece with which Ammons is so often pictured is
plastic instead of the usual hard rubber or metal, and the plastic composition of this
mouthpiece helped to enhance the edgy buzz in Ammons’ tone.
The technique of growling is a concept in which the saxophonist hums or yells
while playing, thereby producing a harsh or raspy tone. This manipulation of tone quality
became a salient feature of the Afro-American saxophone sound. Hawkins often
reinforced his hot sound by growling, and prime examples of his inclination to growl
include his 1939 recording of “Fine Dinner” from Body and Soul and “Stealin’ the Bean”
from his 1959 album Hawk Eyes!. This greatly influenced Gene Ammons, which is
evidenced in his recordings of “Scrapple From the Apple” or “Please Send Me Someone
to Love,” both released on his 1961 record Live! In Chicago. Ultimately, Hawkins’
growling technique became a hallmark of the rhythm and blues saxophone tradition, as
exemplified by Red Prysock’s 1954 recording of “Blow Your Horn.”
Vocality
The concept of the hot, Afro-American sound is steeped in the African vocal
tradition. Portia K. Maltsby, a Professor Emerita of Folklore and Ethnomusicology at
Indiana University, states:
In Africa and throughout the diaspora, black musicians produce an array of
unique sounds, many of which imitate those of nature, animals, spirits and
speech…[by]…the manipulation of timbre, texture and shading in ways
uncommon to Western practice. Hence, the human voice plays such a central role
20
in African music and is utilized in all manner of ways to achieve a wide range of
timbres and nuances.43
Neo-African vocalizations known as ‘field hollers’ or ‘arhoolies’ had been a crucial way
for slaves to preserve their dignity and identity during the harsh conditions of slavery in
the Deep South. African-Americans in the 1800s were forced to preserve African cultural
traditions because their participation in Euro-American life was discouraged by whites.44
They accomplished this by singing spiritual hymns called ‘ring shouts.’ Richard
Crawford is a former president of the American Musicological Society and Professor
Emeritus of Music at the University of Michigan. In his book, An Introduction to
America’s Music, he remarks:
Ring dancing was and is found in many parts of Africa. Indeed, during the time of
slavery, the ring shout was a way to bring transplanted Africans together. The ring
allowed a synthesis of all the elements of African-American music, including
calls and hollers; call and response; additive rhythms and polyrhythms;
heterophony, blue notes, bent notes and elisions; hums, moans and vocables; off-
beat melodic phrasings and parallel intervals and chords; constant repetition of
rhythmic figures and melodic phrases; game rivalry; hand clapping, foot patting;
and a rock-steady pulse.45
Additionally, black preaching styles dating back to the beginning of the
nineteenth century heavily influenced the lyricism inherent in rhythm and blues music.
Geoff Alexander is the director of the Academic Film Archive of North America. In his
1986 paper entitled “Black Preaching Styles,” he writes that black orators preached
“with” their congregation instead of “to” them, establishing a rhythm of interaction or
43 Miller, “Moan Within the Tone,” 161.
44 Richard Crawford, An Introduction to America’s Music (NewYork, NY: W.W. Norton and Company,
2001), 249.
45 Ibid., 257.
21
‘call and response’ with their audiences. Furthermore, preachers intoned their sermons in
a singing style, often using pitch repetition in their delivery of the gospel.46 These
characteristics are evidenced in the 1961 recording of “Blues Up and Down,” as Gene
Ammons and Sonny Stitt trade high C’s for two choruses of the blues. Ammons’ 1962
organ-combo recording, Preachin’, is comprised of eleven gospel hymns including
“Abide With Me,” “Blessed Assurance,” “You’ll Never Walk Alone,” and “Holy Holy.”
Synthesizing these vocal traditions on instruments seemed like the natural course
of events, and the saxophone was frequently used as a lyrical substitute for the human
voice. Much of Ammons’ lyricism occurs as a result of the way he attacks and releases
notes. Often, Ammons would start a note with one fingering and end the same note with a
different fingering. In doing so, he would change the timbre and tuning of the note
(sometimes by a quarter tone), giving that note a certain gruff vocal inflection that
mimicked the nuances (throaty groans, choked screams, etc.) of the Neo-African vocal
tradition. This is evidenced on his 1961 recording of “Blues Up and Down.” Also on the
same recording, he manipulates the decay of certain notes by falling off of them in a
‘wailing’ manner, even going so far as to punctuate certain phrase endings with his
speaking voice (grunts, yells, etc.).
Ammons was known for his ability to vocalize on his instrument, which was
especially evident on his recorded ballads. Charles Walton was a drummer and Associate
Professor of Music at Malcolm X College in Chicago. He extolled Ammons’ lyricism,
46 Geoff Alexander, “Black Preaching Styles,” Academic Film Archive of North America, December 10,
1986, accessed April 28, 2015, http://www.afana.org/preaching.htm.
22
stating that Ammons played ballads as if he had the lyrics in mind. Billie Holiday
claimed that Ammons’ version of “My Foolish Heart” was her favorite, and Ira Gitler
said that he heard Dinah Washington’s voice in Ammons’ playing. According to Nancy
Wilson, Ammons possessed a skill for emoting that was in line with, and influenced by,
the lyricism of Lester Young.47
Saxophonists frequently use ‘subtone’ when playing ballads. The art of subtone
goes beyond just playing softly, as it is a fuller sound with less edge or brightness and is
often most effective in the lowest register of the saxophone.48 Ammons possessed this
ability to play subtone with a hot sound, displaying the influence of the Swing-Era
saxophonist, Ben Webster; and, the attack of these subtone notes occurs while tonguing
very lightly or not at all. The air column is interrupted significantly enough for the notes
to sound articulated, but the tongue may not actually touch the reed. This “V” tongue
(sounding like “vuh-vuh”) can be heard on Ammons’ recording of “You Better Go Now”
from his 1962 album Blue Groove, and can be compared to Ben Webster’s articulation
two decades earlier on “You, You Darlin’.”
A number of rhythm and blues saxophonists were synthesizing Hawkins’ fast,
volatile vibrato along with his big sound. Ammons, however, diverges from this trend,
adopting an approach that is more in line with Lester Young’s concept of vibrato.
Young’s slower vibrato broke from the old, Swing-Era traditions of Louis Armstrong and
47 Wilson, “Gene Ammons: ‘The Jug’”.
48 Pete Thomas, “Subtone,” Taming the Saxophone, accessed April 3, 2015,
http://tamingthesaxophone.com/saxophone-subtone.
23
Coleman Hawkins. In fact, his forward-looking concept of vibrato foreshadowed the
emergence of the new bebop style of Charlie Parker, Sonny Stitt, Gene Ammons and
their contemporaries.
Gene Ammons’ use of growling, along with his hot and visceral tone quality,
were the influence of Coleman Hawkins. This, along with his use of Lester Young’s
lyrical blues vocalizations, gave him credibility as a rhythm and blues artist. Conversely,
his use of Young’s slower vibrato positioned him for success as a bebop player.
Ammons’ ability to amalgamate or compound the different ingredients that are
fundamental to his concept of sound contributed to his validation as a saxophonist who
was proficient in the rhythm and blues genre as well as the bebop style.
24
CHAPTER 4
Rhythmic Devices
Whereas most of the characteristics ingrained in Ammons’ concept of sound
support his inclusion predominantly in the rhythm and blues genre, there are other aspects
of his playing that substantiate his identity as a bebop player. Many of these traits are
melodic or harmonic; they are discussed in Chapter 5. Additionally, he employs certain
rhythmic devices with bebop implications that merit consideration.
The Eighth-Note Feel and the Rhythmic Pocket
The unevenness of swing eighth notes was less pronounced in bebop music,
especially as tempos began to increase.49 In this vein, Ammons’ eighth-note feel was a
departure from the highly pronounced, lilting eighth notes of Swing-Era saxophonists. In
fact he almost seemed to endorse a universal, slightly swung eighth-note feel, whether he
was playing swing or Latin tunes. Evidence of this can be heard on bossa novas like
“Pagan Love Song” from Bad! Bossa Nova or “Calypso Blues” on Night Lights. In both
cases, Ammons is discreetly swinging his eighth notes over a Latin bossa feel,
reminiscent of Charlie Parker’s Latin bebop approach to “A Night in Tunisia,” “Perdido,”
or “Barbados.” While saxophonists such as Sonny Stitt and Johnny Griffin were swinging
more overtly, Ammons’ approach to swing eighth notes was more in line with the subtler
swing feel of Dexter Gordon.
49 Richard J. Lawn, Experiencing Jazz (NewYork, NY: Routledge, 2013), 198.
25
In a jazz context, the rhythmic pocket is the regular and consistent placement of
the beat established by the bass and drums, and the placement of eighth notes within the
rhythmic pocket is a highly personalized aspect of a jazz performer’s identity in music.
Ammons generally opted to play right down the center of this pocket, distinguishing him
from some of his colleagues mentioned above. Sonny Stitt and Johnny Griffin gravitated
toward the front side of the beat. Dexter Gordon often laid back further, and was known
for playing ‘on his heels.’ Ammons’ pocket can be seen as a balance between Stitt’s
approach and Gordon’s feel.
Additionally, Ammons possessed the ability to float independently over the top of
the tempo at times. Dave Liebman calls this rhythmic device ‘over the time,’ stating:
A more abstract concept very much demonstrated by Eric Dolphy, Ornette
Coleman and John Coltrane at various periods is what I term over the time. This
means that for small episodic passages the improviser creates a sense of being out
of time without an obvious reference point. Usually these are fast noted passages
and wild sounding in texture, but the effect is of the improviser freeing himself
from the ongoing pulse like a bird in flight, quickly returning with a vengeance to
earth, or in other words completely swinging in time. The ability to do this
gracefully is one of the highest forms of time playing in my opinion. To be free
but to know where you are at the same time is magical.50
A connection can be made here to the polymetric and polyrhythmic time relationships
found in African music. Pulitzer prize-winning composer, author and historian Gunther
Schuller claims that African polyrhythms are very complex, involving phrases that
seldom coincide vertically. Rather than conforming to strict double-time rhythms within
the beat, playing ‘over the time’ is a gestural occurrence that transcends the confines of
50 Dave Liebman, “Jazz Rhythm,” 2009, accessed March 15, 2015,
http://www.daveliebman.com/Feature_Articles/JazzRhythm.htm.
26
the beat. In the African polyrhythmic tradition, these gestures are rhythmically additive
instead of divisive.51
Liebman is describing this concept in an avant-garde or free jazz context;
however, the Parker-influenced flurries played by Ammons and other bebop musicians
also fit this description. Bebop was essentially eighth-note based, but Parker’s solos were
often riddled with episodic, blistering double-time as well as over-the-time figures that
eclipsed the strict underlying pulse. Moreover, it is likely that Dolphy, Coleman and
Coltrane were all juxtaposing the influence of Parker on the jazz music of their
generation. For these reasons, an argument can be made that playing ‘over the time’ was
a bebop characteristic before it was popularized by avant-garde players. Furthermore, this
technique shifts priority away from being able to dance to the beat, which contradicts the
mandate of both swing and rhythm and blues music.52
A good example of Ammons’ ability to play ‘over the time’ is illustrated in
Example 4.1. During his solo on “Please Send Me Someone to Love,” Ammons launches
a barrage of fast notes beginning with strict double time thirty-second notes occurring
from beat 3 of m. 89 to beat 3 of m. 90. On beat 4 of m. 90, however, he abandons the
beat and tempo, now playing in a fitful and episodic state that has been notated according
to the closest available rhythmic options. He returns to strict adherence of the time on the
last sixteenth note of beat 3 in m. 92.
51 Gunther Schuller, Early Jazz: Its Roots and Musical Development (New York, NY: Oxford University
Press, 1968), 11.
52 Bob Blumenthal, “Chapter 6: Bebop and Modern Jazz,” in Discover Jazz, ed. John Edwards Hasse and
Tad Lathrop (Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education, Inc., 2012), 132.
27
Example 4.1: Gene Ammons, “Please Send Me Someone to Love,” mm. 89-93
Hemiola
A ‘hemiola,’ or ‘cross-rhythm,’ is a rhythmic event that features the implication
of one meter inside the framework of another. One particular type of hemiola that
occurred frequently in the improvisation of Gene Ammons is a rhythmic device in which
triple meter (3/4 or 3/8) is implied over music written in 4/4 time. This device, known as
‘three against four,’ is a common jazz cross-rhythm.53 Much like Liebman’s concept of
playing ‘over the time,’ bebop hemiolas serve to undermine the rhythmic regularity of the
music that might otherwise promote dancing. Though the use of rhythmic devices such as
three against four is not unique to bebop, the movement away from performing jazz as
dance music is certainly a bebop characteristic.54 In contrast to swing and Latin styles,
53 Richard J. Lawn and Jeffrey L. Hellmer, Jazz: Theory and Practice (Belmont, CA: Wadsworth
Publishing Company, 1993), 70.
54 Lawn, Experiencing Jazz, 196.
28
hemiolas in a bebop context tend to occur sporadically and unpredictably, often starting
on weak beats.
Charlie Parker flirted with the use of hemiolas. Example 4.2 is an excerpt of the
melody to “Moose the Mooche,” adapted from the Charlie Parker Omnibook.55
Beginning on the second beat of m. 31, Parker plays two groupings of three beats. This
lends rhythmic uncertainty to the melody of the tune just before the solo begins at the
double bar in m. 33.
Example 4.2: Charlie Parker, “Moose the Mooche,” mm. 29-32
In Example 4.3 from the 1961 version of “Blues Up and Down,” Ammons repeats
the motive introduced on the downbeat of m. 177 three additional times. The four
iterations of this three-beat motive make Ammons sound like he has temporarily lapsed
into 3/4 time while improvising over this up-tempo, twelve-bar blues in quadruple meter.
However, this hemiola only lasts for a duration of three measures and the tempo is 250
beats per minute. The listener does not have enough time to get comfortable with this
briefly imposed feel.
55 Jamey Aebersold and Ken Slone, Charlie Parker Omnibook: For Eb Instruments, Transcribed Exactly
From His Solos (Lynbrook, NY: Atlantic Music Corp., 1978), 4-5.
29
Example 4.3: Gene Ammons, “Blues Up and Down” (1961), mm. 176-180
Later in the same recording of “Blues Up and Down,” Ammons uses a ‘3 + 3 + 2’
cross-rhythm in which the eight beats of two consecutive measures are arranged into two
groups of three with an additional group of two beats at the end. Ammons uses this
hemiola in combination with a chromatic descending sequence. Here in Example 4.4, the
three-beat motive ascends in step-wise motion from the root of Dmin7 on the downbeat
of m. 441 to the fifth of the chord on beat 3. The original motive is then sequenced down
by a half step on beat 4, anticipating the G7 chord by one beat with its tritone
substitution, D!7. A truncated version of the motive is sequenced down chromatically
one last time on beat 3 of m. 442, anticipating the C7 chord by two beats. The brief use of
the 3 + 3 + 2 hemiola, coupled with the chromatically sequenced motive that anticipates
the harmonies, gives Ammons’ solo a sense of sophisticated organization that is typical in
his playing and representative of the bebop language.
Example 4.4: Gene Ammons, “Blues Up and Down” (1961), mm. 441-445
30
Example 4.5 illustrates Ammons’ use of ‘3 + 3 + 2’ on his 1962 recording of the
Latin bossa, “Anna.” Here the saxophonist uses diminution, manipulating the eighth-note
subdivisions of the measure into groups of 3 + 3 + 2. In doing so, he is appropriately
reacting to the Latin clave style of the rhythm section. The drummer, Oliver Jackson, is
playing a ‘bossa nova clave’ or ‘Brazilian clave’ rhythm on the rim of the snare drum
throughout the tune. This rhythmic pattern is produced by accenting beat 1, the upbeat of
beat 2 and beat 4 in the first measure of this two-bar pattern, as well as beat 2 and the
upbeat of beat 3 in the second measure.56 Hank Jones reinforces this rhythm on piano
while comping during Ammons’ solo. Example 4.5 is in fact a dance rhythm hook;
nonetheless, this example still belongs to the Bebop Era. The syncopated sixteenth-note
subdivisions imply a double-time feel, thereby capturing the bebop essence.
Example 4.5: Gene Ammons, “Anna,” mm. 53-55
Example 4.5 shown above is representative of what Jelly Roll Morton called the
‘Latin tinge,’ which was embraced in bebop music by Dizzy Gillespie in songs such as
“Manteca” and “A Night in Tunisia.”57 Similarly, Charlie Parker’s interest in Latin
rhythms is evidenced in his recordings of “Barbados” and “My Little Suede Shoes.”
56 Tim Richards and John Crawford, Exploring Latin Piano: South-American/Cuban/Spanish Rhythms for
the Intermediate Pianist (London: Schott Music Ltd., 2011), 135.
57 Thomas Owens, Bebop: The Music and Its Players (NewYork, NY: Oxford University Press, 1995), 20.
31
Whereas the timbral and stylistic traits discussed in Chapter 3 place Ammons in multiple
genres, the rhythmic characteristics discussed in this chapter support his inclusion in the
bebop community.
32
CHAPTER 5
Gene Ammons’ Vocabulary: The Coalescence of Swing, Rhythm and
Blues, and Bebop
Gene Ammons possessed an ability to fuse elements of swing, rhythm and blues,
and bebop into his own style. Additionally, he had the wherewithal to assess his audience
on any given night and unpack elements of the above genres to use them separately. Bob
Porter stated that Ammons’ vocabulary would be heavily weighted with bebop language
if he was playing on the north side of Chicago to predominantly white patrons.
Conversely, according to Porter, Ammons would emote in the rhythm and blues
vernacular if he was performing on the south side of Chicago to a black audience.58 He
learned from his predecessors, Coleman Hawkins and Lester Young, as well as his
contemporaries such as Charlie Parker, Illinois Jacquet, Sonny Stitt, and Red Prysock.
With respect to Ammons’ vocabulary, direct stylistic comparisons can be made to all of
the above-mentioned saxophonists excluding Coleman Hawkins. This chapter is an
analysis of some of the aspects of Ammons’ melodic and harmonic language that unify
him with these seminal swing, rhythm and blues, and bebop saxophonists.
Elements of Swing: The Influence of Lester Young
The year 1944 marked the beginning of Gene Ammons’ extensive recording
career. Though the Swing Era was winding down, its pervasive influence could still be
58 Wilson, “Gene Ammons: ‘The Jug’”.
33
heard in the language of the next generation of jazz musicians. The young Ammons was a
forward-thinking improviser; however, his roots were steeped in swing. While discussing
the swing elements in Ammons’ playing, a point of reference should be drawn to Lester
Young. Gunther Schuller extolls Young as the most progressive improviser of his time:
…in terms of a revolutionizing and lasting effect on several further generations of
jazz players, it is an incontrovertible fact that Lester was the most influential artist
after Armstrong and before Charlie Parker. What eluded Coleman Hawkins
despite his life-long heroic strivings, namely, domination of the saxophone world,
virtually fell into Lester’s lap. And before his life was a little more than half over,
he had not only spawned a whole school of followers but created a completely
new aesthetic of jazz – for all instruments, not just the tenor saxophone. The
essence of his heritage is that he proposed a totally new alternative to the
language, grammar, and vocabulary of jazz, one that broke away from the
prevailing Armstrong tradition and did so incisively, unequivocally and
unapologetically.59
Lester Young did not start recording until 1936, but his new style, which was
decidedly different from the established swing paradigms, was already developed. This
was evidenced by his severance of employment with Fletcher Henderson before
becoming the lead tenor player with Count Basie from 1934 to 1939.60 Henderson’s
players were all listening to Louis Armstrong and Coleman Hawkins. Young, however,
was avoiding Hawkins’ style, favoring the influence of Jimmy Dorsey and Frankie
Trumbauer. This would explain Young’s cool, light sound.61 Whereas Hawkins’ melodic
style was vertical and more chord-based, Young’s was more linear, deriving from the
59 Gunther Schuller, The Swing Era (New York: Oxford University Press, 1989), 547.
60 David Simpson, “Lester Young: An American Original,” Jazz Institute of Chicago, 2013, accessed
March 1, 2015, http://www.jazzinchicago.org/educates/journal/articles/lester-young-american-original.
61 Schuller, The Swing Era, 548.
34
blues. Indeed, at the age of twenty-five, Young was cutting his teeth playing the blues in
Kansas City with Count Basie.
6/9 Common Language: The Major Pentatonic Scale
Among other melodic tendencies, Lester Young emphasized the sixth and ninth
scale degrees of the key. Additionally, according to Schuller, the concept of melodic
independence from the harmonic progression began with Young.62 These two qualities
combine together to form an approach to improvisation often described as ‘6/9 common
language.’ This vocabulary consists of the major pentatonic scale (scale degrees 1-2-3-5-
6) on the tonic note in the key (C major pentatonic in the key of C major). The
framework of this major pentatonic scale, peppered with chromatic tones, constitutes the
generality of the 6/9 common language. Whereas Gene Ammons did, in fact, try to
emulate the sound of Coleman Hawkins, he was clearly studying the melodic vocabulary
of Lester Young, synthesizing Young’s 6/9 common language into his own playing.
One of the most well-known ‘rhythm changes’63 tunes is Young’s own
composition “Lester Leaps In,” originally recorded in 1939 by Count Basie’s Kansas City
Seven. The first phrase of the actual melody in the A section of the head is illustrated
below in Example 5.1. It is a strict adherence to the major pentatonic scale built on the
tonic of the key. Except for the omission of the last note, the second phrase of the A
section is identical, completing the eight-bar A section of this ‘rhythm changes’ tune. As
62 Schuller, The Swing Era, 548.
63 A ‘rhythm changes’ tune contains a standardized harmonic progression identical to the progression in
George and Ira Gershwin’s “I Got Rhythm.” Hence, a rhythm changes tune could be thought of as a
contrafact, a new melody composed over the preexisting changes to “I Got Rhythm.”
35
is typical of a ‘rhythm changes’ tune, there is no written melody over the bridge. Every
note of the written melody of “Lester Leaps In” conforms to the pentatonic major scale
built on the tonic of the key. Scale degree 2 is not represented in the melody; otherwise,
there are no deviations outside of this pentatonic framework.
Example 5.1: Lester Young, “Lester Leaps In,” mm. 4-7
Example 5.2 is a paragon of Young’s penchant for expanding the blanket major
pentatonic scale with chromatic connections – specifically between scale degrees 2-3 and
5-6. In m. 129 of his solo on “Lester Leaps In,” Young uses chromatic passing tones,
labeled “PT,” first to move from scale degree 6 to scale degree 5 and then to descend
from scale degree 3 to scale degree 9 (or 2). On the upbeat of beat 4 in m. 130, he again
uses a passing tone to get from scale degree 5 back to scale degree 6, this time in an
ascending manner. In m. 131, the E on beat 2 (scale degree 3) is approached by a
chromatic lower neighbor, labeled “LN.” Two more chromatic passing tones in the
second half of m. 131 help Young navigate melodically through this pentatonic scale,
traveling from scale degree 6 on the upbeat of beat 2 to scale degree 9 on the downbeat of
the following measure. The passing tones and lower neighbor circled in mm. 129-132
illustrate the fact that the saxophonist is comfortable using the chromatic notes outside of
the pentatonic scale on both strong and weak parts of the beat.
36
Example 5.2: Lester Young, “Lester Leaps In,” mm. 129-132
Billy Eckstine’s 1944 recording “Blowing the Blues Away” features Gene
Ammons very early in the saxophonist’s career. At this time, the foundation of Ammons’
vocabulary is the 6/9 common language popularized by Lester Young. Example 5.3
shows Ammons using the D!’s repeatedly as chromatic lower neighbors, labeled “LN,”
to approach scale degree 3 of this C major pentatonic scale. In doing so, Ammons
vacillates between the major third and the minor third (written as a D! or !9), which
accentuates the blues aspect of this melody. Finally, a chromatic passing tone at the end
of m. 38 delivers the melody from scale degree 6 to scale degree 5, similar to Ammons’
approach in Example 5.2.
Example 5.3: Gene Ammons, “Blowing the Blues Away,” mm. 37-39
In Example 5.4 Ammons embellishes the blanket major pentatonic scale in the
key of D with a diatonic scale degree 4, rather than using chromatic pitches. The G in m.
2 acts as an upper neighbor, labeled “UN,” and can be thought of as a slow turn. The G in
m. 4 is a passing tone, getting Ammons from scale degree 3 to scale degree 5. The F! in
37
m. 3 does not fit the A7 chord, further reinforcing the fact that Ammons was using 6/9
common language to blanket the quick IV chord (A7) during his solo on “St. Louis
Blues.” This is reminiscent of Young’s inclination to play melodies that might not adhere
completely to the chord changes.
Example 5.4: Gene Ammons, “St. Louis Blues,” mm. 1-5
Example 5.5 is significant in that it illustrates the conclusive placement of
pentatonic vocabulary at the end of Ammons’ solo in the key of G on “Red Top.” It was
common for both Young and Ammons to frame sections of their solos with 6/9 common
language. The soloists might deviate from this pentatonic scaffolding while developing
their solos; however; they would frequently return to this language when wrapping up a
section of a solo, or when ending a solo altogether.
Example 5.5: Gene Ammons, “Red Top,” mm. 41-42
The beginning of Ammons’ solo on his 1950 recording of “Blues Up and Down”
is shown below in Example 5.6. More than on his earlier recordings, Ammons is
beginning to sound increasingly confident with some of the non-swing elements he was
38
incorporating into his vocabulary. However, this 6/9 common language is still a major
component of his improvisations. In the example below, Ammons demonstrates his
ability to slip in and out of C major pentatonic vocabulary through his use of
chromaticism at the beginning of m. 2, the addition of the !7 at the end of m. 3, and the
use of the !5 at the end of m. 4.
Example 5.6: Gene Ammons, “Blues Up and Down” (1950), mm. 1-4
Dominant7(!5): The Creation and Resolution of Tension
Across a number of tonal styles and genres in western music64, phrases almost
always end with a cadence that shifts harmonically from a dominant chord (V) to the
tonic chord (I). This simple process can be seen on a fundamental level as the creation
and subsequent resolution of aural tension. Whether consciously or subconsciously,
listeners hear dominant triads and understand that those chords need to be resolved to
tonic chords when cadencing at the end of phrases. Adding a seventh to the dominant
chord (V7) increases the tension.65 Lester Young was fond of creating even more
dominant tension by raising the fifth of the chord (V7!5). Chromatic alteration of the
64 For the purpose of this paper, ‘western music’ will be defined as the music of Western Europe, in which
major and minor modes and their requisite intervallic relationships are used to construct tonal centers.
65 Ralph Turek, Theory for Today’s Musician (New York: McGraw-Hill, 2007), 613-614.
39
dominant chord’s ninth and fifth occurred with increasing frequency during the evolution
of bebop; and, though Young fits squarely in the Swing Era, the use of augmented (V7!5)
chords by Young, his contemporaries, and even his predecessors could been interpreted
as a foreshadowing of the extended harmonic techniques that would soon be popularized
by bebop innovators like Charlie Parker.
Bob Porter remarked that Lester Young was known for adding “color” to
dominant chords, particularly at the end of the B section in AABA form.66 Porter’s claim
is illustrated below in Example 5.7. This excerpt shows the last four measures of the B
section in the rhythm changes tune, “Lester Leaps In,” followed by the first measure of
the last A section. In m. 59, Young plays a descending, two-octave G7(!5) chord, which
is V7(!5) in the home key of C major. In m. 60, the last measure of the bridge, Young
transitions from his augmented vocabulary back to a fixation on the pitches A and D
which represent scale degrees 6 and 9 respectively in the home key of C. He then plays
6/9 common language vocabulary for the entire last A section of this chorus.
Example 5.7: Lester Young, “Lester Leaps In,” mm. 57-61
Lester Young’s fresh approach to improvisation became the benchmark for the
new generation of jazz saxophonists, and his melodic ideas worked exceptionally well in
66 Bob Porter, Lester Young (Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press, 2005), 67.
40
swing and bebop settings alike. Gene Ammons was a quick study, and his use of the
V7(!5) chord manifests itself in his earliest recordings. In Example 5.8, Ammons uses
the dominant7(!5) chord to progress from the I chord to the IV7 chord in “Blowing the
Blues Away.” The C major chord in m. 39 represents the I chord in this standard blues
progression. The introduction of the B! in m. 40 signifies that the I chord has now
become a secondary dominant (V7/IV), setting the listener up for the resolution to F7 in
m. 41. Before Ammons arrives in m. 41, however, he raises the fifth of C7 on beat 3 of
m. 40. This adds heightened tension to the dominant tonality in m. 40 which, in turn,
makes the resolution to F7 in m. 41 even more satisfying.
Example 5.8: Gene Ammons, “Blowing the Blues Away,” mm. 39-41
Ammons, like Young, realized that the improviser could quickly and efficiently
change the color of the dominant chord simply by altering one note. He showed this
tendency often when transitioning to the IV chord in the fifth measure of standard blues
forms like “Blowing the Blues Away,” illustrated above in Example 5.8. Example 5.9
below reinforces this claim. Here, Ammons is on his second chorus, soloing over a
standard blues progression in D on “St. Louis Blues.” The fourth measure of the form is
m. 16, one measure before the arrival of the IV chord. Ammons begins the measure
playing an unaltered D7 chord (V7/IV) in a linear manner; however, after arriving on the
41
A (the fifth of D7), he toggles upward by a half step to A! on beat 3. He then briefly
arpeggiates the triad in the D7(!5) chord before vacillating back to A natural, which now
acts as the resolution to the ninth of the IV chord, G7.
Example 5.9: Gene Ammons, “St. Louis Blues,” mm. 15-17
Example 5.7 above addresses Lester Young’s use of the dominant7(!5) chord at
the end of the B section as a means of ushering the listener back to the final A section of
the form. The following example, Example 5.10, shows Ammons employing Young’s
technique. Similar to Young’s 1939 version of “Lester Leaps In,” Ammons’ 1955
recording of “Juggernaut” is also a rhythm changes tune whose formal structure is
AABA. The G7 chord in mm. 88-89 in the example below is the V chord at the end of the
B section. Here, Ammons emphasizes the !5 color extensively by arpeggiating G7(!5)
for two measures. The chromatic approach to the G on beat 3 of m. 89 by way of the A
and A! on beat 2 could be construed as a brief suggestion of 6/9 common language in the
key of C major, or as a bebop scale passing tone fragment.
Example 5.10: Gene Ammons, “Juggernaut,” mm. 86-90
42
Example 5.11 below is an excerpt from Gene Ammons’ later 1961 recording of
“Blues Up and Down” with Sonny Stitt. In m. 214, Ammons again utilizes the
dominant7(!5) chord before resolving to the tonic chord in m. 215; however, his strategy
here is more complex than his use of these chords on earlier recordings. The first half of
m. 214 appears to be an extension of the previous Dmin7 chord, especially when
considering the eighth notes on beat 4 of the previous measure. In m. 214, Ammons
clearly spells out the G augmented triad inherent in G7(!5) before the resolution to the I
chord in m. 215; however, the !5 (D!) appears on the weak part of beat 3 and is
approached on the down beat chromatically from the E, a half step above. While the use
of the dominant7(!5) chord pays homage to Lester Young, the E on beat 3 acts as an
appoggiatura tone, modernizing Ammons’ approach to the dominant7(!5) chord.
Example 5.11: Gene Ammons, “Blues Up and Down” (1961), mm. 213-215
Gene Ammons drew from several sources of inspiration, but Lester Young was
undoubtedly one of his biggest influences. Because Young was so adept at playing the
blues and vocalizing on his saxophone in a blues style, he resonated with the next
generation of saxophonists steeped in the Neo-African vocal tradition of field hollers,
ring shouts and gospel preaching. Many of these saxophonists were combining Young’s
sense of lyricism with Coleman Hawkins’ hot sound, and this formula appealed to
43
Ammons as well. His style was also imbued with the qualities of Young and Hawkins;
furthermore, he was intrigued by the developing style of some of his contemporaries, a
style that would come to be known in the late 1940s as ‘rhythm and blues.’
Elements of Rhythm and Blues: The Milieu of Illinois Jacquet and Red Prysock
Doug Miller describes rhythm and blues as the fusion of urban blues with the
driving rhythms of jazz and the vocalizations of gospel music. The blues originally
emerged as a musical depiction of the hardships of African-American life; conversely,
rhythm and blues was dance music that articulated the joy in life.67 This new genre of
black dance music, previously labeled ‘race recordings,’ was eventually dubbed ‘rhythm
and blues’ by Billboard magazine in 1949.68 Most other styles of music at that time
possessed a rhythmic pulse in which the first and third beat of each four-beat measure
was accented, but the rhythm and blues style was defined by its unrelenting accentuation
of beats 2 and 4, otherwise known as a ‘backbeat.’
It is possible to trace the evolution of the backbeat through the blues and jazz
genres of the early Twentieth Century in an effort to gain perspective on its role in the
fully-developed rhythm and blues style emerging in 1949. A subtler use of this rhythmic
device was found in the blues, but it became more overt and significant in rhythm and
blues music.69 Likewise, the accentuation of the weak beats occurred in early jazz,
67 Katherine Charlton, Rock Music Styles: A History (New York, NY: McGraw-Hill, 2008), 20.
68 Miller, “Moan Within the Tone,” 155.
69 Charlton, Rock Music Styles, 20.
44
manifesting itself in banjo and piano accompaniment patterns.70 As early as the big band
Swing Era, the emphasis of beats 2 and 4 migrated to the drummer’s high-hat cymbals.71
The rhythm and blues school went a step further – its unyielding backbeat was played on
the snare, which was often accompanied by regular and repeated cymbal crashes. This
was exemplified in Red Prysock’s tunes such as “Hand Clappin’” from 1955 or “Zip”
from 1956. The establishment of the rhythm and blues backbeat seemed to contradict the
rhythmic evolution of jazz in the 1940s, however, as bebop drummers became
increasingly inclined to obscure the regular pulse.72
During the 1920s, Louis Armstrong, Sidney Bechet and other jazz
instrumentalists were backing blues singers like Bessie Smith on race records. Into the
1930s, numerous attempts were made to bring jazz together with blues singers, and the
locations of these events became the prominent centers for the emergence of the rhythm
and blues style.73 The intersection of jazz, blues and gospel afforded the saxophone the
opportunity to become an integral voice in the newly evolving, Afro-American music.
Christopher Costigan was a graduate student at the University of Georgia who wrote his
dissertation on the development of the rhythm and blues saxophone style. He claims that
an this established genre emerged as a result of localized technical and stylistic
innovations in Chicago, New Orleans, Memphis, New York, Cincinnati and the West
70 Ethan Hein, “The Backbeat: A Literature Review,” March 29, 2013, accessed April 3, 2015,
http://www.ethanhein.com/wp/2013/the-backbeat-a-literature-review/.
71 Lawn and Hellmer, Jazz Theory and Practice, 154.
72 Ibid., 161.
73 Miller, “Moan Within the Tone,” 158.
45
Coast area.74 Some of the characteristics of the established rhythm and blues saxophone
vernacular included extensive use of the blues scale; repetition or prolongation of one
note, and the prevalent use of motivic repetition. Repetitive riffs were often played in the
high and low registers of the saxophone. This rhythm and blues saxophone style alluded
to the Afro-American vocal tradition and was commonly referred to as ‘honking’ or
‘screaming.’75
While illustrating these qualities in the music of Gene Ammons, this paper will
draw comparisons to two established rhythm and blues benchmark saxophonists, Jean
Baptiste Illinois Jacquet and Wilburt “Red” Prysock. Raised in Houston, Texas, Jacquet
epitomized the ‘Texas tenor’ sound and is commonly credited as the first saxophonist to
play in the honking and screaming style.76 Arnold Shaw remarked that Jacquet’s “‘Flying
Home’ solo served to launch a school of booming, demonstrative, and erotic tenor sax
stylists.”77 Red Prysock’s recordings between 1954 and 1957 represent the apex of the
rhythm and blues movement. Record producer and engineer Bob Fisher describes
Prysock during this period as being “the template perhaps for every for every blasting sax
solo on any R&B or rock and roll record you ever heard.”78
Though Young’s light tone contradicts the hot sound of the honkers and
screamers, a strong argument could be made that some of the rhythm and blues elements
74 Christopher James Costigan, The Development of the Rhythm and Blues Saxophone Style: An Analytical
and Performance Based Study (DMA diss., University of Georgia, 2007), 2, accessed March 4, 2015,
https://getd.libs.uga.edu/pdfs/costigan_christopher_j_200712_dma.pdf.
75 Miller, “Moan Within the Tone,” 155.
76 Ibid.
77 Arnold Shaw, Honkers and Shouters (New York, NY: Collier Books, 1978), 173.
78 Bob Fischer, Liner notes from Red Prysock: Hand Clappin’ Foot Stompin’ Rock ‘N’ Roll, Jasmine
Records, JASCD 274, CD, 2013.
46
listed above can be traced back to Lester Young. His linear melodic approach, as well as
the sporadic de-emphasis of chords resulting from his blanketed pentatonic melodies, is
consistent with the blues vocal tradition. Moreover, he was using false or alternate
fingerings before the inception of rhythm and blues, as evidenced in his 1939 recording
of “Lester Leaps In.” The bebop genre had matured roughly four years before the 1949
christening of the term ‘rhythm and blues,’ and many bebop saxophonists like Sonny Stitt
and Dexter Gordon were also synthesizing swing along with rhythm and blues elements
into their own playing. Gene Ammons, however, was a Lester Young disciple who had
been raised on the boogie-woogie piano stylings of his father. The influence of the great
Albert Ammons positioned the younger Ammons to be the champion of this cross-
pollination of saxophone styles, alongside rhythm and blues icons Illinois Jacquet and
Red Prysock.
Use of the Blues Scale
Rhythm and blues musicians commonly incorporated use of the blues scale into
their vocabulary. Just as Lester Young’s 6/9 common language was an expansion of the
major pentatonic scale, the blues scale could be seen as an adaptation of the minor
pentatonic scale whose construction normally includes scale degrees 1, !3, 4, 5 and !7.
The addition of a ‘blue note,’ the chromatic tone between scale degrees 4 and 5,
transforms the pure minor pentatonic scale into the blues scale.
Example 5.12 is an excerpt from Illinois Jacquet’s famous solo on “Flying
Home,” recorded in 1942 with Lionel Hampton. Here, Jacquet is using the blues scale to
47
blanket the chord changes in mm. 26-28. He begins his idea on B! and moves to D!, the
next note in the B! blues scale. Jacquet continues to ascend up the B! blues scale to the
next adjacent scale degree in a succession of syncopated upbeats; however, he returns to
the B! anchor note between each of the rising scale tones. This oblique motion creates a
widening interval between the upper ascending blues scale pitches and the static B! tonic
anchor until the arrival of the F on the upbeat of beat 4 in m. 27. Illinois Jacquet’s use of
the blues scale in Example 5.12 almost resembles something that Lester Young would
have played, but the deliberate substitution of D! (!3) for D (3) in mm. 26 and 28 is a
departure from Young’s 6/9 vernacular into the realm of the blues scale. Indeed, Illinois
Jacquet with Lionel Hampton in the early 1940s still sounds heavily swing-influenced,
even as the rhythm and blues elements in their music are beginning to emerge. Jacquet’s
solo on Hampton’s recording of “Flying Home” marked the inception of a transition from
swing to the rhythm and blues vernacular.
Example 5.12: Illinois Jacquet, “Flying Home,” mm. 26-29
Gene Ammons’ solo on his 1961 recording of “Please Send Me Someone to
Love” is highly representative of his blues scale vocabulary. The D7, F7 and D7/F!
chords in mm. 34-35 of Example 5.13 all have dominant function in the key of G major.
Ammons momentarily transcends the strict rhythm of this medium-slow shuffle,
48
blanketing these chords with a flurry of notes from the G blues scale. The D! as well as
the two F"’s played over the D7 chord in m. 34 allay any suspicion that Ammons might
be referencing the chord changes. Instead, he is punctuating the end of this 32-bar form
with an emotional blues statement. Just before the resolution to the tonic G chord in m.
36, however, Ammons plays a B", momentarily alluding once again to the 6/9 common
language. Through this entire example, Ammons’ use of a blanket scale that bypasses the
specifics of passing chords is reminiscent of Lester Young.
Example 5.13: Gene Ammons, “Please Send Me Someone to Love,” mm. 33-35
In Example 5.14, Ammons ends his solo on “Please Send Me Someone to Love”
with another hot-blooded blues statement in the same part of the form as the previous
example. This time, however, his blues scale vocabulary starts one measure later in the
form over the F7 chord and he maintains his blues language through the resolution at the
double bar in m. 69. Again, Ammons seems more concerned with the conveyance of
emotion than with acknowledgment of the chord changes. Using a mixture of fragmented
compound and simple (duple) rhythms, he creates heightened tension by floating
independently over the time up to the resolution at the double bar in m. 69.
49
Example 5.14: Gene Ammons, “Please Send Me Someone to Love,” mm. 67-69
Example 5.15 looks like a combination of the previous two examples. Ammons
makes use of blues scale vocabulary in mm. 45-49 as he blankets I, I7, IV, !IVo
7, and
back again to I with a G Blues Scale. As in Example 5.14, he makes extensive use of
sixteenth-note sextuplet figures while accenting the first, third and fifth note of each
sextuplet in mm. 47-48. He wraps up this blues scale statement with a deluge of rapidly
descending notes, similar to Example 5.13, finally resolving to a B" on beat 2 of m. 49.
Example 5.15: Gene Ammons, “Please Send Me Someone to Love,” mm. 45-49
Prolongation of One Repeated Note
In addition to the prevalent use of the blues scale, rhythm and blues saxophonists
often engaged in the act of prolonging one note, which could occur for extended
durations of time. In fact, it was not uncommon for one note to be played for an entire
50
chorus of the blues, or even longer. These gospel-influenced vocalizations were executed
with regularity in the extreme high or low registers of the horn. Saxophonists frequently
performed in this way while manipulating false fingerings or using alternative
articulation techniques in an effort to achieve subtle pitch or sound variances. The Afro-
American musicians were playing in the African vocal style, unconcerned about playing
their European instruments in their originally intended manner.79
Example 5.16 demonstrates Illinois Jacquet’s ability to create a great deal of
excitement by playing a high B! for almost two entire eight-measure A sections on his
seminal recording of “Flying Home” with Lionel Hampton. He stands relentlessly on the
tonic B!, consistently re-attacking on the upbeat of 4 and the upbeat of 2. Much in the
black preaching style, the delayed gratification inherent in the repeated B! builds
excitement and anticipation for the listener. If the F7 chords in Example 5.16 are
interpreted as F7sus chords, the repeated B! would be common to all of the chords in this
example. However, Jacquet was most likely just emoting from the gut, unconcerned with
the chord changes. He is ‘screaming’ on the tonic note (B!), and in doing so, he is
preaching to his audience.
79 Miller, Moan Within the Tone, 157.
51
Example 5.16: Illinois Jacquet, “Flying Home,” mm. 33-49
Red Prysock recorded “Blow Your Horn” in 1954, twelve years after Jacquet’s
groundbreaking recording of “Flying Home.” Shown in Example 5.17, Prysock reiterates
the tonic note for an entire chorus of the blues, breaking rank only once in m. 172 when
he plays the A on beat 4. Because the tonic note of C is so easy to manipulate with
alternate fingerings on the saxophone, many of these rhythm and blues songs were
written in the tenor saxophone key of C (concert B!). Here, Prysock is taking advantage
of the opportunity to use alternate fingerings on the repetitive high C. He achieves
changes in pitch and tone color by closing all of the right hand keys in the lower stack
including the low C key. The points at which Prysock executes this alternate fingering are
marked in Example 5.17 with the symbol “0.” Additionally, Prysock growls through his
saxophone for this entire passage as well as for the majority of what comes before and
after this example. This idea of doing so much with so little can be traced back to Sidney
Bechet, who was known for his simple solos containing the effective placement of a few
52
carefully chosen notes, many of which contained sultry bends or other blues inflections.80
By standing on the tonic note for fourteen and a half measures, Red Prysock eliminated
any sense of melodic contour in Example 5.17. An argument could be made that, in doing
so, he essentially converted the saxophone to a percussion instrument for the duration of
this blues chorus.
Example 5.17: Red Prysock, “Blow Your Horn,” mm. 168-183
Gene Ammons made extensive use of the one-note prolongation technique, and
proof of this manifested itself in his playing throughout his entire career. This is
demonstrated below in Example 5.18, an excerpt from Ammons’ 1961 version of “Blues
Up and Down” with Sonny Stitt. Ammons plays three phrases over this twelve-bar blues
progression, each of which begins with a repeated C. He chooses an alternate fingering
80 Mark C. Gridley, Jazz Styles: History and Analysis, 10th
ed., (Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson
Education: 2009), 87.
53
for some of these notes, using the low C fingering with the octave key. This is notated in
Example 5.18 using he symbol “+.” The use of these alternate fingerings in mm. 96-97
produces a ‘do-wop’ effect commonly heard in the rhythm and blues style.81 This
vocalization device is utilized again to begin the next two phrases in mm. 100-101 and
mm. 104-105. Ammons concludes each of the three phrases with an upward leap.
Example 5.18: Gene Ammons, “Blues Up and Down” (1961), mm. 96-108
Also from Ammons’ 1961 version of “Blues Up and Down,” Example 5.19
incorporates two sets of alternate fingerings for C. The first, notated as “0,” uses the
regular C fingering while adding the three right hand lower stack keys and the low C key.
The second alternate fingering, labeled “+,” is the complete low C fingering with the
added octave key. Ammons uses the normal fingering for C when playing the accented
C’s. He alternates these three fingerings in a sequence: the accented normal fingering, the
“0” fingering, and the “+” fingering respectively. This alternation happens over a steady
stream of eighth notes in common time, but the notes sound like they are organized in
81 Miller, “Moan Within the Tone,” 161-162.
54
groups of three due to the strategic placement of the accents. The resulting effect is the
‘three against four’ hemiola discussed in Chapter 4.
Example 5.19: Gene Ammons, “Blues Up and Down” (1961), mm. 109-120
In mm. 205-208 of the same solo, shown in Example 5.20, Ammons repeats a
stream of high C eighth notes using an articulation that involves leaving a portion of the
tongue (usually one side of the tongue) on the reed while playing, effectively muting the
reed. The reed remains partially muted, while new notes are being articulated. This
articulation is often called ‘doodle’ tonguing. Other commonly used names for this
technique include half tonguing, sub tonguing, or ‘dooden’ tonguing. The onomatopoeia
inherent in the term ‘doodle’ tonguing is the best explanation of this technique, used by
saxophonists to achieve subtle variations on one note. The ‘doo-dle’ syllables are notated
in Example 5.20 with the letters “D” and “L” respectively.
55
Example 5.20: Gene Ammons, “Blues Up and Down” (1961), mm. 205-209
Example 5.21 shows Gene Ammons and Sonny Stitt trading on a high C for one
chorus. This happens after they have both soloed extensively and traded fours. The
battling saxophonists are trading high C’s in a ‘call and response’ manner reminiscent of
the responsorial interactions between a black gospel preacher and his congregation.
Additionally, the falls off each note are executed by dropping the jaw as the note
progresses. These falls give their constituent notes a vocal wailing quality, helping to
building excitement at the end of their already sensational solos.
Example 5.21: Gene Ammons, “Blues Up and Down” (1961), mm. 456-468
In Example 5.22, Ammons and Stitt bring this blowing session to a climax
together in the very last chorus. They ratchet up the excitement from the previous chorus
(Example 5.21) by speeding up the melodic rhythm of the exchanges, now trading high
56
C’s once per measure with Ammons on beat 1 and Stitt on the upbeat of beat 2. The C’s
played by each saxophonist are tinged with a shimmer of brief vibrato in substitution of
the falls from the previous chorus, noted above in Example 5.21. Ultimately the dialogue
ends, culminating with a melodic dismount played together in unison beginning on the
upbeat of beat 4 in m. 478.
Example 5.22: Gene Ammons, “Blues Up and Down” (1961), mm. 469-480
Motivic Repetition/Development
Along with the use of the blues scale and the prolongation of one note over
extended passages of music, saxophonists in the rhythm and blues style also frequently
referenced the earlier vocal blues style by reiterating motives or phrases, often
developing or adjusting them to fit the harmonic progression. Red Prysock demonstrates
this in his 1954 recording of “Blow Your Horn.” In Example 5.23 Prysock repeats the
four-note motive that begins in m. 60 and ends on the downbeat of m. 61. With each
repetition, the last two notes are adjusted to accommodate the chord changes. The circled
target notes are then approached from a half step below.
57
Example 5.23: Red Prysock, “Blow Your Horn,” mm. 60-63
Gene Ammons follows Prysock’s lead and is using the same vocabulary seven
years later on “Blues Up and Down,” as shown below in Example 5.24. Again, the
ascending target notes are all approached from a half step below. These target notes serve
as guide tones that ascend chromatically to the G on the downbeat of m. 124. Ammons
includes one extra iteration of the motive, inserted on the upbeat of beat 3 in m. 122 and
resolving to the F! on the downbeat of m. 123. In doing so, he extends Prysock’s motivic
idea, shown above Example 5.23, by one measure.
Example 5.24: Gene Ammons, “Blues Up and Down” (1961), mm. 120-125
Ammons continues improvising in the three-phrase, vocal blues tradition of
statement, repeated statement and response in Example 5.25. Phrase A begins on beat 2
of m. 168 and ends on beat four of m. 171. The next four measures are a direct repeat of
phrase A. The last four measures of this blues chorus, labeled below as phrase A’, serve
as a response to the first two phrases. Inside phrase A’, repetition exists on a micro level
58
with the recurring motive labeled motive X. The three-beat motive, motive X, has an
accented beginning and is repeated three times after its initial occurrence. The placement
of the accents, combined with the repetition of the three-beat motive, establishes a ‘three
against four’ hemiola. This gives phrase A’ a ‘consequent’ feel while concurrently setting
up expectations for another chorus of soloing.
Example 5.25: Gene Ammons, “Blues Up and Down” (1961), mm. 168-180
Gene Ammons employs the three-phrase, blues vocal structure again in “Blues Up
and Down” just one chorus later in Example 5.26. The last note of Example 5.26, held for
three measures, is consistent with the style of the ‘honkers’ and ‘screamers.’ That, along
with the three-phrase vocal structure, make this example a template for improvisation in
the rhythm and blues style.
59
Example 5.26: Gene Ammons, “Blues Up and Down” (1961), mm. 192-204
Elements of Bebop: The Influence of Charlie Parker and Sonny Stitt
Elements of swing combined with the rhythm and blues vernacular are pervasive
in Gene Ammons’ style. The final ingredient in his vocabulary is his penchant for the
bebop (or ‘bop’) language. Historian and author Scott Yanow asserts:
Gene Ammons was part of several different musical idioms. His huge sound was
a throwback to the Swing Era and his ability to soulfully state ideas (sometimes
with just a few notes) fit perfectly in R&B settings, where he was probably the
most influential. And yet Ammons could also play bebop with the best of them,
holding his own against his pal Sonny Stitt and anyone else in saxophone
battles.82
Assuredly, the bebop elements innate in Gene Ammons’ vocabulary can be
compared to the language of Charlie Parker or Sonny Stitt, two of the most formidable
bebop saxophone players of all time. Charlie Parker, along with trumpeter John Birks
82 Scott Yanow, Bebop (San Francisco, CA: Miller Freeman Books, 2000), 101.
60
“Dizzy” Gillespie, is considered to be a founder of the bebop genre.83 Sonny Stitt was a
virtuoso bebop alto saxophonist who collaborated extensively with Gene Ammons over
the years. Sometime between 1949 and 1950 Stitt picked up the baritone and tenor
saxophones as well, possibly in an effort to step out of the shadow of Charlie Parker.84
Both Parker and Stitt had a tremendous impact on Ammons, the former for pioneering the
bebop language and the latter for using it so effectively in close proximity to Ammons.
Surround Tones
‘Surround tones’ are also referred to as a ‘neighbor group’ or ‘changing tones.’
These notes can be described as a chord tone’s upper and lower neighbors, the
combination of which frame the chord tone. Surround tones may be diatonic or chromatic
and are very commonly used in bebop language.85 Example 5.27, excerpted from Jamey
Aebersold and Ken Slone’s transcription taken from the Charlie Parker Omnibook86,
illustrates two ways in which Parker used surround tones. In m. 41 of this excerpt from
Parker’s 1945 recording of “Thriving From a Riff,” the surround tones first appear as
individual neighbor tones (first upper, then lower), interspersed between repetitions of the
target chord tone, G. On beat 3 of m. 41, however, the two surround tones appear
together as a singular modifier for the G that appears on beat 4. The C!’s and the E in m.
42 act as surround tones for their resolution, the D in m. 43. This illustration of a diatonic
83 Lawn, Experiencing Jazz, 199.
84 Owens, Bebop, 47.
85 Lawn and Hellmer, Jazz Theory and Practice, 77.
86 Aebersold and Slone, Charlie Parker Omnibook, 61.
61
upper neighbor and a chromatic lower neighbor in m. 42 is one of the most common
combinations of surround tones in the bebop language.
Example 5.27: Charlie Parker, “Thriving From a Riff,” mm. 41-43
Evidence can be found of Gene Ammons’ use of surround tones in his earliest
recordings. Example 5.28, from Billy Eckstine’s 1944 recording of “Blowing the Blues
Away,” documents Ammons surrounding the E’s in m. 47 with D! and F. The third of the
chord is surrounded by a half step on both sides. This is another example of a surround-
tone figure that includes a diatonic upper neighbor and chromatic lower neighbor.
Example 5.28: Gene Ammons, “Blowing the Blues Away,” mm. 46-48
Here in Example 5.29 from “Juggernaut,” recorded in 1950, Ammons takes a
chromatic approach to surrounding the root of G7. Neither the A! nor the F! that occur
on beat 2 in m. 73 are diatonic to the Dmin7 chord. Nor are they diatonic to the
proceeding G7. They can be interpreted as a chromatic, surround-tone anticipation of the
target chord tone, G, one beat later.
62
Example 5.29: Gene Ammons, “Juggernaut,” mm. 72-73
In some respects, surround tones can be seen as an avoidance of chord tones,
delaying a melodic resolution. At other times, surround tones can be used as melodic
fodder to extend a phrase over a chord with slower harmonic rhythm. In any case,
surround tones are prevalent in Ammons’ bebop vocabulary.
Scalar Versus Arpeggiated Diminished Chords
The diminished scale, also known as the octatonic scale, comprises a symmetrical
series of alternating whole steps and half steps. Because of the nature of the scale’s
construction with respect to its half-step and whole-step relationships, it offers a wide
array of sequential patterns.87 Moreover, this scale can be effectively utilized over
diminished and dominant chords alike. Improvisers predating the modern jazz era tended
to negotiate diminished chords in an arpeggiated manner; however, use of the diminished
scale became popular among bebop musicians in the 1950s.88 Example 5.30 is borrowed
from Charles McNeal’s transcription of Sonny Stitt from the earlier, 1950 version of
“Blues Up and Down,” released on Gene Ammons’ All Star Sessions.89 Here, Sonny Stitt
87 Lawn and Hellmer, Jazz Theory and Practice, 37.
88 Owens, Bebop, 82.
89 Charles McNeal, “Blues Up and Down: Sonny Stitt’s Solo from Gene Ammons’ CD ‘All Star Session
with Sonny Stitt’,” Saxopedia, accessed March 8, 2015, http://www.charlesmcneal.com/uploads/-
BluesUpAndDown_stitt_.pdf.
63
employs the diminished scale in mm. 16-19 using both adjacent scale tone motion (the
interval of a minor second, major second or diminished third) as well as non-adjacent
motion (leaps that are a minor third or larger). He effectively blankets all of the chords
C7, F7, F!o
7 and C with half-whole version of a C diminished scale, that is to say, the
version that starts with the interval of a half step occurring above the root of the scale
(spelled C, C!, E!, E, F!, G, A, B!, C).
Example 5.30: Sonny Stitt, “Blues Up and Down” (1950), mm. 16-19
Interestingly, Stitt often used the whole-half version of the diminished scale (the other
version, with the interval of a whole step occurring above the root of the scale) on tonic
as a blanket over the A sections of rhythm changes. Evidence of his whole-half step
diminished scale use can be heard on Dizzy Gillespie’s 1957 recording of “Eternal
Triangle” which also featured Sonny Stitt and Sonny Rollins.
In m. 57 of “Please Send Me Someone to Love,” found below in Example 5.31,
Ammons uses diminished scale vocabulary much in the same manner as Stitt’s
application in the previous example. The key is G major, and Ammons uses adjacent
scalar motion beginning on the second sixteenth note of beat 3 with the F!. Ammons is
acknowledging the C!o
7 chord occurring on beats 3 and 4 of m. 57 precisely with the C!
whole-half diminished scale. Once Ammons reaches the B! on beat 4, however, he
64
outlines a C!o
7 chord. He overshoots the E (the third of C!o
7) by a whole step, arriving at
F! on the upbeat of beat 4. Now the line changes direction resolving downward to the E,
which then acts as a passing tone to the arrival of D on the G major chord occurring on
the downbeat of m. 58.
Example 5.31: Gene Ammons, “Please Send Me Someone to Love,” mm. 57-58
In the same spot of the form one chorus later on “Please Send Me Someone to
Love,” Ammons uses the diminished scale again. This time he initiates a sequence
starting on beat 3 of m. 89, shown in Example 5.32. From the starting note, this sequence
descends by a half step then changes direction, ascending first by a half step to the point
of origin and then twice by a whole step to the next scale tone. The saxophonist begins by
clearly referencing the C!o
7 as in the previous example; however, he then carries this
pattern over into the tonic major chord, becoming the whole-half diminished pattern so
often used by Stitt on tunes like his 1957 recording of “Eternal Triangle.”
Example 5.32: Gene Ammons, “Please Send Me Someone to Love,” mm. 89-90
65
Double-Time Passages
The use of double time was introduced in Chapter 4 as a rhythmic device;
however, the melodic construction of double-time passages also merits consideration.
With the transition to modern jazz, musicians were required to possess a level of
virtuosity on their instruments that went above and beyond the technical demands
associated with Swing Era.90 The use of double-time passages is a signature characteristic
of bebop, as exemplified in the solos of Charlie Parker.91 Example 5.33, adapted from the
Charlie Parker Omnibook, shows a typical double-time passage played by Parker on his
1956 recording of “Blues for Alice.”92 Close inspection of the double-time section in m.
22 reveals that Parker is subjecting some of the aforementioned surround-tone techniques
to rhythmic diminution. For example, the D, B and C natural found in beat two of m. 22
are a three-note neighbor group (surround tones) for the C!. The sixteenth notes on beat
one of m. 23 all surround the F! on beat two; likewise, the B! and the G on the upbeat of
beat two surround the A on beat 3.
Example 5.33: Charlie Parker, “Blues for Alice,” mm. 20-23
90 Paul Tanner, David McGill and Maurice Gerow, Jazz, 10th
ed. (New York, NY: McGraw-Hill, 2005),
177-178.
91 Ibid., 188.
92 Aebersold and Slone, Charlie Parker Omnibook, 18.
66
In the style of Parker, Gene Ammons also profits from the infusion of double-time
passages into his own vocabulary. Example 5.34 illustrates Ammons’ use of double-time
techniques over mm. 40-42 in “Juggernaut.” Beat 3 in m. 40 can be interpreted as a four-
note neighbor group surrounding the C! on beat 4. Beat 4 is then arpeggiated up to the !9
(also characteristic of bop language). Though the B and two D’s that occur inside beat 4
in m. 41 are diatonic to the G7 chord, they instead serve to surround the target note C,
anticipating the CMaj7 chord occurring on beat 1 of m. 42. Chromatic passing tones are
found intermingling around and between the surround tone episodes.
Example 5.34: Gene Ammons, “Juggernaut,” mm. 39-42
Example 5.35 below is an extension of Example 5.32 above. Here, a mixture of
surround tones (bracketed and labeled “ST”) and diminished scalar vocabulary
contributes to construct an extended passage of double-time and over-the-time figures at
the end of Ammons’ solo on “Please Send Me Someone to Love.” The circled notes
represent the melodic points of arrival that are set up by the surround tones.
67
Example 5.35: Gene Ammons, “Please Send Me Someone to Love,” mm. 89-93
Harmonic Devices: Passing Chords
Along with the shift from swing to bebop came a harmonic revolution. Players
gravitated toward negotiating chord extensions and chord substitutions in the Modern
Jazz Era.93 Charlie Parker pushed the harmonic boundaries of the new genre, producing a
fresh and innovative template for the preexisting twelve-bar blues form. His new
archetype of bebop chord substitutions over what was formerly a very simple chord
progression came to be known as ‘Bird Blues,’ and can be seen below in Table 5.1.94 The
most familiar Parker composition that uses these chord changes, “Blues for Alice,” is a
quintessential example of bebop chord substitutions.
93 Tanner, McGill and Gerow, Jazz, 177-178
94 Lawn and Hellmer, Jazz Theory and Practice, 175.
68
Table 5.1: Chord Changes for ‘Bird Blues’
Fmaj7
m. 1
Emin7 A7(!9)
m. 2
Dmin7 G7(!9)
m. 3
Cmin7 F7
m. 4
B!maj7
m. 5
B!min7 E!7
m. 6
Amin7 D7
m. 7
A!min7 D!7
m. 8
Gmin7
m. 9
C7(!9)
m. 10
Fmaj7 D7
m. 11
Gmin7 C7
m. 12
Diminished Passing Chords
Parker’s harmonic sophistication left a lasting impact on Gene Ammons, who
incorporated passing chords frequently in his own playing. One harmonic substitution
that Ammons used with a degree of frequency was the diminished passing chord. This
chord tends to surface routinely in his solos on beats 3 and 4 in the second measure of a
twelve-bar blues. In Example 5.36 in the key of C major, Ammons begins his solo using
this passing chord straight away in m. 2. On the first two beats of m. 2, he outlines a
Dmin chord, giving the listener the impression that he is disregarding the quick IV chord
and substituting a ii-V in its place. Instead of going to the V chord on beat 3, however, he
shifts up chromatically from D to D!, outlining a D!o
triad (!iio
). The whole-half version
of the D! diminished scale used over the D!o
triad in m. 2 is D!, F, F!, G!/A!, A, B, C
and D. The scale tone A! on the upbeat of beat 4 in m. 2 facilitates a smooth transition
from the A occurring on the downbeat of beat 4 of the same measure to the G, the fifth of
C7, on beat 1 of m. 3.
69
Example 5.36: Gene Ammons, “Blues Up and Down” (1961), mm. 1-5
Example 5.37 of Sonny Stitt soloing on “Blues Up and Down” eleven years
earlier is almost identical to Ammons’ version of the diminished passing chord in
Example 5.36.95 The implied Dmin chord is set up identically in m. 38 (the second
measure of the twelve-bar blues form); however, here Stitt leaps up a fourth on beat 4,
overshooting the A by a whole step as he ascends up the D!o
arpeggio. In doing so, he
reaffirms that diminished chord tones can be approached from a whole step above as well
as a half step below the target chord tone.
Example 5.37: Sonny Stitt, “Blues Up and Down” (1950), mm. 37-41
Minor Passing Chords: iii7-!iii7 and the Use of Sequences
One of the harmonic complexities of Parker’s ‘Bird Blues’ (occurring in mm. 7-8
of the form) that manifests itself in Ammons solos is the iii7-!iii7 substitution for I7 or
VI7. This can be prominently heard on the 1961 Ammons/Stitt recording of “Autumn
Leaves.” Sometimes, when the harmonic rhythm is subjected to diminution, the iii7-!iii7
95 McNeal, “Blues Up Sonny Stitt”.
70
substitution can happen in one measure with two beats to each chord. This would happen
in m. 8 of a twelve-bar blues form, leading into the ii7 normally occurring in bar nine;
however, these passing chords can be an effective approach to any predominant ii7 chord.
Charlie Parker uses this harmonic substitution in his 1946 recording of “Moose the
Mooche.” This is illustrated in Example 5.38, excerpted from the Charlie Parker
Omnibook.96 During the third measure of the last A section of this AABA form in G
major, Parker employs a sequenced descent from the seventh to the fifth of each chord to
serve as the connecting tissue that bridges the distance between m. 57 and m. 59. The
seventh of Bmin and B!min can be traced chromatically as guide tones, arriving on the
seventh of the Amin chord on beat 1 of m. 59.
Example 5.38: Charlie Parker, “Moose the Mooche,” mm. 57-61
Gene Ammons’ use of this harmonic device surfaces early in his career on “St.
Louis Blues” and “Red Top,” both from 1947. Because the progression of iii7-!iii7-ii7-
V7 in mm. 8-10 of a blues chorus begins with three descending chords of the same
quality (parallel minor chords), these three measures offer excellent opportunities for the
improviser to apply melodic sequencing. Ammons uses these passing chords frequently
as a substitution for VI7 in the ninth measure of a twelve-bar blues; moreover, he
96 Aebersold and Slone, Charlie Parker Omnibook, 5.
71
habitually sequences melodic material when negotiating these passing chords. An early
and clear example of this can be seen in m. 38 of his solo on “Red Top,” displayed below
in Example 5.39. The tune is in G major and the Bmin-B!min (iii7-!iii7) in m. 38 is the
eighth measure of this twelve-bar blues. On beat 1 of m. 38, Ammons plays what is
essentially a metered glissando from the seventh of the chord, A, on the downbeat to the
chord’s fifth, F!, on the upbeat of 1. The iii7-!iii7 in m. 38 is harmonically similar to
Parker’s approach in the previous example; however, the harmonic rhythm is augmented
in mm. 39-40 of Example 5.39. The D and the A on beat 2 of m. 38 complete the motive,
which is then sequenced down a half step on beats 3 and 4 of the same measure to
express the B!min7.
Example 5.39: Gene Ammons, “Red Top,” mm. 37-40
Below in Example 5.40, Ammons arpeggiates the iii7 chord from the root, up to
the seventh, and back down to the fifth of the chord in m. 187. This is the seventh
measure of a blues in C major. As in the previous example, he sequences this arpeggiated
chord down a half step. Here, however, Ammons anticipates the Emin7 chord in m. 187
and starts the E!min7 arpeggio two beats early in m. 188, increasing the melodic velocity
of the phrase. Simultaneously, there is a sense of rhythmic augmentation/slower
72
harmonic rhythm, as the iii7 chord and the !iii7 chord are each allotted one full measure
instead of two beats.
Example 5.40: Gene Ammons, “Blues Up and Down” (1961), mm. 187-191
Example 5.42 is taken from Ammons’ 1962 recording of a bossa, entitled “Anna”
in G major, and illustrates the saxophonist’s use of passing chords outside of a blues
context. The sequences in the previous two examples were ‘real’ sequences, maintaining
the intervallic integrity of the original motives being sequenced and containing the
requisite chromaticism necessary to accommodate the non-diatonic harmonies. The
sequence in m. 53 of Example 5.42, however is one in which both minor passing chords
(iii7 and !iii7) comprise a ‘modified’ sequence of the previous measure. The alteration of
the sequence on beat 4 in m. 54 to reflect B! min7, the !iii7 tonality, causes this to
become a modified sequence.97
Example 5.41: Gene Ammons, “Anna,” mm. 53-55
97 Kostka, Payne and Almén, Tonal Harmony: With an Introduction to Twentieth-Century Music, 7th
ed.
(New York, NY: McGraw-Hill, 2013), 96-97.
73
The examples shown above in this chapter are representative of saxophone
vocabulary in swing, rhythm and blues, and bebop styles. At times, some of the
distinctions between these three schools of playing were blurred. Saxophonists that
belonged squarely to one genre were still capable of borrowing from the others. That
being said, all of the above-mentioned saxophonists that have been compared to Ammons
can be easily labeled or compartmentalized based on, among other things, frequently
surfacing aspects of their vocabulary. Gene Ammons, however, was so adept at fusing
swing, rhythm and blues, and bebop that he is difficult to categorize stylistically. He was
a musical polyglot who refused to be pigeonholed or confined to a limited vocabulary,
and his ability to synthesize these styles made him accessible to a wider demographic.
74
CHAPTER 6
Conclusion
Gene Ammons’ sound and style had a tremendous impact on his colleagues,
audiences and future generations of jazz saxophone players. When asked to give advice
to younger musicians, Ammons told a reporter, “I would tell them to get a sound. Practice
their sound. That’s the most important thing.”98 At a young age, Chicago tenor
saxophonist Harold Ousley attempted to imitate the Ammons sound. He obtained a Conn
tenor saxophone and a Brilhart Tonalin mouthpiece, knowing that this was the gear that
Ammons used.99
Renowned saxophonist Johnny Griffin, who also studied at DuSable High School
with Captain Walter Dyett, noted the moment of clarity he had in his youth upon hearing
Ammons for the first time. Griffin was still in high school when he saw Ammons play
with King Kolax. It was at that moment that Griffin knew he wanted to become a
saxophone player.100 Later in 1957, he would find himself performing alongside of both
Gene Ammons and Lester Young at the Stage Door and the Crown Propeller Lodge.101
In recent years a saxophonist named Ellery Eskelin paid homage to Ammons by
recording an entire album of Ammons’ tunes. Entitled The Sun Died, Eskelin’s recording
made the New York Times’ 1996 list of top ten recordings.102 His avant-garde approach
to the songs on this album are a melodic departure from the Ammons school; however,
Ammons’ influence can be readily identified in Eskelin’s organic and visceral sound.
Additionally, the very idea of compounding Gene Ammons’ sound with avant-garde
98 Leo T. Sullivan, “Biography,” Gene Ammons: Legendary Jazz Saxophonist, accessed March 17, 2015,
http://www.geneammons.net/biography/.
99 Berliner, Thinking in Jazz, 107.
100 Travis, Autobiography of Black Jazz, 352.
101 Ibid., 360.
102 Ibid.
75
vocabulary (or the lack thereof) is fundamental to Ammons’ concept of playing across
styles.
In addition to his distinctive composite sound, Ammons had an ability to bring
aspects of different performance styles together, blurring the lines of distinction between
genres. This ultimately was his formula for success, and his fusion of jazz styles with
rhythm and blues resulted in a concept that was in line with the soul jazz movement.103
This funky jazz featured accompaniments with basic, repetitive, and sometimes Latin
rhythms combined with melodies that were blues and gospel influenced.104 Likewise, the
piano was sometimes replaced by the organ and/or the guitar in soul jazz. Jazz historian
Ted Gioia describes Ammons as “a major player, popularizing the ‘soul jazz’ idiom.”105
This claim is evidenced on Ammons’ organ combo recordings of the early 1960s, such as
Live! In Chicago and Brother Jack Meets the Boss with organist Jack McDuff. Ammons
resumed recording in the soul jazz vein after his ultimate release from Statesville
Penitentiary, beginning with The Boss is Back! in 1969 and leading all the way up to his
death with Goodbye in 1974. Players like Red Holloway, Willis “Gator Tail” Jackson,
David “Fathead” Newman, Stanley Turrentine, Hank Crawford and even Joshua Redman
all possess the soul jazz influences gifted to them by Gene Ammons.
To the jazz community, Ammons also bequeathed a legacy of dueling tenor
saxophonists operating in the ‘tenor battle’ format. Billy Eckstine’s 1944 recording of
“Blowing the Blues Away” features Gene Ammons and Dexter Gordon engaging in what
103 David H. Rosenthal, Hard Bop: Jazz and Black Music 1955-1965 (New York: Oxford University Press,
1992), 65-66.
104 Gridley, Jazz Styles, 229.
105 Ted Gioia, The History of Jazz (New York: Oxford University Press, 2011), 243.
76
is the first famous recording of a tenor battle.106 Lester Young and Herschel Evans had
previously become famous for their on-stage tenor rivalries; however, they infrequently
soloed on the same piece and, when they did, their solos were deliberately spaced far
apart.107 For example, on Count Basie’s 1938 recording of “Georgianna,” the solos
played by Herschel Evans and Lester Young are separated by one minute and twenty
seconds of vocals and ensemble playing. In contrast, Ammons and Gordon are locked in
heated musical dispute while trading choruses and four-measure sections (‘trading fours’)
on “Blowing the Blues Away.”
Following in the tradition of “Blowing the Blues Away,” Ammons continued
formalizing the tradition of the tenor battle with his quintet, co-led by Sonny Stitt.108 A
paragon example of the Ammons/Stitt tenor battles is the 1961 recording of “Blues Up
and Down” from Boss Tenors. Kenny Mathieson goes so far as to say that Boss Tenors
could be seen as a template for the twin tenor format.109 In the spirit of Ammons and
Stitt, a large number of saxophonists have paired up in an attempt to exploit the dueling
tenor format. The most notable of these paired saxophonists include Johnny Griffin and
Eddie “Lockjaw” Davis, Dexter Gordon and Wardell Gray, David “Fathead” Newman
and Stanley Turrentine, and even Michael Brecker and Bob Mintzer.
The study of Gene Ammons is an expansion of knowledge in many other broad
areas, such as the rhythmic and lyrical qualities of African music; the evolution of the
106 Morgenstern, Living with Jazz, 230.
107 Schuller, The Swing Era, 550.
108 Kernfeld, “Ammons, Gene”.
109 Mathieson, Cookin’, 225-226.
77
backbeat in blues, jazz, and rhythm and blues; and an in-depth study of Coleman
Hawkins and Lester Young. While each of the individual timbral, rhythmic, melodic and
harmonic devices discussed in this paper can be traced back to earlier sources, the sum of
these characteristics produced a sound that was unique to Gene Ammons. He carefully
molded his style so as to remain versatile in a musical climate that was evolving in
multiple directions and at an ever-increasing rate; furthermore, his multipurpose
saxophone concept manifested itself in the form of high record sales, even during his nine
years in prison. Indeed, Bob Weinstock said that Ammons was the top-selling recording
artist for Prestige Records, outselling Miles Davis by far. Weinstock attributes the
saxophonist’s success to his ability to appeal to jazz listeners and rhythm and blues fans
alike.110
Bob Weinstock’s statements underscore the fact that, at times, an element of
disconnect exists between the critics and the listeners. Even though Gene Ammons has
been largely overlooked by jazz critics and historians, his influence is an undercurrent
that has been felt far and wide by saxophonists and music appreciators of then and now.
The lessons taught by Ammons go above and beyond the notes he played. He taught us
that stylistic diversification is an excellent business model for the working saxophonist.
He taught us that the notes are only as important as their delivery. He taught us to be true
to our convictions, regardless of what the critics think.
110 Wilson, “Gene Ammons: ‘The Jug’”.
78
APPENDIX A
Complete Solo Transcriptions of Gene Ammons
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
APPENDIX B
Solo Transcriptions of
Lester Young, Illinois Jacquet and Red Prysock
Completed in a
Comparative Study of Gene Ammons
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Aebersold, Jamey, and Ken Slone. Charlie Parker Omnibook: For Eb Instruments,
Transcribed Exactly From His Recorded Solos. Lynbrook, NY: Atlantic Music
Corp., 1978.
Alexander, Geoff. “Black Preaching Styles.” Academic Film Archive of North America.
Last modified December 10, 1986. Accessed April 28, 2015.
http://www.afana.org/preaching.htm
Atterton, Jeff, and Leonard Feather. "America: Jazz." Melody Maker. London: Time, Inc.,
August 15, 1970.
Berliner, Paul F. Thinking in Jazz: The Infinite Art of Improvisation. Chicago: The
University of Chicago Press, 1994.
Black, Timuel D., Jr. Bridges of Memory: Chicago's First Wave of Black Migration.
Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press, 2003.
Black, Timuel D., Jr. Bridges of Memory: Chicago's Second Generation of Black
Migration. Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press, 2007.
Blumenthal, Bob. "Chapter 6: Bebop and Modern Jazz." In Discover Jazz, by John
Edward Hasse and Tad Lathrop. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education, Inc.,
2012.
Campbell, Robert L., Armin Büttner, and Robert Pruter. “The King Kolax Discography.”
Clemson University. Last modified August 20, 2013. Accessed February 15,
2015. http://myweb.clemson.edu/~campber/kolax.html
Charlton, Katherine. Rock Music Styles: A History. 5th Edition. New York, NY:
McGraw-Hill, 2008.
Costigan, Christopher James. “The Development of the Rhythm and Blues Saxophone
Style: An Analytical and Performance Based Study.” DMA diss., University of
Georgia, 2007. Accessed March 18, 2015. https://getd.libs.uga.edu/pdfs/costigan
_christopher_j_200712_dma.pdf.
Crawford, Richard. An Introduction to America’s Music. New York, NY: W.W. Norton
and Company, 2001.
Davis, Miles, and Quincy Troupe. Miles: The Autobiography. New York, NY: Simon
and Schuster, 1989.
117
Discogs. “Gene Ammons Discography.” Last modified 2015. Accessed February 24,
2015. http://www.discogs.com/artist/45107-Gene-Ammons.
Enright, Ed. "Gene Ammons: Ultimate Redemption." Down Beat. August 1, 2012.
Accessed January 31, 2015. http://www.downbeat.com/default.asp?sect=stories
&subsect=story_detail&sid=1125.
Fischer, Bob. Liner notes to Red Prysock: Handclappin' Footstompin' Rock 'N' Roll. Red
Prysock. Jasmine Records JASCD 274 MONO. CD. 2013.
Ginell, Cary. Mr. B: The Music and Life of Billy Eckstine. Milwaukee, WI: Hal Leonard
Books, 2013.
Gioia, Ted. The History of Jazz. New York: Oxford University Press, 2011.
Gridley, Mark. C. Jazz Styles: History and Analysis. 10th Ed. Upper Saddle River, NJ:
Pearson Education.
Hein, Ethan. “The Backbeat: A Literature Review.” The Ethan Hein Blog. March 29,
2013. Accessed April 3, 2015. http://www.ethanhein.com/wp/2013/the-backbeat-
a-literature-review/.
Jazz Discography Project. “Gene Ammons Catalog.” Jazz Discography Project. Last
modified July 26, 2001. Accessed March 19, 2015. http://www.jazzdisco.org/
gene-ammons/catalog.
Kernfeld, Barry. “Ammons, Gene.” American Council of Learned Societies. Last
modified February 2000. Accessed February 11, 2015. http://www.anb.org.
ezproxy.lib.utexas.edu/articles/18/18-02717.html.
Kostka, Stefan, Dorothy Payne, and Byron Almén. Tonal Harmony: With an Introduction
to Twentieth Century Music. 7th Edition. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill, 2013.
Lauterbach, Preston. The Chitlin' Circuit: And the Road to Rock 'n' Roll. New York:
W.W. Norton and Company, 2011.
Lawn, Richard J. Experiencing Jazz. 2nd Edition. New York, NY: Routledge, 2013.
Lawn, Richard J., and Jeffrey L. Hellmer. Jazz: Theory and Practice. Belmont, CA:
Wadsworth Publishing Company, 1993.
Liebman, Dave. “Jazz Rhythm.” Daveliebman.com. Last modified 2009. Accessed
March 15, 2015. http://www.daveliebman.com/Feature_Articles/JazzRhythm.htm.
118
Mathieson, Kenny. Cookin': Hard Bop and Soul Jazz, 1954-65. Edinburgh: Canongate
Books, 2002.
McNeal, Charles. "Blues Up and Down: Sonny Stitt's Solo from Gene Ammons' CD 'All
Star Session with Sonny Stit'." Saxopedia. Accessed March 8, 2015. http://www.
charlesmcneal.com/uploads/-BluesUpAndDown_stitt_.pdf.
Miller, Doug. "The Moan Within the Tone: African Retentions in Rhythm and Blues
Saxophone Style in Afro-American Popular Music." Popular Music 14, no. 2
(May 1995): 155-174. Accessed February 16, 2014. http://www.jstor.org/stable/
853397.
Morgenstern, Dan. Living with Jazz. New York: Pantheon Books, 2004.
Morrison, Nick. "Soul Jazz: Where Jazz, Blues and Gospel Meet." Take Five: A Jazz
Sampler. Prod. National Public Radio. January 4, 2010.
Owens, Thomas. Bebop: The Music and Its Players. New York, NY: Oxford University
Press, 1995.
Porter, Bob. Lester Young. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press, 2005.
Richards, Tim and John Crawford. Exploring Latin Piano: South-American/Cuban/and
Spanish Rhythms for the Intermediate Pianist. London: Schott Music Ltd., 2011.
Rosenthal, David H. Hard Bop: Jazz and Black Music 1955-1965. New York: Oxford
University Press, 1992.
Schuller, Gunther. Early Jazz: Its Roots and Musical Development. New York: Oxford
University Press, 1969.
–––. The Swing Era. New York: Oxford University Press, 1989.
Shaw, Arnold. Honkers and Shouters: The Golden Years of Rhythm and Blues. New
York, NY: Collier Books, 1978.
Simpson, David. “Lester Young: An American Original.” Jazz Institute of Chicago. Last
modified 2003. Accessed March 1, 2015. http://www.jazzinchicago.org/educates/
journal/articles/lester-young-american-original.
Sullivan, Leo T. “Biography.” Gene Ammons: Legendary Jazz Saxophonist. Accessed
March 17, 2015. http://www.geneammons.net/biography.
119
Tanner, Paul, David McGill, and Maurice Gerow. Jazz. 10th Edition. New York, NY:
McGraw-Hill, 2005.
Thomas, Pete. “Subtone.” Taming the Saxophone. 2014. Accessed April 3, 2015.
http://tamingthesaxophone.com/saxophone-subtone.
Travis, Dempsey J. An Autobiography of Black Jazz. 1st Edition. Chicago, IL: Urban
Research Institute, Inc., 1983.
Turek, Ralph. Theory for Today’s Musician. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill, 2007.
Twomey, John. “Biography.” Stan Getz- 'The Sound': Pioneer of Cool, Bossa Nova and
Modern Jazz. 2004. Accessed February 23, 2015. http://www.stangetz.net/bio.
html.
Walker, Bruce. “Gene Ammons Biography.” Index of Musician Biographies. 2015.
Accessed February 22, 2015. http://www.musicianguide.com/biographies/
1608003392/Gene-Ammons.html.
Walser, Robert. "The Rock and Roll Era." In The Cambridge History of American Music,
edited by David Nicholls. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1998.
Wang, Richard. “Captain Walter Dyett.” Chicago Jazz Magazine. Last modified May 27,
2008. Accessed April 9, 2014. http://www.chicagojazz.com/thescene/captain-
walter-dyett-86.html.
Wilson, Nancy. "Gene Ammons: The 'Jug'." Jazz Profiles. Prod. National Public Radio.
February 20, 2008. Accessed March 18, 2014. http://www.npr.org/2008/02/20/
19172123/gene-ammons-the-jug.
Yanow, Scott. Bebop. San Francisco, CA: Miller Freeman Books, 2000.
120
SELECTED DISCOGRAPHY
Ammons, Gene. Jug Sessions. EmArcy, 1947.
Ammons, Gene. Red Top. Savoy, 1947.
Ammons, Gene. Early Visions. Chess, 1948.
Ammons, Gene. Young Jug. Chess, 1948.
Ammons, Gene. Soulful Saxophone of Gene Ammons. Chess, 1948.
Ammons, Gene. Gene Ammons All Star Sessions. Prestige, 1950.
Ammons, Gene. Blues Up and Down, Vol. 1. Prestige, 1950.
Ammons, Gene. Golden Saxophone. Savoy, 1952.
Ammons, Gene. Sock!. Prestige, 1955.
Ammons, Gene. Juganthology. Prestige, 1955.
Ammons, Gene. The Happy Blues. Prestige, 1956.
Ammons, Gene. Jammin’ with Gene. Prestige, 1956.
Ammons, Gene. Funky. Original Jazz, 1957.
Ammons, Gene. Jammin’ in Hi Fi with Gene Ammons. Prestige, 1957.
Ammons, Gene. Groove Blues. Prestige, 1958.
Ammons, Gene. Blue Gene. Original Jazz, 1958.
Ammons, Gene. The Gene Ammons Story: Organ Combos. Prestige, 1958.
Ammons, Gene. The Gene Ammons Story: Gentle Jug. Prestige, 1961.
Ammons, Gene. Boss Tenor. Prestige, 1960.
Ammons, Gene. Angel Eyes. Prestige, 1960.
Ammons, Gene. Late Hour Special. Original Jazz, 1961.
121
Ammons, Gene and Sonny Stitt. We’ll Be Together Again. Prestige, 1961.
Ammons, Gene and Sonny Stitt. Boss Tenors: Straight Ahead from Chicago, 1961.
Verve, 1961.
Ammons, Gene. Live! In Chicago. Prestige, 1961.
Ammons, Gene. Boss Soul. Prestige, 1961.
Ammons, Gene. Up Tight!. Prestige, 1961.
Ammons, Gene. Twistin’ the Jug. Prestige, 1961.
Ammons, Gene. Blue Groove. Prestige, 1962.
Ammons, Gene. Preachin’. Prestige, 1962.
Ammons, Gene. Jug and Dodo. Prestige, 1962
Ammons, Gene. Jungle Soul. Prestige, 1962.
Ammons, Gene. Bad! Bossa Nova. Original Jazz, 1962.
Ammons, Gene. Brother Jug. Prestige, 1969.
Ammons, Gene. The Boss is Back!. Prestige, 1969.
Ammons, Gene. Night Lights. Prestige, 1970.
Ammons, Gene. The Chase. Prestige, 1970.
Ammons, Gene. Black Cat. Prestige, 1970.
Ammons, Gene and Sonny Stitt. Together Again for the Last Time. Prestige, 1973.
Ammons, Gene. Goodbye. Prestige, 1974.
Ammons, Albert. Blues and Boogie-Woogie King. Jazz Archives No. 125, 1998.
Ammons, Gene. God Bless Jug and Sonny. Prestige 2001.
Eckstine, Billy. The Legendary Big Band. Savoy, 2002.
122
Joseph Colarusso
2704 Dryden St.
Austin, TX 78748
josephcc@stedwards.edu
(512) 789-1387
Education
Doctor of Musical Arts: Performance with Jazz Emphasis, in progress, The
University of Texas at Austin
Master of Music: Jazz Studies, 2003, The University of Texas at Austin
Bachelor of Music: Applied Saxophone, 1996, The University of Texas at
Austin
Training
Principal Teachers
Saxophones Harvey Pittel
Bass clarinet Harvey Pittel
Clarinet Richard MacDowell
Flute/ Piccolo Beth Whitten
Trumpet Rick White
Jazz Theory/ Improvisation Richard Lawn/ John Mills
Professional Teaching Experience
St. Edward’s University, Austin, TX (2006-present)
• Coordinator of Instrumental Music
• Director of the St. Edward’s University Jazz Ensembles
• Director of the St. Edward’s University Mariachi Alas de Oro
• Applied Woodwinds Instructor
• Music Theory Lecturer
Prairie View A&M University, Prairie View, TX (2004-2009)
• Adjunct Professor of Saxophone and Clarinet
• Lecturer for Music in Contemporary Life
123
Round Rock ISD, Round Rock, TX (1994-2006)
• Private Saxophone, Flute, and Clarinet Instructor at Grisham
Middle School, Chisholm Trail Middle School, Cedar Valley
Middle School, Stony Point High School and Round Rock High
School.
• Director of the Chisholm Trail Middle School Jazz Ensemble.
The University of Texas at Austin, Austin, TX (2001-2003)
• Teaching Assistant for Harvey Pittel- taught applied saxophone
lessons to undergraduate saxophonists.
• Teaching Assistant for the Jazz Studies Department- coached jazz
combos on theory, performance, and improvisation styles.
Pflugerville ISD, Pflugerville, TX (1995-2001)
• Private Saxophone and Bass Clarinet Instructor at Westview
Middle School, Pflugerville Middle School, Pflugerville High
School, and Connally High School.
Publications
Steady- Jazz From the Carriage House (2012)
The St. Edward’s University Jazz Ensemble’s second CD, available at
http://think.stedwards.edu/musicalperformances/discography.
Mariachi Alas de Oro- El Primer (2010)
The St. Edward’s University Mariachi Ensemble’s first CD, available at
http://think.stedwards.edu/musicalperformances/discography.
Steady- Snapshot- In the Beginning (2006)
The St. Edward’s University Jazz Ensemble’s first CD, available at
http://think.stedwards.edu/musicalperformances/discography.
McGraw Hill Higher Education (2006)
Developed a website for my Music in Contemporary Life lecture class at
Prairie View A&M University. It can be viewed at www.jocal.pageout.net.
Awards and Honors
State Bar of Texas-LRE, Austin, TX (2006, 2007, 2009)
Was commissioned by the Law-Related Education department of the
Texas State Bar Association to lecture on American music history at the
2006, 2007 and 2009 State Bar Conventions. I recommended texts that
have now been adopted by the State of Texas as a part of the middle and
high school American history curriculum.
124
Phi Mu Alpha Sinfonia, Prairie View, TX (2006)
Was inducted into the Omicron Zeta chapter of the national music
fraternity Phi Mu Alpha as an honorary member by the students at Prairie
View A&M University.
Region 18 Jazz Band, Austin, TX (2002)
Clinician and conductor for the All Region Jazz Band.
Professional Affiliations
Phi Mu Alpha Sinfonia
Jazz Education Network
Performance Experience
Classical
Austin Symphony Orchestra
Austin Lyric Opera
University of Texas Wind Ensemble
University of Texas Symphony
University of Texas Saxophone Choir
Austin Saxophone Quartet
Nova Saxophone Quartet
Harvey Pittel
Donald Sinta
Jazz
Bob Brookmeyer
Joshua Redman
Mike Stern
Eddie Daniels
Maria Schneider
The Tony Campisi Big Band
Creative Opportunity Orchestra
Ed Shaughnessy
University of Texas Jazz Orchestra
St. Edward’s University Jazz Ensemble
John Mills Times Ten
Manhattan Transfer
The Stardust Orchestra
Dimensions in Blue (Lackland Air Force Base, San Antonio, TX)
Monster Big Band
Frank Sinatra, Jr.
Natalie Cole
Carmen Bradford
125
Commercial
The Temptations
Frankie Valli
Olivia Newton John
10,000 Maniacs
The Guy Lombardo Orchestra
Kenny Rogers
Asleep at the Wheel
Michael Feinstein
Tommy Tune
Marvin Hamlisch
Gino Vannelli
Linda Eder
Archie Bell and the Drells
Julie Budd
Aretha Franklin
Dale Watson
Rick Treviño
Charlie Sexton
Johnny Gimble
Bernadette Peters
W.C. Clark
Extreme Heat
Debby Boone
Musical Theater
Austin Musical Theater
Broadway Texas
University of Texas Department of Theater and Dance
Zilker Hillside Theater
Zachary Scott Theater
Mariachi
Mariachi Alas de Oro
Mariachi Cielo de Austin

More Related Content

PPT
Jazz in Schools Powerpoint
DOC
Resume sba 180515
DOCX
Which is not a step in the problem
PPTX
Modelo de barra cierre de la clase
PPTX
Jeopardy3
PPTX
ANTIGEN AND ANTIBODY REACTIONS
PDF
Yourprezi1
DOC
Resume_SBA_180515
Jazz in Schools Powerpoint
Resume sba 180515
Which is not a step in the problem
Modelo de barra cierre de la clase
Jeopardy3
ANTIGEN AND ANTIBODY REACTIONS
Yourprezi1
Resume_SBA_180515

Similar to COLARUSSO DISSERTATION 5.12.15 (20)

PDF
JAZZ MUSIC.pdf
PDF
How Jazz Evolved Into A Much Loved Musical Tradition
PPT
African Roots of Popular Music
PDF
American swing era 2013
PPT
Introduction To Jazz
PPT
Blues and Early Jazz
PDF
Jazz Music
PDF
UNIT 2 - LESSON 2 - POPULAR MUSIC MPAEH 10
PDF
What Are the Different Types of Jazz Music -Take a Look.pdf
PPT
4 B Jazz After 1900
PPT
Jazz power point
PPT
Jazz
PPTX
Must307 presentation
PDF
Annual Review Of Jazz Studies Volume 14 Evan Spring
PDF
The History Of Jazz Music
PPT
New Orleans Jazz
PPTX
A brief history of jazz
PPTX
Blues and Jazz
PDF
Eddie Lang - The Formative Years (1902-1925)
PDF
Indo-Jazz
JAZZ MUSIC.pdf
How Jazz Evolved Into A Much Loved Musical Tradition
African Roots of Popular Music
American swing era 2013
Introduction To Jazz
Blues and Early Jazz
Jazz Music
UNIT 2 - LESSON 2 - POPULAR MUSIC MPAEH 10
What Are the Different Types of Jazz Music -Take a Look.pdf
4 B Jazz After 1900
Jazz power point
Jazz
Must307 presentation
Annual Review Of Jazz Studies Volume 14 Evan Spring
The History Of Jazz Music
New Orleans Jazz
A brief history of jazz
Blues and Jazz
Eddie Lang - The Formative Years (1902-1925)
Indo-Jazz
Ad

COLARUSSO DISSERTATION 5.12.15

  • 3. EUGENE “GENE” AMMONS: THE COALESCENCE OF SWING, RHYTHM AND BLUES, AND BEBOP IN MODERN JAZZ by Joseph C. Colarusso M.M. Performance Jazz Emphasis, University of Texas at Austin, 2003 B.M. Performance Jazz Emphasis, University of Texas at Austin, 1996 Nontreatise Lecture Recital Document Presented to the Faculty of the Graduate School of The University of Texas at Austin in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Musical Arts in Performance (Jazz Emphasis) The University of Texas at Austin May 2015
  • 4. Dedication This paper is dedicated to my wife, Xochitl, and our girls, Xoey and Lila, with all of my love.
  • 5. v Acknowledgements First, I would like to thank my wife, Xochitl, for her abundant love and support while I worked on this project. I would also like to thank our daughters, Xoey and Lila, for the endless reserves of inspiration that they give me for this and all endeavors. Special thanks to my parents, Joe and Barbara Colarusso, for being the best parents, teachers and role models that anyone could ever ask for. I would like to express my deepest gratitude and appreciation to my committee supervisor and studio teacher, John Mills, for patiently teaching me over a number of years, and for being the highest caliber of music educator both in the classroom and on the bandstand. Thanks to my co-supervisor, Jeff Hellmer, for teaching me how to rehearse and play in a big band. My students will reap the benefits of his exceptional and unparalleled jazz ensemble pedagogy. Additionally, I am indebted to the rest of my committee members from the Butler School of Music; John Fremgen, Michael Tusa, and Eric Drott. They are leading scholars in their respective fields; moreover, they were an invaluable part of my music education. I would also like to express my gratitude to Morris Stevens, Jr. for serving as my outside committee member, and I look forward to continuing my education with him as we work together at St. Edward’s University. Lastly, I would like to thank everyone else who has ever helped me to maximize my potential as a musician, student, educator, and human being.
  • 6. vi Abstract EUGENE “GENE” AMMONS: THE COALESCENCE OF SWING, RHYTHM AND BLUES, AND BEBOP IN MODERN JAZZ Joseph C. Colarusso, D.M.A. The University of Texas at Austin, 2015 Supervisor: John Mills This research project is an exploration of the life and music of Eugene “Gene” Ammons. Though he has been largely overlooked and underrated by many jazz critics and historians, Gene Ammons’ impact on the evolution of jazz and his pervading influence on the jazz saxophonists that came after him is an undercurrent that reaches far and wide. The son of famous boogie-woogie pianist Albert Ammons, Gene Ammons evolved into a saxophone player whose style was steeped in the rhythm and blues tradition. At the same time, a jazz revolution was taking place as musicians like Charlie Parker and Dizzy Gillespie were pioneering the new bebop language. Ammons, having cut his teeth as the solo tenor saxophonist in the Billy Eckstine Orchestra, soon became a master of the new jazz language. He successfully married traditional swing with emotional rhythm and blues and sophisticated bebop, a skill that set him apart from jazz musicians confined to one niche or subgenre in jazz. Ultimately, Ammons’ developed
  • 7. vii style was a paragon of soul jazz, spreading throughout the Hard Bop Era. I will use historical data along with analysis of Ammons’ solo transcriptions to present Gene Ammons as one of the unsung heroes of the saxophone, with his musical contributions meriting consideration within the narrative of modern jazz.
  • 8. viii Table of Contents List of Tables .......................................................................................................... x! List of Examples .................................................................................................... xi! Chapter 1 Introduction ........................................................................................... 1! Chapter 2 Biographical Overview ......................................................................... 5 Chapter 3 The Sound and Vocality of Gene Ammons ........................................ 17 Sound ........................................................................................................... 17 Vocality........................................................................................................ 19 Chapter 4 Rhythmic Devices ............................................................................... 24 The Eighth-Note Feel and the Rhythmic Pocket ......................................... 24 Hemiola........................................................................................................ 27 Chapter 5 Gene Ammons' Vocabulary: The Coalescence of Swing, Rhythm and Blues, and Bebop .................................................................................. 32 Elements of Swing: The Influence of Lester Young ................................... 32 6/9 Common Language: The Major Pentatonic Scale ........................ 34 Dominant7(!5): The Creation and Resolution of Tension.................. 38 Elements of Rhythm and Blues: The Milieu of Illinois Jacquet and Red Prysock ................................................................................................. 43 Use of the Blues Scale ........................................................................ 46 Prolongation of One Repeated Note ................................................... 49 Motivic Repetition/Development........................................................ 56 Elements of Bebop: The Influence of Charlie Parker and Sonny Stitt ........ 59 Surround Tones................................................................................... 60 Scalar Versus Arpeggiated Diminished Chords ................................. 62 Double-time passages ......................................................................... 65 Harmonic Devices: Passing Chords.................................................... 67 Diminished Passing Chords....................................................... 68 Minor Passing Chords: iii7-!iii7 and the Use of Sequences...... 69
  • 9. ix Chapter 6 Conclusion........................................................................................... 74 Appendix A Complete Solo Transcriptions of Gene Ammons ........................... 78 Appendix B Solo Transcriptions of Lester Young, Illinois Jacquet and Red Prysock Completed in a Comparative Study of Gene Ammons ........ 102! Bibliography ....................................................................................................... 116 Selected Discography.......................................................................................... 120! Curriculum Vitae for Joseph Colarusso.............................................................. 122!
  • 10. x List of Tables Table 2.1:!Musicians Who Studied with Captain Walter Dyett.............................. 7! Table 2.2:!Musicians Who Played in the Billy Eckstine Orchestra...................... 11 Table 5.1:!Chord Changes for 'Bird Blues' ........................................................... 68! !
  • 11. xi List of Examples Example 4.1: Gene Ammons, "Please Send Me Someone to Love," mm. 89-93.. ........................................................................................ 27 Example 4.2: Charlie Parker, "Moose the Mooch," mm. 29-32........................... 28 Example 4.3: Gene Ammons, "Blues Up and Down" (1961), mm. 176-180....... 29 Example 4.4: Gene Ammons, "Blues Up and Down" (1961), mm. 441-445....... 29 Example 4.5: Gene Ammons, "Anna," mm. 53-55............................................... 30 Example 5.1: Lester Young, "Lester Leaps In," mm. 4-7..................................... 35 Example 5.2: Lester Young, "Lester Leaps In," mm. 129-132............................. 36 Example 5.3: Gene Ammons, "Blowing the Blues Away," mm. 37-39............... 36 Example 5.4: Gene Ammons, "St. Louis Blues," mm. 1-5................................... 37 Example 5.5: Gene Ammons, "Red Top," mm. 41-42 ......................................... 37 Example 5.6: Gene Ammons, "Blues Up and Down" (1950), mm. 1-4............... 38 Example 5.7: Lester Young, "Lester Leaps In," mm. 57-61................................. 39! Example 5.8: Gene Ammons, "Blowing the Blues Away," mm. 39-41............... 40 Example 5.9: Gene Ammons, "St. Louis Blues," mm. 15-17............................... 41 Example 5.10: Gene Ammons, "Juggernaut," mm. 86-90.................................... 41 Example 5.11: Gene Ammons, "Blues Up and Down" (1961), mm. 213-215..... 42 Example 5.12: Illinois Jacquet, "Flying Home," mm. 26-29................................ 47 Example 5.13: Gene Ammons, "Please Send Me Someone to Love," mm. 33-35 .......................................................................................... 48 Example 5.14: Gene Ammons, "Please Send Me Someone to Love," mm. 67-69 .......................................................................................... 49 Example 5.15: Gene Ammons, "Please Send Me Someone to Love," mm. 45-49 .......................................................................................... 49 Example 5.16: Illinois Jacquet, "Flying Home," mm. 33-49................................ 51 Example 5.17: Red Prysock, "Blow Your Horn," mm. 168-183.......................... 52
  • 12. xii Example 5.18: Gene Ammons, "Blues Up and Down" (1961), mm. 96-108....... 53 Example 5.19: Gene Ammons, "Blues Up and Down" (1961), mm. 109-120..... 54 Example 5.20: Gene Ammons, "Blues Up and Down" (1961), mm. 205-209..... 55 Example 5.21: Gene Ammons, "Blues Up and Down" (1961), mm. 456-468..... 55 Example 5.22: Gene Ammons, "Blues Up and Down" (1961), mm. 469-480..... 56 Example 5.23: Red Prysock, "Blow Your Horn," mm. 60-63.............................. 57 Example 5.24: Gene Ammons, "Blues Up and Down" (1961), mm. 120-125..... 57 Example 5.25: Gene Ammons, "Blues Up and Down" (1961), mm. 168-180..... 58 Example 5.26: Gene Ammons, "Blues Up and Down" (1961), mm. 192-204..... 59 Example 5.27: Charlie Parker, "Thriving From a Riff," mm. 41-43 .................... 61 Example 5.28: Gene Ammons, "Blowing the Blues Away," mm. 46-48............. 61 Example 5.29: Gene Ammons, "Juggernaut," mm. 72-73.................................... 62 Example 5.30: Sonny Stitt, "Blues Up and Down" (1950), mm. 16-19 ............... 63 Example 5.31: Gene Ammons, "Please Send Me Someone to Love," mm. 57-58 .......................................................................................... 64 Example 5.32: Gene Ammons, "Please Send Me Someone to Love," mm. 89-90 .......................................................................................... 64 Example 5.33: Charlie Parker, "Blues for Alice," mm. 20-23.............................. 65 Example 5.34: Gene Ammons, "Juggernaut," mm. 39-42.................................... 66 Example 5.35: Gene Ammons, "Please Send Me Someone to Love," mm. 89-93 .......................................................................................... 67 Example 5.36: Gene Ammons, "Blues Up and Down" (1961), mm. 1-5............. 69 Example 5.37: Sonny Stitt, "Blues Up and Down" (1950), mm. 37-41 ............... 69 Example 5.38: Charlie Parker, "Moose the Mooch," mm. 57-61......................... 70 Example 5.39: Gene Ammons, "Red Top," mm. 37-40 ....................................... 71
  • 13. xiii Example 5.40: Gene Ammons, "Blues Up and Down" (1961), mm. 187-191..... 72 Example 5.41: Gene Ammons, "Anna," mm. 53-55............................................. 72 ! ! ! ! !
  • 14. 1 CHAPTER 1 Introduction Eugene “Gene” Ammons (1925-1974) was a bebop saxophonist with roots that were heavily steeped in the urban blues tradition that would ultimately become rhythm and blues. From an early age up through musical maturity, his parents, teachers, mentors and colleagues gave him the tools and opportunities that would position him for success in the world of music. These pivotal experiences in Ammons’ education and career, presented in Chapter 2, molded him into one of the unsung heroes of the Modern Jazz Era1, and his contribution to the narrative of jazz merits more consideration than it has been given to date. The saxophone is an instrument that can be played in a highly individualistic manner. Whereas many other instrumentalists distinguish themselves through their unique vocabulary, exceptional saxophonists can often be identified solely by the quality of their sound. John Coltrane, Stan Getz and Michael Brecker could easily be picked out of an aural lineup, even if they were playing long tones. Gene Ammons is another great tenor saxophonist who fits into this ‘exceptional tone’ category. In terms of style, he was influenced by the Swing-Era tenor giants, Lester Young and Coleman Hawkins, and this paper will address these significant qualities in his playing.2 In 2008, three-time Grammy award-winning jazz vocalist Nancy Wilson hosted a one-hour documentary on Gene Ammons for National Public Radio, putting his sound and style into historical perspective. According to Wilson, Ammons played with Coleman Hawkins’ big, hot 1 Jazz from the Bebop Era (beginning in the early-mid 1940s) up to the present will hereafter be referred to as ‘modern jazz.’ 2 Ed Enright, “Gene Ammons: Ultimate Redemption,” Down Beat, August 1, 2012, accessed January 31, 2015, http://www.downbeat.com/default.asp?sect=stories&subsect=story_detail&sid=1125.
  • 15. 2 sound and Lester Young’s sense of lyricism.3 Chapter 3 of this document will discuss Ammons’ sound (tonal concept) and his vocality (sense of lyricism). An examination of prevalent rhythmic devices ingrained in his style is presented in Chapter 4. In addition to having an enormous and distinctive sound, Ammons possessed the ability to synthesize elements of swing, rhythm and blues, and bebop. This resulted in his composite vocabulary, discussed in Chapter 5, that was both unique and accessible to audiences over multiple demographics. His swing vernacular included frequent use of melodic ideas that ‘blanket’4 the chord changes with the major pentatonic scale whose root is tonic in the parent key. This approach is known in some circles as ‘6/9 common language.’ That combined with his extensive use of dominant7(!5) chords pays homage to Lester Young’s approach to improvisation. Ammons’ frequent use of blues vocabulary, prolongation of a single repeated note, and motivic repetition prove that the saxophonist was also greatly influenced by the rhythm and blues movement. Lastly, Ammons’ penchant for the new bebop, or ‘bop,’ language is illustrated in his use of surround tones, employment of double-time passages, and treatment of diminished and minor passing chords. At closer examination, it is easy to see the tremendous impact that Gene Ammons had on the evolution of jazz music and its musicians. During his tenure with Billy Eckstine’s band, he contributed greatly to the establishment of the dueling tenor saxophone format known as the ‘tenor battle.’ The saxophonist’s widow, Mildred Ammons, described the symbiotic relationship between her late husband and Sonny Stitt. She recounted that the Gene Ammons/Sonny Stitt collaborations showcased Ammons’ 3 Nancy Wilson, “Gene Ammons: ‘The Jug’,” NPR’s Jazz Profiles, February 20, 2008, accessed April 12, 2014, http://www.npr.org/2008/02/20/19172123/gene-ammons-the-jug. 4 Blanketing chord changes involves using one common scale or set of pitches to play over multiple chords.
  • 16. 3 big sound and Stitt’s flashy technique, and together their styles complemented each other.5 Ultimately, Ammons used his developed amalgamation of swing, rhythm and blues, and bebop sound and vocabulary to become a pivotal player of soul jazz in the Hard Bop Era. The groove-oriented subgenre known as soul jazz began to thrive in the early 1960s.6 However, the saxophonist was forced to assert his influence on this new subgenre by proxy while spending the majority of the sixties in federal prison on drug charges. He died in 1974 at the premature age of forty-nine. Much has been written about Ammons’ contemporaries such as Dexter Gordon, John Coltrane, and Stan Getz; however, Gene Ammons is mysteriously underrepresented in jazz history texts. It is possible that his identification with the rhythm and blues style worked to his detriment when being considered by jazz critics. Doug Miller, lecturer and saxophonist with the Count Basie Orchestra, published an article in Popular Music in 1995 in which he states: Saxophonists, particularly jazz tenorists who crossed over into R&B, were criticised for playing ‘rock and roll.’ Sam ‘The Man’ Taylor, for example, was called to account in a discussion sponsored by Down Beat magazine. Others were labeled by jazz critics as ‘extrovert moderns’ or ‘ audience getters.’7 Nancy Wilson asserts that Ammons possessed musical gifts commensurate with those of other jazz icons of the forties, fifties and sixties; however, he “rarely got a second look by 5 Wilson, “Gene Ammons: ‘The Jug’”. 6 Nick Morrison, “Soul Jazz: Where Jazz, Blues and Gospel Meet,” NPR’s Take Five: A Jazz Sampler, January 4, 2010, accessed February 4, 2015, http://www.npr.org/2010/01/04/98279702/soul-jazz-where- jazz-blues-and-gospel-meet. 7 Doug Miller, “The Moan Within the Tone: African Retentions in Rhythm and Blues Saxophone Style in Afro-American Popular Music,” Popular Music 14, no. 2 (May, 1995): 169, accessed February 16, 2014, http://www.jstor.org/stable/853397.
  • 17. 4 many of the jazz writers and critics of his era.”8 Additionally, jazz critics of the 1950s and 1960s showed an inclination to reserve their praise for artists that were clear innovators, rather than acknowledging those performers that assimilate on a very high level such as Ammons. Because Albert Ammons was generally accepted to be one of the preeminent boogie-woogie pianists of the day, it is also possible that Gene Ammons faced the burden of living in his father’s artistic shadow. I believe, however, that Ammons’ inclination to play fearlessly across styles/genres, without worrying about being a purist in any one particular style, set him apart from many of his contemporaries who could easily be pigeonholed into one category or another. For this reason, I have decided to explore Ammons in depth. Though he recorded up until shortly before his death in 1974, this paper addresses his recordings from 1944 to 1962. These were his developmental, evolutionary years. All of the transcriptions presented in this paper, whether excerpted as examples or compiled in complete form in the Appendices, are written for either B! tenor saxophone or E! alto saxophone (rather than notating concert or sounding pitches) in an attempt to reflect performance practice on these instruments. Through my extensive analysis of Ammons’ sound and approach to improvisation, I hope to provide an account of the saxophonist’s significant contributions to the transition from swing to modern jazz. 8 Wilson, “Gene Ammons: ‘The Jug’”.
  • 18. 5 CHAPTER 2 Biographical Overview Gene Ammons was born on April 14, 1925 on the south side of Chicago in a neighborhood known as Bronzeville. Black émigrés had been moving north from the Gulf Coast in droves during the 1920s, settling, among other places, on the south side of Chicago. A newspaper writer named James J. Gentry witnessed this transformation on the south side of town and gave the neighborhood its moniker. The south side of Chicago was the original Bronzeville; however, Bronzevilles were established in other northern cities including Detroit, Indianapolis and Milwaukee. Across the segregated North, these neighborhoods served as black towns within white cities.9 Ammons was from a musical family. Both of his parents were pianists; moreover, his father was the famous boogie-woogie pianist, Albert Ammons. To date, much more can be found in the histories on Albert Ammons than on his son, Gene. Pianists like Albert Ammons, Pete Johnson, Meade “Lux” Lewis and Camille Howard were playing left-hand ostinato patterns that would define the boogie-woogie style and, ultimately, serve as the most essential rhythmic figure of rock and roll guitar.10 It was Albert Ammons who first introduced the younger Ammons to boogie-woogie and the blues. The pianist spent a lot of time on the road performing; however, when he was home, Meade 9 Preston Lauterbach, The Chitlin’ Circuit: And the Road to Rock ‘n’ Roll (New York: W.W. Norton and Company, 2011), 15. 10 Robert Walser, “The Rock and Roll Era,” in The Cambridge History of American Music, ed. Dave Nicholls (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 1998), 348.
  • 19. 6 “Lux” Lewis and Pete Johnson were frequent visitors at the Ammons house.11 Albert Ammons’ boogie-woogie piano playing undoubtedly influenced his sons’ eventual penchant for fusing the bebop elements that the young saxophonist acquired later with the blues elements introduced at home. Like many other saxophonists of his era, Gene Ammons began his music education on clarinet, making the transition to the tenor saxophone shortly thereafter.12 He attended DuSable High School and studied music under the baton of the renowned Captain Walter Henri Dyett.13 An alumnus of The University of California at Berkeley, “Captain” Walter Dyett was given his nickname when he began conducting the Eighth Regiment Army Band of the Illinois National Guard. Dyett, a violinist, began playing with Erskine Tate a few years after moving to Chicago in 1921. During his tenure at DuSable High School, he became famous for his high musical standards. He was a strict disciplinarian, whose pedagogy included lots of yelling and swearing; however, he was also remembered by his students for his ability to motivate. Tenor saxophonist and DuSable alumnus Bill Adkins claimed that the band director could not say good morning without cursing. Adkins also states that Dyett was a remarkable communicator who would have been successful teaching any subject.14 The bandmaster schooled a remarkable number of student musicians who would soon become famous, many of whom are listed below in Table 2.1. Among others, this list includes jazz saxophone 11 Wilson, “Gene Ammons: ‘The Jug’”. 12 Dan Morgenstern, Living with Jazz (New York: Pantheon Books, 2004), 229. 13 Richard Wang, “Captain Walter Dyett,” Chicago Jazz Magazine (May 27, 2008), http://www.chicagojazz.com/thescene/captain-walter-dyett-86.html. 14 Timuel D. Black, Jr., Bridges of Memory: Chicago's Second Generation of Black Migration (Evanston, Il: Northwestern University Press, 2007), 82-83.
  • 20. 7 legends Gene Ammons, Johnny Griffin, Eddie Harris, Von Freeman and Clifford Jordan;, Count Basie trumpeter George T. “Sonny” Cohn and Duke Ellington trumpeter Ray Nance; jazz vocal icons Johnny Hartman, Nathaniel Adams Coles (known professionally as Nat King Cole) and Dinah Washington; famous jazz bassists Milt Hinton and Wilbur Ware; and drummers Jerome Cooper, Wilbur Campbell and Walter “Baby Sweets” Perkins. Saxophonists John Gilmore (Sun Ra), Joseph Jarmon (Art Ensemble of Chicago) and experimental violinist Leroy Jenkins would eventually emerge as important avant- garde voices. Other commercially successful graduates from DuSable High School include rock and roll guitarist and vocalist Bo Diddley, as well as comedian and actor Redd Foxx. Dr. Emil Hamberlin was a teacher a DuSable High School for over thirty years. In a 1996 interview, he claimed that most all of the black students at DuSable High School were “aggressively academic,” because they realized that education was their way out of poverty.15 Table 2.1: Musicians who studied with Captain Walter Dyett Gene Ammons Red Foxx Clifford Jordan Ronnie Boykins Von Freeman King Kolax Oscar Brashear John Gilmore Claude McLin Homer Brown Bennie Green Jessie Miller Wilbur Campbell Johnny Griffin Ray Nance Sonny Cohn Eddie Harris Pat Patrick Nat King Cole Johnny Hartman Walter Perkins Jerome Cooper Milt Hinton Julian Priester Richard Davis Fred Hopkins Wilbur Ware Bo Diddley Joseph Jarman Dinah Washington Dorothy Donegan Leroy Jenkins John Young 15 Black, Bridges of Memory: Second Generation, 212-213.
  • 21. 8 Historian and author Dempsey Travis claimed that “DuSable High School produced more jazz musicians in the 1930s and 40s under the direction of Captain Walter Dyett than any other institution in the country.”16 At DuSable High, Dyett directed the beginner band, concert band, honors band, booster band, ROTC band and the orchestra. In 1936, the band director began producing the school’s annual Hi-Jinks musicals, a tradition that continued well into the 1960s after he retired. Because of Dyett, DuSable High School became so widely known for its musical talent that famous jazz musicians such as Duke Ellington would drop in to scout talent and meet with the students.17 In 2008, the Institute of Chicago organized a celebration of Captain Dyett and his career as a public school music teacher. The commemoration included naming a plaza after Dyett and unveiling a statue of him. Like so many other great musicians from the south side of Chicago, Gene Ammons learned to hone his musical craft into art under the tutelage of Captain Walter Dyett. While still attending DuSable High School, Ammons joined trumpeter King Kolax’s band and soon became the band’s featured soloist on the tenor saxophone. Kolax was born William Little in Kansas City in 1912, but his family moved to Chicago where he too studied music under the direction of Captain Walter Dyett.18 Kolax’s band was a staging ground for many notable jazz icons including Charlie Parker, Nat “King” Cole, 16 Dempsey J. Travis, An Autobiography of Black Jazz, 1st ed. (Chicago: Urban Research Institute, Inc., 1983), 208. 17 Timuel D. Black, Jr., Bridges of Memory: The First Wave of Black Migration (Evanston, Il: Northwestern University Press, 2003), 181-182. 18 Robert L. Campbell, Armin Büttner and Robert Pruter, “The King Kolax Discography,” Clemson University, August 20, 2013, accessed February 15, 2015, http://myweb.clemson.edu/~campber/kolax.html.
  • 22. 9 John Coltrane, and Cannonball Adderley. Shortly after joining Kolax’s band, Ammons left school on a national tour with him which included multiple engagements at the famous Savoy Ballroom.19 In 1944, Billy Eckstine heard Ammons perform with Kolax and hired the saxophonist on the spot. Dubbed the “Sepia Sinatra” by Down Beat magazine, vocalist and trumpeter William Clarence “Billy” Eckstine left the Earl Hines Orchestra in 1943 with the hopes of putting his own band together.20 The following year he formed his own group and, though it was only extant from 1944 to 1947, his ensemble was an all-star band comprised of some of the top bebop musicians around at that time. Some historians such as Kenny Mathieson claim that his band was a “crucial staging post on the way to bebop.”21 Nancy Wilson described the group as fertile ground for the imminent bebop revolution.22 Jazz historian and former editor for Metronome and Down Beat magazines, Dan Morgenstern, makes this claim as well, calling the band the “chief incubator of budding bebop talent.”23 Other historians such as Barry Kernfeld go one step further, claiming that the Billy Eckstine Orchestra was indeed the first bebop band.24 An extraordinary number of jazz legends, listed below in Table 2.2, performed with the Billy Eckstine Orchestra. This included bebop pioneers such as Charlie Parker and Sonny Stitt on the alto saxophone; Gene Ammons, Charlie Rouse, Wardell Gray, Eli 19 Barry Kernfeld, “Ammons, Gene,” American Nation Biography Online, February, 2000, accessed February 11, 2015, http://www.anb.org.ezproxy.lib.utexas.edu/articles/18/18-02717.html. 20 Cary Ginell, Mr. B: The Music and Life of Billy Eckstine (Milwaukee: Hal Leonard Books, 2013), 53. 21 Kenny Mathieson, Cookin’: Hard Bop and Soul Jazz, 1954-65 (Edinburgh, UK: Canongate Books, 2002), 71. 22 Wilson, “Gene Ammons: ‘The Jug’”. 23 Morgenstern, Living with Jazz, 230. 24 Kernfeld, “Ammons, Gene”.
  • 23. 10 “Lucky” Thompson and Dexter Gordon on the tenor saxophone; as well as John Burkes “Dizzy” Gillespie, Miles Davis and Fats Navarro on the trumpet. The influential jazz vocalist Sarah Vaughan also worked with the Eckstine band. Some of the band members went on to achieve success in other genres as well. Art Blakely became an iconic hard bop drummer, founding and leading the Jazz Messengers for over thirty-five years. Saxophonists Ammons and Lucky Thompson gained recognition as rhythm and blues artists, and Dexter Gordon became a hard bop legend. Miles Davis was influential across numerous genres beyond bebop, most notably cool jazz, hard bop, modal jazz and fusion. According to Barry Kernfeld, Eckstine had originally hired Charlie Parker on alto saxophone and Charlie Rouse on tenor saxophone; however, Rouse was apparently so captivated by Parker’s playing that he couldn’t focus on his own parts. Consequently, he was fired and replaced by Ammons, who served as the principal soloist with Eckstine’s band from late 1944 until the band broke up in 1947. He shines on a number of the orchestra’s hits including “Blowing the Blues Away,” “I Love the Rhythm in a Riff,” “Second Balcony Jump,” “Cool Breeze” and “Oop Bop Sh’bam.” Additionally, Ammons was featured along with Eckstine in the 1946 film Rhythm in a Riff.25 It was during his tenure with the band that he earned the nickname “Jug.” The bandleader had ordered straw hats for the guys and was surprised at the unusually large size of the saxophonist’s head, at which time he declared that Ammons had a head like a jug.26 25 Kernfeld, “Ammons, Gene”. 26 Bruce Walker, “Gene Ammons Biography,” Index of Musician Biographies, 2015, accessed February 22, 2015, http://www.musicianguide.com/biographies/1608003392/Gene-Ammons.html.
  • 24. 11 Table 2.2: Musicians who played in the Billy Eckstine Orchestra Gene Ammons Wardell Gray Sonny Stitt Art Blakey Budd Johnson Eli “Lucky” Thompson Tadd Dameron Howard McGhee Jerry Valentine Miles Davis Fats Navarro Sarah Vaughan Dizzy Gillespie Charlie Parker Dexter Gordon Charlie Rouse In early 1947, Ammons was making his mark as a soloist in jam sessions at Chicago’s Jumptown Club alongside contemporaries such as Miles Davis and Sonny Stitt. He led his own small groups from the middle of 1947 until the spring of 1949. Albert Ammons had been a recording artist for Mercury Records and, like his father, Gene Ammons began to record for Mercury as well. In the summer of 1947, the record label brought father and son together in the studio to record “Hiroshima” and “St. Louis Blues.” There are very few recordings of Gene and Albert Ammons together, all of which were recorded for Mercury Records over two recording dates. These include Mercury 8140 (“Why I’m Leaving You”), Mercury 8022 (“Swanee River Boogie” and “I Don’t Want to See You”), Mercury 70158X45 (“Swanee River Boogie” and “I Don’t Want to See You” from the same session); all recorded on July 2, 1946. Gene and Albert Ammons’ last recorded collaboration took place on August 6, 1947, producing Mercury 8053 (“St. Louis Blues” and “Shufflin’ the Boogie”) and Mercury 8063 (“S.P. Blues” and “Hiroshima”).27 Gene Ammons also had his first hit as leader in 1947. Entitled “Red Top,” the tune was named after his wife, Mildred.28 27 Jazz Discography Project, “Gene Ammons Catalog,” Jazz Discography Project, last modified July 26, 2001, accessed March 19, 2015, http://www.jazzdisco.org/gene-ammons/catalog/. 28 Kernfeld, “Ammons, Gene”.
  • 25. 12 In 1949, Stan Getz left Woody Herman’s illustrious Second Herd, also known as the Four Brothers Band. That spring, Gene Ammons replaced Getz as Herman’s principal saxophone soloist in the Second Herd; however, his tenure with the band was short-lived. He left the band in early September of 1949 and was replaced by Billy Mitchell.29 Ammons’ brief experience with Woody Herman would be his last stint as a sideman.30 In 1950, Ammons began what was to become a long-standing partnership with fellow Eckstine alumnus, Sonny Stitt. Although the Ammons/Stitt Septet was only together formally for two years, the two saxophonists reunited several times during their lives to perform and record. Stitt was very competitive, always flaunting his virtuosic technique and inexhaustible vocabulary. Ammons had the enormous sound and an ability to hush an audience with one note. Together, they complimented each other and they took their show to cities in the North. From 1950 to 1951, the Ammons/Stitt Septet performed frequently in Detroit, Philadelphia, New York City and Boston; however, the majority of their gigs throughout this time were at Birdland in New York. It was during this period that the two tenor saxophonists recorded their first version of “Blues Up and Down.” After the Ammons/Stitt Septet formally dissolved in 1952, Ammons continued enjoying success on the road and in the studio, recording frequently on the Prestige label. Sadly, however, he had also begun using heroin. Dan Morgenstern maintains that the saxophonist stayed clean throughout his time with the Billy Eckstine Orchestra and with 29 Kernfeld, “Ammons, Gene”. 30 Morgenstern, Living with Jazz, 230.
  • 26. 13 Woody Herman’s Second Herd.31 The accuracy of this statement, however, could be challenged. Miles Davis claims in his autobiography that he himself began using heroin while playing in Eckstine’s band (which was defunct by the end of 1947), and that Ammons was the person who introduced him to the drug.32 Moreover, circumstances in Herman’s band make it difficult to believe that Ammons wasn’t using heroin in the late 1940s. According to Stan Getz, heroin use was rampant in the Second Herd.33 Indeed, Stan Getz and Serge Chaloff were both notorious for their addiction. By his own account, however, Ammons started using heroin sometime in the early 1950s.34 In 1958, Ammons was sent to the Statesville Penitentiary near Joliet, Illinois on a conviction for possession of narcotics. He was paroled two years later in June of 1960. It was during this brief respite from jail time that Ammons made his seminal recording Boss Tenor with Tommy Flanagan on piano, Doug Watkins on bass, Art Taylor on drums and Ray Barretto on congas. This recording included one of Ammons’ biggest hits, “Canadian Sunset.” Unfortunately, one of the terms of his parole involved his exclusion from performing in clubs. After repeatedly asking in vain for consent to make a living playing his saxophone, he ultimately began gigging without permission. His parole was promptly revoked and he went back to prison to serve the remaining five months of his original sentence. He was released for the second time in January of 1961.35 31 Morgenstern, Living with Jazz, 230. 32 Miles Davis and Quincy Troupe, Miles: The Autobiography (New York: Simon and Schuster, 1989), 96. 33John Twomey, “Stan Getz- 'The Sound': Pioneer of Cool, Bossa Nova and Modern Jazz,” 2004, accessed February 23, 2015, http://www.stangetz.net/bio.html. 34 Kernfeld, “Ammons, Gene”. 35 Morgenstern, Living with Jazz, 231.
  • 27. 14 After his second release from federal prison, Ammons began recording extensively on the Verve and Prestige labels. The saxophonist was at the height of his career, making hit records like Boss Tenors, recorded with Sonny Stitt in August of 1961 and Up Tight!, recorded in October of the same year. With the terms of his parole now lifted, he appeared often at McKie’s Lounge in Chicago with fellow saxophonists Dexter Gordon, Sonny Stitt and James Moody. The Hammond B-3 organ had begun replacing the piano in smaller jazz combos. Organists like Jimmy Smith, Richard “Groove” Holmes and “Brother” Jack McDuff were connecting jazz fans to rhythm and blues, and Gene Ammons was enthusiastic about the evolution of the Soul Jazz movement. He cut several records during this time with his organ combos including Live! In Chicago with organist Eddie Buster in August 1961, Twisting the Jug with Jack McDuff in November 1961, Brother Jack Meets the Boss with McDuff in January 1962 and Preachin’ with Clarence “Sleepy” Anderson on organ in May 1962. Jazz historian and record producer, Bob Porter, claims that Ammons was at the height of his musical career from 1961 to 1962. Porter also states that the saxophonist was strung out on heroin that entire time.36 In September of 1962, Ammons was arrested again, this time on the much more consequential charge of selling narcotics. Porter insists that Ammons was set up and that someone in Cook County, Illinois “had it in” for him.37 Dan Morgenstern states, “it was a clear case of entrapment, including extortion of a bribe 36 Wilson, “Gene Ammons: ‘The Jug’”. 37 Ibid.
  • 28. 15 ($5,000 according to Gene), but there was no mercy.”38 Illinois’ narcotics laws were strict, and Ammons was sentenced to another ten to twelve years back at Statesville Penitentiary. He ended up serving seven years of that sentence, from September 1962 to October of 1969. While in prison serving this extended sentence, Ammons managed to keep his music career alive. At Statesville, he was permitted to practice his saxophone. Additionally, he was in charge of the music library and he directed the prison band. Outside of prison, Bob Weinstock, founder and executive producer at Prestige Records, was working to keep the Ammons name alive. Weinstock, whether because of some feeling of foreboding or otherwise, had recorded the saxophonist extensively between 1961 and 1962; however, he did not release these recordings immediately. Instead, he released them gradually and systematically during Ammons’ seven-year stay at Statesville. Some of these Prestige releases include Velvet Soul (1964), Late Hour Special (1964), Sock! (1965), Angel Eyes (1965) and Boss Soul! (1966).39 Twelve days after his release in October of 1969, Ammons began resurrecting his career at the Plugged Nickel in Chicago with Kolax on the trumpet. The following month, the saxophonist did a two-day session for Prestige which produced The Boss Is Back! and Brother Jug!. The New York State Liquor Board ruled against allowing him to perform in New York City after his discharge from prison; however, he was received warmly everywhere else. He continued to collaborate with other formidable saxophonists on 38 Morgenstern, Living with Jazz, 231. 39 Discogs, “Gene Ammons Discography,” 2015, accessed February 24, 2015, http://www.discogs.com/artist/45107-Gene-Ammons.
  • 29. 16 performance dates at venues such as the North Park Hotel in Chicago where he performed with Dexter Gordon and Don Byas. In 1973, Ammons recorded one last time with Sonny Stitt on Together Again for the Last Time. Poetically, the last song Ammons ever recorded was the title track to his final record, Goodbye. Shortly thereafter, he was diagnosed with bone cancer and, on August 6, 1974, he passed. To the jazz community, he bequeathed a legacy of earthy and visceral saxophonists that would pride themselves in emulating the Gene Ammons sound.
  • 30. 17 CHAPTER 3 The Sound and Vocality of Gene Ammons Perhaps the most distinguishing characteristics of Gene Ammons’ music are his sound and vocality; moreover, many saxophonists have since tried to emulate his timbral and lyrical qualities. While these two traits are used together to produce a sonic identity on the saxophone, this chapter will unpack the two elements separately. Sound, used here interchangeably with tone quality or timbre, can be manipulated with physical adjustments to the diaphragm and throat position to shape or color the timbre of notes. Additionally, the selection of particular reeds, mouthpieces and horns can influence a saxophonist’s sound. Vocality, as it applies to Ammons, is a lyrical quality that can be traced back to its origins in African vocal music, Afro-American preaching styles and gospel music. Sound Nancy Wilson described Ammons’ sound as being “titanic-like.” According to Chicago radio host John Corbett, Ammons could be picked out of a crowd, even if he was playing long tones, because of the way that he attended to his sound. Trumpeter Lonnie Hillyer recalls an experience playing with Charles Mingus’ band. Ammons was also on that gig; and, according to Hillyer, the saxophonist hushed the audience with one note.40 Likewise, pianist Junior Mance claimed that Ammons had the biggest tenor sound that he 40 Paul F. Berliner, Thinking in Jazz: The Infinite Art of Improvisation (Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1994), 256.
  • 31. 18 had ever heard in his life. He stated that the saxophonist would buy a mouthpiece and file it wide open in an effort to realize his tonal concept, making the mouthpiece unplayable for anyone else.41 Before Ammons, many saxophonists, Lester Young included, were gravitating toward the lighter, cleaner sounds of Rudy Wiedoft, Frankie Trumbauer, Bud Freeman and Jimmy Dorsey. According to Doug Miller, however, numerous aspiring black saxophonists, especially those that were contributing to the establishment of the rhythm and blues style, were interested in imitating the “fatter, earthier sound” already modeled by Sidney Bechet and Coleman Hawkins. This ‘Afro-American’ saxophone sound was strengthened by managing an increase of the air column to produce a more balanced relationship between a note’s fundamental harmonic and the overtones above the fundamental. As a result, the center of resonance was forced out of the neck of the saxophone and further into the body of the horn. More than any other Swing-Era saxophonist, Hawkins’ tone quality served as a model for the next generation of saxophone players, including Arnett Cobb, Illinois Jacquet, Al Sears and Buddy Tate.42 Hawkins’ tonal influence was a point of departure that led to the evolution of a rhythm and blues saxophone tradition. Ammons’ timbral concept also stemmed from the Hawkins school of tone production. Additionally, his instrumental setup helped the saxophonist produce his massive sound on the horn. He played a Conn 10M saxophone, a popular choice among 41 Wilson, “Gene Ammons: ‘The Jug’”. 42 Miller, “Moan Within the Tone,” 157-158.
  • 32. 19 saxophonists looking for a hot sound. He favored playing on Brilhart mouthpieces as well. The white Brilhart Tonalin mouthpiece with which Ammons is so often pictured is plastic instead of the usual hard rubber or metal, and the plastic composition of this mouthpiece helped to enhance the edgy buzz in Ammons’ tone. The technique of growling is a concept in which the saxophonist hums or yells while playing, thereby producing a harsh or raspy tone. This manipulation of tone quality became a salient feature of the Afro-American saxophone sound. Hawkins often reinforced his hot sound by growling, and prime examples of his inclination to growl include his 1939 recording of “Fine Dinner” from Body and Soul and “Stealin’ the Bean” from his 1959 album Hawk Eyes!. This greatly influenced Gene Ammons, which is evidenced in his recordings of “Scrapple From the Apple” or “Please Send Me Someone to Love,” both released on his 1961 record Live! In Chicago. Ultimately, Hawkins’ growling technique became a hallmark of the rhythm and blues saxophone tradition, as exemplified by Red Prysock’s 1954 recording of “Blow Your Horn.” Vocality The concept of the hot, Afro-American sound is steeped in the African vocal tradition. Portia K. Maltsby, a Professor Emerita of Folklore and Ethnomusicology at Indiana University, states: In Africa and throughout the diaspora, black musicians produce an array of unique sounds, many of which imitate those of nature, animals, spirits and speech…[by]…the manipulation of timbre, texture and shading in ways uncommon to Western practice. Hence, the human voice plays such a central role
  • 33. 20 in African music and is utilized in all manner of ways to achieve a wide range of timbres and nuances.43 Neo-African vocalizations known as ‘field hollers’ or ‘arhoolies’ had been a crucial way for slaves to preserve their dignity and identity during the harsh conditions of slavery in the Deep South. African-Americans in the 1800s were forced to preserve African cultural traditions because their participation in Euro-American life was discouraged by whites.44 They accomplished this by singing spiritual hymns called ‘ring shouts.’ Richard Crawford is a former president of the American Musicological Society and Professor Emeritus of Music at the University of Michigan. In his book, An Introduction to America’s Music, he remarks: Ring dancing was and is found in many parts of Africa. Indeed, during the time of slavery, the ring shout was a way to bring transplanted Africans together. The ring allowed a synthesis of all the elements of African-American music, including calls and hollers; call and response; additive rhythms and polyrhythms; heterophony, blue notes, bent notes and elisions; hums, moans and vocables; off- beat melodic phrasings and parallel intervals and chords; constant repetition of rhythmic figures and melodic phrases; game rivalry; hand clapping, foot patting; and a rock-steady pulse.45 Additionally, black preaching styles dating back to the beginning of the nineteenth century heavily influenced the lyricism inherent in rhythm and blues music. Geoff Alexander is the director of the Academic Film Archive of North America. In his 1986 paper entitled “Black Preaching Styles,” he writes that black orators preached “with” their congregation instead of “to” them, establishing a rhythm of interaction or 43 Miller, “Moan Within the Tone,” 161. 44 Richard Crawford, An Introduction to America’s Music (NewYork, NY: W.W. Norton and Company, 2001), 249. 45 Ibid., 257.
  • 34. 21 ‘call and response’ with their audiences. Furthermore, preachers intoned their sermons in a singing style, often using pitch repetition in their delivery of the gospel.46 These characteristics are evidenced in the 1961 recording of “Blues Up and Down,” as Gene Ammons and Sonny Stitt trade high C’s for two choruses of the blues. Ammons’ 1962 organ-combo recording, Preachin’, is comprised of eleven gospel hymns including “Abide With Me,” “Blessed Assurance,” “You’ll Never Walk Alone,” and “Holy Holy.” Synthesizing these vocal traditions on instruments seemed like the natural course of events, and the saxophone was frequently used as a lyrical substitute for the human voice. Much of Ammons’ lyricism occurs as a result of the way he attacks and releases notes. Often, Ammons would start a note with one fingering and end the same note with a different fingering. In doing so, he would change the timbre and tuning of the note (sometimes by a quarter tone), giving that note a certain gruff vocal inflection that mimicked the nuances (throaty groans, choked screams, etc.) of the Neo-African vocal tradition. This is evidenced on his 1961 recording of “Blues Up and Down.” Also on the same recording, he manipulates the decay of certain notes by falling off of them in a ‘wailing’ manner, even going so far as to punctuate certain phrase endings with his speaking voice (grunts, yells, etc.). Ammons was known for his ability to vocalize on his instrument, which was especially evident on his recorded ballads. Charles Walton was a drummer and Associate Professor of Music at Malcolm X College in Chicago. He extolled Ammons’ lyricism, 46 Geoff Alexander, “Black Preaching Styles,” Academic Film Archive of North America, December 10, 1986, accessed April 28, 2015, http://www.afana.org/preaching.htm.
  • 35. 22 stating that Ammons played ballads as if he had the lyrics in mind. Billie Holiday claimed that Ammons’ version of “My Foolish Heart” was her favorite, and Ira Gitler said that he heard Dinah Washington’s voice in Ammons’ playing. According to Nancy Wilson, Ammons possessed a skill for emoting that was in line with, and influenced by, the lyricism of Lester Young.47 Saxophonists frequently use ‘subtone’ when playing ballads. The art of subtone goes beyond just playing softly, as it is a fuller sound with less edge or brightness and is often most effective in the lowest register of the saxophone.48 Ammons possessed this ability to play subtone with a hot sound, displaying the influence of the Swing-Era saxophonist, Ben Webster; and, the attack of these subtone notes occurs while tonguing very lightly or not at all. The air column is interrupted significantly enough for the notes to sound articulated, but the tongue may not actually touch the reed. This “V” tongue (sounding like “vuh-vuh”) can be heard on Ammons’ recording of “You Better Go Now” from his 1962 album Blue Groove, and can be compared to Ben Webster’s articulation two decades earlier on “You, You Darlin’.” A number of rhythm and blues saxophonists were synthesizing Hawkins’ fast, volatile vibrato along with his big sound. Ammons, however, diverges from this trend, adopting an approach that is more in line with Lester Young’s concept of vibrato. Young’s slower vibrato broke from the old, Swing-Era traditions of Louis Armstrong and 47 Wilson, “Gene Ammons: ‘The Jug’”. 48 Pete Thomas, “Subtone,” Taming the Saxophone, accessed April 3, 2015, http://tamingthesaxophone.com/saxophone-subtone.
  • 36. 23 Coleman Hawkins. In fact, his forward-looking concept of vibrato foreshadowed the emergence of the new bebop style of Charlie Parker, Sonny Stitt, Gene Ammons and their contemporaries. Gene Ammons’ use of growling, along with his hot and visceral tone quality, were the influence of Coleman Hawkins. This, along with his use of Lester Young’s lyrical blues vocalizations, gave him credibility as a rhythm and blues artist. Conversely, his use of Young’s slower vibrato positioned him for success as a bebop player. Ammons’ ability to amalgamate or compound the different ingredients that are fundamental to his concept of sound contributed to his validation as a saxophonist who was proficient in the rhythm and blues genre as well as the bebop style.
  • 37. 24 CHAPTER 4 Rhythmic Devices Whereas most of the characteristics ingrained in Ammons’ concept of sound support his inclusion predominantly in the rhythm and blues genre, there are other aspects of his playing that substantiate his identity as a bebop player. Many of these traits are melodic or harmonic; they are discussed in Chapter 5. Additionally, he employs certain rhythmic devices with bebop implications that merit consideration. The Eighth-Note Feel and the Rhythmic Pocket The unevenness of swing eighth notes was less pronounced in bebop music, especially as tempos began to increase.49 In this vein, Ammons’ eighth-note feel was a departure from the highly pronounced, lilting eighth notes of Swing-Era saxophonists. In fact he almost seemed to endorse a universal, slightly swung eighth-note feel, whether he was playing swing or Latin tunes. Evidence of this can be heard on bossa novas like “Pagan Love Song” from Bad! Bossa Nova or “Calypso Blues” on Night Lights. In both cases, Ammons is discreetly swinging his eighth notes over a Latin bossa feel, reminiscent of Charlie Parker’s Latin bebop approach to “A Night in Tunisia,” “Perdido,” or “Barbados.” While saxophonists such as Sonny Stitt and Johnny Griffin were swinging more overtly, Ammons’ approach to swing eighth notes was more in line with the subtler swing feel of Dexter Gordon. 49 Richard J. Lawn, Experiencing Jazz (NewYork, NY: Routledge, 2013), 198.
  • 38. 25 In a jazz context, the rhythmic pocket is the regular and consistent placement of the beat established by the bass and drums, and the placement of eighth notes within the rhythmic pocket is a highly personalized aspect of a jazz performer’s identity in music. Ammons generally opted to play right down the center of this pocket, distinguishing him from some of his colleagues mentioned above. Sonny Stitt and Johnny Griffin gravitated toward the front side of the beat. Dexter Gordon often laid back further, and was known for playing ‘on his heels.’ Ammons’ pocket can be seen as a balance between Stitt’s approach and Gordon’s feel. Additionally, Ammons possessed the ability to float independently over the top of the tempo at times. Dave Liebman calls this rhythmic device ‘over the time,’ stating: A more abstract concept very much demonstrated by Eric Dolphy, Ornette Coleman and John Coltrane at various periods is what I term over the time. This means that for small episodic passages the improviser creates a sense of being out of time without an obvious reference point. Usually these are fast noted passages and wild sounding in texture, but the effect is of the improviser freeing himself from the ongoing pulse like a bird in flight, quickly returning with a vengeance to earth, or in other words completely swinging in time. The ability to do this gracefully is one of the highest forms of time playing in my opinion. To be free but to know where you are at the same time is magical.50 A connection can be made here to the polymetric and polyrhythmic time relationships found in African music. Pulitzer prize-winning composer, author and historian Gunther Schuller claims that African polyrhythms are very complex, involving phrases that seldom coincide vertically. Rather than conforming to strict double-time rhythms within the beat, playing ‘over the time’ is a gestural occurrence that transcends the confines of 50 Dave Liebman, “Jazz Rhythm,” 2009, accessed March 15, 2015, http://www.daveliebman.com/Feature_Articles/JazzRhythm.htm.
  • 39. 26 the beat. In the African polyrhythmic tradition, these gestures are rhythmically additive instead of divisive.51 Liebman is describing this concept in an avant-garde or free jazz context; however, the Parker-influenced flurries played by Ammons and other bebop musicians also fit this description. Bebop was essentially eighth-note based, but Parker’s solos were often riddled with episodic, blistering double-time as well as over-the-time figures that eclipsed the strict underlying pulse. Moreover, it is likely that Dolphy, Coleman and Coltrane were all juxtaposing the influence of Parker on the jazz music of their generation. For these reasons, an argument can be made that playing ‘over the time’ was a bebop characteristic before it was popularized by avant-garde players. Furthermore, this technique shifts priority away from being able to dance to the beat, which contradicts the mandate of both swing and rhythm and blues music.52 A good example of Ammons’ ability to play ‘over the time’ is illustrated in Example 4.1. During his solo on “Please Send Me Someone to Love,” Ammons launches a barrage of fast notes beginning with strict double time thirty-second notes occurring from beat 3 of m. 89 to beat 3 of m. 90. On beat 4 of m. 90, however, he abandons the beat and tempo, now playing in a fitful and episodic state that has been notated according to the closest available rhythmic options. He returns to strict adherence of the time on the last sixteenth note of beat 3 in m. 92. 51 Gunther Schuller, Early Jazz: Its Roots and Musical Development (New York, NY: Oxford University Press, 1968), 11. 52 Bob Blumenthal, “Chapter 6: Bebop and Modern Jazz,” in Discover Jazz, ed. John Edwards Hasse and Tad Lathrop (Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education, Inc., 2012), 132.
  • 40. 27 Example 4.1: Gene Ammons, “Please Send Me Someone to Love,” mm. 89-93 Hemiola A ‘hemiola,’ or ‘cross-rhythm,’ is a rhythmic event that features the implication of one meter inside the framework of another. One particular type of hemiola that occurred frequently in the improvisation of Gene Ammons is a rhythmic device in which triple meter (3/4 or 3/8) is implied over music written in 4/4 time. This device, known as ‘three against four,’ is a common jazz cross-rhythm.53 Much like Liebman’s concept of playing ‘over the time,’ bebop hemiolas serve to undermine the rhythmic regularity of the music that might otherwise promote dancing. Though the use of rhythmic devices such as three against four is not unique to bebop, the movement away from performing jazz as dance music is certainly a bebop characteristic.54 In contrast to swing and Latin styles, 53 Richard J. Lawn and Jeffrey L. Hellmer, Jazz: Theory and Practice (Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Publishing Company, 1993), 70. 54 Lawn, Experiencing Jazz, 196.
  • 41. 28 hemiolas in a bebop context tend to occur sporadically and unpredictably, often starting on weak beats. Charlie Parker flirted with the use of hemiolas. Example 4.2 is an excerpt of the melody to “Moose the Mooche,” adapted from the Charlie Parker Omnibook.55 Beginning on the second beat of m. 31, Parker plays two groupings of three beats. This lends rhythmic uncertainty to the melody of the tune just before the solo begins at the double bar in m. 33. Example 4.2: Charlie Parker, “Moose the Mooche,” mm. 29-32 In Example 4.3 from the 1961 version of “Blues Up and Down,” Ammons repeats the motive introduced on the downbeat of m. 177 three additional times. The four iterations of this three-beat motive make Ammons sound like he has temporarily lapsed into 3/4 time while improvising over this up-tempo, twelve-bar blues in quadruple meter. However, this hemiola only lasts for a duration of three measures and the tempo is 250 beats per minute. The listener does not have enough time to get comfortable with this briefly imposed feel. 55 Jamey Aebersold and Ken Slone, Charlie Parker Omnibook: For Eb Instruments, Transcribed Exactly From His Solos (Lynbrook, NY: Atlantic Music Corp., 1978), 4-5.
  • 42. 29 Example 4.3: Gene Ammons, “Blues Up and Down” (1961), mm. 176-180 Later in the same recording of “Blues Up and Down,” Ammons uses a ‘3 + 3 + 2’ cross-rhythm in which the eight beats of two consecutive measures are arranged into two groups of three with an additional group of two beats at the end. Ammons uses this hemiola in combination with a chromatic descending sequence. Here in Example 4.4, the three-beat motive ascends in step-wise motion from the root of Dmin7 on the downbeat of m. 441 to the fifth of the chord on beat 3. The original motive is then sequenced down by a half step on beat 4, anticipating the G7 chord by one beat with its tritone substitution, D!7. A truncated version of the motive is sequenced down chromatically one last time on beat 3 of m. 442, anticipating the C7 chord by two beats. The brief use of the 3 + 3 + 2 hemiola, coupled with the chromatically sequenced motive that anticipates the harmonies, gives Ammons’ solo a sense of sophisticated organization that is typical in his playing and representative of the bebop language. Example 4.4: Gene Ammons, “Blues Up and Down” (1961), mm. 441-445
  • 43. 30 Example 4.5 illustrates Ammons’ use of ‘3 + 3 + 2’ on his 1962 recording of the Latin bossa, “Anna.” Here the saxophonist uses diminution, manipulating the eighth-note subdivisions of the measure into groups of 3 + 3 + 2. In doing so, he is appropriately reacting to the Latin clave style of the rhythm section. The drummer, Oliver Jackson, is playing a ‘bossa nova clave’ or ‘Brazilian clave’ rhythm on the rim of the snare drum throughout the tune. This rhythmic pattern is produced by accenting beat 1, the upbeat of beat 2 and beat 4 in the first measure of this two-bar pattern, as well as beat 2 and the upbeat of beat 3 in the second measure.56 Hank Jones reinforces this rhythm on piano while comping during Ammons’ solo. Example 4.5 is in fact a dance rhythm hook; nonetheless, this example still belongs to the Bebop Era. The syncopated sixteenth-note subdivisions imply a double-time feel, thereby capturing the bebop essence. Example 4.5: Gene Ammons, “Anna,” mm. 53-55 Example 4.5 shown above is representative of what Jelly Roll Morton called the ‘Latin tinge,’ which was embraced in bebop music by Dizzy Gillespie in songs such as “Manteca” and “A Night in Tunisia.”57 Similarly, Charlie Parker’s interest in Latin rhythms is evidenced in his recordings of “Barbados” and “My Little Suede Shoes.” 56 Tim Richards and John Crawford, Exploring Latin Piano: South-American/Cuban/Spanish Rhythms for the Intermediate Pianist (London: Schott Music Ltd., 2011), 135. 57 Thomas Owens, Bebop: The Music and Its Players (NewYork, NY: Oxford University Press, 1995), 20.
  • 44. 31 Whereas the timbral and stylistic traits discussed in Chapter 3 place Ammons in multiple genres, the rhythmic characteristics discussed in this chapter support his inclusion in the bebop community.
  • 45. 32 CHAPTER 5 Gene Ammons’ Vocabulary: The Coalescence of Swing, Rhythm and Blues, and Bebop Gene Ammons possessed an ability to fuse elements of swing, rhythm and blues, and bebop into his own style. Additionally, he had the wherewithal to assess his audience on any given night and unpack elements of the above genres to use them separately. Bob Porter stated that Ammons’ vocabulary would be heavily weighted with bebop language if he was playing on the north side of Chicago to predominantly white patrons. Conversely, according to Porter, Ammons would emote in the rhythm and blues vernacular if he was performing on the south side of Chicago to a black audience.58 He learned from his predecessors, Coleman Hawkins and Lester Young, as well as his contemporaries such as Charlie Parker, Illinois Jacquet, Sonny Stitt, and Red Prysock. With respect to Ammons’ vocabulary, direct stylistic comparisons can be made to all of the above-mentioned saxophonists excluding Coleman Hawkins. This chapter is an analysis of some of the aspects of Ammons’ melodic and harmonic language that unify him with these seminal swing, rhythm and blues, and bebop saxophonists. Elements of Swing: The Influence of Lester Young The year 1944 marked the beginning of Gene Ammons’ extensive recording career. Though the Swing Era was winding down, its pervasive influence could still be 58 Wilson, “Gene Ammons: ‘The Jug’”.
  • 46. 33 heard in the language of the next generation of jazz musicians. The young Ammons was a forward-thinking improviser; however, his roots were steeped in swing. While discussing the swing elements in Ammons’ playing, a point of reference should be drawn to Lester Young. Gunther Schuller extolls Young as the most progressive improviser of his time: …in terms of a revolutionizing and lasting effect on several further generations of jazz players, it is an incontrovertible fact that Lester was the most influential artist after Armstrong and before Charlie Parker. What eluded Coleman Hawkins despite his life-long heroic strivings, namely, domination of the saxophone world, virtually fell into Lester’s lap. And before his life was a little more than half over, he had not only spawned a whole school of followers but created a completely new aesthetic of jazz – for all instruments, not just the tenor saxophone. The essence of his heritage is that he proposed a totally new alternative to the language, grammar, and vocabulary of jazz, one that broke away from the prevailing Armstrong tradition and did so incisively, unequivocally and unapologetically.59 Lester Young did not start recording until 1936, but his new style, which was decidedly different from the established swing paradigms, was already developed. This was evidenced by his severance of employment with Fletcher Henderson before becoming the lead tenor player with Count Basie from 1934 to 1939.60 Henderson’s players were all listening to Louis Armstrong and Coleman Hawkins. Young, however, was avoiding Hawkins’ style, favoring the influence of Jimmy Dorsey and Frankie Trumbauer. This would explain Young’s cool, light sound.61 Whereas Hawkins’ melodic style was vertical and more chord-based, Young’s was more linear, deriving from the 59 Gunther Schuller, The Swing Era (New York: Oxford University Press, 1989), 547. 60 David Simpson, “Lester Young: An American Original,” Jazz Institute of Chicago, 2013, accessed March 1, 2015, http://www.jazzinchicago.org/educates/journal/articles/lester-young-american-original. 61 Schuller, The Swing Era, 548.
  • 47. 34 blues. Indeed, at the age of twenty-five, Young was cutting his teeth playing the blues in Kansas City with Count Basie. 6/9 Common Language: The Major Pentatonic Scale Among other melodic tendencies, Lester Young emphasized the sixth and ninth scale degrees of the key. Additionally, according to Schuller, the concept of melodic independence from the harmonic progression began with Young.62 These two qualities combine together to form an approach to improvisation often described as ‘6/9 common language.’ This vocabulary consists of the major pentatonic scale (scale degrees 1-2-3-5- 6) on the tonic note in the key (C major pentatonic in the key of C major). The framework of this major pentatonic scale, peppered with chromatic tones, constitutes the generality of the 6/9 common language. Whereas Gene Ammons did, in fact, try to emulate the sound of Coleman Hawkins, he was clearly studying the melodic vocabulary of Lester Young, synthesizing Young’s 6/9 common language into his own playing. One of the most well-known ‘rhythm changes’63 tunes is Young’s own composition “Lester Leaps In,” originally recorded in 1939 by Count Basie’s Kansas City Seven. The first phrase of the actual melody in the A section of the head is illustrated below in Example 5.1. It is a strict adherence to the major pentatonic scale built on the tonic of the key. Except for the omission of the last note, the second phrase of the A section is identical, completing the eight-bar A section of this ‘rhythm changes’ tune. As 62 Schuller, The Swing Era, 548. 63 A ‘rhythm changes’ tune contains a standardized harmonic progression identical to the progression in George and Ira Gershwin’s “I Got Rhythm.” Hence, a rhythm changes tune could be thought of as a contrafact, a new melody composed over the preexisting changes to “I Got Rhythm.”
  • 48. 35 is typical of a ‘rhythm changes’ tune, there is no written melody over the bridge. Every note of the written melody of “Lester Leaps In” conforms to the pentatonic major scale built on the tonic of the key. Scale degree 2 is not represented in the melody; otherwise, there are no deviations outside of this pentatonic framework. Example 5.1: Lester Young, “Lester Leaps In,” mm. 4-7 Example 5.2 is a paragon of Young’s penchant for expanding the blanket major pentatonic scale with chromatic connections – specifically between scale degrees 2-3 and 5-6. In m. 129 of his solo on “Lester Leaps In,” Young uses chromatic passing tones, labeled “PT,” first to move from scale degree 6 to scale degree 5 and then to descend from scale degree 3 to scale degree 9 (or 2). On the upbeat of beat 4 in m. 130, he again uses a passing tone to get from scale degree 5 back to scale degree 6, this time in an ascending manner. In m. 131, the E on beat 2 (scale degree 3) is approached by a chromatic lower neighbor, labeled “LN.” Two more chromatic passing tones in the second half of m. 131 help Young navigate melodically through this pentatonic scale, traveling from scale degree 6 on the upbeat of beat 2 to scale degree 9 on the downbeat of the following measure. The passing tones and lower neighbor circled in mm. 129-132 illustrate the fact that the saxophonist is comfortable using the chromatic notes outside of the pentatonic scale on both strong and weak parts of the beat.
  • 49. 36 Example 5.2: Lester Young, “Lester Leaps In,” mm. 129-132 Billy Eckstine’s 1944 recording “Blowing the Blues Away” features Gene Ammons very early in the saxophonist’s career. At this time, the foundation of Ammons’ vocabulary is the 6/9 common language popularized by Lester Young. Example 5.3 shows Ammons using the D!’s repeatedly as chromatic lower neighbors, labeled “LN,” to approach scale degree 3 of this C major pentatonic scale. In doing so, Ammons vacillates between the major third and the minor third (written as a D! or !9), which accentuates the blues aspect of this melody. Finally, a chromatic passing tone at the end of m. 38 delivers the melody from scale degree 6 to scale degree 5, similar to Ammons’ approach in Example 5.2. Example 5.3: Gene Ammons, “Blowing the Blues Away,” mm. 37-39 In Example 5.4 Ammons embellishes the blanket major pentatonic scale in the key of D with a diatonic scale degree 4, rather than using chromatic pitches. The G in m. 2 acts as an upper neighbor, labeled “UN,” and can be thought of as a slow turn. The G in m. 4 is a passing tone, getting Ammons from scale degree 3 to scale degree 5. The F! in
  • 50. 37 m. 3 does not fit the A7 chord, further reinforcing the fact that Ammons was using 6/9 common language to blanket the quick IV chord (A7) during his solo on “St. Louis Blues.” This is reminiscent of Young’s inclination to play melodies that might not adhere completely to the chord changes. Example 5.4: Gene Ammons, “St. Louis Blues,” mm. 1-5 Example 5.5 is significant in that it illustrates the conclusive placement of pentatonic vocabulary at the end of Ammons’ solo in the key of G on “Red Top.” It was common for both Young and Ammons to frame sections of their solos with 6/9 common language. The soloists might deviate from this pentatonic scaffolding while developing their solos; however; they would frequently return to this language when wrapping up a section of a solo, or when ending a solo altogether. Example 5.5: Gene Ammons, “Red Top,” mm. 41-42 The beginning of Ammons’ solo on his 1950 recording of “Blues Up and Down” is shown below in Example 5.6. More than on his earlier recordings, Ammons is beginning to sound increasingly confident with some of the non-swing elements he was
  • 51. 38 incorporating into his vocabulary. However, this 6/9 common language is still a major component of his improvisations. In the example below, Ammons demonstrates his ability to slip in and out of C major pentatonic vocabulary through his use of chromaticism at the beginning of m. 2, the addition of the !7 at the end of m. 3, and the use of the !5 at the end of m. 4. Example 5.6: Gene Ammons, “Blues Up and Down” (1950), mm. 1-4 Dominant7(!5): The Creation and Resolution of Tension Across a number of tonal styles and genres in western music64, phrases almost always end with a cadence that shifts harmonically from a dominant chord (V) to the tonic chord (I). This simple process can be seen on a fundamental level as the creation and subsequent resolution of aural tension. Whether consciously or subconsciously, listeners hear dominant triads and understand that those chords need to be resolved to tonic chords when cadencing at the end of phrases. Adding a seventh to the dominant chord (V7) increases the tension.65 Lester Young was fond of creating even more dominant tension by raising the fifth of the chord (V7!5). Chromatic alteration of the 64 For the purpose of this paper, ‘western music’ will be defined as the music of Western Europe, in which major and minor modes and their requisite intervallic relationships are used to construct tonal centers. 65 Ralph Turek, Theory for Today’s Musician (New York: McGraw-Hill, 2007), 613-614.
  • 52. 39 dominant chord’s ninth and fifth occurred with increasing frequency during the evolution of bebop; and, though Young fits squarely in the Swing Era, the use of augmented (V7!5) chords by Young, his contemporaries, and even his predecessors could been interpreted as a foreshadowing of the extended harmonic techniques that would soon be popularized by bebop innovators like Charlie Parker. Bob Porter remarked that Lester Young was known for adding “color” to dominant chords, particularly at the end of the B section in AABA form.66 Porter’s claim is illustrated below in Example 5.7. This excerpt shows the last four measures of the B section in the rhythm changes tune, “Lester Leaps In,” followed by the first measure of the last A section. In m. 59, Young plays a descending, two-octave G7(!5) chord, which is V7(!5) in the home key of C major. In m. 60, the last measure of the bridge, Young transitions from his augmented vocabulary back to a fixation on the pitches A and D which represent scale degrees 6 and 9 respectively in the home key of C. He then plays 6/9 common language vocabulary for the entire last A section of this chorus. Example 5.7: Lester Young, “Lester Leaps In,” mm. 57-61 Lester Young’s fresh approach to improvisation became the benchmark for the new generation of jazz saxophonists, and his melodic ideas worked exceptionally well in 66 Bob Porter, Lester Young (Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press, 2005), 67.
  • 53. 40 swing and bebop settings alike. Gene Ammons was a quick study, and his use of the V7(!5) chord manifests itself in his earliest recordings. In Example 5.8, Ammons uses the dominant7(!5) chord to progress from the I chord to the IV7 chord in “Blowing the Blues Away.” The C major chord in m. 39 represents the I chord in this standard blues progression. The introduction of the B! in m. 40 signifies that the I chord has now become a secondary dominant (V7/IV), setting the listener up for the resolution to F7 in m. 41. Before Ammons arrives in m. 41, however, he raises the fifth of C7 on beat 3 of m. 40. This adds heightened tension to the dominant tonality in m. 40 which, in turn, makes the resolution to F7 in m. 41 even more satisfying. Example 5.8: Gene Ammons, “Blowing the Blues Away,” mm. 39-41 Ammons, like Young, realized that the improviser could quickly and efficiently change the color of the dominant chord simply by altering one note. He showed this tendency often when transitioning to the IV chord in the fifth measure of standard blues forms like “Blowing the Blues Away,” illustrated above in Example 5.8. Example 5.9 below reinforces this claim. Here, Ammons is on his second chorus, soloing over a standard blues progression in D on “St. Louis Blues.” The fourth measure of the form is m. 16, one measure before the arrival of the IV chord. Ammons begins the measure playing an unaltered D7 chord (V7/IV) in a linear manner; however, after arriving on the
  • 54. 41 A (the fifth of D7), he toggles upward by a half step to A! on beat 3. He then briefly arpeggiates the triad in the D7(!5) chord before vacillating back to A natural, which now acts as the resolution to the ninth of the IV chord, G7. Example 5.9: Gene Ammons, “St. Louis Blues,” mm. 15-17 Example 5.7 above addresses Lester Young’s use of the dominant7(!5) chord at the end of the B section as a means of ushering the listener back to the final A section of the form. The following example, Example 5.10, shows Ammons employing Young’s technique. Similar to Young’s 1939 version of “Lester Leaps In,” Ammons’ 1955 recording of “Juggernaut” is also a rhythm changes tune whose formal structure is AABA. The G7 chord in mm. 88-89 in the example below is the V chord at the end of the B section. Here, Ammons emphasizes the !5 color extensively by arpeggiating G7(!5) for two measures. The chromatic approach to the G on beat 3 of m. 89 by way of the A and A! on beat 2 could be construed as a brief suggestion of 6/9 common language in the key of C major, or as a bebop scale passing tone fragment. Example 5.10: Gene Ammons, “Juggernaut,” mm. 86-90
  • 55. 42 Example 5.11 below is an excerpt from Gene Ammons’ later 1961 recording of “Blues Up and Down” with Sonny Stitt. In m. 214, Ammons again utilizes the dominant7(!5) chord before resolving to the tonic chord in m. 215; however, his strategy here is more complex than his use of these chords on earlier recordings. The first half of m. 214 appears to be an extension of the previous Dmin7 chord, especially when considering the eighth notes on beat 4 of the previous measure. In m. 214, Ammons clearly spells out the G augmented triad inherent in G7(!5) before the resolution to the I chord in m. 215; however, the !5 (D!) appears on the weak part of beat 3 and is approached on the down beat chromatically from the E, a half step above. While the use of the dominant7(!5) chord pays homage to Lester Young, the E on beat 3 acts as an appoggiatura tone, modernizing Ammons’ approach to the dominant7(!5) chord. Example 5.11: Gene Ammons, “Blues Up and Down” (1961), mm. 213-215 Gene Ammons drew from several sources of inspiration, but Lester Young was undoubtedly one of his biggest influences. Because Young was so adept at playing the blues and vocalizing on his saxophone in a blues style, he resonated with the next generation of saxophonists steeped in the Neo-African vocal tradition of field hollers, ring shouts and gospel preaching. Many of these saxophonists were combining Young’s sense of lyricism with Coleman Hawkins’ hot sound, and this formula appealed to
  • 56. 43 Ammons as well. His style was also imbued with the qualities of Young and Hawkins; furthermore, he was intrigued by the developing style of some of his contemporaries, a style that would come to be known in the late 1940s as ‘rhythm and blues.’ Elements of Rhythm and Blues: The Milieu of Illinois Jacquet and Red Prysock Doug Miller describes rhythm and blues as the fusion of urban blues with the driving rhythms of jazz and the vocalizations of gospel music. The blues originally emerged as a musical depiction of the hardships of African-American life; conversely, rhythm and blues was dance music that articulated the joy in life.67 This new genre of black dance music, previously labeled ‘race recordings,’ was eventually dubbed ‘rhythm and blues’ by Billboard magazine in 1949.68 Most other styles of music at that time possessed a rhythmic pulse in which the first and third beat of each four-beat measure was accented, but the rhythm and blues style was defined by its unrelenting accentuation of beats 2 and 4, otherwise known as a ‘backbeat.’ It is possible to trace the evolution of the backbeat through the blues and jazz genres of the early Twentieth Century in an effort to gain perspective on its role in the fully-developed rhythm and blues style emerging in 1949. A subtler use of this rhythmic device was found in the blues, but it became more overt and significant in rhythm and blues music.69 Likewise, the accentuation of the weak beats occurred in early jazz, 67 Katherine Charlton, Rock Music Styles: A History (New York, NY: McGraw-Hill, 2008), 20. 68 Miller, “Moan Within the Tone,” 155. 69 Charlton, Rock Music Styles, 20.
  • 57. 44 manifesting itself in banjo and piano accompaniment patterns.70 As early as the big band Swing Era, the emphasis of beats 2 and 4 migrated to the drummer’s high-hat cymbals.71 The rhythm and blues school went a step further – its unyielding backbeat was played on the snare, which was often accompanied by regular and repeated cymbal crashes. This was exemplified in Red Prysock’s tunes such as “Hand Clappin’” from 1955 or “Zip” from 1956. The establishment of the rhythm and blues backbeat seemed to contradict the rhythmic evolution of jazz in the 1940s, however, as bebop drummers became increasingly inclined to obscure the regular pulse.72 During the 1920s, Louis Armstrong, Sidney Bechet and other jazz instrumentalists were backing blues singers like Bessie Smith on race records. Into the 1930s, numerous attempts were made to bring jazz together with blues singers, and the locations of these events became the prominent centers for the emergence of the rhythm and blues style.73 The intersection of jazz, blues and gospel afforded the saxophone the opportunity to become an integral voice in the newly evolving, Afro-American music. Christopher Costigan was a graduate student at the University of Georgia who wrote his dissertation on the development of the rhythm and blues saxophone style. He claims that an this established genre emerged as a result of localized technical and stylistic innovations in Chicago, New Orleans, Memphis, New York, Cincinnati and the West 70 Ethan Hein, “The Backbeat: A Literature Review,” March 29, 2013, accessed April 3, 2015, http://www.ethanhein.com/wp/2013/the-backbeat-a-literature-review/. 71 Lawn and Hellmer, Jazz Theory and Practice, 154. 72 Ibid., 161. 73 Miller, “Moan Within the Tone,” 158.
  • 58. 45 Coast area.74 Some of the characteristics of the established rhythm and blues saxophone vernacular included extensive use of the blues scale; repetition or prolongation of one note, and the prevalent use of motivic repetition. Repetitive riffs were often played in the high and low registers of the saxophone. This rhythm and blues saxophone style alluded to the Afro-American vocal tradition and was commonly referred to as ‘honking’ or ‘screaming.’75 While illustrating these qualities in the music of Gene Ammons, this paper will draw comparisons to two established rhythm and blues benchmark saxophonists, Jean Baptiste Illinois Jacquet and Wilburt “Red” Prysock. Raised in Houston, Texas, Jacquet epitomized the ‘Texas tenor’ sound and is commonly credited as the first saxophonist to play in the honking and screaming style.76 Arnold Shaw remarked that Jacquet’s “‘Flying Home’ solo served to launch a school of booming, demonstrative, and erotic tenor sax stylists.”77 Red Prysock’s recordings between 1954 and 1957 represent the apex of the rhythm and blues movement. Record producer and engineer Bob Fisher describes Prysock during this period as being “the template perhaps for every for every blasting sax solo on any R&B or rock and roll record you ever heard.”78 Though Young’s light tone contradicts the hot sound of the honkers and screamers, a strong argument could be made that some of the rhythm and blues elements 74 Christopher James Costigan, The Development of the Rhythm and Blues Saxophone Style: An Analytical and Performance Based Study (DMA diss., University of Georgia, 2007), 2, accessed March 4, 2015, https://getd.libs.uga.edu/pdfs/costigan_christopher_j_200712_dma.pdf. 75 Miller, “Moan Within the Tone,” 155. 76 Ibid. 77 Arnold Shaw, Honkers and Shouters (New York, NY: Collier Books, 1978), 173. 78 Bob Fischer, Liner notes from Red Prysock: Hand Clappin’ Foot Stompin’ Rock ‘N’ Roll, Jasmine Records, JASCD 274, CD, 2013.
  • 59. 46 listed above can be traced back to Lester Young. His linear melodic approach, as well as the sporadic de-emphasis of chords resulting from his blanketed pentatonic melodies, is consistent with the blues vocal tradition. Moreover, he was using false or alternate fingerings before the inception of rhythm and blues, as evidenced in his 1939 recording of “Lester Leaps In.” The bebop genre had matured roughly four years before the 1949 christening of the term ‘rhythm and blues,’ and many bebop saxophonists like Sonny Stitt and Dexter Gordon were also synthesizing swing along with rhythm and blues elements into their own playing. Gene Ammons, however, was a Lester Young disciple who had been raised on the boogie-woogie piano stylings of his father. The influence of the great Albert Ammons positioned the younger Ammons to be the champion of this cross- pollination of saxophone styles, alongside rhythm and blues icons Illinois Jacquet and Red Prysock. Use of the Blues Scale Rhythm and blues musicians commonly incorporated use of the blues scale into their vocabulary. Just as Lester Young’s 6/9 common language was an expansion of the major pentatonic scale, the blues scale could be seen as an adaptation of the minor pentatonic scale whose construction normally includes scale degrees 1, !3, 4, 5 and !7. The addition of a ‘blue note,’ the chromatic tone between scale degrees 4 and 5, transforms the pure minor pentatonic scale into the blues scale. Example 5.12 is an excerpt from Illinois Jacquet’s famous solo on “Flying Home,” recorded in 1942 with Lionel Hampton. Here, Jacquet is using the blues scale to
  • 60. 47 blanket the chord changes in mm. 26-28. He begins his idea on B! and moves to D!, the next note in the B! blues scale. Jacquet continues to ascend up the B! blues scale to the next adjacent scale degree in a succession of syncopated upbeats; however, he returns to the B! anchor note between each of the rising scale tones. This oblique motion creates a widening interval between the upper ascending blues scale pitches and the static B! tonic anchor until the arrival of the F on the upbeat of beat 4 in m. 27. Illinois Jacquet’s use of the blues scale in Example 5.12 almost resembles something that Lester Young would have played, but the deliberate substitution of D! (!3) for D (3) in mm. 26 and 28 is a departure from Young’s 6/9 vernacular into the realm of the blues scale. Indeed, Illinois Jacquet with Lionel Hampton in the early 1940s still sounds heavily swing-influenced, even as the rhythm and blues elements in their music are beginning to emerge. Jacquet’s solo on Hampton’s recording of “Flying Home” marked the inception of a transition from swing to the rhythm and blues vernacular. Example 5.12: Illinois Jacquet, “Flying Home,” mm. 26-29 Gene Ammons’ solo on his 1961 recording of “Please Send Me Someone to Love” is highly representative of his blues scale vocabulary. The D7, F7 and D7/F! chords in mm. 34-35 of Example 5.13 all have dominant function in the key of G major. Ammons momentarily transcends the strict rhythm of this medium-slow shuffle,
  • 61. 48 blanketing these chords with a flurry of notes from the G blues scale. The D! as well as the two F"’s played over the D7 chord in m. 34 allay any suspicion that Ammons might be referencing the chord changes. Instead, he is punctuating the end of this 32-bar form with an emotional blues statement. Just before the resolution to the tonic G chord in m. 36, however, Ammons plays a B", momentarily alluding once again to the 6/9 common language. Through this entire example, Ammons’ use of a blanket scale that bypasses the specifics of passing chords is reminiscent of Lester Young. Example 5.13: Gene Ammons, “Please Send Me Someone to Love,” mm. 33-35 In Example 5.14, Ammons ends his solo on “Please Send Me Someone to Love” with another hot-blooded blues statement in the same part of the form as the previous example. This time, however, his blues scale vocabulary starts one measure later in the form over the F7 chord and he maintains his blues language through the resolution at the double bar in m. 69. Again, Ammons seems more concerned with the conveyance of emotion than with acknowledgment of the chord changes. Using a mixture of fragmented compound and simple (duple) rhythms, he creates heightened tension by floating independently over the time up to the resolution at the double bar in m. 69.
  • 62. 49 Example 5.14: Gene Ammons, “Please Send Me Someone to Love,” mm. 67-69 Example 5.15 looks like a combination of the previous two examples. Ammons makes use of blues scale vocabulary in mm. 45-49 as he blankets I, I7, IV, !IVo 7, and back again to I with a G Blues Scale. As in Example 5.14, he makes extensive use of sixteenth-note sextuplet figures while accenting the first, third and fifth note of each sextuplet in mm. 47-48. He wraps up this blues scale statement with a deluge of rapidly descending notes, similar to Example 5.13, finally resolving to a B" on beat 2 of m. 49. Example 5.15: Gene Ammons, “Please Send Me Someone to Love,” mm. 45-49 Prolongation of One Repeated Note In addition to the prevalent use of the blues scale, rhythm and blues saxophonists often engaged in the act of prolonging one note, which could occur for extended durations of time. In fact, it was not uncommon for one note to be played for an entire
  • 63. 50 chorus of the blues, or even longer. These gospel-influenced vocalizations were executed with regularity in the extreme high or low registers of the horn. Saxophonists frequently performed in this way while manipulating false fingerings or using alternative articulation techniques in an effort to achieve subtle pitch or sound variances. The Afro- American musicians were playing in the African vocal style, unconcerned about playing their European instruments in their originally intended manner.79 Example 5.16 demonstrates Illinois Jacquet’s ability to create a great deal of excitement by playing a high B! for almost two entire eight-measure A sections on his seminal recording of “Flying Home” with Lionel Hampton. He stands relentlessly on the tonic B!, consistently re-attacking on the upbeat of 4 and the upbeat of 2. Much in the black preaching style, the delayed gratification inherent in the repeated B! builds excitement and anticipation for the listener. If the F7 chords in Example 5.16 are interpreted as F7sus chords, the repeated B! would be common to all of the chords in this example. However, Jacquet was most likely just emoting from the gut, unconcerned with the chord changes. He is ‘screaming’ on the tonic note (B!), and in doing so, he is preaching to his audience. 79 Miller, Moan Within the Tone, 157.
  • 64. 51 Example 5.16: Illinois Jacquet, “Flying Home,” mm. 33-49 Red Prysock recorded “Blow Your Horn” in 1954, twelve years after Jacquet’s groundbreaking recording of “Flying Home.” Shown in Example 5.17, Prysock reiterates the tonic note for an entire chorus of the blues, breaking rank only once in m. 172 when he plays the A on beat 4. Because the tonic note of C is so easy to manipulate with alternate fingerings on the saxophone, many of these rhythm and blues songs were written in the tenor saxophone key of C (concert B!). Here, Prysock is taking advantage of the opportunity to use alternate fingerings on the repetitive high C. He achieves changes in pitch and tone color by closing all of the right hand keys in the lower stack including the low C key. The points at which Prysock executes this alternate fingering are marked in Example 5.17 with the symbol “0.” Additionally, Prysock growls through his saxophone for this entire passage as well as for the majority of what comes before and after this example. This idea of doing so much with so little can be traced back to Sidney Bechet, who was known for his simple solos containing the effective placement of a few
  • 65. 52 carefully chosen notes, many of which contained sultry bends or other blues inflections.80 By standing on the tonic note for fourteen and a half measures, Red Prysock eliminated any sense of melodic contour in Example 5.17. An argument could be made that, in doing so, he essentially converted the saxophone to a percussion instrument for the duration of this blues chorus. Example 5.17: Red Prysock, “Blow Your Horn,” mm. 168-183 Gene Ammons made extensive use of the one-note prolongation technique, and proof of this manifested itself in his playing throughout his entire career. This is demonstrated below in Example 5.18, an excerpt from Ammons’ 1961 version of “Blues Up and Down” with Sonny Stitt. Ammons plays three phrases over this twelve-bar blues progression, each of which begins with a repeated C. He chooses an alternate fingering 80 Mark C. Gridley, Jazz Styles: History and Analysis, 10th ed., (Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education: 2009), 87.
  • 66. 53 for some of these notes, using the low C fingering with the octave key. This is notated in Example 5.18 using he symbol “+.” The use of these alternate fingerings in mm. 96-97 produces a ‘do-wop’ effect commonly heard in the rhythm and blues style.81 This vocalization device is utilized again to begin the next two phrases in mm. 100-101 and mm. 104-105. Ammons concludes each of the three phrases with an upward leap. Example 5.18: Gene Ammons, “Blues Up and Down” (1961), mm. 96-108 Also from Ammons’ 1961 version of “Blues Up and Down,” Example 5.19 incorporates two sets of alternate fingerings for C. The first, notated as “0,” uses the regular C fingering while adding the three right hand lower stack keys and the low C key. The second alternate fingering, labeled “+,” is the complete low C fingering with the added octave key. Ammons uses the normal fingering for C when playing the accented C’s. He alternates these three fingerings in a sequence: the accented normal fingering, the “0” fingering, and the “+” fingering respectively. This alternation happens over a steady stream of eighth notes in common time, but the notes sound like they are organized in 81 Miller, “Moan Within the Tone,” 161-162.
  • 67. 54 groups of three due to the strategic placement of the accents. The resulting effect is the ‘three against four’ hemiola discussed in Chapter 4. Example 5.19: Gene Ammons, “Blues Up and Down” (1961), mm. 109-120 In mm. 205-208 of the same solo, shown in Example 5.20, Ammons repeats a stream of high C eighth notes using an articulation that involves leaving a portion of the tongue (usually one side of the tongue) on the reed while playing, effectively muting the reed. The reed remains partially muted, while new notes are being articulated. This articulation is often called ‘doodle’ tonguing. Other commonly used names for this technique include half tonguing, sub tonguing, or ‘dooden’ tonguing. The onomatopoeia inherent in the term ‘doodle’ tonguing is the best explanation of this technique, used by saxophonists to achieve subtle variations on one note. The ‘doo-dle’ syllables are notated in Example 5.20 with the letters “D” and “L” respectively.
  • 68. 55 Example 5.20: Gene Ammons, “Blues Up and Down” (1961), mm. 205-209 Example 5.21 shows Gene Ammons and Sonny Stitt trading on a high C for one chorus. This happens after they have both soloed extensively and traded fours. The battling saxophonists are trading high C’s in a ‘call and response’ manner reminiscent of the responsorial interactions between a black gospel preacher and his congregation. Additionally, the falls off each note are executed by dropping the jaw as the note progresses. These falls give their constituent notes a vocal wailing quality, helping to building excitement at the end of their already sensational solos. Example 5.21: Gene Ammons, “Blues Up and Down” (1961), mm. 456-468 In Example 5.22, Ammons and Stitt bring this blowing session to a climax together in the very last chorus. They ratchet up the excitement from the previous chorus (Example 5.21) by speeding up the melodic rhythm of the exchanges, now trading high
  • 69. 56 C’s once per measure with Ammons on beat 1 and Stitt on the upbeat of beat 2. The C’s played by each saxophonist are tinged with a shimmer of brief vibrato in substitution of the falls from the previous chorus, noted above in Example 5.21. Ultimately the dialogue ends, culminating with a melodic dismount played together in unison beginning on the upbeat of beat 4 in m. 478. Example 5.22: Gene Ammons, “Blues Up and Down” (1961), mm. 469-480 Motivic Repetition/Development Along with the use of the blues scale and the prolongation of one note over extended passages of music, saxophonists in the rhythm and blues style also frequently referenced the earlier vocal blues style by reiterating motives or phrases, often developing or adjusting them to fit the harmonic progression. Red Prysock demonstrates this in his 1954 recording of “Blow Your Horn.” In Example 5.23 Prysock repeats the four-note motive that begins in m. 60 and ends on the downbeat of m. 61. With each repetition, the last two notes are adjusted to accommodate the chord changes. The circled target notes are then approached from a half step below.
  • 70. 57 Example 5.23: Red Prysock, “Blow Your Horn,” mm. 60-63 Gene Ammons follows Prysock’s lead and is using the same vocabulary seven years later on “Blues Up and Down,” as shown below in Example 5.24. Again, the ascending target notes are all approached from a half step below. These target notes serve as guide tones that ascend chromatically to the G on the downbeat of m. 124. Ammons includes one extra iteration of the motive, inserted on the upbeat of beat 3 in m. 122 and resolving to the F! on the downbeat of m. 123. In doing so, he extends Prysock’s motivic idea, shown above Example 5.23, by one measure. Example 5.24: Gene Ammons, “Blues Up and Down” (1961), mm. 120-125 Ammons continues improvising in the three-phrase, vocal blues tradition of statement, repeated statement and response in Example 5.25. Phrase A begins on beat 2 of m. 168 and ends on beat four of m. 171. The next four measures are a direct repeat of phrase A. The last four measures of this blues chorus, labeled below as phrase A’, serve as a response to the first two phrases. Inside phrase A’, repetition exists on a micro level
  • 71. 58 with the recurring motive labeled motive X. The three-beat motive, motive X, has an accented beginning and is repeated three times after its initial occurrence. The placement of the accents, combined with the repetition of the three-beat motive, establishes a ‘three against four’ hemiola. This gives phrase A’ a ‘consequent’ feel while concurrently setting up expectations for another chorus of soloing. Example 5.25: Gene Ammons, “Blues Up and Down” (1961), mm. 168-180 Gene Ammons employs the three-phrase, blues vocal structure again in “Blues Up and Down” just one chorus later in Example 5.26. The last note of Example 5.26, held for three measures, is consistent with the style of the ‘honkers’ and ‘screamers.’ That, along with the three-phrase vocal structure, make this example a template for improvisation in the rhythm and blues style.
  • 72. 59 Example 5.26: Gene Ammons, “Blues Up and Down” (1961), mm. 192-204 Elements of Bebop: The Influence of Charlie Parker and Sonny Stitt Elements of swing combined with the rhythm and blues vernacular are pervasive in Gene Ammons’ style. The final ingredient in his vocabulary is his penchant for the bebop (or ‘bop’) language. Historian and author Scott Yanow asserts: Gene Ammons was part of several different musical idioms. His huge sound was a throwback to the Swing Era and his ability to soulfully state ideas (sometimes with just a few notes) fit perfectly in R&B settings, where he was probably the most influential. And yet Ammons could also play bebop with the best of them, holding his own against his pal Sonny Stitt and anyone else in saxophone battles.82 Assuredly, the bebop elements innate in Gene Ammons’ vocabulary can be compared to the language of Charlie Parker or Sonny Stitt, two of the most formidable bebop saxophone players of all time. Charlie Parker, along with trumpeter John Birks 82 Scott Yanow, Bebop (San Francisco, CA: Miller Freeman Books, 2000), 101.
  • 73. 60 “Dizzy” Gillespie, is considered to be a founder of the bebop genre.83 Sonny Stitt was a virtuoso bebop alto saxophonist who collaborated extensively with Gene Ammons over the years. Sometime between 1949 and 1950 Stitt picked up the baritone and tenor saxophones as well, possibly in an effort to step out of the shadow of Charlie Parker.84 Both Parker and Stitt had a tremendous impact on Ammons, the former for pioneering the bebop language and the latter for using it so effectively in close proximity to Ammons. Surround Tones ‘Surround tones’ are also referred to as a ‘neighbor group’ or ‘changing tones.’ These notes can be described as a chord tone’s upper and lower neighbors, the combination of which frame the chord tone. Surround tones may be diatonic or chromatic and are very commonly used in bebop language.85 Example 5.27, excerpted from Jamey Aebersold and Ken Slone’s transcription taken from the Charlie Parker Omnibook86, illustrates two ways in which Parker used surround tones. In m. 41 of this excerpt from Parker’s 1945 recording of “Thriving From a Riff,” the surround tones first appear as individual neighbor tones (first upper, then lower), interspersed between repetitions of the target chord tone, G. On beat 3 of m. 41, however, the two surround tones appear together as a singular modifier for the G that appears on beat 4. The C!’s and the E in m. 42 act as surround tones for their resolution, the D in m. 43. This illustration of a diatonic 83 Lawn, Experiencing Jazz, 199. 84 Owens, Bebop, 47. 85 Lawn and Hellmer, Jazz Theory and Practice, 77. 86 Aebersold and Slone, Charlie Parker Omnibook, 61.
  • 74. 61 upper neighbor and a chromatic lower neighbor in m. 42 is one of the most common combinations of surround tones in the bebop language. Example 5.27: Charlie Parker, “Thriving From a Riff,” mm. 41-43 Evidence can be found of Gene Ammons’ use of surround tones in his earliest recordings. Example 5.28, from Billy Eckstine’s 1944 recording of “Blowing the Blues Away,” documents Ammons surrounding the E’s in m. 47 with D! and F. The third of the chord is surrounded by a half step on both sides. This is another example of a surround- tone figure that includes a diatonic upper neighbor and chromatic lower neighbor. Example 5.28: Gene Ammons, “Blowing the Blues Away,” mm. 46-48 Here in Example 5.29 from “Juggernaut,” recorded in 1950, Ammons takes a chromatic approach to surrounding the root of G7. Neither the A! nor the F! that occur on beat 2 in m. 73 are diatonic to the Dmin7 chord. Nor are they diatonic to the proceeding G7. They can be interpreted as a chromatic, surround-tone anticipation of the target chord tone, G, one beat later.
  • 75. 62 Example 5.29: Gene Ammons, “Juggernaut,” mm. 72-73 In some respects, surround tones can be seen as an avoidance of chord tones, delaying a melodic resolution. At other times, surround tones can be used as melodic fodder to extend a phrase over a chord with slower harmonic rhythm. In any case, surround tones are prevalent in Ammons’ bebop vocabulary. Scalar Versus Arpeggiated Diminished Chords The diminished scale, also known as the octatonic scale, comprises a symmetrical series of alternating whole steps and half steps. Because of the nature of the scale’s construction with respect to its half-step and whole-step relationships, it offers a wide array of sequential patterns.87 Moreover, this scale can be effectively utilized over diminished and dominant chords alike. Improvisers predating the modern jazz era tended to negotiate diminished chords in an arpeggiated manner; however, use of the diminished scale became popular among bebop musicians in the 1950s.88 Example 5.30 is borrowed from Charles McNeal’s transcription of Sonny Stitt from the earlier, 1950 version of “Blues Up and Down,” released on Gene Ammons’ All Star Sessions.89 Here, Sonny Stitt 87 Lawn and Hellmer, Jazz Theory and Practice, 37. 88 Owens, Bebop, 82. 89 Charles McNeal, “Blues Up and Down: Sonny Stitt’s Solo from Gene Ammons’ CD ‘All Star Session with Sonny Stitt’,” Saxopedia, accessed March 8, 2015, http://www.charlesmcneal.com/uploads/- BluesUpAndDown_stitt_.pdf.
  • 76. 63 employs the diminished scale in mm. 16-19 using both adjacent scale tone motion (the interval of a minor second, major second or diminished third) as well as non-adjacent motion (leaps that are a minor third or larger). He effectively blankets all of the chords C7, F7, F!o 7 and C with half-whole version of a C diminished scale, that is to say, the version that starts with the interval of a half step occurring above the root of the scale (spelled C, C!, E!, E, F!, G, A, B!, C). Example 5.30: Sonny Stitt, “Blues Up and Down” (1950), mm. 16-19 Interestingly, Stitt often used the whole-half version of the diminished scale (the other version, with the interval of a whole step occurring above the root of the scale) on tonic as a blanket over the A sections of rhythm changes. Evidence of his whole-half step diminished scale use can be heard on Dizzy Gillespie’s 1957 recording of “Eternal Triangle” which also featured Sonny Stitt and Sonny Rollins. In m. 57 of “Please Send Me Someone to Love,” found below in Example 5.31, Ammons uses diminished scale vocabulary much in the same manner as Stitt’s application in the previous example. The key is G major, and Ammons uses adjacent scalar motion beginning on the second sixteenth note of beat 3 with the F!. Ammons is acknowledging the C!o 7 chord occurring on beats 3 and 4 of m. 57 precisely with the C! whole-half diminished scale. Once Ammons reaches the B! on beat 4, however, he
  • 77. 64 outlines a C!o 7 chord. He overshoots the E (the third of C!o 7) by a whole step, arriving at F! on the upbeat of beat 4. Now the line changes direction resolving downward to the E, which then acts as a passing tone to the arrival of D on the G major chord occurring on the downbeat of m. 58. Example 5.31: Gene Ammons, “Please Send Me Someone to Love,” mm. 57-58 In the same spot of the form one chorus later on “Please Send Me Someone to Love,” Ammons uses the diminished scale again. This time he initiates a sequence starting on beat 3 of m. 89, shown in Example 5.32. From the starting note, this sequence descends by a half step then changes direction, ascending first by a half step to the point of origin and then twice by a whole step to the next scale tone. The saxophonist begins by clearly referencing the C!o 7 as in the previous example; however, he then carries this pattern over into the tonic major chord, becoming the whole-half diminished pattern so often used by Stitt on tunes like his 1957 recording of “Eternal Triangle.” Example 5.32: Gene Ammons, “Please Send Me Someone to Love,” mm. 89-90
  • 78. 65 Double-Time Passages The use of double time was introduced in Chapter 4 as a rhythmic device; however, the melodic construction of double-time passages also merits consideration. With the transition to modern jazz, musicians were required to possess a level of virtuosity on their instruments that went above and beyond the technical demands associated with Swing Era.90 The use of double-time passages is a signature characteristic of bebop, as exemplified in the solos of Charlie Parker.91 Example 5.33, adapted from the Charlie Parker Omnibook, shows a typical double-time passage played by Parker on his 1956 recording of “Blues for Alice.”92 Close inspection of the double-time section in m. 22 reveals that Parker is subjecting some of the aforementioned surround-tone techniques to rhythmic diminution. For example, the D, B and C natural found in beat two of m. 22 are a three-note neighbor group (surround tones) for the C!. The sixteenth notes on beat one of m. 23 all surround the F! on beat two; likewise, the B! and the G on the upbeat of beat two surround the A on beat 3. Example 5.33: Charlie Parker, “Blues for Alice,” mm. 20-23 90 Paul Tanner, David McGill and Maurice Gerow, Jazz, 10th ed. (New York, NY: McGraw-Hill, 2005), 177-178. 91 Ibid., 188. 92 Aebersold and Slone, Charlie Parker Omnibook, 18.
  • 79. 66 In the style of Parker, Gene Ammons also profits from the infusion of double-time passages into his own vocabulary. Example 5.34 illustrates Ammons’ use of double-time techniques over mm. 40-42 in “Juggernaut.” Beat 3 in m. 40 can be interpreted as a four- note neighbor group surrounding the C! on beat 4. Beat 4 is then arpeggiated up to the !9 (also characteristic of bop language). Though the B and two D’s that occur inside beat 4 in m. 41 are diatonic to the G7 chord, they instead serve to surround the target note C, anticipating the CMaj7 chord occurring on beat 1 of m. 42. Chromatic passing tones are found intermingling around and between the surround tone episodes. Example 5.34: Gene Ammons, “Juggernaut,” mm. 39-42 Example 5.35 below is an extension of Example 5.32 above. Here, a mixture of surround tones (bracketed and labeled “ST”) and diminished scalar vocabulary contributes to construct an extended passage of double-time and over-the-time figures at the end of Ammons’ solo on “Please Send Me Someone to Love.” The circled notes represent the melodic points of arrival that are set up by the surround tones.
  • 80. 67 Example 5.35: Gene Ammons, “Please Send Me Someone to Love,” mm. 89-93 Harmonic Devices: Passing Chords Along with the shift from swing to bebop came a harmonic revolution. Players gravitated toward negotiating chord extensions and chord substitutions in the Modern Jazz Era.93 Charlie Parker pushed the harmonic boundaries of the new genre, producing a fresh and innovative template for the preexisting twelve-bar blues form. His new archetype of bebop chord substitutions over what was formerly a very simple chord progression came to be known as ‘Bird Blues,’ and can be seen below in Table 5.1.94 The most familiar Parker composition that uses these chord changes, “Blues for Alice,” is a quintessential example of bebop chord substitutions. 93 Tanner, McGill and Gerow, Jazz, 177-178 94 Lawn and Hellmer, Jazz Theory and Practice, 175.
  • 81. 68 Table 5.1: Chord Changes for ‘Bird Blues’ Fmaj7 m. 1 Emin7 A7(!9) m. 2 Dmin7 G7(!9) m. 3 Cmin7 F7 m. 4 B!maj7 m. 5 B!min7 E!7 m. 6 Amin7 D7 m. 7 A!min7 D!7 m. 8 Gmin7 m. 9 C7(!9) m. 10 Fmaj7 D7 m. 11 Gmin7 C7 m. 12 Diminished Passing Chords Parker’s harmonic sophistication left a lasting impact on Gene Ammons, who incorporated passing chords frequently in his own playing. One harmonic substitution that Ammons used with a degree of frequency was the diminished passing chord. This chord tends to surface routinely in his solos on beats 3 and 4 in the second measure of a twelve-bar blues. In Example 5.36 in the key of C major, Ammons begins his solo using this passing chord straight away in m. 2. On the first two beats of m. 2, he outlines a Dmin chord, giving the listener the impression that he is disregarding the quick IV chord and substituting a ii-V in its place. Instead of going to the V chord on beat 3, however, he shifts up chromatically from D to D!, outlining a D!o triad (!iio ). The whole-half version of the D! diminished scale used over the D!o triad in m. 2 is D!, F, F!, G!/A!, A, B, C and D. The scale tone A! on the upbeat of beat 4 in m. 2 facilitates a smooth transition from the A occurring on the downbeat of beat 4 of the same measure to the G, the fifth of C7, on beat 1 of m. 3.
  • 82. 69 Example 5.36: Gene Ammons, “Blues Up and Down” (1961), mm. 1-5 Example 5.37 of Sonny Stitt soloing on “Blues Up and Down” eleven years earlier is almost identical to Ammons’ version of the diminished passing chord in Example 5.36.95 The implied Dmin chord is set up identically in m. 38 (the second measure of the twelve-bar blues form); however, here Stitt leaps up a fourth on beat 4, overshooting the A by a whole step as he ascends up the D!o arpeggio. In doing so, he reaffirms that diminished chord tones can be approached from a whole step above as well as a half step below the target chord tone. Example 5.37: Sonny Stitt, “Blues Up and Down” (1950), mm. 37-41 Minor Passing Chords: iii7-!iii7 and the Use of Sequences One of the harmonic complexities of Parker’s ‘Bird Blues’ (occurring in mm. 7-8 of the form) that manifests itself in Ammons solos is the iii7-!iii7 substitution for I7 or VI7. This can be prominently heard on the 1961 Ammons/Stitt recording of “Autumn Leaves.” Sometimes, when the harmonic rhythm is subjected to diminution, the iii7-!iii7 95 McNeal, “Blues Up Sonny Stitt”.
  • 83. 70 substitution can happen in one measure with two beats to each chord. This would happen in m. 8 of a twelve-bar blues form, leading into the ii7 normally occurring in bar nine; however, these passing chords can be an effective approach to any predominant ii7 chord. Charlie Parker uses this harmonic substitution in his 1946 recording of “Moose the Mooche.” This is illustrated in Example 5.38, excerpted from the Charlie Parker Omnibook.96 During the third measure of the last A section of this AABA form in G major, Parker employs a sequenced descent from the seventh to the fifth of each chord to serve as the connecting tissue that bridges the distance between m. 57 and m. 59. The seventh of Bmin and B!min can be traced chromatically as guide tones, arriving on the seventh of the Amin chord on beat 1 of m. 59. Example 5.38: Charlie Parker, “Moose the Mooche,” mm. 57-61 Gene Ammons’ use of this harmonic device surfaces early in his career on “St. Louis Blues” and “Red Top,” both from 1947. Because the progression of iii7-!iii7-ii7- V7 in mm. 8-10 of a blues chorus begins with three descending chords of the same quality (parallel minor chords), these three measures offer excellent opportunities for the improviser to apply melodic sequencing. Ammons uses these passing chords frequently as a substitution for VI7 in the ninth measure of a twelve-bar blues; moreover, he 96 Aebersold and Slone, Charlie Parker Omnibook, 5.
  • 84. 71 habitually sequences melodic material when negotiating these passing chords. An early and clear example of this can be seen in m. 38 of his solo on “Red Top,” displayed below in Example 5.39. The tune is in G major and the Bmin-B!min (iii7-!iii7) in m. 38 is the eighth measure of this twelve-bar blues. On beat 1 of m. 38, Ammons plays what is essentially a metered glissando from the seventh of the chord, A, on the downbeat to the chord’s fifth, F!, on the upbeat of 1. The iii7-!iii7 in m. 38 is harmonically similar to Parker’s approach in the previous example; however, the harmonic rhythm is augmented in mm. 39-40 of Example 5.39. The D and the A on beat 2 of m. 38 complete the motive, which is then sequenced down a half step on beats 3 and 4 of the same measure to express the B!min7. Example 5.39: Gene Ammons, “Red Top,” mm. 37-40 Below in Example 5.40, Ammons arpeggiates the iii7 chord from the root, up to the seventh, and back down to the fifth of the chord in m. 187. This is the seventh measure of a blues in C major. As in the previous example, he sequences this arpeggiated chord down a half step. Here, however, Ammons anticipates the Emin7 chord in m. 187 and starts the E!min7 arpeggio two beats early in m. 188, increasing the melodic velocity of the phrase. Simultaneously, there is a sense of rhythmic augmentation/slower
  • 85. 72 harmonic rhythm, as the iii7 chord and the !iii7 chord are each allotted one full measure instead of two beats. Example 5.40: Gene Ammons, “Blues Up and Down” (1961), mm. 187-191 Example 5.42 is taken from Ammons’ 1962 recording of a bossa, entitled “Anna” in G major, and illustrates the saxophonist’s use of passing chords outside of a blues context. The sequences in the previous two examples were ‘real’ sequences, maintaining the intervallic integrity of the original motives being sequenced and containing the requisite chromaticism necessary to accommodate the non-diatonic harmonies. The sequence in m. 53 of Example 5.42, however is one in which both minor passing chords (iii7 and !iii7) comprise a ‘modified’ sequence of the previous measure. The alteration of the sequence on beat 4 in m. 54 to reflect B! min7, the !iii7 tonality, causes this to become a modified sequence.97 Example 5.41: Gene Ammons, “Anna,” mm. 53-55 97 Kostka, Payne and Almén, Tonal Harmony: With an Introduction to Twentieth-Century Music, 7th ed. (New York, NY: McGraw-Hill, 2013), 96-97.
  • 86. 73 The examples shown above in this chapter are representative of saxophone vocabulary in swing, rhythm and blues, and bebop styles. At times, some of the distinctions between these three schools of playing were blurred. Saxophonists that belonged squarely to one genre were still capable of borrowing from the others. That being said, all of the above-mentioned saxophonists that have been compared to Ammons can be easily labeled or compartmentalized based on, among other things, frequently surfacing aspects of their vocabulary. Gene Ammons, however, was so adept at fusing swing, rhythm and blues, and bebop that he is difficult to categorize stylistically. He was a musical polyglot who refused to be pigeonholed or confined to a limited vocabulary, and his ability to synthesize these styles made him accessible to a wider demographic.
  • 87. 74 CHAPTER 6 Conclusion Gene Ammons’ sound and style had a tremendous impact on his colleagues, audiences and future generations of jazz saxophone players. When asked to give advice to younger musicians, Ammons told a reporter, “I would tell them to get a sound. Practice their sound. That’s the most important thing.”98 At a young age, Chicago tenor saxophonist Harold Ousley attempted to imitate the Ammons sound. He obtained a Conn tenor saxophone and a Brilhart Tonalin mouthpiece, knowing that this was the gear that Ammons used.99 Renowned saxophonist Johnny Griffin, who also studied at DuSable High School with Captain Walter Dyett, noted the moment of clarity he had in his youth upon hearing Ammons for the first time. Griffin was still in high school when he saw Ammons play with King Kolax. It was at that moment that Griffin knew he wanted to become a saxophone player.100 Later in 1957, he would find himself performing alongside of both Gene Ammons and Lester Young at the Stage Door and the Crown Propeller Lodge.101 In recent years a saxophonist named Ellery Eskelin paid homage to Ammons by recording an entire album of Ammons’ tunes. Entitled The Sun Died, Eskelin’s recording made the New York Times’ 1996 list of top ten recordings.102 His avant-garde approach to the songs on this album are a melodic departure from the Ammons school; however, Ammons’ influence can be readily identified in Eskelin’s organic and visceral sound. Additionally, the very idea of compounding Gene Ammons’ sound with avant-garde 98 Leo T. Sullivan, “Biography,” Gene Ammons: Legendary Jazz Saxophonist, accessed March 17, 2015, http://www.geneammons.net/biography/. 99 Berliner, Thinking in Jazz, 107. 100 Travis, Autobiography of Black Jazz, 352. 101 Ibid., 360. 102 Ibid.
  • 88. 75 vocabulary (or the lack thereof) is fundamental to Ammons’ concept of playing across styles. In addition to his distinctive composite sound, Ammons had an ability to bring aspects of different performance styles together, blurring the lines of distinction between genres. This ultimately was his formula for success, and his fusion of jazz styles with rhythm and blues resulted in a concept that was in line with the soul jazz movement.103 This funky jazz featured accompaniments with basic, repetitive, and sometimes Latin rhythms combined with melodies that were blues and gospel influenced.104 Likewise, the piano was sometimes replaced by the organ and/or the guitar in soul jazz. Jazz historian Ted Gioia describes Ammons as “a major player, popularizing the ‘soul jazz’ idiom.”105 This claim is evidenced on Ammons’ organ combo recordings of the early 1960s, such as Live! In Chicago and Brother Jack Meets the Boss with organist Jack McDuff. Ammons resumed recording in the soul jazz vein after his ultimate release from Statesville Penitentiary, beginning with The Boss is Back! in 1969 and leading all the way up to his death with Goodbye in 1974. Players like Red Holloway, Willis “Gator Tail” Jackson, David “Fathead” Newman, Stanley Turrentine, Hank Crawford and even Joshua Redman all possess the soul jazz influences gifted to them by Gene Ammons. To the jazz community, Ammons also bequeathed a legacy of dueling tenor saxophonists operating in the ‘tenor battle’ format. Billy Eckstine’s 1944 recording of “Blowing the Blues Away” features Gene Ammons and Dexter Gordon engaging in what 103 David H. Rosenthal, Hard Bop: Jazz and Black Music 1955-1965 (New York: Oxford University Press, 1992), 65-66. 104 Gridley, Jazz Styles, 229. 105 Ted Gioia, The History of Jazz (New York: Oxford University Press, 2011), 243.
  • 89. 76 is the first famous recording of a tenor battle.106 Lester Young and Herschel Evans had previously become famous for their on-stage tenor rivalries; however, they infrequently soloed on the same piece and, when they did, their solos were deliberately spaced far apart.107 For example, on Count Basie’s 1938 recording of “Georgianna,” the solos played by Herschel Evans and Lester Young are separated by one minute and twenty seconds of vocals and ensemble playing. In contrast, Ammons and Gordon are locked in heated musical dispute while trading choruses and four-measure sections (‘trading fours’) on “Blowing the Blues Away.” Following in the tradition of “Blowing the Blues Away,” Ammons continued formalizing the tradition of the tenor battle with his quintet, co-led by Sonny Stitt.108 A paragon example of the Ammons/Stitt tenor battles is the 1961 recording of “Blues Up and Down” from Boss Tenors. Kenny Mathieson goes so far as to say that Boss Tenors could be seen as a template for the twin tenor format.109 In the spirit of Ammons and Stitt, a large number of saxophonists have paired up in an attempt to exploit the dueling tenor format. The most notable of these paired saxophonists include Johnny Griffin and Eddie “Lockjaw” Davis, Dexter Gordon and Wardell Gray, David “Fathead” Newman and Stanley Turrentine, and even Michael Brecker and Bob Mintzer. The study of Gene Ammons is an expansion of knowledge in many other broad areas, such as the rhythmic and lyrical qualities of African music; the evolution of the 106 Morgenstern, Living with Jazz, 230. 107 Schuller, The Swing Era, 550. 108 Kernfeld, “Ammons, Gene”. 109 Mathieson, Cookin’, 225-226.
  • 90. 77 backbeat in blues, jazz, and rhythm and blues; and an in-depth study of Coleman Hawkins and Lester Young. While each of the individual timbral, rhythmic, melodic and harmonic devices discussed in this paper can be traced back to earlier sources, the sum of these characteristics produced a sound that was unique to Gene Ammons. He carefully molded his style so as to remain versatile in a musical climate that was evolving in multiple directions and at an ever-increasing rate; furthermore, his multipurpose saxophone concept manifested itself in the form of high record sales, even during his nine years in prison. Indeed, Bob Weinstock said that Ammons was the top-selling recording artist for Prestige Records, outselling Miles Davis by far. Weinstock attributes the saxophonist’s success to his ability to appeal to jazz listeners and rhythm and blues fans alike.110 Bob Weinstock’s statements underscore the fact that, at times, an element of disconnect exists between the critics and the listeners. Even though Gene Ammons has been largely overlooked by jazz critics and historians, his influence is an undercurrent that has been felt far and wide by saxophonists and music appreciators of then and now. The lessons taught by Ammons go above and beyond the notes he played. He taught us that stylistic diversification is an excellent business model for the working saxophonist. He taught us that the notes are only as important as their delivery. He taught us to be true to our convictions, regardless of what the critics think. 110 Wilson, “Gene Ammons: ‘The Jug’”.
  • 91. 78 APPENDIX A Complete Solo Transcriptions of Gene Ammons
  • 92. 79
  • 93. 80
  • 94. 81
  • 95. 82
  • 96. 83
  • 97. 84
  • 98. 85
  • 99. 86
  • 100. 87
  • 101. 88
  • 102. 89
  • 103. 90
  • 104. 91
  • 105. 92
  • 106. 93
  • 107. 94
  • 108. 95
  • 109. 96
  • 110. 97
  • 111. 98
  • 112. 99
  • 113. 100
  • 114. 101
  • 115. 102 APPENDIX B Solo Transcriptions of Lester Young, Illinois Jacquet and Red Prysock Completed in a Comparative Study of Gene Ammons
  • 116. 103
  • 117. 104
  • 118. 105
  • 119. 106
  • 120. 107
  • 121. 108
  • 122. 109
  • 123. 110
  • 124. 111
  • 125. 112
  • 126. 113
  • 127. 114
  • 128. 115
  • 129. 116 BIBLIOGRAPHY Aebersold, Jamey, and Ken Slone. Charlie Parker Omnibook: For Eb Instruments, Transcribed Exactly From His Recorded Solos. Lynbrook, NY: Atlantic Music Corp., 1978. Alexander, Geoff. “Black Preaching Styles.” Academic Film Archive of North America. Last modified December 10, 1986. Accessed April 28, 2015. http://www.afana.org/preaching.htm Atterton, Jeff, and Leonard Feather. "America: Jazz." Melody Maker. London: Time, Inc., August 15, 1970. Berliner, Paul F. Thinking in Jazz: The Infinite Art of Improvisation. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1994. Black, Timuel D., Jr. Bridges of Memory: Chicago's First Wave of Black Migration. Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press, 2003. Black, Timuel D., Jr. Bridges of Memory: Chicago's Second Generation of Black Migration. Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press, 2007. Blumenthal, Bob. "Chapter 6: Bebop and Modern Jazz." In Discover Jazz, by John Edward Hasse and Tad Lathrop. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education, Inc., 2012. Campbell, Robert L., Armin Büttner, and Robert Pruter. “The King Kolax Discography.” Clemson University. Last modified August 20, 2013. Accessed February 15, 2015. http://myweb.clemson.edu/~campber/kolax.html Charlton, Katherine. Rock Music Styles: A History. 5th Edition. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill, 2008. Costigan, Christopher James. “The Development of the Rhythm and Blues Saxophone Style: An Analytical and Performance Based Study.” DMA diss., University of Georgia, 2007. Accessed March 18, 2015. https://getd.libs.uga.edu/pdfs/costigan _christopher_j_200712_dma.pdf. Crawford, Richard. An Introduction to America’s Music. New York, NY: W.W. Norton and Company, 2001. Davis, Miles, and Quincy Troupe. Miles: The Autobiography. New York, NY: Simon and Schuster, 1989.
  • 130. 117 Discogs. “Gene Ammons Discography.” Last modified 2015. Accessed February 24, 2015. http://www.discogs.com/artist/45107-Gene-Ammons. Enright, Ed. "Gene Ammons: Ultimate Redemption." Down Beat. August 1, 2012. Accessed January 31, 2015. http://www.downbeat.com/default.asp?sect=stories &subsect=story_detail&sid=1125. Fischer, Bob. Liner notes to Red Prysock: Handclappin' Footstompin' Rock 'N' Roll. Red Prysock. Jasmine Records JASCD 274 MONO. CD. 2013. Ginell, Cary. Mr. B: The Music and Life of Billy Eckstine. Milwaukee, WI: Hal Leonard Books, 2013. Gioia, Ted. The History of Jazz. New York: Oxford University Press, 2011. Gridley, Mark. C. Jazz Styles: History and Analysis. 10th Ed. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education. Hein, Ethan. “The Backbeat: A Literature Review.” The Ethan Hein Blog. March 29, 2013. Accessed April 3, 2015. http://www.ethanhein.com/wp/2013/the-backbeat- a-literature-review/. Jazz Discography Project. “Gene Ammons Catalog.” Jazz Discography Project. Last modified July 26, 2001. Accessed March 19, 2015. http://www.jazzdisco.org/ gene-ammons/catalog. Kernfeld, Barry. “Ammons, Gene.” American Council of Learned Societies. Last modified February 2000. Accessed February 11, 2015. http://www.anb.org. ezproxy.lib.utexas.edu/articles/18/18-02717.html. Kostka, Stefan, Dorothy Payne, and Byron Almén. Tonal Harmony: With an Introduction to Twentieth Century Music. 7th Edition. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill, 2013. Lauterbach, Preston. The Chitlin' Circuit: And the Road to Rock 'n' Roll. New York: W.W. Norton and Company, 2011. Lawn, Richard J. Experiencing Jazz. 2nd Edition. New York, NY: Routledge, 2013. Lawn, Richard J., and Jeffrey L. Hellmer. Jazz: Theory and Practice. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Publishing Company, 1993. Liebman, Dave. “Jazz Rhythm.” Daveliebman.com. Last modified 2009. Accessed March 15, 2015. http://www.daveliebman.com/Feature_Articles/JazzRhythm.htm.
  • 131. 118 Mathieson, Kenny. Cookin': Hard Bop and Soul Jazz, 1954-65. Edinburgh: Canongate Books, 2002. McNeal, Charles. "Blues Up and Down: Sonny Stitt's Solo from Gene Ammons' CD 'All Star Session with Sonny Stit'." Saxopedia. Accessed March 8, 2015. http://www. charlesmcneal.com/uploads/-BluesUpAndDown_stitt_.pdf. Miller, Doug. "The Moan Within the Tone: African Retentions in Rhythm and Blues Saxophone Style in Afro-American Popular Music." Popular Music 14, no. 2 (May 1995): 155-174. Accessed February 16, 2014. http://www.jstor.org/stable/ 853397. Morgenstern, Dan. Living with Jazz. New York: Pantheon Books, 2004. Morrison, Nick. "Soul Jazz: Where Jazz, Blues and Gospel Meet." Take Five: A Jazz Sampler. Prod. National Public Radio. January 4, 2010. Owens, Thomas. Bebop: The Music and Its Players. New York, NY: Oxford University Press, 1995. Porter, Bob. Lester Young. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press, 2005. Richards, Tim and John Crawford. Exploring Latin Piano: South-American/Cuban/and Spanish Rhythms for the Intermediate Pianist. London: Schott Music Ltd., 2011. Rosenthal, David H. Hard Bop: Jazz and Black Music 1955-1965. New York: Oxford University Press, 1992. Schuller, Gunther. Early Jazz: Its Roots and Musical Development. New York: Oxford University Press, 1969. –––. The Swing Era. New York: Oxford University Press, 1989. Shaw, Arnold. Honkers and Shouters: The Golden Years of Rhythm and Blues. New York, NY: Collier Books, 1978. Simpson, David. “Lester Young: An American Original.” Jazz Institute of Chicago. Last modified 2003. Accessed March 1, 2015. http://www.jazzinchicago.org/educates/ journal/articles/lester-young-american-original. Sullivan, Leo T. “Biography.” Gene Ammons: Legendary Jazz Saxophonist. Accessed March 17, 2015. http://www.geneammons.net/biography.
  • 132. 119 Tanner, Paul, David McGill, and Maurice Gerow. Jazz. 10th Edition. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill, 2005. Thomas, Pete. “Subtone.” Taming the Saxophone. 2014. Accessed April 3, 2015. http://tamingthesaxophone.com/saxophone-subtone. Travis, Dempsey J. An Autobiography of Black Jazz. 1st Edition. Chicago, IL: Urban Research Institute, Inc., 1983. Turek, Ralph. Theory for Today’s Musician. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill, 2007. Twomey, John. “Biography.” Stan Getz- 'The Sound': Pioneer of Cool, Bossa Nova and Modern Jazz. 2004. Accessed February 23, 2015. http://www.stangetz.net/bio. html. Walker, Bruce. “Gene Ammons Biography.” Index of Musician Biographies. 2015. Accessed February 22, 2015. http://www.musicianguide.com/biographies/ 1608003392/Gene-Ammons.html. Walser, Robert. "The Rock and Roll Era." In The Cambridge History of American Music, edited by David Nicholls. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1998. Wang, Richard. “Captain Walter Dyett.” Chicago Jazz Magazine. Last modified May 27, 2008. Accessed April 9, 2014. http://www.chicagojazz.com/thescene/captain- walter-dyett-86.html. Wilson, Nancy. "Gene Ammons: The 'Jug'." Jazz Profiles. Prod. National Public Radio. February 20, 2008. Accessed March 18, 2014. http://www.npr.org/2008/02/20/ 19172123/gene-ammons-the-jug. Yanow, Scott. Bebop. San Francisco, CA: Miller Freeman Books, 2000.
  • 133. 120 SELECTED DISCOGRAPHY Ammons, Gene. Jug Sessions. EmArcy, 1947. Ammons, Gene. Red Top. Savoy, 1947. Ammons, Gene. Early Visions. Chess, 1948. Ammons, Gene. Young Jug. Chess, 1948. Ammons, Gene. Soulful Saxophone of Gene Ammons. Chess, 1948. Ammons, Gene. Gene Ammons All Star Sessions. Prestige, 1950. Ammons, Gene. Blues Up and Down, Vol. 1. Prestige, 1950. Ammons, Gene. Golden Saxophone. Savoy, 1952. Ammons, Gene. Sock!. Prestige, 1955. Ammons, Gene. Juganthology. Prestige, 1955. Ammons, Gene. The Happy Blues. Prestige, 1956. Ammons, Gene. Jammin’ with Gene. Prestige, 1956. Ammons, Gene. Funky. Original Jazz, 1957. Ammons, Gene. Jammin’ in Hi Fi with Gene Ammons. Prestige, 1957. Ammons, Gene. Groove Blues. Prestige, 1958. Ammons, Gene. Blue Gene. Original Jazz, 1958. Ammons, Gene. The Gene Ammons Story: Organ Combos. Prestige, 1958. Ammons, Gene. The Gene Ammons Story: Gentle Jug. Prestige, 1961. Ammons, Gene. Boss Tenor. Prestige, 1960. Ammons, Gene. Angel Eyes. Prestige, 1960. Ammons, Gene. Late Hour Special. Original Jazz, 1961.
  • 134. 121 Ammons, Gene and Sonny Stitt. We’ll Be Together Again. Prestige, 1961. Ammons, Gene and Sonny Stitt. Boss Tenors: Straight Ahead from Chicago, 1961. Verve, 1961. Ammons, Gene. Live! In Chicago. Prestige, 1961. Ammons, Gene. Boss Soul. Prestige, 1961. Ammons, Gene. Up Tight!. Prestige, 1961. Ammons, Gene. Twistin’ the Jug. Prestige, 1961. Ammons, Gene. Blue Groove. Prestige, 1962. Ammons, Gene. Preachin’. Prestige, 1962. Ammons, Gene. Jug and Dodo. Prestige, 1962 Ammons, Gene. Jungle Soul. Prestige, 1962. Ammons, Gene. Bad! Bossa Nova. Original Jazz, 1962. Ammons, Gene. Brother Jug. Prestige, 1969. Ammons, Gene. The Boss is Back!. Prestige, 1969. Ammons, Gene. Night Lights. Prestige, 1970. Ammons, Gene. The Chase. Prestige, 1970. Ammons, Gene. Black Cat. Prestige, 1970. Ammons, Gene and Sonny Stitt. Together Again for the Last Time. Prestige, 1973. Ammons, Gene. Goodbye. Prestige, 1974. Ammons, Albert. Blues and Boogie-Woogie King. Jazz Archives No. 125, 1998. Ammons, Gene. God Bless Jug and Sonny. Prestige 2001. Eckstine, Billy. The Legendary Big Band. Savoy, 2002.
  • 135. 122 Joseph Colarusso 2704 Dryden St. Austin, TX 78748 josephcc@stedwards.edu (512) 789-1387 Education Doctor of Musical Arts: Performance with Jazz Emphasis, in progress, The University of Texas at Austin Master of Music: Jazz Studies, 2003, The University of Texas at Austin Bachelor of Music: Applied Saxophone, 1996, The University of Texas at Austin Training Principal Teachers Saxophones Harvey Pittel Bass clarinet Harvey Pittel Clarinet Richard MacDowell Flute/ Piccolo Beth Whitten Trumpet Rick White Jazz Theory/ Improvisation Richard Lawn/ John Mills Professional Teaching Experience St. Edward’s University, Austin, TX (2006-present) • Coordinator of Instrumental Music • Director of the St. Edward’s University Jazz Ensembles • Director of the St. Edward’s University Mariachi Alas de Oro • Applied Woodwinds Instructor • Music Theory Lecturer Prairie View A&M University, Prairie View, TX (2004-2009) • Adjunct Professor of Saxophone and Clarinet • Lecturer for Music in Contemporary Life
  • 136. 123 Round Rock ISD, Round Rock, TX (1994-2006) • Private Saxophone, Flute, and Clarinet Instructor at Grisham Middle School, Chisholm Trail Middle School, Cedar Valley Middle School, Stony Point High School and Round Rock High School. • Director of the Chisholm Trail Middle School Jazz Ensemble. The University of Texas at Austin, Austin, TX (2001-2003) • Teaching Assistant for Harvey Pittel- taught applied saxophone lessons to undergraduate saxophonists. • Teaching Assistant for the Jazz Studies Department- coached jazz combos on theory, performance, and improvisation styles. Pflugerville ISD, Pflugerville, TX (1995-2001) • Private Saxophone and Bass Clarinet Instructor at Westview Middle School, Pflugerville Middle School, Pflugerville High School, and Connally High School. Publications Steady- Jazz From the Carriage House (2012) The St. Edward’s University Jazz Ensemble’s second CD, available at http://think.stedwards.edu/musicalperformances/discography. Mariachi Alas de Oro- El Primer (2010) The St. Edward’s University Mariachi Ensemble’s first CD, available at http://think.stedwards.edu/musicalperformances/discography. Steady- Snapshot- In the Beginning (2006) The St. Edward’s University Jazz Ensemble’s first CD, available at http://think.stedwards.edu/musicalperformances/discography. McGraw Hill Higher Education (2006) Developed a website for my Music in Contemporary Life lecture class at Prairie View A&M University. It can be viewed at www.jocal.pageout.net. Awards and Honors State Bar of Texas-LRE, Austin, TX (2006, 2007, 2009) Was commissioned by the Law-Related Education department of the Texas State Bar Association to lecture on American music history at the 2006, 2007 and 2009 State Bar Conventions. I recommended texts that have now been adopted by the State of Texas as a part of the middle and high school American history curriculum.
  • 137. 124 Phi Mu Alpha Sinfonia, Prairie View, TX (2006) Was inducted into the Omicron Zeta chapter of the national music fraternity Phi Mu Alpha as an honorary member by the students at Prairie View A&M University. Region 18 Jazz Band, Austin, TX (2002) Clinician and conductor for the All Region Jazz Band. Professional Affiliations Phi Mu Alpha Sinfonia Jazz Education Network Performance Experience Classical Austin Symphony Orchestra Austin Lyric Opera University of Texas Wind Ensemble University of Texas Symphony University of Texas Saxophone Choir Austin Saxophone Quartet Nova Saxophone Quartet Harvey Pittel Donald Sinta Jazz Bob Brookmeyer Joshua Redman Mike Stern Eddie Daniels Maria Schneider The Tony Campisi Big Band Creative Opportunity Orchestra Ed Shaughnessy University of Texas Jazz Orchestra St. Edward’s University Jazz Ensemble John Mills Times Ten Manhattan Transfer The Stardust Orchestra Dimensions in Blue (Lackland Air Force Base, San Antonio, TX) Monster Big Band Frank Sinatra, Jr. Natalie Cole Carmen Bradford
  • 138. 125 Commercial The Temptations Frankie Valli Olivia Newton John 10,000 Maniacs The Guy Lombardo Orchestra Kenny Rogers Asleep at the Wheel Michael Feinstein Tommy Tune Marvin Hamlisch Gino Vannelli Linda Eder Archie Bell and the Drells Julie Budd Aretha Franklin Dale Watson Rick Treviño Charlie Sexton Johnny Gimble Bernadette Peters W.C. Clark Extreme Heat Debby Boone Musical Theater Austin Musical Theater Broadway Texas University of Texas Department of Theater and Dance Zilker Hillside Theater Zachary Scott Theater Mariachi Mariachi Alas de Oro Mariachi Cielo de Austin