SlideShare a Scribd company logo
The 3-2-1 rule
Mike Resseler
Product Strategist
| @mikeresseler | @veeamMike.Resseler@Veeam.com
Agenda
Why?
Why are we talking about this?
© 2015 Veeam Software. All rights reserved. All trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
Business Requirements
More
applications and
services faster
Lower
IT cost
Enable the
Always-On business
Modern Data Center
Virtualization Modern
storage
Cloud
Access from any place
any device
More and
better IT
services
Lower IT costs
1
Enable the
Always-On business
Modern Data Center
Lower operational
costs
Provision IT
services faster
Strengthen security
and control
More
applications and
services faster
Lower
IT cost
Enable the
Always-On business
Modern Data Center
Virtualization Modern storage Cloud
Lower operational
costs
Provision IT
services faster
Strengthen security
and control
More
applications and
services faster
Lower
IT cost
Enable the
Always-On business
Modern Data Center
Virtualization Modern storage Cloud
24/7 operations
No patience for
downtime and data loss
Growing amount
of data
Enable the Always-On BusinessTM
The 3-2-1 Rule
What is it?
History
• As far as we know it...
• Invented by Peter Krogh (photographer: dpbestflow.org/node/262)
There are two kinds of people in the world –
those who have had a hard drive failure,
and those who will
The 3-2-1 Rule
*Yes, technically “the cloud” is probably using a harddisk too
Three copies
One copy offsite
Two media types*
The 3-2-1 Rule
3 Copies
You need (at least) 3 copies of your data
2 Different Media
The data should be stored at least at 2 different media
1 Offsite
1 of the copies should be offsite
3 Copies
Choices
Production
storage
Different Media
Choices
Primary storage Primary storage
Backup storage
Offsite
Tape
• Best price per GB
• Does not consume power to be
stored
• Requires manual activities to be
sent offsite
• Restores are not satisfying for
demanding RTO
Remote Site
• All in the hands of the owner
• Disk based
• Staff needs to maintain two sites
• Capital expenses for building and
hardware rarely used
Co-location
• Same benefits as an owned remote site
• Rental of the “building”
• Again, staff need to maintain two sites
• Capital expenses for hardware that is
rarely used
“Cloud”
• No expense for building or hardware
• “Pay-as-you-go” model
• Reduce the complexity
• Seed and collect services for large
transfers
• Upload /Download
• What happens with your data
• RTO might be slow
Layers
Layers & Possibilities
• One solution fits all?
• Multiple layers is a better defense
• Why stop at 3-2-1?
• Think further
Tiered approach
• Sum the benefits
of different tiers
• Neutralize the limits
of each tier
• Statistics are your best friends
• Most of the restores come
from recent restore points
• Focus on your RTO, but design
around only the First Tier
of your data protection strategy
“Files are rarely re-opened. Over
66% are re-opened once and 95%
fewer than five times”
“Files re-opens are temporally
related.Over 60% of re-opens occur
within a minute of the first.”
Measurement and Analysis of Large-Scale Network File System Workloads
Andrew W. Leung, Shankar Pasupathy, Garth Goodson, Ethan L. Miller, 2008
Tier- (-1): Application protection
• Single point of failure (if the app fails…)
• Consume production storage (but limited)
• Leverages the application
• No impact on the hypervisor
• Fast restores!
• Possibly user restore possibilities
#1 GOAL: First defense starts within the application. E.g. SharePoint
deleted items & versioning, Email deleted items, AD deleted items, SQL
Log transaction…
Tier-0: Storage snapshots
• Single point of failure (inside the same storage
they protect)
• Consume precious production storage
• No application consistency (or hard to have)
• A volume contains multiple VMs
• Leverage performance of the storage
• Low impact on the hypervisor
• Fast restores! Content is non deduplicated
• With Veeam you can add application
consistency
#1 GOAL: High-frequency copies with low impact on production
Tier-1: Small and fast JBOD
• Hold few restore points
• The vast majority of restores come
from the last week
• A proper server with Windows or
Linux (runs Veeam Datamover locally)
• Multicore CPU and good amount
of RAM
• Local disks or DAS
• Mix SSD and HDD
#1 GOAL: Offer fast restores!!!
Tier-2: Large and cheap disk storage
Still local and on disk to allow decent RPO and RTO
Any disk solution with low $/GB
• SAN
• Deduplication appliance
• NAS
• Software solutions
• …
#1 GOAL: Extend retention period
Tier-3: Offsite archival
Can be added after Tier-2 or directly after Tier-1
#1 GOAL: Extend retention AND offer offsite protection
Tape
• Require manual activities to go
offsite
• Large amount of data can be moved
on restores
“Cloud”
• Directly reachable via Internet connection
• A dumb storage space or an active
component?
• Remote compute power allows direct
restores from cloud repositories
Overall design
Tier-0: Storage snapshots
Tier-1: Small and fast JBOD
Tier-2: Large and cheap disk storage
Tier-3: Offsite archival
I have a dream…
Production
storage
I have a dream…
Q&A
Thank you!

More Related Content

PPT
EarthLink Business Cloud Server Backup
PPTX
Uncovering the Cloud: Is it Right for You? - Marco
PPTX
Citrix XenDesktop: Dealing with Failure - SYN408
PPTX
The Next Generation of Hyperconverged Infrastructure - Cisco
PPTX
Webinar: Five Problems Facing Business-Critical NFS Deployments
PPTX
3 migration
PDF
Dana Quinn Velocity Keynote
PPTX
Optimal Azure Database Development by Karel Coenye
EarthLink Business Cloud Server Backup
Uncovering the Cloud: Is it Right for You? - Marco
Citrix XenDesktop: Dealing with Failure - SYN408
The Next Generation of Hyperconverged Infrastructure - Cisco
Webinar: Five Problems Facing Business-Critical NFS Deployments
3 migration
Dana Quinn Velocity Keynote
Optimal Azure Database Development by Karel Coenye

What's hot (20)

PPTX
Virtualization
PPTX
MGT3342BUS - Architecting Data Protection with Rubrik - VMworld 2017
PPTX
Why containers are the competitive advantage your business needs
PDF
VMworld 2013: VMware NSX: A Customer’s Perspective
PPTX
Capacity - Ransomware - Protection - Three Windows File Server Upgrades to Avoid
PDF
Unlocking the Full Power of Your Backup Data with Veritas NetBackup Data Virt...
PDF
VMworld 2013: Separating Cloud Hype from Reality in Healthcare – a Real-Life ...
PPT
Virtualization for competitive advantage - Eric Vanderburg
PPTX
Hosting facilities for companies
PPTX
Five things virtualization has changed in your dr plan
PPTX
Scaling apps for the big time
PPTX
Financial Modeling for HCI/Cloud
PDF
Hyperconverged Infrastructure: The Leading Edge of Virtualization
PDF
Hyper Converged Systems
PPTX
DR in the Cloud: Finding the Right Tool for the Job
PPTX
Modern Cloud Fundamentals: Misconceptions and Industry Trends
PDF
How to Migrate to Cloud with Complete Confidence and Trust
PPTX
Cloud Technology Brief 2013 Q1 - Thailand
PDF
Experiencing the hyperconverged
PPTX
Evaluating the Cloud
Virtualization
MGT3342BUS - Architecting Data Protection with Rubrik - VMworld 2017
Why containers are the competitive advantage your business needs
VMworld 2013: VMware NSX: A Customer’s Perspective
Capacity - Ransomware - Protection - Three Windows File Server Upgrades to Avoid
Unlocking the Full Power of Your Backup Data with Veritas NetBackup Data Virt...
VMworld 2013: Separating Cloud Hype from Reality in Healthcare – a Real-Life ...
Virtualization for competitive advantage - Eric Vanderburg
Hosting facilities for companies
Five things virtualization has changed in your dr plan
Scaling apps for the big time
Financial Modeling for HCI/Cloud
Hyperconverged Infrastructure: The Leading Edge of Virtualization
Hyper Converged Systems
DR in the Cloud: Finding the Right Tool for the Job
Modern Cloud Fundamentals: Misconceptions and Industry Trends
How to Migrate to Cloud with Complete Confidence and Trust
Cloud Technology Brief 2013 Q1 - Thailand
Experiencing the hyperconverged
Evaluating the Cloud
Ad

Similar to E2 evc 3-2-1-rule - mikeresseler (20)

PDF
Houd controle over uw data
PPTX
Back-ups: Hoe ze je kunnen redden van een cyberaanval
PPT
EMC IT's Best Practices
PDF
Managed Data Services
PDF
Managed Data Services
PDF
Managed Data Services
PPTX
Webinar: Making The Always-On Data Center A Reality
PDF
Managed Data Services
PDF
Managed Data Services
PPTX
Managing storage on Prem and in Cloud
PPTX
Designing Effective Storage Strategies to Meet Business Needs
PPTX
Designing Effective Storage Strategies to Meet Business Needs
PDF
AWS User Group October
PDF
Generic RLM White Paper
PDF
Storage for Microsoft®Windows Enfironments
PPTX
The 5 Keys to Virtual Backup Excellence
PPTX
The 5 Keys To Virtual Backup Excellence Exa Grid And Veeam October 25 2012
PDF
Veeam-backup-storage-best-practices-v12.1.pdf
PPT
CDW: SAN vs. NAS
Houd controle over uw data
Back-ups: Hoe ze je kunnen redden van een cyberaanval
EMC IT's Best Practices
Managed Data Services
Managed Data Services
Managed Data Services
Webinar: Making The Always-On Data Center A Reality
Managed Data Services
Managed Data Services
Managing storage on Prem and in Cloud
Designing Effective Storage Strategies to Meet Business Needs
Designing Effective Storage Strategies to Meet Business Needs
AWS User Group October
Generic RLM White Paper
Storage for Microsoft®Windows Enfironments
The 5 Keys to Virtual Backup Excellence
The 5 Keys To Virtual Backup Excellence Exa Grid And Veeam October 25 2012
Veeam-backup-storage-best-practices-v12.1.pdf
CDW: SAN vs. NAS
Ad

Recently uploaded (20)

PPTX
Big Data Technologies - Introduction.pptx
PDF
Encapsulation theory and applications.pdf
PDF
Electronic commerce courselecture one. Pdf
PPTX
KOM of Painting work and Equipment Insulation REV00 update 25-dec.pptx
PPTX
Understanding_Digital_Forensics_Presentation.pptx
PPTX
Cloud computing and distributed systems.
PDF
Reach Out and Touch Someone: Haptics and Empathic Computing
PDF
NewMind AI Monthly Chronicles - July 2025
PDF
How UI/UX Design Impacts User Retention in Mobile Apps.pdf
PDF
Per capita expenditure prediction using model stacking based on satellite ima...
DOCX
The AUB Centre for AI in Media Proposal.docx
PPTX
Effective Security Operations Center (SOC) A Modern, Strategic, and Threat-In...
PDF
Architecting across the Boundaries of two Complex Domains - Healthcare & Tech...
PPTX
A Presentation on Artificial Intelligence
PDF
Mobile App Security Testing_ A Comprehensive Guide.pdf
PDF
Unlocking AI with Model Context Protocol (MCP)
PPTX
Detection-First SIEM: Rule Types, Dashboards, and Threat-Informed Strategy
PPT
“AI and Expert System Decision Support & Business Intelligence Systems”
PPTX
20250228 LYD VKU AI Blended-Learning.pptx
PDF
KodekX | Application Modernization Development
Big Data Technologies - Introduction.pptx
Encapsulation theory and applications.pdf
Electronic commerce courselecture one. Pdf
KOM of Painting work and Equipment Insulation REV00 update 25-dec.pptx
Understanding_Digital_Forensics_Presentation.pptx
Cloud computing and distributed systems.
Reach Out and Touch Someone: Haptics and Empathic Computing
NewMind AI Monthly Chronicles - July 2025
How UI/UX Design Impacts User Retention in Mobile Apps.pdf
Per capita expenditure prediction using model stacking based on satellite ima...
The AUB Centre for AI in Media Proposal.docx
Effective Security Operations Center (SOC) A Modern, Strategic, and Threat-In...
Architecting across the Boundaries of two Complex Domains - Healthcare & Tech...
A Presentation on Artificial Intelligence
Mobile App Security Testing_ A Comprehensive Guide.pdf
Unlocking AI with Model Context Protocol (MCP)
Detection-First SIEM: Rule Types, Dashboards, and Threat-Informed Strategy
“AI and Expert System Decision Support & Business Intelligence Systems”
20250228 LYD VKU AI Blended-Learning.pptx
KodekX | Application Modernization Development

E2 evc 3-2-1-rule - mikeresseler

  • 1. The 3-2-1 rule Mike Resseler Product Strategist | @mikeresseler | @veeamMike.Resseler@Veeam.com
  • 4. Why are we talking about this? © 2015 Veeam Software. All rights reserved. All trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
  • 5. Business Requirements More applications and services faster Lower IT cost Enable the Always-On business Modern Data Center Virtualization Modern storage Cloud Access from any place any device More and better IT services Lower IT costs 1
  • 6. Enable the Always-On business Modern Data Center Lower operational costs Provision IT services faster Strengthen security and control
  • 7. More applications and services faster Lower IT cost Enable the Always-On business Modern Data Center Virtualization Modern storage Cloud Lower operational costs Provision IT services faster Strengthen security and control
  • 8. More applications and services faster Lower IT cost Enable the Always-On business Modern Data Center Virtualization Modern storage Cloud 24/7 operations No patience for downtime and data loss Growing amount of data Enable the Always-On BusinessTM The 3-2-1 Rule
  • 10. History • As far as we know it... • Invented by Peter Krogh (photographer: dpbestflow.org/node/262) There are two kinds of people in the world – those who have had a hard drive failure, and those who will
  • 11. The 3-2-1 Rule *Yes, technically “the cloud” is probably using a harddisk too Three copies One copy offsite Two media types*
  • 13. 3 Copies You need (at least) 3 copies of your data
  • 14. 2 Different Media The data should be stored at least at 2 different media
  • 15. 1 Offsite 1 of the copies should be offsite
  • 19. Choices Primary storage Primary storage Backup storage
  • 21. Tape • Best price per GB • Does not consume power to be stored • Requires manual activities to be sent offsite • Restores are not satisfying for demanding RTO
  • 22. Remote Site • All in the hands of the owner • Disk based • Staff needs to maintain two sites • Capital expenses for building and hardware rarely used
  • 23. Co-location • Same benefits as an owned remote site • Rental of the “building” • Again, staff need to maintain two sites • Capital expenses for hardware that is rarely used
  • 24. “Cloud” • No expense for building or hardware • “Pay-as-you-go” model • Reduce the complexity • Seed and collect services for large transfers • Upload /Download • What happens with your data • RTO might be slow
  • 26. Layers & Possibilities • One solution fits all? • Multiple layers is a better defense • Why stop at 3-2-1? • Think further
  • 27. Tiered approach • Sum the benefits of different tiers • Neutralize the limits of each tier • Statistics are your best friends • Most of the restores come from recent restore points • Focus on your RTO, but design around only the First Tier of your data protection strategy “Files are rarely re-opened. Over 66% are re-opened once and 95% fewer than five times” “Files re-opens are temporally related.Over 60% of re-opens occur within a minute of the first.” Measurement and Analysis of Large-Scale Network File System Workloads Andrew W. Leung, Shankar Pasupathy, Garth Goodson, Ethan L. Miller, 2008
  • 28. Tier- (-1): Application protection • Single point of failure (if the app fails…) • Consume production storage (but limited) • Leverages the application • No impact on the hypervisor • Fast restores! • Possibly user restore possibilities #1 GOAL: First defense starts within the application. E.g. SharePoint deleted items & versioning, Email deleted items, AD deleted items, SQL Log transaction…
  • 29. Tier-0: Storage snapshots • Single point of failure (inside the same storage they protect) • Consume precious production storage • No application consistency (or hard to have) • A volume contains multiple VMs • Leverage performance of the storage • Low impact on the hypervisor • Fast restores! Content is non deduplicated • With Veeam you can add application consistency #1 GOAL: High-frequency copies with low impact on production
  • 30. Tier-1: Small and fast JBOD • Hold few restore points • The vast majority of restores come from the last week • A proper server with Windows or Linux (runs Veeam Datamover locally) • Multicore CPU and good amount of RAM • Local disks or DAS • Mix SSD and HDD #1 GOAL: Offer fast restores!!!
  • 31. Tier-2: Large and cheap disk storage Still local and on disk to allow decent RPO and RTO Any disk solution with low $/GB • SAN • Deduplication appliance • NAS • Software solutions • … #1 GOAL: Extend retention period
  • 32. Tier-3: Offsite archival Can be added after Tier-2 or directly after Tier-1 #1 GOAL: Extend retention AND offer offsite protection Tape • Require manual activities to go offsite • Large amount of data can be moved on restores “Cloud” • Directly reachable via Internet connection • A dumb storage space or an active component? • Remote compute power allows direct restores from cloud repositories
  • 33. Overall design Tier-0: Storage snapshots Tier-1: Small and fast JBOD Tier-2: Large and cheap disk storage Tier-3: Offsite archival
  • 34. I have a dream… Production storage
  • 35. I have a dream…
  • 36. Q&A