SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Incorporating Data Logger and Biological
Monitoring to Diagnose Stream Pollutants
and Aid in Reclamation Efforts
By Eric Null
Aquatic Biologist
Conemaugh Valley Conservancy
Data Logger and Biological Monitoring
• Two Very Powerful Tools for Pollution
Monitoring
• Biological Sciences and Data Logging
Technology are Advancing Rapidly
• Both are Long Term Monitoring Practices
• When Used Together They can Produce
Powerful Data
An Introduction on How to Drill Into
the Data
Data Logger Data
The Unique Qualities of Data Logger
Data
• Data Logger Data Sets are Immense
• Logging Intervals Must Be Short To Capture
Episodes (15 min)
• This Data can not be Looked at Like Grab Data
• Averages Change Drastically
• Full Stream Behavior is Seen
• Eyes Going Crossed and Migraines are
Symptoms
Every Stream is Different
Spikes and Valleys
• Can be Caused Naturally or by Disturbance
• Frequency and Duration can Determine
Between Causes
Stream A
Stream B
Biological Data
Macroinvertebrates
• Macroinvertebrate Taxa Act Like Letters in the
Alphabet that can Spell Out Pollutants
• Certain Taxa only Thrive in Certain Polluted
Conditions
• Abundance and Diversity Can Determine the
Type of Pollutant
Spelling Test
• Your Stream is Dominated by the following
Taxa, What is the Pollutant ?
– Amphinemura
– Cheumatopshche
– Ilybius
– Diptera
– ACID Impacts
Another Stream
• Your Stream is Dominated by the following
Taxa, What is the Pollutant ?
– Hydropsyche
– Odonates
– Tabanus
– This Stream has Thermal Pollution, It is HOT
One More
• Take a Guess what is Wrong Here
– Psilotreta
– Oligochaeta
– Ochlerotatus
– You guessed it Organics and Sewage
Fish Data
• Fish Abundance and Diversity can Determine
Pollution
• Fish Disappear Before Macroinvertebrates in
Polluted Streams
• Different Fish Life Stages are impacted by
Different Pollutants
Cross Referencing Biological and Data
Logger Data to Diagnose the Pollutant
• This is When Both Make More Sense
• Conductivity and Other Parameters Influence
Community Structure
• The Community Structure Indicates What is
causing the Conductivity and Other
Parameters to Behave the way they are
Behaving
Stream A
Logger Data Biological Data
• Macroinvertebrates
– Extremely Low
Numbers of
Individuals
– Poor Diversity
– Acid Tolerant Taxa
• Fish
– All Juveniles
– Low Numbers of
Individuals
– Ok Diversity
Stream A
• Pulsing Spikes with a Constant Occurrence
• Depressed Biological Communities
• No Adult Fish
• Pollution Tolerant Macroinvertebrates
• ACID and METALS
Stream B
Data Logger Data Biological Data
• Macroinvertebrates
– High Biomass and
Individuals
– Low Diversity
– Organic and Acid
Tolerant Black Fly
Taxa were Dominant
– Most Taxa Collected
were Pollution
Tolerant
Stream B
• Large Conductivity Spikes
• High Biomass and Abundance
• Low Diversity of Macros
• Acidophilic Macroinvertebrates
• ORGANICS AND ACID
Stream C (The Hard One)
Data Logger Data Biological Data
• Macroinvertebrates
– Low Diversity and
Numbers
– Acid Tolerant Taxa
• Fish
– Low Diversity
– Acid Tolerant Taxa
– White Sucker/Creek
Chub
Stream C
• Consistent Mid Level Conductivity
• Low Macroinvertebrate Diversity and
Abundance
• Low Fish Abundance and Diversity
• Pollution Tolerant Taxa (Fish and Macros)
• Episodic Acidification with Alkalinity
Replacement by Metals and Acidity
Stream D
Data Logger Data Biological Data
• Macroinvertebrate
– Very High Diversity
– Very High
Abundance
– Dominated by
Pollution Intolerant
Taxa
– No Organic Loading
Stream D
• Very Consistent and Low Conductivity
• Very Diverse Macroinvertebrate Community
• Volunteers and Staff Very Excited to
Electrofish in 2015
• HIGH QUALITY H2O
Conclusions
• Data Logger and Biological Data on their Own
are Powerful Assessment Tools
• When Combined they can be used Very
Effectively to Isolate Individual Pollutants
• Data Sets May Appear Confusing at First, but
Over Time Become Easier to Interpret
• Using Both can Better Interpret Each
Individual Data Set
Questions?

More Related Content

PPTX
Panola_County_Presentation
PDF
Timm_etalSER2016Raging
PPTX
2013 ICEEFP Multi-year Database of Acoustic Monitoring (MyDam)_Jina Kim
PPTX
John Curley, et al., PA DEP, "Emergency Projects to Extinguish Coal Refuse Ba...
PPT
Emilie Rzotkiewicz, Allegheny Land Trust, “Wingfield Pines AMD: Connecting to...
PPTX
Beverly Braverman, et al., Mountain Watershed Association, "Preserving the Fu...
PPTX
Bill Reichert, Schuylkill Headwaters Association, "Preserving the Future of O...
PDF
Kitty Vagley, Pittsburgh Botanic Garden, “Reclamation at the Pittsburgh Botan...
Panola_County_Presentation
Timm_etalSER2016Raging
2013 ICEEFP Multi-year Database of Acoustic Monitoring (MyDam)_Jina Kim
John Curley, et al., PA DEP, "Emergency Projects to Extinguish Coal Refuse Ba...
Emilie Rzotkiewicz, Allegheny Land Trust, “Wingfield Pines AMD: Connecting to...
Beverly Braverman, et al., Mountain Watershed Association, "Preserving the Fu...
Bill Reichert, Schuylkill Headwaters Association, "Preserving the Future of O...
Kitty Vagley, Pittsburgh Botanic Garden, “Reclamation at the Pittsburgh Botan...

Viewers also liked (20)

PPTX
Cliff Denholm, Stream Restoration Incorporated, "Passive Treatment of Acidi...
PPT
Joseph Schueck, Agri Drain Manufacturers, "Flow Distribution Box"
PPTX
Ryan A. McCampbell, Bloomsburg University, "A Cost-Benefit Analysis of AMD Re...
PPTX
Vince Brisini, Olympus Power, LLC, “Making Sense of the SENSE Act”
PPTX
Mark Killar, Western Pennsylvania Conservancy, “Sewickley Creek Cost/Benefit ...
PPT
Tiff Hilton, “Manganese—Misunderstood, Mis-Regulated, & Mistaken for a Problem”
PPTX
Brad Shultz, OSMRE, “Effective Aerobic Wetland Design for Metals Polishing in...
PPT
Matt Kierstead, Milestone Heritage Consulting, “A Mine is a Terrible Thing to...
PPT
Ryan Ellis, Interstate Mining Compact Commission, “State Regulatory Authority...
DOCX
B hoffnar930 am2015
PPTX
Eric Cavazza, et al., PA DEP, "Preparing for SMCRA Reauthorization in 2021"
PPTX
Brian Bradley, PA DEP, “Pennsylvania AML/AMD Program and Funding Overview”
PPT
Terry Schmidt, Skelly & Loy, “Big Run Restoration: A Success Story”
PPT
Melissa Meade, Temple University, “Dialogical Communication and Digital Citiz...
PPTX
Anne Daymut, WPCAMR, “Non-Profit Lobbying Rules”
PPTX
Robert Hughes and Michael Hewitt, EPCAMR, “3D Modeling of Eastern Pennsylvani...
PPTX
Missy Reckner, Kiski-Conemaugh Stream Team, “Building Capacity to Complete Re...
PPTX
Rachel Kester, Trout Unlimited, “TU’s OM&R Jobs Analysis Study”
PPTX
Len Lichvar, Somerset Conservation District, “Economics of Conservation Recre...
PPT
John Stefanko, PA DEP Deputy Secretary, Office of Abandoned Mine Operations, ...
Cliff Denholm, Stream Restoration Incorporated, "Passive Treatment of Acidi...
Joseph Schueck, Agri Drain Manufacturers, "Flow Distribution Box"
Ryan A. McCampbell, Bloomsburg University, "A Cost-Benefit Analysis of AMD Re...
Vince Brisini, Olympus Power, LLC, “Making Sense of the SENSE Act”
Mark Killar, Western Pennsylvania Conservancy, “Sewickley Creek Cost/Benefit ...
Tiff Hilton, “Manganese—Misunderstood, Mis-Regulated, & Mistaken for a Problem”
Brad Shultz, OSMRE, “Effective Aerobic Wetland Design for Metals Polishing in...
Matt Kierstead, Milestone Heritage Consulting, “A Mine is a Terrible Thing to...
Ryan Ellis, Interstate Mining Compact Commission, “State Regulatory Authority...
B hoffnar930 am2015
Eric Cavazza, et al., PA DEP, "Preparing for SMCRA Reauthorization in 2021"
Brian Bradley, PA DEP, “Pennsylvania AML/AMD Program and Funding Overview”
Terry Schmidt, Skelly & Loy, “Big Run Restoration: A Success Story”
Melissa Meade, Temple University, “Dialogical Communication and Digital Citiz...
Anne Daymut, WPCAMR, “Non-Profit Lobbying Rules”
Robert Hughes and Michael Hewitt, EPCAMR, “3D Modeling of Eastern Pennsylvani...
Missy Reckner, Kiski-Conemaugh Stream Team, “Building Capacity to Complete Re...
Rachel Kester, Trout Unlimited, “TU’s OM&R Jobs Analysis Study”
Len Lichvar, Somerset Conservation District, “Economics of Conservation Recre...
John Stefanko, PA DEP Deputy Secretary, Office of Abandoned Mine Operations, ...
Ad

Similar to Eric Null, Conemaugh Valley Conservancy, "Incorporated Data Logger and Biological Monitoring to Diagnosis Stream Pollutants and Aid in Reclamation Efforts" (20)

PDF
Bijoy Nandan S - UEI Day 2 - Kochi Jan18
PDF
DSD-INT 2019 DANUBIUS-RI the Scientific Agenda-Bradley
PPT
ChemColor.ppt
PPTX
Ecological indicators and support with local examples
PPTX
3.1 the use of fish as ecological indicators en
PPTX
Bioindicators ppt
PPTX
minimum flow- need & response
PPTX
Workshop 1 - Rebecca North
PPTX
Biology Journal Report (Ecological Assessment of River Systems in the Philipp...
PPTX
Aqa a2 biology unit 4 complete
PPTX
Carrying capacity of ecosystem
PPTX
Biodiversity & its conservation
PPSX
.......................................................
PPTX
Water quality and standards batool.pptx
PPTX
Water quality and standards batool.pptx
PDF
Summary and interpretation of monitoring data for synthetic pyrethroids in U....
PPT
fragile arctic tundra : nature and the science
PDF
Pierce County 2010 Surface Water Report Card
PPSX
nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
PPTX
SummerInTheOzarks
Bijoy Nandan S - UEI Day 2 - Kochi Jan18
DSD-INT 2019 DANUBIUS-RI the Scientific Agenda-Bradley
ChemColor.ppt
Ecological indicators and support with local examples
3.1 the use of fish as ecological indicators en
Bioindicators ppt
minimum flow- need & response
Workshop 1 - Rebecca North
Biology Journal Report (Ecological Assessment of River Systems in the Philipp...
Aqa a2 biology unit 4 complete
Carrying capacity of ecosystem
Biodiversity & its conservation
.......................................................
Water quality and standards batool.pptx
Water quality and standards batool.pptx
Summary and interpretation of monitoring data for synthetic pyrethroids in U....
fragile arctic tundra : nature and the science
Pierce County 2010 Surface Water Report Card
nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
SummerInTheOzarks
Ad

More from Michael Hewitt, GISP (20)

PDF
2022 PA AMR Conference Domestic Production of Critical Minerals 9:30AM 6/22/22
PPT
Sullivan County Meaningful Watershed Education Experience
PPTX
Harry E. Coal Waste Pile Reclamation Project in Swoyersville, PA
PPTX
Jacob Johnson, et al, Penn State University - “Case Study to Assess the Costs...
PPTX
Peter Smyntek, et al, St. Vincent College - “Screen to Stream – Student citiz...
PPTX
Beth Berkhouser, Interdependence Hexagon Project - “Connecting Art – Creating...
PPTX
Tom Gray, Tetra Tech Inc. - “Coal and Coal Mine Wastes a Resource for Rare E...
PPT
David Thomas and Donald Hedge, Broad Top Township - “Passive Treatment System...
PPTX
Mike Korb, Tetra Tech Inc. - “How to Give the Best Field Trip Ever”
PPTX
Robert Hughes, EPCAMR - “Watershed Group Funding through PA’s Educational Imp...
PPTX
Rachael Grube, EPCAMR - “New Methods for Digitizing Mine Maps”
PPTX
Tom Clark, Susquehanna River Basin Commission - “Susquehanna River Basin Mine...
PPTX
Joe Pizarchik - “Preserving Decades for Success; A Plan for O&M Funding”
PPTX
Daniel Bochicchio, Skybernetics - “Valuable Insights from On High: Drone use ...
PPTX
Eric. E. Cavazza P.E., Director PA DEP Bureau of Abandoned Mine Reclamation -...
PPTX
Jaret Gibbons, ARIPPA - “Environmental Benefits of the Coal Refuse Industry”
PPT
Tim Altares, PA DEP BAMR - “Pennsylvania’s Abandoned Coal Mine Fires”
PDF
Colin Lennox, Eco Islands LLC, “Metal Reclamation Units for AMD and Nutrient ...
PPTX
Hank Zielinski, Northhampton Generating Company, “Excellence in Surface Coal ...
PPTX
Matt MacConnell, Lehigh River Stocking Association, “Lausanne Tunnel Remediat...
2022 PA AMR Conference Domestic Production of Critical Minerals 9:30AM 6/22/22
Sullivan County Meaningful Watershed Education Experience
Harry E. Coal Waste Pile Reclamation Project in Swoyersville, PA
Jacob Johnson, et al, Penn State University - “Case Study to Assess the Costs...
Peter Smyntek, et al, St. Vincent College - “Screen to Stream – Student citiz...
Beth Berkhouser, Interdependence Hexagon Project - “Connecting Art – Creating...
Tom Gray, Tetra Tech Inc. - “Coal and Coal Mine Wastes a Resource for Rare E...
David Thomas and Donald Hedge, Broad Top Township - “Passive Treatment System...
Mike Korb, Tetra Tech Inc. - “How to Give the Best Field Trip Ever”
Robert Hughes, EPCAMR - “Watershed Group Funding through PA’s Educational Imp...
Rachael Grube, EPCAMR - “New Methods for Digitizing Mine Maps”
Tom Clark, Susquehanna River Basin Commission - “Susquehanna River Basin Mine...
Joe Pizarchik - “Preserving Decades for Success; A Plan for O&M Funding”
Daniel Bochicchio, Skybernetics - “Valuable Insights from On High: Drone use ...
Eric. E. Cavazza P.E., Director PA DEP Bureau of Abandoned Mine Reclamation -...
Jaret Gibbons, ARIPPA - “Environmental Benefits of the Coal Refuse Industry”
Tim Altares, PA DEP BAMR - “Pennsylvania’s Abandoned Coal Mine Fires”
Colin Lennox, Eco Islands LLC, “Metal Reclamation Units for AMD and Nutrient ...
Hank Zielinski, Northhampton Generating Company, “Excellence in Surface Coal ...
Matt MacConnell, Lehigh River Stocking Association, “Lausanne Tunnel Remediat...

Recently uploaded (20)

PPTX
Parliamentary procedure in meeting that can be use
PDF
CXPA Finland Webinar: Rated 5 Stars - Delivering Service That Customers Truly...
PPTX
Part I CSO Conference and AVP Overview.pptx
PDF
Item # 8 - 218 Primrose Place variance req.
PDF
2024-Need-Assessment-Report-March-2025.pdf
PPTX
cpgram enivaran cpgram enivaran cpgram enivaran
PPTX
International Tracking Project Unloading Guidance Manual V1 (1) 1.pptx
PPTX
Workshop introduction and objectives. SK.pptx
PPTX
Reactivity of metals with oxygen, rusting.pptx
PPTX
True Fruits_ reportcccccccccccccccc.pptx
PPTX
LUNG CANCER PREDICTION MODELING USING ARTIFICIAL NEURAL NETWORK.pptx
PDF
CXPA Finland Webinar - Modern Components of Service Quality - Alec Dalton - ...
PPTX
CHS rollout Presentation by Abraham Lebeza.pptx
PPT
Republic Act 9729 Climate Change Adaptation
PPTX
Developing_An_Advocacy_Agenda_by_Kevin_Karuga.pptx
PPTX
Part II LGU Accreditation of CSOs and Selection of Reps to LSBs ver2.pptx
PPTX
Robotics_Presentation.pptxdhdrhdrrhdrhdrhdrrh
PPTX
3.-Canvassing-Procedures49for election.pptx
PDF
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAaaaaaaaAAAAAAAt - ĐV.pdf
PDF
Dean, Jodi: Concept Paper - Multi Family Lot
Parliamentary procedure in meeting that can be use
CXPA Finland Webinar: Rated 5 Stars - Delivering Service That Customers Truly...
Part I CSO Conference and AVP Overview.pptx
Item # 8 - 218 Primrose Place variance req.
2024-Need-Assessment-Report-March-2025.pdf
cpgram enivaran cpgram enivaran cpgram enivaran
International Tracking Project Unloading Guidance Manual V1 (1) 1.pptx
Workshop introduction and objectives. SK.pptx
Reactivity of metals with oxygen, rusting.pptx
True Fruits_ reportcccccccccccccccc.pptx
LUNG CANCER PREDICTION MODELING USING ARTIFICIAL NEURAL NETWORK.pptx
CXPA Finland Webinar - Modern Components of Service Quality - Alec Dalton - ...
CHS rollout Presentation by Abraham Lebeza.pptx
Republic Act 9729 Climate Change Adaptation
Developing_An_Advocacy_Agenda_by_Kevin_Karuga.pptx
Part II LGU Accreditation of CSOs and Selection of Reps to LSBs ver2.pptx
Robotics_Presentation.pptxdhdrhdrrhdrhdrhdrrh
3.-Canvassing-Procedures49for election.pptx
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAaaaaaaaAAAAAAAt - ĐV.pdf
Dean, Jodi: Concept Paper - Multi Family Lot

Eric Null, Conemaugh Valley Conservancy, "Incorporated Data Logger and Biological Monitoring to Diagnosis Stream Pollutants and Aid in Reclamation Efforts"

  • 1. Incorporating Data Logger and Biological Monitoring to Diagnose Stream Pollutants and Aid in Reclamation Efforts By Eric Null Aquatic Biologist Conemaugh Valley Conservancy
  • 2. Data Logger and Biological Monitoring • Two Very Powerful Tools for Pollution Monitoring • Biological Sciences and Data Logging Technology are Advancing Rapidly • Both are Long Term Monitoring Practices • When Used Together They can Produce Powerful Data
  • 3. An Introduction on How to Drill Into the Data
  • 5. The Unique Qualities of Data Logger Data • Data Logger Data Sets are Immense • Logging Intervals Must Be Short To Capture Episodes (15 min) • This Data can not be Looked at Like Grab Data • Averages Change Drastically • Full Stream Behavior is Seen • Eyes Going Crossed and Migraines are Symptoms
  • 6. Every Stream is Different
  • 7. Spikes and Valleys • Can be Caused Naturally or by Disturbance • Frequency and Duration can Determine Between Causes
  • 11. Macroinvertebrates • Macroinvertebrate Taxa Act Like Letters in the Alphabet that can Spell Out Pollutants • Certain Taxa only Thrive in Certain Polluted Conditions • Abundance and Diversity Can Determine the Type of Pollutant
  • 12. Spelling Test • Your Stream is Dominated by the following Taxa, What is the Pollutant ? – Amphinemura – Cheumatopshche – Ilybius – Diptera – ACID Impacts
  • 13. Another Stream • Your Stream is Dominated by the following Taxa, What is the Pollutant ? – Hydropsyche – Odonates – Tabanus – This Stream has Thermal Pollution, It is HOT
  • 14. One More • Take a Guess what is Wrong Here – Psilotreta – Oligochaeta – Ochlerotatus – You guessed it Organics and Sewage
  • 15. Fish Data • Fish Abundance and Diversity can Determine Pollution • Fish Disappear Before Macroinvertebrates in Polluted Streams • Different Fish Life Stages are impacted by Different Pollutants
  • 16. Cross Referencing Biological and Data Logger Data to Diagnose the Pollutant • This is When Both Make More Sense • Conductivity and Other Parameters Influence Community Structure • The Community Structure Indicates What is causing the Conductivity and Other Parameters to Behave the way they are Behaving
  • 17. Stream A Logger Data Biological Data • Macroinvertebrates – Extremely Low Numbers of Individuals – Poor Diversity – Acid Tolerant Taxa • Fish – All Juveniles – Low Numbers of Individuals – Ok Diversity
  • 18. Stream A • Pulsing Spikes with a Constant Occurrence • Depressed Biological Communities • No Adult Fish • Pollution Tolerant Macroinvertebrates • ACID and METALS
  • 19. Stream B Data Logger Data Biological Data • Macroinvertebrates – High Biomass and Individuals – Low Diversity – Organic and Acid Tolerant Black Fly Taxa were Dominant – Most Taxa Collected were Pollution Tolerant
  • 20. Stream B • Large Conductivity Spikes • High Biomass and Abundance • Low Diversity of Macros • Acidophilic Macroinvertebrates • ORGANICS AND ACID
  • 21. Stream C (The Hard One) Data Logger Data Biological Data • Macroinvertebrates – Low Diversity and Numbers – Acid Tolerant Taxa • Fish – Low Diversity – Acid Tolerant Taxa – White Sucker/Creek Chub
  • 22. Stream C • Consistent Mid Level Conductivity • Low Macroinvertebrate Diversity and Abundance • Low Fish Abundance and Diversity • Pollution Tolerant Taxa (Fish and Macros) • Episodic Acidification with Alkalinity Replacement by Metals and Acidity
  • 23. Stream D Data Logger Data Biological Data • Macroinvertebrate – Very High Diversity – Very High Abundance – Dominated by Pollution Intolerant Taxa – No Organic Loading
  • 24. Stream D • Very Consistent and Low Conductivity • Very Diverse Macroinvertebrate Community • Volunteers and Staff Very Excited to Electrofish in 2015 • HIGH QUALITY H2O
  • 25. Conclusions • Data Logger and Biological Data on their Own are Powerful Assessment Tools • When Combined they can be used Very Effectively to Isolate Individual Pollutants • Data Sets May Appear Confusing at First, but Over Time Become Easier to Interpret • Using Both can Better Interpret Each Individual Data Set