From System to Local to System
2 likes455 views
This document summarizes a 3-year project that aimed to design on multiple levels to scale a system in transition from local to systemic. It discusses the methods used, including analyzing themes from project documentation and media over time. Key findings included preliminary design principles for living labs as catalysts of change. The document notes they are now applying these lessons in new contexts and investigating how to better support the phase of embedding and scaling insights from local labs systemically. It poses questions about experiences with this challenging third phase and concepts from systems dynamics that could help address balancing local and systemic levels when enacting systemic change through distributed initiatives.
From System to Local to System
- 1. From system to local to system Design principles to scale for a system in transition De Lille, C.S.H. & Overdiek, A.
- 2. Intro – our basic approach in a 3 years project Design on all levels: • Design project governance • Design local labs • Design tools for labs • Design lab “franchise" • Design dialogues/communication/activities
- 3. Method To understand how we scaled between the local and the systemic, we used our own research reports, the documentation of stakeholder meetings, the archive with physical artefacts (house style, banners, scenario’s, presentations) and media publications about the project as data. We analysed by plotting themes emerging from this data on the project’s timeline, revealing principles and their situatedness in the process. To generalize the findings of this single and contextual case, we related results to the widely discussed Systemic Design Framework of the U.K. Design Council (2021) and identified a key overlooked phase: that of scaling in a system in transition. We are currently in the process of applying the findings of this study in the context of four living labs in circular economy, to further investigate the potential of our model for other contexts.
- 4. Future Proof Retail - case Transition to sustainable & digitally powered sector • 50+ partners from quadruple helix • 14 municipalities • 8 lab formulas • 22 labs • 500+ SME retailers
- 5. Future Proof Retail - case
- 6. Results: plotting themes on timeline
- 15. Results: preliminary design principles Labs as Catalysts of Change Storytelling Distributed Leadership Room for Intuition
- 16. Third phase!
- 18. Next steps • Paper DRS2022 (zooming in on third phase from two cases/contexts) • Book Innovating with Networks (documenting systemic experiences) • Research Future Proof Labs (comparing with experiences in other context beyond retail) • Sprong Systemic Co-Design (collaboration across 4 universities on systemic change during 8 years) • Already finished: • Innovating with Labs (book out, via Lulu) • Follow up projects initiated: Next Fashion Retail, PPS local Labs, Future Proof Labs, Circular Retail, etc.)
- 19. Questions from us for you • Other experiences with third phase? • Which concepts from System Dynamics are helpful? • "Balancing" local and systemic levels? • “Rippling” versus disrupting systems? • Long lasting effects on systemic change? • Comparing similar large scale projects in the future in other contexts? • Analysis across similar cases at next conference?
- 20. ©Drawing by Jan Rothuizen c.s.h.delille@hhs.nl a.overdiek@hhs.nl Feel free to contact us!