SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Green Computing

     Presented by:
     Kumar Gaurav
     B.Tech 4th Year (CS)
Green Computing
• Why
  – computer energy is often wasteful
     • leaving the computer on when not in use (CPU and fan consume
       power, screen savers consume power)
  – printing is often wasteful
     • how many of you print out your emails or meeting agendas
     • printing out partial drafts
     • for a “paperless” society, we tend to use more paper today than
       before computer-prevalence
  – pollution
     • manufacturing techniques
     • packaging
     • disposal of computers and components
  – toxicity
     • as we will see, there are toxic chemicals used in the manufacturing
       of computers and components which can enter the food chain and
       water!
Energy Use of PCs
• CPU uses 120 Watts
• CRT uses 150 Watts
  – 8 hours of usage, 5 days a week = 562 KWatts
     • if the computer is left on all the time without proper power saver
       modes, this can lead to 1,600 KWatts
  – for a large institution, say a university of 40,000 students
    and faculty, the power bill for just computers can come to
    $2 million / year
• Energy use comes from
  – electrical current to run the CPU, motherboard, memory
  – running the fan and spinning the disk(s)
  – monitor (CRTs consume more power than any other
    computer component)
  – printers
Reducing Energy Consumption
• Turn off the computer when not in use, even if just for
  an hour
• Turn off the monitor when not in use (as opposed to
  running a screen saver)
• Use power saver mode
   – in power saver mode, the top item is not necessary, but
     screen savers use as much electricity as any normal
     processing, and the screen saver is not necessary on a flat
     panel display
• Use hardware/software with the Energy Star label
   – Energy Star is a “seal of approval” by the Energy Star
     organization of the government (the EPA)
• Don’t print unless necessary and you are ready
• Use LCDs instead of CRTs as they are more power
  efficient
Manufacturing
• Microchip fabrication has over 400 distinct steps which
  involve 4 general phases




• Throughout, the process requires a great deal of ultra-pure
  water and the chips are bathed in chemical solvents
   – the resources used are shown below
Chemical Elements Used: Lead
• used in soldering of printed circuit boards and other
  components
   – also used in glass for CRTs
• It is estimated that between 1997 and 2004, 1.2
  billion tons of lead was used in computer components
• The problem:
   – lead can cause damage to the central and peripheral
     nervous systems, blood system, kidneys, endocrine system
     and cause negative effects on child brain development
   – lead accumulates in the environment and has toxic effects
     on plants, animals and microorganisms
   – electronics contribute 40% of the total amount of lead
     found in landfills and can make its way from landfills into
     the water supplies
Chemical Elements Used: Mercury
• Mercury is used in
   – batteries, switches, housing, printed circuit boards
   – mercury is found in medical equipment, data transmission
     equipment, telecommunications equipment and cell phones as
     well
   – if is estimated that 22% of the yearly use of mercury is in
     electrical and electronic equipment
      • although a small amount of mercury is used, it is used in nearly all
        computer construction amounting to 400,000 pounds of mercury used
        between 1997 and 2004
• The problem
   – mercury spreads out in water transforming into methylated
     mercury which easily accumulates in living organisms
   – it enters the food chain through fish that swim in polluted
     waters
   – methylated mercury can cause chronic brain damage
Other Chemical Elements
• Cadmium is used in resistors for chips, infrared detectors
  and in semiconductors (plus older CRTs)
   – estimated that between 1997 and 2004, 2 million pounds of
     cadmium was used in computer components
• The problem:
   – cadmium is classified as toxic, these compounds accumulate in
     the human body, particularly the kidneys
   – cadmium is absorbed through respiration and also food intake
   – cadmium has a half life of 30 years so that cadmium can
     poison a human body slowly through the human’s life
• Hexavalent Chromium (Chromium VI) is used to treat
  steel plates (an anti-corrosive) and it is estimated that
  between 1997 and 2004, 1.2 million pounds were used in
  computer components
   – if you’ve seen Erin Brokovich, you know that this can lead to
     cancer and a number of other medical problems
Plastics
• Plastics are found throughout the computer, largely from
  casings but also internally to hold components together
   – 4 billion pounds of plastic were used to build computers and
     components between 1997 and 2004
• One specific form of plastics used is polyvinyl chloride
  (PVC) which is used in cabling and housings
   – PVC is difficult to recycle and the production and burning of
     PVC generates dioxins and furans
• The plastics in computers are often treated with flame
  retardant chemicals, particularly brominated flame
  retardant
   – these chemicals can act as endocrine disrupters and increase
     risk of several forms of cancer
   – they have been found entering the food chain
Chemical Elements Found in
         Computers and Components
• Elements in bulk: lead, tin, copper, silicon, carbon, iron
  and aluminum
• Elements in small amounts: cadmium and mercury
• Elements in trace amounts:
   – germanium, gallium, barium, nickel, tantalum, indium,
     vanadium, terbium, beryllium, gold, europium, titanium,
     ruthenium, cobalt, palladium, manganese, silver, antimony,
     bismuth, selenium, niobium, yttrium, rhodium, platinum,
     arsenic, lithium, boron, americium
• List of examples of devices containing these elements
   – almost all electronics contain lead & tin (as solder) and copper
     (as wire & PCB tracks), though the use of lead-free solder is
     now spreading rapidly
   – lead: solder, CRT monitors (Lead in glass), Lead-acid battery
List Continued
• List of examples of devices containing these elements
   – tin: solder
   – copper: copper wire, printed circuit board tracks
   – aluminum: nearly all electronic goods using more than a
     few watts of power
   – iron: steel chassis, cases & fixings
   – silicon: glass, transistors, ICs, Printed circuit boards.
   – nickel & cadmium: nickel-cadmium rechargeable batteries
   – lithium: lithium-ion battery
   – zinc: plating for steel parts
   – gold: connector plating, primarily in computer equipment
   – mercury: fluorescent tubes (numerous applications), tilt
     switches (pinball games, mechanical doorbells)
   – sulphur: lead-acid battery
   – carbon: steel, plastics, resistors
Disposal
• Consider that the average computer lifespan is about 2
  years (cell phones < 2 years)
   – 10 years ago, the lifespan of a computer was 5 years
   – between 1997 and 2004, it is estimated that 315 million
     computers became obsolete (and were discarded, donated, or
     recycled)
• 183 million computers were sold in 2004 (674 million
  cell phones!)
• New users in China (178 million by 2010) and India (80
  million by 2010) will require the creation of new
  computers
• Disposal of these devices constituted 20-50 million tons
  per year (about 5% of the total waste of the planet)
   – this waste is called e-waste
   – where are we going to put all of it?
Land Fills




• Europe has outlawed using landfills for computer
  components
   – the US and Europe export a lot of e-waste to Asian landfills
     (especially China even though China has outlawed the
     importing of e-waste)
   – in addition, incineration of computer components leads to air
     pollution and airborne toxins
Other Solutions
• Reuse: donate your computer components to people who
  may not have or have lesser quality computers
   – inner city schools, churches, libraries, third world countries
      • this however leads to the older computers being dumped but there is
        probably no way around this as eventually the older computers would be
        discarded anyway
• Refurbish: rather than discarding your computer when
  the next generation is released, just get a new CPU and
  memory chips – upgrade rather than replace
   – while you will still be discarded some components, you will
     retain most of the computer system (e.g., monitor, the system
     unit housing, cables)
• Are there adequate incentives to do either of the above?
  Do computer companies encourage
  refurbishing/upgrading?
One More Solution: Recycling
• If companies can recycle the plastics and other
  components, this can greatly reduce waste and toxins
   – however, the hazardous materials in e-waste can harm the
     recycle workers if they are not properly protected
      • in undeveloped countries, a lot of the recycling chores are left up to
        unprotected children!
• Developed countries now have facilities for recycling e-
  waste
   – however, in Europe, the plastics are discarded instead of
     recycled because the flame retardant chemicals are too toxic to
     work with
• To resolve these problems, the computer manufacturers
  must start using recyclable chemicals
How Do the Companies Rate?
• 8: Nokia - regained its top position for eliminating the
  worst chemicals from many products
   – still needs to report on its recycling rate percentage
• 7.3: Dell - still among the top but loses points for not
  having models free of the worst chemicals
   – strong support for global take back
• 7.3: Lenovo - dropping down the rank for not having a
  clear global take back program
   – still missing out on products free of the worst chemicals on the
     market
• 7: Sony Ericsson - among the top with clear timeline to
  have products free of the worst chemicals by 2008
   – need better chemicals take back reporting program
Continued
• 6.7: Samsung - strong position for having a good
  chemical policy, but still lack products that are free from
  the worst chemicals
   – its take back system is not yet global and need improvement
• 6.7: Motorola - some products on the market are free
  from the worst chemicals but loses points for not
  providing clear timelines for eliminating these
  chemicals in all products
   – score points on reporting the recycling rate
• 6: Toshiba - good improvement particularly on waste
  and take back criteria
   – moved forward for providing some models without the worst
     chemicals and for timelines for complete phase out
• 6: Fujitsu-Siemens - some models free of worst
  chemicals, but loses point for a weak take back and
  recycling program
Continued
• 5.7: Acer - standing still with improved chemical policies but no
  models free of the worst chemicals
   – needs to improve on take back program
• 5.3: Apple - top mover with concrete timelines to eliminate the
  worst chemicals
   – loses points for not have a green product on the market and for a weak take
     back program
• 5.3: HP - a free-faller, dropping down for failing to provide clear
  timelines for eliminating the worst chemicals
   – it looses points for weak definition of take back policies
• 5: Panasonic - moving up for making available products free of
  the worst chemicals
   – loses point for poor take back program
• 4: Sony - at the bottom of the rank for losing penalty point for
  inconsistent take back policies
   – some models without the worst chemicals
Green computing

More Related Content

PDF
Green computing
PPT
Deepak's green computing
PPTX
Green computing
PPTX
Green computing
PPT
Green computing
PPTX
Green computing ppt
PPTX
Green computing
PPT
Green computing: An environmental necessity.
Green computing
Deepak's green computing
Green computing
Green computing
Green computing
Green computing ppt
Green computing
Green computing: An environmental necessity.

What's hot (20)

PPTX
Green computing
PPT
green computing presentation
PPT
Green computing
PPTX
Green Computing
PDF
Green Computing Seminar
PPTX
Green Computing
PPTX
Green computing -
PPTX
Green computing 1
PDF
Green Computing
PPT
Green Computing
PDF
Green IT - IT as an Environmental Issue - Richard Hodges
PPTX
IS GREEN COMPUTING GOOD FOR BUSINESS?
PPTX
Green computing ppt
PPTX
Green Computing
PPTX
Green computing ppt
DOCX
Green computing
PPT
Green computing ameera
PPTX
Green computing ppt
PPT
Green computing topic
PPTX
Green computing and environment concern final)
Green computing
green computing presentation
Green computing
Green Computing
Green Computing Seminar
Green Computing
Green computing -
Green computing 1
Green Computing
Green Computing
Green IT - IT as an Environmental Issue - Richard Hodges
IS GREEN COMPUTING GOOD FOR BUSINESS?
Green computing ppt
Green Computing
Green computing ppt
Green computing
Green computing ameera
Green computing ppt
Green computing topic
Green computing and environment concern final)
Ad

Viewers also liked (20)

PPT
Green Computing
PPTX
Green computing
PPT
Green computing
PPTX
Green computing by hafiz umair
PPT
Green Computing
PPT
Final ppt
PPTX
Green cloud
PPTX
Li fi
PDF
Going paperless nema.ppt
KEY
Green IT Concept
PDF
Paperless Office Presentation
PPSX
Green computing
PPTX
Apple iOS
PPTX
OLED technology Seminar Ppt
PPTX
Li-Fi Technology (Perfect slides)
PPTX
Green Technology
PPT
Cloud computing simple ppt
PDF
Internet of Things
PPTX
ppt on LIFI TECHNOLOGY
PDF
How to Make Awesome SlideShares: Tips & Tricks
Green Computing
Green computing
Green computing
Green computing by hafiz umair
Green Computing
Final ppt
Green cloud
Li fi
Going paperless nema.ppt
Green IT Concept
Paperless Office Presentation
Green computing
Apple iOS
OLED technology Seminar Ppt
Li-Fi Technology (Perfect slides)
Green Technology
Cloud computing simple ppt
Internet of Things
ppt on LIFI TECHNOLOGY
How to Make Awesome SlideShares: Tips & Tricks
Ad

Similar to Green computing (20)

PPT
Green Computing
PPTX
Green computing (1)
PPT
Green computing
PPT
Green computing
PPTX
Harmful Effect Of Computers On Environment - EWASTE
PPTX
Ef fects of computers on enviournment
PPTX
Green technology
PPTX
Presentation1
POTX
Green technology
PPTX
Green Electronics
PPT
PPT
E waste 33
PDF
E waste management
POTX
Green technology
PPTX
Green computing
PPT
Simple presentation on Green computing
POTX
Greentechnology 130201061641-phpapp01
PPTX
Nothing Green about IT.
PDF
greencomputingppt-111110031733-phpapp02.pdf
Green Computing
Green computing (1)
Green computing
Green computing
Harmful Effect Of Computers On Environment - EWASTE
Ef fects of computers on enviournment
Green technology
Presentation1
Green technology
Green Electronics
E waste 33
E waste management
Green technology
Green computing
Simple presentation on Green computing
Greentechnology 130201061641-phpapp01
Nothing Green about IT.
greencomputingppt-111110031733-phpapp02.pdf

More from Kumar Gaurav (8)

PPT
Brief introduction to the c programming language
PPT
Brain chips
PDF
A project report on online trading
PDF
A project report on chat application
PPT
Artificial intelligence
PPT
3g wireless technology
PPT
Surface computer
PDF
Surface computing1
Brief introduction to the c programming language
Brain chips
A project report on online trading
A project report on chat application
Artificial intelligence
3g wireless technology
Surface computer
Surface computing1

Recently uploaded (20)

DOCX
The AUB Centre for AI in Media Proposal.docx
PDF
Network Security Unit 5.pdf for BCA BBA.
PPT
“AI and Expert System Decision Support & Business Intelligence Systems”
PDF
Chapter 3 Spatial Domain Image Processing.pdf
PDF
Modernizing your data center with Dell and AMD
PDF
Build a system with the filesystem maintained by OSTree @ COSCUP 2025
PPTX
Understanding_Digital_Forensics_Presentation.pptx
PDF
Per capita expenditure prediction using model stacking based on satellite ima...
PPTX
Effective Security Operations Center (SOC) A Modern, Strategic, and Threat-In...
PDF
NewMind AI Monthly Chronicles - July 2025
PDF
Reach Out and Touch Someone: Haptics and Empathic Computing
PDF
Peak of Data & AI Encore- AI for Metadata and Smarter Workflows
PPTX
20250228 LYD VKU AI Blended-Learning.pptx
PDF
Agricultural_Statistics_at_a_Glance_2022_0.pdf
PPTX
Detection-First SIEM: Rule Types, Dashboards, and Threat-Informed Strategy
PDF
KodekX | Application Modernization Development
PDF
Unlocking AI with Model Context Protocol (MCP)
PDF
cuic standard and advanced reporting.pdf
PDF
Bridging biosciences and deep learning for revolutionary discoveries: a compr...
PDF
7 ChatGPT Prompts to Help You Define Your Ideal Customer Profile.pdf
The AUB Centre for AI in Media Proposal.docx
Network Security Unit 5.pdf for BCA BBA.
“AI and Expert System Decision Support & Business Intelligence Systems”
Chapter 3 Spatial Domain Image Processing.pdf
Modernizing your data center with Dell and AMD
Build a system with the filesystem maintained by OSTree @ COSCUP 2025
Understanding_Digital_Forensics_Presentation.pptx
Per capita expenditure prediction using model stacking based on satellite ima...
Effective Security Operations Center (SOC) A Modern, Strategic, and Threat-In...
NewMind AI Monthly Chronicles - July 2025
Reach Out and Touch Someone: Haptics and Empathic Computing
Peak of Data & AI Encore- AI for Metadata and Smarter Workflows
20250228 LYD VKU AI Blended-Learning.pptx
Agricultural_Statistics_at_a_Glance_2022_0.pdf
Detection-First SIEM: Rule Types, Dashboards, and Threat-Informed Strategy
KodekX | Application Modernization Development
Unlocking AI with Model Context Protocol (MCP)
cuic standard and advanced reporting.pdf
Bridging biosciences and deep learning for revolutionary discoveries: a compr...
7 ChatGPT Prompts to Help You Define Your Ideal Customer Profile.pdf

Green computing

  • 1. Green Computing Presented by: Kumar Gaurav B.Tech 4th Year (CS)
  • 2. Green Computing • Why – computer energy is often wasteful • leaving the computer on when not in use (CPU and fan consume power, screen savers consume power) – printing is often wasteful • how many of you print out your emails or meeting agendas • printing out partial drafts • for a “paperless” society, we tend to use more paper today than before computer-prevalence – pollution • manufacturing techniques • packaging • disposal of computers and components – toxicity • as we will see, there are toxic chemicals used in the manufacturing of computers and components which can enter the food chain and water!
  • 3. Energy Use of PCs • CPU uses 120 Watts • CRT uses 150 Watts – 8 hours of usage, 5 days a week = 562 KWatts • if the computer is left on all the time without proper power saver modes, this can lead to 1,600 KWatts – for a large institution, say a university of 40,000 students and faculty, the power bill for just computers can come to $2 million / year • Energy use comes from – electrical current to run the CPU, motherboard, memory – running the fan and spinning the disk(s) – monitor (CRTs consume more power than any other computer component) – printers
  • 4. Reducing Energy Consumption • Turn off the computer when not in use, even if just for an hour • Turn off the monitor when not in use (as opposed to running a screen saver) • Use power saver mode – in power saver mode, the top item is not necessary, but screen savers use as much electricity as any normal processing, and the screen saver is not necessary on a flat panel display • Use hardware/software with the Energy Star label – Energy Star is a “seal of approval” by the Energy Star organization of the government (the EPA) • Don’t print unless necessary and you are ready • Use LCDs instead of CRTs as they are more power efficient
  • 5. Manufacturing • Microchip fabrication has over 400 distinct steps which involve 4 general phases • Throughout, the process requires a great deal of ultra-pure water and the chips are bathed in chemical solvents – the resources used are shown below
  • 6. Chemical Elements Used: Lead • used in soldering of printed circuit boards and other components – also used in glass for CRTs • It is estimated that between 1997 and 2004, 1.2 billion tons of lead was used in computer components • The problem: – lead can cause damage to the central and peripheral nervous systems, blood system, kidneys, endocrine system and cause negative effects on child brain development – lead accumulates in the environment and has toxic effects on plants, animals and microorganisms – electronics contribute 40% of the total amount of lead found in landfills and can make its way from landfills into the water supplies
  • 7. Chemical Elements Used: Mercury • Mercury is used in – batteries, switches, housing, printed circuit boards – mercury is found in medical equipment, data transmission equipment, telecommunications equipment and cell phones as well – if is estimated that 22% of the yearly use of mercury is in electrical and electronic equipment • although a small amount of mercury is used, it is used in nearly all computer construction amounting to 400,000 pounds of mercury used between 1997 and 2004 • The problem – mercury spreads out in water transforming into methylated mercury which easily accumulates in living organisms – it enters the food chain through fish that swim in polluted waters – methylated mercury can cause chronic brain damage
  • 8. Other Chemical Elements • Cadmium is used in resistors for chips, infrared detectors and in semiconductors (plus older CRTs) – estimated that between 1997 and 2004, 2 million pounds of cadmium was used in computer components • The problem: – cadmium is classified as toxic, these compounds accumulate in the human body, particularly the kidneys – cadmium is absorbed through respiration and also food intake – cadmium has a half life of 30 years so that cadmium can poison a human body slowly through the human’s life • Hexavalent Chromium (Chromium VI) is used to treat steel plates (an anti-corrosive) and it is estimated that between 1997 and 2004, 1.2 million pounds were used in computer components – if you’ve seen Erin Brokovich, you know that this can lead to cancer and a number of other medical problems
  • 9. Plastics • Plastics are found throughout the computer, largely from casings but also internally to hold components together – 4 billion pounds of plastic were used to build computers and components between 1997 and 2004 • One specific form of plastics used is polyvinyl chloride (PVC) which is used in cabling and housings – PVC is difficult to recycle and the production and burning of PVC generates dioxins and furans • The plastics in computers are often treated with flame retardant chemicals, particularly brominated flame retardant – these chemicals can act as endocrine disrupters and increase risk of several forms of cancer – they have been found entering the food chain
  • 10. Chemical Elements Found in Computers and Components • Elements in bulk: lead, tin, copper, silicon, carbon, iron and aluminum • Elements in small amounts: cadmium and mercury • Elements in trace amounts: – germanium, gallium, barium, nickel, tantalum, indium, vanadium, terbium, beryllium, gold, europium, titanium, ruthenium, cobalt, palladium, manganese, silver, antimony, bismuth, selenium, niobium, yttrium, rhodium, platinum, arsenic, lithium, boron, americium • List of examples of devices containing these elements – almost all electronics contain lead & tin (as solder) and copper (as wire & PCB tracks), though the use of lead-free solder is now spreading rapidly – lead: solder, CRT monitors (Lead in glass), Lead-acid battery
  • 11. List Continued • List of examples of devices containing these elements – tin: solder – copper: copper wire, printed circuit board tracks – aluminum: nearly all electronic goods using more than a few watts of power – iron: steel chassis, cases & fixings – silicon: glass, transistors, ICs, Printed circuit boards. – nickel & cadmium: nickel-cadmium rechargeable batteries – lithium: lithium-ion battery – zinc: plating for steel parts – gold: connector plating, primarily in computer equipment – mercury: fluorescent tubes (numerous applications), tilt switches (pinball games, mechanical doorbells) – sulphur: lead-acid battery – carbon: steel, plastics, resistors
  • 12. Disposal • Consider that the average computer lifespan is about 2 years (cell phones < 2 years) – 10 years ago, the lifespan of a computer was 5 years – between 1997 and 2004, it is estimated that 315 million computers became obsolete (and were discarded, donated, or recycled) • 183 million computers were sold in 2004 (674 million cell phones!) • New users in China (178 million by 2010) and India (80 million by 2010) will require the creation of new computers • Disposal of these devices constituted 20-50 million tons per year (about 5% of the total waste of the planet) – this waste is called e-waste – where are we going to put all of it?
  • 13. Land Fills • Europe has outlawed using landfills for computer components – the US and Europe export a lot of e-waste to Asian landfills (especially China even though China has outlawed the importing of e-waste) – in addition, incineration of computer components leads to air pollution and airborne toxins
  • 14. Other Solutions • Reuse: donate your computer components to people who may not have or have lesser quality computers – inner city schools, churches, libraries, third world countries • this however leads to the older computers being dumped but there is probably no way around this as eventually the older computers would be discarded anyway • Refurbish: rather than discarding your computer when the next generation is released, just get a new CPU and memory chips – upgrade rather than replace – while you will still be discarded some components, you will retain most of the computer system (e.g., monitor, the system unit housing, cables) • Are there adequate incentives to do either of the above? Do computer companies encourage refurbishing/upgrading?
  • 15. One More Solution: Recycling • If companies can recycle the plastics and other components, this can greatly reduce waste and toxins – however, the hazardous materials in e-waste can harm the recycle workers if they are not properly protected • in undeveloped countries, a lot of the recycling chores are left up to unprotected children! • Developed countries now have facilities for recycling e- waste – however, in Europe, the plastics are discarded instead of recycled because the flame retardant chemicals are too toxic to work with • To resolve these problems, the computer manufacturers must start using recyclable chemicals
  • 16. How Do the Companies Rate? • 8: Nokia - regained its top position for eliminating the worst chemicals from many products – still needs to report on its recycling rate percentage • 7.3: Dell - still among the top but loses points for not having models free of the worst chemicals – strong support for global take back • 7.3: Lenovo - dropping down the rank for not having a clear global take back program – still missing out on products free of the worst chemicals on the market • 7: Sony Ericsson - among the top with clear timeline to have products free of the worst chemicals by 2008 – need better chemicals take back reporting program
  • 17. Continued • 6.7: Samsung - strong position for having a good chemical policy, but still lack products that are free from the worst chemicals – its take back system is not yet global and need improvement • 6.7: Motorola - some products on the market are free from the worst chemicals but loses points for not providing clear timelines for eliminating these chemicals in all products – score points on reporting the recycling rate • 6: Toshiba - good improvement particularly on waste and take back criteria – moved forward for providing some models without the worst chemicals and for timelines for complete phase out • 6: Fujitsu-Siemens - some models free of worst chemicals, but loses point for a weak take back and recycling program
  • 18. Continued • 5.7: Acer - standing still with improved chemical policies but no models free of the worst chemicals – needs to improve on take back program • 5.3: Apple - top mover with concrete timelines to eliminate the worst chemicals – loses points for not have a green product on the market and for a weak take back program • 5.3: HP - a free-faller, dropping down for failing to provide clear timelines for eliminating the worst chemicals – it looses points for weak definition of take back policies • 5: Panasonic - moving up for making available products free of the worst chemicals – loses point for poor take back program • 4: Sony - at the bottom of the rank for losing penalty point for inconsistent take back policies – some models without the worst chemicals