Informal Assessment
- 1. Instituto Pedagógico de Caracas Departamento de Idiomas Modernos Cátedra de Lingüística Prof. Rosynella Cardozo R. Prof. Jonathan Magdalena
- 2. Informal assessment is a way of collecting information about our students‘ performance in normal classroom conditions. This is done conditions without establishing test conditions such as in the case of formal assessment. Informal assessment is sometimes referred to as continuous assessment as it is done over a period of time. .
- 3. Informal Assessment is a form of systematic observation. observation Firstly, we need to work out what, when and where we are going to assess, as it is obviously impossible to assess all students' performance all the time. Then we must establish clear criteria for assessing students and not only rely on rough impressions. Finally it is important to link the informal assessment we do with our formal assessment (tests) and with self-assessment done by the students themselves. We must also give our students feedback to help them identify areas which may cause them difficulties when they do formal tests as well as heightening their awareness of how they assess themselves. .
- 4. A replacement for other forms of assessment such as formal or self-assessment. The only way of obtaining and giving information about our students. A way of avoiding tests altogether, which allows the teacher to make decisions about students based purely on informal observation. An impressionistic form of assessment without criteria on which to make judgments about students' progress. A single system which can be used by all teachers in all contexts. A form of assessment to be considered in isolation from other forms of assessment but rather as part of a larger, overall program which should be a balanced system of decision-making. .
- 5. Assign a grade for each statement in the following way: 5 Agree strongly/4 Agree/3 Indifferent/2 Disagree/1 Disagree strongly 1 Informal assessment of language skills is the most important area for us to assess informally. 2 Non-linguistic factors should not be assessed - this is the job of psychologists. 3 Informal assessment is simply the systematic observation of our students. 4 Informal assessment could replace all those time-consuming tests that I have to give. 5 Informal assessment should be part of an overall system of assessment. .
- 6. Assign a grade for each statement in the following way: 5 Agree strongly/4 Agree/3 Indifferent/2 Disagree/1 Disagree strongly 6 Informal assessment means what it says: 'informal' - I observe and make a judgments based on my experience - rating scales are a waste of time. 7 An adequate system of informal assessment already exists in my school - we take in essays and compositions and mark them. 8 Informal assessment can only take place in the classroom. 9 Even without set criteria, I always mark written work in the same way - I know what I am looking for. 10 Students sometimes act differently when I walk round the class and listen to their conversations. .
- 7. Decide which of the following items you assess informally by giving a mark or by merely getting an impression of. LINGUISTIC FACTORS Get an overall Give a specific impression mark a. written homework b. written grammar activities c. speaking activities d. projects e. listening tasks f. reading tasks g. writing tasks h. vocabulary activities . i. other
- 8. Decide which of the following items you assess informally by giving a mark or by merely getting an impression of. NON-LINGUISTIC FACTORS Get an overall Give a specific impression mark a. attitude/effort b. class participation c. group work d. organisation of work e. presentation of work f. punctuality g. other .
- 9. What will you mark informally? Essays, compositions? When will you carry out informal assessment? At the beginning of the process? Across the school term? Where will you implement it? In the classroom? As homework? Which aspects will you assess consciously and give grades? Which things will you get only a general impression of? What instrument will you use to assure reliability? How will you weight each area? What will you give most marks for? How much informal assessment will you do compared to formal and self/peer assessment? How balanced is your evaluation plan? .
- 10. “An adequate system of informal assessment already exists in my school - we take in essays and compositions and mark them.” Firstly, it means that we might tend to concentrate on written work and on grammar exercises rather than focusing on oral skills. Secondly, when we mark work we might assign marks on the basis of the 'impression' that we have of the work. We are not thinking in detail about what exactly we expect the students to achieve. Finally, when we add up marks at the end of term we tend to make judgments in terms of impressions and without a clear idea of what we are assessing.
- 11. Non-Linguistic Factors: Because of time, one practical option Factors is the use of a checklist. These may be Yes/No or Pass/Fail, checklist “the student can or cannot satisfy a certain criterion”. Another example may be “ability to work within a group”. Linguistic Factors: Here, it is much more likely that students Factors can satisfy criteria to a greater or lesser degree, in other words, they will be improving along he process, eg oral expression. In these cases, a more descriptive system of grading is needed than Yes/No or Pass/Fail. An alternative is to use a rating scale (Holistic or analytic) to grade student performance in these areas into a number of bands, eg 0 is a poor performance and 5 is an excellent performance.
- 12. SPEAKING Informal assessment of speaking solves the problem of practicality It can have a motivating effect on learners. It is done by observing students' oral performance in class We can systematize this gathering of impressions is by giving students points based on pre-defined criteria In a busy classroom, informal assessment is not always easy We may get a distorted view of overall class ability if we cannot listen to all students during all activities Some students might try harder when they know we are listening to them Students may perform worse in the knowledge that the teacher is actively monitoring them.
- 13. SPEAKING Decide on the assessment criteria and the type of scale to use Adapt these methods to your own particular situation Produce (with your colleagues) band scales to assess oral performance at any time you decide It is also possible to give your students the same bands and ask them to assess themselves (and then compare) Assess students' performance at a particular time. Tell students that you will be assessing them over the next few lessons With large classes, choose five or six students to assess in each lesson (though do not tell them that they have been assessed) During the tasks you can go around the class and write down your assessments of students' performance
- 14. SPEAKING TASKS Tasks that students normally do in class General group or pair-work activities Pair-work interviews Group surveys Role-plays Information-gap activities Oral presentations Games
- 15. WRITING Assessing written work can be very time consuming Decide how many and what sort of compositions are going to be assessed. Consider the amount of writing which should be done individually and that which is done in groups Make sure that the feedback given to students is used by them. The link between informal assessment of writing and self-assessment is vital (use correction codes) As with speaking, we need to think very carefully about what assessment criteria we need to use (rating scales, checklists…)
- 16. LISTENING We normally assess listening in lockstep fashion. This means that all the students listen to one text at the same time. We can informally assess students' listening proficiency by getting an impression of what they have understood We can also assess listening proficiency when monitoring activities or reactions to instructions from you One simple way of checking on answers may be asking for a show of hands to find out how many students (false impressions) Extralinguistic clues can often be a basis to assess listening proficiency, eg facial gestures (false impressions too)
- 17. LISTENING An alternative would be to go through the answers one by one and ask the class who answered correctly You can monitor class responses to each question and assess the class as a whole in relation to particular questions You can also ask students to recycle what they have heard either orally or in written form A further method of assessment is to use a recorded text as the basis for a speaking activity You can measure ability to understand language by observing students’ reaction to your instructions or their ability to understand each other When you need to make an overall judgment of listening ability, you can use band scales as for speaking and writing
- 18. LISTENING HOLISTIC SCALE (example) 5 Can understand complex messages Can understand different oral presentations Can distinguish between explicit and implicit information 4 Sometimes has difficulty with some complex messages . Can understand most oral presentations In general, can distinguish explicit and implicit information 3 Has difficulty with complex messages Has difficulty with some oral presentations Cannot, in general, distinguish between explicit and implicit information 2 Cannot understand complex messages Has difficulty with most types of oral presentation Cannot distinguish between explicit and implicit information 1 Cannot understand simple messages Cannot understand any type of oral presentation
- 19. READING We also assess reading in lockstep fashion (one task for all) You can assess reading by monitoring the way students behave during the reading activity (false impressions) Another way is by checking class understanding of some points from a given reading passage You can go through the answers with the whole class An alternative is to collect in answers to reading texts and mark them yourself (you might prefer a test instead) One thing you have to bear in mind is subject knowledge A more reliable alternative that of recycling information. For example, students can read a letter and then write a reply to it or read a text and then role-play a situation from it.
- 20. READING Jigsaw reading can be useful. Divide a text up and different groups have to tell the others about their part One way of checking understanding is by asking students to tell you about a text in their own language Students can also work out their own tasks on texts for other students to do (this includes students who have different reading styles, speeds, interests and ability) In mixed ability classes it can be particularly interesting to assess individual reading. One-to-one conversation is another option. You may wish to discuss a text As well as assessment through oral feedback, a quicker way is to get students to write about what they have read You can always use reading records, checklists or rating scales
- 21. READING INSTRUMENTS (example) READING RECORD FORM Name:; Class Title of book: Author: Summary of plot: Personal opinion:
- 22. READING INSTRUMENTS (example) RATING SCALE 5 Can understand all necessary text types with no difficulty 4 Has minor difficulty with different text types 3 Has considerable difficulty with different text types 2 Cannot understand different text types 1 Cannot understand any text type CHECKLIST 1 can understand factual articles in magazines YES NO 1 can understand informal letters YES NO
- 23. GRAMMAR AND VOCABULARY Informal assessment of grammar is often used at the practice stage of the lesson You can go around the class and identify problems You may find it useful to assess students' grasp of structure and lexis in general while they are doing free writing and speaking activities. Rather than assess communication as a whole', which we have looked at in previous sections, you can focus solely on language. You could go around the class and write down the most important mistakes that the students are making. You can go through the mistakes with the whole class, or alternatively plan remedial activities to deal with the problems.
- 24. GRAMMAR AND VOCABULARY As well as focusing on students' use of language you can also check their knowledge of it in an informal way through class quizzes. You can work out a series of questions to ask about both grammar and lexis and you can run the quiz in an enjoyable way, giving students bonus points, prizes etc. The sort of questions you can ask the groups are as follows: 'What is wrong with this sentence? My fathers are called John and Mary'. 'Make a sentence from these words. ' 'What does bicycle mean in Spanish, Italian etc?' In this informal way you can get an idea of your learners' knowledge and ability to use specific structures and lexis.
- 25. Attitude: The student is… interested in class activities, willing to offer opinions, co-operative with teacher/peers, willing to respond to the opinions of others Co-operativeness: The student is… is able to work in pairs, able to work in groups, able to work as a member of the whole class, able to share ideas and knowledge Independence: The student is… able to plan and organize own work, able to self-correct where necessary, able to use sources of information, Creativity and presentation: The student… shows original thought, initiative, inventiveness, presents work neatly and in an ordered manner