1. 1
I am Jayden Smith
I am here because I love to give presentations.
You can find me at @username
MARXIST
CRITICISM
REPORTERS:
Rodrigora, Ferle Mae S.
Tingcang, Dejey Ann A.
2. TOPIC OUTLINE
2
Introduction
Historical
Background
Reading from a Marxist
Perspective:
Economic Power
Reading from a Marxist
Perspective:
Materialism vs Spirituality
Reading from a Marxist
Perspective:
Class Conflict
Writing A Marxist Analysis:
Pre-writing
Writing A Marxist Analysis:
Drafting & Revising
4. KARL HEINRICH MARX (1818-1883)
4
➢ A 19th century German philosopher and
economist
➢ He argued that the means of production
controls a society’s institutions and beliefs,
contended that is history progressing
towards the eventual triumph of
communism, and introduced the concept
of
DIALECTICAL MATERIALISM
➢ Conflicts lead to historical/social/ideological
process through synthesis of those
contradictions.
5. FRIEDRICH ENGELS (1820-1895)
5
➢ Born in Barmen, Rhine province,
Prussia (Germany)
➢ A political economist
➢ The closest collaborator of Karl
Marx
8. “
8
8
• Marx’s writings still provide the history of Economy,
Sociology, History, Politics called Marxism.
• Although Marxism was not designed as a method of literary
analysis, it’s principles were applied to literature early on.
IDEOLOGY
- Consciousness and perceptions within a society often
controlled by the ruling class.
9. JOSEPH STALIN (1878-1959)
9
➢ A dictator of the Union of Soviet Socialist
Republics (USSR) from 1929-1953.
➢ The Soviet Union was transformed from a
peasant society into a industrial and
military superpower.
➢ He ruled by terror, and millions of his own
citizens dies during his brutal reign.
➢ He make certain that literature promoted
socialism, soviet actions, and its heroes
11. GEORG LUKACS (1885-1971)
11
➢ A Hungarian Marxist philosopher
➢ Influenced the mainstream of
European communist thought
during the first half of the 20th
century.
12. GEORG LUKACS (1885-1971)
12
REFLECTIONISM
➢ A text will reflect the society that has
produce it.
➢ Discover how characters and their
relationships typify and reveal class
conflict, the socioeconomic system, or the
politics of the time and place.
➢ Lead to an understanding of the system
and the author's worldview or
“weltanschauung”
13. GEORG LUKACS (1885-1971)
13
VULGAR MARXISM
➢ Seeks to determine the nature of a given
society
➢ To find “a truer, more concrete insight into
reality”
➢ To look for “the full process of life”
14. LOUIS ALTHUSSER (1918-1990)
14
➢ Algerian-born French philosopher
➢ Literature and art can affect
society, even lead it to
revolution.
➢ His ideas are called
“Production theory”
15. LOUIS ALTHUSSER (1918-1990)
15
INTERPELLATION
➢ Is a process in which we encounter our
culture’s values and internalize them.
➢ To explain in which ideas get into our
heads and have an effect on our lives, so
much that cultural ideas have such a hold
on us that we believe that they are our
own.
16. 16
2 BEST-KNOWN CRITICS
FREDRIC JAMESON TERRY EAGLETON
➢ An American literary critic
➢ Marxist political theorist
➢ He talks about the political
unconscious, the exploitation and
oppression buried in a work.
➢ British critic & literary theorist
➢ Interrelations between ideology
and literary form
➢ He sets himself against the
dominance of the privileged
class.
18. ECONOMIC POWER
18
MATERIAL CIRCUMSTANCES
- Economic conditions underlying
the society
HISTORICAL SITUATION
- The ideological atmosphere they
generate
A society is shape by its “forces of production”
19. ECONOMIC POWER
19
• Materials circumstances of her society have
relegated her to a dreary existence from which she
can find no exist.
Madame Loisel
- Has no commodity to sell, only her youth and
beauty to be used to attract a husband.
Monsieur Loisel
- Accept the situation that he does not understand
her hunger to be part of a more glamorous and
elegant world.
THE DIAMOND NECKLACE by Guy de Maupassant
21. ECONOMIC POWER
21
CAPITALISM
➢ An economic system in which private
actors own and control property in
accord with their interests, and demand
and supply freely set prices in markets
in a way that can serve the best
interests of society.
22. 22
2 PART STRUCTURE:
BOURGEOISIE
➢ Who own property and thereby control the means of production
PROLETARIAT
➢ The workers controlled by the bourgeoisie and whose labor
produces their wealth.
24. ECONOMIC POWER
24
COMMODIFICATION
➢ An attitude of valuing things not for utility (use
value) but for their power to impress (sign value)
or for their resale possibilities (exchange value).
CONSPICIOUS CONSUMPTION
- Is the purchase of goods or services for the specific
purpose of displaying one’s wealth.
26. 26
▪ Who are the powerful people in the society depicted in
the text?
▪ Who are the powerless people?
▪ Are the two groups depicted with equal attention.
▪ Which group are you encouraged to admire?
▪ Which do you have sympathy for?
▪ Why do the powerful people have their power?
▪ Why is this power denied to others?
▪ From what is the power in the narrative derived. For
example, is it inherited? Based on money? A result to
violence?
To examine the economic forces in the
narrative, you can these questions as a guide.
28. MATERIALISM vs SPIRITUALITY
28
"It is not our philosophical or religious beliefs that make
us who we are, for we are not spiritual beings but
socially constructed ones.“
➢ The material world will show us reality.
➢ Because the base and the superstructure are under
the control of the dominant class, the people’s
worldview is likely to be false; the critic’s obligation
is to expose the oppression and consequent
alienation that have been covered over.
29. 29
▪ What does the setting tell you about the distribution of
power and wealth?
▪ Is there evidence of conspicuous consumption?
▪ Does the society that is depicted value things for their
usefulness, for their potential for resale or trade, or for
their power to convey social status?
▪ Do you find in the text itself evidence that the work is a
product of the culture in which it originated?
▪ Where do you see characters making decisions based
not on abstract principles, but on the economic system in
which they live?
These insights will blossom from asking the
following questions:
31. CLASS CONFLICT
31
Basic Assumption in Marxism: The “forces of
production,” the way goods and services are produced,
will, in a capitalist society, inevitably generate conflict
between social classes created by the way economic
resources are used and who profits from them.
➢ The Marxist is aware that the working class does not
always recognize the system in which it has been
caught.
32. 32
■ How many different social classes do the characters represent?
■ Where do they struggle with each other?
■ Do you find repression and manipulation of workers by owners?
■ Is there evidence of alienation and fragmentation?
■ Does the bourgeoisie in the text, either consciously or
unconsciously, routinely repress and manipulate less powerful
groups? If so, what are the tools they use? News media? Religion?
Literature? Art?
■ Do the working-class characters realize their lack of power?
■ Does the work of literature advocate reform or revolution, either
overtly or obliquely?
In order to find evidence of class conflict and its
repercussions, we can ask the following questions about the
text you are analyzing:
34. 34
▪ What are the values of the author’s time and place? Where are
they reflected in the text?
▪ What biographical elements of the author’s life can account for
his or her ideology? For example, to what social class did the
author’s family belong? Where is that evident in the text?
▪ What are the socioeconomic conditions of the writer’s culture?
Where are they reflected in the text?
▪ Who read the work when it was published? How was it initially
received? Was it widely read? Banned? Favorably or
unfavorably reviewed?
▪ What were the circumstances of its publication? Was it quickly
accepted, widely distributed, highly promoted? Or was it
published with difficulty? Was it given limited distribution?
Take some time to examine the following questions:
35. 35
4 IMPORTANT GOALS
1. To clarify your understanding of the ideology of the work
2. To identity the elements of the text that present the ideology
3. To determine how those elements promote it—that is, convince
the reader to accept it
4. To assess how sympathetic or opposed it is to Marxist
principles.
37. 37
THE INTRODUCTION
▪ announce the ideology of the text and its relationship to Marxist
views
▪ it is important that your reader share your understanding of the
stance taken by the text.
38. 38
THE BODY
▪ The central part of your essay will demonstrate the acceptance or rejection of
Marxist principles in the text you are analyzing.
▪ You may choose to discuss each major character, assess the nature of the social
institutions
▪ depicted, or point out the struggles between groups of people.
▪ It might be helpful to think about the usefulness of explication, comparison and
contrast, and analysis.
39. 39
THE CONCLUSION
▪ The conclusion of a Marxist analysis often takes either the form of an
endorsement of classless societies in which everyone has equal access
to power and goods or of criticism of repressive societies when that is
not the case.
▪ You may find it interesting to reflect on what the work has revealed to
you about your own ideology.