SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Humanities perspectives on
digital scholarship
Dual levels of significance in Australian
historical data: the case for equilibrium
1http://www.versi.edu.au/
Dr Craig Bellamy
Analyst Digital Humanities
Secretary: Australasian Association for Digital Humanities
• What is historical significance?
• What is historical significant data?
• What is a ‘dual level of historical significant
data? (and why this is important for
preservation)
http://www.versi.edu.au/ 2
Historical significance
• Significance is a debate!
• Centred upon a community
• Different levels of significance (ie. local,
regional, national, international; academic
and public communities)
http://www.versi.edu.au/ 3
http://www.versi.edu.au/
4
http://www.versi.edu.au/ 5
http://www.versi.edu.au/ 6
http://www.versi.edu.au/ 7
http://www.versi.edu.au/ 8
Does digitisation make
something more historically
significant?
http://www.versi.edu.au/ 9
Sometimes...
http://www.versi.edu.au/ 10
http://www.versi.edu.au/ 11
http://www.versi.edu.au/ 12
Value-adding...
• Locatable (ANDS)
• Reusable (Open Data: API, RDF,
XML TEI
• Machine Readable: data of more
value when combined with other
data
..and People (the Digital Humanities)
http://www.versi.edu.au/ 13
http://trove.nla.gov.au/result?q=8+hour+
day
14
Adding a scholarly layer...
• Data doesn’t ‘speak for itself’; it can be
secondary or primary evidence about
historical phenomena (contextual
metadata important)
• It doesn't exist outside of interpretation (ie.
expert knowledge).Better systems need to
be developed to aid re-use and
interpretation (ie. facsimile copies often
don’t aid in interpretation)
http://www.versi.edu.au/ 15
http://www.pachube.com 16
http://www-958.ibm.com/software/data/cognos/manyeyes/ 17
http://www-
958.ibm.com/software/data/cognos/manyeyes/
18
http://criminalintent.org/getting-started/ 19
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/08/18/books/old-bailey-trials-are-tabulated-for-
scholars-online.html
20
http://www.versi.edu.au/ 21
Use creates significance...
• We are at a time of experimentation (lots of
different standards and approaches to using data)
(make data available in the most useable way
possible).
• Data document’s better than ‘published’ PDFs etc.
(they are OK if it is just one individual reader, but
often we need a computer to read and manipulate
data for new types of research)
• Individual approaches (ie. ‘focussed systems’)
often easier to use than broader approaches
http://www.versi.edu.au/ 22
Closing comments: Old data in new
bottles?
• Unless data is discoverable and usable;
there is little reason that it should be online
as it can’t be built upon and advanced
• Use of Data helps sustainability (many
barriers to open access)
• People create ‘significance’ through
turning data into knowledge and
wisdom...(many epistemological issues;
quantitative research etc.)
http://www.versi.edu.au/ 23
• Questions?
http://www.versi.edu.au/ 24

More Related Content

PPT
Contributing an Open Source Solution to the Library Community
PDF
Data journalismtips
PPTX
Your digital humanities are in my library! No, your library is in my digital ...
PPTX
Ed psy 510 6th class
PDF
'Your Scholarship. Our World. Preserving the Long Tail' by Vicky Reich
PPT
Planning Warehouse 13
PPTX
Research
PDF
myOntology: Community-driven Vocabulary Design and Maintenance for E-Commerce
Contributing an Open Source Solution to the Library Community
Data journalismtips
Your digital humanities are in my library! No, your library is in my digital ...
Ed psy 510 6th class
'Your Scholarship. Our World. Preserving the Long Tail' by Vicky Reich
Planning Warehouse 13
Research
myOntology: Community-driven Vocabulary Design and Maintenance for E-Commerce

What's hot (17)

PPTX
Increasing Student Engagement: Embedding in Undergraduate Research Experiences
PPTX
A Future Role for the Library Discovery Interface
PDF
KESW2012 Hackathon St Petersburg
PDF
Linked data: what it means, why it matters. Karen Coyle
PPTX
Artful learning
PDF
Starting Small: Practical First Steps in Digital Preservation
PDF
Whose Archives? Reflections on ethics and the cultural significance of web ar...
PPTX
Connected heritage: How should Cultural Institutions Open and Connect Data?
PPTX
NECTAR_VRE1
PPTX
Web RDF
PPTX
Bayer "Sustaining (and Reimagining) the Monograph"
PPTX
Libraries & Mobile Tech
PDF
UKSG 2018 Plenary - Privacy and the library patron: an ongoing ethical challe...
PPTX
MichalkoLibrary Collaboration iSchoolShareable-1
KEY
GOLD GALILEO 2010 Summary
PPTX
Web RDF
PPTX
Increasing Student Engagement: Embedding in Undergraduate Research Experiences
A Future Role for the Library Discovery Interface
KESW2012 Hackathon St Petersburg
Linked data: what it means, why it matters. Karen Coyle
Artful learning
Starting Small: Practical First Steps in Digital Preservation
Whose Archives? Reflections on ethics and the cultural significance of web ar...
Connected heritage: How should Cultural Institutions Open and Connect Data?
NECTAR_VRE1
Web RDF
Bayer "Sustaining (and Reimagining) the Monograph"
Libraries & Mobile Tech
UKSG 2018 Plenary - Privacy and the library patron: an ongoing ethical challe...
MichalkoLibrary Collaboration iSchoolShareable-1
GOLD GALILEO 2010 Summary
Web RDF
Ad

Viewers also liked (15)

PPSX
Lexound PRO 6000 headset for call centers
ODP
PPTX
วิธีการสร้างตารางใน Microsoft Word
DOCX
Transcripts
PPTX
Evaluation of my Final Product
DOCX
Lilliana Hernández Pérez CV
DOCX
Ecuaciones diferenciales 1
PPT
LaTrobe_eCoffee_5-Nov-10
PDF
Sammy Koenigsberg
PPTX
As 10 melhores frases motivacionais de filmes
PDF
WhitepaperDigitalHumanities
PPTX
EL INTERNET
PDF
Propiedades del arándano
DOC
PDF
Ser Publicos Edicion 19
Lexound PRO 6000 headset for call centers
วิธีการสร้างตารางใน Microsoft Word
Transcripts
Evaluation of my Final Product
Lilliana Hernández Pérez CV
Ecuaciones diferenciales 1
LaTrobe_eCoffee_5-Nov-10
Sammy Koenigsberg
As 10 melhores frases motivacionais de filmes
WhitepaperDigitalHumanities
EL INTERNET
Propiedades del arándano
Ser Publicos Edicion 19
Ad

Similar to paradisec-conf (20)

PPTX
Data and science
PDF
MPhil Lecture on Data Vis for Analysis
PPT
Esad 12may2010
PDF
CAEPIA 2011
PPTX
Beyond the Black Box: Data Visualisation
PDF
From Access to Use: the quality of human-archives interactions as a research ...
PDF
Digital Humanities and “Digital” Social Sciences
PPTX
FSCI Data Discovery
PDF
Parthenos Webinar Make It Happen - Carrying Out Research and Analyzing Data
PPT
Open Data Publication - Requirements, Good practices, and Benefits
PPT
Towards a digital library for York
PPTX
Data, librarians, and services
PPT
Jankowski, Vks E Research Slidecast, 26 June2008
PPTX
Digital Cultural Heritage: Experiences from British Library
PPTX
Digital Cultural Heritage: Experiences from British Library
PDF
Libraries Connect Communities to History
PPT
What does open science mean? A stakeholder perspective
PPT
What's the Point Of Digitisation: Measuring Use and Impact
PPT
Presentation by Ingrid Parent: Digital Academic Content and the Future of Lib...
PPTX
The Challenges of Making Data Travel, by Sabina Leonelli
Data and science
MPhil Lecture on Data Vis for Analysis
Esad 12may2010
CAEPIA 2011
Beyond the Black Box: Data Visualisation
From Access to Use: the quality of human-archives interactions as a research ...
Digital Humanities and “Digital” Social Sciences
FSCI Data Discovery
Parthenos Webinar Make It Happen - Carrying Out Research and Analyzing Data
Open Data Publication - Requirements, Good practices, and Benefits
Towards a digital library for York
Data, librarians, and services
Jankowski, Vks E Research Slidecast, 26 June2008
Digital Cultural Heritage: Experiences from British Library
Digital Cultural Heritage: Experiences from British Library
Libraries Connect Communities to History
What does open science mean? A stakeholder perspective
What's the Point Of Digitisation: Measuring Use and Impact
Presentation by Ingrid Parent: Digital Academic Content and the Future of Lib...
The Challenges of Making Data Travel, by Sabina Leonelli

More from Craig Bellamy (20)

PPTX
The Ethics of AI in Education
PPTX
Digital Humanities Pathways Semiar: University of Melbourne
PDF
Bellamy_certificate
PPTX
Facilitation based training in the Higher Ed sector
PPTX
Blended_Conference_pres_v4_MR
PPTX
Bellamy_death_DHA2016
PPTX
cbellamy_presentation1
PPT
IBES poster pias
PPTX
PIAS - POSTER - 2011
PDF
BoF Bellamy et al 2010
PDF
arts-humanities-A4
PDF
PPTX
Bellamy_death_internet1
PDF
Digital Humanities Workshop 22 March 2011
PPTX
Planning Session 3 AADH (priorities)
PPTX
Planning Session 2 AADH (framework)
PPT
PPT
PPT
smith_street_2014
PPT
IS_2010
The Ethics of AI in Education
Digital Humanities Pathways Semiar: University of Melbourne
Bellamy_certificate
Facilitation based training in the Higher Ed sector
Blended_Conference_pres_v4_MR
Bellamy_death_DHA2016
cbellamy_presentation1
IBES poster pias
PIAS - POSTER - 2011
BoF Bellamy et al 2010
arts-humanities-A4
Bellamy_death_internet1
Digital Humanities Workshop 22 March 2011
Planning Session 3 AADH (priorities)
Planning Session 2 AADH (framework)
smith_street_2014
IS_2010

paradisec-conf