SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Performance-Based Public
Participation
CTAA Expo 2016
May 2016
Southern Georgia
Regional Commission
DHS/5311 Coordinated Transportation
DHS/5311 Non-Coordinated
Transportation
Valdosta Urbanized Area
DHS Human Service Transportation
Okefenokee
National
Wildlife
Refuge
Outline
• What is Performance Management?
• Principles of PBPP and PP
• Qualitative vs. Quantitative
• Examples from VLMPO
Definitions
• Performance management includes activities
which ensure that goals are consistently being
met in an effective and efficient manner
(Wikipedia)
• Transportation Performance Management as
a strategic approach that uses system
information to make investment and policy
decisions to achieve national performance
goals (FHWA)
PBPP Principles
• Measureable Outcomes
• Strategic Direction
– Goals, Objectives, Measures
• Analysis
– Trends, Targets, Strategies, Priorities
• Planning and Programming
– Allocate Resources
• Implementation
– Measuring, Evaluation, Reporting
PBPP in the Planning Process
Public Involvement Principles
• Reasonable Opportunity for Involvement
– Events and Communications
• Documented Process
– Policies, Strategies, Performance Measures
Qualitative vs. Quantitative
• How do you measure if public participation
was effective?
– 5 people showed up, but you had great input and
dialogue
– 100 people showed up, but you had little
feedback, little dialogue
• Numbers only take you so far
– How much did you spend per person on your last
public comment period?
VLMPO Examples
• Participation Plan Structure
– Includes Title VI Assurance Plan & LEP Plan
– Policies, Strategies, Performance Measures
• Annual Report
– PP Performance Measures
VLMPO PP Policies
• Meetings Notification & Accessibility
– Timeliness, location, LEP, agendas,
• Public Comment Periods
– Timeliness, location, comments, interested parties
• LRTP/TIP Amendments
– Comments, events
• Open Records, Title VI Complaints, etc.
VLMPO PP Strategies
• A means to an end – not associated with
policies
• Speakers, newsletters, media, publications,
social media, open houses, events, hearings,
comments, surveys, committees, stakeholders,
focus groups, LEP, accessibility, CCV
collaboration, partnerships, marketing
VLMPO PP Performance Measures
• Defined by the strategies
– Quantitative
– Trackable with Trends
• Annual Report indicates: increase, decrease, neutral
– None that are qualitative
PP Performance Measurement
• Public Relations Measures
• Use the tools available to us
• Measure everything we can
• Learn from past experiences
• Technology is changing public participation
Questions?
www.sgrc.us
Corey Hull, AICP
229-333-5277 or chull@sgrc.us

More Related Content

PDF
Case Study for Research Ethics Social Audit for Public Service Delivery_PACc
PPTX
Organizational Capacity Assessments for Policy, Advocacy, Financing, and Gove...
PDF
Impact Evaluation for Policy Making_Promoting Uptake of Impact Evaluation Fin...
PPTX
Framework and Toolkit to Strengthen Evaluation Capacity
PPTX
RAPID perspective on Research into Use
PDF
Criteria and indicators for defining and measuring peatland restoration
PDF
Using case-based methods to assess scalability and sustainability: Lessons fr...
PPTX
PPWNov13- Day 3- S. Babu- IFPRI
Case Study for Research Ethics Social Audit for Public Service Delivery_PACc
Organizational Capacity Assessments for Policy, Advocacy, Financing, and Gove...
Impact Evaluation for Policy Making_Promoting Uptake of Impact Evaluation Fin...
Framework and Toolkit to Strengthen Evaluation Capacity
RAPID perspective on Research into Use
Criteria and indicators for defining and measuring peatland restoration
Using case-based methods to assess scalability and sustainability: Lessons fr...
PPWNov13- Day 3- S. Babu- IFPRI

What's hot (20)

PDF
Impact Evaluation Step by Step Evaluating the Impact of Formality_GRADE
PPTX
Using SURVEYBE to improve the collection of panel data experience from EDI
PPTX
Monitoring stakeholder engagement
PPTX
IFAD’s Approach to Policy Engagement
PPTX
CRP on Policies, Institutions and Markets (PIM) independent evaluation : Brie...
PDF
The Organizational Capacity Assessment Tool
PDF
Molly Irwin - Evidence informed policy making - 27 June 2017
PPTX
Assessing the PEPFAR Global OVC Graduation Benchmarks
PPTX
CR and Sustainability - Research methodology
PDF
Rwanda stakeholder & action mapping 2014 15
PDF
Session 11.1: Gender in NAPs (NAP GN, NAP-Ag, (FAO/UNDP))
PDF
12.1.4 Strategic communication (NAP GN)- Gender session
PDF
11.2 Climate Resilience Roadshow Introduction
PDF
Water Research Impact and Uptake Workshop wrap up
PDF
Training on Monitoring & Evaluation (M&E) of Adaptation and the NAP process
PPTX
Daphne outcome measures final
PPTX
Elements of implementing innovation platform
PPTX
Strengthening the links between research and practice: the Research in Librar...
PDF
Guidance on CRP Commissioned Evalautions
PDF
Stakeholder mapping lr part 2
Impact Evaluation Step by Step Evaluating the Impact of Formality_GRADE
Using SURVEYBE to improve the collection of panel data experience from EDI
Monitoring stakeholder engagement
IFAD’s Approach to Policy Engagement
CRP on Policies, Institutions and Markets (PIM) independent evaluation : Brie...
The Organizational Capacity Assessment Tool
Molly Irwin - Evidence informed policy making - 27 June 2017
Assessing the PEPFAR Global OVC Graduation Benchmarks
CR and Sustainability - Research methodology
Rwanda stakeholder & action mapping 2014 15
Session 11.1: Gender in NAPs (NAP GN, NAP-Ag, (FAO/UNDP))
12.1.4 Strategic communication (NAP GN)- Gender session
11.2 Climate Resilience Roadshow Introduction
Water Research Impact and Uptake Workshop wrap up
Training on Monitoring & Evaluation (M&E) of Adaptation and the NAP process
Daphne outcome measures final
Elements of implementing innovation platform
Strengthening the links between research and practice: the Research in Librar...
Guidance on CRP Commissioned Evalautions
Stakeholder mapping lr part 2
Ad

Similar to Performance Based Public Participation (20)

PPTX
PEC Performance Presentation
PPTX
management exclusive 101 key findings.pptx
PDF
Setting the scene – Trends in programming Research and Innovation for Impact
PDF
IWEco Webinar: Monitoring & Evaluation of Communication Campaigns – Dr. Pete...
PDF
Evidence On Trial: weighing the value of evidence in academic enquiry, policy...
PPT
Synthesis of symposium outcomes
 
PPTX
Evaluating HIV Policy Advocacy: The Local Capacity Initiative
PDF
Lena Etuk Why Measure Social Impact?
PPTX
Importance of M&E
PDF
C8 logical framework approach (lfa)
PPTX
Participative Rural Appraisal,Tools,Techniques Requirements, Scope,Risks, by...
PDF
Introduction to Policy Evaluation
PPTX
Elements of implementing innovation platform
PDF
Stakeholder engagement, communications or knowledge on working abroad – who c...
PDF
Performance budgeting in health: Outline of key issues - Ronnie Downes, OECD
PPTX
M & E approaches for key population programs: perils, pitfalls, and promising...
PDF
Seminar on Advisory and Knowledge Services: Evidence for What Works (Sept 17,...
PPTX
Evaluation of SME and entreprenuership programme - Jonathan Potter & Stuart T...
PPTX
Recap day 1 and 2
PDF
Arts Council England Environmental Reporting - Updating Policy and Action Pla...
PEC Performance Presentation
management exclusive 101 key findings.pptx
Setting the scene – Trends in programming Research and Innovation for Impact
IWEco Webinar: Monitoring & Evaluation of Communication Campaigns – Dr. Pete...
Evidence On Trial: weighing the value of evidence in academic enquiry, policy...
Synthesis of symposium outcomes
 
Evaluating HIV Policy Advocacy: The Local Capacity Initiative
Lena Etuk Why Measure Social Impact?
Importance of M&E
C8 logical framework approach (lfa)
Participative Rural Appraisal,Tools,Techniques Requirements, Scope,Risks, by...
Introduction to Policy Evaluation
Elements of implementing innovation platform
Stakeholder engagement, communications or knowledge on working abroad – who c...
Performance budgeting in health: Outline of key issues - Ronnie Downes, OECD
M & E approaches for key population programs: perils, pitfalls, and promising...
Seminar on Advisory and Knowledge Services: Evidence for What Works (Sept 17,...
Evaluation of SME and entreprenuership programme - Jonathan Potter & Stuart T...
Recap day 1 and 2
Arts Council England Environmental Reporting - Updating Policy and Action Pla...
Ad

More from Valdosta-Lowndes Metropolitan Planning Organization (19)

PDF
Making the Case for Transit: Valdosta Pilot Shuttle Program
PPTX
Bicycle and Pedestrian Planing in Southern Georgia
PPTX
2040 Transportation Vision Plan Highlights
PPTX
By the Number: Lowndes County in 2040
PPTX
Travel Demand Model VLMPO CAC-TAC
PPTX
2040 Transportation Plan Hahira Presentation
PPTX
PPTX
Climate Change and Transportation Planning
PPTX
Sociology Applied in Transportation Planning Spring 2014
PPTX
A Common Community Vision for Greater Lowndes County
PPTX
2040 Socioeconomic Study - GLPC Presentation
PPTX
2040 Socioeconomic Study - VLMPO Presentation
PPTX
Sociology Applied to Transportation Planning
PPTX
PPTX
FY2013 Valdosta-Lowndes MPO Annual Report Summary
PPTX
2030 and 2035 Transportation Plans Review
PPTX
Georgia Transportation Infrastructure Bank
PPTX
Regional Transportation Planning an Introduction
PPT
Georgia's Transportation Investment Act: Lessons Learned
Making the Case for Transit: Valdosta Pilot Shuttle Program
Bicycle and Pedestrian Planing in Southern Georgia
2040 Transportation Vision Plan Highlights
By the Number: Lowndes County in 2040
Travel Demand Model VLMPO CAC-TAC
2040 Transportation Plan Hahira Presentation
Climate Change and Transportation Planning
Sociology Applied in Transportation Planning Spring 2014
A Common Community Vision for Greater Lowndes County
2040 Socioeconomic Study - GLPC Presentation
2040 Socioeconomic Study - VLMPO Presentation
Sociology Applied to Transportation Planning
FY2013 Valdosta-Lowndes MPO Annual Report Summary
2030 and 2035 Transportation Plans Review
Georgia Transportation Infrastructure Bank
Regional Transportation Planning an Introduction
Georgia's Transportation Investment Act: Lessons Learned

Recently uploaded (20)

PDF
PPT Item # 2 -- Announcements Powerpoint
PPTX
26.1.2025 venugopal K Awarded with commendation certificate.pptx
PPTX
11Sept2023_LTIA-Cluster-Training-Presentation.pptx
PPTX
sepsis.pptxMNGHGBDHSB KJHDGBSHVCJB KJDCGHBYUHFB SDJKFHDUJ
PDF
ISO-9001-2015-internal-audit-checklist2-sample.pdf
PPTX
SOMANJAN PRAMANIK_3500032 2042.pptx
DOC
LU毕业证学历认证,赫尔大学毕业证硕士的学历和学位
PDF
Abhay Bhutada and Other Visionary Leaders Reinventing Governance in India
PPTX
School Education Programs for Social Impact Learn with Parramatta Mission
PDF
It Helpdesk Solutions - ArcLight Group
PDF
Population Estimates 2025 Regional Snapshot 08.11.25
PPTX
Introduction_to_the_Study_of_Globalization.pptx
PDF
2025 Shadow report on Ukraine's progression regarding Chapter 29 of the acquis
PDF
ISO-9001-2015-gap-analysis-checklist-sample.pdf
PDF
PPT Items # 6&7 - 900 Cambridge Oval Right-of-Way
PPTX
GOVERNMENT-ACCOUNTING1. bsa 4 government accounting
PDF
4_Key Concepts Structure and Governance plus UN.pdf okay
PDF
PPT Item #s 2&3 - 934 Patterson SUP & Final Review
PPTX
Presentatio koos kokos koko ossssn5.pptx
PDF
Items # 6&7 - 900 Cambridge Oval Right-of-Way
PPT Item # 2 -- Announcements Powerpoint
26.1.2025 venugopal K Awarded with commendation certificate.pptx
11Sept2023_LTIA-Cluster-Training-Presentation.pptx
sepsis.pptxMNGHGBDHSB KJHDGBSHVCJB KJDCGHBYUHFB SDJKFHDUJ
ISO-9001-2015-internal-audit-checklist2-sample.pdf
SOMANJAN PRAMANIK_3500032 2042.pptx
LU毕业证学历认证,赫尔大学毕业证硕士的学历和学位
Abhay Bhutada and Other Visionary Leaders Reinventing Governance in India
School Education Programs for Social Impact Learn with Parramatta Mission
It Helpdesk Solutions - ArcLight Group
Population Estimates 2025 Regional Snapshot 08.11.25
Introduction_to_the_Study_of_Globalization.pptx
2025 Shadow report on Ukraine's progression regarding Chapter 29 of the acquis
ISO-9001-2015-gap-analysis-checklist-sample.pdf
PPT Items # 6&7 - 900 Cambridge Oval Right-of-Way
GOVERNMENT-ACCOUNTING1. bsa 4 government accounting
4_Key Concepts Structure and Governance plus UN.pdf okay
PPT Item #s 2&3 - 934 Patterson SUP & Final Review
Presentatio koos kokos koko ossssn5.pptx
Items # 6&7 - 900 Cambridge Oval Right-of-Way

Performance Based Public Participation

  • 2. Southern Georgia Regional Commission DHS/5311 Coordinated Transportation DHS/5311 Non-Coordinated Transportation Valdosta Urbanized Area DHS Human Service Transportation Okefenokee National Wildlife Refuge
  • 3. Outline • What is Performance Management? • Principles of PBPP and PP • Qualitative vs. Quantitative • Examples from VLMPO
  • 4. Definitions • Performance management includes activities which ensure that goals are consistently being met in an effective and efficient manner (Wikipedia) • Transportation Performance Management as a strategic approach that uses system information to make investment and policy decisions to achieve national performance goals (FHWA)
  • 5. PBPP Principles • Measureable Outcomes • Strategic Direction – Goals, Objectives, Measures • Analysis – Trends, Targets, Strategies, Priorities • Planning and Programming – Allocate Resources • Implementation – Measuring, Evaluation, Reporting
  • 6. PBPP in the Planning Process
  • 7. Public Involvement Principles • Reasonable Opportunity for Involvement – Events and Communications • Documented Process – Policies, Strategies, Performance Measures
  • 8. Qualitative vs. Quantitative • How do you measure if public participation was effective? – 5 people showed up, but you had great input and dialogue – 100 people showed up, but you had little feedback, little dialogue • Numbers only take you so far – How much did you spend per person on your last public comment period?
  • 9. VLMPO Examples • Participation Plan Structure – Includes Title VI Assurance Plan & LEP Plan – Policies, Strategies, Performance Measures • Annual Report – PP Performance Measures
  • 10. VLMPO PP Policies • Meetings Notification & Accessibility – Timeliness, location, LEP, agendas, • Public Comment Periods – Timeliness, location, comments, interested parties • LRTP/TIP Amendments – Comments, events • Open Records, Title VI Complaints, etc.
  • 11. VLMPO PP Strategies • A means to an end – not associated with policies • Speakers, newsletters, media, publications, social media, open houses, events, hearings, comments, surveys, committees, stakeholders, focus groups, LEP, accessibility, CCV collaboration, partnerships, marketing
  • 12. VLMPO PP Performance Measures • Defined by the strategies – Quantitative – Trackable with Trends • Annual Report indicates: increase, decrease, neutral – None that are qualitative
  • 13. PP Performance Measurement • Public Relations Measures • Use the tools available to us • Measure everything we can • Learn from past experiences • Technology is changing public participation