Plaintiff's reply in brief in response to defendant's response brief and in support of the plaintiff's motion for summary judgment

Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 92 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/18/2012 Page 1 of 35

I TH E U N I
N TED STA TES D I STR I T C O U RT FO R
C FI by '
LED D.
C.
TH E SO U TH ER N D ISTR I T O F FLO D A
C

CA SE N 0 . 1I ZOI CI - TZ/ M ON TO N
: - ZO- V SEI Sl J
'AN 8 2 1
22
STEVEN M .L MORE
ARI
CLERK U. DI CT
S ST
s. o FL - MI MI
D. f A. A
TR AI BU JD UV EAN U ,
AN
Pl i if
a nt f ,

VS.

D l A s CHA RI E s,l c . A N A G I
sM TI x , SPER T,
DEREK Ti o m s a LA SH AN D A AD AM S
l nd
De e nt
f nda s.

PLAI FF' REPLY BRI I RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT' RESPONSE BRI
NTI S EF N S EF
AND I SUPPORT OF THE PLAI FF' M O TI FO R SUM M ARY JUDGEM ENT
N NTI S ON

Pli ifTr in Bed ve n ( oSeLiia t, ratrk o a ç o a f, ie ti
ant aa j u a u Pr
f t n )hee fe n wn s t v n 'fls h s
g M
r s et t Defnda ' Re yBreli Suppor oft Pli ifsM oton f Summay
epons o he e nts pl it n t he antf' i or r
Judgm e and s a e a f l w s:
nt t t s s olo

Introducton
i

Defnda DimasCha iis l ,anon- ottc porton501c( or niai who
e nt s rte ,nc. pr i or ai ()3) ga z ton,
o r t s 28 ha f ho esi 1 s a e t tc r t 9o t U . G o m m e ,ofw hi h Co-
pe a e l way us n 3 t t s ha ontac s m he S. ve nt c
de e nt AnaGipe q De e Tom a a Las ndaAdamsa ee oyee ofDim a Cha ii ,
f nda s s r rk s nd ha r mpl s s s rtes
l ,e e e i o t doc to 1 1 201 abre i r s ns t t M ova ' r s
nc. nt r d nt he ke n / 2/ 2 i f n e po e o he nt s e pons br e ,i
e if n
whi h t y m a an t te pt't as e t ha t M ova ,i una e t s a e a ba i f hi c ai s
c he de t t m ' o s r t t he
a nt s bl o t t s s or s l m ,
whehe ofaco tt tonalort tousnaur . TheDe e nt r s ns brefwassmpl t t
t r nsiu i ori t e f nda s' e po e i i y ha ,
a ta t m pf' ast y f l d t a r s a orr butt co e e e e soft Pl i if s
n t te , he aie o dd e s nd/ e he r l m nt he a ntf '
a gu e s and mor i
r m nt , e mpora l t ra gu e t a edevoi oft t t a f c ta sa e e s
tnty hei r m n s r d he nzh, nd a tz l tt m nt
i c tng t tt D e e nt a i w e e i c pl t c pla e w ih gui i s tf t
ndi a i ha he f nda s' ctons r n om e e om i nc t delnes e or h
bot by t D e rm entofC o r to a w el asM o nt spr ec i nsi r ntw ihi t
h he pa t r ec i ns s l va ' ot to nhe e t n he
Consi i Thi r po et t Def nda ' r pl bref wila n r butt De e nts
tmton. s es ns o he e nts e y i , l gai e he f nda '
a gu e s a wila addii na clrt t t co e i nsorgnal m a i t M ova '
r m nt , nd l dd to l a iy o he nt nto i i ly de n he nts
Compl nt M oton f Sum ma yJ
ai , i or r udgm e t t Cour,a hi r s ns bre t t De e nt
nt o he t nd s e po e if o he f nda s
rs
e pons bref
e i .


Fact Backeround
ual

On J y,28,201 wih t a ova ofCCM Die orCa l Rodrgu t M ovantwa
ul 0, t he ppr l r ct ros i ez he s
ta f rfom Col n Low Co r c i Fa iiyt Dim a Cha ii s I .ha f hous l at d
r ns e r ma r e tonal c lt o s s rte , nc l way e, oc e
i Da a,Fl rda.Asi not a
n ni o i s ed bove Defnda Dima Cha ii , l ,i no pr co o a i n
, e nt s s rtes nc. s n- oft m r to
5 ()3 o g niain, oo eae 2 h lwa h us si 1 sae t t o ta tfo teU.
01c( ) r a z to wh p r ts 8 af y o e n 3 tts ha c n rc ' m h S
r
Gove m e ,ofwhih Co- e nt Ana Giper,De e To a a Las ndaAda a e
m nt c def nda s s t r k m s nd ha ms r
e oye ofDimasCha ii I m o ai
mpl es s rtes nco r ton.

U po a rvala D im a Cha ii f iiy, he M o nts r e r e ve a pa ke c a ni
n ri t s s r tes ac lt t va i d ec i d c t ont i ng
t Dim a Halwa Hous Re l tons butdi notr eveaDimasCha ii Ha
he s s f y e gu ai , d ec i s rtes ndbook, as
t r wer none a ia ea t tm eofhi a rva . I i i pora t not t tt Dim a
he e e va lbl t he i s r i l t s m tnt o e ha he s s
Halwa Hous Regultonsbook i nott s me a Ha
f y e ai s he a s ndbook a doesnotc an t s me
nd ont i he a
i or i a i i onl ac s y ove viw oft polc e a pr e esc ai d wihi t
nf maton s t s y ur or r e he ii s nd oc dur ont ne t n he
handbook,a t ha boo doc t d ase de eha be n modii d sncet M ova ss ond
nd he nd k ke e vi nc s e fe i he nt ec
a r s a l w s t The M ova pr vi d t a opr a e saf m e be sw ih c esofhi dr ve
r e t nd a ui. nt o de he ppr i t t f m r t opi s i r
lc ns ,drvi hit y fom t Di son ofM ot Ve clsi Tal ha s e vehi l r gi katon,
i e e i ng sor r he vii or hi e n la s e , ce e s i
a vai i m a e,i c pla ewih t tr sa c ndii nec s r t o an pe s i
nd ld ns nc n om i nc t he e m nd o tons es a y o bt i nnison
t o ae am ot ve c edurng s r ii Bet ta i m a t r a on f whih t
o per t or hi l i upe v son. ha s t y, he e s or c he
M ova wa nota ove t drve asco e
nt s ppr d o i , nt nded byt De e nt, i unkno e n t
he f nda s s wn ve oday. l t
wa f t sr s t tt Pl i ifdi notf e a t
s or hi ea on ha he antf d e l s hough hewa vi a i t tr sofhi
s oltng he e m s
c i m e whe on O c o r 1 201 t M ovantdr hi f m iy ve cl t D i m ashal wa
ontne nt n t be 3, 0, he ove s a l hi e o s f y
ho e f hi biwee y r po t
us or s - kl e r.

An il ga s r h wasco uced oft ve c et M o ntdr a pr pe t wa
le l ea c nd t he hil hat va ove nd o ry s
r m ove fom t ve cl wiho t kno e oft M ova a wiho t M o ntbeng
e d r he hi e t ut he wl dge he nt nd t ut he va i
pr s nta t s a c D e e nt a s red t ta c l a t l phone a phone c r a a pa ke
e e t he e r h. f nda s s e t ha elul r e e , ha ger nd c t
ofc ga e t we e f
i r tes r ound i t gl c
n he ove ompa t ntoft c ra c nfs a e . Daa a e de e
rme he a nd o i c t d t nd vi nc
fom t s vela ca r st tc ai d i or ton r ga di t il ls r h a s zu e
r he ur il nce me a ha ont ne nf ma i e r ng he lega ea c nd ei r
we ei e i ly de to d.
r nt ntona l sr ye

D urng hi r i nc a D i m a H ous ,t M o ntw a c ns a l t r orzed,
i s es de y t s s e he va s o t nty e r i
i i i t d,a hum iit d wihouta r ga d f rhi m e c lcondii orhi diniy, i t t
ntm da e nd la e t ny e r o s di a tons s g t n ha
h wa f r e t d ce nn j bswhc we ei dr c vilto o h sd co ' dr ci e
e s o c d o o la ig o ih r n ie t oain f i o t rs ie tv s
doc or sor s e n g ng a f rast pr ve hi m e ca t e t e , a dn i ut oij y l
t ' der , ve oi s a o e nt s di l r a m nt d ig ns lt nur . n
vi a i ofhi Til V 1 pr e tons t M ova w a dicrm i t d a ha as e co t l , by
ol ton s te 1 ot c i , he nt s s i na e nd r s d nsanty
t Defnda s bec us hewa af e g r s kewih a a c nt pr c ied Gr k- t
he e nt , a e s or i ne , po t n c e , a tc ee orhodox
Rei on,a i whie.
lgi nd s t

On Oc o r20,201 at6: A . . whie se pi i hi be a DimasHous , t
t be 0, 30 M , l l e ng n s d t s e he
m ova wa a r se by t U . M arhala nt a ta po td t F. .C.M i mi wihouta
nt s r e t d wo S. s l ge s nd r ns re o D a , t ny
c r lvi a i thi a wihoutI uePr ce sofLa . The i r e a i n w asdone
ha ges e ed gans m nd t l o s w nca c r to
wihoutt knowldge ofUSPO a CCM Die t r Ca l Rodrgue , a he di nots> t
t he e nd r c o , ros i z s d i he
pa r f t i a c r ton, husm a ng i cla t tt De e nt e ge i ac m pa gn of
pe s or he nc r e a i t ki t e r ha he f nda s nga d n a i


e asng e de e a f brc tng doc e si o dert c
r i vi nc nd a i a i um nt n r o overup a s pi i oft e nt .
ny us con he ve s
Th M o a i a r ta tef l wigd c me t h veb e fb iae ( o a tsEx bt
e v nt s wa e h t h ol n o u n s a e n a rc td M v n ' hii,
o
Do u n s# 8 41 5 , 8 6 , , 6 .Nofd rl mpo e o F. C. ne t g tiv le
c me t 3 , , 3 5 , 0 61 6 ) e e a e ly e f D. wa td o e n ov d
wih hi ca e t y we ea r oft c r a ilgala i oft Def nt Fe r l
t s s , he r wa e he ove t nd le ctons he enda . de a
D e r m e ofCor e tonsM i iCo e orPr c a Uni M a ge H a r s n,
pa t nt r ci am uns l i e nd t na r r i o unde t sr c
r he t i t
s si nsoft F. C.war n,a tm ptd i af w i tnc st co a tt ofi eofCCM
ugge to he D. de te e n e nsa e o nt c he fc
Di e t r Ca l Rodr gue t no a l The M o ntw a uli a e y r e e f om F. . . i m i
r c o , r os i z, o vai. va s tm t l el as d r DC M a
on J nua y 03,2011
a r .

Di ctRe pons t De e
re s e o f ndantsArzum e sa Ciaton t Aut iv
' nt nd t i o hort

The Pl nt f cannotm ai ai any c e o acton aga ns any D e e
ai if nt n aus f i i t f ndant.
a. Fal e A rres and I pri onm ent
s t m s
TheDef nda s i t i r s ebrefm a t e ero o a s ri a
e nt ' n he r e pons i ke hr e r ne us s e tons boutt
he
pl i i fw ih r a dst hi a gu e s on f l e ar e ta i prs e :
a ntf t eg r o s r m nt a s r s nd m i onm nt
t antf f ist s tf rh a f t de o tatng a f s i ionme o a r s by
t i if a l o e o t ny acs m nsr i
pl ale mprs nt r re t
a s ii Dee nt'( 3ofDef nt r pons bret
ny pectc fnda ' p. enda s' es e i ).
2. t hePl ntf w a unde t m igui d i pr s i t thewa atfeeman'durng
T ai if s r he s de m e son ha s Gr ' i
hi tmea Dima '( 3ofDee nt'rs ns bre
s i t s s'p. fnda s epo e ig.
çrhid,heDefnda sdi notar to i iont Pli if'p. ofDe e nt
ç r t
- e nt d res r mprs he antf ( 3 fnda s'
r s eble )
e pons i f.
Lets t ke a m o e t add e st D e e nt 'f r ta t r e r ne c a m st t
' a m nt o r s he f nda s i s nd hi d r o ous l i ha
Pli iff ist s tf t any f ct de
a ntf al o e orh a s monsr tng af s i ionm e o are tby a
ta i ale mprs nt r r s ny
s c fc Def nda ,a t tt D e e nt di nota r s ori pr s n t Pl ntf . A s
pe i i e nt nd ha he f nda s d r e t m i o he ai if
sa e i M o ntspr vi usbre ,i wa t die ta i r ta tonsoft Def nda
tt d n va ' e o if t s he r c nd ndiec c i he e nt
w hi h l d t t c i m e oft M ova . C a aton i ,ofc zs a r qui e e e e of
c ea o he ontne nt he nt us i s olr e, e r d l m nt
aflei io nt Se Ovit v. a c ,954F. 1 1 4( t Ci.1 .A
as mprs nme . e at Pe r e 2d 470, 47 9h r 992)
pr bai n/pa ol ofi e nee nota t ly us f cet de an apr ba i pa oleil ly.
o to r e tc r d c ual e or o t i o ton/ r e legal
Alhough f s i prs e us ly f l s f l e a r t f l e i prs e m a t ke
t al e m i onm nt ua l olow a s r es , a s m i onm nt y a
pl e e n afe a va i a r s . l a1 oft Re
ac ve t r ld r e t n 1 he pons s a bref f o t D e e nt ,t
e nd i s r m he f nda s hey
c am t tt tt M ova wa c r i r
l i ha ha he nt s ha ged ntoduci c r ba t t f ciiy,whe i f ct
ng onta nd o he a lt n n a
he w a c ge w ih a vi a i n 1 w hi h s ii a l t s s on,M a a m r or
s har d t ol to 08, c pec t c ly, t es i
pos nuf c e,
i r ucin ofaha r t ( smos lkeyt beus di a es peores pe
ntod to zadous ool Tool ti l o e n n ca ca
a t m ptort s r e a a w e po c pa e ofdoi ofdoi s r ousbodiy ha m t ot r ;o
te o ev s a n a bl ng ng e i l r o he s r
t eha adoust i tttonals c iyorpes lsf /'t i l t tofac lphone.
hos z r o nsiui e urt rona aet ,o ncude ha el
Fi s a f e os ,a ce lphone unl s us d a de ona i de c ca
r t nd or m t l es e t ton vi e nnotbe s n a t ea t
ee s hr t o
pe s lo i tm to ls ey.Atbes t sa lge vi ai n s d ha bee c r d a a
r ona r nsi i na af t t hi le d ol to houl ve n ha ge s
Code 305,ç s s on ofa hi nota horze f r t nto orr c i by t i a e, t
ç es i
pos nyt ng ut i d or e e i n e e pt he nm t no
i ued t t ough r ar channel N ow ,why w oul t D ef
ss o hr egul s. d he endant i ease t char
s' ncr he ges
agans t pl i ifs h t tt y a em or s ve e? The a we t t tque to i sm pl
i t he antf uc ha he r ee r ns r o ha si n s i e.
A vi a i 1 woul ha r quie t Pl i ifsr mova fo t f c lt bac t f r l
olton 08 d ve e r d he antf e l r m he a iiy k o ede a
pr s n, he ea i hew a c r d a opra e y,i hous s to w o d ha s fc
io w r s f s ha ge ppr i t l n- e anc i ns ul ve uf i ed.

3


G oi ba k t t ca e 1 w and a gu ent a s r e i o pr ous r s ns ,a polc of i e
ng c o he s a r m s s e t d n ur evi e po e i e fc r
m a behed t ha ii ta e ' c i i pr e ng i heknowi ypr vi d f le
y l o ve iniit d'a rm nal oc edi f ngl o de as
i o m a i t t pr ec or o ot r i e i er e e w ih t pr e ut r si o m e
nf r ton o he os ut r he w s nt f r d t he os c o ' nf r d
dic e i Se Ree 77 F. a 1
s r ton. e, d, 3d t 054;Tor es 966 F.
r , supp. t 1
a 365. l s h c es ça
n uc as , t n
itl g nt xecs o te. (r s c trs ds rto b c me i sil, a a
nel e e rie f h . p o e uo 'q icein e o s mpo sb e' nd
i . '
pr e uton ba e on t f le i or ton i de m e çpr ur d by t pe s gi ngt
os c i s d he a s nf ma i s e d ç oc e he r on vi he
flei or ton.'
as nf mai 'Howe r aprvaectze ma behedla ef flea rs unde j
ve , i t ii n y l ibl or as re t r
1 3 i heors ca e t pl ntf t bea r t by vite off lesa e
98 f he us d he ai if o resed ru as tt ment heors
s he
ma t t polce Do v.Decr s e o,1 96U. Dit LEXI 1 75,* ( D.Pa.
de o he i . by e c nz 9 S. s. S 31 40 E.
Se .9,1 .Thus otrcli i cea,t Defnda sdi no plcet Pli ifi
pt 996) , l am s l r he e nt d t a he antf n
ha ufs t y di howe rpr vi d f l ea mil a ng satm e st t Bur a of
ndc f , he d ve o de a s nd se di t e nt o he e u
Prs n s c ta tera iiyt lv u tc wa i arda dt ePlitf wa d n e te
io s u h h th i b l o e yj sie s mp ie n h an if s e id h
t
prvie oft fee
i l ge he r domst c ewih havi c
hat om t ng ompl t aprs n s ntnc a beng
eed io e e e nd i
a f de com m uniy m o t i i a hal wa hous f c lt
f or d t nior ng n f y e a iiy.

W hi h l dsust a e st Defnda s's c co e i t Pl i ifwa
c ea o ddr s he e nt e ond nt nton, he antf s
unde t m i gu de i pr s i t the w a a % r m a 'd i hi tm e a D i m a A t
r he s i d m e s on ha s G ee n' ur ng s i t s s.
f
nopoi di t M o nts ehi efasa fe man dlrng hi tm ea Dim a ,a t
nt d he va e ms l re zi s i t s s nd he
M ova ope a i a a o obie whieunde t as umpton t thewa a horz d t do
nt r tng n ut m l l r he s i ha s ut ie o
s d e n t u tf t eDee da s cam.Le' n t xa p e wi o a g s c nr r t
o o s o j siy h fn nt' li ts o mi p ls t r n e , o tay o
h
t D e e nt s a e e s t M ova w asnota f de a pr s rco i d t a f de a
he f nda s' t t m nt , he nt e r l i one ntne o e r l
f iiy,a t c d notbe r a r t he w a a f de a i a e a f de t prviege
ac lt nd hus oul e r esed, s e r l nm t f or d he i l
ofdw eli i a halw a hous a ho e c i m e due t hi he lh. As w e m a
lng n f y e nd m ontne nt o s at de
cla i ourprvi brelt co t ont ot ha ha s nbeng o pa ol ori
er n e ous it he urs he her nd ve ee i n r e n
haf yho ea bengmor t nj taprviege TheCo tha fundpr e tdlbe t
lwa us s i e ha us i l . ur s o otce i ry
i er s s a t r a i a e i r l as d f om i tt i
nt e t fe n nm t s e e e r ns iutonalc i e .l M oni s y v.
onfnem nt n se
Br we, 0 U. 471( 9 2 ,h Co r rc r ie apaoe 'lb ryitr s i
e r 4 8 S. 1 7 ) te u t e o z d r les ie t ne e tn
r mai ng c tonal fe o paol 'H1 c nbeganf lye oye a i 9eet be
e ni ondii ly re n r e:' e a( i ul mpl d nd s o
wih f iy and f i
t am l rendsand t f m t ot endurng atachm ent ofnor allf ...
o or he her i t s m i e.
( i c n iini v r d fee tfo ta o c n ie n i ap io '1 . t4 2 Reyng
H)s o dto s ey ifrn r m h t f o fn me t n rs n. d a 8 . li
'
o M o rse t Co r i Yo n v. r e, 2 U. 1 3( 9 7 , edt a a imae
n ris y,he u tn u g Ha p r 5 0 S. 4 1 9 ) h l h t n n t
enr l d i Okl
ole n ahoma' pr - r epr r m aloha apr e t lbe t i e e te ilng
s epa ol og a s d ot ced i ry nt r s ntti
hi t d pr es bef eheco d ber m ove fom t pr a . r t pr - r ee
m o ue oc s or ul e d r he ogr m The e he e pa ol
' sr e ed fom prs bef r t e r ton ofhi s ntnce. ke hi o
'
wa elas r ion o e he xpia i se e He pt s wn
r sd n e h s u h , btie , n man an daj b; n h lv dalf g neal fe o
ei e c ; e o g t o an d a d itie o a d e i e ie e rly re f
t i i s ofi pr s nm e . B y vi t e oft D e e nt 'w il u di r r f
he nc dent m i o nt' ' ru he f nda s lf l s ega d or
M o nt rghtt t sprvie ,t pl ntf s f r d da
va s i o hi i l ge he ai if ufe e mage and o r u t c t f
s ppo t niy os, or
notbei a e t lve no a f e m a buta a m a w ho ha e r d t pr vie ofbe ng
ng bl o i t s r e n, s n s a ne he i l ge i
f e ofc r cto li tt tona c i m e .
re or e i na ns iu i l onfne nt
The Def nda s a gum entt ,Se n i a oft D e e nt c d a r tor
e nt ' r hat tve f ny he f nda s oul r es
i pri t Pl ntf ,a prviege exi tas a m aterof1 t engage i r ess or even
m son he ai if i l s t aw o n eckl
o r geo cond ti t r i s fc e e de e t ts
uta us uc f he e s ufi i nt vi nc ha howst De e ntdi nom or
he f nda d e
t n a s r l lrg si ape misbl way.'The e i no hi lga o pe mi sbl a
ha s e t ega i ht n r si e ' r s t ng e l r r s i e bout
tum pi up c r s s t tt y ca e a out e t ts t d t D e e nt 'i r nt
r ng ha ge uch ha he us n com ha uie he f nda s nhe e
digus and dilkef M ova ,i t t r a edoc nt d c esofStt Ator yst t
s t si or nt n hat he e r ume e as a e t ne ha
ha bee c c e ofc i i c r sf rpaddi fl swih f lec r sa are t.
ve n onvi t d rm nal ha ge o ng ie t as ha ge nd r ss

4


I t sca e t D e e nt a e no di f r nta i i f t s r a on t tM ova s d be
n hi s he f nda s r f e e nd t s or hi e s ha nt houl
a r e s mma yj g n .
wad d u r ud me t
b. A s aul and Bat e
s t t ry

The De e nt a i de at fom t tu h whe t y cli t tM o nta gue
f nda s' gan vi e r he r t n he am ha va r d
t t Pl ntf' m a a a s ri t t ç pr di aBP- a BP- f m
hat he ai if s de n s e ton ha ,t
Not ovi ng 9 nd IO or
c nsiue a a s uta db t r '( . Dee d n sb ifrs o s ) Th De e d n s a e
o ttts n sa l n at y'p 4 fn a t re e p n e. e fn a t' r
e
a i atem ptng t co
ga n t i o nvol e t i s by m i s a i t f ct ,i t tw e s m pl a e d
ut he s ue s t tng he a s n ha i y gr e
wi teDe e d n ' a srini t i moinf rs mmayj d me th t anif s
t h f n a ts se t n her t o u r u g n ta Pli tf ha
h o o
no pr de a f c s t s
t ovi d ny a t o uppo ta l ga i ofa s ul and ba t r The M ova '
r le tons s a t te y. nts
sa e e w asnota e i ofa s ul a ba t r w ih t de a oft s f m s but
t t m nt n quaton s a t nd te y t he ni l he e or ,
r t rt m a t ca et ,t s h r or oft a s ulsa ba tr t tt k plceas
a he o ke he s hat t uc ec d he s a t nd te y ha oo a
no
t Def nda ' r f e t pr de t M o ntw ih a m e nsofdoc e i s i
he e nt s e us d o ovi he va t nd a um ntng a d
a i . A nna Gi pe ts a i s o ofno ha ng pr de BP- f m st M o nt
ctons' ' s r ' dm s i n t vi ovi d 9 or o va ,
pr dest M ova no mea ofdoc ntng t a e ofpr e s abus sof
ovi he nt ns ume i he bus s oc s , e
Consi to lrght a c vi lbe teson t pa toft De e nt,a e n goest t
tm i na i s nd i l i ri he r he f nda s nd ve o he
e e ofpr vi ng t M ova ve y ltl m a e i ldoc l ent ton ofhi e re e a
xt nt o di he nt r ite t r a lm a i s xpe i nc s t
t ha f
he l way ho e whi h w a t i e i oft D e e nt 'a1 al
us , c s he nt nton he f nda s 1 ong,e s nta l
s e i ly
co e i and c r ng up t rm i co
nc alng ove i hei s nduct A sw e a gue pr vi usy t co t ha
. r d e o l he ur s ve
m a i c e rt t i A le v.M c M or i , o.4: c 8l SN L,2007 W L 1
de t l a ha , n l n rs N 06- v- 0 72564,a *
t2
( D. o. a 1 2 0 )t lig alg to t a p io e c udn tg t re a c poiy
E. M J n. 9, 0 7 t dn le ain h t rs n r o l o e g iv n e l
ho c
o f r b re s mmayj d me t o d fnd n s'a dbe a eo ti Co r h sa
r o ms a rd u r u g n f r e e a t' n c us f h s u t a n
,
o lg to t d n teDe e d n ' r q s f rs mma yj dg n , n teM o a t
b iain o e y h fn a ts e uet o u r u me t a d h v n
s ul b a r e s mmayj d me t
ho d e wa d d u r u g n .
M alci Prosecuton
i ous i

Even w ih t M o nts e o ntand c ntr buta oft Def nda s c a m
t he va ' l que oge e t l he e nt ' l i
t tt M ovanthasnot a c nno e t bls t e e e sofm alci uspr e uton,
ha he , nd a t s a i h he l m nt io os c i
e p cal t ek y ee n so tec mme c me to j d ca p o e dngo tep an if
s e il h e lme t f h o n e n f u iil r c e i n h litf,
y
byt dee nta tr nai oft i fvo oft Pli itt tt Dee nt mus
he fnda nd e mi ton he n a r he antfl ha he fnda s t
beawade s
r d ummayj
r udgme .Thef c oft matri t tç 1 fde a cli fr
nt a t he te s ha W 1 e r l ams o
maiiuspr e utonar borowe fom t c
lco os c i e r d r he ommo 1w t t..( c i es
n a or . whihl mpos
la lt o aprvaepe s whoi tt t sc i i lpr e di agans a i e
ibiiy n i t r on nsiu e rm na oc e ngs i t n nnoc nt
pe s wiho pr bl c us f a i ope pur e Thefdealcai unde (
ron t ut oba e a e or n mpr r pos . e r lm r 42
U. C. scin 1 8 f rmaiiu p o e ut nd fesfo tesaecvls i i t t t
S. ) e to 9 3 o l o s r sc i ifr r m h tt ii u tn ha i
c o
r quie t tsae ofi a sac i 'nde c oroflw'nsiut t c i nalpr ee ngs
e r s ha t t fcil tng u r ol a i tt e he rmi oc di
a ns t pli ifa t r by de i hi ofrght s c e unde t Consiui '
gai t he a ntf nd he e prve m i s e ur d r he tt ton.'
Toresv.Supe i e ntofPolc ,8 F. 404,409( s Ci.990)
r rntnde ie 93 2d 1t r1 .
The Pli ifwasnotgu ly ofi r ucngha a do m ae il i o ac r ci l
antf it ntod i z r us tras nt or e tona
f iiy, hi c l phone w ass m pl c r ba a nots e hi t c d be
ac lt as s e l i y onta nd, nd om t ng hat oul
us d t e c pe orha m t wela eoft e i t f clt M or ove , hi c l
e o sa , r he f r hos n he a iiy. e r t s elphone
wa c r ba f i vi l sa ng a Dimasf ciii ,a we enotco r ba
s onta nd or ndi dua s tyi t s a ltes nd r nta nd
f a i vi lonho eco i m e .Furhe m o e t c l phonei hi ve cl,
or n ndi dua m nfne nt t r r , he e l n s hi e
m i i t cas ofdr g pos e s on c tt e m at r a pos e s o ho e rgi n
ght n he e u s s i ons iut e i l s s i n, w ve ve
5


t f c t hewasnotatemptng t i r uc i i o t f iiy on hi pe s a
he a t hat t i o ntod e t nt he aclt s r on, nd
wa i f cti t gl c
s n a n he ove ompa t e ofhi ve c eunbe
rm nt s hi l knowns t t M ova does
t o he nt
notcons iu e ac t orm a e i lpos e s o The pl i i fw a unde t as um pton
tt t tz al t ra s s i n. a ntf s r he s i
t hewasa et drve,a hi i a oft pr e sdoe no tkea y fom
hat bl o i nd s gnor nce he oc s s t a wa r
hi gul,buthi ope ai a mot rve c ei nott r as t hewast ke bac t
s it m r tng o hil s he e on hat a n ko
prs ast twoul ha be n s ehi addr s e i hous t oug Dim a
ion, ha d ve e om t ng e s d n- e hr h s s
c r ctonalpr dur s butr he i w a t c ge ha ng i duce ha r us
or e i oce e , at r t s he har vi nko d za do
ma e i t tco tt t d hi de a ofhi pa ol. Gi n t f c t tt De e nt '
t ral ha nsiu e s ni l s r e ve he a t ha he f nda s
we e s a c ng f a r a on t ha M o nt s pa ol r voke due t t i pe s l
r e r hi or ny e s o ve va ' r e e d, o he r r ona
ha r f Pl i ifa w hathe sood f , tng undert col oft l w ,
ted or a ntf nd t or ac i he or he a
Def nda si e i ly m i-ndi td Pl ntf, husconsi i t M ova ' cai
e nt ntntonal s i ce ai if t tmtng he nts l m
f m a i i pr ec i n,a co e nty de i ng hi ofr ght s c led t de t
or lc ous os uto nd ns que l pr vi m i s e tr m r he
Cons iuto a he ha s r e hi de t s i t i prs n confne e t us e r i
tt i n, s d e v d s bt o oc e y n i o i m nt h a n ng
hi t prvie ofpa ol
m he i l ge r e.

The De e nt w a t M ova t a es a1t i vi ua elm e sof
f nda s nt he nt o ddr s 1 he ndi d l e nt
m a i ouspr ec i be us t y a e a a e t i a tonsde e t M ova t
lci os uton ca e he r w r he r c i ni d he nt he
a lt t s w how a lged c
biiy o ho le onduc de i hi oflbe t by a dit to a
t prved m i ry, sori n nd
c z i oft pr e s sof l w ,ie. f l ii aton ofe de ,m i c r ng hi
om pton he oc s e a . , a s tc i vi nce s ha gi m
wih vi atonst twhe em uc gr trt n hi a tons a ot re e ousc
t ol i ha r h eae ha s c i , nd he r gi onduct
na e yt de a ofdoc e sne s a yt e urng duepr s ,r uli
m l he nil um nt ce s r o ns i oce s es tng
uli ael i t de a a r vocai n ofhi pa ol,a i i f t sr a on t t
tm t y n he ni l nd e to s r e nd t s or hi e s ha
M o a ts o db a r e s mma yj d me t
v n h ul e wa d d u r u g n .
d. A bus ofProcess
e

TheDe e nt ma t cai t tf Pli ift s
f nda s ke he l m ha or antf o uppor ac us ofa ton f
t a e c i or
a e ofpr es ,thePli ifmus pr vet tt px ce swa us d f a i
bus oc s t t a ntf t o ha he o s s e or n mmedit ae
pur eohe t nwhih iwasdesgne '( 6Dee nt'r pons bre Thes
pos t r ha c t i d' p. fnda s es e ig. e
pr s e and pr edur sputi plc byt De rme ofCo r ci whe enotput
oce s s oc e n a e he pa t nt r e tons r
i o pl e t de t Pl i ifs rght a pr vie s a t M ova f r he as e t t t
nt ac o ny he a ntf i s nd i l ge , nd he nt u t r s r s ha
t e pr ed te a pr s esw e e no puti o pl cet c
hes oc tr s nd oce s r t nt a o overup t D ef nda s
he e nt '
wilulmiconduc a midoi .TheDe e nt a eba i ly a s ri t tbe us
lf s t nd s ngs f nda s r scal s e tng ha ca e
t rf brc ton ofdoc e s untu hf lsatm e s a pa d tlsac e st
hei a i ai um nt , r t u t e nt, nd dde ie hive he
pumos ofpunihi t defnda ,ha ii j tte Thefc oft matri t ta
e s ng he e ntt t t s usiid. a t he te s ha n
a eofpr s occ swhe t r ,t saca eofa ton i t 4a ii fom onepa t
bus oce s ur n he e ç
i us c i n o1 rsng r ry
m a ng a malci a delbe aem ius orpe v r i ofr a l is c ur pr s
ki i ous nd i r t s e r e son egulry s ued o t oce s
( vi orci nal notusii byt unde l nglga a to '( of v.McDonnel,418
ci l rmi ) j tted he ryi e l cin' W lf l
U. 539,94S. .2963,41L. 2d935( 97 ) Thi i whatha oc ure i t c e
S. Ct Ed. 1 4). ss s c rd n he as
oft Pl ntf,a t M o
he ai if nd he vanti s s e ofa s ri t thec le st Def nda s
s o ur s e ton, ha hal nge he e nt
t pr uc doc e st ta e i Se r e e e a s a pe w ih t pr r sgnat e
o od e um nt ha r n nt y nt r d nd t m d t he ope i ur s
a da es ThePli ifa t De e nt bot know t t tt e f r sdono e s
nd t . antf nd he f nda s h hat ha hes o m t xit
a t y woul ha be n doc e e a e de eofco pla ewih d pr es a
s he d ve e um nt d s vi nc m i nc t ue oc s nd
l w f la r s by t D e e nt . Aga n,a 1t tha be n pr de a e f brca e
a u r e t he f nda s i 1 ha s e ovi d r a i t d
doc e s a Pl i ifha i hi pr viusr pons sa e e pr ded e bisof
um nt, nd antf s n s e o es e tt m nt ovi xhi t
i t esi whi h e oye ad onihi ot r t f brcae doc nt . I t
nsanc n c mpl es m s ng he s o a i t ume s f he


M o ntsc am st t se a e E ms tnta e a s l-er ng'ast De e nt
va ' l i o hi nd r , ç ubsa it d nd e fs vi ' he f nda s
t
a s r i t r m os r e r s ns br ef t n t D ef nda ss ul ha no toubl
s e t n hei t ec nt e po e i , he he e nt ho d ve r e
pr di e de e ofs d doc e sbeng e e e i ot Se r s t m t ta e
ovi ng vi nc ai um nt i ntr d nt he nty yse ha r
c pla e w ih gu delnes9om t N a i lA r hi s a Re r A dm i s r ton a
om i nc t i i he tona c ve nd co ds nit a i nd
t CCM , at rt n t doc e st ha pr de t ta ewr
he r he ha he um nt hey ve ovi d ha r oughtwih t t he
Def nda s mit ke a i c ur c e a ar s toft i haset co rup t r
e nt ' sa s nd na c a i s s e ul her t o ve hei
mide d . Ac o dn l,heM o n s o l b a r e s mma yj g n .
s e s c r igy t va t h ud e wad d u r ud me t
e. N e i nce a G r sN eglge e
glge nd os i nc
The D e e nt c a m t tt Pl ntf f l t m a nt i a c us ofac i n f
f nda s l i ha he ai i f ais o i a n a e to or
neglgenc orgr sne i ncebe us t Pl i ifc nnots
i e os glge ca e he antf a how adut owe byt
y d he
D e enda st w a br ac d,orda a t tow e f om a a l ge br a h of
f nt hat s e he m ges hat l d r ny le d e c
dut I'eDe e nt e n go a f ra pantng t ms l a ec rng a
y. h f nda s ve s a s i i he eves r a i nd
co pa s ona e c a m i t t y m a t r com m e to t tt M ova no
m s i t l i ng hat he de he e nda i n ha he nt t
pa tcpa ei a m a laci tes Howe r i o page3 ofExhi tA t t s
rii t n ny nua tvii . ve , n n bi o hi
respons poi s outan i t
e nt ns ance i w hi A na G i
n ch spert t she beleves t tdustng
, hat i hat t i
qua ii ' t gi nghi adie tve t pe l m m a llbor Afe da a da
lfes' hus vi
, m r c i o rbr nua a . tr ys nd ys
ofha a s e i M s G i pe tsa enc t M ova s nta e a la e ai w ihi t s
r s m nt n . s r ' bs e, he nt e n m i n m l t n hi
D i m as Cha ii s i e nals t i c tng,t. .pa n a di c f ti m y lver'
s rte nt r ysem ndi a i t. i nd s om or n i '
( hbtA, 4t ti r s o e .Ye a an,nalte d td 1 / 92 0 t ep an if
Ex ii p. o h s ep ns) t g i i etr ae 0 1 /01 , h litf
wr e,thi lte i t a s you t tt y,1 / 9/ 0,1 50A . . 1wa c le t
ot t s e tr s o dvie
t ha oda 0 1 201 0: M , s a ld o
t f ontdes a t d t t1s d va uum t r
he r k nd ol ha houl c he oom f hi ,i a a t m ptt
or m n n te o
i i i t m e. He goe on t s at t t t..asa r s tofa1 a i a ns m e f
ntm da e ' ' s o t e ha , :. e ul 1 ctons gai t , or
t l s w e by M r Thom asa hi s a f m y lve ha s ole a 1do e r e e
he a t ek, . nd s t f , i r s w l n nd xpe i nc
p i 'Ex bi B, 4,ot sr s o s ) Th Mo nt n o t r q s aBP- fr
an'( hi t p. t hi e p n e . e va we t n o e uet 9 om
i t s m elte ,a di s 5 tm e wihi t c r ponde e wihi t Exhi tB,
n he a e tr nd d o i s t n he ores nc s t n he bi
i a dto t c u te sv r a rq e tfrt s f nns l i ce rt a fo j s te
n d i n o o n ls eb l e u s o he e o . t s la h t r m u th
i
i e alc r ponde esal t tt De e nt br c d t i dut a t r
nt m ores nc one,ha he f nda s ea he her y, nd hei
de a oft BP- f r w asonl a a t m ptt pr ve a f rhe doc e a i of
ni l he 9 om y n te o e nt ny u t r um nt ton
t vi a i ns ofbr a h ofdu y a t obvi da a st tr s t d f o t
he ol to ec t nd he ous m ge ha e ule r m he
ha a s e , o c d m a llbor t te e bae t M o ntsme c c ton,of
r s m nt f r e nua a , ha xac r td he va ' di al ondii
whi t Defnda sawa eoft da
ch he e nt r he magebeng ca e a e de i M r .Giper'
i us , s vi nt n s s ts
pr s t addrs t is wihM r n oma ( bi A, 4,ot sr pons )
omie o e s he sue t . s Exhi t p. t hi es e.
Th r f r ,h De e d n s agu n t a p an ifsmoinf rs mmayj d me t s
e eo e t e f n a t' r me t h t litf to o u r u g n i,
ç voi ofa pr pe f ct s
ç
de d ny o r a s uppori a neglge ,c am soff c ma
tng ny i nce l i or ed nuall bor
a ,
co tnty t rorz d a i i daed,a pe mit t a ce m e l f m hi wie'i
nsa l e r i e nd ntmi t nd r ted o c pt a s or s f ' s ,
ye a herdi s on f om t t ut aspr oft ne i ntac s on t par oft
t not ver i r he r h oof he glge t he t he
def nda ,a t diec a p oxi aeda a t tr ule t t pl ntf ar
e nt nd he r t nd r m t m ges ha es t d o he ai if e
docume e i Dima Chaii own i ena me sgi s tm ( fnda '
ntd n s s rtes ntr l sa ng yse Dee nts
r s e,p.7 .I t Pli ifspr ousr s et Dee nt'moi f
epons ) n he antf' evi epons o fnda s ton or
s mmayj dg n hea s re ta, p io o tca viltsap io e' Eiht
u r u me t s e td h t a rs n fiil oae rs n rs g h
A m endm e rght ,and i de m e ne i nti he s i delber t y i f e e t t
nt i s s e d glge f / he s i a el ndi f r nt o he


prs rss rousm e ca ne ds Se Eselev.Ga bl 429 U. 97,1 04,97
ione ' e i di l e . e t l m e, S. 03-
S. .285,50L. 2d251( 976) Delbe aei fee ee ompase onl
Ct Ed. 1 . i r t ndifrnc nc ss y
unne s a y a wa o i lc i ofpan r pug ntt t c cenc ofm a nd.
ce s r nd nt n ntiton i e na o he ons i e nki
S ei .t1 4-6, 7S. . 5 ' u j ci rc e s s, a u e i t ci n l a
e da 0 0 9 Ct28 .' be t e klsne s' s s d n he rmia lw,
S ve '
i t a oprat ts f delbe aei fee e. i urla lt t rj 1 a
s he ppr i e e t or i r t ndifrnc To nc ibiiy mde 983, n
i vi ua mus bepe s naly i ve i t de i to ofape s n' c tm tonal
ndi d l t r o l nvol d n he prvai n r o s onsi i
rg s Se Lo a v. mih71 F.d7 6 7 8( t Ci.98 ) a d frt e era o s
iht. e z no S t, 8 2 5 , 6 5h rl 3 , n o h s e s n
t eM o a t e u s t t h c u t rn hi moinf rs mma yj d me tb
h v n r q e tha t e o r g a t s t o u r u g n e
o
a r d.
wa de

2. The C om pl ntf l t alege any t i conductor vi at ons ofFederalLaw
ai ais o l ortous ol i
or t C ons i uton.
he tt i
a. Fi s Am endm ent
rt

TheDefnda ma st cli i hi prviusr pons bre t t t (he
e nt ke he am n s e o es e if ha,i t he
mova )fist pr dea pr re de ede nsr tngt theas dt a tnd
nt al o ovi ny ope vi nc mo tai ha ke o te
rlgi s r i so sdeafvemierdi a t thi r q s wa de ed'( 8,
ei ous e vce uti i l a us nd ha s e ue t s ni 'p.
Dee da t rs o s b ig.Ye a anweaefr e t a d e sy t n t rd p rur
fn ns e p n e re tgi r oc d o d r s e a ohe e a t e
f om t t t on t pm' oft D e e nt . On 7/ / 0 t M ova m a a r ques t
'r he nzh he t he f nda s 29 201 he nt de e to
Las hondaA da s i w hi h he r ques e a w a de e t abiiy t a t nd a Rom a a
m ,n c e t d, nd s ni d he lt o te ni n
Orhodox Chtr l td o St t Road 7,i Pe okePi , o whih M s Ada s
t lch ocae n ae n mbr nes t c . m
r pled t tyo a e o y alowe t ta lwihi fvem ie oft f clt f r i o
e i ha u r nl l d o r ve t n i ls he a iiy or elgi us
sr ie ( ii C, 1t t i rs ns ) I f c,h M o a t d , oh rd c me td
e vc s Exhb t p o hs epo e . n a tt e v n ma e 2 te o u ne
r ueton 84/ 0a o 1 / 201 a1ofwhihweede e byM s Adams( bi
eq s / 201 nd n 06/ 0, 1 c r nid . Exhi t
C, 2- t t sr s e) A1 pa te i l ngt dee nt ar a r oft s cil
pp 3,o hi epons . 1 ris ncudi he fnda s e wa e he pe a
e e to t t e( )mi r l whc sae ta,ine c pt nt t er l wi o ybe
xc p in o h 5 l ue ih tts h tt x e i o h ue l nl
e a o l
madewhe yoursatd de
n t e nomi to ofwor hi ca
nai n s p nnotbel a e wihi fvem iesof
oc t d t n i l
tepr g a ' ( hii4t teP an ifrs o s frs mmayj d me t.Ye a an
h o rm' Ex bt o h litf e p n e o u r u g n) t g i
.
be us De e nt we eco nc t tt y ha co r d up t rvi l ton oft
ca e f nda s r nvi ed ha he d ve e hei o ai he
Pli ifsfr tAm e
antf is ndme rghtby de ng hi aBP- f r t f l c nce t t
nt i nyi m 9 o m, hey et onvi d ha
ma ngasatme s frfom t t t s has ç (hemova )f l t pr dea
ki t e nt o a r he nzh uc ,ç t he nt ais o ovi ny
pr re de e de ons r tng t the as d t a t nd r lgi s r i s o s de a tve
ope vi nc m ta i ha ke o te e i ous e v ce ut i i
mier di a t thi r q s wa de e 'butt y f ie t r me rt t i own
l a us nd ha s e ue t s ni d' , he a ld o e mbe hat her
i e a s tm co ane t e de et tM ova woul us t vai t hi ca m f
nt m l yse nt i d he vi nc ha nt d e o ldae s li or
vi a i ofhi fr tam e m e r ghtt f e dom ofr i o a a or ngl t
ol ton s is nd nt i o r e elgi n, nd cc di y, he
M o a ts o db a r e s mma yj d me t
v n h ul e wa d d u r u g n .

Fourth A m endm ent-

The De e nt a tmptt maket c s t tasaco ton oft Pl ntf '
f nda s te o he a e ha ndii he ai ifs
pa ol t he cons nt d t <s a c s ofhi pe s a ve c e' H o e r t Pl i if
r e hat e e o çe r he s r on nd hi l ' w ve , he a ntf
.
ma i cla t i vi sa DimasHous t hewa sm pl ope ai af miy
de t e r o ndi dual t s e hat s i y r tng n l
ve cl,t 1 1 1 hi r r r pori r quie e s Alhough t i vi uasi t
hi e o 51 s equied e tng e r m nt. t he ndi d l n he
ha f y hous ha rghtt s a c hi pe s upo e e i t buidi t Supr m e
l wa e d, i o e r h s r on n nt r ng he l ng, he e


Co thasf
ur ound t t hi f m iy m e be sha a pr t t d i e es a i tt i pr t
ha , s a l m r ve o ec e nt r t ga ns he r opery
b i s be t os a c e a s iue ' he tep o e uins e t j siya
eng u j c t e r h d nd ez r . ' n h r sc t e ks o u tf
W o
wa r nte s s ar h by pr ofvolm t r c e ,i i no lm ied t pr t c e
ra ls e c oof t a y ons nt t s t i t o oof hat ons nt
was gi n by t def nda , m a s
ve he e nt but y how t tt pe m i s on t s a c w as o a ne
ha he r s i o e r h bt i d
fo a t r pary whopos es e co mon a hort ove o o he s t e r ltons p
r m hid t s sd m ut iy r r t r ufki nt ea i hi
t t pr mieso e f c ss
o he e s r fe t oughtt bei pe e ' td Stt sv.M al k,41 U.S.
o ns ctd.Unie a e toc 5
1 4 1 ( 9 4 .l teM o n ' p e iusr s o s t t Dee d n ' moin fr
6 , 71 1 7 ) n h va ts rv o e p n e o he fn a ts to o
s mmayj g nth M o n a k o e g dt twhl ap o ain rsrg to prv c
u r ud me te va t c n wld e ha, ie r b to e' ih f ia y
ma be u tfa l dmi ih dd rn t p ro o p o ain (e Ima v. tt,1 4 Ga
y j siib y i ns e u ig he e id f r b t se n n S ae 2 .
o
Ap 1 0( )( 8 S d41 )( 9 ),' o to r sau d e n tc n eta
p. 9 2 1 3 E2 3 1 71) ' bainay tt s o s o o v r
m
pr tone ' fm iy, eatve a findsi o 'e ond c a s ctze .... s pe e
oba i rs a l r l i s nd re nt s c l s ' ii ns The e opl
a e nots rppe oft rrghtofpr va be a e t y m ay be lvi w ih a pr ba i ne or
r ti d hei i i cy c us he i ng t o to r
(j maybelvi wiht m. Stt v. ry,s aat1 .TheSuprmeCour of
she i ng t he ' ae Foga t upr 51
' e t
M o a t onl c ti t c unty t ad e st r mik a i oft wa r ntes
nt na, he y our n he o r o dr s he a t tons he ra l s
s a c co to ofpr ba i on t r pa teslvi wih apr bai ne ,c l d t ta
e r h ndii n o ton hid ri i ng t o to r onc ude ha
s a c wa r ntba e on pr ba eca emus be o ane be or apr bai rsr sde e
e r h ra sd o bl us t bti d f e o tone ' e i nc
orpr ry m a be s a c d ' o t tt l ga i e e t ofi e t r peronsc n be
ope t y e r he ' ha he e l ntr ss nnoc nt hid s
s a
ade t l pr t c e ... Gi n t sf c ,t M ova s dbea r s
qua ey o e t d. ' ve hi a t he
' nt houl wa ded umm a y
r
j g n.
ud me t
c. Fith and Fourt
f eenth A m endm ents

The D ef nda sm a t cl i t tt Pl ntf r e ve pr rnotc ofhi
e nt ke he a m ha he ai i f ec i d ope ie s
vi a i and w a pr vi d ahe rng upon hi r tzn t Fe r lD e e i Ce e i
ol ton, s o de ai s e t o de a t nton nt r n
r
M im i Ho e r t M ova wa st ma i clart thene rha ahea i wih
a . w ve , he nt nt o ke t e ha ve d rng t
a y ne net e a Dima Ch rte , rwi a yj dca bo ya t Bura o P io s
n o , ih r t s s a i s no t n u iil d the e u f rs n .
i h
The i a c r to w a done w ihoutt know l dge ofU SPO a CCM D ie t ,Ca l
nc r e a i n s t he e nd r c or r os
Rodrgu z,a he di notsgn t pa r f t i r e ai n,husm a ng i c e rt tt
i e s d i he pe s or he nca c r to t ki t l a ha he
Def nda se
e nt ngage i ac m pa gn ofe m i a f brc tng doc e si or rt c r
dn a i r sng nd a ia i um nt n de o ove
up a s pi on oft e nt . TheM ova i a ton t s nc i l vid upon hi by
ny us ci he ve s nt n ddii o a tons e e m
t halwa hous ,hewasf ce t s r i ea a tona 81da i f de ali r e ai
he f y e or d o e v c n ddii l ys n e r nca c r ton.
ExhbtD t t smoin c nan t eitma (p12 e hb t c nanted c me t
ii o hi t o ti s h n e l p - , x ii D) o ti h o u n s
o
whi h i c t t bot Dim a Cha ii punihe wih 3 we ksofe r dut no
c ndi a e hat h s s rtes s d t e xta y,
vi ior f r 3 wee ,a no w e ke pa s s ye t Def nda sha t ne ve t c ai
st s o ks nd e nd s e , t he e nt ve he r o l m
t tt y ha no pa ti punihi t M ova ,a m or i por a l t a l ged
ha he d r n s ng he nt nd e m t nty he le
doc e whi h t Pli ifi co nc i a f brcai n by t defnda st c ve up
um nt c he a ntf s nvi ed s a i to he e nt o o r
t rilgala s (p 3- Exhi tD t t sr s ns)wa adoc ntt tPli ifha
hei le ct, p 4, bi o hi epo e s ume ha antf d
note n s e o be n a a e e s e untll ng a t rhe w a r l a e a be n t
ve e n r e w r xit d i o f e s e e s d nd ga he
pr s ofdico r f t sl ws t M os lkel be us t doc e di note s
oce s s ve y or hi a ui. t i y ca e he um nt d xit
untlafe hewasr las d fom t Fe r lf c lt whi h c l i o quesi t
i tr ee e r he de a a iiy, c als nt ton he
De e nt c am t tPl i ifwa a f de pr rduepr e s a f t er a ons
f nda s' l i ha antf s for d ope oc s , nd or hes e s ,
t M o n s o l b a r e s mmayj d me t
he va t h ud e wad d u r u g n .
d. Eighth A m endm ent
The D e e nt e i il s at i t i r s ns br e t ,ç he Pl i iff l t
f nda s xplc ty t e n he r e po e i f hat û
t a ntf ais o
stfrha cu lo u us l u ih n'a dt e g o t j ketn ei c e kta,
e o t ny r e r n ua p n s me t n h y o n o o o gu n h e h t
'
9


ç e t nl t Pl ntf who i s ils r ng a prs s nt nc c nnotc pl i t tbei
f rai y he ai i f s tl e vi i on e e e a om a n ha ng
de i d a m ea f om hi w ie i c ue a unus la i a e a e notpe m it d hom e
pr ve lr s f s r l nd ua s nm t s r r te
c o dme l'( fn a t' r s o s , 9 .I a lzngcamso Eihh Ame d n
o ke as' De e d n s' e p n e p ) n nay i li f g t n me t
vi a i ,t c t m us l a di c e e a e ofbasc htm a nee . s w e ha
ol tons he our s t ook t s r t r as i l n ds A ve
r e l hel ''A) i tt in'oblgai unde t eght ame
ec nty d,'( n nsiuto s i ton r he i h ndme i a a e i i
nt s t n nd f t
f m ihess nt nce prs r wih ade t f
u s e e d ione s t qua e ood,c ot ng,s le ,s niai n, e c l
l hi het r a t to m di a
c r a pe s s ft ' W rghtv. he 642 F. 11 11 33( h Ci.
ae, nd ronal aey.' i
' Rus n, 2d 29, 32- 9t r
l 8ltiain o te ) 6 2F.da 1 4 - 7 W h n a ay igwhehe Dima c a ie
g lctto mitd . 8 2 t 2 6 4 . e n lzn t r s s h rt s
i
vi at d t i oblga i t r s c t Pl ntt sei a e e rght ,i i c ea t t
ol e he r i ton o e pe t he ai ir ght m ndm nt i s t s l r ha
t i s i no l ra l ughi m a t r
he s ue s onge a ng te .
Looki ba k a t M ova ' di c s o oft D e e nt sN e i nce, ti
ng c t he nts s us i n he f nda ' glge i s
ce rt tat
la ha lhough t de e nt a tmptt pantt m s ve a c rng a
he f nda s te o i he el s s a i nd
c pas i t goi a f rt poi outt tt y m a t r om m enda i t t
om s ona e, ng s a o nt ha he de he ec ton hat he
M ova notpa tci t i a m a lac i tes H oweve ,i on page 3 ofExhi tA t
nt r i pa e n ny nua tvii . r n bi o
t sr s ns poi souta i tnc i whi h Ana Giper,t ts be ive t t tng
hi e po e nt n nsa e n c s t ha he le s hat t i
dus
qualfe ' t gi ng hi adieci t pero m ma
ii s' hus vi
, m r tve o f r nuallbo .ARe da a daysof
a r r ys nd
ha a s e i M s Gipe tsa e e, heM ova s nta e ala e alwihi t s
r s m nt n . s r ' bs nc t nt e n m i n m i t n hi
DimasCha ii i e nals t m i c tng,G..pai a dico f ti m y lve '
s rtes ntr yse ndia i t. n nd s m or n i r'
( hb t p 4t t i rs ns ) Ye a an i alte d td 1 /92 0 t ep an if
Ex ii A, . o hs epo e . t g i,n etr ae 0 1 /01 , h litf
w r e t hi l te i t a s yo t tt y,1 19 201 1 50 A . . 1w a c l d t t
ot , ç s e t r s o dvi e u ha oda 0/ / 0, 02
t M , s ale o he
fontde k a t d t tIs d vac
r s nd ol ha houl uum t r
he oom f hi ,i a ate ptt i i i e
or m n n tm o ntm dat
m e. H e goe o t s a e t t <. .a a r s tofa1 a tonsaga ns m e f t l tw e k,
'
' s n o t t ha , t . s e ul 1 ci i t , or he as e
byM r Thomasa hi sat mylve hass lna 1do e re epan'( bi B,
. nd s tf ir wole nd xpeinc i ' Exhi t
p. t t sr pons ) l f ci a i vi t tDee nt ha pr vi l ha ma
4, o hi es e . f or ng n ndi dualha fnda s d e ousy d de
t c et t B'r a ofPrs t notpa tcpa ei a m a llbo , o d ta
he as o he u e u ions o ri i t n ny nua a r t us nd
vacuum t n i nota c e rca e ofc u a unus lpuni hm e ,a t a vi aton of
he s la s r el nd ua s nt nd hus ol i
t d t t p o iea e u t me ia c r a dp r o a s ft ,h r i noj siei te
he uy o r vd d q ae dc l ae n e s n l aey t ee s u tc n h
word.
l

The D ef nda si a a t m ptt c
e nt n n te o overt i vi a i ofhi c tt i na r g s
he r ol tons s ons im o l i ht ,
a tm ptt pa nthi a as l d ma t tsmpl wasl ng f ahom ec
te o i m s poie n ha i y ooki or ookedm eal
fom hi w ie.Eve wih t m a ti t t f ctt tt we ea r ofhi m e c
r s f n t he dmitng o he a ha hey r wa e s di al
c tons t D ef nda sha r f s d t a r s t Pl i if s c a m t the w a not
ondii , he e nt ve e u e o dd e s he a ntf ' l i ha s
pr vi d m e l t twe edibetc findl a wa gi n dicplna y a ton f a
o de a s ha r a i re y, nd s ve s i i r c i or n
i i ntw he e i w i e w a de i rng f asa r s tofhi notr ce vi a qua e
nc de r s f s lve i ood e ul m e i ng de t
nut ii na fom t ha f y hous s et ng t t a e r quie by l t do. Thi
r to l r he l wa e, om hi hat hey r e r d aw o s
vi a e De rm e ofCo r c i Polcisi whih, ti ma t t te c i tt i s
olt s pa t nt r e ton i e n c i s ndaed ha a h nsiuton'
f s r i epr r m ofe snutii nal balnce a i ng me s SpecalFoo a
ood e v c og a f r rto ly a d, ppetzi al. i d nd
M e s 28C. R.j5 20 a Pr a Sttme 4700. FoodSe viesM a ,
al, F. 47. nd ogrm ae nt 05, rc nual
pr de t m edi ldi t be a ia e t i a e who r quie s h di t . The M ova '
ovi hat ca e s va l bl o nm t s e r uc e s nts
r ea c hasf undho ve t t aprs ofk i vi atsaprs rsEi h
es r h o we r ha , ion t al ol e ione ' ght
Am endme rght ,a i de d ne i nti he s i dei r t l i fe e t t
nt i s nd s eme glge f /he s lbe a ey ndif r nt o he
prs rss rousm e ca ne .SeeEse l v. mb1, U. 97,1 0 97 S. .
ione ' e i di l eds t le Ga e429 S. 03- 4, Ct
285,50L. 2d25l( 976) a a or ngl t M ova ' motonf s
Ed. 1 , nd cc di y he nts i or umma y
r
judgme s dbeg a ed.
nt houl r nt

10


3. The Pl nt f hasf ied t appear f depos tons D ef ndant 'de i e f t
ai if al o or ii , e s s gnat d ac s
shoul be t n as e t bls f pur esoft s M oton f Sum m ar
d ake s a i hed or pos hi i or y
Judgm ent a t De endant cl m and Pl ntf pl di s d be sr c n.
, s he f s ai ai irs ea ngs houl t i ke

On D e e be 06, 1t D e e nt f l d a M oton t D i m i sA c i n f r
c m r 201 he f nda s ie i o s s to o
Faitr t Appe a De ii ( ume #78) TheM ova a knowl st tt
lze o ar t poston Doc nt . nt c edge ha he
Def nda ' co ms la tmpt d t s he e de ii o t f l wi occ sons
e nts t e te e o c dul postons n he olo ng a i ;
Oco r1 , 0l , v mbe l , 01 , n De e e 5 2 1 ( mpo ieExhbt1t
tbe 0 2 1 No e r 1 2 1 a d c mb r , 0 1 Co st ii o
Dee nt moi . M ova a i f rhe a kno e st thet rtndst
fnda s ton) The nt gan u t r c wldge ha mdesa he
i pora e ofs d de ii f t publc' i e es i e dii r s uton of
m tnc ai postons or he i s nt r t n xpe tous e ol i
ltga i t c t nee t m a ge isdoc t . l i a ar ul oft sunde sa ng
ii ton, he our' d o na t
s ke s t s s es t hi r tndi
t tt M ova m a e r a t m ptt c m uni a e vi e ais be wee t M ova a
ha he nt de ve y te o om c t a m l t n he nt nd
t Def nda ' co e ast hi i biiyt m a a tnd t de ii duet hi
he e nts uns l o s na lt o ke te he postons o s
document a c tdoc t d il s s Furhe mor a e de i t ba k and f t
ed nd our ke e lnes e . t r e, s vi nt n he c orh
ema lco r s nde es t De e
i r e po nc , he f ndantsc ' ouns lm a no r que tf rc r ntme c l
e de e s o ure di a
do ume t t j siyteM o a tsa srinta h wa u a l t atn wh c te
c n s o u tf h v n ' se t h t e s n be o te d, ih h
o
M ova woul ha be n gl d t pr de s h t s i doc e aton woul r s ti
nt d ve e a o ovi , uc hat ad um nt i d e ul n
et rar c d i oft M ova ' de ii n t atm et thewasphyscal a et
ihe es he ulng he nts posto o i ha i ly bl o
a a f hi de ii n,o s h t tot ra r nge nt f de i t M ova c d
ppe r or s posto r uc ha he ra me s or posng he nt oul
ber a ona ymadeie. vi tlphoneorcos cruit e so I i notcla a t
e s bl . ) a ee l e ic telviin. t s er s o
why t Def nda ' couns lwoul quesi t M ova ' heat a he wa orgi l
he e nts e d ton he nts lh s s i naly
r l a e fom t Defnda ' Ha f y Hous t hom ec i m e d t s ver l
e e s d r he e nts lwa eo onfne nt ue o e a
me c c tons name ybeng di gnos d wih He ttsC i e ton,Cir i oft
di al ondii , l i a e t pa ii nf ci rhoss he
lve ,di be es chr c f tgue de es i t o boc ope a a c t ,1 pl t e co ,
i r a t , oni a i , pr s on, hr m yt ni , s ies ow a el t unt
a pos i elve c nc ri caedby elvae apha f t pr t n lvel s wn i bl t t
n sbl i r a e ndi t e td l -e o o ei e s ho n ood es
a M R1r uls Gi n t f c t tt o y s e
nd es t. ve he a t ha he nl ubs quentc nge t t M o ntshe t
ha s o he va ' alh
co to ha be n o si whih hi he lh ha fzt rde e i a e a t tt M ova
ndii n s e ne n c s at s t he t ror t d, nd ha he
r nt
bele d i good f ih t tt De e ntsa t rc
ive n at ha he f nda ' nd hei ouns lwe ea r oft s
e r wa e he e
c r um s a es a f t r or t tD e e nt s c t s di notr que ta upda e
i c t nc , nd ur he m e ha f nda ' o m el d e s ny td
me c r co ds9om t M ova i c tng ac
dial e r he nt ndi a i hangei hi c r ntme c c ton,
n s ure dial ondii he
di notpr vi f r he pr ofhi c
d o de u t r oof s ondii nsa i w a notr ques e orw a r nt d unde
to s t s e td ra e r
t cic s a es The D e e nts c
he r um t nc . f nda ' ouns li hi m oton a s r s t tbe a e t
e n s i s e t ha c us he
M o ntwasa et appe a m e aton, e e hi M oton f Summ a y J
va bl o ar t di i pr par d s i or r udgme , nt
St t m e ofFa t ,Re s d St t m e s ofFa t ,a t pr vi usr pons t t
a e nt c s vi e a e nt c s nd he e o es e o he
Def nda sM oton f Summ a y J
e nt i or r udgm e ,M ova s d ha be a et m a i t
nt nt houl ve en bl o ke t o
t s he e de ii ; we rt sas e to doe nottkei oco i r ton t tf
he c duld postons ho ve hi s ri n s a nt nsde a i ha or
t f rt l s s ve m ont ,t A s ie t M ova ha be n ba ti ha c us d hi
he o he a t e n hs he c t s he nt s e tlng s a e s
physcanst gi hi a 50/ c nc ofs vvi hi s he uld s ge y, ch ha be n
i i o ve m 50 ha e ur i ng s c d e ur r whi s e
r s hed e duet hi e c r t m e ca co to a t f c t theha us what
e c uld o s xa e baed di l ndii n, nd he a t ha s ed
ltl r m a ni e r he had r a ni t pr pa e hi m otons a c t um e s
i te e i ng ne gy em i ng o e r s i nd our doc nt .
( eCompost Exhi t2t t smoton) Si e, Dee nt di notr pondor
Se ie bi o hi i . nc The fnda s d es
r butt Pl ntf ' a gument ct to ofCi lPr ed e,a m o eo rt y di not
e he ai ifs r s iai n vi oc ur nd r ve he d
r iea ne a gu nt t t se f c , heM ova r a s t t f l ngke f c or
as ny w r me s o hi fe t t nt e s ers he olowi y at s
wih r s ctt t Fe r lnze ofCi lPr e ea t r medi t tt Def nda s
t e pe o he de a l s vi oc dur nd he e es ha he e nt
ha a t i dipos :
d t he r s al

11


Fe rl e s o Ci iPr c dle3 ( )4 d aswihtea mi srto o ad p sto
dea Rult) f vl o e t 0 b ( ) e l t h d nitain f e o iin
r
w he apa t i phys ca l una e t a t nd a s hed e de ii i pr vi s a to l
n ry s i ly bl o te c ul d pos ton t o de ddii na
a nuesf o a ni t i or ai n t tac e sbot t Defnda ' nee f
ve or bti ng he nf m to ha hive h he e nts d or
i o m a i i r ga ds t t di co r a t M ova ' phys c la lt t com pl
nf r ton n e r o he s ve y nd he nt s i a biiy o y:
G Remot M e s Thepa tesmay si a e
çBy e an . ri tpult --ort c tm a o moton
he our y n i
or r t ta depos ton be t ke by t l phone orot r r m ot m ea .Fort
de - ha ii a n ee he e e ns he
pumos oft snzea Rul 28a) 37a)( ,a 37( ( ) t deposto tkes
e hi l nd es ( , ( 2) nd b) 1,he iin a
pl c wher t de nta we st quesins'
ae e he pone ns r he to .'
Thi ho ve wo d ha r quie aco tor r whih t De e ntsc uns wa
s we r ul ve e r d ur de , c he f nda ' o el s
unwilngt a quie.Sub vson(# (3.l or rt fciiaels e nsvepr e es
li o c r diii @ 4 n de o a ltt e s xpe i oc dur ,
pr son i madef t r co di oft tm onyby ot rt n se
ovi i s or he e r ng esi he ha tnopa cm e ns cg.
phi a - . ,
by m e ha ca,elckoni ,orphot a cmea .Bec us t s met
c ni l e c op phi ns a e he e hodsgi rs t
ve ie o
pr bl m s ofac ur y a t u t r hi s t pa t t ki t de ii n i r q r d t
o e c ac nd r s wo t nes , he r y a ng he pos to s e uie o
a y f a c t de .The o de i t s c f ho t t tmony i t be r c ded,
ppl or our or r r r s o pe iy w he esi so e or
pr e ve a fl a i ma conti wha e ra tona s f r t co tde m s
es r d, nd ied, nd t y an t ve ddii l a egua ds he ur e
ne es a y. W hi h l a t M o ntt ques i whe he t D e e ntt u y que tone
c sr c e ds he va o ton t r he f nda r l si d
t M ova ' hea t c ton,orw he hert s w a sm pl a s
he nt s lh ondii t hi s i y ubve sve t tc t a d t
r i ac i o voi he
co ta es i M ova ' Peii f Sum ma y J
ur ddr sng nts tton or r udgme a t we ef a f lof
nt s hey r e r u
s r ngt oft M o nt sc e.
te h he va ' as
3. Ru e3 ( )a t o ie ted src c u tor q iea atr e 'op yt era o a e
l 7 d u h rz s h itit o r t e ur n to n y ' a h e s n bl
t
e ns s i udi a t ne ' ee ,c us d by t f iur ' iscle t a a a a
xpe e , ncl ng tor ys f s a e he al e'of t int o ppe r t
de ii ' e st co ttndst tt f iur wass tntal usiidort tot r
poston,' s he ur i ha he al e
unl ubsa ilyj tfe ha he
cr u tn e ma ea a r o e pe s su j s. Un e Rul 3 ( )2 , ihhm t e
ic msa c s k n wad f x n e n u t' d r e 7 b ( ) whc s h
'
s meln a ea Ru e3 ( ) tebzd no s wi s b tn il u ttc to a ds e il
a a gu g s l 7 d ,h l e f ho ng u sa ta j si ai n n p ca
r i
cr um sa esi on t pa t beng s nctone Falt f e ng Cor v. ilrBr w i
ic t nc s he ry i a i d. sa fBr wi p. M le e ng
Co.702F. 770,784( h Ci.983) W et a yt smebur n ofpr frRul
, 2d 9t r1 . hus ppl he a de oof o e
3 ( ) Sic , o a ti t eo eh r i t ec s fcngsncin ,h b ld no p o ff r
7 d . n e M v n s h n e e n h a e a i a t s te tr e f r o o
o
pr ngt ts tntalusii to frsnctonsflso t Dee nt a t i
ovi ha ubsa i j tfcain o a i al n he fnda s nd her
co el a a t ug t De e nt sc
uns , nd lho h he f nda ' ouns lha pr ve hi s ft be a e r i t
e s o n m el o n xpe t n he
a eaofl w,hi a lt t makema e i lsa e
r a s biiy o t ra tt ment off c st wa dst M ovantsmedial
s a t o r he ' c
condii n a a lt t m ake i t de ii i i que to
to nd biiy o t o postons s n s i n.
The c t ha a s f
ours ve lo ound i Hyde & Dr t v. nne h R.Ba rt t
n ah Ke t ke ha :
t ec nnotco l t tea h oft a lntc or tonswass t nta l
t a
W ncude ha c he ppela om a i ubsa ily
j si e i fiigt atn ted p sto s Onl K'ngsf i r t a p a wa
u tt d n al o te d h e o i n . y u ' al e o p e r s
i n i u
s bsa tal u tte . to g weh ved cie t ra ht emeiso t
u tnilyj si d Al u h
i h a e l d o e c h rt f he
n
a gu e t tK ' w a e us d f o a t ndi t de ii nsf hea t
r m nt ha ung s xc e r m te ng he pos to or lh
r s , dode i t tK'ngha a t l s,agood f t diput c e i
ea ons we cde ha u d, t he ea t aih s e onc m ng
t quesi n ofw he he he w a oblga e t a a i lghtofhi s r o il s.
he to t r s i t d o ppe r n i s e i us lnes
Hewa t rf r s bsa tal j tfe i fiigt a pe ra t d p sto .d.
s heeo e u tn il usiid n al o p a t he e o i n I
y n i
(n fc h s bs q n l de o b anc nc r. we r a ds u s da o e no
I a t e u e ue ty id f r i a e) Ho ve, s ic se b v , ne
oft ot com or i have a good f t di e concer ng t r f ltest
he her atons aih sput ni hei aitr o
a a . e f K' Hyde & Dr t ha f l t s w t isci nt w e e
ppe r Exc pt or ung, ah s aied o ho hat t le s r
s bsa tal u tfe i viltn tec u t ds o e yo des ( d a dDr t v.
u tn ilyj siid n oaig h o r' ic v r r r .Hy e n ah
s
Ke t R.Ba r e a ( F. l1 2:.
nneh ke , t l 24 3d 6 '9
5. l t Defnda ' c uns lwa t l convi edt tt M o ntwa a di t r
f he e nts o e s nly nc ha he va s voi ng hei
r que tf dic r vi de ii t c ul ha e r s d t i rght unde Fed a
e s or s ove y a poston, hey o d ve xe cie he r i s r er l

12


Rul ofCi lPr e e45( ( )d)a g a tldaSubpoe f De ii i whih
e vi oc dur b)c( ndt nd ie na or poston,n c
t c twoul i s aCommand t Atend aDe sii Thi woul bedonei an
he our d s ue o t po ton. s d n
c r t (, 1 Av i ig Un u Bu d no Ex n e S n to s A p ryo atr e
#è /o c( ) o dn d e r e r pe s ; a cin . a t r to n y
)
r s nsbl f r i s ng a s r i a s
e po i e o s ui nd e v ng ubpoe m us t ke r as bl s e t a d
na t a e ona e t ps o voi
i o igu ueb r e o e pe s o ap ro s be tt t es b o n . eis ngc u t
mp sn nd u d n r x n e n e s n u j c o h u p e a Th sui o r
m us e o ce t sdut a i pos a a o i t s nc i - whi h m ay i l l t
t nf r hi y nd m e n ppr pra e a ton c nc ude os
e r ngsa r as na e a t ne sf es -on apary ora t e who f ist c
n ni nd e o bl tor y' e - t tom y al o ompl Iy. n
f l wi t nle ofcvi pr ce e,hec t
olo ng he ls i l o dur t our woul is a o de f c e i
d s ue nd r r or ont mpt n
whi h t i s ng co tm a hol i co e pta pe s who, vi bee s r d,f l
c he s ui ur y d n nt m r on ha ng n e ve ais
wihouta quat e us t o y t s
t de e xc e o be he ubpoe na.
6. G i n t f tt D e e nt sc
ve he ac hat f nda ' ouns lkno s t tt y w oul nothave m e t bur n
e w ha he d t he de
ofpr r qui i t c t o i s a s poe f t M o ntt a a i lg oft
oof e r ng he our t s ue ub na or he va o ppe r n i ht he
c ii alna u e ofhi hea t c ton,t chos i t ad t c r um ve t s pr es ,a
rtc tr s lh ondii hey e ns e o i c nt hi oc s nd
us o he a nuesofac e ng t sm e nst t re ,t r ng t c t is
e t r ve hivi hi a o hei nds hus obbi he our of t
po e t c pe c pla e w ih t r esofc vi pr dlr
w r o om l om i nc t he ul i l oce z e.
A dititc t swi dic eton t e t bls t tm ea plc ofde ii .l r
src our ha de s r i o sa ih he i nd a e postons n e
StndadM easCom .81 F. 625,628( 0t Ci.987 , r. s se 488U. 881
a r tl , 7 2d 1 h r1 ) cetdimisd, S. ,
1 S. d.201 1 L. 2d 1 ( 988 . r t s cilma tre ane t ti wa
09 Ct , 02 Ed. 71 1 ) Hee,he pe a se xpli d ha t s
ne s a y f t Hong Kong de iinst tkeplcei Sa Fr nc s s t tt c t
ce s r or he posto o a a n n a ico o ha he our
c d ove s et pr ee ngssncea la shad dir ga de t pr vi usde ii n
oul r e he oc di i ppe lnt s e r d he e o posto
or r Healono e t tap la shaddonebusne sa fld s ti t Norhe n
de . s t d ha pe lnt i s nd ie ui n he t r
Di ki tofCa iom i a s ul t e or e c t ha t a a t r The e f t a e
s c lf a nd ho d her f e xpe t o ve o ppe r he e. s ac s r
s fc entt es a i h t tt r wasno a us ofdi c e i i or rng t de ii nst
ufi i o t bls ha he e b e s r ton n de i he pos to o
oc ur i San Fr nc s
c n a i co.
8. Bef r a di ki tc tdi m i s s a c pl nt i mus wei t fve f t s pr s rbed i
o e s c our s s e om ai , t t gh he i ac or e c i n
W a rrv.J hnso 91 F. 652,656( hCi.990) The t dititcour mus
ndee o tn, 0 2d 9t r1 . n,he src t t
fnd t tapa t sbe vi i i no i t depostonsde
i ha ry' ha or n g rng he ii mons e wilunes ,ba
katd lf l s d
f t orful. sa v.
aih, a tFeltd Amerca HondaM oo Co.76 F. 1 1 ( h
in tr , 2 2d 334, 341 9t
Ci.985)
r1 .
9. Fi l t tfh f ct r quie t dititc ur t c i ra tm a e l s s ve e
naly, he it a or e r s he src o t o onsde le t , e s e r ,
s ncto be o eor rng dimis l To de e mi whehe t dititc tf fle t s
a i ns f r de i s sa. t r ne t r he src our ulild hi
oblgai t rviwi co te neswhehert co t( )e iil dic s dt
i ton,he e e ng ur xami t he ur 1 xplcty s use he
f a i lt ofls dmsi s nc i a e ane why a tr tve s nctonswoul be
e sbiiy e s tc a tons nd xpl i d le na i a i d
i p r p it, 2 i e ne atmaies n to sbeo eo d rn ds sa, n ( )
na p o rae ( ) mplme td le tv a cin f r r e ig imis l a d 3
w a e t pa t oft pos i lt ofdi m i s be or ac aly or rng i . d i na 91
m d he r y he s biiy s s al f e m l de i t A r a , 3
F. at1 2- 3. ,' xplctdic so ofat r tve i unnec s a y i t ditit
2d 41 1 But ' ii s us i n
e lenai s s e s r f he src
co ta u ly tisa tm atve bef r e oyi t uli ae s nci n ofdim is l'
ur ct a l re le i s o e mpl ng he tm t a to s s a. '
M a o ,833 F. a 1
l ne 2d t 32.

Ac o di l t eM o n s o l bea r e s
c r ngy h va t h ud wad d umma yj d me t
r u g n.
Conc us on
l i

W HEREFOR E,t ki i o c i r ton t a or m entoned pr m i e , t
a ng nt ons de a i he f e i e s s and he
De e nt i biiy t pr vi hones, rua i a gu e st s
f nda s' na lt o o de t pe s sve r m nt o uppor t i c am s t
t her l i , he
M o a trs e tul r q e t t Co r t a r e s
v n e p cf ly e u ss he u t o wa d d ummayj g n i h sfv r
r ud me t n i a o .

13


Dat Ja y 16t, 2012
e: nuar ll

Re pe t uly Subm it d,
s cf l te

/ /
A e&# , J gq
m
TR AI BU J V EAN U ,PRO SE LI GA N T
AN DU TI

14

*

CERTI CATE OF SERVI
FI CE

lhe e y ce tf t ton ora
r b riy ha boutJANUARY 1 t , 201 atu and c r tco oft
6b 2 re orec py he
f egoi doc e wa s r d upon t f l ng vi t Unie Stt sPosal
or ng um nt s e ve he olowi a he t d a e t
Se vi e, r tCl s M ai:
r c Fi s a s l

Di m as Char t es I .
s i i , nc,
141 N. .1 St Avenue
W
Dani FL 33004-
a, 2835

Ana Gispert
Dim asChartesl .
s ii znc
141 N. .1 St Avenue
W .
Dani FL 33004-2835
a,

Der Thom as
ek
Di asChartesl .
sm ii ,nc
141 N. .1 St Avenue
W
Dani FL 33004-
a, 2835

LashandaAda s
m
Di m asChartesl .
s ii ,nc
141 N. .1 St Avenue
W .
Dani , 33004-
a FL 2835

Da d S.
vi Chai etEs re
qui
At or y f Def
t ne or endant s
4000 Holywood Boul var
l e d
Sui e 265-
t South
Holyw ood, 33021
l FL

EXECUTED ON THI 16t DAY OFJ
S h ANUARY,2012
M
. /
/K /& z
z z> /
41
TRAI BUJ
AN DUVEA U,PRO SE
5601 W .BROW ARD BLVD.
,
PLANTATI FL 33317
ON,


EX H I I A
B T

Casea Cha ii -Fr hst r Document 92 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/18/2012 Page 17 ofo 1
Di m 1:11-cv-20120-PAS t
s s rtes es a Pa 1 35
ge f

* *-
-
*.
.
.. I AS
SM HA RI ES
TI
W ?( )<-.
'
.
î ='
x. Home Seach Ta
r sks Repors Admi srton
t nitai
Tr i Bu du
aan j veanu
Ac' REouEs'
noN rs AcTl REQUE DETAIS
oN ST L
cAsENoTEs St f
af giper,ana
s t
CLE TI O
IN NF Cl
i
ent Budu ean Tr a
j v u, ain
CLENTST I
I AY NFo Number 3869
cosl r
wc's Requesed
t 10/ 2010 8: AM
17/ 31
CLENTTAsKs
I Date
DI
SCHARGE St us
at Com pl ed
et
DRII I
V NG NFO Thi ac i i t i or yOut no I dentRepor orConfscaton Sl
s ton s o nf m hat nci t i i ip
EMPLOYMENT Reason wer pr ded by St fmember atDi
e ovi af s smas Chartes,nc.as r r by
ii l , equied
EMP O N SCHE UL
L YME T D E BOP Reg a i s Bes Re d Tr i Budu eanu
ulton . t gars aan j v
FI MOVEMENTS
XED Pr ous
evi l you READ t Rul and Regul i Handbook gien t you by me
f he es aton v o
HouEcox .
F Res s s
pon e y wi s ta t si n p t ourprc e. tab d i j ttat
ou l ee h t hi s ot arof
l o edur Con r an s us h
M and i wilbe di
t l sposed of/Ana gi
. sped
ovsuEN' REouEs's
r r gip , ana 1 19/ 5: 00 PM
s ed 0/ 2010 24:
OF FENSES Response
O PEN M OVEMENTS
PAYMENT S
PROGRAMS
REQUI CHECKS
RED
ST ATUS HISTORY Save Reset Cancel Reassin
g
SUBSI STENCE
SUMMAR Y

hdpr dr i s a e T r hst
/ a- e r es M
/ e i nt he e / to e t/ i e
s de sc dul sAc iG quessActoG quesDe al . p.. 9/ 2011
t t isas . 7/

ragt 1 Ul 1
' . D Case Cba iis-Fr s a t Document 92 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/18/2012 Page 18 of 35
ib as1:11-cv-20120-PAS
sa rte e hst r

@*
:.
z: I AS
SM HA RI ES
TI
t t e ,.p'
% - .-'
- 0 -r
.
'
.
= Hom e s ac: T s s Re ors Ad ns rt
e r ak p t miitaion
<>
= -< -

Tr anBuduve
ai j anu AcnoN REouEs'DE LS
r TAI
AcnoN ReouesTs
CASE NoTEs St f
af gi rxana
sx t
CLE TI O
IN NF Cl
i
ent Budu e Tr a
j v anu, ain
CUI STAY I
ENT NFO Num ber 3901
GoN' r
r s
Ac' Requesed 10/ 2010 12.29 pu
t 19/ .
CLI n sKs
ENT Date
DISCHARGE st us
at Gom pl ed
et
DR N IF
M G NO n j i t ad iey t tb ca e'h ve ce an Tr an Budu ea
s s o vs ou ha e us ' e hil d ai j v nu
t
EMPLOYMENT has NOT bei aut i by Di as Chartesm l ni mak t Sear
ng horzed sm ii nc., t e he ch
EMPLOYMENT scHeouLe and Consscaton Il .Al pl
i legal so ease be advi t Ido notSmoke, i
de hat Drnk
MoveMsr s Reason 0:USe any Dr and neiherdoesany memberofmy f i n er or
ugs, t am l
y. ef e
Fl
xEo t accusatons ofuse ofCiar t i f se.l som eone i t St coul
he i g etes s al f n he af d
HOMEcoNF . make such ofst ement t how can jtustsuch per
r sons t sear my
o ch
MOVEMENT REQUESTS I he at w ts,hen
ockerort vehi e, ihoutm e bei pr
cl ng esentorwihoutm y knol
t edge ?
OF E E
F NS S Bes Re dsTr anBudu ean
t gar ai j v u
OPEN MOVEMSNTS Pr ous Pl
evi ease r yourHandbookr di sear
ead egar ng ches. Ana gi
/ sped
PAYMENT S Responses gs etan 1/920 0s:10 PM
ip f a 01 / 1 3 :0
PRooM Ms Response
REQUI CHECKS
RED
STATUS HlToR
s y
SusslT
s ENcE
suMm Ry .
Save Reset Cancel Reassi
gn

@ 9/ 2011
7/

CaseasCha iis-Fr s a t
Dim 1:11-cv-20120-PASr Document 92 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/18/2012 Page 19 ofof 1
s rte e hst Page 1 35

*#
*
. *.
. : I AS
SM H A RI ES
TI
'
.v '. J
Q ) .'
u ?t
'
h. $, ,-,
'.,1.>,='
-. s.
- Home Seach Task Repors Admi srton
r s t nitai
Tr an Bu duv
ai j eanu
AcnoN REQUESTS Ac-l REouE rDETAIS
roN s' L
CASE NoTEs St f
af gi t ana
sper,
CLE TI O
IN NF Cl
i
ent Budu e Tr an
j v anu, ai
CLENTST I O
I AY NF Number 3867
CoNn r
wc's Requesed 10/ 6/
t 1 2010 12: PM
42
CUI TASKS
ENT Dat
e
DISCHARGE St us
at Compl ed
et
DRII I
V NG NFO Thi i a r
s s equestt Exponge t 300'
o he Shotgi t me on Frday
ven o i
EMPL OYMENT 10/ 2010, 30 pm.The r
15/ 4: easonf t r
or he equesti t mor t 24
s hat e han
EMPL OYMENT SCHEDULE hour has pass si t i dentoccur and no r
s ed nce he nci ed eason f ext on
or ensi
FI MovExEx-s
XED r WaS gien t me.Alo plase not t among ot sancton,her was
v o s e e hat her i t e
H ' ghtW or Dut 'pl
'Li k y' aced i t s Shoot Pl
n hi . ease not t f t lhave
e he act hat
OME CoNF . Reason been diagnosed w jh t f lwi medi condii - r Hepatts C -
t he olo ng cal tons: vial ii
MOVEMENTRE QUESTS Li cihosi -- i Cancer- oni Fatgue - abet dr
ver r s lver chr c i Di es ombocyt openi
a
OF FENSES -- Pl el s Count-- Pherpher Bl Cicul i These medi
low at et low i al ood r aton cal
OPE MOVEMENT
N S condii do notper tme t acceptany ki ofwor BestRegar
tons mi o nd k. ds
PA NT
YME S TF i b j v u
aan udu ean
paoon xs Pr ous Denid.Thi i notan I dentRepod butan i house di plnar r
evi e ss nci n sci i y epo .
REQUI C HECKS
RED Respons Al :yourfl fom t i tt i st esyou ar clar t wor wii yo
es so i r he ns iuton at
e e e ed o k tn
medl condii Ibel dustng qualfes. Ana gi
cal tons. i eve i ii / sped
STATUS HITORY
S gs e , ana 10/ 20105: 00 PM
ip d 19/ 22:
SUBSISTENCE Response
SUMMARY

gn

hup:/ ni s w e / es e Re i nt
/dn a- e rFr hst s de sche es A c i G e s s A c i eq s D e a l . p.. 9 7/ 1
dul / to que t/ toG ue t t isas . / 201

Casem Cha ii -Fr hst r Document 92 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/18/2012 Page 20 1 of 1
Di m s
s 1:11-cv-20120-PAS t
rtes es a Pa of 35
ge

*+
-
..
:- I AS
SM HA RI ES
TI
t 'f ,'q:::j
i i i;:s/
'
x ? kv?' z:y.
-. ,
.. .
- tl. . Home seach n sk Repors Admi stai
r s t ni rton
Tr anBudu
ai j veanu
Ac'oN RE
n QUESTS ACTI REQUE DETAIS
ON ST L
CASENoTEs St f
af gi t ana
sper,
CLE I O
INT NF Cl
i
ent Budu ean Tr an
j v u, ai
CLE ST I
INT AV NFO Number 3900
coNn r
wc's Request 10/ 9/
ed 1 2010 12: PM
24
CLI TAsKs
ENT Date
DI
SCHARGE st us
at Com plt
e ed
DRI NG I O
VI NF Thi I t ri t advi you't lexperence pai and di
s eter s o se hat i n sconf ti my
or n
EMPLOYMENT I er Thi i due t bei upsetand harassed f t I week, Mr
i . ss
v o ng r or he ast by .
EMPLOYMENT SCHEDULE Thomas and hi St fmember Pl
s af s. ease be ki and advi M r Thomas
nd se .
FI MOVEMENTS
XED Reason t r r n fom upsetng me due t my medialcondii and t
o efai r i o c tons, he
dam mage ican be done t my fagi I er Ifankl beleve t s confi
t o r l i . r y i
e v hi lct
HOME coNF. has escal ed fom not ng t a Per
at r hi o sonalLeveland i i auempt t be
ts ed o
MOVEMENT REouEs's
r r ved i a vi ctve way by M r Thomas.BestRegar Tr an
esol n ndi i . ds ai
OF E E
F NS S Budu anu
j ve
OPEN MOVEMENTS Pr ous
evi Ido hope t youf beter Iwi speakt M rThomasr di t s
hat eel t . l l o egar ng hi
PAYMENTS Responses siuaton si as you know Ihave been outoft
t i nce own si 10/ 10. Ana
nce 14/ /
PROGRAMS gi t
sper
gi
sped,ana10/ 20105: 00 PM
19/ 31:
RE RED CHE
QUI CKS Response
STATUS HISTORY
SUBSISTENCE
SUMMARY

gn

hdp:/ ni- e erFr hst
/dn a s w / es r
*
e i nt he esAc iG e t/ i equesDe il.s . 9/ / l
sde sc dul / to quessActoG t t sa p.. 7 201


EXH I I B
B T

Di
CaseCha i s -Fr s a t Document 92 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/18/2012 Page 22 01 1
la 1 of 35
' ge
s ms 1:11-cv-20120-PAS
m dte e hst r

**
-
..
:.
- I AS
SM HA RI ES
TI
zs (; sj
tœ *- .s
es -z jj
j; ;v 'j
- w.' g,
j j :r
e)
V .. .
x
-'
t Home se r h T s s Re o t Admiltain
ac ak p rs nsrto
Tr i Bu duve
aan j anu
AcnoN REQUESTS ACTI RE
ON QUEST DE LS
TAI
cAsE Nomss St f
af Adams,Lashonda
cLs I O
INr NF Cl t
i
en Budu ean Tr an
j v u, ai
cusxrs' l
r wFo
Av Number 3872
coxn s
wcv Request
ed 10/ 2010 9: AM
17/ 17
c uEuvTAsKs Dat
e
Dl
scHAaoe st us
at com pl ed .
et
DRM NG I
NFO Pl
ease be knd and r de a BP- For , Ican 5l i t t pr
i ovi 9 m so e t o he oper
EMP OY N
L ME T Re on
as au onI r po abef gr van es Th vouTr an Bud ea
t es es ns l or i c . ank
e ai juv nu
EMP O N SCH UL Pr i s
L YME T ED E evou Mr Budu ean unorun t yi un l t obai a BP- Fr I
. j v u, f t ael was abe o t n 9 om.
Fl MovEMsN'
xEo rs Responses wil
lcheckwih t Diect t see iwe have such f m.
t he r or o f or
Ad . as n a 1 /9 0 94 0 AM
ams L ho d 0 1 Q01 :270
HOME CONF. R
MOVEMENT REQUES TS esponse
OFFENSES
O pEN M OVEMENTS
PAYMENTS
PROGRAMS
Save Reset Cancel Reassgn
i
REQUI CHECKS
RED
STATUS HI STORY
SUBSISTENCE
SUMMARY

heo./ o- omr r hRv
/aonl e evm aq sem eqdent
i schedul A ctoG eaues AcdonReques ev l % p.. 9/ 2011
es/ i l/ e s. . 7/

Dim m Chmii s- Fr hst r Document 92 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/18/2012 Page 23 tl1
s s te es a t
Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS riïr 1 of 35
t )

**
:.*
* *. I AS
SM HA Rl E5
Tl
1.it. xcs .
A'r. .
'
w)4
i
. ..
. Home s ac ns s Re ot Ad nsrt
e rh k prs miitai
on
Tr an Bu du nu
ai j vea
AcroN RequEs'
rs ACTI REQUE DE L
ON ST TAIS
CA Nor s
SE 'e St f
a gi er an
sp t a
CUE I O
NT NF Cl
i
ent Budu anu Tr an
j ve , ai
CLENTST l o
I AY NF Num ber 3889
coNJ r
wc's Request 10/ 010 10: AM
e 18Q 53
CLI TAsKs
ENT Date
D1
scHARoE st us
at Com pl ed
et
DRM NG I
NFO Thi I t i t i or you t B. . Regul i s at t an I dent
s eter s o nf m hat O P. atons t es hat nci
EMPLOYMENT Repor and a Consscaton Sl shoul be pr ded t t prs
t i ip d ovi o he ionerwihi 24
tn
EMRLOYMENT scHeouus hour oft i dent Al an i
s he nci . x nvestgaton shoul be cari outi t 5r
i i d red n he st
FlEo MovsMex'
x rs 24 bour Oft i dentby a bodyofpeopl t have no knol
s be nci e hat edge oft he
i dentand ar neutal Upon t fndi oft s NeutalComm i on,
nci e r. he i ngs hi r ssi a
HoMe coNF. shotcoul be i
d ssued wihi 5r 24 houroft i denti prsonerwas
t n st he nci f i
MoveMEN' RE
r ouEs'r
s found t be gui Today.
o l
y. when lhave ask Mr n omas and Ms.Adams
ed .
OFFENSES f a copy oft i dentr tand a copy oft consscaton slp, was
or he nci epor he i il
OPEN MOVEMENTS t d t t woul t me back t prson when '
ol hat hey d ake o i They'do t
' hatand t hat
pAvxsxvs Reason t s i t Grst
hi s he i mas Char is,nc.and NOT t Bur ofPrsons.Pl
ie l
t he eau i ease
not t t ot day,
e hat he her when Ihave asked M r R omas idoct shoul
. f or d
PROGRAMS have a I say i a medi materher he r
ast n cyl t e. esponded:. s i The
Thi s
RE REo cHEcKs
qul B o e and doct does nothave any say her I IghtofaIoft above,
or e. n i l he l
STATUS HISTORY am ki y aski you t hel m e i t s materas Iam conf
ndl ng o p n hi t , used and do not
SusslsTENcE under and why my ConsiutonalRi hs ar vi at and why i i t
st tt i g t e ol ed s s hat
SUMMARV when Iask aboutmy rght lam bei t eat
i s' ng hr ened wih a '
t Rwet n t
ur o
Prson' it s isue cannotbe r ved i
i ' f hi s
. esol nhouse i an ami e way.hen I
n cabl t
ki r uesta BP- For . Icoui 5I my grevances out de oft s
ndl e 9 m so l e
d i si hi
i tui Be eg dsTr a Budu ean
nsi t
t on. st ar ain j v u
Pr ous Pi
evi ease r yourhandbook r di contaband.Bestr ds.Ana
ead egar ng r egar /
Responses gi t
sper
qs et an 1 / 92 05 0 PM
ip l a 0 1 /01 27:0
Response

gn

J

hew./ ol- o o mm hAt em eqde sc dll / to e x Ac
/ao o c nrr eq n i nt he leKAci G uue fonRequeo e l- p.. 9 7 2011
x sc . / /

Case Chmii -Fr hst r
s s tes es a Fa 1i11
ge J
Dim a 1:11-cv-20120-PASt Document 92 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/18/2012 Page 24 of 35
- .

**
..
* .*
.
+ 1 AS
SM HA qj ys
yj
-'
* '-
# ---
'v.
-

.
' '<<) ?
è? k - >-
: i
U
.
Home s ac n s s Re ors Ad ns rt
e r: k pt miita i
on
Tr i Budu
aan j veanu
A Ac'oN REouEsm DET LS
n AI
cnoN REoues's
r
CA No E
SE T s St'
a gipe tan
s r a
CLE TIF
IN N o Cl
i
ent Bud ean Tr a
juv u, ain
CLI STAY l
ENT NFo Num ber 3905
CoNT r
Ac's Requested 10/ 9/
1 2010 4: PM
39
CLI TASKS
ENT Date
Dl
scHu oe st us
at compl ed .
et
DRM NG I
NFO 'hj a r
r s equestf a copy ofALL Shot i
or s ssued t me ort my name by
o o
EMPLOYMENT Dismas Chartes,nc. af member Subsequenty Iam r
ii l St f s. l equestng t
i hat
EMeLOYMENT ScHeouus Reason 3 BP- For Wi be i t me f each one oft
9 m l l ven o or he o I ssu o me
FI MovEMEx's
XED r Or 0 my nam e, lcoul l mygrevances.Ibeleve t
so d e i i hese ar my
e
Constt i Ri s, t shoul be notdeni BestRegar Tr an
iutonal ght and hey d ed. ds ai
HOMEcoN .
F Budu eanu
j v
M OVEMENT REQUESTS Pr ous
evi t
r ered
ansf r
OFFENSES Responses gs eta 1 / Q01 42 0 PM
ip r, na 020 0 :6:0
O P MOVEMENTS
EN Response
PAYMENT S
PROGRAMS
RE JRED CHECKS
QII
ST ATUS HISTORY
SUBSI STENCE. Save Reset Cancel Reassi
gn
SUMMARY

h% '/ ni q w e m x K G e i nt he e c i e
/dn n- e r hsG s de sc dl WA toG aues A c
W doG eque e e l . p.. 9/ / 1
s o s% . 7 201

rM ? lk* 1
J
.
Dim u Cha
s dfes-Fr hst r
es a t
x
..
. ' jo
,
< .

*'
z.
.
*
..
p I A S c qxqj rs
SM yj
r2)(7 G-
J -*W -%
*
i :
V '*
. Home se rh n s s Re o
ac k p- Ad ns rso
miita n
Tr in Budu
aa j veanu AcnoN REouEs' DEu l
r ts
Acno. RsouEs'
rs
CAS No s
E a StW
a gi et an
sp r a
CLE TIF
IN s o Cl t
ien Budu ean Tr an
j v u, ai
CLI ST l
ENT AY NFo Number 3899
coN' '
r r
v s Request 10/ 2010 11: AM
ed 19/ 25
CII n sKs
-ENT Date
Dl u Ros
scl St us
at Gom pl ed
et
DRM NG I O
NF Thi I t i t advi you t t
s eter s o se hat oday 10/ 2010, 50 am , was cal t
19/ 10: I l o
ed
EMPLOYMENT t fontdesk and t d t lshoul vacuum t r
he r ol hat d he oom 'orhi 'i an
'f mf n
,
EMPLOYMENTScHsot s
x atem ptt i i dat me.M s.Gi tpl
t o ntmi e sper ease be awar t as a r tof
e hat esul
Fl oMov Me s
xe e vr aIa on a n tme,o te I tweekbyMr Thomasa hi sa my
I di s gis f r h as . nd s tf,
Reason l has s lw and Ido experence pai Thi has been a gr ups t
iver walo i n. s eat et o
HOME coNF. t f s o eave me i peace. d keep on
me, yours af m ember do notwantt l
and n an
MOVEMENT REouss'
rs harassi me, t any r
f ng wihout eason.Please be ki and pr de me wih a
nd ovi t
OFFENSES BP- For , Ican 5I my grevanci
9 m so e i es.
out de oft spher oft s
si
-
he e hi
ops Mov Ms s
N e Nl i tui Be tReg dsTr anbudu ean
nsi t
t on. s ar ai j v u
PAYMENTS Pr ous
evi yoU HAVE BEEN GI A DI
VEN RECTI TO VACUM N THE ROOM AS A
VE
paoou Ms Res ons s SANCTI EXTRA DUTK AND YOU REFUSEDJ aNA GI
p e ON, SPERT
gipet a a 1g 9 1 5:90 PM
s r n (1 r 0 2 ::
REQUI CHECKS
RED Response
STATUS HISTORY
Sussl NcE
sa
SUMMARY

Save Reset Cancel Reas gn
si

. '
.
.

t
. ;
y
/

tt../ ol - o o mr botem etden scbe zeq An i
.t./ o o mzv ec n
ao l t dll / innRe t/ fonReaue e 's% p-. 9 7/ 1
cuesqAc e œ l . - / 201

Case Cha ii s-Fr hstr
s s rte es a t Pa 1 ot 1
ge
Dim a 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 92 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/18/2012 Page 26 of 35
' .mw

#e
*
. * *
.. * I AS
SM HA RI ES
TI
)-2':) > )
k. Nf. u
p' u % gj
.
-.
s x
Hom e Sear
ch Tasks Repors
t Adm i st aton
ni r i
Tr an Bu du
ai j veanu
AcnoN ReouEs's
r Ac' REouEs' DE LS
nos r TAI
cAs No E
: ms St f
af gip t a
s er na
CLE lF
INT N o Cl t
i
en Bud e ,Tr an
j uv anu ai
CLE ST I O
INT AY NF Num ber 3907
coN wc's
n r Requested 10/ 2010 6: PM
19/ 47
CLI TAsKs
ENT Dat
e
DI
SCHARGE st us
at compl ed
et
DRM NG I O
NF pjease be ki and advie atyourown conveni
nd s ence, perwhi r es
as ch ul
EMPLOYMENT t s i tt i f l
hi ns iuton olows:The B. P.Rul orDi asChartes,nc.Rul
O. es sm ii l es.
EMPLOYMENTSCHEDULE Reason I appear t me t r es appl her ar a materofc
t so hat ul ied e e t onveni
ence and
FI MOVEMENTS
XED DOtOfS ometng ofl nat e.Pl
i egal ur ease hel me t under t t si
p o sand hi ssue.
H Bes Re d Trin Bud e
t gars aa juv anu
OMEcoNF.
M Pr ous
evi tansf r
r ered
OVEMENT REouEs's
r Responses gs d, ana 10/0/ 104:6: PM
ipe 2 20 2 00
OFF ENSES Response
OPEN MOVEMENT S
PAYMENTS
PROGRAMS
REQUI CHECKS
RED
S'v us HlToRy
r s S
SUSSE C
BITN E a e Ree Ca cl Re sin )
v st ne a sg
SUMMARY

/
.
T? .
J
..
1
.
t
t ,
h
p

hc :/ ni -e e m r hsG
/dn a s w r es e i sc dul / fonRe t/ tov e
sdent he esAc quessAc i ques eaisas . 9 7 2011
r t l . p.. / /

5

EX H I T C
BI

Dim u Cha ii -Fr hst r Document 92 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/18/2012 Page 28 t1 35
s rtes es a t
Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS rage 1 of 1
)

*
*#*
*'.
.
.. l AS
SM H A RI ES
TI
'? ( ' %@
t- w> z
W ' e
. R
-
Home se r h Ta k Re ot Ad nsrto
ac ss p rs miitain
Tr a Bu duve
ain j anu
AcyoN REouEs's
l r AcnoN Rcoues' DETAIS
r L
cAsE NoTEs Staf Adams,Lashonda
CLEN I o
I T NF Cl t
i
en Budu eanu Tr a
j v , ain
CLENTST I
I AY NFO Number 3235
coxa r
wc's Request
ed 7/ 2010 12: PM
29/ 24
CLI TAsKs
ENT Dat
e
Dl u aoe
scl st us
at compl ed .
et
DRI NG I O
VI NF jwoul l t atend Chur Sevi ev Sunday mom i att
di o t
ke ch ces, el ng, he
EMPL OYMENI Reason Romani Orhodox Chur l ed on ST .
an t ch ocat Road 441 and Pembr
ooke
EMPLOYMENT SCHEDULE Pines.
FI MOVEMENT
XED S PX Vi I
OLS YOU ar Onl al
e y l owed t tavelWihi 5ve m i oft f ly f
or tn les he acit or
i
HOMC COHF. RPSRODSSS F i ous Ser c
Plgi vies.
Adams,Las
honda7/92 04: 00PM
2 /01 23:
M ovEMeN' ReouE r
r s's R
O esponse
FFENSES
OPEN MOVEMENTS
PAYMENTS
PROGRAMS
REQUI CHECKS
RED S
SA U Hl o Y
TTS s R
T a e lRee Ca c l Re sin
v st ne asg
SUBSI
STENCE
SUMMARY

&
he : de a- e e T r s
// s w r e hsG e i nt
s de sche es A c i G eques A c
di / to l/ doG eque r e l . p.. 9/ 2011
s M s % . 7/

Pa 1of1
ge
1 1 % ( HM -Frs str
:s1 '
1 AX e h at

'
.
I AS
SM
.
= Home Se rh YW 's
ar k è# A
'3- ---
-- '
- -'-- '''
- -' - --.
-
Tr a Bu duve
A= oN REQUQ anu
ain j STS X OVEMSW REQDE DQT V
ST AI
cAsE Noa s StaF Adams,Lashonda
CUENT I
NFO Clent
i Bu' veanu, ai
d Tr an
CUENT ST I O
AY NF Request Dat
ed e :/ 201:
4/
coN wcr
l 's Requ t F Da t 88201
ese or t // :
Dlc ARosKs
cuHv n e
sH Loo tons
i Gener
N me al
a st e
re
a s- c
tw -
- * s e
o4 mp
Hol Cr
y oss 6232 Fpmor
l e soj
jywoou't 33024
F
Dnl ho I O
vll NF Church Steet
r
EMPLO- EG ScHaouus Requesl OutTf
Eupl svr
-oa ed me 9: AM
00
Fl M ovsx- s
xso Dur i
aton 4 Ho rs G Miues
ul) n tl)
HoueMENT Reque r
MO< coug. a's M ode c) t in To
Transporat
f o Yr
ZnS9OXed by Fami Frend
l i
y/

o- sxses Mode of Tr
anspored by Famiym rend
t l i
opEN MoveMsr s
PAYMENTS Tr
ansporaton Fr
ti om Iwoul tke t atend Chur Ser es.Di ance:7. miabott
di o t ch e st 3 - l
Reason - -
1 mi
5 ns
PgooM Ms œcKs
Rs aeo ci
STqul H' ORY
ATUS SY St us Rexson
ataj
oeni Denl evenl Gan you rr and 5ne a chur wih l fve mies
GOOded ng. ty ch t n l l
sussl ENcE
sT - - eft f ly.
he acit
i
SUMMARY Gancel

Di Pa elof1
g
s asO s tes -Fres art
m rii hst

MovEMEr REouEsT DET L
AIS
St f
af Adams.Lashonda
Cl
ient Bu' duveanu,Tr an
ai
Request Dat 106/
ed e / 2010
Dat etd o k
Reeu se F r 10/ 2010
q 10/
.-
.. M
Loca:ons Gener
al
Name ta
r- ate u ci
re w st t
as
Romani Oc odox Ghur 6232 Fimor Skeet
an ch l e
l Hol
lywood FL 33024
Request Out 10: AM
ed 00
Time
Dur i
aton 3 Hx ds 0 Miu s.
l n wt)
Mode Of Transpoe d by Fami Frend
l i
y/
Transpoe tonTo
i
Mode Of
Transporaton
ti Tœnspored by Fami / i
t l Frend
y
From
Thi i a r
s s equestf ' ch Aoendance'Chur i I ed at9. M iand shoul 1keabout
or' Chur ' ch s ocat 5 d
Reason 16 M i esby car Ther ar ONLY Y o Oe odoxchur
nut . e e ches i So* Fl i and b har
n ordav ot e
I ed about16 m i es awayfom my home.
ocat nut r
St us
at Deni ed
Deni Reason You need t 5nd a pl ofwor p wihi 5 mi sofyourhome.
al o ace hshi t n l
e
Ica c lJ
ne

&


EX H I I D
B T


' ' ' -
B lm asChahdes I
a , nm
b i i Ina
sc i Re ort

.- .- . ...w
Rsgd tN
o . .j r
s g xp xà
Budu ean Tr a
' v u, ain 80 5. %
65 0 Dani Be h
a ac
Rul # '
e ae of lg Of ns
t Al ed f e
e e St t s
au
309 1 1
c/35DsG Pr e e
omelas

Descr ton and Com m ena :
i i

Mr Buduv uwa o ere op a iga moorv il on 1 / 3201 Mr Budu ea i
. j ean s bs v d ertn t ehce 0 1 / 0. j v nu s .
notau horzed t o er e a mot vehi e wihoutt a r oft Diedor
t i o at or cl t he oval he r .

Resi
denfs Com m ene :
a'>. p , -
hJ a r l '
' r- z f '
*- . .
e
w /y . . lz -
-
goz. & 9y#m 4 Ae 9
er . H s / ,r *e 2OZ
Y /
Rsetiar
einSnte
d gu e d .. Dt
ae , oyywv
v
g
/ k /Z>
w ' 1 l 'l
0- Y= '
B
Re t g Stf Si
gori a f g
n l . Dae 1q-
t
). 1ç= tc
Pr en ng St Sina u e
es : al g t r . Da e
t
/ ( .(
u. y . D
.

I
nvest aton:
i i

Resi
dents Com m ene :
'

Num berofDRs t dat
o e: 2 NumberofDRsf t s r e: 0
or hi ul

Acton Taken:
i
' . cv'' & ' pnh
wâkqn fr '
- /'t êHn* . T m w
. *
. ha <e, u Y Q # - 5 H- G*
'< % Y /
f ' '*
&- =
, , r -q. e
r Pu . '-çz
..
T> .
.
: e
.

Resde tSi at e
i n gn ur Dae
l 'naur
q te Dae
t
xe
.wz f - -3
e* f

$ 5& VVW YW O' 3 PM 'X

dci n
207il P g 1o 1
ae f
Revi > / 04
sed 01/


Cas 1. 1- -' 1ZO- A Docum en 60 En er on FLSD Docl t10 03/ 1 Page 28 of39
e ' cv zo
1 r' PJS t t ed œ / 201

' im a cha fr -
Di l rr- .
. . -- -- -- . - - . ...

. &s Inar R : cr
cl l v t ' l
j
l
'

.ret.. - jaa.
ll '
i . e' '
-=-
w. :h .
v l a

l * ;
? lD eer e -.o.-
at lu c. m . I
.
.. .**
- . ! . . --J 1w l
. '
. . ,n: .
e . .-
w-
,s!vus i
J
0
:e
.
! &
. ;
,
scrPt nu'd com m ent . '
1-
- 1 -n' s ..
e - v. . 1
- ,
!
;
. . . -
* ;. ys . - zw - w. *- * -
. Q
e N
z >er 4 %
< .. .
.- .
. .
- .7 -r
R =sil a.s c om
. ceIt
- .
m e n.s.
t.

; ...=n* -n . >
j N=Qc- tS-.a,r ,
.--
e . >lx
c ..
*. *
' ,:q
. 0
.
.
lce ',. . Qa = w. . Io --
..
I 9 &n
. -ni
4 - .
h a
. w..'wl. =q ya
a .. co .r
,. u . 1
. I
.
*
rC.Q.p.l ws.= gtr .r.
'=. m.Kru Qa j .
w%. rt > mj n .
.l a
. . m * D= &
-t='
-
,
. * = . t.:'-
l. . z.
. l . ?
D=!
-- .
'
-
l
' l
lnvestgaton:
i i

P esi os Comm ont '
x dent'

lu
N1 m berofDQs t dah :
. ' o t
x e 1
$ %' - - -
I ' *
, I .
. . t o ru e: i
j
:
1
.
%ctol -1 ken.
, il a

Re uxn sknaur
s-:t
' ts
Oa e
l '
ISxlslc tr
r r c auo
a.
j - . l).
(j
ae

Kp-s2@8 (
Continued)

FINDINGS OF THE COMMITTEE
The ace was committed as charged. Code l08 and Code 309

b. The following act was committed :
c. No prohibited act was committed: Expunge according to your Statement of Work.

V . SPECIFIC EVIDENCE RELIED ON TO SUPPORT FINDINGS
Your due process rights were read and reviewed with you by the CDC Committee at the time of the
hearing. You stated you understood your rights.
The CDC found evidence that your behavi violated the BOP's Pr
or ohibited Act, Code l i. . Pos
08 e session
manufacture, or introduction of a hazardous tool an Cod 309 i. Vi
d e e. olati a condi
ng tion of a community pro m.
gra
The Co tt based i decisi o the fac outli d i t wri n re
mmi ee ts on n ts ne n he tte port: On 10/13/10 I o erv off der
bs ed en
B duvea wal ng t ds his vehic blue Ford Ex re tru
uj nu ki owar let plo r ck) i t res nt par ng lo He t got i
n he ide ki t. hen nto
t vehicle a ba
he nd cked t ve
he hicle into a parking s pace. I asked his counselor i he was a
f uthorized to dri and
ve
she stated that he was not and that his wife was authorize t tr
d o anspo hi A review of his fi co borated
rt m. le rro
t he was not a h ed t dri Offe
hat ut oriz o ve. nder Bujduvea ha dri n t ve cle f his ho to the f lity.
nu d ve he hi rom me aci
Hi c
s ouns or went o
el utsi a bro ht off r B duv
de nd ug ende uj eanu i de where we questio hi a ut w he was
nsi ned m bo hy
driving without authorization . Staff explained to him that it was against the rules for hi to operate a
m
vehicle without permission and we searched his vehicle. Duri the search staff found an unauthorized cell
ng
p ne ( ack Mot
ho bl orola in of nder B
fe ujduvea s na a a bl Motor c phone c rger. Off r B
nu' me) nd ack ola ar ha ende ujduveanu
is therefore in violation of code Bogiviolating a condition of a community program and code lo8tpossession
manufaceure, or introduction of a hazardous tool.

V I . SAN CTION RECOMMENDATION Based on the above evidence the Committee recommends
offender Bujduveanu, Trai re
an main Discipli ' transferred.
nazy

VII . REASON FOR SAN CTION RECOMM ENDATION

To deter this and other inmates from committing similar acts the
future .
VIII . APPEAL RIGHTS Inmate was adv ised .
The inmate has been advtsed of the findings, specific evidence relied on, action and reasons for
the action . The inmate has been advised of his ri ght to appeal under the Administrati Remedy
ve
Procedure or by letter within 20 days of the imposition of t sanction to the Regional Director.
he
A copy of this report has been qiven to t inmate.
he

IX . D ISCIPLIN E COM MITT EE
: .
Chairperson Member Member

Galo Rugel <
X . ACTION BY DHO

Typed Name/signature - DHO Date

(This for ma be replicated via WP)
m y

&

x'- à8. 7 CENTER DISCIPLINE COM ITTEE REPORT (
p s2 ' o 3 CCC'S) CDF M
R
MAR 94 *
U .S . DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE FEDERAL BUREAU OF PRISONS

Name of Inmate Register Number He ' Date
Bujduveanu, Traian 80655-004 10/29/10
g Date of I dent
nci ident Report Prohibited
10/13/10 10/13/10 Actl Code 108, 309
s)
summar of Chargel Possession, manufacture or introduction of a hazardous tool / Vi
y s olati a
nq
c ndition of a communit ro ram .

1. NOTICE OF CHARGE IS)
Date Typed Name/signature DHO
A. Advance written notice of charges (copy of incident report) was given to inmate on
10/20/10 at 0739 by Dontallis Render . ( Resident refused to accept a copy of
the charges when he was picked up by the US Marshals.
Date Time

The CDC Heari Was held on
ng 10/29/10 at 10:50am .
Date Time

The inmate was advised of his rights before this CDC by: Bobbie Lowery

on 10/22/10 and a copy of the adviseme of ri
nt ghts form is attached.
Date

STAFF REPRESENTATIVE
Inmate waived right to staff representative: ( No/ He originally called for RM Corky
Yes/ NA)
Shennett who was unable to attend due to his work schedule.

Inmate requested staff representative and NA appeared.
Requested staff representative declined or could not appear but inmate was advised of option
to postpone hearing to obtain another staff represe ntative with the result t hat: Staff
mooher Angela Moore was sent as a staff rep and offender Bujduveanu did not request another
staff rep .

III PRESENTATION OF EVIDENCE .
A. Inmate has been advised of his right to present a statement or to remain silent, to present
documents, including written st atements of unavailable witnesses, and for relevant and
material witnesses to appear in his behalf at the hearing .
Inmate admits/denies the chargel during the investigati
s) on
Summary of Inmate Statement:

Witnesses:
The inmate requested witnesses: .I &A/No/NA)
.Y
1. The following persons were called as witnesses at this hearing and appeared: See
a t c m n ( .. ( : -V
ta h e t ( / XJ
O
A summary of testimony of each is attached: (
Yes/No/NA)
T e f l n pe o r u e w e n c l f r t r as nt gi n:A S
h ol owi g rs ns eq est d er oe al ed o he e o sl ve J
Unavailable witnesses were requested to submit written statements and those statements
were considered: I.e s/No/NA)
. Y.

Documentaz Bvidence : In addition to the incident Report and Investigation, the Committee
'y
considered the follp -tpg documents
. y z--olq . pà. - çoms..lce/- the fokkow g-- ments-- . ,
l. Ce t tc4 si - - .- .M doa l .
Documentation allowi offender Bujduveanu s wife to transport him and photos of the cell
n:
phone and charger.
Confidential information was considered by the CDC and not provided to inmate (Yes/No/N&)

Plaintiff's reply in brief in response to defendant's response brief and in support of the plaintiff's motion for summary judgment

More Related Content

Similar to Plaintiff's reply in brief in response to defendant's response brief and in support of the plaintiff's motion for summary judgment (20)

More from Cocoselul Inaripat (20)

Recently uploaded (20)

Plaintiff's reply in brief in response to defendant's response brief and in support of the plaintiff's motion for summary judgment