Pre breeding in maize
- 2. • Activities related to genetic resources are characterized by high cost and long term return. • Thus the conservation of genetic variability for the future and the efficient utilization of available accessions are two important goals to be attained. • However, the low utilization of germplasm banks is not restricted to Brazil but to other developing countries as well. • Therefore, pre-breeding is a promising alternative to link genetic resources and breeding programs.
- 3. INTRODUCTION • Maize (Zea mays L.) is a genetically highly studied plant species, consequently, the inheritance of several characteristics and its genome are well known. • Some factors for the key position of maize among panmitic species are : economic value, genetic diversity and variability, well identified by its ten chromosomes, facility to obtain large number of seeds from controlled (self and outcross) pollination and facility to obtain different types of progenies. • Also, many outstanding scientists devoted their life to the study of both basic and applied research. • As a result, most breeding methods for allogamous species have been developed initially in maize
- 4. • About 300 races of maize have been recognized in the Western Hemisphere. Brieger et al. (1958) and Paterniani & Goodman (1977) described and evaluated the genetic potential for races of maize in Brazil and adjacent areas. • Approximately 50% of these races are adapted to low altitudes (0 - 1000 m), 10% to intermediate (1000 - 2000 m), and 40% to higher altitudes (>2000 m). • Regarding to endosperm type 40% are floury, 30% are flints, 20% are dents, less than 10% are popcorns, and almost 3% are sweetcorns (Paterniani & Goodman, 1977).
- 5. • It is estimated that about 100,000 accessions of maize are maintained in germplasm banks around the world (Chang, 1992). • In 1994, the International Maize and Wheat Improvement Center (CIMMYT) Maize Germplasm Bank had in storage nearly 11,000 accessions in its base and active collections. • Over the next two decades, the bank will eventually reach from 30,000 to 35,000 accessions (Taba, 1994).
- 6. • The search for superior genotypes regarding yielding ability, disease and pest resistance, stress tolerance or better nutritional quality is very hard, competitive and expensive. • This is why breeders tend to concentrate to adapted and improved materials, avoiding wild parents, landraces and exotics, available in germplasm banks which would require long time, high financial support besides the difficulty to identify potentially useful genes. • Marshall (1989) emphasized that the difficulty to identify useful genes is the main factor responsible for the low utilization of these accessions. • Evidently, there is a gap between available genetic resources and breeding program activities. • While germplasm banks try to preserve as much as possible the genetic variability to be used by breeders, breeding programs do not explore efficiently the available diversity, relying almost exclusively on their working collection.
- 7. • It is generally recognized that commercial hybrids stand on a narrow genetic basis (Goodman, 1990). • Hybrid maize breeding is a very competitive enterprise and the trend is that this competition is likely to increase. • Thus, plant breeders are exploring elite inbred lines since these materials are expected to yield promising results in the short term. • In order to secure continuous genetic improvement, maize breeders adopt several ways to obtain new genetic materials.
- 8. • Among these, recently, both public and private programs are using intensively the most improved available materials. • In this way, to develop new populations and inbred lines, commercial F1 hybrids are being widely used, since this is a legitimate source of parental germplasm (Parks, 1993). • However, the recurrent use of these genotypes should increase the narrowness of the genetic base. • In a short time, available commercial hybrids probably will be very similar since they partake the same genetic background. • Genetic vulnerability must be a constant concern in plant breeding for all species. • Theoretical expectations and actual experience show that the use of uniform materials can be dangerous, as occurred with cytoplasm T, susceptible to Helminthosporium maydis race T in the United States in 1970 and next year in other regions of the world.
- 9. • Pre-breeding programs can generate new base populations for breeding programs and also assist in identifying heterotic patterns for hybrid programs. • Marshall (1989) considered that the lack of pre-breeding programs is the most limiting factor for using landrace germplasms and unadapted exotic lines from collections. • Pre-breeding at CIMMYT's Germplasm Bank collections, aims to provide to breeders ready utilization of materials with specific traits of interest as well as a means to broaden the diversity of improved germplasm. • Caribbean collections are receiving first priority for pre-breeding efforts, based on the interest of this germplasm both by tropical and temperate maize breeders, and the fact that, evaluations of these collections are already under way (Taba, 1994). • As a result of these pre-breeding programs, many gene pools and populations were developed by CIMMYT for tropical lowlands, as shown in TABLE 1.
- 11. • Clearly pre-breeding programs are time-consuming and tiresome. • For private plant breeders, generally under pressure to fulfill short term goals, exotics that underwent pre-breeding are likely to be more useful and certainly more attractive (Smith & Duvick ,1989). • Consequently, close cooperation between public and private institutions can be especially helpful in pre-breeding programs (Smith & Duvick, 1989; Nass et al., 1993).
- 12. • Heterotic pattern is a key factor for utilizing germplasm to maximize performance of the population-crosses and derived hybrids (Eberhart et al., 1995). • Pre-breeding can identify heterotic patterns for breeeding programs where the goal is hybrid development. • Although the heterotic pattern between Lancaster Sure Crop and Reid Yellow Dent has received greatest use in U.S. programs, other heterotic patterns have been considered as Leaming and Midland (Hallauer et al., 1988). • Identification of other heterotic patterns should contribute for a broadening of germplasms to be used commercially (Mungoma & Pollak, 1988).
- 13. • CIMMYT's heterotic patterns are shown in TABLE 2
- 14. • The need to keep the amount of accessions in genetic banks in a manageable number is becoming more evident. • In this way, an additional advantage of well succeeded pre- breeding programs is the establishment of core collections. • The main goal of the core is to represent the genetic diversity of a crop species and its relatives with a minimum of repetitiveness. • Brown (1989a) suggested that the core should consist of about 10% of the collection, which represents nearly 70% of the genetic variability. • Moreover, the core should not exceed 3,000 entries. • The establishment of these collections does not affect the base collection strategic role that is a source of replacement of the extensive genetic variability of different species (Brown 1989a,b; Vilela-Morales et al., 1997).
- 15. Methods • There are several alternatives for incorporating useful characteristics into adapted materials. • The methodology depends on the heritability, gene action, number of genes involved, heterosis, and genotype x environment interactions. • Whenever a superior germplasm is available from ongoing breeding programs, improvement by introgression is usually the least expensive and speedy method for improving the selected pre- breeding accessions (Eberhart et al., 1995).
- 16. • The ideal proportion of exotics to be incorporated into adapted germplasms has been investigated by several researchers, but so far there is no conclusive information about this question. • According to Bridges & Gardner (1987), it depends on the breeding goals (short or long term), and also on the performance of both exotics and adapted germplasms. • Wellhausen (1965) recommended the incorporation of about 25% of exotic germplasm into Corn Belt adapted materials.
- 17. • Crossa & Gardner (1987) reported that populations with 75% and 100% of adapted germplasm did not differ in grain yield, being both populations superior to populations with 50% of adapted germplasm. • Different levels of introgression (0, 25, 50, 75, and100%) were evaluated by Michelini & Hallauer (1993), who observed that better yields were obtained in crosses with 50% exotic germplasm, and also suggested the use of the exotic heterotic pattern Suwan-1 and Tuxpeño for further selection in U.S. Corn Belt breeding programs
- 18. • Backcrossing is an efficient way to transfer characteristics controlled by one or two genes, although it can be used also for higher number of genes, including quantitative characters. • Thus, backcross has been used to improve adaptation of exotic germplasms. • Eberhart (1971) suggested that the first backcross to adapted germplasm is the best base population to start selection. • Degree of dominance and diversity of the parents affect the optimum number of backcrosses before initiating selection.
- 19. • In general, as the degree of dominance increases and as the parents become more diverse, additional generations of backcrossing before initiation of selection are required (Dudley, 1982). • However, if exotic germplasms have been previously selected for adaptability, immediate positive effects can be obtained (Crossa et al.1987; Mungoma & Pollak, 1988). • Considering the probability of fixing alleles, Crossa (1989) observed that if an exotic population has been selected for adaptability and should have high frequency of favorable alleles, the resulting population can be used directly as base population for selection. • In the case backcross is used with the adapted parental, then an increase in population size is recommended in order to maintain the previously incorporated favorable alleles.
- 20. New base populations • Another alternative to improve germplasm utilization is the synthesis of new populations and their subsequent introduction into breeding programs. • This has been an important CIMMYT's contribution for maize breeding around the world. • Several pools have been developed according to specific characteristics such as maturity cycles, climatic zones, grain color and endosperm types (Salhuana, 1987).
- 21. • Crossa et al. (1990) suggested the use of germplasm collections to develop new heterotic populations for reciprocal recurrent selection, both to develop inbred lines and hybrids based on combining ability as well as for introgression into heterotic populations. • The collections and/or their derived cross populations could also be improved by intrapopulational methods in order to develop superior open-pollinated varieties.
- 22. Successful examples • Salhuana (1987) showed an interesting proposal involving scientists from several countries to evaluate maize germplasm. • He suggested that the following traits should be taken in a preliminary evaluation : early and final stand, male and female flowering, plant and ear height, broken plants, lodged plants, number of ears per plant (prolificacy), endosperm type, grain color, quality of the ear and yield. • In addition to these traits, others may be considered according specific situations.
- 23. Latin American Maize Project (LAMP) • LAMP is a real example of pre-breeding program, which includes 12 countries (Argentina, Bolivia, Brazil, Colombia, Chile, U.S., Guatemala, Mexico, Paraguay, Peru, Uruguay and Venezuela). • LAMP evaluated 15,000 accessions in the first stage, with close cooperation of the public and private sectors. • Pioneer Hi-Bred International Company was decisive for the financial support of the project. • The great genetic variability in Latin American maize is recognized, although there is much to be known, especially its potential and its significance for breeding approaches. • There is also little available information concerning agronomic traits.
- 24. • LAMP was carried out in five stages over a 5-year period. • In stage 1 each accession selected in each country was grown with two replications at a single location. • In stage 2 only the top 20% evaluated accessions were planted in two locations with two replications and the upper 5% were selected. • Selected materials were interchanged among countries in stage 3. They were planted at each partner's country in two locations and with two replications; they were also crossed with an adapted local tester in an isolated field.
- 25. • In stages 4 and 5, experiments were conducted to test the combining ability of the selected accessions with the adapted testers. • Evaluations for resistance to disease and tolerance to climatic and soil conditions were also planned. • Pollak (1993) showed the results of 562 Caribbean maize accessions obtained in Puerto Rico. • Grain yield of the best 20% ranged from 3,937 to 7,773 kg ha-1, and 18 accessions out yielded the check "Diente de Caballo", a local improved variety.
- 26. • Accessions with good ear quality and grain yield were identified for use in the Caribbean and other tropical breeding programs. • In Brazil, 1,111 accessions fulfilled the conditions required by LAMP (minimum of 1 kg of seeds and viability > 75%), and all adapted to altitude under 2000 m. TABLE 3 shows the selected accessions after two years of evaluations at different locations in Brazil (M.X. Santos Pers. Comm.). • It can be seen that several accessions showed high grain yield besides other important agronomic traits like low ear height and earliness
- 28. Problems to be investigated and suggestions • Environmental conditions for maize in the tropics are widely variable. • Edaphic and climatic variations are found among and within different regions. • Socioeconomic differences are also found among regions, as well as among farmers, within these regions (Paterniani, 1990). • All these factors indicate that tropical conditions for a good corn crop are more adverse then those found in temperate areas. • Consequently, problems of breeding are more numerous and more complex. • Since most of the local cultivars seldom possess the required characteristics for the different growing conditions, pre-breeding program for some specific traits should be conducted locally.
- 29. • Priority should be given to the following characteristics: • 1) plant and ear height, since generally tropical materials have tall plants with ear placement high on the stalks; • 2) prolificacy, which is highly correlated to grain yield; • 3) tassel size, since is negatively correlated to yield and tropical maize cultivars frequently have large tassels (25 to 35 branches) ; • 4) disease resistance, nowadays, the main problem in Brazil; • 5) insect resistance, also a great problem in tropical and subtropical areas; • 6) drought tolerance, since the growing season in tropical and subtropical areas is characterized by erratic variations of rainfall;
- 30. • 7) tolerance to aluminum toxicity, important for specific areas and several contributions have shown the presence of genetic variability in maize for Al tolerance; • 8) nutritional quality, particularly important for developing countries; • 9) low temperature tolerance, especially as a strategy for growing maize in subtropical areas, such as in South of Brazil; • 10) other traits, such as nitrogen and phosphorus utilization efficiency, earliness, photosynthetic efficiency, and stalk quality.
- 31. • REFERENCES • BECK, D.L.; VASAL, S.K.; CROSSA, J. Heterosis and combining ability of CIMMYT's tropical early and intermediate maturity maize (Zea mays L.) germplasm. Maydica, v.35, p.279-285, 1990. • BRIDGES JR., W.C.; GARDNER, C.O. Foundation populations for adapted by exotic crosses. Crop Science, v.27, p.501-506, 1987. • BRIEGER, F.G.; GURGEL, J.T.A.; PATERNIANI, E.; BLUMENSCHEIN, A.; ALLEONI, M.R. Races of maize in Brazil and other eastern South America countries. Washington, 1958. (NAS-NRC, 593) • BROWN, W.L. A broader germplasm base in corn and sorghum. Proceedings Annual Corn and Sorghum Research Conference, v.30, p.81-89, 1975.