Program Evaluation Rubric

2015 Judy Serritella Exemplary Library Media Program Self-Evaluation Rubric
GLMA & GLA
October 2014 Page 1 of 13
All Rights Reserved
All Exemplary programs will meet or exceed the definitions below for Basic, Proficient, and Exemplary programs. All Exemplary programs
will have achieved the requirements set out in state education laws, state board policies, state guidelines, and selected National Standards.
Target Indicators
And Categories
Levels of Proficiency
Category 1 - Student
Achievement and Instruction
Basic Proficient Exemplary
1. Information Literacy Standards are
integrated into content instruction
(Information Power; Principle 2; Pg.
58)
AASL Standards for the 21st-Century
Learner are integrated into content
instruction. (
http://tinyurl.com/3q8dpa)
Information Literacy Skills
curriculum is comprised of
basic library media orientation
skills and instruction on how
to find information.
Information literacy skills are
integrated into the curriculum through
the collaborative efforts of the Library
Media Specialist and teachers. Georgia
Performance Standards (GPS) and
Common Core GPS (CCGPS) are used
as a basis for teaching.
The library media program fosters critical thinking
skills and independent inquiry so students can
learn to choose reliable information and become
proactive and thoughtful users of information and
resources. The Library Media Specialist and
classroom teacher collaborate using CCGPS and
GPS to plan and teach the units of study. The
library media program uses the AASL standards to
help shape the learning of students in the school
2. Collaborative planning includes
both the Library Media Specialists and
teachers to ensure use of library media
center resources that support on-going
classroom instruction and
implementation of state curriculum
and the GPS and CCGPS.
(IFBD 160-4-4-.01)
The Library Media Specialist
participates in collaborative
planning when initiated by the
teacher.
encourages collaborative planning
among teachers who are teaching units
of similar content. The Library Media
Specialist is familiar with the Georgia
Standards.org website and the
Common Core standards and
encourages teachers to use the
resources available on GSO web page.
The Library Media Specialist actively plans with
and encourages every teacher to participate in the
design of instruction. Learning strategies and
activities for all students are designed with all
teachers who are willing to plan collaboratively.
All students with diverse learning styles, abilities,
and needs are included in collaborative plans.

GLMA & GLA
All Rights Reserved
3. Professional library media staff are
engaged in active teaching role/s.
(Information Power;
Principle 4, p. 58)
makes recommendations to
students for class projects and
pleasure reading. The Library
Media Specialist provides basic
orientation and instruction on
information location skills.
The Library Media Specialist and
teachers plan and teach collaboratively
so that the library media program is an
extension of classroom instruction.
The Library Media Specialist uses a variety of
teaching styles to meet diverse needs of students.
Collaborative planning, which takes place on a
regular basis, determines where and how student
assessment takes place, and whether the teacher or
the Library Media Specialist does the assessment.
The GPS and CCGPS are integrated into the units
led by the LMS and classroom teacher.
4. The library media center resources
encourage and support reading,
viewing, and listening.
(Information Power;
Principle 6, p. 58)
Bulletin boards and displays of
books and reading materials
reflect different aspects of the
curriculum, holidays, and
community interests to support
recreational reading.
The library media center offers events
and activities that appeal to a wide
range of interests. Attendance statistics
verify students’ use.
The library media center is a critical element in the
school’s reading program. The library media
program meets the needs of both the
reading/language arts curriculum and recreational
reading.
5. Services are provided to students
who have diverse learning abilities,
styles, and needs.
(Information Power; Principle 7,
p. 58)
The library media center
resources reflect diverse
learning abilities, styles, and
needs.
The library media staff selects
resources and informs teachers of these
resources with recommendations to
support students’ diverse learning
abilities and styles.
The Library Media Specialist and teachers collect
and use student data to design activities that will
lead to student achievement. The library media
program supports instructional strategies and
learning activities that meet individual needs.
6. Student achievement is routinely
assessed.
(A Planning Guide for Information
Power; p. 36)
The classroom teacher is
responsible for assessing
student achievement.
Together the teacher and Library
Media Specialist develop a rubric(s) or
another effective means for assessing
The teacher and Library Media Specialist use a
variety of collaboratively designed tools for
assessing student achievement, e.g., rubrics,
student self-evaluations, and student
presentations to peers and/or adult professionals
in a field of study.

GLMA & GLA
All Rights Reserved
Target Indicators
Category 2 – Technology Basic Proficient Exemplary
7. Technology Management
Provide and manage access to
digital collections, technology tools
& technology resources that support
and enhance instruction and reflect
the needs and interests of diverse P-
12 students, school and community.
(ALA/ AASL Standards for Initial
Preparation of School Librarians,
2010, Standard 5.5.3)
The library provides an
inadequate technology
infrastructure to support teaching
and learning.
The library does not have a plan
in place for the updating and
replacing of hardware.
The library does not have a
virtual presence of any kind.
The school library media
specialist rarely promotes 24-7
access to electronic resources.
Many teachers are not aware of
electronic databases available for
research and support of the CCSS
literacy focus.
The library provides an adequate
technology infrastructure to support
teaching and learning.
The library may have a plan in place
for the updating and replacing
hardware, however it is not
implemented on a regular basis.
The library has a virtual environment
which provides basic information
concerning library programs and
additional resources.
The school library media specialist
sometimes promotes 24-7 access to
electronic resources.
Not all subject area teachers may be
aware that there are electronic
databases available for research and to
support the CCSS literacy focus.
The library provides a strong technology
infrastructure to support teaching and learning.
The library has an active plan in place for the
updating and replacing hardware (e.g. computers).
The library has an active and engaging virtual
environment which highlights student work,
advocates for the library program and provides 24-
7 access to additional resources (e.g. website,
school library blog)
The school library media specialist consistently
promotes and informs to ensure 24-7 access to
electronic resources.
All subject area teachers are aware that there are
electronic databases available for research and to
support the CCSS literacy focus.

GLMA & GLA
All Rights Reserved
8. Technology Integration
integrates the use of emerging
technologies as a means for
effective and creative teaching and
to support P-12 students' conceptual
understanding, critical thinking and
creative processes.
(ALA/ AASL Standards for Initial
Preparation of School Librarians,
2010, Standard 1.1.4)
The school library media
specialist uses technology to
deliver curriculum content or
instructions to students.
The SLMS occasionally attempts
to integrate emerging technologies
into instruction to reinforce the
skills, dispositions,
responsibilities, and self-
assessments in AASL Standards
for the 21st
-Century Learner and
Georgia state standards that
support student achievement.
The SLMS rarely recommends
technology tools to enhance
instruction.
directs teachers and students in the
conventional use of technology tools.
He/she encourages adaptation of
technology by allowing students to
select a tool and modify its use to
accomplish the task at hand.
The SLMS integrates emerging
technologies into instruction that
reinforce the skills, dispositions,
responsibilities, and self-assessments in
AASL Standards for the 21st-Century
Learner and state standards that support
The SLMS often recommends
technology tools to enhance instruction.
The school library media specialist cultivates a rich
learning environment where the blending choice of
technology tools with student-initiated
investigations or projects across any content area is
promoted.
The SLMS integrates emerging technologies into a
variety of instructional strategies to support the
diverse learning styles, interests, and ability of all
students to inquire, think critically, and gain and
create knowledge.
Integration of these technologies also reinforces the
skills and self-assessments in AASL Standards for
the 21st
-Century Learner and Georgia state
standards that support student achievement.
The SLMS consistently recommends technology
tools to enhance instruction and is a building leader
modeling technology integration.

GLMA & GLA
All Rights Reserved
Target Indicators
Category 3 - Staffing Basic Proficient Exemplary
9a. If less than base size:
A school system shall provide no less
than half-time services of a Library
Media Specialist for each school less
than base size and shall provide adult
supervision in the library media center
for the entire instructional day.
Base Size definition defined by
unweighted FTE:
Grades K-5: 450
Grades 6-8: 624
Grades 9-12: 970
In compliance with state board
rule.
A full-time Library Media Specialist is
employed and is not shared at any other
time with other areas in the school nor
does he/she provide services outside
the library media center. Adult
supervision by certified personnel is
available for the entire day.
Full-time Library Media Specialist is employed
and is not shared at any other time with other areas
in the school nor does he/she provide services
outside the library media center. Adult
supervision by certified personnel is available for
the entire day.
9b. If base size or larger:
A school system shall employ a full-
time Library Media Specialist for each
base size school or larger.
(Base size defined by unweighted
FTE: K-5, 450; 6-8, 624; 9-12, 970)
(CGB, 160-5-1-.22)
In compliance with state board
rule, but the Library Media
Specialist may be required to
perform other duties on a daily
or frequent basis.
Library Media Specialist is not required
to perform other duties on a daily or
frequent basis. A part-time library
media paraprofessional is employed.
The following criteria that exceed state rules are
in place: Additional support personnel are
employed in areas of the library media program.
Library media staff is always available
throughout the instructional day to assist teachers
and students. Support staff is not shared in other
areas of the school. A full-time paraprofessional
person (clerk) is on staff in the library media
center.

GLMA & GLA
All Rights Reserved
Target Indicators
Category 4- Facilities, Access,
and Resources
10. There shall be a plan for flexibly
scheduled library media center access
for students and teachers in groups or
as individuals simultaneously
throughout each instructional day.
Accessibility shall refer to the facility,
the staff, and the resources and shall
be based on instructional need.
(IFBD 160-4-4-.01)
Flexible scheduling makes
resources and assistance
available at the time of learning
need, but school schedules may
override this preferable
flexibility. Library media staff
is available to teachers and
students for most of the school
day.
Flexible scheduling and library media
staff are available throughout the day to
assist teachers and students regardless
of ability or disability. The library
media center is available either before
or after school.
Flexible scheduling is maintained allowing full
participation of teachers and the Library Media
Specialist in collaborative planning and allowing
students to come to the library media center at any
time. The library media center is available both
before and after school. Some evening hours may
be scheduled for instructional needs of students
and families.
11. School library media center
square footage requirements based on
FTE.
(Square Footage Requirements for
Use in Developing the Local Facilities
Plans)
http://tinyurl.com/Ga-Media-
Center-square-footage (Page 6)
Based on FTE, the library
media center meets minimum
square footage requirements.
Based on FTE, the library media center
exceeds minimum square footage
requirements and is large enough to
accommodate large and small groups
and individuals working
simultaneously. Shelving, storage
areas, and electric wiring meet the
needs of the collection.
Based on FTE, the library media center exceeds
minimum square footage requirements and is large
enough to accommodate large and small groups
and individuals working simultaneously. Shelving,
storage areas, and electric wiring meet the needs of
the collection. In addition, production and
presentation space is available. Students with
special needs are easily accommodated in the
Library Media Center.
12. Streaming video is used
throughout the school to support the
curriculum. Interactive whiteboards
and computers are used for teaching
and learning throughout the school.
A central electronic media distribution
system is also available.
(Square Footage Requirements for
Use in Developing the Local Facilities
Plans)
Streaming video is used on a
regular basis to support the
curriculum.
The school has several white
boards located throughout the
building and used on a frequent
basis.
Electronic distribution system
meets state requirements.
Streaming video is used on a regular
basis to support the curriculum.
The school has several white boards
located throughout the building and
used on a frequent basis.
Electronic distribution system meets
state requirements.
Streaming video and other technologies are used
on a regular basis to support the curriculum. The
Library Media Center has a whiteboard and it is
used on a regular basis.
The school has several white boards located
throughout the building and used on a frequent
basis.
Electronic distribution system meets state
requirements.

GLMA & GLA
All Rights Reserved
13. Print and non-print resources and
access to online information are basic
to a library media program. A school
network is effective for delivering
media resources to the classroom and
beyond. Multiple computers are
available for student access to online
resources that enhance instruction.
(FY02 Computers in the Classroom
Technology Project - A Georgia
Lottery Grant)
Print and non-print library
media center resources are
adequate to support the core
curriculum. Two or three
computers for student access to
online resources are available in
the library media center.
Print and non-print resources, including
subscription databases and other library
media center resources are available
online to multiple networked computers
within the library media center only. A
LAN (Local Area Network) is fully
functional. Network services are
delivered to all classrooms.
Print and non-print resources, including
subscription databases, access to the Internet, and
other library media center resources are available
on a LAN throughout the school. Some library
media center resources are accessible via Internet
access outside the school. Students use library
media center technology independently for
extended projects and information retrieval.
14. All library media resources are
managed for maximum efficient use.
The library media center has an
electronic online public access catalog
(OPAC). Funds for acquisition of
computers are utilized to implement
the goals/objectives set forth in the
State Technology Plan 2007-2012 or
in the System Comprehensive School
Improvement Plan.
(FY02 Computers in the Classroom
Technology Project - A Georgia
Lottery Grant)
Management and circulation
workstations and at least one
online catalog access (OPAC)
exist in the library media center.
MARC format is used.
The OPAC is electronically networked
to several computers within the library
media center. New acquisitions are
added based on reliable review sources,
state and national award books, and
curriculum needs. Weeding is an
ongoing process. A network
distribution of resources beyond the
library media center is not available.
The OPAC is available on a LAN throughout the
school. All resources are recorded in MARC
format so that access is available on the LAN and
weeding of out-of-date materials can be timely.
The OPAC is up-to-date and reflects the library
media center holdings. Some library media center
resources are accessible via Internet access outside
the school.

GLMA & GLA
All Rights Reserved
15. One of the national educational
technology goals states: “Effective
and engaging software and on-line
resources will be an integral part of
every school’s curriculum.” The
GALILEO Virtual Library provides
Georgia students and teachers access
to exceptional on-line resources at no
cost to the local school district. .
Students will be given
instruction in accessing
GALILEO. The password will
be provided in a timely manner.
Instruction and promotion of
GALILEO will be in an organized
manner and conducted on a frequent
basis. Students, faculty, and staff will
be given instruction and professional
development in the use of GALILEO.
Instruction and promotion of GALILEO will be in
an organized manner and conducted on a frequent
basis. . Searches will be administered and taught in
such a way that maximize efficiency and result in a
high quality product Best Practices and Learning
Models that encourage and endorse GALILEO will
be produced, taught, and shared with other Library
Media Specialists throughout the state. The
Library Media Specialist conducts Staff
Development classes with the faculty and staff.
The faculty and staff will take advantage of the
online courses and lessons available through
GALILEO.

GLMA & GLA
All Rights Reserved
Target Indicators
Category 5 - Administrative
Support
16. The local system superintendent
shall appoint a system media contact
person (SMCP) to serve as a liaison to
the department.
(IFBD, 160-4-4.-.01 )
A system media contact person
(SMCP) is appointed and
communication from the SMCP
is received and posted for all
Library Media Specialists and
staff. The media coordinator or
curriculum coordinator may
serve as the SMCP to facilitate
communication to and from
DOE.
A system media contact person
(SMCP) is appointed and
communication from the SMCP is
received and posted for all Library
Media Specialists and staff. The SMCP
coordinates communication among all
Library Media Specialists in the district,
and disseminates messages from
GaDOE, GALILEO, and other entities.
The SMCP maintains communication among
Library Media Specialists in the district. District
level administrators facilitate the communication
among the SMCP, Library Media Specialists, and
themselves. The SMCP understands the role of the
Library Media Specialist and encourages
opportunities for Library Media Specialists to meet
regularly. The district encourages links on school
and district websites for library media center
announcements and services.
17. Administrative staff support at
both the school and district levels is
essential for the development of a
strong library media program.
(Information Power; Principle 4, p.
100)
The school principal provides
support to the library media
program and makes time to
meet with the Library Media
Specialist occasionally.
The school principal and district
administrators take an active role in
encouraging teachers to integrate
library media resources into the
curriculum. School, department, and
district level administrators meet
regularly with the Library Media
Specialist.
The school principal and district administrators
take a leadership role in encouraging teachers to
integrate library media resources into the
curriculum, fostering a climate of collaboration and
inquiry, encouraging the Library Media Specialist
to be knowledgeable about current educational
trends, promoting occasional visits to exemplary
programs, and providing budgetary support.
18. Each local board of education
shall adopt a library media policy that
provides for the establishment of a
media committee at the system level
and at each school. A library media
committee makes recommendations
and decisions relating to planning,
operation, evaluation, and
improvement of the library media
program. This committee shall
annually evaluate library media
services and develop a multi-year
media plan for budget services and
priorities.
(IFBD, 160-4-4.-.01)
System and local school library
media committees support
implementation of the library
media program. A media
advisory committee exists and
meets once or twice a year.
(This committee may be the
same as the technology
committee in some local
schools.)
A library media advisory committee
exists and meets a minimum of twice a
year. Planning and evaluation of the
library media program is executed
regularly. (This committee may be the
same as the technology committee in
some schools.)
A library media advisory committee is effective in
the development of library media policy, e.g.,
budget development, acquisition of resources, and
reconsideration of materials. This policy, which
may be the media/technology plan in some schools,
is the basis of operation for actions of the advisory
committee, the library media staff, and
administration. It is evaluated, reviewed, and
updated annually.

GLMA & GLA
All Rights Reserved
19. Local Board approved library
media policy is current. This policy
requires development of procedures
for the school system and for selecting
materials locally, handling requests
for reconsideration of materials,
considering gifts of instructional
resources, using non-school owned
materials, and complying with the
copyright law.
(IFBD, 160-4-4.-.01)
A written library media policy
exists and is implemented and
updated inconsistently.
A library media policy exists is
implemented consistently. The Library
Media Specialist recommends periodic
revisions.
A library media policy sets out clear and
comprehensive policies and is reviewed annually
with guidance from the library media advisory
committee for update consideration and subsequent
local board approval. It is used by the library
media staff as a guiding document for the operation
of the library media center.
20. Each local school system shall
spend 100 percent of the funds
designated for library media center
costs.(O.C.G.A. 20-2-167)
The library media program
receives an allocation for
expenditures every year. This
amount meets the minimum
expenditure tests.
The library media program budget
exceeds the minimum state allocation.
Local funding supplements state
allocation.
The Library Media Specialist, with guidance from
the library media advisory committee, is a partner
with school and district administrators in planning
the media budget. Long-range strategic planning
and supplemental funding plans are made
cooperatively, and can include bond issues, grants,
school fundraising, and business partnerships to
supplement the budget.

GLMA & GLA
All Rights Reserved
Target Indicators
Category 6 - Staff
Development
21. Staff development opportunities
are available both for the library
media staff to enhance their own
professional knowledge and for the
library media staff to provide
information and technology literacy
skills to other teachers and
administrative staff. Professional
resources and services for all faculty
members are provided in the library
media center for the "learning
community".
(Information Power; Principle 8, p.
100)
Library Media Specialist
participates in staff
development options and
provides informal staff
development instruction during
collaborative planning with
teachers. Current professional
resources are maintained in the
library media center if the
district does not provide a
centralized professional
resource center.
Library Media Specialist seeks to
enhance his/her professional skills,
particularly technology skills, beyond
those required for recertification or by
the school district. Library Media
Specialist provides occasional formal
staff development instruction and
informal instruction during
collaborative planning with teachers.
The school system makes staff
development options available for
library media support staff. The
Library Media Specialist is
knowledgeable of the district
professional development services.
Library Media Specialist continually seeks to
enhance his/her professional, particularly
technology, skills. The Library Media Specialist,
when funding permits, also participates annually in
state or national conferences. The Library Media
Specialist is included in planning the staff
development program for the school staff and
assists in teaching and organizing sessions. The
Library Media Specialist is recognized as a master
teacher and provides staff development options
beyond routine planning, e.g., providing a formal
needs assessment to determine staff development
needs of the faculty and designing formal courses to
address those needs. The Library Media Specialist
draws on professional resources both at the local
and district levels and online to provide individual
assistance to teachers using technology and
designing curriculum. The Library Media
Specialist may also assist the teacher in his/her
graduate research and secure professional resources
for them through interlibrary loan.

GLMA & GLA
All Rights Reserved
List of citations used in this rubric:
Information Power: Building Partnerships for Learning.
http://www.ala.org/Content/NavigationMenu/AASL/Professional_Tools10/Information_Power/Information_Power.htm
American Association of School Librarians [and] Association for Educational Communications and Technology, Chicago:
American Library Association, 1998. ISBN 0-8389-3470-6
Official Code of Georgia: O.C.G.A. 20-2-167, 12/03/01 and O.C.G.A 20-2-184, http://www.legis.state.ga.us/cgi-
bin/gl_codes_detail.pl?code=20-2-167 http://www.legis.state.ga.us/cgi-bin/gl_codes_detail.pl?code=20-2-184
A Planning Guide for Information Power. .American Association of School Librarians a division of the American Library Association,
Chicago, 1999, ISBN # 0-8389-8073-2
AASL Standards for 21st
Century Learners. American Association of School Librarians: a division of the American Library
Association. Chicago, 2007. http://www.ala.org/aasl/standards.
ALA/ AASL Standards for Initial Preparation of School Librarians (2010). American Library Association/ American Association of
School Librarians. Chicago, 2010.
http://www.ala.org/aasl/sites/ala.org.aasl/files/content/aasleducation/schoollibrary/2010_standards_with_rubrics_and_statements_1
-31-11.pdf
State Board Rule: IDA (1), 160-4-2-.01The Quality Core Curriculum and Student Competencies
http://www.doe.k12.ga.us/_documents/doe/legalservices/160-4-2-.01.pdf
State Board Rule: IFBD, 160-4-4.-.01 Media Programs
State Board Rule: CGB, 160-5-1-.22 Personnel Required
State Lottery Guidelines: FY02 Computers in the Classroom Technology Project - A Georgia Lottery Grant
http://techservices.doe.k12.ga.us/edtech/edtechcomputerclass.htm
State Facilities Guidelines: Square Footage Requirements for Use in Developing the Local Facilities Plans;
http://www.doe.k12.ga.us/_documents/schools/facilities/squareft.pdf

Program Evaluation Rubric

More Related Content

What's hot (20)

Similar to Program Evaluation Rubric (20)

More from Rebecca West (6)

Recently uploaded (20)

Program Evaluation Rubric