Running head: FORMULATING A DATA PRESENTATION
BRIEF 1
FORMULATING A DATA PRESENTATION BRIEF
3
Formulating a Data Presentation Brief
Student Name
Institution
Course
Date
A brief is a way of communicating to clients and stakeholders
about the objectives of a business and what the business aims to
achieve at the end. Formulating a brief provides information to
clients and partners and thus it is important to provide the right
information in a proper manner for the best results (Brigham,
2016). An effective data presentation brief utilizes the
relationship between the presenter and the clients and ensures
that it puts data in a clear and concise manner which is able to
draw the attention of the audience and make them comprehend
the data (Kirk, 2016). Data presentations may contain large
volumes of variable data and using the right method to
formulate a brief determines the ease with which the audience is
able to understand, visualize the data and create interest in the
project.
One of the methods of formulating an effective data
presentation brief is through the use of charts. Charts provide
an interesting way of presenting data to an audience. Charts
have an advantage when presenting a data brief in that they
enable presenters to display data in ways that are appealing to
the audience (Kirk, 2016). This is because different charts like
bar graphs can use different colors that are appealing which
help to capture the attention of the audience (Kirk, 2016). In
addition, bar graphs are easy to read, interpret and understand at
a glance. One of the disadvantage of using charts as a method of
presenting data briefs is that focusing on the visual aspects of
charts as a way to make them attractive to the audience may end
up camouflaging the data being presented which can make the
audience to miss the objectives (Brigham, 2016). In addition,
presenting complex data on charts may be boring to the
audience. Another limitation with the use of charts such as pie
charts is that they are limited to the number of variables that
they can display and therefore, if the data contains numerous
variables, they become inappropriate.
Using a Tedtalk can help in presenting data statistics to an
audience. This is normally accompanied by some data slides.
This method gives the presenter a golden opportunity to be more
convincing to the audience through their display of confidence
(Brigham, 2016). The presentation can win over the audience
depending on the credibility of the speaker. This method might
be a disadvantage if the presenter has poor communication
skills and lack of confidence. Talking might also get the
audience bored and make them fail to visualize the data.
The method of formulating a data brief presentation is very
critical to the success of a presentation in terms of the ease in
which the audience is able to visualize and comprehend the data
and therefore presenters to select a method whose benefits
outweigh the disadvantages in order to communicate effectively
to the audiences.
References
Brigham, T. J. (2016). Feast for the eyes: an introduction to
data visualization. Medical reference services quarterly, 35(2),
215-223.
Kirk, A. (2016). Data Visualisation: A Handbook for Data
Driven Design. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, Ltd.
Running head: CAPSTONE COMPONENT PART 4 2
CAPSTONE COMPONENT PART 4 2
Capstone Component Part 4
Karen Crump
National Louis University
Course: HED 632, Student Development Theory
Instructor: Dustin Heuerman, Ed.D.
University of Nevada Las Vegas and Development of Social
Identity and Gender Identity
Gender identity is the self-recognition of an individual's own
gender about their traits. As early as three years of age, children
start developing individual behavior that is linked to a specific
gender, either female or male. In the early stages of childhood,
gender identity is evaluated based on the interests that the
children develop. Typically, male children are attracted to
masculine objects and activities as toy cars and toy guns.
On the other hand, small girls tend to be attracted to soft toys
such as dolls and colorful items. Social identity refers to who
particular regard themselves to be based on the social groups
they often engage with, or they were born to. The development
of social status is mainly dependent on the characteristics of the
group that an individual identifies themselves with, (Wood &
Eagly, 2018). A person's behavior is mostly influenced by their
decision to conform to certain social groups. At older ages,
gender identity can be expressed through hobbies and interests
in individual careers while social status can be expressed
mainly through dress code.
The University of Nevada, Las Vegas, a public research
university, introduced a program to address gender, race, and
identity. The program offers the opportunity for scholars and
learners to explore and study extensively about social status as
well as gender identity. Setting up an entirely autonomous
department for the program has promoted successful research
into the issues that revolve around gender identity and social
identity. The University also offers a range of courses in the
field of gender, race, and identity and has continuously
produced intellectuals in this specific field, (Coates, 2015). The
LGBTQ community has fully been recognized by the institution
since 2015. Members of the LGBTQ community often get
counseling services from the institution's counseling
department. Despite the University's commitment to promoting
free gender expression, the institution has often failed to
safeguard the freedom of expression for the LGBTQ community.
Several cases have been reported where members of the LGBTQ
community have been harassed or stigmatized within the
institution. There lack clear guidelines and policy that dictates
the action to be taken against perpetrators of gender harassment
within the University (Harry & Watson, 2017).
However, it is imperative to note that the University of Nevada
has remained firmly committed to the development of gender
and social identity. Funding of research and support of gender-
related programs by the University has played a significant role
in promoting and spreading awareness on identity-related issues
both within and outside the University.
Oral Roberts University and Development of Faith, Disability
Identity & Social Class
Faith can be defined as complete trust and belief in a particular
doctrine and the willingness to uphold the required standards
associated with a specific religion of choice. The development
of faith has well been noted to start right from the upbringing of
children (Parks, 2018). Raising a child to believe in a sure
religion often has a lasting impact on their lifetime beliefs and
actually influences every decision they shall make in life. As
humans, we often fail to question what has been fed to us by
people whom we fully trust. It is therefore unlikely that a
person who was raised in a family solidly founded in
Christianity will at any time dispute or question Christianity.
Social class refers to the various classifications that people are
grouped into based on certain notable aspects of their lives such
as marriage, wealth, royalty, and dynasties or even the people
they often engage with. Disability identity can be defined as the
personal sense of attachment and belonging that an individual
develops towards a particular form of disability or
incapacitation. With disability identity, individuals tend to
actively support and have positivity while associating with
persons with disability.
At Oral Roberts University, religion is a significant aspect that
guides every activity within the institution. Oral Roberts is a
private community-based evangelical university whose core
values are grounded in the Christian faith (Synan, 2018). The
institution was founded, not only to educate academic wise but
also to serve as a religious institution of higher learning to
Christian scholars. The mission statement of the University is
emphatic on the life skills that are necessary to Christian
scholars. The sole mission remains to be the creation of world
leaders who are well grounded in the holy spirit of Christianity
and who will positively impact the world.
One thing that the University does best is to teach positive
values to all the learner at the institution. Christian values
taught at the University are very much relevant in Christian
society. Also, the University offers full support to
underprivileged Christians who wish to further their education
but lack financial aid. The University provides scholarships for
students from all over the world for them to pursue their desired
career goals. However, the institution does not fully extend its
support to non-Christian individuals who seek opportunities at
the University. Setting a strict policy that requires all students
enrolled at the University to be Christians is not quite a good
practice in the current world. We live in a free society where
freedom of expression and freedom of worship is guaranteed
(Zdor et al., 2018). Therefore, the University should come up
with revised guidelines that are not discriminative against non-
Christians.
References:
Coates, J., (2015). Women, men, and language: A
sociolinguistic account of gender differences in style.
Routledge.
Harry, K., & Watson, J. (2017). Shaping Identity in Prehispanic
Southern Nevada.
Parks, S. D., (2018). Faith Development. The Oxford Handbook
of Religion and American Education, 103.
Synan, V. H., (2018). The Pentecostal Roots of Oral Roberts'
Healing Ministry. Spiritus: ORU Journal of Theology, 3(2), 12.
Wood, W., & Eagly, A. H. (2015). Two traditions of research on
gender identity. Sex Roles, 73(11-12), 461-473.
Zdor, R., Henson, S. M., Murray, M., Navia, B., Wells, R., &
Goodwin, T. (2018). Fostering Student Faith Development and
Integration across the Curriculum: The Andrews University
Biology Department Experience.
Running head: CAPSTONE PART 3
1
CAPSTONE PART 3
5
Faith and Spirituality
Karen Crump
National Louis University
Dr. Dustin Heuerman
HED 632
Faith and Spirituality
Parents put into helping their children understand the concepts
that could turn out to be confusing and complicated for their
understanding. An excellent example of such situations involves
the processing of agreement and difference between Faith,
religion, and spirituality. When kids fail to understand these
concepts, they become frustrated, opening them up to the
possibility of rubbishing their essence in life. Parents guide
their children and the young ones under their care to understand
Faith, religion, and spirituality because these elements inspire
the development of a purposeful and happy life (Flannelly,
Weaver & Costa, 2014). Several theories have been advanced to
aid the understanding of the development of Faith and
spirituality. The proponents of the methods utilized different
approaches to explain the evolution of Faith and spirituality.
The proponents include Bruce Powers, John Westerhoff, James
Fowler, Larry Stephens, Gordon Allport, and others (Newman,
2004). Therefore, this essay utilizes Fowler’s faith development
theory to advance the discussion on the drafting of a working
theory of student development towards professional experience
inspired by Faith, spirituality, and religion.
James Fowler’s faith development theory is a cognitive
developmental model that aids the understanding of the
processes of spiritual development without the influence of the
traditions of an individual (Hvidt et al., 2017). The holistic
orientation of the theory examines how one is related to the
universe across the life span. It has seven stages. The
advancement of my faith development stages and method
borrows from different theories and emulates Fowler's
approach. For instance, I will use scenes that describe the
cognitive processes involved in the advancement of Faith and
perceptions of individuals. The theory borrows from my
experience and how it shaped my ideologies of Faith.
1st stage: Initial Faith
The stage describes our first encounter with Faith and how we
process the idea of God and prayer. It serves an essential role in
laying the spiritual foundation (Johnstone et al., 2015). In this
stage, the individual lacks control over the information relayed
but may experience the inception of the crisis internally.
2nd stage: Conditioning of God’s Love
This stage aims to acclimatize the individuals towards
internalizing God’s unconditional love. For instance, the parents
separate themselves from the child and give them space to
create their perception of God (Kadar et al., 2015). It is a stage
that follows the previous step, which focused on aligning
individuals towards spirituality. It elicits similarity with
Erikson’s stages of development where autonomy goes head to
head with shame. Children will not find it comfortable to
remain at home when all the members of the family go to
church. It also functions as the intuitive-projective Faith that
uses gestures and narratives to inspire the imaginations of an
individual. It gives rise to the moral emotions that make an
individual aware of the taboos, thereby striking a balance
between the representation of God and the aspects of life
considered to be ungodly.
3rd stage: Literal and conventional Faith
The third stage pools together individuals in the elementary
school years to middle adolescence, where an individual move
from self-condemnation to the destruction of the Distorted
Image of God (Souza et al., 2015). At this stage, one is bound to
make mistakes and seek forgiveness from God to avoid the
wrath of the parents. Children at this stage begin to apply the
truths about God because they are aware of sins and their
wages. As time passes, they develop a healthy image of God as
their Faith strengthens and instructs them towards obeying the
commandments of God and staying away from sin. The lessons
about spiritual concepts begin to cement, and they enter to view
God as a patient, loving, forgiving, and accepting Father. The
driving force at this stage is a belief that allows them to Accept
Jesus as the Messiah.
4th Stage: Faith of Identity and Intimacy
Between the age of 12 to 35, people gain salvation or baptism
that allows them to accept themselves as temples of God. At
this stage, the relationships with God become that of close
dependence as people seek the control of the Holy Spirit in their
conscience. Teenagers search for their identity while those in
their late thirties begin to regret the things they have done in
life. They start to drift towards God.
5th Stage: Spiritual Ministry and Universalizing Faith
At the late stage of life, people begin to seek the Kingdom of
God because they want to make amends for their sins to have a
peaceful transition into the next life called eternity (McKay &
Wood, 2019). Some venture into sharing the word of God while
others take the spiritual and Faith matters seriously by doing
missions, leading Bible studies, and doing charity.
The bottom line of faith and spirituality theory is to aid the
development of an explanation that allows individuals to
understand how their Faith is shaped by the circumstances they
face in their environment when growing up. When people find it
challenging to align with the common understanding in the early
stages of life, at one point in life, they come back to seek to
belong in one of the most appealing religions that suit their
Faith and spirituality.
References
Flannelly, K. J., Weaver, A. J., & Costa, K. G. (2014). A
systematic review of religion and spirituality in three palliative
care journals, 1990–1999. Journal of Palliative Care, 20(1), 50-
56.
Hvidt, N. C., Hvidtjørn, D., Christensen, K., Nielsen, J. B., &
Søndergaard, J. (2017). Faith moves mountains—mountains
move Faith: two opposite epidemiological forces in research on
religion and health. Journal of religion and health, 56(1), 294-
304.
Johnstone, B., Yoon, D. P., Cohen, D., Schopp, L. H.,
McCormack, G., Campbell, J., & Smith, M. (2015).
Relationships among spirituality, religious practices,
personality factors, and health for five different faith
traditions. Journal of religion and health, 51(4), 1017-1041.
Kadar, J. L., Scott, A. B., Hipp, K., Belavich, T. G., Butter, E.
M., Rye, M. S., ... & Zinnbauer, B. J. (2015). Religion and
spirituality: Unfuzzying the fuzzy. In Sociology of
Religion (pp. 29-34). Routledge.
McKay, M., & Wood, J. C., (2019). The New Happiness:
Practices for Spiritual Growth and Living with Intention. New
Harbinger Publications.
Newman, L. L., (2004). Faith, Spirituality, and Religion: A
Model for Understanding the Differences. College Student
Affairs Journal, 23(2), 102-110.
Souza, V. D. M., Frizzo, H. C. F., Paiva, M. H. P. D., Bousso,
R. S., & Santos, Á. D. S. (2015). Spirituality, religion, and
personal beliefs of adolescents with cancer. Revista Brasileira
de Enfermagem, 68(5), 791-796.
Running head: FAITH AND SPIRITUALITY
1
FAITH AND SPIRITUALITY
2
FAITH AND SPIRITUALITY
HED632 CAPSTONE 2
Karen Crump
National Louis University
Dr. Dustin Heuerman
May 5, 2019
Faith and Spirituality Development Literature Review
For quite some time, the development and application of
religion, Faith, and spirituality have fronted a significant
concern among scholars. In most cases, the three concepts have
been used interchangeably although Faith, spirituality, and
religion are three distinct and different concepts. Notably, Faith
is about knowing Godly ways, religion is about is practicing
Faith while spirituality is about being in Faith. According to
Crowther & Hall (2015), Faith is the foundation of any creed or
spirituality, on the other hand, spirituality and religion
indicators of Faith.
Hvidt et al. (2017), argues that the study of spirituality and
faith development was neglected until the late 1980s. The issue
of Faith and religion traces its history back in 1000, but no
theory or model addressed the issue of their development. The
author further notes that learning the concepts of Faith and
spirituality forms the basis for the study of any religion.
However, in modern days, there has been tremendous progress
in the research of the two concepts. The author recognizes in
need to study the development of Faith and religion since they
form an important theme in understanding the religion and
culture of the people. The period between 1000 and 1300
marked a crucial time in the development and study of Faith and
spirituality. During this time, people began to learn about
scripture and began exercising religion. Though there was the
existence of worship during this time, there was not Faith that
was linked to religion. People merely picked, followed, and
accepted what they were advised to do and Faith was not
essential to them. However, in the early fifteenth century,
scholars began to scrutinize the church especially Roman
Catholic –a move that was aimed at understanding the religion
deeply. This journey was planned by Martin Luther who sought
to comprehend the significance of Faith in religion. In this time,
the concept of Faith began to surface especially among the
Protestants who believed that, "salvation drops by Faith alone,
regardless of acts of kindness or the holy observances” (Souza
et al., 2015).
Making Faith make sense
Faith is an essential aspect of human beings that help them to
create a pattern throughout their lifespan. Considerably, Faith
shapes the rational way of “making sense of, and committing to,
transcendent values and realities; to ultimate concerns” (Hvidt
et al., 2017). Faith development can be understood through a
cognitive developmental model known as faith development
theory (FDT). This approach allows people and scholars to
assess the process of spiritual development free from any
influence from faith traditions. Faith development can be
understood through multiple stages:
Intuitive-Projective Faith
Mythical-literal Faith
Synthetic-conventional Faith
Individuated-reflective Faith
Conjunctive Faith
Universalizing Faith
The first stage which is intuitive-projective Faith begins when a
kid starts to learn a new language characterized by the use of
symbols in play and speech. In this stage, young children are
highly influenced by their old people in their lives especially
parents. There is a lot of imitation in this stage kids learn about
God and angels, and the consequences of disobeying the word
of God. In the mythical-literal, children begin to develop the
ability to think logically and connect to the things that happen
in their lives. Children start to learn new stories and beliefs that
shape their Faith and symbolize the sense of belonging to a
particular faith (Souza et al., 2015). In the third stage which is
synthetic-conventional Faith is the stage that takes place in the
adulthood and people begin to follow the value and belief
systems that link them to God. Individuative-reflective Faith
happens in early adulthood whereby people start to evaluating
and examining the actual costs and belief and develop their own
Faith. Conjunctive Faith takes place at the middle age forces
people to build their personal coherence aimed at nurturing and
deepening their relationship to God. The last phase is called
universalizing Faith that happens in old age and is linked to
“universal structures that belong to all faiths” (Souza et al.,
2015).
According to Crowther & Hall (2015), Faith is key to the
development and growth of spirituality. Faith and spirituality
present some outcomes or befits. Spiritual Faith helps people to
forgive each other, and people with spiritual divine believe
forgiveness. Religion allows people to become spiritually holy
leading to victory in life. Religious Faith is a sign of salvation
which helps people to act right and love one another. With
Faith, people can do a lot of good which is in line with the
teachings of God. According to Christians, Faith helps them to
avoid committing any kind of sin –something that brings good
things in their lives. Religion is defined by spirituality and
Faith which help the believer in fighting life battles and
winning them. Though the study of Faith and spirituality has
been limited, recent researches have proved excellent and
promising progress in understanding the development of the two
concepts concerning religion.
References
Crowther, S., & Hall, J. (2015). Spirituality and spiritual care in
and around childbirth. Women and birth, 28(2), 173-178.
Hvidt, N. C., Hvidtjørn, D., Christensen, K., Nielsen, J. B., &
Søndergaard, J. (2017). Faith moves mountains—mountains
move Faith: two opposite epidemiological forces in research on
religion and health. Journal of religion and health, 56(1), 294-
304.
Souza, V. D. M., Frizzo, H. C. F., Paiva, M. H. P. D., Bousso,
R. S., & Santos, Á. D. S. (2015). Spirituality, religion and
personal beliefs of adolescents with cancer. Revista Brasileira
de Enfermagem, 68(5), 791-796.
Running Head: LITERATURE REVIEW: DEVELOPMENT OF
FAITH AND SPIRITUALITY
1
LITERATURE REVIEW: DEVELOPMENT OF FAITH AND
SPIRITUALITY 6
Literature Review: Development of Faith and Spirituality
Karen Crump
National Louis University
April 28, 2019
Literature Review: Development of Faith and Spirituality
Faith and other spirituality have caused wars, discussions, and
massacres from the beginning of time. Thinking back, clash, for
the most part, starts when gatherings of individuals have
varying otherworldly convictions. While this issue has improved
all through time, as the general acknowledgment of decent
variety has extended, it is as yet a common reason for strife
today. The movement of religion since forever can be intently
inspected by understanding the social atmosphere in some
random period. Starting in 1000 amid the High Middle Ages and
advancing to the Reformation, one can look at the move in
religious other spirituality and faith. While different spirituality
and religion are frequently close to home points, one can look at
the ordinary convictions of a territory. While in the High
Middle Ages one didn't have the privilege to pick their very
own religious way, as time advances, that extravagance turns
out to be increasingly typical.
From 1000-1300, religion was a remarkable piece of day by day
life for individuals of the High Middle Ages. Right now the
"Christian church was the focal point of network life" enabling
natives to assemble around religious assets (McKay & Wood,
2019). Individuals likewise reinforced with their cleric since he
"frequently worked in the fields with the general population,"
putting everybody on a similar dimension. Mass was a
remarkable piece of every week except right now it was
discussed in Latin although most of the residents did not know
the language. This incredibly added to individuals' association
with religion since they for the most part gone to Mass as a
constant everyday practice and not for any close to the home
feeling of other spirituality. Because of the way that they
couldn't comprehend the Mass implied that their own different
spirituality was not reliable. Additionally, individuals mainly
learned scriptural stories through "the depictions on the
congregation dividers" rather than their very personal profound
encounters (McKay & Wood, 2019). In this manner, while day
by day life rotated around religious exercises and occasions,
individuals did not have an individual association with their
faith. Religion had an influence in their day by day life since
they had no real option except to go to Christian based
occasions, yet the quality of their own faith was very feeble.
This way, individuals were not picking which faith was
essential to them; they were simply following the group and
accepting what they were advised to take. This attitude of
religion was regular in this timeframe, and the independence of
religion did not happen until nearer to the fifteenth century,
amid the Reconstruction.
Individuals in the mid-sixteenth century were extraordinarily
devout yet additionally started to scrutinize the Roman Catholic
Church. Quite a bit of this originated from anticlericalism, or
"resistance to the pastorate" (McKay & Wood, 2019).
Individuals were angry because ministry individuals were
improper, insensible and holding numerous positions. These
reactions of the ministry enabled Martin Luther's plans to
spread quickly. Martin Luther's investigations enabled him to
comprehend the significance of faith. Protestant idea trusted
that "salvation drops by faith alone, regardless of acts of
kindness or the holy observances." This genuinely tangled with
customary Catholic conviction of the seven holy observances.
For Luther, "daily religious practice, visit admissions, and
fasting gave him minimal otherworldly harmony (Stephenson &
Berry, 2015). He kept saying that faith is a blessing and not
given to the individuals who implore, quickly or go to
administrations more. This realized the single side to religion,
accentuating the person's association with God, and not
religious conventions.
Furthermore, Luther disdained the clearance of guilty pleasures
since he accepted there was no real way to pay for the
pardoning of sins. This conviction formally started the
Reformation with the posting of his 95 Theses. His proposals
were initially imprinted in Latin; however then meant German,
enabling most of the individuals to peruse and get them
(Zinnbauer & Pargament, 2015). The way that they were
imprinted in the vernacular made Luther's conviction across the
board as he picked up an incredible gathering of devotees;
something that would have been unimaginable in earlier
hundreds of years. With this came a massive change in how
individuals saw religion yet additionally caused religious
pressure in numerous nations. Martin Luther caused commotion
on philosophical terms as well as on issues of "riches, influence
and fundamental structure" (Flannelly, Weaver & Costa, 2014).
Protestant idea likewise joined adherents by expressing that a
congregation ought to be an "otherworldly brotherhood of
devotees" (Oman, 2018). This changed the mindset of religious
organizations, making them all the more neighborly and joined
rather than one individual lecturing an expansive gathering of
individuals. Martin Luther's beliefs drastically influenced how
individuals saw religion and what they ought to accept. It
started the individual voyage one has with faith rather than
solid masses of individuals compelled to tune in to similar
messages every week. With the official acknowledgment of
Lutheranism in 1555, nations were permitted to pick among
Catholicism and Lutheranism, a noteworthy advance in the
adventure to autonomous faith and other spirituality.
What I have realized through the investigation of religion in
history is how unimaginably fortunate we are present to face a
daily reality such that we are each permitted to have our own
thoughts of faith and other spirituality. While Luther and
Erasmus were uncommon in their time, these days' individuals
generally can trust whatever they pick. I particularly appreciate
the independence of faith since I don't trust it is satisfactory for
anybody to advise someone else what to put stock in (Johnstone
et al., 2015). Spirituality is something unimaginably close to
home and in this way should be an individual adventure for each
individual. Experiencing childhood in an interfaith family, I
could watch two unique belief systems. I trust this has affected
my perspectives on religion since I comprehend that one's
religious convictions just straightforwardly have an effect on
them self. Watching my folks join both Catholic and Jewish
customs into our family demonstrated to me the outrageous
estimation of assorted variety, something I have always
appreciated. Actually, my faith can be ascribed to my seven
summers spent at the Jewish summer camp where I was
permitted to investigate my religion through workmanship,
music and network petition (Johnstone et al., 2015). These
seven summers reinforced my own faith yet additionally enable
me to acknowledge a decent variety of assorted types. In this
way, I feel fortunate to have the capacity to pick my very own
profound way, dissimilar to those in the High Middle Ages or
amid the Reformation when it was the choice of the lord. While
religion and faith will result in all probability dependably
motivation banter, I figure we can think back on history and
recognize what amount has changed over the most recent 1000
years, and be appreciative for it. Comment by Dustin
Heuerman: For the final paper, write in only third person.
References
Flannelly, K. J., Weaver, A. J., & Costa, K. G. (2014). A
systematic review of religion and spirituality in three palliative
care journals, 1990–1999. Journal of Palliative Care, 20(1), 50-
56.
Johnstone, B., Yoon, D. P., Cohen, D., Schopp, L. H.,
McCormack, G., Campbell, J., & Smith, M. (2015).
Relationships among spirituality, religious practices,
personality factors, and health for five different faith
traditions. Journal of religion and health, 51(4), 1017-1041.
Kadar, J. L., Scott, A. B., Hipp, K., Belavich, T. G., Butter, E.
M., Rye, M. S., ... & Zinnbauer, B. J. (2015). Religion and
spirituality: Unfuzzying the fuzzy. In Sociology of
Religion (pp. 29-34). Routledge.
McKay, M., & Wood, J. C. (2019). The New Happiness:
Practices for Spiritual Growth and Living with Intention. New
Harbinger Publications.
Oman, D. (2018). Defining religion and spirituality. Handbook
of the psychology of religion and spirituality, 2, 23-47.
Stephenson, P. S., & Berry, D. M. (2015). Describing
spirituality at the end of life. Western Journal of Nursing
Research, 37(9), 1229-1247.
Zinnbauer, B. J., & Pargament, K. I. (2015). Religiousness and
spirituality. Handbook of the psychology of religion and
spirituality, 21-42.
Running Head: LITERATURE REVIEW: DEVELOPMENT OF
FAITH AND SPIRITUALITY
1
LITERATURE REVIEW: DEVELOPMENT OF FAITH AND
SPIRITUALITY 6
Literature Review: Development of Faith and Spirituality
Karen Crump
National Louis University
April 28, 2019
Literature Review: Development of Faith and Spirituality
Faith and other spirituality have caused wars, discussions, and
massacres from the beginning of time. Thinking back, clash, for
the most part, starts when gatherings of individuals have
varying otherworldly convictions. While this issue has improved
all through time, as the general acknowledgment of decent
variety has extended, it is as yet a common reason for strife
today. The movement of religion since forever can be intently
inspected by understanding the social atmosphere in some
random period. Starting in 1000 amid the High Middle Ages and
advancing to the Reformation, one can look at the move in
religious other spirituality and faith. While different spirituality
and religion are frequently close to home points, one can look at
the ordinary convictions of a territory. While in the High
Middle Ages one didn't have the privilege to pick their very
own religious way, as time advances, that extravagance turns
out to be increasingly typical.
From 1000-1300, religion was a remarkable piece of day by day
life for individuals of the High Middle Ages. Right now the
"Christian church was the focal point of network life" enabling
natives to assemble around religious assets (McKay & Wood,
2019). Individuals likewise reinforced with their cleric since he
"frequently worked in the fields with the general population,"
putting everybody on a similar dimension. Mass was a
remarkable piece of every week except right now it was
discussed in Latin although most of the residents did not know
the language. This incredibly added to individuals' association
with religion since they for the most part gone to Mass as a
constant everyday practice and not for any close to the home
feeling of other spirituality. Because of the way that they
couldn't comprehend the Mass implied that their own different
spirituality was not reliable. Additionally, individuals mainly
learned scriptural stories through "the depictions on the
congregation dividers" rather than their very personal profound
encounters (McKay & Wood, 2019). In this manner, while day
by day life rotated around religious exercises and occasions,
individuals did not have an individual association with their
faith. Religion had an influence in their day by day life since
they had no real option except to go to Christian based
occasions, yet the quality of their own faith was very feeble.
This way, individuals were not picking which faith was
essential to them; they were simply following the group and
accepting what they were advised to take. This attitude of
religion was regular in this timeframe, and the independence of
religion did not happen until nearer to the fifteenth century,
amid the Reconstruction.
Individuals in the mid-sixteenth century were extraordinarily
devout yet additionally started to scrutinize the Roman Catholic
Church. Quite a bit of this originated from anticlericalism, or
"resistance to the pastorate" (McKay & Wood, 2019).
Individuals were angry because ministry individuals were
improper, insensible and holding numerous positions. These
reactions of the ministry enabled Martin Luther's plans to
spread quickly. Martin Luther's investigations enabled him to
comprehend the significance of faith. Protestant idea trusted
that "salvation drops by faith alone, regardless of acts of
kindness or the holy observances." This genuinely tangled with
customary Catholic conviction of the seven holy observances.
For Luther, "daily religious practice, visit admissions, and
fasting gave him minimal otherworldly harmony (Stephenson &
Berry, 2015). He kept saying that faith is a blessing and not
given to the individuals who implore, quickly or go to
administrations more. This realized the single side to religion,
accentuating the person's association with God, and not
religious conventions.
Furthermore, Luther disdained the clearance of guilty pleasures
since he accepted there was no real way to pay for the
pardoning of sins. This conviction formally started the
Reformation with the posting of his 95 Theses. His proposals
were initially imprinted in Latin; however then meant German,
enabling most of the individuals to peruse and get them
(Zinnbauer & Pargament, 2015). The way that they were
imprinted in the vernacular made Luther's conviction across the
board as he picked up an incredible gathering of devotees;
something that would have been unimaginable in earlier
hundreds of years. With this came a massive change in how
individuals saw religion yet additionally caused religious
pressure in numerous nations. Martin Luther caused commotion
on philosophical terms as well as on issues of "riches, influence
and fundamental structure" (Flannelly, Weaver & Costa, 2014).
Protestant idea likewise joined adherents by expressing that a
congregation ought to be an "otherworldly brotherhood of
devotees" (Oman, 2018). This changed the mindset of religious
organizations, making them all the more neighborly and joined
rather than one individual lecturing an expansive gathering of
individuals. Martin Luther's beliefs drastically influenced how
individuals saw religion and what they ought to accept. It
started the individual voyage one has with faith rather than
solid masses of individuals compelled to tune in to similar
messages every week. With the official acknowledgment of
Lutheranism in 1555, nations were permitted to pick among
Catholicism and Lutheranism, a noteworthy advance in the
adventure to autonomous faith and other spirituality.
What I have realized through the investigation of religion in
history is how unimaginably fortunate we are present to face a
daily reality such that we are each permitted to have our own
thoughts of faith and other spirituality. While Luther and
Erasmus were uncommon in their time, these days' individuals
generally can trust whatever they pick. I particularly appreciate
the independence of faith since I don't trust it is satisfactory for
anybody to advise someone else what to put stock in (Johnstone
et al., 2015). Spirituality is something unimaginably close to
home and in this way should be an individual adventure for each
individual. Experiencing childhood in an interfaith family, I
could watch two unique belief systems. I trust this has affected
my perspectives on religion since I comprehend that one's
religious convictions just straightforwardly have an effect on
them self. Watching my folks join both Catholic and Jewish
customs into our family demonstrated to me the outrageous
estimation of assorted variety, something I have always
appreciated. Actually, my faith can be ascribed to my seven
summers spent at the Jewish summer camp where I was
permitted to investigate my religion through workmanship,
music and network petition (Johnstone et al., 2015). These
seven summers reinforced my own faith yet additionally enable
me to acknowledge a decent variety of assorted types. In this
way, I feel fortunate to have the capacity to pick my very own
profound way, dissimilar to those in the High Middle Ages or
amid the Reformation when it was the choice of the lord. While
religion and faith will result in all probability dependably
motivation banter, I figure we can think back on history and
recognize what amount has changed over the most recent 1000
years, and be appreciative for it.
References
Flannelly, K. J., Weaver, A. J., & Costa, K. G. (2014). A
systematic review of religion and spirituality in three palliative
care journals, 1990–1999. Journal of Palliative Care, 20(1), 50-
56.
Johnstone, B., Yoon, D. P., Cohen, D., Schopp, L. H.,
McCormack, G., Campbell, J., & Smith, M. (2015).
Relationships among spirituality, religious practices,
personality factors, and health for five different faith
traditions. Journal of religion and health, 51(4), 1017-1041.
Kadar, J. L., Scott, A. B., Hipp, K., Belavich, T. G., Butter, E.
M., Rye, M. S., ... & Zinnbauer, B. J. (2015). Religion and
spirituality: Unfuzzying the fuzzy. In Sociology of
Religion (pp. 29-34). Routledge.
McKay, M., & Wood, J. C. (2019). The New Happiness:
Practices for Spiritual Growth and Living with Intention. New
Harbinger Publications.
Oman, D. (2018). Defining religion and spirituality. Handbook
of the psychology of religion and spirituality, 2, 23-47.
Stephenson, P. S., & Berry, D. M. (2015). Describing
spirituality at the end of life. Western Journal of Nursing
Research, 37(9), 1229-1247.
Zinnbauer, B. J., & Pargament, K. I. (2015). Religiousness and
spirituality. Handbook of the psychology of religion and
spirituality, 21-42.
Running head: CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 1
Gender and Sexual Identity Development
[Student Name]
National Louis University
HED 632
Dr. Dustin Heuerman
SAMPLE COURSE CAPSTONE EXAMPLE
This document is not meant to serve as a perfect assignment
submission, but
as a good example of how your paper should look when
submitted.
CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 2
Gender and Sexual Identity Development
Gender and sexual identity development is one area that higher
education leaders must
familiarize themselves with as they strive to create safe and
welcoming environments for a
diverse population of students. As students come to terms with
various aspects of their
development, gender and sexual identity theories provide
insight into the stages that students
navigate as they determine their objectives and abilities (Torres,
Jones & Renn, 2009).
Moreover, identity development can be influenced by how
students interact within their
environments. Therefore, research surrounding gender and
sexual identity development is
important to helping facilitate identity development in other
areas (Konik & Stewart, 2004) and
in assisting higher education leaders with creating optimal
environments for students.
Theoretical Significance
Students may experience feelings and behaviors that cause
internal conflicts or
challenges to healthy identity development. This may be
especially true when religious and
sexual identities converge. Bayne (2016) proposed possible
interventions or techniques that can
help students progress from early stages of minority sexual
identity to later stages of acceptance
and integration. Likewise, other research has revealed the Cass’
Model of Sexual Identity
Development can help us understand how students move from
Stage One of Identity Confusion
to Stage Six of Identity Synthesis whereby individuals come to
integrate their sexual identity into
their overall identity (Degges-White & Myers, 2000). This is
crucial to ensuring higher
education groundbreakers seek to implement programs and
services that are designed to reach
students where they are and to serve the “whole person.”
In addition to studying gender and sexual identity theories,
Gragg (2012) encourages
those working with sexually minority youth to address their own
biases, but not to allow a lack
CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 3
of expertise in gender and sexual identity prevent effective
work with individuals. By examining
and reviewing gender and sexual identity theories, we can
address problems and behaviors that
may occur as students move to normalize their experiences and
confront impending difficulties
(Cramer, 1980). Graham & et al (2011) adds that men who
develop healthy sexual identity are
less likely to experience mental distress while other researchers
note the complexity of gender
and sexual identity development impacts psychological
adjustment and self-esteem (Rosario,
Schrimshaw & Hunter, 2011). More support is given to the link
between psychological
adjustment and self-distress and sexual identity development in
the study conducted by Shepler
& Perrone-McGovern, 2016 of 791 college students. There are
implications to suggest that one’s
sexual identity status or stage of development impacts his or her
psychological well-being.
Furthermore, researchers have shown a link between the
depression and black men who are
isolated in their sexual identity (Graham & et al, 2011). By
studying sexual identity formation,
we can prepare to assist students and begin to explore avenues
that help them develop healthy
sexual identities. This includes implementing programs and
services that promote positive self-
esteem and identity acceptance.
Models of Gender and Sexual Identity Development
There are several models of Gender and Sexual Identity
Development that may help to
inform and influence the understanding of this important
identity formation. Morgan (2012)
sought to classify student’s sexual formation using
Worthington’s heterosexual identity
development to gather student narratives and found recognizing
heterosexual identity to be more
challenging. Historically, sexual identity theories have viewed
the foundation of sexual identity
as moving in a linear formation. Cass’s (1979) six-stage
process of sexual identity integration
has been the model for subsequent theories which describe
sexual identity development as
CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 4
occurring in chronological stages (Degges-White & Myers,
2000). Likewise, Fassinger’s Model
of Gay and Lesbian Identity (1996) describes the identity
process as beginning with Awareness,
moving through Exploration and Deepening/Commitment to the
final stage of
Internalization/Synthesis (Gervacio, 2012). Nevertheless, more
recent research has indicated
sexual identity formation does not necessarily follow a linear or
stable process (Morgan, 2012 &
Rosario, Schrimshaw & Hunter, 2011); rather, individuals
experience various stages at any given
time. It is imperative that student affairs professionals take
from sexual identity theories what is
necessary to create more inclusive environments for students.
Gaps in the Literature
The current literature does not cover all the bases needed to
adequately explain gender
and sexual identity formation. There is a growing sentiment
related to the fluidity of gender and
sexual identity; that it overflows the rigid categories of
heterosexuality, homosexuality and
bisexuality (Carr, 2009). While the notion of fluid sexuality is
nothing new and earlier research
mentions the complexity surrounding gender and sexual
identities (Pryce, 2006), the research is
at its infancy stage. However, current research has proposed
that a gender revolution is
underway. Moreover, gender and sexual identity should not be
viewed synonymously or with the
same meaning. Changing societal norms see gender as falling on
a spectrum and not limited to
binary assignments of male and female (Parrenas, 2017).
Therefore, there is a need for a more in
depth exploration of the fluidity of gender and sexuality as it
relates to the process of one’s
unique identity development in the 21st century.
Multiplicity in Identity Development
Evans (2009) reminds us that the conceptual model of multiple
dimensions of identity
was developed by earlier theorists and that the core of self or
one’s personal identity includes
CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 5
personal attributes and other important factors. Besides, gender,
sexual orientation, race, social
class, family, education and culture are viewed as intersecting
circles surrounding the core
identity. Within gender and sexual identity developments lies a
multitude of intersecting circles
that presents the gap in the research. An increasing number of
young people are embracing the
idea that gender and sexuality transcends the traditional binaries
of male and female, gay or
straight (Steinmetz,2017). This is in stark contrast to the
identity theories that seem to combine
sex and gender and use the terms interchangeably, inferring
these identity formations are one in
the same and occur in a linear and stage-like fashion (Gevacio,
2012).
There is a Gender Revolution
There is a movement pushing forward the need to “update” the
concept of gender and to
acknowledge its deeply social and psychological attributes and
influences (Gender Identity,
2016). This view that gender identity is not automatically
binary, but is fluid and separate from
sexual orientation or biology (Parrenas, 2017 & Gender
Identity, 2016) is obvious with popular
culture. As evident by the 2014 Facebook move to allow users
to select from 56 ways to describe
their gender. Some of these include: agender, cis- and trans-
variants, gender fluid, pangender
and two-spirit (Gender Identity, 2017). In addition, New York
passed a law making it illegal to
discriminate against any of the 31 gender identities and gender
expressions outlined by the New
York Commission on Human Rights (Gender Identity
Expression, 2015).
The gender and sexual identity development are both public and
private entities requiring
deeper understanding for Student Affairs professionals to create
environments of inclusiveness.
There is a need to stay current with the terminology, as the
world is rapidly changing; gender is
no longer contained by the binaries of male and female. The
popular adage is that sex is what is
between your legs and gender is what is between your ears
(Gevisser, 2015). Moreover, sexual
CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 6
orientation is who we have sex with and gender is our deeply
held sense of being male, female or
something else entirely. The broader spectrum of gender and
sexual identity development can
help students and those working with them reduce gender
confusion and identity struggle by
helping to validate feelings and experiences. The genderqueer
movement is growing and some
colleges have students introduce themselves by their preferred
pronouns (he/his, she/her/hers,
they/them) and some identity as pansexual rather than gay or
straight (Gevisser, 2015).
The growing response that gender and sexual fluidity transcends
the rigid categories of
heterosexuality, homosexuality and bisexuality (Parrenas, 2017)
gives rise to the need for more
research. The complexity surrounding sexual and gender
identity indicates that we are in a
gender and sexual identity revolution that may warrant the
development of additional theories to
explore this developmental process (Gevisser, 2015). Changing
societal norms see gender as
falling on a spectrum and not limited to binary assignments of
male and female (Parrenas, 2017).
Rogers’ Theory of Gender and Sexual Identity builds upon
previous theories and supports the
complexity of sexual fluidity in individual development.
Rogers’ Theory of Gender and Sexual Identity
Like Evans’ model, Rogers’ Theory is a series of junctions of
progress whereby
individuals move fluidly as they grow to understand themselves
in relation to their external
environments. Rogers’ identity development is not seen as
always linear or sequential in nature
(Morgan, 2012). There are four stages that are included within
this working theory.
Stage 1-Pre-Socialization of Gender and Sexual Identity
In the Pre-Socialization stage, the individual is unaware or not
influenced by the larger
society or parental expectations of gender or sexual identity
roles. This can show up in children,
who are not aware of sexuality and gender and/or whose parents
do not subscribe to colors,
CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 7
clothes, toys or activities traditionally assigned to male or
female. In addition, adolescents and
adults may be unmoved by social pressures to conform to what
is expected in terms of gender or
sexuality. In this stage, the individual may exhibit fluidity, but
may experience conflict or crisis
when external expectations are imposed upon the individual
(Gender Identity, 2016).
Stage 2- Social Identity Conflict
In this stage of Rogers’ Theory, the individual is aware of and
concerned about
mainstream social expectations of gender and sexual identity.
This causes personal conflict as the
individual’s feelings, thoughts or identity contradict roles. The
individual may be influenced by
parental, peer, employer or society’s expectations and struggle
with finding or expressing their
own voice. In this stage, the individual may hide sexual identity
or conform according to what he
or she deems acceptable. Although, the view may be gender
identity is not automatically binary,
but is fluid (Parrenas, 2017), the individual seeks conformity to
lessen outward conflict with
popular culture.
Stage 3- Sexuality and Gender Acceptance
In Stage 3 of this theory, individuals have developed acceptance
for their own gender or
sexual identity. The individual may have found a healthy and
supportive peer group and parental
encouragement as well as a significant relationship that is
affirming. Individuals in this stage are
less likely to experience conflict between themselves and
society. They are not prone to conform
to gender expectations and are in the evolving pride and
confidence part of the development. The
gender and sexual identity formation are both public and private
entities that are seamlessly
integrated into the person’s overall development.
Stage 4-Pride and Confidence
CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 8
Persons who are operating from this position of their gender and
sexual identity
development are fully aware of who they are and do not waver
in expressing their preferences,
identity or gender. Persons have a strong sense of self and
understand the potential for social
conflict as it pertains to gender roles and sexual identity, but do
not feel the need to conform.
Individuals understand the need and are driven to stay current
with the terminology. At Stage 4,
the individual is aware of the gender movement within the
rapidly changing world. Persons may
view gender as no longer contained by the binaries of male and
female and subscribe to the
notion that “sex is what is between your legs and gender is what
is between your ears (Gevisser,
2015).”
It is important to reiterate that this is a working theory in need
of further development.
Moreover, it is not to viewed as linear or occurring in sequence
for individuals may have various
facets of any stage at periods during their development.
Resources in Higher Education
Helping students develop to their full potential includes
supporting them as they question
and change their sexual identities. Student affairs leaders must
concern themselves with keeping
up with the trends, terminology and theories related sexual
identity formation as they strive to
create environments conducive to healthy and positive student
development
Tennessee State University and DePaul University are examples
of two institutions
offering programs to support gender and sexual development on
college campuses. Tennessee
State University and DePaul University are two distinctly
different institutions of higher
education which provide resources and support for students of
the sexual minority communities.
Tennessee State University (TSU) is a public, land-grant
(1890), HBCU (Historically
Black College & University) located in Nashville, Tennessee
founded in 1912. TSU has an
CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 9
enrollment of over 7,000 undergraduate, 1,900 graduate students
who can choose from 47
Bachelor, 24 Masters and 8 Doctoral degrees (TSU, 2017).
DePaul University is a private, catholic institution located in
Chicago, Illinois. The
university was founded in 1898 and has at the heart of its
mission, research, teaching and
community service. Its enrollment is 15,407 undergraduate,
7,703 graduate and has been named
as one of the nation’s Best Value Colleges by Forbes (DePaul,
2017).
What do they do well?
TSU offers support for the LGBTQ campus community by
providing training, policies,
programs and education through the Office of Equity and
Inclusion. In 2013-2014, the Office of
Equity and Inclusion collaborated with The Human Rights
Campaign to provide an LGBTQ film
screening of, The New Black documentary on the campus (TN
State Newsroom, 2014). The
documentary tells the story of how the African-American
community grappled with the gay
rights and the recent same-sex marriage movement. In addition,
the college celebrates LGBTQ
week in October with a series of activities, Safe Zone Training,
panel discussions and free
HIV/AIDS testing (LGBTQ at TSU, 2014).
The university promotes a supportive environment for students
to build connections and
positive networks that will help them be successful students.
The campus puts forth policy and
communicates that they will not tolerate any harassment, ill
treatment or discrimination of any
student or persons seeking to benefit from the campus
resources. Moreover, the campus
communicates the importance of associations for LGBTQ
students and provides a space on
campus for students to commune and share or express
themselves in a reassuring environment.
Tennessee State University provides a system of helpful allies
for the lesbian, gay,
bisexual, transgender and queer/questioning community. There
is a published list of these
CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 10
campus professionals provided on the website (Safe Zone
Allyship, 2017). These individuals
have completed the half day Safe Zone training and display the
symbol in their work or living
space to denote they are a registered or official Ally. An ally
has been educated about the
concerns and issues of the LGBTQ people and know about the
resources available to support
them (LGBTQ at TSU, 2014).
DePaul University in Chicago, Illinois is the first Catholic
University to establish an
LGBTQ Studies program. Starting in 2005, the minor in LGBTQ
Studies allows students to
analyze sex and sexuality within an interdisciplinary inquiry
and examines the experiences of
people who identify as a part of a sexually minority group
(DePaul, 2017). This private Catholic
university has integrated LGBTQA services and programs into
the overall student experience at
DePaul. The campus has a strong history of providing support
and services to students in the
LGBTQA community beginning in 1982 when Society of the
Individual was established to
become the first gay student organization. In addition, the
university hired its first full-time
LGBTQA Student Services Coordinator for its LGBTQA
Student Services department (DePaul,
2017). There are ongoing campus discussions, activities and
programs that seek to provide
support, services and connections for students. There is also a
Faculty and Staff LGBTQA
organization and an annual Stonewall Awards which recognizes
members of DePaul’s LGBTQA
communities who are promoting an accepting and affirming
climate on the campus.
What do they do poorly?
Overall, both institutions do an excellent job of promoting
acceptance and support for members
of the LGBTQA communities on their campuses. However,
Tennessee State University needs to
update the links and information on the website. Much of the
information and programs are dated
from 2014. DePaul seems to have ongoing updated information
and is active on Twitter,
CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 11
Facebook and community sites. This is likely due to having had
over 25 years of a commitment
to the LGBTQA communities. Both institutions could do a
better job of advertising available
training and resources available to the public and surrounding
community.
Rogers’ Theory of Sexual Identity Development is comprised of
four stages: 1) Pre-
socialization- the individual is unaware of the larger society or
social expectations of gender
roles; 2) Social Identity Conflict/Personal Awareness-
Individual becomes aware that internal
feelings or gender may conflict with parental and social
expectations, may struggle with role-
playing; 3) Social Acceptance- Individual begins the quest to
find support among peers and
others who identify with sexual minority group; 4)
Pride/Confidence- Individual challenges
gender roles and traditional assignments of gender expectations;
individual accepts and
integrates his gender and sexuality into who he is as an
individual.
Through their programs and services, Tennessee State
University and DePaul University
ensures a supportive and accepting environment regardless of
where a student falls on the
continuum of gender and sexual identity development. Whether
a student is coming out,
questioning or boldly displaying their sexuality pride, each
institution provides a space on the
campus for students to connect and explore who they are
without discrimination or harassment.
Implications for Best Practices in Higher Education
Colleges and universities must present climates where LGBTQ
students feel safe,
supported and affirmed as students and persons in varying
stages of gender and sexual identity
development. Institutions of higher learning are not only places
of learning, but are also
miniature societies (Teaching Tolerance, 2017). Moreover, it is
not only about the special
treatment afforded to LGBTQ students, but also it is how
colleges and universities teach
acceptance and understanding for all people. This means that
those outside of the LGBTQ
CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 12
community need to be taught awareness, tolerance and respect
for all fellow students, regardless
of their gender identity and sexual orientation. This is
imperative given the recent Human Rights
Campaign survey that revealed LGBT students report being
verbally and physically harassed at
school (Teaching Tolerance, 2017), which means LGBTQ
students are likely to have negative
educational experiences. Creating supportive environments have
shown to improve educational
outcomes for all students when campus resources are reflective
of safety, support and openness.
Schools are improving resources and services to the LGBTQ
study body they offer more
programs and co-curricular activities to help create safe and
welcoming campuses (Kratsas,
2017). The Campus Pride Index is a tool that assists colleges
and universities to learn ways to
improve their LGBTQ campus life and to ultimately shape the
educational experience to be more
inclusive, welcoming and respectful of all gender and sexual
identities as well as Ally people
(Campus Pride Index, 2017). The Campus Pride Index acts as a
measure of LGBTQ policies,
programs and practices and includes 50+ self-assessment
questions, which correspond to eight
different LGBTQ-friendly factors. These eight factors are:
• LGBTQ Policy Inclusion
• LGBTQ Support & Institutional Commitment
• LGBTQ Academic Life
• LGBTQ Student Life
• LGBTQ Housing
• LGBTQ Campus Safety
• LGBTQ Counseling & Health
• LGBTQ Recruitment & Retention Efforts
CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 13
The Campus Pride Index sends campus officials a confidential
report of the index tool
along with recommendations for improvement and an LGBTQ-
friendly rating through a 5-star
scoring system (Campus Pride Index, 2016). Finally, Campus
Pride lists the top 30 LGBTQ-
friendly colleges and universities on its website for potential
students, families and employees to
review.
Awareness. Any program or service starts with awareness.
Educators and higher
education professionals can support LGBTQ students by
implementing some best practices for
creating climates or environments in which students feel safe
and affirmed. Some of these
include the following:
• Gay-Straight Alliance Clubs (this is a way to educate students
about
diversity and can offer support).
• Encourage and reward campus officials to form Ally
organizations. (Allies
are trained persons who have agreed to actively support and
publically
acknowledge they are safe and offer welcoming environments).
• Make sure dress codes are enforced equally among all
students.
• Empower students to express themselves, and
• Use gender-inclusive language at all event communications,
including
forms and applications (options for preferred pronouns).
• Provide an LGBTQ glossary of terms to all students, faculty
and staff.
Policy. Colleges and universities can update and implement
Anti-Bullying Policies and
codes of conduct to communicate public statement of safety for
students. The policies should
make clear that all students are protected and explicit
safeguarding measures are in place for
LGTBQ students. The Consortium of Higher Education LGBT
Resource Professionals advise in
CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 14
their Suggested Best Practices for Asking Sexual Orientation
and Gender on College
Applications, that because of the growing numbers of students
identifying as non-binary,
applications should include “genderqueer” and “agender”
choices.
Some other policy suggestions are:
• Gender-Inclusive Housing,
• Transition-Related Medical Expenses,
• LGTBQ Identity Questions as an Option on Admission
Application and
Enrollment Forms (Because gender and sexuality are fluid,
students
should have the option to change gender and sexual identity on
campus
records during their academic career).
• Trans-Inclusive Admission Policy, and
• Policies that Include Gender Identity/Expression.
Training. Institutions can offer annual training for the entire
campus community from
students, staff, faculty to administrators. It should be
communicated that all have a role in
promoting an inclusive campus environment that is welcoming
to all students.
Campus Resources. It is important that LGBTQ resources
support students who are
experiencing varying levels of gender and sexual identity
development. Counselors who are
trained and equipped to support students experiencing anxiety,
depression and increased thoughts
of suicide should be a part of the campus. Several resources are:
• Support groups,
• Counseling Services,
• HIV/AIDS Testing,
• Gender Neutral Rest Rooms,
CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 15
• Supportive housing/residence life, and
• Referrals to community partners (housing, food, medical,
etc.).
Finally, it is important that higher education professionals and
universities and colleges
put forth best practices and services that will ensure supportive
and welcoming environments for
students in the LGBTQ community. Through inclusive policies
and procedures, a climate of
openness can help students reach their optimal potential during
their higher education
experience.
CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 16
References
(2016). In Campus Pride. Retrieved June 5, 2017, from
https://www.campuspride.org/campuspride2016top30/
(2016). In Consortium of Higher Education. Retrieved June 5,
2017, from
www.lgbtcampus.org
Bayne, H.B. (2016). Helping gay and lesbian students integrate
sexual and religious identities.
Journal of College Counseling, 19(1), 61-75.
doi:10.1002/jock.12031Cover, R. (2011).
Queer youth suicide, culture and identity: Unlivable Lives?.
Burlington, VT: Routledge
Cramer, P. (1980). The development of sexual identity. Journal
of Personality Assessment,
44(6), 604.
Degges-White, S., Rice, B., & Myers, J.E. (2000). Revisiting
Cass’ theory of sexual identity
formation: A study of lesbian development. Journal of Mental
Health Counseling, 22(4),
318.
DePaul University (2017). Key facts & rankings. Accessed from
https://www.depaul.edu/about/Pages/rankings.aspx
DePaul University (2017). LGTBQ studies. Accessed from
https://las.depaul.edu/academics/lgbtq-
studies/about/Pages/default.aspx
Dentato, M. P., Craig, S. L., Messinger, L., Lloyd, M., &
McInroy, L. B. (2014). Outness among
LGBTQ social work students in North America: The
contribution of environmental
supports and perceptions of comfort. Social Work Education,
33(4), 485-501.
doi:10.1080/02615479.2013.855193
Gender Identity. (2016). New Atlantis: A journal of Technology
& Society, (50), 86-113.
CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 17
Gender Identity Expression. (2015). New York Commission on
Human Rights. Accessed from
https://www1.nyc.gov/assets/cchr/downloads/pdf/publications/G
enderID_Card2015.pdf
Gervacio, J. (2012). A comparative review of Cass’s and
Fassinger’s sexual orientation identity
development models, e Vermont Connection: 33(7). Available
at:
http://scholarworks.uvm.edu/tvc/vol33/iss1/7
Graham, L.F., Aronson, R.E., Nichols, T., Stephens, C.F., &
Rhodes, S.D. (2011). Factors
influencing depression and anxiety among Black sexual
minority men. Depression
Research & Treatment, 1-9. Doi:10.1155/2011/587984
Gragg, R.A. (2012). Working with sexual minority youth:
Coming out. Brown University Child
& Adolescent Behavior Letter, 28(10), 1-6.
Evans, N.J., Forney, D.S., Guido, F.M., Patton, L., Renn, K.
(2009). Student development
In college: Theory, research, and practice (2nd ed.). San
Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
Katz-Wise, S.L. (2015). Sexual fluidity in young adult women
and men: associations with sexual
orientation and sexual identity development. Psychology &
Sexuality, 6(2), 189-208.
doi:10.1080/19419899.2013.876445
Kratsas, G. (2017). 50 great LGBTQ-friendly colleges.
Retrieved at
www.greatvaluecolleges.net/50-great-lgbtq-friendly-colleges/
Konik, J., & Stewart, A. (2004). Sexual identity development in
the context of compulsory
heterosexuality. Journal of Personality, 72(4), 815-844.
doi:10.1111/j.0022-
3506.2004.00281.x
LGBTQ at TSU (2014). Supporting the LGBTQ campus
community. Accessed from
http://www.tnstate.edu/eeoaa/tsusafezone.aspx
Morgan, E.M. (2012). Not always a straight path: College
student’s narratives of heterosexual
CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 18
Identity development. Sex Roles, 66, 79-93.
Office of Equity & Inclusion (2017). TSU safe zone ally listing.
Accessed from
http://www.tnstate.edu/eeoaa/szallies.aspx
Parrenas, J. (2017). Twenty-first century gender: Welcome to
the gender revolution!
Lesbian News, 42(10), 66-67.
Pryce, A. (2006). Let’s talk about sexual behavior in the human
male: Kinsey and the invention
Of (post) modern sexualities. Sexuality & Culture, 10(1), 63-93
Rosario, M., Schrimshaw, E.W., & Hunter, J. (2011). Different
patterns of sexual identity
development over time: Implications for the psychological
adjustment of lesbian, gay, and
bisexual youths. Journal of Sex Research, 48(1), 3-15.
doi:10.1080/0022449090333106
Shepler, D., & Perrone-McGovern, K. (2016). Differences in
psychological distress and esteem
based on sexual identity development. College Student Journal,
50(4), 579-589.
Steinmetz, K. (2017). Infinite identities. (Cover story). Time,
189(11). 48-54.
Teaching Tolerance. (2017). A project of the southern poverty
law center. Retrieved from
www.tolerance.org/category/classroom-resources/sexual-
orientation
Torres, v., Jones, S.R., & Renn, K.A., (2009). Identity
development theories in student affairs:
Origins, status, and new approaches. Journal of College Student
Development, 50(6),
577-596.
Module 9: Capstone Final Paper
How can you use the concepts identified in this assignment, and
the class as a whole, to successfully support student
development in college?
As you consider ways to support college student development,
discuss those in the context of an area of higher education
where you currently work or where you wish to work,
ADVISING,
How does your chosen area of higher education fit into the
bigger picture of student development as a whole?
Incorporate this final component into a well synthesized final
paper including the other four components you have worked on
during this course.
Final Paper Requirements:15 – 20 pages in length, double
spaced (not including the cover page or reference page);
· Incorporate a minimum of ten scholarly references;
Running head FORMULATING A DATA PRESENTATION BRIEF               .docx

More Related Content

DOCX
Running head CAPSTONE COMPONENT PART 42CAPSTONE COMPONENT PA.docx
PDF
Nhs Essay Examples. 001 Nhs Essays Essay 04 09 2013page0 Thatsnotus
PDF
Research Proposal Essay Example
PDF
HutchCC Grant Navigator - September 2024 Issue
DOCX
Cultural Differences in Parenting.docxRunning Head CULTURAL D.docx
PDF
San Jose State University Bateman Competition 2019
DOCX
Lead The Match - Final Report 5-10-16
PDF
UALR Institute on Race and Ethnicity Strategic Directions 2014 and Beyond
Running head CAPSTONE COMPONENT PART 42CAPSTONE COMPONENT PA.docx
Nhs Essay Examples. 001 Nhs Essays Essay 04 09 2013page0 Thatsnotus
Research Proposal Essay Example
HutchCC Grant Navigator - September 2024 Issue
Cultural Differences in Parenting.docxRunning Head CULTURAL D.docx
San Jose State University Bateman Competition 2019
Lead The Match - Final Report 5-10-16
UALR Institute on Race and Ethnicity Strategic Directions 2014 and Beyond

Similar to Running head FORMULATING A DATA PRESENTATION BRIEF .docx (15)

PDF
Placement Essay 1434007
DOCX
CALIFORNIA LUTHERAN UNIVERSITYINSTITUTIONAL REVIEW BOARDAP.docx
PDF
What Are Some Good Compare And Contrast Essay Topics.pdf
PDF
What Are Some Good Compare And Contrast Essay Topics.pdf
PPTX
Achieving Equitable Outcomes with Results-Based Accountability
PDF
MTarquinio-AGDA2016
PDF
Essays Done For You
PDF
Nhs Essay Tips.pdf
PDF
Spring 2017 MoCDA Newsletter
DOCX
Campaign 377 final
PDF
Focusing-on-Race-and-Advancing-Equity-at-UW
PDF
Essay Topics On Religion.pdf
PPTX
HUMMSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS.pptx
PDF
Al Qaed A Radical Islamic Militant Groups Of Islam And The...
PDF
Diversity white paper-final
Placement Essay 1434007
CALIFORNIA LUTHERAN UNIVERSITYINSTITUTIONAL REVIEW BOARDAP.docx
What Are Some Good Compare And Contrast Essay Topics.pdf
What Are Some Good Compare And Contrast Essay Topics.pdf
Achieving Equitable Outcomes with Results-Based Accountability
MTarquinio-AGDA2016
Essays Done For You
Nhs Essay Tips.pdf
Spring 2017 MoCDA Newsletter
Campaign 377 final
Focusing-on-Race-and-Advancing-Equity-at-UW
Essay Topics On Religion.pdf
HUMMSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS.pptx
Al Qaed A Radical Islamic Militant Groups Of Islam And The...
Diversity white paper-final
Ad

More from wlynn1 (20)

DOCX
Running head MARKETING ANALYSIS ASSIGNMENTS .docx
DOCX
Running head MANAGING A DIVERSE WORKFORCE1MANAGING A DIVERSE.docx
DOCX
Running head MANAGING TECHNOLOGICAL INNOVATION IN DIGITAL BUS.docx
DOCX
Running head MANAGERIAL REPORT FOR SUPERVISING MANAGER 1MAN.docx
DOCX
Running head MANAGING DYNAMIC ENVIRONMENTS FINAL .docx
DOCX
Running head MANAGING DONUT FRANCHISES1MANAGING DONUT FRANCHIS.docx
DOCX
Running head MANAGEMENT DILEMMAS1MANAGEMENT DILEMMAS6.docx
DOCX
Running head MANAGERIAL ACCOUNTING 1MANAGERIAL ACCOUNTING.docx
DOCX
Running head LOGISTIC REGRESSION .docx
DOCX
Running head MANAGEMENT OF CONGESTIVE HEART FAILURE THROUGH MO .docx
DOCX
Running head MALWARE .docx
DOCX
Running head LOS ANGELES AND NEW YORK BUDGETARY COMPARISON .docx
DOCX
Running head MAJOR PROJECT1MAJOR PROJECT9Initial Ou.docx
DOCX
Running Head MAJOR CONCERNS OF CLIMATE CHANGE IN CHINA 1MAJO.docx
DOCX
Running Head LOGISTICS1Running Head LOGISTICS7.docx
DOCX
Running head LOGIC MODELLOGIC MODEL 2Logic modelStu.docx
DOCX
Running head LITERATURE REVIEW1MINORITY BOYS SCHOOL DROPOUT A.docx
DOCX
Running head LIVING WITH CHRONIC ILLNESS1Living with Chroni.docx
DOCX
Running Head LITERATURE REVIEW2LITERATURE REVIEW 2.docx
DOCX
Running head LOGIC MODELLOGIC MODEL 4Situ.docx
Running head MARKETING ANALYSIS ASSIGNMENTS .docx
Running head MANAGING A DIVERSE WORKFORCE1MANAGING A DIVERSE.docx
Running head MANAGING TECHNOLOGICAL INNOVATION IN DIGITAL BUS.docx
Running head MANAGERIAL REPORT FOR SUPERVISING MANAGER 1MAN.docx
Running head MANAGING DYNAMIC ENVIRONMENTS FINAL .docx
Running head MANAGING DONUT FRANCHISES1MANAGING DONUT FRANCHIS.docx
Running head MANAGEMENT DILEMMAS1MANAGEMENT DILEMMAS6.docx
Running head MANAGERIAL ACCOUNTING 1MANAGERIAL ACCOUNTING.docx
Running head LOGISTIC REGRESSION .docx
Running head MANAGEMENT OF CONGESTIVE HEART FAILURE THROUGH MO .docx
Running head MALWARE .docx
Running head LOS ANGELES AND NEW YORK BUDGETARY COMPARISON .docx
Running head MAJOR PROJECT1MAJOR PROJECT9Initial Ou.docx
Running Head MAJOR CONCERNS OF CLIMATE CHANGE IN CHINA 1MAJO.docx
Running Head LOGISTICS1Running Head LOGISTICS7.docx
Running head LOGIC MODELLOGIC MODEL 2Logic modelStu.docx
Running head LITERATURE REVIEW1MINORITY BOYS SCHOOL DROPOUT A.docx
Running head LIVING WITH CHRONIC ILLNESS1Living with Chroni.docx
Running Head LITERATURE REVIEW2LITERATURE REVIEW 2.docx
Running head LOGIC MODELLOGIC MODEL 4Situ.docx
Ad

Recently uploaded (20)

PDF
English Textual Question & Ans (12th Class).pdf
PPTX
Virtual and Augmented Reality in Current Scenario
PDF
ChatGPT for Dummies - Pam Baker Ccesa007.pdf
PDF
BP 505 T. PHARMACEUTICAL JURISPRUDENCE (UNIT 2).pdf
PPTX
A powerpoint presentation on the Revised K-10 Science Shaping Paper
PPTX
What’s under the hood: Parsing standardized learning content for AI
PDF
Hazard Identification & Risk Assessment .pdf
PDF
Skin Care and Cosmetic Ingredients Dictionary ( PDFDrive ).pdf
PDF
AI-driven educational solutions for real-life interventions in the Philippine...
PDF
What if we spent less time fighting change, and more time building what’s rig...
PDF
HVAC Specification 2024 according to central public works department
PDF
Uderstanding digital marketing and marketing stratergie for engaging the digi...
PDF
Race Reva University – Shaping Future Leaders in Artificial Intelligence
PDF
Paper A Mock Exam 9_ Attempt review.pdf.
PDF
semiconductor packaging in vlsi design fab
PDF
David L Page_DCI Research Study Journey_how Methodology can inform one's prac...
PDF
FOISHS ANNUAL IMPLEMENTATION PLAN 2025.pdf
PPTX
Introduction to pro and eukaryotes and differences.pptx
PDF
BP 704 T. NOVEL DRUG DELIVERY SYSTEMS (UNIT 1)
PPTX
Share_Module_2_Power_conflict_and_negotiation.pptx
English Textual Question & Ans (12th Class).pdf
Virtual and Augmented Reality in Current Scenario
ChatGPT for Dummies - Pam Baker Ccesa007.pdf
BP 505 T. PHARMACEUTICAL JURISPRUDENCE (UNIT 2).pdf
A powerpoint presentation on the Revised K-10 Science Shaping Paper
What’s under the hood: Parsing standardized learning content for AI
Hazard Identification & Risk Assessment .pdf
Skin Care and Cosmetic Ingredients Dictionary ( PDFDrive ).pdf
AI-driven educational solutions for real-life interventions in the Philippine...
What if we spent less time fighting change, and more time building what’s rig...
HVAC Specification 2024 according to central public works department
Uderstanding digital marketing and marketing stratergie for engaging the digi...
Race Reva University – Shaping Future Leaders in Artificial Intelligence
Paper A Mock Exam 9_ Attempt review.pdf.
semiconductor packaging in vlsi design fab
David L Page_DCI Research Study Journey_how Methodology can inform one's prac...
FOISHS ANNUAL IMPLEMENTATION PLAN 2025.pdf
Introduction to pro and eukaryotes and differences.pptx
BP 704 T. NOVEL DRUG DELIVERY SYSTEMS (UNIT 1)
Share_Module_2_Power_conflict_and_negotiation.pptx

Running head FORMULATING A DATA PRESENTATION BRIEF .docx

  • 1. Running head: FORMULATING A DATA PRESENTATION BRIEF 1 FORMULATING A DATA PRESENTATION BRIEF 3 Formulating a Data Presentation Brief Student Name Institution Course Date A brief is a way of communicating to clients and stakeholders about the objectives of a business and what the business aims to achieve at the end. Formulating a brief provides information to clients and partners and thus it is important to provide the right information in a proper manner for the best results (Brigham, 2016). An effective data presentation brief utilizes the relationship between the presenter and the clients and ensures that it puts data in a clear and concise manner which is able to draw the attention of the audience and make them comprehend the data (Kirk, 2016). Data presentations may contain large volumes of variable data and using the right method to formulate a brief determines the ease with which the audience is able to understand, visualize the data and create interest in the
  • 2. project. One of the methods of formulating an effective data presentation brief is through the use of charts. Charts provide an interesting way of presenting data to an audience. Charts have an advantage when presenting a data brief in that they enable presenters to display data in ways that are appealing to the audience (Kirk, 2016). This is because different charts like bar graphs can use different colors that are appealing which help to capture the attention of the audience (Kirk, 2016). In addition, bar graphs are easy to read, interpret and understand at a glance. One of the disadvantage of using charts as a method of presenting data briefs is that focusing on the visual aspects of charts as a way to make them attractive to the audience may end up camouflaging the data being presented which can make the audience to miss the objectives (Brigham, 2016). In addition, presenting complex data on charts may be boring to the audience. Another limitation with the use of charts such as pie charts is that they are limited to the number of variables that they can display and therefore, if the data contains numerous variables, they become inappropriate. Using a Tedtalk can help in presenting data statistics to an audience. This is normally accompanied by some data slides. This method gives the presenter a golden opportunity to be more convincing to the audience through their display of confidence (Brigham, 2016). The presentation can win over the audience depending on the credibility of the speaker. This method might be a disadvantage if the presenter has poor communication skills and lack of confidence. Talking might also get the audience bored and make them fail to visualize the data. The method of formulating a data brief presentation is very critical to the success of a presentation in terms of the ease in which the audience is able to visualize and comprehend the data and therefore presenters to select a method whose benefits outweigh the disadvantages in order to communicate effectively to the audiences.
  • 3. References Brigham, T. J. (2016). Feast for the eyes: an introduction to data visualization. Medical reference services quarterly, 35(2), 215-223. Kirk, A. (2016). Data Visualisation: A Handbook for Data Driven Design. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, Ltd. Running head: CAPSTONE COMPONENT PART 4 2 CAPSTONE COMPONENT PART 4 2 Capstone Component Part 4 Karen Crump National Louis University Course: HED 632, Student Development Theory Instructor: Dustin Heuerman, Ed.D.
  • 4. University of Nevada Las Vegas and Development of Social Identity and Gender Identity Gender identity is the self-recognition of an individual's own gender about their traits. As early as three years of age, children start developing individual behavior that is linked to a specific gender, either female or male. In the early stages of childhood, gender identity is evaluated based on the interests that the children develop. Typically, male children are attracted to masculine objects and activities as toy cars and toy guns. On the other hand, small girls tend to be attracted to soft toys such as dolls and colorful items. Social identity refers to who particular regard themselves to be based on the social groups they often engage with, or they were born to. The development of social status is mainly dependent on the characteristics of the group that an individual identifies themselves with, (Wood & Eagly, 2018). A person's behavior is mostly influenced by their decision to conform to certain social groups. At older ages, gender identity can be expressed through hobbies and interests in individual careers while social status can be expressed mainly through dress code. The University of Nevada, Las Vegas, a public research university, introduced a program to address gender, race, and identity. The program offers the opportunity for scholars and learners to explore and study extensively about social status as well as gender identity. Setting up an entirely autonomous department for the program has promoted successful research into the issues that revolve around gender identity and social identity. The University also offers a range of courses in the field of gender, race, and identity and has continuously produced intellectuals in this specific field, (Coates, 2015). The LGBTQ community has fully been recognized by the institution since 2015. Members of the LGBTQ community often get counseling services from the institution's counseling department. Despite the University's commitment to promoting free gender expression, the institution has often failed to safeguard the freedom of expression for the LGBTQ community.
  • 5. Several cases have been reported where members of the LGBTQ community have been harassed or stigmatized within the institution. There lack clear guidelines and policy that dictates the action to be taken against perpetrators of gender harassment within the University (Harry & Watson, 2017). However, it is imperative to note that the University of Nevada has remained firmly committed to the development of gender and social identity. Funding of research and support of gender- related programs by the University has played a significant role in promoting and spreading awareness on identity-related issues both within and outside the University. Oral Roberts University and Development of Faith, Disability Identity & Social Class Faith can be defined as complete trust and belief in a particular doctrine and the willingness to uphold the required standards associated with a specific religion of choice. The development of faith has well been noted to start right from the upbringing of children (Parks, 2018). Raising a child to believe in a sure religion often has a lasting impact on their lifetime beliefs and actually influences every decision they shall make in life. As humans, we often fail to question what has been fed to us by people whom we fully trust. It is therefore unlikely that a person who was raised in a family solidly founded in Christianity will at any time dispute or question Christianity. Social class refers to the various classifications that people are grouped into based on certain notable aspects of their lives such as marriage, wealth, royalty, and dynasties or even the people they often engage with. Disability identity can be defined as the personal sense of attachment and belonging that an individual develops towards a particular form of disability or incapacitation. With disability identity, individuals tend to actively support and have positivity while associating with persons with disability. At Oral Roberts University, religion is a significant aspect that guides every activity within the institution. Oral Roberts is a private community-based evangelical university whose core
  • 6. values are grounded in the Christian faith (Synan, 2018). The institution was founded, not only to educate academic wise but also to serve as a religious institution of higher learning to Christian scholars. The mission statement of the University is emphatic on the life skills that are necessary to Christian scholars. The sole mission remains to be the creation of world leaders who are well grounded in the holy spirit of Christianity and who will positively impact the world. One thing that the University does best is to teach positive values to all the learner at the institution. Christian values taught at the University are very much relevant in Christian society. Also, the University offers full support to underprivileged Christians who wish to further their education but lack financial aid. The University provides scholarships for students from all over the world for them to pursue their desired career goals. However, the institution does not fully extend its support to non-Christian individuals who seek opportunities at the University. Setting a strict policy that requires all students enrolled at the University to be Christians is not quite a good practice in the current world. We live in a free society where freedom of expression and freedom of worship is guaranteed (Zdor et al., 2018). Therefore, the University should come up with revised guidelines that are not discriminative against non- Christians. References: Coates, J., (2015). Women, men, and language: A sociolinguistic account of gender differences in style. Routledge. Harry, K., & Watson, J. (2017). Shaping Identity in Prehispanic Southern Nevada. Parks, S. D., (2018). Faith Development. The Oxford Handbook of Religion and American Education, 103. Synan, V. H., (2018). The Pentecostal Roots of Oral Roberts' Healing Ministry. Spiritus: ORU Journal of Theology, 3(2), 12.
  • 7. Wood, W., & Eagly, A. H. (2015). Two traditions of research on gender identity. Sex Roles, 73(11-12), 461-473. Zdor, R., Henson, S. M., Murray, M., Navia, B., Wells, R., & Goodwin, T. (2018). Fostering Student Faith Development and Integration across the Curriculum: The Andrews University Biology Department Experience. Running head: CAPSTONE PART 3 1 CAPSTONE PART 3 5 Faith and Spirituality Karen Crump National Louis University Dr. Dustin Heuerman HED 632 Faith and Spirituality Parents put into helping their children understand the concepts that could turn out to be confusing and complicated for their understanding. An excellent example of such situations involves the processing of agreement and difference between Faith, religion, and spirituality. When kids fail to understand these concepts, they become frustrated, opening them up to the possibility of rubbishing their essence in life. Parents guide their children and the young ones under their care to understand Faith, religion, and spirituality because these elements inspire the development of a purposeful and happy life (Flannelly, Weaver & Costa, 2014). Several theories have been advanced to aid the understanding of the development of Faith and spirituality. The proponents of the methods utilized different approaches to explain the evolution of Faith and spirituality.
  • 8. The proponents include Bruce Powers, John Westerhoff, James Fowler, Larry Stephens, Gordon Allport, and others (Newman, 2004). Therefore, this essay utilizes Fowler’s faith development theory to advance the discussion on the drafting of a working theory of student development towards professional experience inspired by Faith, spirituality, and religion. James Fowler’s faith development theory is a cognitive developmental model that aids the understanding of the processes of spiritual development without the influence of the traditions of an individual (Hvidt et al., 2017). The holistic orientation of the theory examines how one is related to the universe across the life span. It has seven stages. The advancement of my faith development stages and method borrows from different theories and emulates Fowler's approach. For instance, I will use scenes that describe the cognitive processes involved in the advancement of Faith and perceptions of individuals. The theory borrows from my experience and how it shaped my ideologies of Faith. 1st stage: Initial Faith The stage describes our first encounter with Faith and how we process the idea of God and prayer. It serves an essential role in laying the spiritual foundation (Johnstone et al., 2015). In this stage, the individual lacks control over the information relayed but may experience the inception of the crisis internally. 2nd stage: Conditioning of God’s Love This stage aims to acclimatize the individuals towards internalizing God’s unconditional love. For instance, the parents separate themselves from the child and give them space to create their perception of God (Kadar et al., 2015). It is a stage that follows the previous step, which focused on aligning individuals towards spirituality. It elicits similarity with Erikson’s stages of development where autonomy goes head to head with shame. Children will not find it comfortable to
  • 9. remain at home when all the members of the family go to church. It also functions as the intuitive-projective Faith that uses gestures and narratives to inspire the imaginations of an individual. It gives rise to the moral emotions that make an individual aware of the taboos, thereby striking a balance between the representation of God and the aspects of life considered to be ungodly. 3rd stage: Literal and conventional Faith The third stage pools together individuals in the elementary school years to middle adolescence, where an individual move from self-condemnation to the destruction of the Distorted Image of God (Souza et al., 2015). At this stage, one is bound to make mistakes and seek forgiveness from God to avoid the wrath of the parents. Children at this stage begin to apply the truths about God because they are aware of sins and their wages. As time passes, they develop a healthy image of God as their Faith strengthens and instructs them towards obeying the commandments of God and staying away from sin. The lessons about spiritual concepts begin to cement, and they enter to view God as a patient, loving, forgiving, and accepting Father. The driving force at this stage is a belief that allows them to Accept Jesus as the Messiah. 4th Stage: Faith of Identity and Intimacy Between the age of 12 to 35, people gain salvation or baptism that allows them to accept themselves as temples of God. At this stage, the relationships with God become that of close dependence as people seek the control of the Holy Spirit in their conscience. Teenagers search for their identity while those in their late thirties begin to regret the things they have done in life. They start to drift towards God. 5th Stage: Spiritual Ministry and Universalizing Faith At the late stage of life, people begin to seek the Kingdom of
  • 10. God because they want to make amends for their sins to have a peaceful transition into the next life called eternity (McKay & Wood, 2019). Some venture into sharing the word of God while others take the spiritual and Faith matters seriously by doing missions, leading Bible studies, and doing charity. The bottom line of faith and spirituality theory is to aid the development of an explanation that allows individuals to understand how their Faith is shaped by the circumstances they face in their environment when growing up. When people find it challenging to align with the common understanding in the early stages of life, at one point in life, they come back to seek to belong in one of the most appealing religions that suit their Faith and spirituality. References Flannelly, K. J., Weaver, A. J., & Costa, K. G. (2014). A systematic review of religion and spirituality in three palliative care journals, 1990–1999. Journal of Palliative Care, 20(1), 50- 56. Hvidt, N. C., Hvidtjørn, D., Christensen, K., Nielsen, J. B., & Søndergaard, J. (2017). Faith moves mountains—mountains move Faith: two opposite epidemiological forces in research on religion and health. Journal of religion and health, 56(1), 294- 304. Johnstone, B., Yoon, D. P., Cohen, D., Schopp, L. H., McCormack, G., Campbell, J., & Smith, M. (2015). Relationships among spirituality, religious practices, personality factors, and health for five different faith traditions. Journal of religion and health, 51(4), 1017-1041. Kadar, J. L., Scott, A. B., Hipp, K., Belavich, T. G., Butter, E.
  • 11. M., Rye, M. S., ... & Zinnbauer, B. J. (2015). Religion and spirituality: Unfuzzying the fuzzy. In Sociology of Religion (pp. 29-34). Routledge. McKay, M., & Wood, J. C., (2019). The New Happiness: Practices for Spiritual Growth and Living with Intention. New Harbinger Publications. Newman, L. L., (2004). Faith, Spirituality, and Religion: A Model for Understanding the Differences. College Student Affairs Journal, 23(2), 102-110. Souza, V. D. M., Frizzo, H. C. F., Paiva, M. H. P. D., Bousso, R. S., & Santos, Á. D. S. (2015). Spirituality, religion, and personal beliefs of adolescents with cancer. Revista Brasileira de Enfermagem, 68(5), 791-796. Running head: FAITH AND SPIRITUALITY 1 FAITH AND SPIRITUALITY 2 FAITH AND SPIRITUALITY HED632 CAPSTONE 2 Karen Crump National Louis University Dr. Dustin Heuerman May 5, 2019
  • 12. Faith and Spirituality Development Literature Review For quite some time, the development and application of religion, Faith, and spirituality have fronted a significant concern among scholars. In most cases, the three concepts have been used interchangeably although Faith, spirituality, and religion are three distinct and different concepts. Notably, Faith is about knowing Godly ways, religion is about is practicing Faith while spirituality is about being in Faith. According to Crowther & Hall (2015), Faith is the foundation of any creed or spirituality, on the other hand, spirituality and religion indicators of Faith. Hvidt et al. (2017), argues that the study of spirituality and faith development was neglected until the late 1980s. The issue of Faith and religion traces its history back in 1000, but no theory or model addressed the issue of their development. The author further notes that learning the concepts of Faith and spirituality forms the basis for the study of any religion. However, in modern days, there has been tremendous progress in the research of the two concepts. The author recognizes in need to study the development of Faith and religion since they form an important theme in understanding the religion and culture of the people. The period between 1000 and 1300 marked a crucial time in the development and study of Faith and spirituality. During this time, people began to learn about scripture and began exercising religion. Though there was the existence of worship during this time, there was not Faith that was linked to religion. People merely picked, followed, and accepted what they were advised to do and Faith was not essential to them. However, in the early fifteenth century, scholars began to scrutinize the church especially Roman Catholic –a move that was aimed at understanding the religion deeply. This journey was planned by Martin Luther who sought
  • 13. to comprehend the significance of Faith in religion. In this time, the concept of Faith began to surface especially among the Protestants who believed that, "salvation drops by Faith alone, regardless of acts of kindness or the holy observances” (Souza et al., 2015). Making Faith make sense Faith is an essential aspect of human beings that help them to create a pattern throughout their lifespan. Considerably, Faith shapes the rational way of “making sense of, and committing to, transcendent values and realities; to ultimate concerns” (Hvidt et al., 2017). Faith development can be understood through a cognitive developmental model known as faith development theory (FDT). This approach allows people and scholars to assess the process of spiritual development free from any influence from faith traditions. Faith development can be understood through multiple stages: Intuitive-Projective Faith Mythical-literal Faith Synthetic-conventional Faith Individuated-reflective Faith Conjunctive Faith Universalizing Faith The first stage which is intuitive-projective Faith begins when a kid starts to learn a new language characterized by the use of symbols in play and speech. In this stage, young children are highly influenced by their old people in their lives especially parents. There is a lot of imitation in this stage kids learn about God and angels, and the consequences of disobeying the word of God. In the mythical-literal, children begin to develop the ability to think logically and connect to the things that happen in their lives. Children start to learn new stories and beliefs that shape their Faith and symbolize the sense of belonging to a particular faith (Souza et al., 2015). In the third stage which is synthetic-conventional Faith is the stage that takes place in the adulthood and people begin to follow the value and belief
  • 14. systems that link them to God. Individuative-reflective Faith happens in early adulthood whereby people start to evaluating and examining the actual costs and belief and develop their own Faith. Conjunctive Faith takes place at the middle age forces people to build their personal coherence aimed at nurturing and deepening their relationship to God. The last phase is called universalizing Faith that happens in old age and is linked to “universal structures that belong to all faiths” (Souza et al., 2015). According to Crowther & Hall (2015), Faith is key to the development and growth of spirituality. Faith and spirituality present some outcomes or befits. Spiritual Faith helps people to forgive each other, and people with spiritual divine believe forgiveness. Religion allows people to become spiritually holy leading to victory in life. Religious Faith is a sign of salvation which helps people to act right and love one another. With Faith, people can do a lot of good which is in line with the teachings of God. According to Christians, Faith helps them to avoid committing any kind of sin –something that brings good things in their lives. Religion is defined by spirituality and Faith which help the believer in fighting life battles and winning them. Though the study of Faith and spirituality has been limited, recent researches have proved excellent and promising progress in understanding the development of the two concepts concerning religion. References Crowther, S., & Hall, J. (2015). Spirituality and spiritual care in and around childbirth. Women and birth, 28(2), 173-178. Hvidt, N. C., Hvidtjørn, D., Christensen, K., Nielsen, J. B., & Søndergaard, J. (2017). Faith moves mountains—mountains move Faith: two opposite epidemiological forces in research on religion and health. Journal of religion and health, 56(1), 294- 304. Souza, V. D. M., Frizzo, H. C. F., Paiva, M. H. P. D., Bousso, R. S., & Santos, Á. D. S. (2015). Spirituality, religion and
  • 15. personal beliefs of adolescents with cancer. Revista Brasileira de Enfermagem, 68(5), 791-796. Running Head: LITERATURE REVIEW: DEVELOPMENT OF FAITH AND SPIRITUALITY 1 LITERATURE REVIEW: DEVELOPMENT OF FAITH AND SPIRITUALITY 6 Literature Review: Development of Faith and Spirituality Karen Crump National Louis University April 28, 2019
  • 16. Literature Review: Development of Faith and Spirituality Faith and other spirituality have caused wars, discussions, and massacres from the beginning of time. Thinking back, clash, for the most part, starts when gatherings of individuals have varying otherworldly convictions. While this issue has improved all through time, as the general acknowledgment of decent variety has extended, it is as yet a common reason for strife today. The movement of religion since forever can be intently inspected by understanding the social atmosphere in some random period. Starting in 1000 amid the High Middle Ages and advancing to the Reformation, one can look at the move in religious other spirituality and faith. While different spirituality and religion are frequently close to home points, one can look at the ordinary convictions of a territory. While in the High Middle Ages one didn't have the privilege to pick their very own religious way, as time advances, that extravagance turns out to be increasingly typical. From 1000-1300, religion was a remarkable piece of day by day life for individuals of the High Middle Ages. Right now the "Christian church was the focal point of network life" enabling natives to assemble around religious assets (McKay & Wood, 2019). Individuals likewise reinforced with their cleric since he "frequently worked in the fields with the general population," putting everybody on a similar dimension. Mass was a remarkable piece of every week except right now it was discussed in Latin although most of the residents did not know the language. This incredibly added to individuals' association with religion since they for the most part gone to Mass as a constant everyday practice and not for any close to the home feeling of other spirituality. Because of the way that they couldn't comprehend the Mass implied that their own different spirituality was not reliable. Additionally, individuals mainly learned scriptural stories through "the depictions on the congregation dividers" rather than their very personal profound encounters (McKay & Wood, 2019). In this manner, while day
  • 17. by day life rotated around religious exercises and occasions, individuals did not have an individual association with their faith. Religion had an influence in their day by day life since they had no real option except to go to Christian based occasions, yet the quality of their own faith was very feeble. This way, individuals were not picking which faith was essential to them; they were simply following the group and accepting what they were advised to take. This attitude of religion was regular in this timeframe, and the independence of religion did not happen until nearer to the fifteenth century, amid the Reconstruction. Individuals in the mid-sixteenth century were extraordinarily devout yet additionally started to scrutinize the Roman Catholic Church. Quite a bit of this originated from anticlericalism, or "resistance to the pastorate" (McKay & Wood, 2019). Individuals were angry because ministry individuals were improper, insensible and holding numerous positions. These reactions of the ministry enabled Martin Luther's plans to spread quickly. Martin Luther's investigations enabled him to comprehend the significance of faith. Protestant idea trusted that "salvation drops by faith alone, regardless of acts of kindness or the holy observances." This genuinely tangled with customary Catholic conviction of the seven holy observances. For Luther, "daily religious practice, visit admissions, and fasting gave him minimal otherworldly harmony (Stephenson & Berry, 2015). He kept saying that faith is a blessing and not given to the individuals who implore, quickly or go to administrations more. This realized the single side to religion, accentuating the person's association with God, and not religious conventions. Furthermore, Luther disdained the clearance of guilty pleasures since he accepted there was no real way to pay for the pardoning of sins. This conviction formally started the Reformation with the posting of his 95 Theses. His proposals were initially imprinted in Latin; however then meant German, enabling most of the individuals to peruse and get them
  • 18. (Zinnbauer & Pargament, 2015). The way that they were imprinted in the vernacular made Luther's conviction across the board as he picked up an incredible gathering of devotees; something that would have been unimaginable in earlier hundreds of years. With this came a massive change in how individuals saw religion yet additionally caused religious pressure in numerous nations. Martin Luther caused commotion on philosophical terms as well as on issues of "riches, influence and fundamental structure" (Flannelly, Weaver & Costa, 2014). Protestant idea likewise joined adherents by expressing that a congregation ought to be an "otherworldly brotherhood of devotees" (Oman, 2018). This changed the mindset of religious organizations, making them all the more neighborly and joined rather than one individual lecturing an expansive gathering of individuals. Martin Luther's beliefs drastically influenced how individuals saw religion and what they ought to accept. It started the individual voyage one has with faith rather than solid masses of individuals compelled to tune in to similar messages every week. With the official acknowledgment of Lutheranism in 1555, nations were permitted to pick among Catholicism and Lutheranism, a noteworthy advance in the adventure to autonomous faith and other spirituality. What I have realized through the investigation of religion in history is how unimaginably fortunate we are present to face a daily reality such that we are each permitted to have our own thoughts of faith and other spirituality. While Luther and Erasmus were uncommon in their time, these days' individuals generally can trust whatever they pick. I particularly appreciate the independence of faith since I don't trust it is satisfactory for anybody to advise someone else what to put stock in (Johnstone et al., 2015). Spirituality is something unimaginably close to home and in this way should be an individual adventure for each individual. Experiencing childhood in an interfaith family, I could watch two unique belief systems. I trust this has affected my perspectives on religion since I comprehend that one's religious convictions just straightforwardly have an effect on
  • 19. them self. Watching my folks join both Catholic and Jewish customs into our family demonstrated to me the outrageous estimation of assorted variety, something I have always appreciated. Actually, my faith can be ascribed to my seven summers spent at the Jewish summer camp where I was permitted to investigate my religion through workmanship, music and network petition (Johnstone et al., 2015). These seven summers reinforced my own faith yet additionally enable me to acknowledge a decent variety of assorted types. In this way, I feel fortunate to have the capacity to pick my very own profound way, dissimilar to those in the High Middle Ages or amid the Reformation when it was the choice of the lord. While religion and faith will result in all probability dependably motivation banter, I figure we can think back on history and recognize what amount has changed over the most recent 1000 years, and be appreciative for it. Comment by Dustin Heuerman: For the final paper, write in only third person. References Flannelly, K. J., Weaver, A. J., & Costa, K. G. (2014). A systematic review of religion and spirituality in three palliative care journals, 1990–1999. Journal of Palliative Care, 20(1), 50- 56. Johnstone, B., Yoon, D. P., Cohen, D., Schopp, L. H.,
  • 20. McCormack, G., Campbell, J., & Smith, M. (2015). Relationships among spirituality, religious practices, personality factors, and health for five different faith traditions. Journal of religion and health, 51(4), 1017-1041. Kadar, J. L., Scott, A. B., Hipp, K., Belavich, T. G., Butter, E. M., Rye, M. S., ... & Zinnbauer, B. J. (2015). Religion and spirituality: Unfuzzying the fuzzy. In Sociology of Religion (pp. 29-34). Routledge. McKay, M., & Wood, J. C. (2019). The New Happiness: Practices for Spiritual Growth and Living with Intention. New Harbinger Publications. Oman, D. (2018). Defining religion and spirituality. Handbook of the psychology of religion and spirituality, 2, 23-47. Stephenson, P. S., & Berry, D. M. (2015). Describing spirituality at the end of life. Western Journal of Nursing Research, 37(9), 1229-1247. Zinnbauer, B. J., & Pargament, K. I. (2015). Religiousness and spirituality. Handbook of the psychology of religion and spirituality, 21-42. Running Head: LITERATURE REVIEW: DEVELOPMENT OF FAITH AND SPIRITUALITY 1 LITERATURE REVIEW: DEVELOPMENT OF FAITH AND SPIRITUALITY 6 Literature Review: Development of Faith and Spirituality
  • 21. Karen Crump National Louis University April 28, 2019 Literature Review: Development of Faith and Spirituality Faith and other spirituality have caused wars, discussions, and massacres from the beginning of time. Thinking back, clash, for the most part, starts when gatherings of individuals have varying otherworldly convictions. While this issue has improved all through time, as the general acknowledgment of decent variety has extended, it is as yet a common reason for strife today. The movement of religion since forever can be intently inspected by understanding the social atmosphere in some random period. Starting in 1000 amid the High Middle Ages and advancing to the Reformation, one can look at the move in religious other spirituality and faith. While different spirituality and religion are frequently close to home points, one can look at the ordinary convictions of a territory. While in the High Middle Ages one didn't have the privilege to pick their very own religious way, as time advances, that extravagance turns out to be increasingly typical. From 1000-1300, religion was a remarkable piece of day by day life for individuals of the High Middle Ages. Right now the "Christian church was the focal point of network life" enabling natives to assemble around religious assets (McKay & Wood, 2019). Individuals likewise reinforced with their cleric since he
  • 22. "frequently worked in the fields with the general population," putting everybody on a similar dimension. Mass was a remarkable piece of every week except right now it was discussed in Latin although most of the residents did not know the language. This incredibly added to individuals' association with religion since they for the most part gone to Mass as a constant everyday practice and not for any close to the home feeling of other spirituality. Because of the way that they couldn't comprehend the Mass implied that their own different spirituality was not reliable. Additionally, individuals mainly learned scriptural stories through "the depictions on the congregation dividers" rather than their very personal profound encounters (McKay & Wood, 2019). In this manner, while day by day life rotated around religious exercises and occasions, individuals did not have an individual association with their faith. Religion had an influence in their day by day life since they had no real option except to go to Christian based occasions, yet the quality of their own faith was very feeble. This way, individuals were not picking which faith was essential to them; they were simply following the group and accepting what they were advised to take. This attitude of religion was regular in this timeframe, and the independence of religion did not happen until nearer to the fifteenth century, amid the Reconstruction. Individuals in the mid-sixteenth century were extraordinarily devout yet additionally started to scrutinize the Roman Catholic Church. Quite a bit of this originated from anticlericalism, or "resistance to the pastorate" (McKay & Wood, 2019). Individuals were angry because ministry individuals were improper, insensible and holding numerous positions. These reactions of the ministry enabled Martin Luther's plans to spread quickly. Martin Luther's investigations enabled him to comprehend the significance of faith. Protestant idea trusted that "salvation drops by faith alone, regardless of acts of kindness or the holy observances." This genuinely tangled with customary Catholic conviction of the seven holy observances.
  • 23. For Luther, "daily religious practice, visit admissions, and fasting gave him minimal otherworldly harmony (Stephenson & Berry, 2015). He kept saying that faith is a blessing and not given to the individuals who implore, quickly or go to administrations more. This realized the single side to religion, accentuating the person's association with God, and not religious conventions. Furthermore, Luther disdained the clearance of guilty pleasures since he accepted there was no real way to pay for the pardoning of sins. This conviction formally started the Reformation with the posting of his 95 Theses. His proposals were initially imprinted in Latin; however then meant German, enabling most of the individuals to peruse and get them (Zinnbauer & Pargament, 2015). The way that they were imprinted in the vernacular made Luther's conviction across the board as he picked up an incredible gathering of devotees; something that would have been unimaginable in earlier hundreds of years. With this came a massive change in how individuals saw religion yet additionally caused religious pressure in numerous nations. Martin Luther caused commotion on philosophical terms as well as on issues of "riches, influence and fundamental structure" (Flannelly, Weaver & Costa, 2014). Protestant idea likewise joined adherents by expressing that a congregation ought to be an "otherworldly brotherhood of devotees" (Oman, 2018). This changed the mindset of religious organizations, making them all the more neighborly and joined rather than one individual lecturing an expansive gathering of individuals. Martin Luther's beliefs drastically influenced how individuals saw religion and what they ought to accept. It started the individual voyage one has with faith rather than solid masses of individuals compelled to tune in to similar messages every week. With the official acknowledgment of Lutheranism in 1555, nations were permitted to pick among Catholicism and Lutheranism, a noteworthy advance in the adventure to autonomous faith and other spirituality. What I have realized through the investigation of religion in
  • 24. history is how unimaginably fortunate we are present to face a daily reality such that we are each permitted to have our own thoughts of faith and other spirituality. While Luther and Erasmus were uncommon in their time, these days' individuals generally can trust whatever they pick. I particularly appreciate the independence of faith since I don't trust it is satisfactory for anybody to advise someone else what to put stock in (Johnstone et al., 2015). Spirituality is something unimaginably close to home and in this way should be an individual adventure for each individual. Experiencing childhood in an interfaith family, I could watch two unique belief systems. I trust this has affected my perspectives on religion since I comprehend that one's religious convictions just straightforwardly have an effect on them self. Watching my folks join both Catholic and Jewish customs into our family demonstrated to me the outrageous estimation of assorted variety, something I have always appreciated. Actually, my faith can be ascribed to my seven summers spent at the Jewish summer camp where I was permitted to investigate my religion through workmanship, music and network petition (Johnstone et al., 2015). These seven summers reinforced my own faith yet additionally enable me to acknowledge a decent variety of assorted types. In this way, I feel fortunate to have the capacity to pick my very own profound way, dissimilar to those in the High Middle Ages or amid the Reformation when it was the choice of the lord. While religion and faith will result in all probability dependably motivation banter, I figure we can think back on history and recognize what amount has changed over the most recent 1000 years, and be appreciative for it.
  • 25. References Flannelly, K. J., Weaver, A. J., & Costa, K. G. (2014). A systematic review of religion and spirituality in three palliative care journals, 1990–1999. Journal of Palliative Care, 20(1), 50- 56. Johnstone, B., Yoon, D. P., Cohen, D., Schopp, L. H., McCormack, G., Campbell, J., & Smith, M. (2015). Relationships among spirituality, religious practices, personality factors, and health for five different faith traditions. Journal of religion and health, 51(4), 1017-1041. Kadar, J. L., Scott, A. B., Hipp, K., Belavich, T. G., Butter, E. M., Rye, M. S., ... & Zinnbauer, B. J. (2015). Religion and spirituality: Unfuzzying the fuzzy. In Sociology of Religion (pp. 29-34). Routledge. McKay, M., & Wood, J. C. (2019). The New Happiness: Practices for Spiritual Growth and Living with Intention. New Harbinger Publications. Oman, D. (2018). Defining religion and spirituality. Handbook of the psychology of religion and spirituality, 2, 23-47. Stephenson, P. S., & Berry, D. M. (2015). Describing spirituality at the end of life. Western Journal of Nursing Research, 37(9), 1229-1247. Zinnbauer, B. J., & Pargament, K. I. (2015). Religiousness and spirituality. Handbook of the psychology of religion and spirituality, 21-42. Running head: CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 1
  • 26. Gender and Sexual Identity Development [Student Name] National Louis University HED 632 Dr. Dustin Heuerman SAMPLE COURSE CAPSTONE EXAMPLE This document is not meant to serve as a perfect assignment submission, but as a good example of how your paper should look when submitted. CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 2 Gender and Sexual Identity Development Gender and sexual identity development is one area that higher education leaders must familiarize themselves with as they strive to create safe and welcoming environments for a diverse population of students. As students come to terms with various aspects of their development, gender and sexual identity theories provide insight into the stages that students
  • 27. navigate as they determine their objectives and abilities (Torres, Jones & Renn, 2009). Moreover, identity development can be influenced by how students interact within their environments. Therefore, research surrounding gender and sexual identity development is important to helping facilitate identity development in other areas (Konik & Stewart, 2004) and in assisting higher education leaders with creating optimal environments for students. Theoretical Significance Students may experience feelings and behaviors that cause internal conflicts or challenges to healthy identity development. This may be especially true when religious and sexual identities converge. Bayne (2016) proposed possible interventions or techniques that can help students progress from early stages of minority sexual identity to later stages of acceptance and integration. Likewise, other research has revealed the Cass’ Model of Sexual Identity Development can help us understand how students move from Stage One of Identity Confusion to Stage Six of Identity Synthesis whereby individuals come to
  • 28. integrate their sexual identity into their overall identity (Degges-White & Myers, 2000). This is crucial to ensuring higher education groundbreakers seek to implement programs and services that are designed to reach students where they are and to serve the “whole person.” In addition to studying gender and sexual identity theories, Gragg (2012) encourages those working with sexually minority youth to address their own biases, but not to allow a lack CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 3 of expertise in gender and sexual identity prevent effective work with individuals. By examining and reviewing gender and sexual identity theories, we can address problems and behaviors that may occur as students move to normalize their experiences and confront impending difficulties (Cramer, 1980). Graham & et al (2011) adds that men who develop healthy sexual identity are less likely to experience mental distress while other researchers note the complexity of gender and sexual identity development impacts psychological
  • 29. adjustment and self-esteem (Rosario, Schrimshaw & Hunter, 2011). More support is given to the link between psychological adjustment and self-distress and sexual identity development in the study conducted by Shepler & Perrone-McGovern, 2016 of 791 college students. There are implications to suggest that one’s sexual identity status or stage of development impacts his or her psychological well-being. Furthermore, researchers have shown a link between the depression and black men who are isolated in their sexual identity (Graham & et al, 2011). By studying sexual identity formation, we can prepare to assist students and begin to explore avenues that help them develop healthy sexual identities. This includes implementing programs and services that promote positive self- esteem and identity acceptance. Models of Gender and Sexual Identity Development There are several models of Gender and Sexual Identity Development that may help to inform and influence the understanding of this important identity formation. Morgan (2012)
  • 30. sought to classify student’s sexual formation using Worthington’s heterosexual identity development to gather student narratives and found recognizing heterosexual identity to be more challenging. Historically, sexual identity theories have viewed the foundation of sexual identity as moving in a linear formation. Cass’s (1979) six-stage process of sexual identity integration has been the model for subsequent theories which describe sexual identity development as CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 4 occurring in chronological stages (Degges-White & Myers, 2000). Likewise, Fassinger’s Model of Gay and Lesbian Identity (1996) describes the identity process as beginning with Awareness, moving through Exploration and Deepening/Commitment to the final stage of Internalization/Synthesis (Gervacio, 2012). Nevertheless, more recent research has indicated sexual identity formation does not necessarily follow a linear or stable process (Morgan, 2012 & Rosario, Schrimshaw & Hunter, 2011); rather, individuals experience various stages at any given
  • 31. time. It is imperative that student affairs professionals take from sexual identity theories what is necessary to create more inclusive environments for students. Gaps in the Literature The current literature does not cover all the bases needed to adequately explain gender and sexual identity formation. There is a growing sentiment related to the fluidity of gender and sexual identity; that it overflows the rigid categories of heterosexuality, homosexuality and bisexuality (Carr, 2009). While the notion of fluid sexuality is nothing new and earlier research mentions the complexity surrounding gender and sexual identities (Pryce, 2006), the research is at its infancy stage. However, current research has proposed that a gender revolution is underway. Moreover, gender and sexual identity should not be viewed synonymously or with the same meaning. Changing societal norms see gender as falling on a spectrum and not limited to binary assignments of male and female (Parrenas, 2017). Therefore, there is a need for a more in depth exploration of the fluidity of gender and sexuality as it
  • 32. relates to the process of one’s unique identity development in the 21st century. Multiplicity in Identity Development Evans (2009) reminds us that the conceptual model of multiple dimensions of identity was developed by earlier theorists and that the core of self or one’s personal identity includes CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 5 personal attributes and other important factors. Besides, gender, sexual orientation, race, social class, family, education and culture are viewed as intersecting circles surrounding the core identity. Within gender and sexual identity developments lies a multitude of intersecting circles that presents the gap in the research. An increasing number of young people are embracing the idea that gender and sexuality transcends the traditional binaries of male and female, gay or straight (Steinmetz,2017). This is in stark contrast to the identity theories that seem to combine sex and gender and use the terms interchangeably, inferring these identity formations are one in
  • 33. the same and occur in a linear and stage-like fashion (Gevacio, 2012). There is a Gender Revolution There is a movement pushing forward the need to “update” the concept of gender and to acknowledge its deeply social and psychological attributes and influences (Gender Identity, 2016). This view that gender identity is not automatically binary, but is fluid and separate from sexual orientation or biology (Parrenas, 2017 & Gender Identity, 2016) is obvious with popular culture. As evident by the 2014 Facebook move to allow users to select from 56 ways to describe their gender. Some of these include: agender, cis- and trans- variants, gender fluid, pangender and two-spirit (Gender Identity, 2017). In addition, New York passed a law making it illegal to discriminate against any of the 31 gender identities and gender expressions outlined by the New York Commission on Human Rights (Gender Identity Expression, 2015). The gender and sexual identity development are both public and private entities requiring
  • 34. deeper understanding for Student Affairs professionals to create environments of inclusiveness. There is a need to stay current with the terminology, as the world is rapidly changing; gender is no longer contained by the binaries of male and female. The popular adage is that sex is what is between your legs and gender is what is between your ears (Gevisser, 2015). Moreover, sexual CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 6 orientation is who we have sex with and gender is our deeply held sense of being male, female or something else entirely. The broader spectrum of gender and sexual identity development can help students and those working with them reduce gender confusion and identity struggle by helping to validate feelings and experiences. The genderqueer movement is growing and some colleges have students introduce themselves by their preferred pronouns (he/his, she/her/hers, they/them) and some identity as pansexual rather than gay or straight (Gevisser, 2015). The growing response that gender and sexual fluidity transcends the rigid categories of
  • 35. heterosexuality, homosexuality and bisexuality (Parrenas, 2017) gives rise to the need for more research. The complexity surrounding sexual and gender identity indicates that we are in a gender and sexual identity revolution that may warrant the development of additional theories to explore this developmental process (Gevisser, 2015). Changing societal norms see gender as falling on a spectrum and not limited to binary assignments of male and female (Parrenas, 2017). Rogers’ Theory of Gender and Sexual Identity builds upon previous theories and supports the complexity of sexual fluidity in individual development. Rogers’ Theory of Gender and Sexual Identity Like Evans’ model, Rogers’ Theory is a series of junctions of progress whereby individuals move fluidly as they grow to understand themselves in relation to their external environments. Rogers’ identity development is not seen as always linear or sequential in nature (Morgan, 2012). There are four stages that are included within this working theory. Stage 1-Pre-Socialization of Gender and Sexual Identity
  • 36. In the Pre-Socialization stage, the individual is unaware or not influenced by the larger society or parental expectations of gender or sexual identity roles. This can show up in children, who are not aware of sexuality and gender and/or whose parents do not subscribe to colors, CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 7 clothes, toys or activities traditionally assigned to male or female. In addition, adolescents and adults may be unmoved by social pressures to conform to what is expected in terms of gender or sexuality. In this stage, the individual may exhibit fluidity, but may experience conflict or crisis when external expectations are imposed upon the individual (Gender Identity, 2016). Stage 2- Social Identity Conflict In this stage of Rogers’ Theory, the individual is aware of and concerned about mainstream social expectations of gender and sexual identity. This causes personal conflict as the individual’s feelings, thoughts or identity contradict roles. The individual may be influenced by
  • 37. parental, peer, employer or society’s expectations and struggle with finding or expressing their own voice. In this stage, the individual may hide sexual identity or conform according to what he or she deems acceptable. Although, the view may be gender identity is not automatically binary, but is fluid (Parrenas, 2017), the individual seeks conformity to lessen outward conflict with popular culture. Stage 3- Sexuality and Gender Acceptance In Stage 3 of this theory, individuals have developed acceptance for their own gender or sexual identity. The individual may have found a healthy and supportive peer group and parental encouragement as well as a significant relationship that is affirming. Individuals in this stage are less likely to experience conflict between themselves and society. They are not prone to conform to gender expectations and are in the evolving pride and confidence part of the development. The gender and sexual identity formation are both public and private entities that are seamlessly integrated into the person’s overall development.
  • 38. Stage 4-Pride and Confidence CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 8 Persons who are operating from this position of their gender and sexual identity development are fully aware of who they are and do not waver in expressing their preferences, identity or gender. Persons have a strong sense of self and understand the potential for social conflict as it pertains to gender roles and sexual identity, but do not feel the need to conform. Individuals understand the need and are driven to stay current with the terminology. At Stage 4, the individual is aware of the gender movement within the rapidly changing world. Persons may view gender as no longer contained by the binaries of male and female and subscribe to the notion that “sex is what is between your legs and gender is what is between your ears (Gevisser, 2015).” It is important to reiterate that this is a working theory in need of further development.
  • 39. Moreover, it is not to viewed as linear or occurring in sequence for individuals may have various facets of any stage at periods during their development. Resources in Higher Education Helping students develop to their full potential includes supporting them as they question and change their sexual identities. Student affairs leaders must concern themselves with keeping up with the trends, terminology and theories related sexual identity formation as they strive to create environments conducive to healthy and positive student development Tennessee State University and DePaul University are examples of two institutions offering programs to support gender and sexual development on college campuses. Tennessee State University and DePaul University are two distinctly different institutions of higher education which provide resources and support for students of the sexual minority communities. Tennessee State University (TSU) is a public, land-grant (1890), HBCU (Historically Black College & University) located in Nashville, Tennessee founded in 1912. TSU has an
  • 40. CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 9 enrollment of over 7,000 undergraduate, 1,900 graduate students who can choose from 47 Bachelor, 24 Masters and 8 Doctoral degrees (TSU, 2017). DePaul University is a private, catholic institution located in Chicago, Illinois. The university was founded in 1898 and has at the heart of its mission, research, teaching and community service. Its enrollment is 15,407 undergraduate, 7,703 graduate and has been named as one of the nation’s Best Value Colleges by Forbes (DePaul, 2017). What do they do well? TSU offers support for the LGBTQ campus community by providing training, policies, programs and education through the Office of Equity and Inclusion. In 2013-2014, the Office of Equity and Inclusion collaborated with The Human Rights Campaign to provide an LGBTQ film screening of, The New Black documentary on the campus (TN State Newsroom, 2014). The
  • 41. documentary tells the story of how the African-American community grappled with the gay rights and the recent same-sex marriage movement. In addition, the college celebrates LGBTQ week in October with a series of activities, Safe Zone Training, panel discussions and free HIV/AIDS testing (LGBTQ at TSU, 2014). The university promotes a supportive environment for students to build connections and positive networks that will help them be successful students. The campus puts forth policy and communicates that they will not tolerate any harassment, ill treatment or discrimination of any student or persons seeking to benefit from the campus resources. Moreover, the campus communicates the importance of associations for LGBTQ students and provides a space on campus for students to commune and share or express themselves in a reassuring environment. Tennessee State University provides a system of helpful allies for the lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and queer/questioning community. There is a published list of these
  • 42. CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 10 campus professionals provided on the website (Safe Zone Allyship, 2017). These individuals have completed the half day Safe Zone training and display the symbol in their work or living space to denote they are a registered or official Ally. An ally has been educated about the concerns and issues of the LGBTQ people and know about the resources available to support them (LGBTQ at TSU, 2014). DePaul University in Chicago, Illinois is the first Catholic University to establish an LGBTQ Studies program. Starting in 2005, the minor in LGBTQ Studies allows students to analyze sex and sexuality within an interdisciplinary inquiry and examines the experiences of people who identify as a part of a sexually minority group (DePaul, 2017). This private Catholic university has integrated LGBTQA services and programs into the overall student experience at DePaul. The campus has a strong history of providing support and services to students in the LGBTQA community beginning in 1982 when Society of the
  • 43. Individual was established to become the first gay student organization. In addition, the university hired its first full-time LGBTQA Student Services Coordinator for its LGBTQA Student Services department (DePaul, 2017). There are ongoing campus discussions, activities and programs that seek to provide support, services and connections for students. There is also a Faculty and Staff LGBTQA organization and an annual Stonewall Awards which recognizes members of DePaul’s LGBTQA communities who are promoting an accepting and affirming climate on the campus. What do they do poorly? Overall, both institutions do an excellent job of promoting acceptance and support for members of the LGBTQA communities on their campuses. However, Tennessee State University needs to update the links and information on the website. Much of the information and programs are dated from 2014. DePaul seems to have ongoing updated information and is active on Twitter,
  • 44. CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 11 Facebook and community sites. This is likely due to having had over 25 years of a commitment to the LGBTQA communities. Both institutions could do a better job of advertising available training and resources available to the public and surrounding community. Rogers’ Theory of Sexual Identity Development is comprised of four stages: 1) Pre- socialization- the individual is unaware of the larger society or social expectations of gender roles; 2) Social Identity Conflict/Personal Awareness- Individual becomes aware that internal feelings or gender may conflict with parental and social expectations, may struggle with role- playing; 3) Social Acceptance- Individual begins the quest to find support among peers and others who identify with sexual minority group; 4) Pride/Confidence- Individual challenges gender roles and traditional assignments of gender expectations; individual accepts and integrates his gender and sexuality into who he is as an individual. Through their programs and services, Tennessee State
  • 45. University and DePaul University ensures a supportive and accepting environment regardless of where a student falls on the continuum of gender and sexual identity development. Whether a student is coming out, questioning or boldly displaying their sexuality pride, each institution provides a space on the campus for students to connect and explore who they are without discrimination or harassment. Implications for Best Practices in Higher Education Colleges and universities must present climates where LGBTQ students feel safe, supported and affirmed as students and persons in varying stages of gender and sexual identity development. Institutions of higher learning are not only places of learning, but are also miniature societies (Teaching Tolerance, 2017). Moreover, it is not only about the special treatment afforded to LGBTQ students, but also it is how colleges and universities teach acceptance and understanding for all people. This means that those outside of the LGBTQ
  • 46. CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 12 community need to be taught awareness, tolerance and respect for all fellow students, regardless of their gender identity and sexual orientation. This is imperative given the recent Human Rights Campaign survey that revealed LGBT students report being verbally and physically harassed at school (Teaching Tolerance, 2017), which means LGBTQ students are likely to have negative educational experiences. Creating supportive environments have shown to improve educational outcomes for all students when campus resources are reflective of safety, support and openness. Schools are improving resources and services to the LGBTQ study body they offer more programs and co-curricular activities to help create safe and welcoming campuses (Kratsas, 2017). The Campus Pride Index is a tool that assists colleges and universities to learn ways to improve their LGBTQ campus life and to ultimately shape the educational experience to be more inclusive, welcoming and respectful of all gender and sexual identities as well as Ally people (Campus Pride Index, 2017). The Campus Pride Index acts as a
  • 47. measure of LGBTQ policies, programs and practices and includes 50+ self-assessment questions, which correspond to eight different LGBTQ-friendly factors. These eight factors are: • LGBTQ Policy Inclusion • LGBTQ Support & Institutional Commitment • LGBTQ Academic Life • LGBTQ Student Life • LGBTQ Housing • LGBTQ Campus Safety • LGBTQ Counseling & Health • LGBTQ Recruitment & Retention Efforts CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 13 The Campus Pride Index sends campus officials a confidential report of the index tool along with recommendations for improvement and an LGBTQ- friendly rating through a 5-star scoring system (Campus Pride Index, 2016). Finally, Campus Pride lists the top 30 LGBTQ-
  • 48. friendly colleges and universities on its website for potential students, families and employees to review. Awareness. Any program or service starts with awareness. Educators and higher education professionals can support LGBTQ students by implementing some best practices for creating climates or environments in which students feel safe and affirmed. Some of these include the following: • Gay-Straight Alliance Clubs (this is a way to educate students about diversity and can offer support). • Encourage and reward campus officials to form Ally organizations. (Allies are trained persons who have agreed to actively support and publically acknowledge they are safe and offer welcoming environments). • Make sure dress codes are enforced equally among all students. • Empower students to express themselves, and • Use gender-inclusive language at all event communications, including
  • 49. forms and applications (options for preferred pronouns). • Provide an LGBTQ glossary of terms to all students, faculty and staff. Policy. Colleges and universities can update and implement Anti-Bullying Policies and codes of conduct to communicate public statement of safety for students. The policies should make clear that all students are protected and explicit safeguarding measures are in place for LGTBQ students. The Consortium of Higher Education LGBT Resource Professionals advise in CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 14 their Suggested Best Practices for Asking Sexual Orientation and Gender on College Applications, that because of the growing numbers of students identifying as non-binary, applications should include “genderqueer” and “agender” choices. Some other policy suggestions are: • Gender-Inclusive Housing, • Transition-Related Medical Expenses,
  • 50. • LGTBQ Identity Questions as an Option on Admission Application and Enrollment Forms (Because gender and sexuality are fluid, students should have the option to change gender and sexual identity on campus records during their academic career). • Trans-Inclusive Admission Policy, and • Policies that Include Gender Identity/Expression. Training. Institutions can offer annual training for the entire campus community from students, staff, faculty to administrators. It should be communicated that all have a role in promoting an inclusive campus environment that is welcoming to all students. Campus Resources. It is important that LGBTQ resources support students who are experiencing varying levels of gender and sexual identity development. Counselors who are trained and equipped to support students experiencing anxiety, depression and increased thoughts of suicide should be a part of the campus. Several resources are:
  • 51. • Support groups, • Counseling Services, • HIV/AIDS Testing, • Gender Neutral Rest Rooms, CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 15 • Supportive housing/residence life, and • Referrals to community partners (housing, food, medical, etc.). Finally, it is important that higher education professionals and universities and colleges put forth best practices and services that will ensure supportive and welcoming environments for students in the LGBTQ community. Through inclusive policies and procedures, a climate of openness can help students reach their optimal potential during their higher education experience.
  • 52. CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 16 References (2016). In Campus Pride. Retrieved June 5, 2017, from https://www.campuspride.org/campuspride2016top30/ (2016). In Consortium of Higher Education. Retrieved June 5, 2017, from www.lgbtcampus.org Bayne, H.B. (2016). Helping gay and lesbian students integrate sexual and religious identities. Journal of College Counseling, 19(1), 61-75. doi:10.1002/jock.12031Cover, R. (2011). Queer youth suicide, culture and identity: Unlivable Lives?. Burlington, VT: Routledge Cramer, P. (1980). The development of sexual identity. Journal of Personality Assessment, 44(6), 604. Degges-White, S., Rice, B., & Myers, J.E. (2000). Revisiting Cass’ theory of sexual identity formation: A study of lesbian development. Journal of Mental
  • 53. Health Counseling, 22(4), 318. DePaul University (2017). Key facts & rankings. Accessed from https://www.depaul.edu/about/Pages/rankings.aspx DePaul University (2017). LGTBQ studies. Accessed from https://las.depaul.edu/academics/lgbtq- studies/about/Pages/default.aspx Dentato, M. P., Craig, S. L., Messinger, L., Lloyd, M., & McInroy, L. B. (2014). Outness among LGBTQ social work students in North America: The contribution of environmental supports and perceptions of comfort. Social Work Education, 33(4), 485-501. doi:10.1080/02615479.2013.855193 Gender Identity. (2016). New Atlantis: A journal of Technology & Society, (50), 86-113. CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 17 Gender Identity Expression. (2015). New York Commission on Human Rights. Accessed from https://www1.nyc.gov/assets/cchr/downloads/pdf/publications/G
  • 54. enderID_Card2015.pdf Gervacio, J. (2012). A comparative review of Cass’s and Fassinger’s sexual orientation identity development models, e Vermont Connection: 33(7). Available at: http://scholarworks.uvm.edu/tvc/vol33/iss1/7 Graham, L.F., Aronson, R.E., Nichols, T., Stephens, C.F., & Rhodes, S.D. (2011). Factors influencing depression and anxiety among Black sexual minority men. Depression Research & Treatment, 1-9. Doi:10.1155/2011/587984 Gragg, R.A. (2012). Working with sexual minority youth: Coming out. Brown University Child & Adolescent Behavior Letter, 28(10), 1-6. Evans, N.J., Forney, D.S., Guido, F.M., Patton, L., Renn, K. (2009). Student development In college: Theory, research, and practice (2nd ed.). San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass. Katz-Wise, S.L. (2015). Sexual fluidity in young adult women and men: associations with sexual orientation and sexual identity development. Psychology & Sexuality, 6(2), 189-208. doi:10.1080/19419899.2013.876445
  • 55. Kratsas, G. (2017). 50 great LGBTQ-friendly colleges. Retrieved at www.greatvaluecolleges.net/50-great-lgbtq-friendly-colleges/ Konik, J., & Stewart, A. (2004). Sexual identity development in the context of compulsory heterosexuality. Journal of Personality, 72(4), 815-844. doi:10.1111/j.0022- 3506.2004.00281.x LGBTQ at TSU (2014). Supporting the LGBTQ campus community. Accessed from http://www.tnstate.edu/eeoaa/tsusafezone.aspx Morgan, E.M. (2012). Not always a straight path: College student’s narratives of heterosexual CAPSTONE FINAL PROJECT 18 Identity development. Sex Roles, 66, 79-93. Office of Equity & Inclusion (2017). TSU safe zone ally listing. Accessed from http://www.tnstate.edu/eeoaa/szallies.aspx Parrenas, J. (2017). Twenty-first century gender: Welcome to the gender revolution!
  • 56. Lesbian News, 42(10), 66-67. Pryce, A. (2006). Let’s talk about sexual behavior in the human male: Kinsey and the invention Of (post) modern sexualities. Sexuality & Culture, 10(1), 63-93 Rosario, M., Schrimshaw, E.W., & Hunter, J. (2011). Different patterns of sexual identity development over time: Implications for the psychological adjustment of lesbian, gay, and bisexual youths. Journal of Sex Research, 48(1), 3-15. doi:10.1080/0022449090333106 Shepler, D., & Perrone-McGovern, K. (2016). Differences in psychological distress and esteem based on sexual identity development. College Student Journal, 50(4), 579-589. Steinmetz, K. (2017). Infinite identities. (Cover story). Time, 189(11). 48-54. Teaching Tolerance. (2017). A project of the southern poverty law center. Retrieved from www.tolerance.org/category/classroom-resources/sexual- orientation Torres, v., Jones, S.R., & Renn, K.A., (2009). Identity development theories in student affairs: Origins, status, and new approaches. Journal of College Student Development, 50(6),
  • 57. 577-596. Module 9: Capstone Final Paper How can you use the concepts identified in this assignment, and the class as a whole, to successfully support student development in college? As you consider ways to support college student development, discuss those in the context of an area of higher education where you currently work or where you wish to work, ADVISING, How does your chosen area of higher education fit into the bigger picture of student development as a whole? Incorporate this final component into a well synthesized final paper including the other four components you have worked on during this course. Final Paper Requirements:15 – 20 pages in length, double spaced (not including the cover page or reference page); · Incorporate a minimum of ten scholarly references;