SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Peering/Interconnection
Response
Licensed Telecommunication Carriers
under the Telecommunications Act which:
● National backbone connecting all five key 5 capital cities with clear channel protected 100G capacity to each; and
● Backbone must be connected to at least two (2) diverse IP PoP’s in each capital city. Each PoP in each city must be
interconnected with at least 40G protected with upgrade path to 100G; and
● Offer commercial wholesale IP transit services to other carriers, retail service providers and content providers; and
● Have at least 100G aggregated clear international capacity which provides diversity between Australia, the United
States and Asia; and
● Operate DDoS protection outside Australia at the major international IP gateways prior to connecting to
international capacity toward Australia; and
● Have relevant approvals for data interception and data retention from the Attorney General’s department; and
● 24/7 NOC based in Australia and be a CERT Australia partner;
Nationally Significant Network
2
Contents Item01Are deemed to be Nationally Significant Networks and allowed to require other NSNs to
provide internet interconnections between networks. Incumbents Telstra, Optus and AAPT/TPG along with
other nationally significant networks Superloop, Vocus and Vodafone would/could qualify.
Current framework has left Australia with some of the
highest IP/transit domestic pricing in the world
(USA $0.20, HK $1.10, SG $1.50 per mbps per month
compared to Australia at $5.00 representing a 400% to
2500% increase in cost for Australian network
operators)
Domestic intecap transmission is around $0.30 per
Mbps per protected 10G yet IP transit is ~$5.
Due to lack of competition Gang of Four (GoF)
domestic transit pricing almost mirrors
international capacity pricing and with international
pricing expected to drop soon domestic peering/transit
will have a dampening impact
Current arrangement often means that global carriers
and content providers are “third line forced” into
purchasing other services from the GoF providers to
access their “eyeball” networks at a reasonable price
It’s an open policy available to any network that meets
the deemed peering criteria (ie. nationally significant)
Why this is important - Competition
GoF members get two (2) bites of the cherry as their
consumers get charged internet access fees, yet also
charge carriers and content providers to get access to
their networks and get free ride on the originating
network (often despite carrying the data to Australia at
no charge to the GoF member)
Australia to date has unfortunately missed a great
opportunity to be an internet hub for Asia (Singapore
and Hong Kong) however with the latest round of
submarine cables about to land in Australia there is an
opportunity for Australia to be competitive both
domestically and internationally
Encourages investment in telecommunications
infrastructure both domestically and internationally
which is made on the basis of servicing wholesale
customers (RSP’s) and retail customers (corporate and
residential)
Having a broadly non-descriminatory policy (no-named
basis) allows fluidity in the market and new entrants
to become a Nationally Significant Network
SD Wan is one of the fastest growing market
segments in the world and is a technology stack
that overlays Software Defined Networking (SDN)
on different networks to deliver a ubiquitous and
secure network connection.
The existing GoF will have both commercial and
technical advantage over all other network
providers in Australia as carriers and SD-WAN
providers looking to deployed SD-WAN will at
some level be required to and pay for
interconnects with the GoF to deliver reliable and
lower latency connectivity.
Currently Telstra and Optus for example will
essentially be paid to interconnect to other
networks including other NSNs as full transit rate
and be placed at a significant commercial
advantage to others.
Why is this important? Unintentional SD-WAN Tax
SD Wan is one of the fastest growing market segments in the world and is a technology stack that overlays
Software Defined Networking (SDN) on different networks to deliver a ubiquitous and secure network
connection.
Yet ACCC think it’s OK?
No action required?
Only peer is Mumbai?
Market is efficient?
Really?
Australia Transit Pricing is Uncompetitive
Broad variance among cities..
Weighted Media 10 GigE IP Transit Prices in Selected Cities, Q4 2017
Source: Telegeography.com
Why this is important - National Security
● Networks with which the national IP backbone sits upon must be able to withstand
certain levels of attack from internal and external parties
● Ideally these protective mechanisms should happen at the international borders *before*
coming to Australia leaving Australia’s international connectivity “protected”
● Interconnection between NSN’s should happen with ports/interconnects that have
scale to avoid congestion during burst events and be offloaded as locally as possible,
as fast as possible, hence interconnection should ideally be at 100G and in each of the
five major states/capital city. This fundamentally improves resiliency during attacks
where 10G ports could become congested
● Being a licensed and commercial carrier provides obligations on the provider
● Being an NSN provides the benchmark and certainty for security agencies and the
Attorney General’s Department that providers are appropriately resourced and regulated
to comply with various obligations
● More NSN’s that meet this benchmark the greater the resiliency of the nations
telecommunications infrastructure and the greater emphasis and optionality on
service
● Without a fully competitive interconnection environment pushing pricing lower
compared to peer countries within our region less content will be stored, processed
and transmitted in Australia
Initiator Pays:
● Initiator Pays for establishment
● Either settlement free (SKA) or settlement basis
● Settlement basis ‘net’ average gigabit
● 10/40/100G interconnections only
● Commitment to not over-subscribe ports
● Peering in all five markets with interconnection
locations to be made available at either
Responders PoP locations or major neutral data
centers at the Initiators discretion
Interconnection Commercial Settlement
(assuming no SKA)
7
Port Speed Install/Upgrade OTC MRC Interconnection Matrix
10 30 days 500 500 $500/net average
gigabit per month
40/100 60 days 5000 1000 $300/net average
gigabit per month
Appendix: Security is Important to be a
Nationally Significant Network

More Related Content

PPTX
Slattery COMMSDAY prediction superdeck 2015-2018
PPTX
Future Thinking of Cloud and Connectivity - Commsday 2016
PPT
Examine the economics of rolling out LTE
PPTX
Fundamentals of Mobile Network Sharing
PPTX
Sckipio road to 2025 key quotes
PDF
ISP status in Bangladesh 2016
PPT
Benoit Felten
PDF
Small Cell Industry Insight & Experience Sharing
Slattery COMMSDAY prediction superdeck 2015-2018
Future Thinking of Cloud and Connectivity - Commsday 2016
Examine the economics of rolling out LTE
Fundamentals of Mobile Network Sharing
Sckipio road to 2025 key quotes
ISP status in Bangladesh 2016
Benoit Felten
Small Cell Industry Insight & Experience Sharing

What's hot (20)

PDF
DWS16 - Future networks forum - Ranulf Scarbrough, BT Superfast
PDF
Huawei - Making the World Smaller with Small Cell
PDF
DWS16 - Future networks forum - Gabrielle Gauthey, Groupe Caisse des dépots
PDF
The future of spectrum pricing, May 2017
PDF
Commonwealth Digital Broadcasting Siwtchover FOrum 2015 Regis Le Roux
PPTX
Beyond LTE Launch
PDF
NetIX - Moving Traffic to the Expressway Jan 2016
PPT
5G and FTTH: The Value of Convergence
PDF
The Data Tsunami - Spectrum Allocation, Infrastructure Sharing and Industry C...
PDF
Spectrum pricing in India 18 July 2019
PPTX
Small cell networks why & when to care!
PPTX
Mike Locke - Satellite Internet
PPT
O3b Networks Company Info
PDF
The future of spectrum pricing S Zehle Coleago 24 jan 17 sz
PPTX
Edinburgh seminar 31/5/2018 Ian Corden Plum Consulting
PDF
O3b Networks presentation
PDF
Spectrum auction failure and how to avoid it v001 030319 sz
PDF
Vehicular CrowdCell. Bringing CrowdCell Technology into Vehicles
PPTX
Javier Lecanda - Colt SDN/NFV Experience inca 201706
PDF
Spectrum pricing, make or break the 5 g momentum, June 2019
DWS16 - Future networks forum - Ranulf Scarbrough, BT Superfast
Huawei - Making the World Smaller with Small Cell
DWS16 - Future networks forum - Gabrielle Gauthey, Groupe Caisse des dépots
The future of spectrum pricing, May 2017
Commonwealth Digital Broadcasting Siwtchover FOrum 2015 Regis Le Roux
Beyond LTE Launch
NetIX - Moving Traffic to the Expressway Jan 2016
5G and FTTH: The Value of Convergence
The Data Tsunami - Spectrum Allocation, Infrastructure Sharing and Industry C...
Spectrum pricing in India 18 July 2019
Small cell networks why & when to care!
Mike Locke - Satellite Internet
O3b Networks Company Info
The future of spectrum pricing S Zehle Coleago 24 jan 17 sz
Edinburgh seminar 31/5/2018 Ian Corden Plum Consulting
O3b Networks presentation
Spectrum auction failure and how to avoid it v001 030319 sz
Vehicular CrowdCell. Bringing CrowdCell Technology into Vehicles
Javier Lecanda - Colt SDN/NFV Experience inca 201706
Spectrum pricing, make or break the 5 g momentum, June 2019
Ad

Similar to Superloop's accc internet interconnection (20)

DOCX
national broadband network
PDF
Commerce Commission NZ - High speed broadband technical issues paper - 19 dec...
PDF
Why pon ftt h & fttb are so important for players and what is the end game
PDF
NBN Impact on Industries in Australia
PPTX
PacNOG 24: Keeping local traffic local by doing local peering
PDF
Dr Nguyen Duc_Bridging Govt NBN Policy to End-Users_Melbourne_26-June-2012
PDF
BGP Services IP Transit vs IP Peering
PPTX
KINX Peering Forum - A Brief Overview of Regulation of Interconnection
PPTX
National information infrastrcuture_Rrecommendations to Deptt of Electronics ...
PDF
Gaurab Ixp Tutorial
PPT
Mr. Paul Budde's presentation at QITCOM 2011
PDF
PacNOG 31: Internet Exchange Points
PDF
PITA 27th AGM & Business Forum Expo 23: Internet Exchange Points
PDF
PacNOG 25: Keeping local traffic local by doing local peering
PPT
NTT America Gin (Global Ip Network) Overview
PDF
PCTA 2018: ASNs - why is it important to cable broadband providers?
PDF
Telstra Programmable Networks & Scaling a Serverless Team with Automation
PPT
ATIC Summit - Community Broadband Workshop 11/13/12
PPTX
Sébastien Bachollet
PDF
Internet Exchange Points, presented at Peering Workshop at the PITA 29th AGM,...
national broadband network
Commerce Commission NZ - High speed broadband technical issues paper - 19 dec...
Why pon ftt h & fttb are so important for players and what is the end game
NBN Impact on Industries in Australia
PacNOG 24: Keeping local traffic local by doing local peering
Dr Nguyen Duc_Bridging Govt NBN Policy to End-Users_Melbourne_26-June-2012
BGP Services IP Transit vs IP Peering
KINX Peering Forum - A Brief Overview of Regulation of Interconnection
National information infrastrcuture_Rrecommendations to Deptt of Electronics ...
Gaurab Ixp Tutorial
Mr. Paul Budde's presentation at QITCOM 2011
PacNOG 31: Internet Exchange Points
PITA 27th AGM & Business Forum Expo 23: Internet Exchange Points
PacNOG 25: Keeping local traffic local by doing local peering
NTT America Gin (Global Ip Network) Overview
PCTA 2018: ASNs - why is it important to cable broadband providers?
Telstra Programmable Networks & Scaling a Serverless Team with Automation
ATIC Summit - Community Broadband Workshop 11/13/12
Sébastien Bachollet
Internet Exchange Points, presented at Peering Workshop at the PITA 29th AGM,...
Ad

Recently uploaded (20)

PPTX
Job_Card_System_Styled_lorem_ipsum_.pptx
PPTX
Digital Literacy And Online Safety on internet
PDF
SASE Traffic Flow - ZTNA Connector-1.pdf
PPTX
E -tech empowerment technologies PowerPoint
PDF
Vigrab.top – Online Tool for Downloading and Converting Social Media Videos a...
PDF
WebRTC in SignalWire - troubleshooting media negotiation
PPTX
Internet___Basics___Styled_ presentation
PPTX
Power Point - Lesson 3_2.pptx grad school presentation
DOCX
Unit-3 cyber security network security of internet system
PDF
Slides PDF The World Game (s) Eco Economic Epochs.pdf
PPTX
international classification of diseases ICD-10 review PPT.pptx
PPTX
Slides PPTX World Game (s) Eco Economic Epochs.pptx
PPTX
CHE NAA, , b,mn,mblblblbljb jb jlb ,j , ,C PPT.pptx
PPTX
innovation process that make everything different.pptx
PPTX
Funds Management Learning Material for Beg
PDF
Testing WebRTC applications at scale.pdf
PPT
Design_with_Watersergyerge45hrbgre4top (1).ppt
PPT
isotopes_sddsadsaadasdasdasdasdsa1213.ppt
PPTX
INTERNET------BASICS-------UPDATED PPT PRESENTATION
PPTX
SAP Ariba Sourcing PPT for learning material
Job_Card_System_Styled_lorem_ipsum_.pptx
Digital Literacy And Online Safety on internet
SASE Traffic Flow - ZTNA Connector-1.pdf
E -tech empowerment technologies PowerPoint
Vigrab.top – Online Tool for Downloading and Converting Social Media Videos a...
WebRTC in SignalWire - troubleshooting media negotiation
Internet___Basics___Styled_ presentation
Power Point - Lesson 3_2.pptx grad school presentation
Unit-3 cyber security network security of internet system
Slides PDF The World Game (s) Eco Economic Epochs.pdf
international classification of diseases ICD-10 review PPT.pptx
Slides PPTX World Game (s) Eco Economic Epochs.pptx
CHE NAA, , b,mn,mblblblbljb jb jlb ,j , ,C PPT.pptx
innovation process that make everything different.pptx
Funds Management Learning Material for Beg
Testing WebRTC applications at scale.pdf
Design_with_Watersergyerge45hrbgre4top (1).ppt
isotopes_sddsadsaadasdasdasdasdsa1213.ppt
INTERNET------BASICS-------UPDATED PPT PRESENTATION
SAP Ariba Sourcing PPT for learning material

Superloop's accc internet interconnection

  • 2. Licensed Telecommunication Carriers under the Telecommunications Act which: ● National backbone connecting all five key 5 capital cities with clear channel protected 100G capacity to each; and ● Backbone must be connected to at least two (2) diverse IP PoP’s in each capital city. Each PoP in each city must be interconnected with at least 40G protected with upgrade path to 100G; and ● Offer commercial wholesale IP transit services to other carriers, retail service providers and content providers; and ● Have at least 100G aggregated clear international capacity which provides diversity between Australia, the United States and Asia; and ● Operate DDoS protection outside Australia at the major international IP gateways prior to connecting to international capacity toward Australia; and ● Have relevant approvals for data interception and data retention from the Attorney General’s department; and ● 24/7 NOC based in Australia and be a CERT Australia partner; Nationally Significant Network 2 Contents Item01Are deemed to be Nationally Significant Networks and allowed to require other NSNs to provide internet interconnections between networks. Incumbents Telstra, Optus and AAPT/TPG along with other nationally significant networks Superloop, Vocus and Vodafone would/could qualify.
  • 3. Current framework has left Australia with some of the highest IP/transit domestic pricing in the world (USA $0.20, HK $1.10, SG $1.50 per mbps per month compared to Australia at $5.00 representing a 400% to 2500% increase in cost for Australian network operators) Domestic intecap transmission is around $0.30 per Mbps per protected 10G yet IP transit is ~$5. Due to lack of competition Gang of Four (GoF) domestic transit pricing almost mirrors international capacity pricing and with international pricing expected to drop soon domestic peering/transit will have a dampening impact Current arrangement often means that global carriers and content providers are “third line forced” into purchasing other services from the GoF providers to access their “eyeball” networks at a reasonable price It’s an open policy available to any network that meets the deemed peering criteria (ie. nationally significant) Why this is important - Competition GoF members get two (2) bites of the cherry as their consumers get charged internet access fees, yet also charge carriers and content providers to get access to their networks and get free ride on the originating network (often despite carrying the data to Australia at no charge to the GoF member) Australia to date has unfortunately missed a great opportunity to be an internet hub for Asia (Singapore and Hong Kong) however with the latest round of submarine cables about to land in Australia there is an opportunity for Australia to be competitive both domestically and internationally Encourages investment in telecommunications infrastructure both domestically and internationally which is made on the basis of servicing wholesale customers (RSP’s) and retail customers (corporate and residential) Having a broadly non-descriminatory policy (no-named basis) allows fluidity in the market and new entrants to become a Nationally Significant Network
  • 4. SD Wan is one of the fastest growing market segments in the world and is a technology stack that overlays Software Defined Networking (SDN) on different networks to deliver a ubiquitous and secure network connection. The existing GoF will have both commercial and technical advantage over all other network providers in Australia as carriers and SD-WAN providers looking to deployed SD-WAN will at some level be required to and pay for interconnects with the GoF to deliver reliable and lower latency connectivity. Currently Telstra and Optus for example will essentially be paid to interconnect to other networks including other NSNs as full transit rate and be placed at a significant commercial advantage to others. Why is this important? Unintentional SD-WAN Tax SD Wan is one of the fastest growing market segments in the world and is a technology stack that overlays Software Defined Networking (SDN) on different networks to deliver a ubiquitous and secure network connection.
  • 5. Yet ACCC think it’s OK? No action required? Only peer is Mumbai? Market is efficient? Really? Australia Transit Pricing is Uncompetitive Broad variance among cities.. Weighted Media 10 GigE IP Transit Prices in Selected Cities, Q4 2017 Source: Telegeography.com
  • 6. Why this is important - National Security ● Networks with which the national IP backbone sits upon must be able to withstand certain levels of attack from internal and external parties ● Ideally these protective mechanisms should happen at the international borders *before* coming to Australia leaving Australia’s international connectivity “protected” ● Interconnection between NSN’s should happen with ports/interconnects that have scale to avoid congestion during burst events and be offloaded as locally as possible, as fast as possible, hence interconnection should ideally be at 100G and in each of the five major states/capital city. This fundamentally improves resiliency during attacks where 10G ports could become congested ● Being a licensed and commercial carrier provides obligations on the provider ● Being an NSN provides the benchmark and certainty for security agencies and the Attorney General’s Department that providers are appropriately resourced and regulated to comply with various obligations ● More NSN’s that meet this benchmark the greater the resiliency of the nations telecommunications infrastructure and the greater emphasis and optionality on service ● Without a fully competitive interconnection environment pushing pricing lower compared to peer countries within our region less content will be stored, processed and transmitted in Australia
  • 7. Initiator Pays: ● Initiator Pays for establishment ● Either settlement free (SKA) or settlement basis ● Settlement basis ‘net’ average gigabit ● 10/40/100G interconnections only ● Commitment to not over-subscribe ports ● Peering in all five markets with interconnection locations to be made available at either Responders PoP locations or major neutral data centers at the Initiators discretion Interconnection Commercial Settlement (assuming no SKA) 7 Port Speed Install/Upgrade OTC MRC Interconnection Matrix 10 30 days 500 500 $500/net average gigabit per month 40/100 60 days 5000 1000 $300/net average gigabit per month
  • 8. Appendix: Security is Important to be a Nationally Significant Network