SlideShare a Scribd company logo
0Mobile Monday NorwayJan 2010Ajit JaokarTelecoms 2.0: Understanding the Impact of Open Mobile
Ajit JaokarAjit JaokarUK based - Hands on Publisher (futuretext) - Author (Mobile Web 2.0, Social Media Marketing, Open Mobile) - Chair: Oxford University's Next Gen Mobile Applications panel - PhD student UCL/UK  - Consulting – Operators, Governments/EU, Startups – World Economic Forum - future of the InternetRecent and forthcoming talks includeMobile world congress(2007,2008,2009),  CEBIT, Stanford University - MIT Sloan -Web 2.0 expo - Ajaxworld Supernova - CNN money - BBC - Oxford University European parliamentGlobal top 20 wireless bloggerAccording to fierce wireless www.opengardensblog.futuretext.com1
2Open Mobile - Outline  .. What you will learn:  A holistic view - Web. Mobile. Appstores. Open
  How the value chain is changing
  Where it is going to (which appstore will 'win')
  Web v.s Apps?
  How to get the soft copy of my latest book for free ..On the internet - no one knows ..
Open MobileOpen Mobile - is even your dog can log on to any mobile :) - like the PC
Open Mobile = your dog can log  Cringeworthy as it may sound! - On a more serious note it implies UNLEASHING(UNLOCKING) THE DEVICEi.e. complete separation of access from service! -  device is not tied to the network (like a PC)
Open mobile - Net neutralityOpen Mobile - Net neutrality argument and decoupling the network from the service. Think of multiplayer chess over the network: There are two possibilities - A)  If the network is agnostic (i.e. no intelligence is built into the network) - then the chess player can concentrate on creating the chess application. B) If the network is 'intelligent' - then you need a 'network expert' to create a chess application.(a)is an example of intelligence shifting to the edge of the networkwww.maniacworld.com6
7Building a cage? http://www.museumfurniture.com/curiosities/8birdcage1.jpg
Or building a play frame? Building a Cage or Building a play frame? Both have a structure. One restricts you - the other allows you to explore. The choice is ours .. And the choice has commercial benefits .. http://www.the1foru.co.uk/ekmps/shops/the1foru/images/action_tramps_2005_271%5Bekm%5D465x300%5Bekm%5D.jpg8
The inevitable forces driving Open MobileWhy OpenMobile is inevitable: Like a freight train .. You cannot stop it ..  http://www.edrants.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/09/rr1.jpg9
The inevitable forces driving Open MobileThe three riders of Open Mobile:  The Internet
  Creation of content (vs.. consumption)
  Social networkinghttp://www.usfca.edu/pj/images/4-3horse.jpg10
The Internet ..The Internet:  All packets are created equal
Dumb pipes – smart notes
  No differential charging for IP traffic
  'Communication based' not driven by media players (which seeks to make us passive consumers)
  Connected by IP and http protocols
  Creation and not consumptionhttp://static.howstuffworks.com/gif/webserver-backbone-sm.gifhttp://www.technologyreview.com/Infotech/18944/?a=f11
12The Internet drives Open The Internet drives 'Open' but Open means many things to many people … Open source - and especially it's impact on devices - Android•  Open standards - W3C standards• Open APIs i.e. Application Programming Interfaces - for instance access to Location APIs• Open access (freedom to contact anyone on the network), • Open choice of enablers (for example - the ability to choose your billing system),
13The Internet drives Open • Data portability (ownership of your data)• The ability to access any application (i.e. not just the provider's application) a.k.a the classic 'Walled Garden' debate - On deck/ Off deck• 'Open' in relationship to the Cloud• Impact on developers and a shift in value to the edge of the network  Low barriers of entry for third party developersFrom a mobile perspective, 'Open' in the purest sense means to be like the PC - i.e. individuals are not tied to a network or to a device. Anyone can simply 'log on' to the network or device using their credentials anywhere
Open - from a customer perspective ..Open’ means the ability to access a resource or to communicate with people within reasonable commercial and technological barriers. Not free. Open - makes a lot more sense from a customer perspective14
Forces at work .. Telecoms StackWe are seeing two forces at work: Value is being abstracted to higher levels of the stack / edge of the network (ex appstores, Google Latitude) - for Long tail applications and at the same time, the networks will find profitable niches in areas which they can uniquely do - ex via LTEhttp://www.explore-highland-perthshire.com/images/highland_games/pitlochry/tug_of_war.jpg15
Social networksConverged address book, Social networks integrated into devices, TwitterCloudAzure; Verizon, Chrome cloud synchronization, bookmark syncContent	Paid/Free, Hulu, YouTube, spotify, 3D, HDEcosystemsLG, Nokia Ovi, Samsung, VCAST, Appstores vs Mobile Web, BREW apps, China Mobile, iPhone, JIL, getjar, BONDI-W3CDeviceFeature vs. Smart-phone, Nokia, LG, Samsung, HTC, Motorola, SE, RIM, netbooks, open source on devices, sensors, mobile web, emerging marketsMobile WebHTML5, Chrome, WebOS, Real time web, Browser extensionsLTEfemtocells, HSDPA+, bearer aware services,
Value moves away from the network – (Long Tail, Unpredictable use) and also towards the network(Smart Grids, security, Cloud, mobile health)
A two sided business model .. Two-sided markets, also called two-sided networks, are economic networks having two distinct user groups that provide each other with network benefits. Ex: credit cards (cardholders, merchants); video games (gamers and game developers); the Internet. Benefits to each group exhibit demand economies of scale on the other. Consumers, prefer credit cards honoured by more merchants and while merchants prefer cards carried by more consumers.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two-sided_market
A two sided business model .. Devices, networks and Appstores themselves are part of the ecosystem i.e. Enablers between the customer and the developer
A two sided business model ..
21The ecosystem ..http://www.elmspuzzles.com/gallery/Robinson/Watering%20Hole.jpg
Choosing the least worst option ..Like voting .. People will choose the least worst option
The irony …Eight years … i-mode launch 22 February 1999i-Phone launch January 9, 2007 
Closed to open ..  Locked - closed platforms - open platforms - web apps
Live and let die ..Live and let die .. OR Mobile apps vs.. the Mobile Web?
Twitter must die .. Twitter must die for the real time web to live ..
iPhone must die for .. Mobile Web Apps Will Win In The Long Haul – Vic Gundotra .. Google ..
The rise and rise of the iPhoneAccording to Frost and Sullivan, App store downloads are forecast to reach 6.7B by 2014
The rise and rise of the iPhoneIn Nov 2009, App Store carried more items than the world’s largest retailer, Wal-Mart, which merchandises about 100,000 items per store.
Not all free ...
Appstore inside ..‘Appstore inside’ – Not just the usual suspects. Allow unpredictable use(generative) – anything can be a platform - adapted from Distimo
5 characteristics of an app store ..Five Characteristics of appstores : visionmobile-  Single marketplace (submission, certification, targeting, pricing)-  Centralised billing , settlement, reporting-  Global distribution - across handsets, operators, off deck-  Provisioning (install upgrades etc)-  On device discovery - discovery, catalogue, marketing
The web platform ..The web platform – source O Reilly
Web OSWeb OS – execution environment for cloud applications. It goes beyond just making the Web local(HTML5 already does that). Specifically, If Identity and context become agnostic - then services will be nomadic and personalised. The web OS obtains the profile, determines the context, personalizes the web service. Bridges the Web and the mobile
35IdentityProfileContextWeb OSWeb OSPersonalise ..Personalise ..Web OS for TV?

More Related Content

PDF
Designing for diversity - how to stop worrying and embrace the Android revol...
PDF
Rethinking the Mobile Web by Yiibu
PPT
Social Networks On Cell Phones Mobile Devices
PPT
Mobile today-tomorrow-201006-aberla
PPT
Netcetera Presentation on Mobile Marketing
PPTX
Platform Strategy: Openness, Innovation & Control
PPT
Singapore Mobile 2.0 & Ux Trends 2009: Scott Weiss
PDF
The mobile ecosystem and development strategies
Designing for diversity - how to stop worrying and embrace the Android revol...
Rethinking the Mobile Web by Yiibu
Social Networks On Cell Phones Mobile Devices
Mobile today-tomorrow-201006-aberla
Netcetera Presentation on Mobile Marketing
Platform Strategy: Openness, Innovation & Control
Singapore Mobile 2.0 & Ux Trends 2009: Scott Weiss
The mobile ecosystem and development strategies

Viewers also liked (8)

PDF
Peter Tymms and Evidence Based Education
PPT
Richard Andrews
PPT
Working In Partnership With Students - Session Seventeen
PPTX
Gule Sider Live
PDF
Presentazione Franco Gianera
PPTX
PPT
Dave Lambert TTRB launch
PPT
Introducing Behavioural, Emotional And Social Difficultie - Session Eleven
Peter Tymms and Evidence Based Education
Richard Andrews
Working In Partnership With Students - Session Seventeen
Gule Sider Live
Presentazione Franco Gianera
Dave Lambert TTRB launch
Introducing Behavioural, Emotional And Social Difficultie - Session Eleven
Ad

Similar to Telecoms 2.0: Understanding the Impact of Open Mobile (20)

PDF
Firefox OS - Evolving the brand role
PDF
Drupalcamp New York 2009
PDF
NEAR Protocol at the Decentralized Summit 2019
PDF
Mobile system overview
PDF
Technology and UX,UI design trends for 2023
PPT
Future platform for internet of things
PDF
Wearable Products and Technology Outlook - July 2013
PPTX
ICT.pptx
PPTX
FinalPPT-StJoseph (3).pptx
POTX
Cloud computing
PDF
Building Mobile Websites with Joomla
PDF
Chrome for android_devfestx
PDF
Relinquishing Control: Creating Space for Open Innovation
PDF
Mobile Web Design & Development 2011
PDF
Un Microsystem Company Analysis Essay
PDF
Making a Better World with Technology Innovations
PPTX
Stronger than Chuck Norris: SharePoint in clouds, on earth, in subway and in ...
PDF
Marketplace Innovation Report | Q4, 2015
PDF
Internet of Things
PDF
Exploring the physical web
Firefox OS - Evolving the brand role
Drupalcamp New York 2009
NEAR Protocol at the Decentralized Summit 2019
Mobile system overview
Technology and UX,UI design trends for 2023
Future platform for internet of things
Wearable Products and Technology Outlook - July 2013
ICT.pptx
FinalPPT-StJoseph (3).pptx
Cloud computing
Building Mobile Websites with Joomla
Chrome for android_devfestx
Relinquishing Control: Creating Space for Open Innovation
Mobile Web Design & Development 2011
Un Microsystem Company Analysis Essay
Making a Better World with Technology Innovations
Stronger than Chuck Norris: SharePoint in clouds, on earth, in subway and in ...
Marketplace Innovation Report | Q4, 2015
Internet of Things
Exploring the physical web
Ad

More from MobileMonday Norway (20)

PDF
The Future of the Internet – Real-Time-Web by Synaptic
PDF
Internet of Things Business Model Transformation
PDF
Digital Transformation by the Internet of Everything
PPTX
Future of Web is Mobile by Dag Olav Norem
PPTX
Our Mobile Future by Torleiv Maseng
PDF
Huawei IDEOS
PDF
Mobile Marketing and Advertising
PDF
Mobile Finacial Services
PDF
Oslo Startup Weekend
PDF
The New Mobile Econonomy by Rudy De Waele
PDF
Rubberduck i pad
PPTX
PPTX
Forum Nokia Developer Services
PPT
Teleplan - Innovation in Telecom & Media
PDF
Beyond 3G: Bringing Networks, Terminals and the Web Together
PPT
Mobile Social Media & Networking
PPT
The Future Is Agumented
PPT
Mobile Networks Today And Tomorrow
The Future of the Internet – Real-Time-Web by Synaptic
Internet of Things Business Model Transformation
Digital Transformation by the Internet of Everything
Future of Web is Mobile by Dag Olav Norem
Our Mobile Future by Torleiv Maseng
Huawei IDEOS
Mobile Marketing and Advertising
Mobile Finacial Services
Oslo Startup Weekend
The New Mobile Econonomy by Rudy De Waele
Rubberduck i pad
Forum Nokia Developer Services
Teleplan - Innovation in Telecom & Media
Beyond 3G: Bringing Networks, Terminals and the Web Together
Mobile Social Media & Networking
The Future Is Agumented
Mobile Networks Today And Tomorrow

Recently uploaded (20)

PPTX
A Presentation on Artificial Intelligence
PPTX
KOM of Painting work and Equipment Insulation REV00 update 25-dec.pptx
PDF
MIND Revenue Release Quarter 2 2025 Press Release
DOCX
The AUB Centre for AI in Media Proposal.docx
PPTX
Cloud computing and distributed systems.
PDF
Agricultural_Statistics_at_a_Glance_2022_0.pdf
PDF
Network Security Unit 5.pdf for BCA BBA.
PDF
Unlocking AI with Model Context Protocol (MCP)
PDF
Assigned Numbers - 2025 - Bluetooth® Document
PDF
7 ChatGPT Prompts to Help You Define Your Ideal Customer Profile.pdf
PDF
Architecting across the Boundaries of two Complex Domains - Healthcare & Tech...
PDF
A comparative analysis of optical character recognition models for extracting...
PDF
Building Integrated photovoltaic BIPV_UPV.pdf
PPTX
Programs and apps: productivity, graphics, security and other tools
PDF
Chapter 3 Spatial Domain Image Processing.pdf
PPTX
Digital-Transformation-Roadmap-for-Companies.pptx
PDF
Dropbox Q2 2025 Financial Results & Investor Presentation
PDF
Optimiser vos workloads AI/ML sur Amazon EC2 et AWS Graviton
PDF
Encapsulation theory and applications.pdf
PDF
Diabetes mellitus diagnosis method based random forest with bat algorithm
A Presentation on Artificial Intelligence
KOM of Painting work and Equipment Insulation REV00 update 25-dec.pptx
MIND Revenue Release Quarter 2 2025 Press Release
The AUB Centre for AI in Media Proposal.docx
Cloud computing and distributed systems.
Agricultural_Statistics_at_a_Glance_2022_0.pdf
Network Security Unit 5.pdf for BCA BBA.
Unlocking AI with Model Context Protocol (MCP)
Assigned Numbers - 2025 - Bluetooth® Document
7 ChatGPT Prompts to Help You Define Your Ideal Customer Profile.pdf
Architecting across the Boundaries of two Complex Domains - Healthcare & Tech...
A comparative analysis of optical character recognition models for extracting...
Building Integrated photovoltaic BIPV_UPV.pdf
Programs and apps: productivity, graphics, security and other tools
Chapter 3 Spatial Domain Image Processing.pdf
Digital-Transformation-Roadmap-for-Companies.pptx
Dropbox Q2 2025 Financial Results & Investor Presentation
Optimiser vos workloads AI/ML sur Amazon EC2 et AWS Graviton
Encapsulation theory and applications.pdf
Diabetes mellitus diagnosis method based random forest with bat algorithm

Telecoms 2.0: Understanding the Impact of Open Mobile

  • 1. 0Mobile Monday NorwayJan 2010Ajit JaokarTelecoms 2.0: Understanding the Impact of Open Mobile
  • 2. Ajit JaokarAjit JaokarUK based - Hands on Publisher (futuretext) - Author (Mobile Web 2.0, Social Media Marketing, Open Mobile) - Chair: Oxford University's Next Gen Mobile Applications panel - PhD student UCL/UK - Consulting – Operators, Governments/EU, Startups – World Economic Forum - future of the InternetRecent and forthcoming talks includeMobile world congress(2007,2008,2009), CEBIT, Stanford University - MIT Sloan -Web 2.0 expo - Ajaxworld Supernova - CNN money - BBC - Oxford University European parliamentGlobal top 20 wireless bloggerAccording to fierce wireless www.opengardensblog.futuretext.com1
  • 3. 2Open Mobile - Outline .. What you will learn: A holistic view - Web. Mobile. Appstores. Open
  • 4. How the value chain is changing
  • 5. Where it is going to (which appstore will 'win')
  • 6. Web v.s Apps?
  • 7. How to get the soft copy of my latest book for free ..On the internet - no one knows ..
  • 8. Open MobileOpen Mobile - is even your dog can log on to any mobile :) - like the PC
  • 9. Open Mobile = your dog can log Cringeworthy as it may sound! - On a more serious note it implies UNLEASHING(UNLOCKING) THE DEVICEi.e. complete separation of access from service! - device is not tied to the network (like a PC)
  • 10. Open mobile - Net neutralityOpen Mobile - Net neutrality argument and decoupling the network from the service. Think of multiplayer chess over the network: There are two possibilities - A) If the network is agnostic (i.e. no intelligence is built into the network) - then the chess player can concentrate on creating the chess application. B) If the network is 'intelligent' - then you need a 'network expert' to create a chess application.(a)is an example of intelligence shifting to the edge of the networkwww.maniacworld.com6
  • 11. 7Building a cage? http://www.museumfurniture.com/curiosities/8birdcage1.jpg
  • 12. Or building a play frame? Building a Cage or Building a play frame? Both have a structure. One restricts you - the other allows you to explore. The choice is ours .. And the choice has commercial benefits .. http://www.the1foru.co.uk/ekmps/shops/the1foru/images/action_tramps_2005_271%5Bekm%5D465x300%5Bekm%5D.jpg8
  • 13. The inevitable forces driving Open MobileWhy OpenMobile is inevitable: Like a freight train .. You cannot stop it .. http://www.edrants.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/09/rr1.jpg9
  • 14. The inevitable forces driving Open MobileThe three riders of Open Mobile: The Internet
  • 15. Creation of content (vs.. consumption)
  • 16. Social networkinghttp://www.usfca.edu/pj/images/4-3horse.jpg10
  • 17. The Internet ..The Internet: All packets are created equal
  • 18. Dumb pipes – smart notes
  • 19. No differential charging for IP traffic
  • 20. 'Communication based' not driven by media players (which seeks to make us passive consumers)
  • 21. Connected by IP and http protocols
  • 22. Creation and not consumptionhttp://static.howstuffworks.com/gif/webserver-backbone-sm.gifhttp://www.technologyreview.com/Infotech/18944/?a=f11
  • 23. 12The Internet drives Open The Internet drives 'Open' but Open means many things to many people … Open source - and especially it's impact on devices - Android• Open standards - W3C standards• Open APIs i.e. Application Programming Interfaces - for instance access to Location APIs• Open access (freedom to contact anyone on the network), • Open choice of enablers (for example - the ability to choose your billing system),
  • 24. 13The Internet drives Open • Data portability (ownership of your data)• The ability to access any application (i.e. not just the provider's application) a.k.a the classic 'Walled Garden' debate - On deck/ Off deck• 'Open' in relationship to the Cloud• Impact on developers and a shift in value to the edge of the network Low barriers of entry for third party developersFrom a mobile perspective, 'Open' in the purest sense means to be like the PC - i.e. individuals are not tied to a network or to a device. Anyone can simply 'log on' to the network or device using their credentials anywhere
  • 25. Open - from a customer perspective ..Open’ means the ability to access a resource or to communicate with people within reasonable commercial and technological barriers. Not free. Open - makes a lot more sense from a customer perspective14
  • 26. Forces at work .. Telecoms StackWe are seeing two forces at work: Value is being abstracted to higher levels of the stack / edge of the network (ex appstores, Google Latitude) - for Long tail applications and at the same time, the networks will find profitable niches in areas which they can uniquely do - ex via LTEhttp://www.explore-highland-perthshire.com/images/highland_games/pitlochry/tug_of_war.jpg15
  • 27. Social networksConverged address book, Social networks integrated into devices, TwitterCloudAzure; Verizon, Chrome cloud synchronization, bookmark syncContent Paid/Free, Hulu, YouTube, spotify, 3D, HDEcosystemsLG, Nokia Ovi, Samsung, VCAST, Appstores vs Mobile Web, BREW apps, China Mobile, iPhone, JIL, getjar, BONDI-W3CDeviceFeature vs. Smart-phone, Nokia, LG, Samsung, HTC, Motorola, SE, RIM, netbooks, open source on devices, sensors, mobile web, emerging marketsMobile WebHTML5, Chrome, WebOS, Real time web, Browser extensionsLTEfemtocells, HSDPA+, bearer aware services,
  • 28. Value moves away from the network – (Long Tail, Unpredictable use) and also towards the network(Smart Grids, security, Cloud, mobile health)
  • 29. A two sided business model .. Two-sided markets, also called two-sided networks, are economic networks having two distinct user groups that provide each other with network benefits. Ex: credit cards (cardholders, merchants); video games (gamers and game developers); the Internet. Benefits to each group exhibit demand economies of scale on the other. Consumers, prefer credit cards honoured by more merchants and while merchants prefer cards carried by more consumers.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two-sided_market
  • 30. A two sided business model .. Devices, networks and Appstores themselves are part of the ecosystem i.e. Enablers between the customer and the developer
  • 31. A two sided business model ..
  • 33. Choosing the least worst option ..Like voting .. People will choose the least worst option
  • 34. The irony …Eight years … i-mode launch 22 February 1999i-Phone launch January 9, 2007 
  • 35. Closed to open .. Locked - closed platforms - open platforms - web apps
  • 36. Live and let die ..Live and let die .. OR Mobile apps vs.. the Mobile Web?
  • 37. Twitter must die .. Twitter must die for the real time web to live ..
  • 38. iPhone must die for .. Mobile Web Apps Will Win In The Long Haul – Vic Gundotra .. Google ..
  • 39. The rise and rise of the iPhoneAccording to Frost and Sullivan, App store downloads are forecast to reach 6.7B by 2014
  • 40. The rise and rise of the iPhoneIn Nov 2009, App Store carried more items than the world’s largest retailer, Wal-Mart, which merchandises about 100,000 items per store.
  • 42. Appstore inside ..‘Appstore inside’ – Not just the usual suspects. Allow unpredictable use(generative) – anything can be a platform - adapted from Distimo
  • 43. 5 characteristics of an app store ..Five Characteristics of appstores : visionmobile- Single marketplace (submission, certification, targeting, pricing)- Centralised billing , settlement, reporting- Global distribution - across handsets, operators, off deck- Provisioning (install upgrades etc)- On device discovery - discovery, catalogue, marketing
  • 44. The web platform ..The web platform – source O Reilly
  • 45. Web OSWeb OS – execution environment for cloud applications. It goes beyond just making the Web local(HTML5 already does that). Specifically, If Identity and context become agnostic - then services will be nomadic and personalised. The web OS obtains the profile, determines the context, personalizes the web service. Bridges the Web and the mobile
  • 46. 35IdentityProfileContextWeb OSWeb OSPersonalise ..Personalise ..Web OS for TV?
  • 47. 36
  • 48. 10 reasons why web wins ..1) UI: UI fragmentation is minimised through web standards2) No IPR: There is a potentially a relationship between IPR status and fragmentation. i.e. : if there exists revenue generating IPR on a technology there is a financial incentive (from non holders) to create alternatives and fragment3) Ease of programming: web is easier to program than other languages4) Web technology embraces the graphical creatives i.e. allows UI people to more easily engage in apps5) Web is proven6) Visible code/open source which could help leverage new users7) Same code potentially works across web and mobile8) Widgets are a common paradigm across web and mobile9) Many of the ecosystem gaps are being overcome(billing)10) More programmers know it
  • 49. Who will dominate ..Everyone will ‘survive’ – Qs is who will dominate? Ethos of the Web is ‘winner take all’ provided that they serve the customer(and by extension the developer)
  • 50. The Cambrian explosion ..Multiple ecosystems .. Thrive and proliferate .. And that’s a healthy state .. But the web always catches up – faster bandwidth – faster processors
  • 51. Demos ..3D graphics – o3d - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uofWfXOzX-gDrag and drop - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wmf87PyU18MGifter - http://htmlfive.appspot.com/static/gifter.htmlDraw - http://htmlfive.appspot.com/static/draw.html
  • 54. Macromyopia ..Macromyopia – short term over estimate. Long term – under estimate
  • 55. Open Mobile ..Open Mobile - soft copy now free - 298 pages. Email me at Ajit.jaokar@futuretext.com.Print copy £19.99 / €19.99 / USD $19.99 44
  • 56. Thanks! ajit.jaokar@futuretext.com www.futuretext.com www.opengardensblog.futuretext.com PublishingWorkshopsConsultingAll images from Google images – copyright owned by respective holders45