SlideShare a Scribd company logo
18 The missing link:<br />turning shopper<br />insight into<br />practice<br />Toon van Galen<br />A leading expert and pioneer in shopper research, Toon van Galen is the<br />founder of Ratera & van Galen Sdn Bhd together with his wife, Montse<br />Ratera. The company operates from their headquarters in Kuala Lumpur,<br />and helps their international FMCG and retail clients overcome barriers at<br />point of sale across South-East Asia, China and the Middle East.<br />Fewer decisions are taken in-store than<br />previously thought<br />People are talking about how important it is to reach out to shoppers.<br />Some say: ’70 per cent of all decisions are made in store’ (Point-of-<br />Purchase Advertising Institute and Meyers Research Center, 1995) or<br />’68 per cent of all products are bought on impulse’ (POPAI). People<br />say brand loyalty has disappeared: ’68 per cent of all shoppers are<br />brand switchers’ (Nielsen Media Research, 2006). And apparently the<br />conclusion has to be that the store has become the ‘moment of truth’.<br />A massive shift of budgets towards store-related advertising is in full<br />swing. People make it look as if we could wield near total control over<br />shoppers’ brand decisions at store level.<br />According to Deloitte Development (2007), ’70 per cent of all decisions<br />are made on the shop floor, and 68 per cent of products are<br />bought on impulse’. We would love this to be true, but it does seem a<br />Shopper_Book.indb 111 16/06/2009 08:54:36<br />112 Strategy: How to Approach Shopper Marketing<br />bit high, doesn’t it? Think about it: 70 per cent of all shoppers have not<br />decided what brand or product they are going to buy. Do you shop like<br />this yourself? Do you know anybody at all who shops like this? We do<br />not. We have interviewed shoppers since 1997 across South-East Asia,<br />China and the Middle East and we consistently found that the majority<br />of shoppers do (italics) plan what products they will buy in advance, as well<br />as which brand they will buy; the only element still to be decided on<br />the shop floor is the pack size or variant of the product they intended<br />to buy. Following a series of randomly selected shopper projects we<br />carried out across the markets, on a sample size of 11,840 shoppers, we<br />found that the actual percentage of shoppers who made an unplanned<br />purchase for any given product was only 20 per cent (Ratera & van<br />Galen database of selected shopper studies, N = 11,840, shoppers<br />interviewed for a range of common dry grocery FMCG goods bought<br />in supermarkets and hypermarkets in the markets mentioned earlier in<br />the chapter).<br />Moreover, the numbers commonly quoted on brand loyalty seem<br />due for revision. We find brand loyalty levels averaging at 83 per cent<br />across FMCG categories (Ratera & van Galen database of selected<br />shopper studies, N = 9,794, same markets as mentioned before,<br />average of all measured categories), but of course this still leaves 17<br />per cent as opportunity.<br />The effect of in-store impulses is lower than many people like to<br />believe. Another bit of news that might temper some of the initial<br />enthusiasm is the outcome of effect measurements of in-store media.<br />Let us say that shoppers buy, on average, around 25 items in a grocery<br />trip and manage to do this in 67 minutes (Ratera & van Galen database<br />of selected shopper studies, N = 401, hypermarket and supermarket<br />shoppers, grocery items, location Malaysia, 2008). The time needed<br />for the physical exercise involved in getting the trolley, walking the distance<br />needed and putting items in the trolley leaves around 15 minutes<br />for the proper decision process and information intake about these<br />25 purchased decisions, since we know the average active browsing<br />time per product is 35 seconds (hypermarkets and supermarkets). I<br />imagine you are calculating as follows: assuming shoppers are most<br />interested in information for a certain product category at the immediate<br />moment of their decision in front of the shelf, this would leave<br />very little time for POS impulses to have an impact.<br />Let us get one thing straight. We are total believers in the fact that<br />the shop floor plays an ever more crucial role in the brand decision<br />process. We are firm believers in the fact that shoppers can be influenced<br />on the shop floor. We also believe that the only realistic way<br />to achieve this is via in-store media. Is it bad if you can convince one<br />in every 50 shoppers to buy your brand instead of another (Ratera<br />Shopper_Book.indb 112 16/06/2009 08:54:36<br />The Missing Link: Turning Shopper Insight into Practice 113<br />& van Galen database of selected shopper studies, estimate based on<br />the fact that only 20 per cent decide on the brand in-store, combined<br />with studies that show that 11 per cent of those have correct recall and<br />admit possibly being influenced by this particular POS material)? We<br />don’t think so. Is it bad that only one in three passers-by in an aisle<br />notice a certain prominent shelf banner, and only one in six recall both<br />the right brand and the message? We don’t think so. We just think<br />that we should understand better what is really going on in shoppers’<br />minds and get realistic data about how they are really influenced by<br />impulses we design at the point of purchase.<br />Figure 18.1 Shopper’s shelf impressions<br />Shopper_Book.indb 113 16/06/2009 08:54:36<br />114 Strategy: How to Approach Shopper Marketing<br />Many shoppers find current category presentations in stores confusing<br />and unexciting. In interviews, the average score that shoppers<br />give for category presentation in the store in front of shelves is reasonable<br />with 8 out of 10 (Ratera & van Galen database of selected shopper<br />studies, N = 7,469, sub-sample of surveys quoted before), but also<br />around a third of shoppers find that the layout could be clearer and/<br />or more exciting. This is probably not helped by the fact that shoppers<br />use at least two competing hypermarkets or supermarkets each week<br />for their grocery shopping and that most major retailers across our<br />markets present the same category differently within their stores, even<br />within the same chain.<br />A successful shopper marketing strategy has to be rooted in true<br />shopper insight. If, for the sake of argument, we characterize the<br />shopper as a person who has a very short period of time for a decision,<br />a very limited time span for information intake in-store, and a low<br />recall of any impulses thrown at him or her, there is still an enormous<br />window of opportunity. Shoppers can be influenced at the point of<br />purchase even though, at this point in time, the success rate of our<br />efforts might be lower than we hope. Many shoppers also have unsatisfied<br />information needs about products and the suitability of products<br />for their needs. They are interested to learn selected relevant facts<br />about products to help their decision making. So how could we use<br />this insight? We could use a better insight into the shopping and decision<br />process to make product grouping and shelf layout easier for<br />consumers to shop and understand. And we could take away hidden<br />barriers to better purchasing by making the layout a facilitator of a<br />higher-spending and more satisfied shopper.<br />Translating advertising messages used outside the store directly<br />into POS material for in-store use might not lead to the right impact,<br />since they do not address the specific barriers that exist at shelf level.<br />Shopper_Book.indb 114 16/06/2009 08:54:36<br />The Missing Link: Turning Shopper Insight into Practice 115<br />Some implementation examples of<br />these findings<br />Cooking oil case: create a clear upgrade<br />path for cooking oil shoppers<br />In this study (which we presented at the Esomar world retail<br />conference in Valencia in 2007), we found that shoppers typically<br />bought only one type of cooking oil, and that the main<br />barrier that prevented spending more on a second speciality<br />oil like olive oil was lack of insight into the benefits of using different<br />oil types for different cooking purposes. A regrouping of<br />the category, along with changing the order of presentation of<br />the higher-margin speciality oils to first in the flow, and adding<br />basic explanations at shelf level about the usage, led to a sales<br />increase of 22 per cent (and won the category management<br />project of the year award of one of the biggest Asian retailers,<br />Dairy Farm International, Giant Hypermarket, Malaysia).<br />Hair care (shampoo and conditioner) case:<br />take away existing barriers in the category<br />presentation<br />This category is dominated by some of the most professional<br />marketing companies in the world, yet traditional shopper marketing<br />approaches still prevailed in stores during one of our<br />studies. This had led to a traditional brand blocking presentation<br />in shelves, combined with random brand advertising signage<br />on top of the header boards directly above the category, but<br />not matched by actual products directly underneath the boards.<br />All major retail chains used different layouts for this category.<br />A thorough study of the behaviour in-store by shampoo shoppers,<br />which also delved into perceptions and barriers by means<br />of combining five or so different methodologies (such as traffic<br />flow tracking and video analysis combined with browsing observations<br />and interviews at the aisle but also in-depth focus group<br />discussions), made clear that most hair care shoppers are<br />unhappy with their current choice of shampoo and conditioner.<br />Shopper_Book.indb 115 16/06/2009 08:54:36<br />116 Strategy: How to Approach Shopper Marketing<br />The search for the right message at<br />POP sometimes involves breaking the<br />existing category rules<br />The actual finding of solutions on product layout and grouping, based<br />on how shoppers shop the category, combined with the right message<br />at POP, is an art only a few people understand. Whilst it is fairly easy<br />to come up with a more logical grouping for some categories (think<br />of pet food: people prefer a split into dog, cat, fish, and then divided<br />into dry, wet, treats), for most categories the decision tree is not the<br />right lead to follow when designing the merchandising hierarchy on<br />the shelf. If shoppers buy mainly cheap cooking oil based on price<br />comparisons, the common mistake could be to conclude: ‘Let’s group<br />it by price and put the lower-price ones first in the flow, since that<br />is what they currently buy.’ We may then find that the only reason<br />they buy like this is because they are not sure about the usage of the<br />slightly more expensive alternative oil types. That means there is an<br />opportunity to educate them on-shelf about use of different oil types<br />and thus break the old rules of the shopping process. If shoppers are<br />At the same time they are hesitant to switch brands because<br />of insecurity about the suitability of products for their hair type<br />and lack of clarity about which conditioners fit with which shampoos.<br />For some shoppers the ideal shampoo presentation was<br />a grouping of products by hair type, such as all products for<br />long black hair or dry hair grouped together. Testing showed,<br />however, that this was not acceptable for all types of shoppers,<br />mainly because they did not know exactly what hair type they<br />have. The implemented shopper marketing strategy made some<br />simple improvements in product grouping, putting conditioners<br />not on the top shelf or even in a separate section but directly<br />next to their respective mother variants, and this alone led to a<br />quick increase in sales. The ultimate desire for shoppers was for<br />a quick and efficient verification of their hair type and for related<br />tips about which product combinations would have the desired<br />effect. Some of these findings were later introduced in another<br />market via use of hair testing equipment and subsequent advice<br />on shampoo type and brand, on and near the shelf, with promising<br />results.<br />Shopper_Book.indb 116 16/06/2009 08:54:36<br />The Missing Link: Turning Shopper Insight into Practice 117<br />brand loyal to shampoo only because they are risk averse, but actually<br />keen to change, there is clearly an opportunity to seduce them into a<br />better alternative by breaking with the current way they purchase the<br />category.<br />Obviously we need to look for alternatives that find a balance<br />between shopper needs and relevance in terms of higher category<br />spending and retailers’ and manufacturers’ profits. This breaking of<br />the old shopping behaviour rules requires an experienced eye combined<br />with more complex research designs, mostly a combination of<br />various in-store methods together with qualitative techniques and<br />shopper segmentation tools and correlation analyses across various<br />in-store factors.<br />The road to successful implementations<br />Even if trade marketing or sales departments find the budget, and<br />the marketing department can overcome the ‘not invented here’<br />syndrome and come up with the additional budget and support for<br />properly designed in-store materials, the ensuing sell-in of the project<br />findings to major retailers sometimes leads to demands for cash rather<br />than gratitude for offering profit-generating category solutions.<br />Luckily there are more and also different parties coming on to<br />the shopper marketing scene – advertising agencies, for example,<br />are starting to see that this part of the budget is not coming back and<br />that communication at store level requires new skills. This influx of<br />brainpower from different angles could lead to a much needed fusion<br />between the knowledge and insight part, on one hand, and the creative<br />design and communication part, on the other hand.<br />We are no doubt heading for even more interesting times. Let us<br />enjoy them.<br />References<br />Deloitte Development (2007) Shopper Marketing: Capturing a shopper’s<br />heart, mind and wallet, Deloitte Development, New York<br />Nielsen Media Research (2006) In store ads sway consumers, Adweek,<br />29 August [Online] http://www.mediabuyerplanner.com/2006/08/29/<br />nielsen_instore_ads_sway_68/<br />Point-of-Purchase Advertising Institute and Meyers Research Center<br />(1995) Consumer Buying Habits Study, Point-of-Purchase Advertising<br />Institute and Meyers Research Center, Englewood, NJ<br />Shopper_Book.indb 117 16/06/2009 08:54:36<br />
The Missing Link
The Missing Link
The Missing Link
The Missing Link
The Missing Link
The Missing Link
The Missing Link
The Missing Link

More Related Content

PPTX
Integrating Shopper into Marketing
PPTX
Shopper Marketing
PPTX
"Shopper Marketing - Consumer Packaged Goods" Presentation 041912
PDF
Shopper Insight techniques summary
PDF
Customizing the In-Store Experience to Meet Shopper Preference
PDF
Shoppermarketing
PPTX
Shopper Marketing Summit 2015 Presentation
PDF
inSpirations_Coupon Effectiveness
Integrating Shopper into Marketing
Shopper Marketing
"Shopper Marketing - Consumer Packaged Goods" Presentation 041912
Shopper Insight techniques summary
Customizing the In-Store Experience to Meet Shopper Preference
Shoppermarketing
Shopper Marketing Summit 2015 Presentation
inSpirations_Coupon Effectiveness

What's hot (20)

PPTX
Shopper marketing 2013 update
PDF
Sample Project_Jingyi Zhu
PPT
Coca Cola
PDF
Winners and losers along the digital path to purchase_TNS
PDF
Path to purchase : comment stimuler votre croissance ?
PDF
Shopper Marketing Magazine - May 2015
PDF
Progressive Grocer February 2015 - Grocery Loyalty Article
PPTX
The Future of Shopper Marketing is Now
PDF
Transformational Shopper Marketing Strategy
PPTX
Popular approach for shopper research and shopper marketing
PDF
Radius shopper marketing intro
PDF
Predictive Marketing Engine - Intema Solutions (White Paper)
PDF
Palmer2e ch01
DOCX
The importance of adaptability
PDF
Ad age pricecuts
DOC
Results
PDF
MGA 2016 Winter_Numainville Article
PDF
Sales and the Buyer: Why You Should Let the Buyer Design Your Sales Organization
PDF
Remodista RetailSource Paper - The Seamless Commerce Experience
PDF
Consumer Propensity Report APAC
Shopper marketing 2013 update
Sample Project_Jingyi Zhu
Coca Cola
Winners and losers along the digital path to purchase_TNS
Path to purchase : comment stimuler votre croissance ?
Shopper Marketing Magazine - May 2015
Progressive Grocer February 2015 - Grocery Loyalty Article
The Future of Shopper Marketing is Now
Transformational Shopper Marketing Strategy
Popular approach for shopper research and shopper marketing
Radius shopper marketing intro
Predictive Marketing Engine - Intema Solutions (White Paper)
Palmer2e ch01
The importance of adaptability
Ad age pricecuts
Results
MGA 2016 Winter_Numainville Article
Sales and the Buyer: Why You Should Let the Buyer Design Your Sales Organization
Remodista RetailSource Paper - The Seamless Commerce Experience
Consumer Propensity Report APAC
Ad

Similar to The Missing Link (20)

PDF
Lecture TePe 8 december
PDF
Lecture Te Pe 8th December
PPTX
Getting shopper attention
PDF
Anuga Food Tech Crash Course Shopper Marketing lecture by Retail House
PPTX
Creating in-storevalue - Why& how
PPTX
brand managent-creating in store value
PPT
GMA (Grocer Manufacturers Association) She Speaks Shopper Marketing
PDF
Shopper Journey Planning Process
PDF
Stop interrupting shoppers
 
PDF
shopper_marketing_whitepaper_en
PDF
How To Segment And Target The Right Customer PowerPoint Presentation Slides
PPT
The Store Newsletter
PDF
How To Develop The Perfect Target Customer Personas PowerPoint Presentation S...
PPTX
Consumer Buying Behavior Part 1 of 2
PDF
Shopper Insights Wine09
PPTX
Shopper Marketing 2013
PDF
Implementing Customer Strategy For Your Organization Complete Deck
DOCX
PDF
Top Ways To Reach Your Target Audience PowerPoint Presentation Slides
PDF
ECR Europe Forum '08. Shopper is a king
Lecture TePe 8 december
Lecture Te Pe 8th December
Getting shopper attention
Anuga Food Tech Crash Course Shopper Marketing lecture by Retail House
Creating in-storevalue - Why& how
brand managent-creating in store value
GMA (Grocer Manufacturers Association) She Speaks Shopper Marketing
Shopper Journey Planning Process
Stop interrupting shoppers
 
shopper_marketing_whitepaper_en
How To Segment And Target The Right Customer PowerPoint Presentation Slides
The Store Newsletter
How To Develop The Perfect Target Customer Personas PowerPoint Presentation S...
Consumer Buying Behavior Part 1 of 2
Shopper Insights Wine09
Shopper Marketing 2013
Implementing Customer Strategy For Your Organization Complete Deck
Top Ways To Reach Your Target Audience PowerPoint Presentation Slides
ECR Europe Forum '08. Shopper is a king
Ad

The Missing Link

  • 1. 18 The missing link:<br />turning shopper<br />insight into<br />practice<br />Toon van Galen<br />A leading expert and pioneer in shopper research, Toon van Galen is the<br />founder of Ratera & van Galen Sdn Bhd together with his wife, Montse<br />Ratera. The company operates from their headquarters in Kuala Lumpur,<br />and helps their international FMCG and retail clients overcome barriers at<br />point of sale across South-East Asia, China and the Middle East.<br />Fewer decisions are taken in-store than<br />previously thought<br />People are talking about how important it is to reach out to shoppers.<br />Some say: ’70 per cent of all decisions are made in store’ (Point-of-<br />Purchase Advertising Institute and Meyers Research Center, 1995) or<br />’68 per cent of all products are bought on impulse’ (POPAI). People<br />say brand loyalty has disappeared: ’68 per cent of all shoppers are<br />brand switchers’ (Nielsen Media Research, 2006). And apparently the<br />conclusion has to be that the store has become the ‘moment of truth’.<br />A massive shift of budgets towards store-related advertising is in full<br />swing. People make it look as if we could wield near total control over<br />shoppers’ brand decisions at store level.<br />According to Deloitte Development (2007), ’70 per cent of all decisions<br />are made on the shop floor, and 68 per cent of products are<br />bought on impulse’. We would love this to be true, but it does seem a<br />Shopper_Book.indb 111 16/06/2009 08:54:36<br />112 Strategy: How to Approach Shopper Marketing<br />bit high, doesn’t it? Think about it: 70 per cent of all shoppers have not<br />decided what brand or product they are going to buy. Do you shop like<br />this yourself? Do you know anybody at all who shops like this? We do<br />not. We have interviewed shoppers since 1997 across South-East Asia,<br />China and the Middle East and we consistently found that the majority<br />of shoppers do (italics) plan what products they will buy in advance, as well<br />as which brand they will buy; the only element still to be decided on<br />the shop floor is the pack size or variant of the product they intended<br />to buy. Following a series of randomly selected shopper projects we<br />carried out across the markets, on a sample size of 11,840 shoppers, we<br />found that the actual percentage of shoppers who made an unplanned<br />purchase for any given product was only 20 per cent (Ratera & van<br />Galen database of selected shopper studies, N = 11,840, shoppers<br />interviewed for a range of common dry grocery FMCG goods bought<br />in supermarkets and hypermarkets in the markets mentioned earlier in<br />the chapter).<br />Moreover, the numbers commonly quoted on brand loyalty seem<br />due for revision. We find brand loyalty levels averaging at 83 per cent<br />across FMCG categories (Ratera & van Galen database of selected<br />shopper studies, N = 9,794, same markets as mentioned before,<br />average of all measured categories), but of course this still leaves 17<br />per cent as opportunity.<br />The effect of in-store impulses is lower than many people like to<br />believe. Another bit of news that might temper some of the initial<br />enthusiasm is the outcome of effect measurements of in-store media.<br />Let us say that shoppers buy, on average, around 25 items in a grocery<br />trip and manage to do this in 67 minutes (Ratera & van Galen database<br />of selected shopper studies, N = 401, hypermarket and supermarket<br />shoppers, grocery items, location Malaysia, 2008). The time needed<br />for the physical exercise involved in getting the trolley, walking the distance<br />needed and putting items in the trolley leaves around 15 minutes<br />for the proper decision process and information intake about these<br />25 purchased decisions, since we know the average active browsing<br />time per product is 35 seconds (hypermarkets and supermarkets). I<br />imagine you are calculating as follows: assuming shoppers are most<br />interested in information for a certain product category at the immediate<br />moment of their decision in front of the shelf, this would leave<br />very little time for POS impulses to have an impact.<br />Let us get one thing straight. We are total believers in the fact that<br />the shop floor plays an ever more crucial role in the brand decision<br />process. We are firm believers in the fact that shoppers can be influenced<br />on the shop floor. We also believe that the only realistic way<br />to achieve this is via in-store media. Is it bad if you can convince one<br />in every 50 shoppers to buy your brand instead of another (Ratera<br />Shopper_Book.indb 112 16/06/2009 08:54:36<br />The Missing Link: Turning Shopper Insight into Practice 113<br />& van Galen database of selected shopper studies, estimate based on<br />the fact that only 20 per cent decide on the brand in-store, combined<br />with studies that show that 11 per cent of those have correct recall and<br />admit possibly being influenced by this particular POS material)? We<br />don’t think so. Is it bad that only one in three passers-by in an aisle<br />notice a certain prominent shelf banner, and only one in six recall both<br />the right brand and the message? We don’t think so. We just think<br />that we should understand better what is really going on in shoppers’<br />minds and get realistic data about how they are really influenced by<br />impulses we design at the point of purchase.<br />Figure 18.1 Shopper’s shelf impressions<br />Shopper_Book.indb 113 16/06/2009 08:54:36<br />114 Strategy: How to Approach Shopper Marketing<br />Many shoppers find current category presentations in stores confusing<br />and unexciting. In interviews, the average score that shoppers<br />give for category presentation in the store in front of shelves is reasonable<br />with 8 out of 10 (Ratera & van Galen database of selected shopper<br />studies, N = 7,469, sub-sample of surveys quoted before), but also<br />around a third of shoppers find that the layout could be clearer and/<br />or more exciting. This is probably not helped by the fact that shoppers<br />use at least two competing hypermarkets or supermarkets each week<br />for their grocery shopping and that most major retailers across our<br />markets present the same category differently within their stores, even<br />within the same chain.<br />A successful shopper marketing strategy has to be rooted in true<br />shopper insight. If, for the sake of argument, we characterize the<br />shopper as a person who has a very short period of time for a decision,<br />a very limited time span for information intake in-store, and a low<br />recall of any impulses thrown at him or her, there is still an enormous<br />window of opportunity. Shoppers can be influenced at the point of<br />purchase even though, at this point in time, the success rate of our<br />efforts might be lower than we hope. Many shoppers also have unsatisfied<br />information needs about products and the suitability of products<br />for their needs. They are interested to learn selected relevant facts<br />about products to help their decision making. So how could we use<br />this insight? We could use a better insight into the shopping and decision<br />process to make product grouping and shelf layout easier for<br />consumers to shop and understand. And we could take away hidden<br />barriers to better purchasing by making the layout a facilitator of a<br />higher-spending and more satisfied shopper.<br />Translating advertising messages used outside the store directly<br />into POS material for in-store use might not lead to the right impact,<br />since they do not address the specific barriers that exist at shelf level.<br />Shopper_Book.indb 114 16/06/2009 08:54:36<br />The Missing Link: Turning Shopper Insight into Practice 115<br />Some implementation examples of<br />these findings<br />Cooking oil case: create a clear upgrade<br />path for cooking oil shoppers<br />In this study (which we presented at the Esomar world retail<br />conference in Valencia in 2007), we found that shoppers typically<br />bought only one type of cooking oil, and that the main<br />barrier that prevented spending more on a second speciality<br />oil like olive oil was lack of insight into the benefits of using different<br />oil types for different cooking purposes. A regrouping of<br />the category, along with changing the order of presentation of<br />the higher-margin speciality oils to first in the flow, and adding<br />basic explanations at shelf level about the usage, led to a sales<br />increase of 22 per cent (and won the category management<br />project of the year award of one of the biggest Asian retailers,<br />Dairy Farm International, Giant Hypermarket, Malaysia).<br />Hair care (shampoo and conditioner) case:<br />take away existing barriers in the category<br />presentation<br />This category is dominated by some of the most professional<br />marketing companies in the world, yet traditional shopper marketing<br />approaches still prevailed in stores during one of our<br />studies. This had led to a traditional brand blocking presentation<br />in shelves, combined with random brand advertising signage<br />on top of the header boards directly above the category, but<br />not matched by actual products directly underneath the boards.<br />All major retail chains used different layouts for this category.<br />A thorough study of the behaviour in-store by shampoo shoppers,<br />which also delved into perceptions and barriers by means<br />of combining five or so different methodologies (such as traffic<br />flow tracking and video analysis combined with browsing observations<br />and interviews at the aisle but also in-depth focus group<br />discussions), made clear that most hair care shoppers are<br />unhappy with their current choice of shampoo and conditioner.<br />Shopper_Book.indb 115 16/06/2009 08:54:36<br />116 Strategy: How to Approach Shopper Marketing<br />The search for the right message at<br />POP sometimes involves breaking the<br />existing category rules<br />The actual finding of solutions on product layout and grouping, based<br />on how shoppers shop the category, combined with the right message<br />at POP, is an art only a few people understand. Whilst it is fairly easy<br />to come up with a more logical grouping for some categories (think<br />of pet food: people prefer a split into dog, cat, fish, and then divided<br />into dry, wet, treats), for most categories the decision tree is not the<br />right lead to follow when designing the merchandising hierarchy on<br />the shelf. If shoppers buy mainly cheap cooking oil based on price<br />comparisons, the common mistake could be to conclude: ‘Let’s group<br />it by price and put the lower-price ones first in the flow, since that<br />is what they currently buy.’ We may then find that the only reason<br />they buy like this is because they are not sure about the usage of the<br />slightly more expensive alternative oil types. That means there is an<br />opportunity to educate them on-shelf about use of different oil types<br />and thus break the old rules of the shopping process. If shoppers are<br />At the same time they are hesitant to switch brands because<br />of insecurity about the suitability of products for their hair type<br />and lack of clarity about which conditioners fit with which shampoos.<br />For some shoppers the ideal shampoo presentation was<br />a grouping of products by hair type, such as all products for<br />long black hair or dry hair grouped together. Testing showed,<br />however, that this was not acceptable for all types of shoppers,<br />mainly because they did not know exactly what hair type they<br />have. The implemented shopper marketing strategy made some<br />simple improvements in product grouping, putting conditioners<br />not on the top shelf or even in a separate section but directly<br />next to their respective mother variants, and this alone led to a<br />quick increase in sales. The ultimate desire for shoppers was for<br />a quick and efficient verification of their hair type and for related<br />tips about which product combinations would have the desired<br />effect. Some of these findings were later introduced in another<br />market via use of hair testing equipment and subsequent advice<br />on shampoo type and brand, on and near the shelf, with promising<br />results.<br />Shopper_Book.indb 116 16/06/2009 08:54:36<br />The Missing Link: Turning Shopper Insight into Practice 117<br />brand loyal to shampoo only because they are risk averse, but actually<br />keen to change, there is clearly an opportunity to seduce them into a<br />better alternative by breaking with the current way they purchase the<br />category.<br />Obviously we need to look for alternatives that find a balance<br />between shopper needs and relevance in terms of higher category<br />spending and retailers’ and manufacturers’ profits. This breaking of<br />the old shopping behaviour rules requires an experienced eye combined<br />with more complex research designs, mostly a combination of<br />various in-store methods together with qualitative techniques and<br />shopper segmentation tools and correlation analyses across various<br />in-store factors.<br />The road to successful implementations<br />Even if trade marketing or sales departments find the budget, and<br />the marketing department can overcome the ‘not invented here’<br />syndrome and come up with the additional budget and support for<br />properly designed in-store materials, the ensuing sell-in of the project<br />findings to major retailers sometimes leads to demands for cash rather<br />than gratitude for offering profit-generating category solutions.<br />Luckily there are more and also different parties coming on to<br />the shopper marketing scene – advertising agencies, for example,<br />are starting to see that this part of the budget is not coming back and<br />that communication at store level requires new skills. This influx of<br />brainpower from different angles could lead to a much needed fusion<br />between the knowledge and insight part, on one hand, and the creative<br />design and communication part, on the other hand.<br />We are no doubt heading for even more interesting times. Let us<br />enjoy them.<br />References<br />Deloitte Development (2007) Shopper Marketing: Capturing a shopper’s<br />heart, mind and wallet, Deloitte Development, New York<br />Nielsen Media Research (2006) In store ads sway consumers, Adweek,<br />29 August [Online] http://www.mediabuyerplanner.com/2006/08/29/<br />nielsen_instore_ads_sway_68/<br />Point-of-Purchase Advertising Institute and Meyers Research Center<br />(1995) Consumer Buying Habits Study, Point-of-Purchase Advertising<br />Institute and Meyers Research Center, Englewood, NJ<br />Shopper_Book.indb 117 16/06/2009 08:54:36<br />