![If Not the Click, Then What? - Ad Age
• [The click’s] the closest thing to a standard, but it doesn’t mean anything to
anybody, and CMOs are just tired of hearing about it.
– Andrea Kerr Redniss, Senior VP Digital, Optimedia
• Remember why you’re advertising…You are not advertising for clicks…What
you’re advertising for is to sell me stuff or change perception, and that’s what
we need to be measuring against.
– Carrie Frolich, Managing Director Digital, Mediaedge: cia
• By measuring the last ad seen or clicked by a converter, they focus entirely on
a brief time span at the bottom of the funnel. Evaluating only a single point of
advertising contact oversimplifies the delivery and performance of any media
channel.
– Microsoft’s Atlas Institute
5](https://image.slidesharecdn.com/1059wthesilentclickopa-090715130729-phpapp01/85/The-Silent-Click-Opa-5-320.jpg)
![Key Findings
• There are more relevant ways to measure the branding impact of online
ad campaigns beyond clicks – which is a Direct Response metric
• Search + Site Visitation + e-Commerce Spending [measured over time
to account for latency effects] = a smart formula for measuring display
advertising effectiveness
– One in 5 exposed to display advertising conduct related searches for the
advertised brands
– One in 3 exposed to display advertising visit the advertised brands’ sites
– E-commerce spending in the advertised categories was significantly higher
among online audiences exposed to the largest ad campaigns
• Environment Matters: There are differences in audience composition
and behavior of those exposed to display advertising on content sites
– Audiences exposed to display advertising are more engaged with
advertisers’ sites – staying longer and consuming more pages
– Audiences exposed to display advertising that visit advertisers’ sites have
higher incomes than their typical visitors – and this positively impacts
related online spending
52](https://image.slidesharecdn.com/1059wthesilentclickopa-090715130729-phpapp01/85/The-Silent-Click-Opa-52-320.jpg)
The Silent Click Opa
- 1. The Silent Click: Building Brands Online June 2009 Conducted in partnership with www.online-publishers.org
- 2. Research Objectives • Demonstrate online advertising’s role in building brands and achieving key branding goals – Discern relevant behaviors that correlate with online ad exposure – Understand the role of environment in attracting a valuable consumer 2
- 3. So Many Ads, So Few Clicks - BusinessWeek Rich Media Click-Through Rates by Industry 0.17% 0.12% 0.12% 0.11% 0.10% 0.10% 0.09% 0.08% 0.08% 0.07% 0.06% Source: DoubleClick DART for Advertisers, January – July 2008 3
- 4. Ad Clickers Follow the 80/20 Rule • Despite only representing 16% of the Internet population, moderate to heavy clickers account for 80% of display ad clicks in the month analyzed • Clickers are predominately younger (24-44 age range) • Clickers tend to be lower income (under $40K) • Two-thirds of Web users didn’t click 100% 6% 10% 18% 16% 50% Click Frequency 31% Heavy Moderate Light 68% 30% Non 51% 20% 0% % Internet Pop % of Clickers % of Clicks Source: comScore, Natural Born Clickers (2008) 4
- 5. If Not the Click, Then What? - Ad Age • [The click’s] the closest thing to a standard, but it doesn’t mean anything to anybody, and CMOs are just tired of hearing about it. – Andrea Kerr Redniss, Senior VP Digital, Optimedia • Remember why you’re advertising…You are not advertising for clicks…What you’re advertising for is to sell me stuff or change perception, and that’s what we need to be measuring against. – Carrie Frolich, Managing Director Digital, Mediaedge: cia • By measuring the last ad seen or clicked by a converter, they focus entirely on a brief time span at the bottom of the funnel. Evaluating only a single point of advertising contact oversimplifies the delivery and performance of any media channel. – Microsoft’s Atlas Institute 5
- 6. How Consumers Spend Time Online Has Changed Greatly the Last 5 Years • Consumers now spend over 40% of their online time with Content, and only about one-fourth of their time with email and IM • Community is a relatively new and growing segment Share of Online Time, 2003 Q1 2009 Search Search 3% 5% Commerce Commerce 16% 14% Content 34% Communication Content Communication 27% 42% 46% Community 12% Source: OPA Internet Activity Index 6
- 7. Display Impacts Search 4 Weeks After Exposure Source: comScore “Whither the Click?” as published in June 2009 Journal of Advertising Research • This dynamic is important because of the synergy between display ads and search, and because a Trademark or a Brand search is a significant indicator of purchase intent % Making a TM/Brand Search Control Test 0.9% 0.7% 0.6% 0.5% 0.5% 0.4% 0.3% 0.2% % Lift: 52% % Lift: 46% % Lift: 40% % Lift: 38% Week of first Weeks 1-2 after Weeks 1-3 after Weeks 1-4 after exposure first exposure first exposure first exposure Indicates significant lift above control at 90% CL 7
- 8. Display Ads Also Drive Traffic to Advertisers Over Time Source: comScore “Whither the Click?” as published in June 2009 Journal of Advertising Research • Display advertising’s ability to drive traffic is persistent • These significant lifts would be overlooked by only considering immediate actions (e.g., a click) Advertiser Site Reach Control Test 6.6% 5.8% 4.8% 4.5% 3.9% 3.5% 3.1% 2.1% % Lift: 65% % Lift: 54% % Lift: 49% % Lift: 46% Week of first Weeks 1-2 after Weeks 1-3 after Weeks 1-4 after exposure first exposure first exposure first exposure Indicates significant lift above control at 90% CL 8
- 10. Methodology • Methodology: – Data source: comScore’s proprietary online panel that passively tracks the online behaviors of 1 million United States Internet users – Findings are based on four popular online categories and measuring their audiences’ interaction with the most pervasive advertisers • Site categories: Business News, Entertainment, News, Sports • Findings are based on the aggregate roll-up of visitors to the top 50 sites in each category, as determined by January 2009 Media Metrix unique visitor data 10
- 11. Methodology (cont’d) • Methodology: – comScore’s Ad Metrix data determines the top 20 display advertisers for the top 50 sites in each category, based on the number of display ad impressions delivered in January 2009 – Advertising value is determined by the composition and online behavior of the audiences from these top sites who were exposed to the largest display campaigns; specifically • Trademark Searches related to advertisers’ brands • Traffic driven to advertisers’ sites • Ecommerce transactions related to the categories of the advertisers’ brands • Household income is a proxy for audience value 11
- 12. Aggregate Results 12
- 13. 80 Ad Campaigns for 53 Brands Tracked Across 200 of the Most Trafficked Sites • Allstate • Domino’s Pizza • ING Group • Skymall • Alltel • Dunkin Donuts • Intuit • Sprint Nextel • American Airlines • E*Trade • JCPenney • Stop & Shop • American Express • Fidelity • Kia Motors • TD Bank • AT&T • Ford • The Ladders • Ticketmaster • Audi • Frontgate • Microsoft • T-Mobile • Bank of America • GMC • Monster • Toyota • Brookstone • H&R Block • Nissan • Travelocity • Capital One • Hampton Inn • NutriSystem • TurboTax • Charles Schwab • Hewlett Packard • Oracle • Vacations To Go • Coors • Holiday Inn • PNC Bank • Verizon • Dell • Honda • Progressive • Vicks • Disney Vacations • Infiniti • Scottrade • Visa • Weight Watchers N=53 Brands Source: comScore AdMetrix, 01/09 13
- 14. These 53 Brands by Industry Brands by Industry QSR F&B Online Svcs 4% 2% 6% CPG Financial 6% Services 28% Telecom 9% Tech 9% Auto 15% Retail 9% Travel 11% N=53 Brands Source: comScore AdMetrix, 01/09 14
- 15. Exposure to Display Ads Correlates with Significant Consumer Activity • About one in five consumers searched on the advertised brand • Separately, about one-third visited the advertiser’s site in February UVs Exposed to Advertising Search Advertised Brands 18% Visit Advertisers' Sites 29% 0% 10% 20% 30% Base: 86.2MM Exposed to at least one of top 20 advertisers Source: comScore Marketing Solutions, 02/09 15
- 16. These Advertiser Site Visitors are More Engaged than the Sites’ Usual Visitors • Consumers exposed to the display advertising spent over 50% more time than the average visitors to these sites the next month • This rise in time spent is matched by a similar increase in page views Advertiser Site Engagement All UVs to Advertiser Sites UVs Exposed to Advertising 62 41 34 22 Minutes/UV Pages/UV Sources: All UVs comScore MediaMetrix, 02/09 Exposed UVs comScore Marketing Solutions, 02/09 16
- 17. Greater Spending for Advertiser Site Visitors Exposed to Biggest Campaigns • These figures represent the average e-commerce spending in February for visitors to the 53 brands’ sites – comparing visitors exposed to these brands’ January online ad campaigns with those not exposed E-commerce $/Advertiser Site Visitor Feb ‘09 Unexposed to Top Campaigns $227 +7% Exposed to Top Campaigns $242 $200 $225 $250 Bases: Unexposed 99.2MM; 86.2MM Exposed Source: comScore Marketing Solutions, 02/09 17
- 18. More E-Commerce Spending by Those Exposed to Related Online Advertising Travel $/Advertiser Visitor Feb ‘09 Consumer Electronics $/Advertiser Visitor Feb ‘09 Unexposed $569 +9% Unexposed $171 +22% Exposed $623 Exposed $209 $500 $550 $600 $650 $100 $150 $200 $250 CPG $/Advertiser Visitor Feb ‘09 Unexposed $74 +14% Exposed $84 Source: comScore Marketing Solutions, 02/09 $65 $70 18 $75 $80 $85
- 19. Content Site Segment Results 19
- 20. News & Information 20
- 21. Top 20 Advertiser Categories Top 20 Advertiser Categories: News & Info Retail QSR 5% CPG 5% 5% Financial Services 20% Travel 15% Telecom 20% Tech 15% Auto 15% Source: comScore AdMetrix, 01/09 21
- 22. Those Exposed to Advertising on Top 50 News Sites Act on These Brands • One in five search advertised brands online • One in three visit these advertisers’ sites News UVs Exposed to Top 20 Advertising Search Advertised Brands 20% Visit Advertisers' Sites 29% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% Base: 69.5MM Exposed to at least one of top 20 advertisers Source: comScore Marketing Solutions 02/09 22
- 23. Exposed Visitors View 40% More Pages on Advertisers’ Sites Advertiser Site Engagement All UVs to Advertiser Site Exposed News Site UVs 62 44 34 27 Minutes/UV Pages/UV Sources: All UVs comScore MediaMetrix, 02/09 Exposed UVs comScore Marketing Solutions, 02/09 23
- 24. They are Higher Income – Especially from OPA Sites – Than Typical Visitors OPA News Top 50 News Top 20 Advertisers HHI 140 Index 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 HHI OPA Base: 49.4MM;Top 50 Base 69.5MM Source: comScore Marketing Solutions 02/09 24
- 25. Much More Spending by the Exposed – Especially Those from OPA News Sites Ecommerce $/News Site Visitor Feb ‘09 Dollars Spent by Unexposed Additional Dollars Spent by Exposed Dollars Spent by Exposed, % Dollar Increase Spent by Exposed Top 50 News $259 +$111 $370, +43% OPA News $236 +$190 $426, +81% $0 $50 $100 $150 $200 $250 $300 $350 $400 $450 OPA Base: 49.4MM;Top 50 Base 69.5MM Source: comScore Marketing Solutions 02/09 25
- 26. Travel and CPG Brands Benefit from These Higher Income News Audiences Travel $/News Site Visitor Feb ‘09 Dollars Spent by Unexposed Dollars Spent by Exposed, Additional Dollars by Exposed % Dollar Increase Spent by Exposed • This is especially true for Top 50 News $741 +$192 $933, +26% those seeing the applicable OPA News $647 +$376 $1,023, +58% ads on OPA member sites • The additional travel dollars $0 $300 $600 $900 $1,200 spent by those exposed on CPG $/News Site Visitor Feb ‘09 OPA news sites was about double that of the top 50 Top 50 News $92 +$26 $118, +28% • Additional CPG dollars spent by those exposed on OPA news sites was almost triple OPA News $86 +$73 $159, +85% that of those exposed on the rest of the top 50 $0 $50 $100 $150 $200 26 Sources: comScore Marketing Solutions, 02/09
- 27. Results for an Insurance Company • Among those exposed to advertising on News sites, this leading insurer saw more than double its typical page views • Search and Visitation rates among those exposed were much higher than the Financial Services’ industry-wide CTR average, which was the lowest among the 11 industries tracked News UVs Exposed to Engagement with Insurer Brand Insurer Advertising Feb ‘09 Search Insurer All UVs to Insurer Brand Brand 2% Exposed News Site UVs Visit Insurer Site 2% 22 9 7 10 Fin Svc Avg CTR* 0.06% 0.0% 0.5% 1.0% 1.5% 2.0% Minutes/UV Pages/UV Sources: Search & Visits comScore Marketing Solutions 02/09 All UVs comScore MediaMetrix, 02/09; Exposed UVs comScore Marketing Solutions, 02/09 *CTR Source: DoubleClick DART for Advertisers January – July 2008 27
- 28. Sports 28
- 29. Top 20 Advertiser Categories Top 20 Advertiser Categories: Sports F&B Online Svcs 5% 10% Financial Travel Services 10% 35% Telecom 20% Auto 20% Source: comScore AdMetrix, 01/09 29
- 30. Among Those Exposed to Advertising on Sports Sites… • One in five consumers searched on the advertised brand • Over one in four visit the advertisers’ sites Sports UVs Exposed to Top 20 Advertising Search Advertised Brands 19% Visit Advertisers' Sites 28% 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% Base: 37.6MM Exposed to at least one of top 20 advertisers Source: comScore Marketing Solutions, 02/09 30
- 31. Ad-Exposed UVs View 20% More Pages of Advertisers’ Content Advertiser Site Engagement All UVs to Advertiser Site Exposed Sports Site UVs 54 45 27 28 Minutes/UV Pages/UV Sources: All UVs comScore MediaMetrix, 02/09 Exposed UVs comScore Marketing Solutions, 02/09 31
- 32. OPA and Top 50 Sports Sites Drove High Income Audiences to Advertisers OPA Sports Top 50 Sports Top 20 Advertisers HHI 140 Index 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 HHI OPA Base: 14.2MM;Top 50 Base 37.6MM Source: comScore Marketing Solutions 02/09 32
- 33. Significantly Greater Spending by UVs Exposed to Ads on OPA Sports Sites Ecommerce $/Sports Site Visitor Feb ‘09 Dollars Spent by Unexposed Additional Dollars Spent by Exposed Dollars Spent by Exposed, % Dollar Increase Spent by Exposed Top 50 Sports $215 +$9 $224, +4% OPA Sports $186 +$55 $241, +30% $0 $50 $100 $150 $200 $250 $300 OPA Base: 14.2MM;Top 50 Base 37.6MM Source: comScore Marketing Solutions 02/09 33
- 34. Travel and Telecom Benefit – Especially From OPA Sports Sites Travel $/Sports Site Visitor Feb ‘09 Dollars Spent by Unexposed Dollars Spent by Exposed, Additional Dollars Spent by Exposed % Dollar Increase Spent by Exposed Top 50 Sports $530 +$45 $575 +8% • Travel dollars spent by those exposed on OPA sports sites OPA Sports $506 +$176 $682, +35% was quadruple that of the top 50 sports sites $0 $200 $400 $600 $800 • Additional telecom dollars Telecom $/Sports Site Visitor Feb ‘09 spent by those exposed on sports sites was over 5X that of those exposed on the Top 50 Sports $90 +$16 $106, +18% rest of the top 50 OPA Sports $68 +$87 $155, +128% $0 $50 $100 $150 $200 34 Source: comScore Marketing Solutions, 02/09
- 35. Results for an Automaker • Among those exposed to advertising on Sports sites, this automaker obtained a more engaged audience – As comparison, we provide Auto’s industry-wide CTR average Sports UVs Exposed to Engagement with Auto Brand Auto Advertising Feb ‘09 All UVs to Auto Brand Search Auto Brand 0.1% Exposed Sports Site UVs 9 Visit Auto Site 0.3% 5 4 2 Auto Avg CTR* 0.09% 0.0% 0.1% 0.2% 0.3% 0.4% Minutes/UV Pages/UV Sources: Search & Visits comScore Marketing Solutions 02/09 All UVs comScore MediaMetrix, 02/09; Exposed UVs comScore Marketing Solutions, 02/09 *CTR Source: DoubleClick DART for Advertisers January – July 2008 35
- 36. Entertainment 36
- 37. Top 20 Advertiser Categories Top 20 Advertiser Categories: Entertainment Travel QSR 5% 5% Retail 5% Tech 25% Financial Svcs 10% CPG 10% Telecom 25% Auto 15% Source: comScore AdMetrix, 01/09 37
- 38. Entertainment Site Visitors Exposed to Ads Engage With Advertisers’ Brands • One in five consumers searched on advertised brands • Separately, one-third visited the advertiser’s site in February Entertainment UVs Exposed to Top 20 Advertising Search Advertised Brands 20% Visit Advertisers' Sites 34% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% Base: 75.1MM Exposed to at least one of top 20 advertisers Source: comScore Marketing Solutions, 02/09 38
- 39. Visitors Exposed to Ads Spend About 50% More Time with Advertisers’ Sites Advertiser Site Engagement All UVs to Advertiser Site Exposed Entertainment Site UVs 64 41 35 23 Minutes/UV Pages/UV Sources: All UVs comScore MediaMetrix, 02/09 Exposed UVs comScore Marketing Solutions, 02/09 39
- 40. More Ecommerce Spending by Those Viewing Ads on Entertainment Sites Ecommerce $/Entertainment Site Visitor Feb ‘09 Dollars Spent by Unexposed Additional Dollars Spent by Exposed Dollars Spent by Exposed, % Dollar Increase Spent by Exposed Top 50 Entertainment $215 +$14 $229, +7% OPA Entertainment $190 +$19 $209, +10% $0 $50 $100 $150 $200 $250 OPA Base: 19.8MM;Top 50 Base 75.1MM Source: comScore Marketing Solutions 02/09 40
- 41. Greater CPG and Telecom Spending by Those Exposed to Ads on OPA Entertainment Sites CPG $/Entertainment Site Visitor Feb ‘09 Dollars Spent by Exposed, Dollars Spent by Unexposed % Dollar Increase Spent by Exposed Additional Dollars Spent by Exposed • More CPG spending by Top 50… $70 +$9 $79 +13% those exposed to advertising OPA Entertainment $61 +$39 $100, +64% on OPA Entertainment sites compared to top 50 $0 $50 $100 $150 Entertainment sites Telecom $/Entertainment Site Visitor • More Telecom spending by Feb ‘09 those exposed to ads on OPA Entertainment sites – Top 50 in contrast to the results for Entertainment $95 $71, -25% other Entertainment sites OPA Entertainment $67 +$9 $75, +12% $0 $50 $100 41 Source: comScore Marketing Solutions, 02/09
- 42. Results for a Software Company • This software company had more engaged audiences among those exposed to advertising on Entertainment sites • Software company also had higher search and visitation rates among those exposed to advertising compared to average CTR rates for Technology ads Entertainment UVs Exposed to Engagement with Software Brand Software Advertising Feb ‘09 All UVs to Software Brand Search Software Brand 3% Exposed Entertainment Site UVs 35 Visit Software Site 6% 8 11 12 Tech Avg CTR* 0.12% 0% 10% 20% 30% Minutes/UV Pages/UV Sources: Search & Visits comScore Marketing Solutions 02/09 All UVs comScore MediaMetrix, 02/09; Exposed UVs comScore Marketing Solutions, 02/09 *CTR Source: DoubleClick DART for Advertisers January – July 2008 42
- 43. Business News 43
- 44. Top 20 Advertiser Categories Top 20 Advertiser Categories: Business News Online Svcs 5% Telecom 10% Retail Financial 15% Services 50% Tech 20% Source: comScore AdMetrix, 01/09 44
- 45. UVs Exposed to Ads on Business News Sites Engage with Advertised Brands • One in seven searched, and more importantly about one in four visited the advertisers’ sites Business News UVs Exposed to Top 20 Advertising Search Advertised Brands 14% Visit Advertisers' Sites 23% 0% 10% 20% 30% Base: 38.3 MM Exposed to at least one of top 20 advertisers Source: comScore Marketing Solutions, 02/09 45
- 46. UVs Exposed to Ads Spent Twice the Time, Viewing 2x Pages on Ad Sites Advertiser Site Engagement All UVs to Advertiser Site Exposed Business News UVs 98 55 47 27 Minutes/UV Pages/UV Sources: All UVs comScore MediaMetrix, 02/09 Exposed UVs comScore Marketing Solutions, 02/09 46
- 47. These Visitors Are of a Higher Quality, as Measured by Income • While visitors to the advertiser sites index at the online average, those exposed to January’s biggest ad campaigns who visited were higher income – especially those from OPA members in the business category • Counter to clicks, the higher the income, the more likely those exposed to the ad visited the advertiser’s site OPA Business News Top 50 Business News Top 20 Advertiser Sites HHI 180 Index 160 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 HHI <$15K $15-$24.9K $25-$39.9K $40-$59.9K $60-$74.9K $75-$99.9K $100K+ Source: comScore Marketing Solutions 02/09 47 OPA Base: 12.6MM;Top 50 Base 38.3MM
- 48. More Ecommerce Spending by Those Exposed to Ads on Business News Sites • Ecommerce spending is greater for business news site visitors exposed to the top ad campaigns – especially among those seeing these ads on OPA business news sites Ecommerce $/Business News Visitor Feb ‘09 Dollars Spent by Unexposed Additional Dollars Spent by Exposed Dollars Spent by Exposed, % Dollar Increase Spent by Exposed Top 50 Business $206 +$53 $259, +26% OPA Business $212 +$122 $334, +58% $0 $100 $200 $300 $400 OPA Base: 12.6MM;Top 50 Base 38.3MM Source: comScore Marketing Solutions 02/09 48
- 49. More Spending on High Involvement Goods Correlates With Ad Exposure Tech $/Business News Visitor Feb ‘09 Dollars Spent by Unexposed Dollars Spent by Exposed, Additional Dollars Spent by Exposed % Dollar Increase Spent by Exposed Top 50 Business $282 +$8 $290, +3% • High involvement categories like Technology and Telecom OPA Business $230 +$137 $367, +60% show higher spending among those exposed to ads on $0 $100 $200 $300 $400 OPA Business News sites Telecom $/Business News Visitor Feb ‘09 Top 50 Business $63+$37 $100, +59% OPA Business $84 +$149 $233, +177% $0 $125 $250 49 Source: comScore Marketing Solutions 02/09
- 50. Results for a Wireless Advertiser • A leading wireless company had higher traffic and visitor engagement among those exposed to advertising on Business News sites – As comparison, we provide Telecom’s industry-wide CTR average Business News UVs Exposed to Engagement with Wireless Brand Wireless Advertising Feb ‘09 All UVs to Wireless Brand Search Wireless Brand 14% Exposed Business Site UVs 32 Visit Wireless Site 23% 9 7 Telecom Avg CTR* 0.08% 4 0% 10% 20% 30% Minutes/UV Pages/UV Sources: Search & Visits comScore Marketing Solutions 02/09 All UVs comScore MediaMetrix, 02/09; Exposed UVs comScore Marketing Solutions, 02/09 *CTR Source: DoubleClick DART for Advertisers January – July 2008 50
- 51. Conclusions 51
- 52. Key Findings • There are more relevant ways to measure the branding impact of online ad campaigns beyond clicks – which is a Direct Response metric • Search + Site Visitation + e-Commerce Spending [measured over time to account for latency effects] = a smart formula for measuring display advertising effectiveness – One in 5 exposed to display advertising conduct related searches for the advertised brands – One in 3 exposed to display advertising visit the advertised brands’ sites – E-commerce spending in the advertised categories was significantly higher among online audiences exposed to the largest ad campaigns • Environment Matters: There are differences in audience composition and behavior of those exposed to display advertising on content sites – Audiences exposed to display advertising are more engaged with advertisers’ sites – staying longer and consuming more pages – Audiences exposed to display advertising that visit advertisers’ sites have higher incomes than their typical visitors – and this positively impacts related online spending 52
- 53. Key Findings (cont’d) • Visitors exposed to display advertising spend more on e-commerce overall and in the advertised categories – especially true for those viewing display ads on OPA Member sites • OPA News Sites – average e-commerce spending by visitors exposed to ads was 15% higher ($426) than those exposed on the Top 50 News sites • OPA Sports Sites – average e-commerce spending for those exposed to ads was 8% higher ($241) than those exposed on the Top 50 Sports sites • OPA Entertainment sites – CPG spending after ad exposure was up 64% ($100) compared to13% on the Top 50 Entertainment sites • OPA Business News sites – average e-commerce spending by those exposed to ads was 21% higher ($334) compared to those exposed on Top 50 53
- 54. Appendix: Sites by Content Category 54
- 55. Top 50 News & Information Sites • ABC News • MSN News & Weather • AccuWeather Sites • MSNBC • Advance Internet • MTVU • AOL News • NBC Local Media • Associated Press • New York Magazine • BBC • Newsday • Belo • Newsweek • Boston.com • NPR • Buzzle • Reuters • CBS News • Scripps Interactive Newspaper Group • CNN • Scripps Television Station Group • Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc. • Sun-Times • Cox Newspapers • Telegraph Media Group • eHow • The New York Post • FOX News • The New York Times • Gannett Sites & USAToday • The Washington Post Company • Gawker Media • The Weather Channel • Guardian • Time • Hearst Newspapers • Times Online • Huffington Post • Topix • Lee Enterprises • Tribune Newspapers • Legacy • Weather Underground • Mail Online • Weatherbug Property • McClatchy Corporation • WorldNow • MediaNews Group • Yahoo! News OPA News sites in bold 55 Source: comScore MediaMetrix, 01/09
- 56. Top 50 Business News Sites • 1888 Press Release • Guardian Business • ADVFN • Hoovers • Alley Insider • IBD editorials • All Business • IB Times • AOL Money & Finance • INC • Bankaholic • Investors.com • BBC News - Business • Investor Words • Bizjournals • Kiplinger • Bloomberg • Manta • BNET • Minyanville.com • BusinessWeek Online • Morningstar • Businesswire.com • Motley Fool • Chicago Business • MSN Money • CJ Online • Nasdaq Property • CNBC • NYSE • CNN Money • Principal.com • Comcast.net Finance • Reuters • Economist • Seeking Alpha • Ed Week • Street Inside • Fast Company • The Street • Financial Times Group • The Wall Street Journal • Forbes • Times Online - Business • FOX Business • Wikinvest • Free-Press-Release • Yahoo! Finance • Google Finance • Zacks OPA Business News sites in bold 56 Source: comScore MediaMetrix, 01/09
- 57. Top 50 Sports Sites • About.com Sports and Recreation • NBC Sports • Australianopen.com • NCAA • BNQT • NFL Internet Group • Bodybuildingforyou.com • NHL Network • CBS Sports • OFF-ROAD.COM • Comcast.net Sports • PGA Tour • Dead Spin • Sher Dog • Demand Media Sports • Soccer.com • Digital Sports • SPEED Sites • Ehow Sports And Fitness • Sportgenic • ESPN • Sporting News • Fanhouse • SportNet • FANIQ • Sports Direct • Fantasy Sports Ventures • Sports Illustrated Sites • FOX Sports on MSN • Sports Blogs, Inc. • GN Outdoor (Gorilla Nation) • Sportsviews.com • Golf Channel • Stack Media • Hachette Filipacchi Men's Enthusiasts Network • Tampabaysuperbowl.com • highschoolsports.net • U.S Olympic Team Sites • InterMedia Outdoors • UFC • International Speedway Corporation • Universal Sports • JUMPTV • USAToday Sports • MLB • Vertical Sports Group • NASCAR • Yahoo! Sports • NBA • Yardbarker Sports Media OPA Sports sites in bold 57 Source: comScore MediaMetrix, 01/09
- 58. Top 50 Entertainment Sites • A&E Interactive • MSN Music • ABC Family • MSN TV • ABC • MTV Networks Music • About.com Entertainment • MyFox • Access Hollywood • MySpace Music • AOL Music • National Geographic Sites • AOL Television • NBC Network • ARTISTdirect Network • omg! • Ask Men • PBS • Asylum • People • BET Networks • Play List • CBS Television • Rhapsody • Comedy Central • Ripe Digital Entertainment • Discovery Networks • SOAPnet • E! Online • Sony Music Entertainment • ELYRICS • TMZ • Entertainment Weekly • Tribune Broadcasting • Fox Broadcasting • TV.COM • Gray Television • Ultimate-guitar.com • Jango Music Network • Universal Music Group • Last.fm Ltd • Warner Music • Lyrics.com • Windowsmedia.com Music • Lyricsmode.com • WWE • Macrovision • Yahoo! Music • Metro Lyrics • Yahoo! TV OPA Entertainment sites in bold 58 Source: comScore MediaMetrix, 01/09
- 59. For More Information Research Questions: Stuart Schneiderman Director of Research Online Publishers Association stuarts@online-publishers.org PR Inquiries: Aimee Yoon Dotted Line Communications 646.678.4980 aimee@dottedlinecomm.com 59