SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Exploring Variable Pay
Fair isn’t equal
Mykkah Herner, MA, CCP
Modern Compensation Evangelist
Paige Hanley, CCP
Manager, Customer Operations
A copy of the presentation and recertification credit will be sent out
within a couple of business days
15,000 Positions 3,500 Customers 11 Countries
250 Compensable Factors
54 Million Salary Profiles
www.payscale.com
Paige Hanley, CCP
Manager, Customer Operations
https://www.linkedin.com/in/paige-hanley-ccp-26599716
Mykkah Herner, MA, CCP
Modern Comp Evangelist
https://www.linkedin.com/in/mykkahherner
www.payscale.com
Protections for equal pay
Fair pay isn’t equal
Linking Fair Pay and Variable Pay
• Variable pay basics
• Creative variable pay
Where to start
www.payscale.com
Less than 100 Employees
100 - 1,000 Employees
More than 1,000 Employees
Nearly 7600 Respondents
www.payscale.com
73% of employers consider
employees fairly paid
36% of employees feel they
are paid fairly
www.payscale.com
Protections for Equal Pay
Legal Disclaimer: this is intended to be
informational, not to serve as legal advice.
If you think you have a potential pay
discrimination issue, seek out a lawyer.
www.payscale.com
Definition
what counts
as a job?
Secrecy
non-retaliation
for talking
about pay
Burden of Proof
100% of difference
demonstrated
from 1 of 4 reasons
California Fair Pay Act
WHAT’S THE BIG DEAL?
As California Goes…
…so goes the nation.
48/50 States have some
version of a pay equity
law on the books
9/10 Provinces* have
some version of a pay
equity law on the books
www.payscale.com
Other legal protections
Federal, State, and Local laws
Minimum Wage
Fair Labor Standards Act
Other laws
www.payscale.com
Fair isn’t equal
www.payscale.com
Fair
doesn’t
necessarily
mean
equal
EqualFair
https://hbr.org/2016/03/when-unequal-pay-is-actually-fair
There are some
really good reasons
to differentiate pay
www.payscale.com
Appropriate differentiation by
Performance
Results
Experience
Skills
Education
www.payscale.com
Linking Fair and Variable Pay
www.payscale.com
Prevalence of bonuses has steadily
increased over the past 4 years
68.5% 69.3%
73.4% 74.3%
50.0%
55.0%
60.0%
65.0%
70.0%
75.0%
80.0%
2013 2014 2015 Current
Do You Give Bonuses?
www.payscale.com
Is your bonus budget bigger in 2016
than 2015?
41% of all companies, 50% of top
performing companies
www.payscale.com
Variable Pay Basics
Linking Pay to Performance
Culture and perks that reward
high performers
Higher increases for top
performers
Results-based variable pay
Performance-based rewards
& recognition
The variable pay umbrella
 Incentive
 Project Bonus
 Retention Bonus
 Signing Bonus
 Perks
So you need to put together a
variable pay plan
Hint: keep it simple
www.payscale.com
Mix of pay
What ratio of base to variable?
www.payscale.com
Aligned goals
Company goals
Team goals
Individual goals
www.payscale.com
Incentive Plan Incentive Level
Mix of Base to
Variable
Mix of Company
to Individual
Overall, it may look like this…
Bonus Level Possible Org Level(s)
Bonus Payout as % of
Base
Bonus
Percentage
(Individual)
Bonus
Percentage
(Organization)
Level 1 Individual Contributor 5% 75% 25%
Level 2 Lead, Supervisor 10% 60% 40%
Level 3 Manager 15% 40% 60%
Level 4 Director 20% 25% 75%
www.payscale.com
Consider
budget
org culture
job level
job function
company life cycle
…
Overall pay structure may
differ based on pay goals
www.payscale.com
Mix of pay by life cycle
High Rewards
& Recognition
High Rewards
& Recognition
Moderate
Rewards &
Recognition
Moderate
Rewards &
Recognition
Moderate
Variable
High Variable
Moderate
Variable
Low Variable
Low Base Low Base High Base
Moderate
Base
High Equity
Moderate
Equity
Moderate
Equity
Low Equity
www.payscale.com
What other kinds of variable
pay should we consider?
www.payscale.com
What type of bonus?
15.8% 18.1%
61.8%
25.7%
40.0%
14.4%
Retention
bonuses
Hiring
bonuses
Individual
incentive
bonuses
Team
incentive
bonuses
Spot bonuses
or other
discretionary
bonus
programs
Other (please
specify)
www.payscale.com
Who gets bonuses?
69.0%
75.2%
69.3%
47.0%
12.6%
Executives Directors and
Managers
Professional,
Technical and
Administrative
Exempt Employees
Non-Exempt
Workers
Other (please
specify)
www.payscale.com
How frequently?
4.9%
12.6%
6.4%
66.6%
9.4%
Monthly Quarterly Biannual Annual Ad-hoc
Get Creative
 Passes to sporting events
 Catered lunches for winning teams
 Days off after big deadlines
 Choice of work assignment
 Development opportunities
 Lunch with the CEO
 Remote work
www.payscale.com
Need help getting started?
• If you don’t already have one, find an affordable legal resource in your state
• Get to know the makeup of your workforce
• Survey employees, formally or informally, to identify what motivates them
• What is your current mix of pay? Do you offer something in all four tiers?
• Evaluate your readiness for variable pay – what training is necessary?
PayScale Delivers Where Other Compensation Providers Fall Short
PayScale leads the world in compensation knowledge with the freshest and
most detailed data from over 54 million salary profiles. More than 3500
organizations use PayScale’s software and intelligence to get the greatest
return on their talent. Smart businesses use PayScale Insight to recruit, retain
and motivate their people.
Visit our blog: www.payscale.com/compensation-today
Join our Group on LinkedIn: Compensation Today: HR Best Practices
Paige Hanley, CCP
Manager, Customer Operations
Mykkah Herner, MA, CCP
Modern Compensation Evangelist
www.payscale.com

More Related Content

PDF
Webinar-Comp Foundations-Overpayment/Underpayment
PDF
Webinar-Spring Clean Your Comp
PPTX
Webinar-Modern Pay for Performance
PDF
Webinar-Going Beyond the California Fair Pay Act
PPTX
Webinar-Understanding the Corporate Chasm
PDF
Comp Foundations: Recruiting
PDF
Webinar-How to Set a Comp Budget
PPTX
Webinar-Comp is a Team Sport
Webinar-Comp Foundations-Overpayment/Underpayment
Webinar-Spring Clean Your Comp
Webinar-Modern Pay for Performance
Webinar-Going Beyond the California Fair Pay Act
Webinar-Understanding the Corporate Chasm
Comp Foundations: Recruiting
Webinar-How to Set a Comp Budget
Webinar-Comp is a Team Sport

What's hot (20)

PDF
Webinar-Comp Foundations-Be an Analytics Hero
PPTX
Compensation Foundations: Gender Pay Equity
PDF
Webinar-The Pay Transparency Spectrum
PDF
Webinar-Compensating the Workforce of Tomorrow
PDF
Range and Strategy
PPTX
PayScale: The Pay Transparency Challenge webinar
PDF
Webinar-Compensation Best Practices for 2017
PPTX
Webinar-Compensating the Workforce of Tomorrow
PDF
Webinar-Comp 101
PPTX
Webinar-How to Elevate Your Talent Analysis with Multiple Data Sources
PDF
Comp Foundations: Executive Buy-in
PDF
Webinar-Comp Foundations: Total Comp Report
PDF
Webinar-Identifying & Addressing Compensation Needs
PPTX
PayScale Customer Webinar: 2016 Compensation Best Practices Report
PDF
Webinar - 5 Keys for Retaining Top Talent
PDF
Compensation 201
PPTX
Webinar-Communicating Pay to Employees
PDF
Webinar-5 Steps to Building a Modern Comp Plan
PDF
Webinar-5 Steps to a Painless Increase Cycle with PayScale Crew
PPTX
Webinar-Top HR Myths
Webinar-Comp Foundations-Be an Analytics Hero
Compensation Foundations: Gender Pay Equity
Webinar-The Pay Transparency Spectrum
Webinar-Compensating the Workforce of Tomorrow
Range and Strategy
PayScale: The Pay Transparency Challenge webinar
Webinar-Compensation Best Practices for 2017
Webinar-Compensating the Workforce of Tomorrow
Webinar-Comp 101
Webinar-How to Elevate Your Talent Analysis with Multiple Data Sources
Comp Foundations: Executive Buy-in
Webinar-Comp Foundations: Total Comp Report
Webinar-Identifying & Addressing Compensation Needs
PayScale Customer Webinar: 2016 Compensation Best Practices Report
Webinar - 5 Keys for Retaining Top Talent
Compensation 201
Webinar-Communicating Pay to Employees
Webinar-5 Steps to Building a Modern Comp Plan
Webinar-5 Steps to a Painless Increase Cycle with PayScale Crew
Webinar-Top HR Myths
Ad

Viewers also liked (20)

PPTX
Top Comp Trends of 2016
PPT
Lista De Precios
PPT
Helycobacter pylori
PPTX
TO VARIABLE, OR NOT TO VARIABLE? CHOOSING A CSM COMP MODEL
PPT
Comp Planning Pros: How To Design A Cash Compensation Program For Global & Gr...
PPTX
Enfermedades de transmisión sexual (ets)
PPTX
PPT
Dessler 12
PPT
Hrd 24-mathis-12e-ch13-sh-variable pay and executive compensation
PPT
Bacilos Entericos Upla
PPTX
Farmacos: Antibioticos - generalidades
PPTX
Sales compensation plan
PPTX
Reinventing Performance Management - How to do it right
PPT
Dessler 08
PPT
Farmacodinamia Lucho
PPT
Chapter 13 Variable Pay and Executive Compensation
PPT
Antibioticos generalidades farmacologia clinica
PPT
Training, Motivating, Compensating, and Leading the Salesforce
PPTX
Compensation plan ppt
Top Comp Trends of 2016
Lista De Precios
Helycobacter pylori
TO VARIABLE, OR NOT TO VARIABLE? CHOOSING A CSM COMP MODEL
Comp Planning Pros: How To Design A Cash Compensation Program For Global & Gr...
Enfermedades de transmisión sexual (ets)
Dessler 12
Hrd 24-mathis-12e-ch13-sh-variable pay and executive compensation
Bacilos Entericos Upla
Farmacos: Antibioticos - generalidades
Sales compensation plan
Reinventing Performance Management - How to do it right
Dessler 08
Farmacodinamia Lucho
Chapter 13 Variable Pay and Executive Compensation
Antibioticos generalidades farmacologia clinica
Training, Motivating, Compensating, and Leading the Salesforce
Compensation plan ppt
Ad

Similar to Webinar-Exploring Variable Pay (20)

PPTX
Using Compensation to Motivate Performance
PDF
Webinar - Best Practices in Pay-for-Performance
PDF
3 Habits of Highly Effective Pay Plans
PPTX
Insight expert webinar slides
PPTX
Get Pay Right with PayScale Insight Expert
PDF
5 Pay Essentials for Growing Your Company
PDF
Perfecting Pay for Performance
PDF
Strenghtening the link between pay and performance
PDF
Webinar-How to Do Comp Like Top-Performing Companies
PPTX
New England Compensation Trends & Pay Practices
PDF
California Compensation Trends and Pay Practices
PDF
Lessons from the Web Front Lines
PDF
5 Steps to a Smart Compensation Plan
PDF
Can You Pay People Without Rating Them?
PPTX
Pathway Group - Apprenticeships and the future
PDF
Webinar - Unlock the Power of Payfactors
PDF
How to Improve Line of Sight in your Organization
PPTX
Canadian Compensation Trends & Pay Practices
PPTX
Grow with PayScale Insight Expert
PPTX
Webinar: How to Communicate to Comp Executives and Managers
Using Compensation to Motivate Performance
Webinar - Best Practices in Pay-for-Performance
3 Habits of Highly Effective Pay Plans
Insight expert webinar slides
Get Pay Right with PayScale Insight Expert
5 Pay Essentials for Growing Your Company
Perfecting Pay for Performance
Strenghtening the link between pay and performance
Webinar-How to Do Comp Like Top-Performing Companies
New England Compensation Trends & Pay Practices
California Compensation Trends and Pay Practices
Lessons from the Web Front Lines
5 Steps to a Smart Compensation Plan
Can You Pay People Without Rating Them?
Pathway Group - Apprenticeships and the future
Webinar - Unlock the Power of Payfactors
How to Improve Line of Sight in your Organization
Canadian Compensation Trends & Pay Practices
Grow with PayScale Insight Expert
Webinar: How to Communicate to Comp Executives and Managers

More from PayScale, Inc. (20)

PDF
Webinar - How AI is reshaping pay decisions.pdf
PDF
Webinar - Pay transparency legislation What's new and what's next.pdf
PDF
Webinar - The pay strategy conversations keeping HR leaders up at night
PDF
Webinar - Mind the Gap: Perceived Pay vs. Reality
PDF
Webinar - Unlock the Power of Data in Your Compensation Strategy
PDF
Webinar - Crafting a Clear Compensation Strategy for 2025
PDF
Webinar-How to Better Leverage Data to Fuel Your Compensation Lifecycle.pdf
PDF
Customer Webinar - MarketPay Customer Summit.pdf
PDF
Webinar - Stay Ahead of 2026: Ensure Compliance and Build a Stronger Compensa...
PDF
Webinar - How to Strengthen Your Salary Data Strategy
PDF
Customer Webinar - Unlock Instant Access to the Market’s Top Salary Survey
PDF
Webinar - 2025 Compensation Best Practices Panel
PDF
Webinar - Pay Transparency Legislation Best Practices in 2025
PDF
Webinar - Lessons from This Year’s Comp Cycle
PDF
Webinar - Navigating Compensation in the Manufacturing and Biopharmaceutical ...
PDF
Webinar - Unlock Efficiency and Collaboration with Payscale Compensation Plan...
PDF
Webinar - Smart Job Description Management
PDF
Webinar - How to Train Managers to Have Successful Pay Conversations
PDF
Webinar - Mastering Effective Pay Communications: Best Practices for Success
PDF
Webinar - Pay Equity Webinar: Unlock the Power of Proactive Pay Equity
Webinar - How AI is reshaping pay decisions.pdf
Webinar - Pay transparency legislation What's new and what's next.pdf
Webinar - The pay strategy conversations keeping HR leaders up at night
Webinar - Mind the Gap: Perceived Pay vs. Reality
Webinar - Unlock the Power of Data in Your Compensation Strategy
Webinar - Crafting a Clear Compensation Strategy for 2025
Webinar-How to Better Leverage Data to Fuel Your Compensation Lifecycle.pdf
Customer Webinar - MarketPay Customer Summit.pdf
Webinar - Stay Ahead of 2026: Ensure Compliance and Build a Stronger Compensa...
Webinar - How to Strengthen Your Salary Data Strategy
Customer Webinar - Unlock Instant Access to the Market’s Top Salary Survey
Webinar - 2025 Compensation Best Practices Panel
Webinar - Pay Transparency Legislation Best Practices in 2025
Webinar - Lessons from This Year’s Comp Cycle
Webinar - Navigating Compensation in the Manufacturing and Biopharmaceutical ...
Webinar - Unlock Efficiency and Collaboration with Payscale Compensation Plan...
Webinar - Smart Job Description Management
Webinar - How to Train Managers to Have Successful Pay Conversations
Webinar - Mastering Effective Pay Communications: Best Practices for Success
Webinar - Pay Equity Webinar: Unlock the Power of Proactive Pay Equity

Recently uploaded (19)

PDF
TOP 10+ AngularJS Developers for Hire in 2025 with Upstaff Platform with Upst...
PDF
Induction and Socialization __Objectives
PDF
The Silent Sabotage - When A Teammate Undermine You At Work.pdf
PDF
Sirogiddin D. Senior Data Engineer, DataOps with ML & Data Science skills
PPT
Staffing, Human resource management practices
PPTX
HR Solution PEOEOR Payroll Outsourcing.pptx
DOC
UP毕业证学历认证,阿拉巴马大学毕业证国外证书
PDF
The Symphony of AI and User Experience_ Demystifying the Connection.pdf
PDF
Labor Market Regulations, and others (Session 4 Report) DADO.pdf
PPTX
Human Resources Management Presentation.pptx
DOC
Penn毕业证学历认证,阿拉斯加大学费尔班克斯分校毕业证学位证书复制
PPTX
ADVANCED WORKFORCE PLANNING FOR mBA GRADS
PDF
How to Identify suspicious Linked In Profiles
DOC
ISU毕业证学历认证,斯旺西大学毕业证留学回国
PPTX
Determine your personality and how to apply it in leadership
PPTX
HR Payroll Management Amazon presentation
PPT
Training Design strategies and methods.ppt
PPTX
Strategic Human Resource Management in practice
PDF
LEADERSHIP Horizon : To LEAD with HEART (HR Development))
TOP 10+ AngularJS Developers for Hire in 2025 with Upstaff Platform with Upst...
Induction and Socialization __Objectives
The Silent Sabotage - When A Teammate Undermine You At Work.pdf
Sirogiddin D. Senior Data Engineer, DataOps with ML & Data Science skills
Staffing, Human resource management practices
HR Solution PEOEOR Payroll Outsourcing.pptx
UP毕业证学历认证,阿拉巴马大学毕业证国外证书
The Symphony of AI and User Experience_ Demystifying the Connection.pdf
Labor Market Regulations, and others (Session 4 Report) DADO.pdf
Human Resources Management Presentation.pptx
Penn毕业证学历认证,阿拉斯加大学费尔班克斯分校毕业证学位证书复制
ADVANCED WORKFORCE PLANNING FOR mBA GRADS
How to Identify suspicious Linked In Profiles
ISU毕业证学历认证,斯旺西大学毕业证留学回国
Determine your personality and how to apply it in leadership
HR Payroll Management Amazon presentation
Training Design strategies and methods.ppt
Strategic Human Resource Management in practice
LEADERSHIP Horizon : To LEAD with HEART (HR Development))

Webinar-Exploring Variable Pay